I remember playing as low honor, and then when Arthur was diagnosed with tb it generally left me sad so i started doing good things and was left with one of the best emotional experiences in years
@@kranx2690exactly you get the point of the game... Arthur was scared of dying a bad person i also dont see the point in being low honor when you can quick save you get the gunslinger grips and all
I always play low honor until the end. It makes the most sense. Arthur Morgan is a violent criminal. He is the gangs enforcer. When the dirty work needs to be done, it's Arthur who does it. Honor has nothing to do with it. It's a game about violent outlaws. If the protagonist of the story was a lawman, chasing down the Van Der Linde gang, you'd see them as nothing but violent degenerates. If we played as Dutch you'd think he was a hero too. In reality they're criminals and at the end they all get what's coming to them. I play the game according to the story. Yes, sometimes I kill innocents and that isn't something Arthur does, but it gets me money. I often have bounties in 3 states and will kill bounty hunters and take the jewels off their bodies. Arthur is not a good man. Even at the end he's not a good man, but he's a bad man whom, at the end of his life, tries to do good for those he loves. The reality is, just like many of you, the Van Der Linde gang are horribly deluded individuals who believe that, despite all the evils they do, they are good people. Charles knows they are nothing but criminals. Even Sadie Adler does. Even Hosea realizes that they became nothing but murderers. While others work for their living, the Van Der Lindes make their living from robbing others. People hate Micah but you know what I think? I think Micah is the purest of them all. He has no grand delusions of being some grand helper of the poor. He knows that he is an outlaw, a vicious killer who does not follow the law or the rules of society. Dutch is a great and charismatic character. He's capable of convincing nearly all of his followers that they're doing good but in reality Dutch needs the gang because he has a bounty on his head and they are both protection and camouflage. I mean, we play as a character who often kills officers and innocent people who are simply doing their jobs and trying to protect the innocent. Not to mention we badly hurt people and ruin their lives through extortion. You may be deluded enough to believe that Arthur is an honorable man, but tell me what Arthur does in the story that is honorable? Is robbing a man honorable? Is killing law enforcement officers and honorable thing to do? Is beating a dying man senseless and giving another man brain damage honorable? No. None of those things are honorable. Arthur was never supposed to be a good man. If he were then it wouldn't be a game called "Red Dead Redemption"
@@LuisLopez-wn6tzI don't see the point in playing a game where the protagonist is an enforcer in a gang of violent robbers and murderers and trying to be a good guy. Robin Hood is only the hero of the poor, he's not a hero for the proletariat or bourgeoisie. These guys aren't even Robin Hoods. They're robbers and killers. I don't see how you believe they can be honorable just because they are human and have emotions. I believe it's the brave men who seek these guys out, often to their own demise, who are the true heroes. We may be the protagonist of the story, but Arthur is no hero. We play as a villain.
High honor Arthur is the prefect example of tragic hero. He had all the reasons in the world to be evil and ruthless, but still chose the path of redemption...
Low honor: He accepted his fate, he lived his way, he'll die his way High Honor: He's afraid, but he still takes a gamble that love exists and does a loving act.
@@kian_the_superbb you can't have a conversation with Sister while Arthur is low honor even you've done all Sister and Brother missions. You only meet Reverend as being low honor
Bro high honor be boring I bought red dead to create bloodshed and have action when you’re high honor you are restricted to being good all the time EDIT: All of you children are getting upset in my replies talking about “that’s not how the game is supposed to be played” or “Go play something else” in all honesty I don’t care. I’m playing the game to have fun you are playing to make an imaginary video game character a “good man” for a cutscene at the end of the game. Like I’m sorry I offended you by calling it boring I’m not going to let a imaginary ingame social status from stopping me having fun. I get it ooo main character dies at a sunset big deal but at the end of the day everything in the game is fake so play it to have fun not for a goddamn good reputation.
After my first run being a high honor one, it was really hard to be low honor. This is the only game that makes me feel bad about killing random npc’s.
Agree and it’s just hard because the story line is perfect although arthur was an outlaw u can see that everybody has a sec chance to change to be better for some people
Yea, R* did a great job when making NPCs in this game, you feel empathy for them because of how realistic they feel. I hope they make them fun to kill again in the next GTA though and leave the realism to thr RDR series
@@A.0.1.T it still isnt worth it like for what are you hurting him hes gonna stay alive until 1907 and till then he will get used to the eye and the pain goes away
The best thing about this assessment is it shows when and where the overall story can best be done by being evil and then redeeming yourself in later chapters
The best way to play is to be a bad man up till the doctors "if you know you know" and then play as a good man so it feels more like a redemption than a corse corection.
I finished the game with max honor. RDR2 taught me so many things I didn't know about, like revenge being a fool's game. And the nun's words really hit me deep when she said "take a gamble that love exists and do a loving act". I ended up choosing to help John with high honor. The best game I've ever played.
After 5 chapters of low honor and then all of chapter 6 fishing and greeting people in Saint Denis, I got to that choice and audibly said to myself "Nah, outlaw for life" and went back for the money. Will admit the death scene on the mountain was much better but I don't regret my choice
I finished the game with Max Honor. The game taught me so many things aswell. And the examples you gave were the things I learnt out of more. Even if I complete 100% of the game and I can do whatever I want, I will still be Max Honor because I feel horrible about killing NPCs. I was Max/high honor in all the chapters and I regret NOTHING about that. The high-honor story really payed off greatly.
I Finished The Game In 2 Saves Both Were Max Honor And Honestly I Shed Some Tears(8 In Total In The First Save And The Save Second Was 5) In Both When Arthur Dead It Was A Really Sad Scene To Watch
Red Dead Redemption 2 changed me for the better. I can tell you all that. From the moment I wrote this comment until the second you are reading this reply, I just keep on being better and better. Heck this game got me to the point that it fixed my relationship with my religion because of how it changed my mindset. I don't regret playing this game at all.
