Affidavit: Surviving roommate saw Idaho killer | Morning in America
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 ก.ค. 2024
- The surviving roommate who lived in the house where four University of Idaho students were killed later helped police identify the man accused of the deadly stabbings, a newly unsealed probable cause affidavit shows.
Full story: bit.ly/3W6Vv73
#IdahoKillings #BrianKohberger #Idaho
Start your day with "Morning in America," NewsNation's live three-hour national morning newscast hosted by Adrienne Bankert. Weekdays starting at 7a/6C.
NewsNation is your source for fact-based, unbiased news for all America.
More from NewsNation: www.newsnationnow.com/
Get our app: trib.al/TBXgYpp
Find us on cable: trib.al/YDOpGyG
How to watch on TV or streaming: trib.al/Vu0Ikij
![USAB Showcase: Australia vs USA [OFFICIAL STREAM]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/keiEr_MOaSQ/mqdefault.jpg)
The fact he was casing out the house MONTHS before is so creepy..This affidavit says a lot about the type of person he is
I remember Bryan’s downstairs neighbor reporting that he’d seen Bryan come home with a girl a couple times and could hear them talking from his apartment. I wonder if that was Dylan. Maybe he’d been inside the home and that’s how he knew his way around and exactly which bedrooms to hit? Conveniently walked by Dylan’s bedroom TWICE and didn’t think to go in for her?
@@megkathleen the affidavit states that a shoeprint was found outside of DM's door
@@SaltySaltySalty. I think that was probably him walking out the door like she said but is it all as she said it was? Did he stop to kiss her or something?
What is your speculation based on? He probably did not realise there were six people in the house., as two were not visitors. It is possible he did not realise how large this weird, complex three-storey house is, or that he thought it was two back-to-back homes. Nor would he necessarily expect to find more than one person in a room. Nor might he have expected one to call for pizza at 4am. It is more likely that he thought he would get into one room and kill one person and slip back out, and enjoy the thrill of people like you pointing fingers at bewildered roommates.
@@eh1702 The entirety of the public is thinking the same thing. Stop defending her. It’s normal for the public to question something that does NOT ADD UP. It’s as simple as that. You’re not some martyr just for defending a girl you think had no involvement in this when you don’t know.
As cruel as this sounds, I truly believe that if capital punishment came in the form of how the murderer did their killing, then we would have a lot less killings.
It’s not cruel, it is an eye for an eye. I totally agree.
No, actually homicidal maniacs are also suicidal but too agressive outwardly or too cowardly, so you would actually be doing them a favor. Nothing is worse than life long solitary confinment.
I like your thought, but no amount of "torture" can equate to the same torture experienced across multiple people and family and friends affected by the torturer.
I agree
Bullshit, anyone who wants to kill will kill, they dont care about anything, there is no correlation with death penalty and lower crime.
This is truly sickening .... God bless the police department for their hard work and dedication. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
This case just gets crazier and crazier
Its wild
Yep I'm afraid of what of info is coming....
So many weird things with this case. One thing I haven't see talked about is the risk he took. He likely knew there would be up to 6 people in the house, including one male. How in the world would an intelligent person expect to be able to kill all those people in different rooms with only a knife and have nobody in the house scream at the top of their lungs, possibly have people escape and alert neighbors, call the police during the act, etc. There are so many things that could have gone wrong that it seems unlikely someone would even attempt it without other elements at play. And why did he just walk right past the other roommate and not kill her too? This whole thing just doesn't make sense the way it's being told.
Also, its not clear the motive.
Drugs is the link here.
Intelligent person? He left his DNA at the crime scene, used his car as a getaway vehicle, and according to telephone records his phone was near the residence on 12 different occasions.
Since he cases out the place he could tell it was a party house , he could probably count on the occupants being drunk / high at any given moment. People who are under the influence have inhibited judgement. It’s why it’s so bad to consume alcohol / drugs and then drive
I believe before he slaughtered them he drugged them. Why he didn't kill the 5th and 6th roommate is a beyond bizarre fact/question.
Who needs enemies when you got friends like this
Agree. Honestly that's why Idgaf about judging the people that surround me. Like if you're stupid and selfish ( just like this bitch Dylan M.) I want absolutely nothing to do with you. Nobody needs "friends" like this girl. I can already imagine how the interactions her must be like. Very fake.
Who said they were friends? What if they were roommates. I am not in my roommates business or give A damn about their lives or what they’re doing or what their names are
@@Hello-lm1fvyou wouldn't give a damn if you literally heard your roommate being murdered and came face to face with said murderer?
@@Fyhbvcvbmiih I would. I don’t care about their day to day lives…. Where they go. What they do for work. I’m making a point that roomate doesn’t equal friendship. Anyone ina. Life threatening situation deserves attention and to be helped of course
Agree with comments...and if she was able to call friends from her cell phone, why wouldn't she hit 911 and call police? Especially with extreme fear of my life.
There are a NEW set of questions Bryan could pose on Redit should he ever get the chance to pole criminals. 1. How long after your crime did you realize the cops were on to you ? 2. How did it feel when the FBI executed a no knock warrant on your dwelling at 3 AM to arrest you? 3. How did you feel after you learned you left a key piece of evidence at the crime scene ? 4. How did it feel when you realized you can never take a dump or shower in private again ? 5. How did it feel when you realized you were caught ?
She thought she heard I’m going to help you but maybe he actually said “nobody can help you”….
Right
that's chilling!
For all ones saying oh this poor girl who had opportunity to call 911 after she saw him leave !! Try telling that these poor poor family's who lost they kids try telling them that
That makes more sense
@@Native722 right?
How do you hear crying and see a creepy stranger in the house and just go back to your room??? I understand being scared, but WTF?! 🤯
Not just back to her room, but took a nap after he left like wth
Had to be drugs
@@mach183 "just heard screaming, crying, saw a stranger leave my home..
Better call my bestie and shoot some dope, take a nap, then call the cops"
Ok , CHECKS OUT
@@Amused_Comfort_Inc lmfao 🤣 not funny but golly !!!! How does that look ???!!! Suspect as fuck!!!!!
Something isn't right still about how he could do this alone.
i read in the Affidavit that both Dylan and Bethany was in the house during the murder occured and Bethany was on the first floor while Dylan was on the same floor as Xana and Ethan. i'm just curious on how intoxicated Bethany was (if she was indeed drinking that night) to not hear anything like Dylan, since people claimed Dylan was also intoxicated but still able to hear Kaylee (affidavit also assumed that it could be Xana saying that since her phone was active on tiktok during that time) said
- someone in the house,
- heard Xana's crying,
- heard a male voice saying "its okay i can help you",
- still able to open her door three times,
- came face to face with suspect,
- give a full on description on the suspect eventho its dark.
that doesnt sound intoxicated to me. people also said "its a frat house, people come and go the whole time for party." yeah, i guess if there were party in the house at that time (which they dont) so i dont see how seeing an all black, mask on dude, bushy eyebrow and you clearly didnt recognized the said male, doesnt alert u in some way, let alone for the next 7-8 hours.
we need more interviews statement of Bethany, to know her side of story on why didnt she hear anything, like the dog barking for example since this affidavit focus too much on Dylan's statement.
what was Bethany doing from 8-11 before the police phone call was made. who is the friend that Dylan called before they decided to call police? did they mean she called Bethany to come upstair together with her to check on the roomates? and a lot of people were like "the unconcious person" that were stated in the police call is probaly Dylan. she probably fainted from the shocked.
okay.
and my question is, who let the friend in and discover unconcious Dylan?
and if its not Dylan that were meant as "unconcious person", i do not think seeing two person in the pool of their own blood can be deem as "unconcious"
that just question i have, yall can share opinion. please do not scream and be mean. 🙄
i am also interested to hear more on that 911 call. hoping they'll release the call. we can hear more on how they react in the call upon seeing a devastating and horror scene in front of their eyes.
We'll hopefully find out why she didn't call police when they call her as a witness.
yes. Or get another 'chair ' ready..
Yeah, and let DM lie her way out of it and play innocent.
@@TaurusBebez I mean are you guys seruous? Not even all the informations out yet???? You must have been one of the people thinking it was the taco truck guy.
@@carbar8 No I did not suspect the taco truck guy, at least the taco truck guy did not hear the roommates cry and whimper yet do nothing until noon the next day.
@@TaurusBebez But think from her perspective first without judging? We still don’t even have all the details, there’s serious pieces missing that they haven’t released. I mean when she woke up from hearing the noises and crying she was most likely confused and drunk, went to check and saw an unfamiliar man probably covered in blood and she went into SHOCK. For god sakes she’s a young girl who knows what was going on in her mind like are there more people in the house? will they hear her if she calls the cops? is the guy coming back for her? i’m guessing she hid until she felt safe enough. 8 hours is a lot of time but shock can do that to you.
My heart goes out to the parents of the victims, as well as Bryan’s parents this has got to be a nightmare for them as well.
I've heard of toddlers calling 911 to save a family member. Something does not sit right with this scenario. You hear something that is off, you hear the dog bark, you see a masked man and then you go to sleep? I'm not buying it. There has to be a reason why she waited 8 hours before checking on her roommates. Even then she called friends instead of the police. There's something odd about this situation. This odd scenario at least deserves a look into her cell phone comms.
Dylan is either extremely selfish or dumb beyond belief
EXACTLY
Notice how the police were called 2 the crime scene AFTER she called her friends over, making sure the whole house was contaminated w DNA thus making it harder 2 pinpoint the actual killer 😳
We saw on Inside edition a dog called 911 like lassie(dog show my timeline 1950's)!! Sooo they better not lie to me!! Lie to the defense who gonna chop U up on the stand making U the lying idiot U are?! U might just be going into jail instead of Brian!!? Something iis not right? Maybe professional hit, with Brian the patsy!!? The cab driver said it was a drug house? Suppose b Dylan supplied drugs for most of college, & k & M tried to blackmail her for $$! !! Ethan, & xanna in the way!! Had to go.also!! Something is not right & not adding up!?
There's just something so suspicious about this entire case and I still think there's something not right about the witnesses recounts on what happened. Why would the killer want to risk leaving behind a witness...and if he had this planned he would know how many people were in the house. He was Cleary watching and waiting.
Witness, co-conspirator?
i guess the survivors are innocent for real but they did notice something was wrong and chose to ignore for their own safety consideration. If the kids got to rescue in time they might still have some chances of surviving
even if she was in shock for hours, why did they call other friends over first before the cops? how can u call other friends over first instead of the cops or ambulance when 4 people are dead in the house?
I have a lot of sympathy for the survivors, but I also have a lot of questions. She was "frozen" in fear, but she was still able to lock her bedroom door. She then didn't call 911, didn't check on any of her housemates, and instead went to bed until midday.
I feel terrible for all the people involved in this apart from the perpetrator, of course, but it's not unreasonable to ask how the hell someone can experience that and do nothing. If this experience was enough to terrify her into being frozen how did she secure herself in her room? And if she could do that how could she then not do anything at all for another EIGHT hours?
It's just baffling.
Right?! The entire thought process is insane. Doing literally anything at all would have been better than doing nothing for 1/3 of a day.
Well. You would think that a female would call the police over to help secure the residence, then lock it up. But it seems that late, late night stuff went on at that place...And it was none of her business. I can see that way also. Each floor was a separate residence (or room). They only shared the kitchen, lR. They may not have been as close as the pictures represent, I don't know. And the weather did warrant the use of a ski mask-to some people.
@greenleaf why was she scared then if random people being in the home at 4 am was business as usual? Why didn't she do anything when she heard crying? Why did she keep looking out her door but made the conscious choice to not get help for hours. I'm not trying to come off as rude, just have so many questions because it just doesn't make sense.
@@greenleaf2233 there was no party that night so no random guests, TRY AGAIN
You sound really stupid @C T
She was frozen in fear because of the unrecognizable figure in her home. Did you not know someone can be shocked and SCARED at the same time. She was scared he might have still been in the house. Scared if she did ANYTHING she would be doomed just like her best friends. Are you human? Sure doesnt sound like it.
Something doesn’t feel right with the roommate…She had a phone yet didn’t call for help and locked herself in a room for several hours
Right right she should be charged as an accessory I mean there's no reason for her not to call me when she has no excuse as far as I'm concerned none
@@kyleehunsaker5974 I can’t wrap my head around it it’s so crazy…if she got them help right away maybe some of them would still be alive…
@@TiffanyShae ok but wait 5 hours call police really what the f...
@@kyleehunsaker5974 she actually waited 8 hrs!!!! It doesn’t make sense 🙀
There has to be something behind her not calling police promptly. I have ptsd and am treated for it. Nobody experiences something like that, and then in her shocked state, she goes to sleep for 8 hours, then calls her friends, then FINALLY calls 911. I'm not accusing her of being apart of it AT ALL. It's just an ODD, WEIRD choice! 🤷♀️
Bro stfu with all this shit about Dylan. She was highly intoxicated lmao. I don’t think her thoughts were oh my roommates are getting murdered Lmao I bet that was the last thing on her mind.
I would never be able to sleep soundly knowing an intruder is in my home. It makes no sense to me. Idc what anyone says that person is a coward for not contacting anyone else sooner.
Exactly….it literally makes no sense
I said the same thing
@@Hunterbenx bro that house was a frat house lol. People coming in left and right, plus she’s intoxicated too like give the girl a break damn, you don’t know how things went down or weren’t in that situation
Why did it take the survivors so long to call 911? I'm sure they were just scared but I just wonder why.
I would say under the influence of drugs or alcohol and sleep it off before calling the police. People don't think logically when impaired.
Why didn’t the girl call the cops immediately when she saw a masked man in her house?
She is either extremely dumb or complicit. Certainly she has zero empathy or concern for her housemates' safety or lives. One or more life could've been saved.
Right! Who just goes back to bed after seeing a stranger in their home in the middle of the night?
@@imakeajiffypuff4525 Dylan that's who!
Everybody is coming after this girl based on the affidavit- the affidavit doesn’t have ALL the information, that won’t come till trial. People saying dumb things like “ShE NeEdS To Be QuEsTiOnEd!! InTeRrOgAtED!!!” Really Sherlock? Ya think LE hasn’t done that? Just calm down and learn a little patience, you’ll be alright.
I have more questions. It sounds like Xana Kernodle did not die immediately. How long before the crying stopped? She was crying the second time and the third time the roommate opened the door? No help was called for?
I know it broke my heart every time I think about it 😢😞😞🥹
She knew something was wrong with Xana and didn’t even go check the second time BEFORE seeing Bryan. Even after, she didn’t even wait half an hour - an hour to call police to make sure she was safe. She waited an entire 8 HOURS. She wasn’t so frozen that she couldn’t lock her door and walk herself back to her bed.
How do we know he was at this house 12 times prior bc he was stalking them - what if he had something going on with Dylan? They need to check her phone too and see if she was ever at his apartment. Apparently his downstairs neighbor heard him bring a girl home a few times and heard them talking all night. Why did he spare Dylan in a bedroom on the same floor as the two others - he just so happened to ignore her bedroom (the closest one to the stairway and the sliding door) TWICE and went into the far one? How did he know his way through the house? How did she see his DARK eyebrows in the DARK??
Like make it make sense!
Maybe she watched Ethan get murdered and knew she was next so that’s why the crying. These type injuries surely took their lives really quickly.
I imagine Dylan assumed at first the crying was a private thing between Xana and her guest Ethan.
Sometimes if you feel your blood leaving your body that quickly, maybe that’s all she had the energy for…crying until silence.
Then the roomate didn't call 911 immediately. doesn't add up.
Until she’s called up to the stand to give her eyewitness testimony, we know nothing. Your assumptions don’t do anything but start rumors. You sound ignorant.
Nope sketchy at least 🤔
@@justinchurch7675 lol they only speculated the timing, didn’t even suggest anything to begin a rumor? Damn. I’m all for the justice system handling it too, but bro, relax. 😂
@@justinchurch7675 you sound delusional bc Dylan literally told police this is what happened so its not rumors 🤡🤡 it's in the affidavit 🤦♂️
Right, they should arrest that person, she has said 2 differ storys they wore sleepin, then she did hire and saw some1 in black.
8 hours until calling the cops?
And after she went to sleep...
She is not guilty for surviving, of course, and she didn't harm anyone, but man, she did nothing to help either.
Reminds me of a case a woman was killed, and as she was getting killed, her big ass dog watched it happen and did nothing.
I can't be the only person on the planet wondering why the 'survivor" didn't call the police THEN when she saw him face to face.
Because it was a busy house and she had no idea everyone was dead.
There had just been a grub hub delivery
It was a covid mask, not a balaclava or ski mask.
@@mvubu6823 exactly she didnt know they was dead remember she thought xani was passed out thats when she called feds why would u call feds after being in a froze trauma phrase and go upstairs as u see the killer leave of ur freinds dead i wouldn't and barely in mind if she dkd leave her room and lock herself out i possible think the killer would turned round and killed her. So its good she sitted and waited it out she did the right decision and saved her self and beth
Nah fuck all that she know wassup shock or fear everyone in their right senses would’ve called the cops regardless
@@sharollan789 you're not subscribing to 'group think'. What's the matter, you got too much common sense?
@@mvubu6823 but she heard her friend say “ someone is in here “ and heard her cry ! Come on at that point anyone and everyone starts wondering and shit you don’t just assume oh well
Makes no damn sense at all. Why would they wait until the morning time to call the cops and then call saying their unresponsive? Instead of they were murdered
My thoughts on Dylan:
1. I don't think she was in any conspiracy whatsoever with the killer.
2. I believe she did see the killer exiting through the sliding glass door.
3. I believe she heard what she said she heard.
4. I believe she was terrified to an extreme degree.
5. Despite her terror and fear, I still think she had enough of her wits left to call her other surviving roommate.
6. I don't know why she didn't call the police about the intruder.
a. Too traumatized? b. Didn't want the cops coming over to find her drunk or under some drug-related influence and/or find contraband in the house? c. Extremely poor judgement under the circumstances? d. Stupid beyond belief?
Whatever the answers, that poor girl was traumatized, made poor decisions and now will suffer all over again but to a much worse degree now that the affidavit has been released to the public. Her life is ruined and I'm saddened by that thought.
Kinda true. Even if she did everything right to keep herself safer in that scenario, she will forever have Survivors Guilt. Compiled with whatever society has to say about her intentions or decisions. Sad thought actually. Thank you for giving this perspective ❤I was beginning to get lost in the comment theories. Really though, no matter what she did right or wrong, she has to live with it. That frickin’ sucks.
I'm going with Dylan is extremely selfish and/or stupid beyond belief
Was contemplating this as well. Only reason she would not call the police is if she had drugs in her system.
I think the only explanation for her not calling was maybe she was the "unconscious person" mentioned in the 911 call. What if she fainted from shock? Idk i don't want to blame her but she should of at least called 911 at that moment
I remember Bryan’s downstairs neighbor reporting that he’d seen Bryan come home with a girl a couple times and could hear them talking from his apartment. I wonder if that was Dylan. Just very weird how her story doesn’t add up and that he so conveniently walked right by her room TWICE and didn’t go for her? He knew exactly where to go? Makes you wonder if he’d been inside the house before and why by the one person who witnessed this and survived didn’t render aid or attempt to even call the police…
Who sees someone walk past them wearing a mask, dressed in black, in their house, after hearing crying, and hearing someone say, there is someone in here, and doesn't call the cops at that very moment, when we know all these kids have their phones on them or close by at all times. At some point she will have to answer why she waited over 6 hours to call the cops....and don't tell me she was drunk and fell asleep, cause I've been drunk, and someone walking by me in my house wearing a mask and dressed in black that I don't know who it is....will take my buzz away rather quick. Don't be surprised if in the coming days we find out this DM girl has been taken in for more questioning by the police. Because 2+2 does not equal 4 here.
Agreed mmmmhmmmm
Is the possibility not being discussed that the surviving roommate (Dylan ❤️) who saw him and was likely still in shock was the 'unconscious person' who was the SUBJECT of the 911 call - not the actual caller? So the other surviving roommate finds Dylan, can't calm her down or communicate so calls friends to try and connect with/help her get her thoughts out, and eventually someone realizes something terrible happened so they need to call police in the midst of the chaos.
The police should be the first place she should of called
How did the other roommate know what state D was in when this affidavit says she locked herself in the room?
@kozak2010998 Okay, boss… but I think you missed my point(s)… ;)
@DistancedSocially I had that thought too… maybe she eventually made her way upstairs and heard crying coming from Dylan’s room before she made it any further into the house? Dylan heard a familiar voice and managed to unlock & let her in…? Maybe the roommates had each other’s door codes… or…? Obviously just speculating but it could explain a lot of the things that have been hard to make sense of so far.
If it in fact she was drunk and sleepy than this would greatly reduce her reliability as a witness and if I was the defense than I would rip into it during cross examination.
The fact that she didn't call for 8 hours, the defense will rip into that. Why didn't she call 911? It wasn't as urgent or an emergency.
How misleading, the survivor saw someone in all black and a face mask. Not BK exactly. We still need to see evidence.
Also, I wonder why roommate didn't call police as fast as possible after the individual left premise. Very odd. I witnessed a shooting and after we escaped gunman and we're safe we called cops immediately.
Maybe she was so traumatized and hangover she passed out & that was what that 911 unconscious person report was about
You hear people crying and don’t go check on them??? Why lock yourself in the room for hours? What if he came back for you? Strange shit going on.
Yes... makes zero sense even for a drunk person...
Yeah i can't understand how you can hear crying and then a masked stranger in your home at night and just go back to sleep
Look up Manson murder of Sharon Tate; four ppl were killed and a young man in guest house survived...He also heard the screams of someone being killed, but didnt come out till police arrived many hrs later...Totally reminds me of this case.
All mass criminals causing death should get the death penalty.
But she saw the killer and still took 7-8 hours to call 911 ??? Why??
Prayers for that Justice..evil needs to go .
She didn't call the police because there was drugs on the property and they didn't want to call the police and she didn't know anything had happened, it was only after she came down off the drugs and the realization of what happened kicked in, she fainted.
You're speculating your ass off, huh?
@@TaurusBebez She already replied about being on Ecstasy so just hear it for yourself instead of insulting people when you show your ignorance.
@@sallyvella7012 Her being on drugs is no defense especially since she was lucid enough to remember the perps height and his "bushy brows", so ya'll are the ignorant ones defending that chick.
What a load of waffle 😂😂😂
@@sallyvella7012 sources? ive been keeping up with this for months and this is the first ive ever heard of ecstasy.
Why would she wait 8 hours though?!? Like why? I understand freezing and going into panic mode, but she saw him leave the house. I wonder why she didn’t run to get her phone and call for help. Maybe before leaving he threatened to kill her if she called for help? Just maybe
That is crazy that the roommate saw the guy in the house and he didn't kill her and she didn't call the cops for another 7/8 hours makes no sense
Seriously, if I heard a male tell one of my crying friends that he would help the person crying, I would not be running to see what was wrong, especially when the stranger at that point had not to her knowledge by what is stated, no violence had occurred.
She claimed to hear a victim say someone is in the house, and a males voice say something like don't worry I'm here to help you. There were surveillance cameras outside of their house that picked up a loud thud and crying. If a camera outside can pick up that noise, I just don't see how you wouldn't hear that inside the residence. Then she literally saw a masked man leaving their home, and was scared enough to "freeze" yet didn't check on anyone or call for help for 8 hours?
What on earth? The girl didn’t call police til lunch time?
The fact the survivors never came in the spotlight through this whole thing to say anything always insinuated to me that they knew something. And once again, my hunch was correct. She needs to surface and explain why she didn't do anything for 7 hours then decided to call friends before police. That might sit better with the public.
It was explained in the Affidavit. If you don't understand the Medical state of Freezing or Shock. Educate yourself. I'm happy that she is alive.
@@zenamen5221 I wouldn't be so quick to dismiss DM's behavior. State of shock or not, her behavior was very strange. We need to wait until all of the information is released.
They never have even come out to call the killer & his actions deplorable in public. Or say they were thankful to be the only survivors. Nope sounds to me like they knew how this was always gonna turn out 🤷♂️
@@zenamen5221 Is that how you educate yourself..just believe everything you read or hear? Theres a reason why ignorance and stupidity is on the rise in this world..people like you. Educating yourself implies to still question what you're told to make sense of everything you soak in. And what you stated still doesn't negate the fact they have never been in the spotlight to tell about their experience.
She doesn't owe anything to the public, at all... She has enough on her plate having to deal with the trauma and grief of what happened, and the only people she owes any explanations to is law enforcement, who have already cleared her of any suspicion. Internet sleuths don't have the authority to judge and demand things from victims
She didn’t call the police for 8 hours. The investigators told us at first that they were all asleep and didn’t hear anything and now she heard something and saw a man. Goes back to sleep, 8 hours later, goes to their rooms and doesn’t notice a bloodbath but says she thought they were asleep? Blood would be the first thing you SEEE!! it’s REDDDDDD. Then goes ahead and calls her friends to come and see what happened, they come and contaminate the crime scene and they later call 911. They’ve to be held accountable too
Makes NO sense. She knew something was wrong with Xana and didn’t even go check the second time BEFORE seeing Bryan. Even after, she didn’t even wait half an hour - an hour to call police to make sure she was safe. She waited an entire 8 HOURS. She wasn’t so frozen that she couldn’t lock her door and walk herself back to her bed.
How do we know he was at this house 12 times prior bc he was stalking them - what if he had something going on with Dylan? Why did he spare Dylan in a bedroom on the same floor as the two others - he just so happened to ignore her bedroom (the closest one to the stairway and the sliding door) TWICE and went into the far one? How did he know his way through the house? How did she see his DARK eyebrows in the DARK??
@@megkathleen thank you. I don’t wanna say she had something to do with but her statement is gonna be used against her and it’s not gonna look good for her. Not going to check on your friends is fishy. Waiting 8 hours is fishy. She heard screaming and the dog barked. That’d set me off and def would think something is wrong and I’d head up to check on someone or yell out to them and ask if everything is ok. This girl is gonna get grilled by the defendants side.
Yes! The police were awful quick to clear the roommates as innocent but clearly this needs to be looked into further. Who waits to call police for HOURS after seeing a stranger inside your house in the middle of the night? It makes absolutely no sense. If she truly is innocent, she is just an idiot I guess.
@@rashidvalentine idk if she was part of the crime BUT at the very least she is liable for negligence aka failure to render aid! Much like if you're in a car wreck and others are hurt yet you don't call for help you can be liable for that
Most of what you just wrote here probably didn't happen. The police were mis-leading us from the start because they didn't want BK to know how much they had. They certainly didn't want him to know DM saw him.
I know a lot of the comments on here are defending this roommate, but something is not right about this. Police need to go back and investigate those roommates a lot harder. I think there is still more to this story. It makes absolutely no sense that you would wait for about 8 HOURS before checking on anyone or calling the police after seeing an intruder in your home in the middle of the night. Either she's still not telling the full story or she is a complete dingbat. Whatever the answer is, something just isn't right here.
I agree with you
I thought as much too. There’s more to it. I hope that justice will be served properly.
Why don’t they include the other parents always kaylees parents
I don’t understand why she didn’t call 911, she may have saved a life.
That DM Girl knew something was wrong because she opened her room door three times to see what was going on. So she already had the feeling that something wasn't right up to 3 times, plus the fact that she heard someone say Someone was in the house and the dog was barking and there was howling! That DM knew something was going on and something wasn't right, otherwise you wouldn't open your room door 3 times to see what's there. Then she saw B pass by dressed in total black and mask and her feeling she had earlier was confirmed because she stood dead still and locked her door! No... It is not acceptable that she waited 8 hours to call the police! She knew something was wrong before she saw B in the hallway.
Right ! Her life was magically spared, then she got tired and took a nap. WTF this kinda stuff plays out All the time and I wouldnt doubt if she conspired to have them offed
It's called Freeze and then Shock. SHOCK is a medical reality, and the subconscious mind takes over. Look it up. Educate yourself. Yes, it's acceptable because she is alive.
Not to mention if she acted quickly, they may have been saved. She knew exactly what she was doing. It's sickening how everyone online is defending her. But "she's just a poor widdle gurl" please 🤦♂️
And, she didn’t check on them herself, she asked someone else to discover the gruesome scene, which is another sign that she knew she’s guilty of something.
I keep seeing a lot of people defending her behavior, claiming that she was "too shocked" or "too drunk" to do anything. I call major bs on that. There's no way a young woman is going to just ignore her roommate's crying and loud thuds and not at least call the police.
With this weird testimony from the roommate and the fact the accused killer stated” was anyone else arrested?” When he was taken into custody I’d say that roommate is definitely worth looking into
I'm thinking Bryan was thinking of his father.
BEEN worth looking into.
"THE IDAHO 4" | The ROOMMATES were always the best SUSPECTS 🔪🩸
th-cam.com/video/VjjVB6CSJ9U/w-d-xo.html
@@Sunshinensea , yep.
If she was involved she wouldn't have given an accurate description of Bryan to the police. She would have said she didn't see anyone and had been sleeping. It breaks my heart that these kids were murdered and left to die slowly. I wish this girl had the courage to crawl out of her window to get help.
@@MLABCD How did she see DARK eyebrows in the DARK? How did she see he wasn’t muscular but “athletically built” in the DARK? She probably got nervous as the cops were talking to her. Don’t assume she’s so innocent just bc she’s a female. How do we know she wasn’t the girl he’d brought home to his apartment multiple times per the downstairs neighbor’s report? Don’t defend what flat out doesn’t add up. It’ll come out in time but she looks shady af
If he is guilty, I think all who support the death penalty in the first place think it was made for people just like this.
How did she see him but he didn’t see her?
She could have been on the stairs but she was close enough to describe he had bushy eyebrows and his build......yeah ain't adding up
WTF!!! She didn't do something right away!!??
It wasn’t face to face we don’t know if he didn’t see her.
We
Know she saw him but not otherwise
This is horrible 😢
Please remember the surviving roommate is very young and is probably dealing with intense survivors guilt. She was probably in extreme fear when she saw BK and maybe under the influence and not thinking properly. Remember who did the ACTUAL crime. RIP to the victims ❤
But its bullshit she has no excuse not calling 911
Oh my god r u serious young her excuse she in College please tell me you're not that stupid
@Surf’n’Turf waiting 5 hours to call police there's no f****** excuse
i think she didn't call just because the house received so many noise complaints and the cops were always checking for underage drinking there .. not sure about fear because fearing for your life might override fear of getting a fine for underage drinking or too loud music.
What does not add up is that one of the victims received a DoorDash at 4 am, one of the surviving victims heard a noise at a round 4 am she thought is the dog playing on the 3rd floor, so no one, neither the DoorDash guy nor the surviving victim was worried about the noise? Then she opened up the door again and heard someone crying and someone saying "someone is here", then opened the door again and saw the killer face to face and then closes her door and not check up on her friends or call the police or seek advice from someone???? She is absolutely an egoistic person!
Nowhere in the affidavit does it say Dylan and the killer saw each other face to face.
I think part of his thrill kill was to have someone witness him so that person could be traumatized. He seems to be that effing crazy
It's also strange that he obviously knew where people were in the house. If it wasn't targeted, wouldn't he have started on one floor and went to all different rooms. Why would he skip over DM room over and over again. I can understand knowing the layout beforehand because you can look that stuff up. So how did he skip DM room and know to go to the room upstairs and them xanas room. Weird.
Okay, what's up with this roommate? She sees a weird stranger, someone crying, dog barking, and she does NOTHING?? Unless maybe that kind of chaos is a common occurrence in their house? Maybe she thought it was just more chaos.
If the two surviving housemates were sleeping on the first floor, then how come the killer allegedly ‘walked right towards and past’ this particular housemate, and out the glass sliding doors which, btw, are located on the second floor? Doesn’t make sense.
They were all close friends who lived together, they did everything together. DM was drunk, all of them were partying that night. She froze, but also probably didn't want to overreact by calling the police. She didn't know that Brian murdered her friends. Stop judging her, she is also a victim.
She's a coward!! Her story makes no sense. She seems very heartless. She's shady in this one way or another.
How'd Xana have a door dash at 4 and they say they were killed between 4-4:25?
If. If Bryan is offered a deal to avoid trial, life with no possibility of parole, he can refuse the deal.
Sure sounds like the roommate gave the killer six hours to get away before calling the cops, this is too suspicious.
How about you just hand him over to the families
They said there was a uber eats order to the house at 4am. Most of the roommates sounded like they were still awake. I dont understand how you dont see or smell 4 dead bodies in your house. Usually you call out to your roommates and say good morning! How the hell do you not go crazy from surviving such a gruesome crime. Guy looks guilty as hell.
Don’t believe the killer had any idea that there were 6 people there
Why would the man just walk past her but stabbed all the others!! I wondering why the hell she didn't call 911 immediately becuz they could probably have been helped but instead she just went back into her room and locked the door?? THIS DOESNT SOUND RIGHT AT ALL!!
I was watching an interview with a former FBI agent, I believe he was one or in law enforcement of some kind, anyways....he made a good point as to why DM did not call 911 right away. He mentioned that it was dark in the house, and just because she saw him does not mean he actually saw her. I mean he could have been so focused to get out that his mind was fixated on getting to the door and completely disregarded the person he just walked past, she did say he went directly to the door and left as he passed by her. And maybe she opened her door a crack to see rather than being out in the wide open. But honestly, from the way things have been described, I don't think that Ethan or xana were meant to be murdered. I believe they were so because they heard and went out to see what the commotion was. She said she heard someone say there is someone here....since both the girls upstairs were in bed when killed, I think that was Xana, not Kaylee, saying it to Ethan, I wouldn't be surprised if he got up to check things out and tried running back into the room and locking it but the killer was right on him. He was killed on the bed, which would explain why the roommate was hearing Xana crying, probably out of fear, then the killer made the remark of helping her, in his own devious way, because why would the roommate say it was a male not that it was Ethan, and then attacked her and decided he was done and walked away. In the dark DM could have seen the suspect walk out and figured okay he's gone but I will lock my room in case he comes back. Then in the morning when she wasn't hearing the other roommates she called friends to come and check because she was afraid he might be back? I heard somewhere that she called friends before leaving the room because she was too scared to walk out her room and they saw xana in the doorway....they used her phone to call 911.
It is very strange that he didn’t kill everyone
This makes you want to keep you kids at a local college, living at home! These predators are everywhere and, as a parent, it makes you feel like you can't let your kids go out into the world and be young. It is sickening!
American college life is pathetically unhealthy. The cost is absurd and the lifestyle of partying excessively is unnecessary. In Europe we have balance and drinking is not such a covered thing because alcohol is rarely forbidden. Living with family is the ideal so you can save and have family support. I get it if you are at MIT or somewhere spectacularly unmatchable but most courses and programs are so similar.
Come on now DM could've called the police THERE'S NO EXCUSE OR JUSTIFIYING IT!!
If it in fact she was drunk and sleepy than this would greatly reduce her reliability as a witness and if I was the defense than I would rip into it during cross examination.
The fact that she didn't call for 8 hours, the defense will rip into that. Why didn't she call 911? It wasn't as urgent or an emergency.
Newscasters absolutely LOVE that word ""Chilling""..... Lol.
These parents need to get off their little media tour and stfu. They’re harming the prosecution and making this worse for everyone.
I agree
I don't think anyone should throw judgement until they know the details. She's not going to call 911 if she doesn't suspect anything. The killer didn't break in and she didn't witness any murders, only that he was there. Seeing as there are plenty of people that come in and out of the house she may have assumed it to be the ex bf or a one night stand. It's easy to say from our view 'she should have called 911' because we know what happened after the fact. She obviously had no idea anyone was murdered that night. I'm sure 99% of people would call 911 if they knew that their friends had been attacked/their life is now in danger.
She saw a masked man take her roommate by the face and cover her nose and mouth 😂yeah, nothing to see here!
I’m confused now.
I'm 💔that Kaylees 'paranoid' (family description in a news interview) suspicion of being stalked, been taken more serious.
Lesson Learned😔
It's a possibility and seems up to this point a reasonable explanation for How this loser could attack four young adults and none of them stop him(especially the boyfriend/girlfriend in the same room/bed?) And not have the others hear something and do something to stop him. It turns out that this 5th roommate Did hear the others as they were being killed...one is crying , one is saying to the other, "it's OK, I'll help you"...this In Itself is bizarre and incomprehensible. He's killing a young woman, and the girl's boyfriend says "it's OK, I'll help you"??? I don't understand this dialog. It's creepy, it's weird and it's off the wall. ...I got off track...
Is it possible the POS drugged all of them before he broke in and slaughtered them?
I knew he'd done it alone, I knew that others in that house Had to have heard noises as he's killing each of them separately, but I didn't understand how they collective didn't fight him off. The only explanation is they were drugged by the coward.
I am beyond the beyond with the 5th roomate(what is the testimony of the 6th roommate???) . She heard what would definitely be odd comments and noises. She actually peers out her door and sees the loser. She then doesn't call the cops , nor does the 6th roommate for 6-8 hrs. WHY? IT MAKES NO SENSE!!!
I know its morbid to think this... but this POS saw the 5th roommate and didn't attack or kill her...and the morbid question is WHY??? It doesn't make sense, unless he was exhausted and wanted to get out of there no matter what. But even common sense wise it doesn't make sense.
I have a feeling that more bizarre facts will come to the public arena, and some of them will be unpleasant for the surviving roommates. The authorities seem to be doing a excellent job on this case, and I think they are looking at the 2 surviving roommates carefully.
If the surviving roommates were involved in some way they would have already been arrested as quickly as this Bryan guy was.
So authorities are trusting the roommate's testimony? Why? Her testimony doesn't make sense and is not credible.
Why doesn't it " make sense "?
Yeah ive noticed it too.Its like they defend her.Hopefully the victims parents will sue her.
If this person saw the guy in black with a mask, did she call police. She said she went back to her room and locked her door??????? Why didn't she call police???????This makes no sense?????
Why the heck did she not call the police???
The roommate saw the murderer and one of the victims was still alive at that time. Question is why didn't she call 911? At least one of the victims would be alive today if that call had been made right away
It was a loud busy house. Even if she heard screaming, it doesn't mean that they were loud or panicked. 5 girls lived in that house, so even though a man leaving around 4am may be unusual, it doesn't mean anyone was killed. He was not aggressive towards her. There were no reasons to automatically assume her Roommates were murdered. She didn't have the facts that we now have.
@@AFloridaSon If you see someone with a mask on gloves and everything and you don’t panic you must have a room temperature IQ
It was reported that all of those poor kids had fatal wounds. Sadly, there was nothing any emergency services techs could have done to help save any of them.
Get real....an intruder......call the police. End of conversation.
@@valeries929 you don't know that
You come face-to-face with the killer yet you never question it you never called the police you turn around and go back to sleep know something sounds fishy. This is beyond fishy.
This “roomate” sounds funny as hell. Hears cries, sees masked man, and strangely walks past her but she goes to bed and not wake up till next day. YEAH RIGHT?!! I smell a setup.
So if you see a unknown masked intruder at 4am after hearing crying JUST go back to sleep like a baby until noon and everything will be okay🤦♂️🤦♂️🤡🤡
Roommate was in a frozen shock for 8 hours after? Doesn’t make sense. I would want to get away from
The place I saw a strange intruder rather than stay in place for that long knowing police weren’t coming
Sadly her story makes absolutely no sense at all, what on earth 🙈
Can someone tell me the information on where it states that she fell back asleep? Just wondering how she was able to do that after seeing something so scary like a man with a black mask in the house?
Not sure if it came from her statement or not, whatever she was doing something is off .....
@@Aquariusloves for sure! Something isn’t adding up. Even in a state of shock you wouldn’t chose to go back to sleep. I would like to read where it says that.
@@gracec7128 Right well her room was on the first floor and if she heard all that noise three different times she should have known something was up, she lives there and she knows her roommates ..now I'm still confused how she got close enough to see his eyebrows, and body shape but he didn't see her, and why he bypassed the first floor and went up the stairs to the other roommates, now he was watching since Aug so had he been in the house before to know their layout.....it still ain't adding up
@@Aquariusloves her room was on the second level. Same as Xana’s room.
@@Aquariusloves that’s wild, now I have even more questions 😦
Who freezes for 7 hours ?🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄
I understand wanting execution. It's a shame it takes so long and so many times of the parents having to go to court and fight.
It just doesn't add up.
If she had done something sooner like call the cops some of her friends might have survived... it certainly sounds like that!
Useless friends. No 911 call . No help. Those four bled to death.
I'm confused. If room-mate DM had one of the bedrooms on the first floor and spied this masked, dark clothed figure coming towards her to exit thru the glass door, I thought the glass sliding doors were only located on the 2nd and 3rd floors?
She was on the second floor. Her bedroom was adjacent Xana’s room closest to the sliding door and stairway. He walked by her room twice and didn’t even think to go in there? Not buying it.
I’ve been in situations where I’ve frozen and fainted from fear. But 8 hours is a LONG time not to do anything even after hearing crying and thuds.
I get locking yourself in your room, but why not text one of your roommates to see if they’re okay?? She knew something was wrong with Xana and didn’t even go check the second time BEFORE seeing Bryan. Even after, she didn’t even wait half an hour - an hour to call police to make sure she was safe. She waited an entire 8 HOURS. She wasn’t so frozen that she couldn’t lock her door and walk herself back to her bed.
How do we know he was at this house 12 times prior bc he was stalking them - what if he had something going on with Dylan? Why did he spare Dylan in a bedroom on the same floor as the two others - he just so happened to ignore her bedroom (the closest one to the stairway and the sliding door) TWICE and went into the far one? How did he know his way through the house? How did she see his DARK eyebrows in the DARK??
Why wouldn’t she call the cops too?
In the affidavit it says DM’s bedroom was on the same floor as Ethan and Xana.
DM lived on the second floor.
thanks for the clarification on where her bedroom was.
And you now he would have some injuries on his body especially his hands , the police took a picture of his hand while he was in his car with his dad !
He pretty much thinks he’ll get the death penalty which he would
He should and asap this guys a monster if he did commit this crime which it looks pretty apparent
Wau
Muy loco
Confusion Confusion 😕
Rest in Peace, Xana, Maddie, Kaylee and Ethan ❤💜💛💙
And this is only coming out now?
Well only certain information can be publicly released during an active investigation and trial. This is a law. This is why we only get so much info until AFTER the case is closed. This is why everyone thought Meg the Stallion was lying up until the guilty verdict against Tory. Everyone claimed she was lying, even after his verdict. Then, the other evidence was released as public. The phone call, the X-rays of her feet, etc. Not all of that is publicly available until after the case. Please remember this.
It wasn't determined to involve any harm or murder until noon.