Nah saving side quests that give u high honor or involve redemption and then just doing a ton of those (while greeting people and helping those in random encounters) best way to increase honor fast and also way better of a redemption arc and way more emotional then some guy just greeting everyone in a town. Mistakes are actually redeemed (Downes family, Last Strauss mission where u Absolve all debts and kick out that piece of trash, paying debts you have in towns to atleast try to make up for the irredeemable murder sprees)
I challenge myself with low honor by simply not paying off my bounty it's really fun and kinda stressful when you're in the wildness going to sleep and waking up to bounty hunters but I recommend it
low honor throughout the game and Greet for hours to gain high honor in the end. *"That man massacred countless people.....but he said Hello to just as many."* 😂😂😂
I'm playing as Arthur rn like right at this moment and I am on the last mission where I am saving Abgail and I will be emotional because I am high honor and I am planning to save John and this is actually the first time I am high honor
The only game ever where the Story changed my play style. At first I used to be low honor but throughout the game without even thinking about it, I just got into high honor. Truly the best story game I’ve ever played.
The same thing happened to me when I played Ghost of Tsushima. At first, I was fighting at open, like true samurai. And then, without realizing that, I became Ghost, who mostly kills stealthily
@@spider-deku4479 I just slaughtered them from the beginning in the most efficient way 😂 I'd get the uncle flashbacks basically instantly after any new ghost skill
Even though this is the low honor ending and I hate it, this is actually a badass last word and fits low honor Arthur very well. Better than getting stabbed to death as he tries to crawl away in the go for the money ending.
My first playthrough was low honour because I didn’t see a way for Arthur to change, the low honour death genuinely shook me, throughout the game I didn’t even realise I was getting attached to Arthur’s character and the end cemented my hate for Micah, I didn’t like him from the start even when I was doing the exact same things as him and sometimes even worse, revenge was a bitter happiness. My second playthrough was high honour and I’m glad it wasn’t my first since I don’t think I would’ve became a better person in the real world if it was my first. The game changed my view on everything in life which is why I’m actually trying to pursue something that I still think is impossible to reach but I won’t give up until I’ve done all I can to achieve it.
While playing with low honor gives way more freedom, it kinda makes you feel guilty, yet when you play with high honor you could just ball your eyes out from it all the emotional experience. This game really knows how to hit you in the feels.
High honor reduces the prices on the stores, some loot beneficies, a special grip for cattleman revolver, etc; when low honor gives you just a skull grip for double action, so it's easier have high honor. And the cutscenes about death of gang members and other stuff in all chapters make a lot more sense
Well if you play a high honor character you'll need those lowered costs. In my current gameplay I have $30k. I have enough to buy everything in the game, whether it comes with a discount or not. And the double action is a great weapon. It's an upgrade of the single action. And I use those right now. They're great weapons
The cutscenes of death of other gang members don't make any more sense. When Arthur talks about the members who died before the game started he doesn't talk like he does in the high honor cutscenes
@@rocketjumpmaster34 It is half true, low honor increase the chances of valuable items, tobacco, cigars and decrease the chances of medicines. With high honor, the chance of medicines is increased and don't decrease the chance of valuable items, from the moment you have filled your medicine inventory, literally 90% of time will drop only jewels and other valuable items like clocks, rings, buckles and other stuff. I literally made 60K looting the bodies of bounty hunters and seelling the items and 98% of the game I was High Honor.
On my first playthrough I genuinely played with high honor until the end, all I wanted was to help others who couldn't help themselves which made it sadder when my Arthur couldn't help himself and no one was able to help me.
@silasworld2200that’s cool! In rdr2 epilogue I did the most bad things I could think of so I could reach the lowest honor then I kept creating people. I got a diamond achievement
I will always play high honor, it's my 3rd playthrough and still, i'm sticking with the high honor path. I refuse to destroy the picture of the masterpiece rockstar created in the high honor path.
This game truly can bring out a persons true self if played on how you truly want to. Thos game lets you see true humanity and that its possible to change but its up to you if you want to change. Arthur was the furthest from a Saint but he knew and accepted that. But tried to do what he felt was right. Even Bad men can do good.
I love the wolf/buck imagery throughout the game and in like the cutscenes between chapters and stuff.. man this game is a masterpiece. I liked playing my first time because I was naturally low honor for a long time, cuz I wanted to go around doing cowboy stuff, robbing and killing. By the time I got TB, I realized that continuing to do all that on the level of the “common man” had no meaning anymore, and started doing good deeds, refusing payment for services, and giving money to those who needed it. At the end of the day, I was dying, so why do I need all this?
I like playing low honor at the beginning and then high honor slowly to emphasize the change in arthur It also really correlates with the high honor dialogue with the nun when she said “you don’t know you”
"Sean's been killed...head shot half off in a ambush" -low honor "He was like an annoying little brother to me...what fun we had riding together...what a goddam mess were making of things" -high honor
Imo the low honour death for Arthur was better than high honour cuz when you kill Micah if you shoot him once in chest it goes hard af and when Dutch shoots Micah it feels like he was avenging Arthur for Micah shooting him
I played high honor the whole way and achieved highest honor. But with the way Arthur talks and feels about his actions at the start of the story, i feel like it makes more sense to play low honor. It validates the redemption thats needed
Just finished this game for the first time yesterday morning. I shed some tears for Mr Morgan getting his good ending Redemption. That was a true man who just wanted to do the right thing
In my tenth game of story mode, these were my reflections on each chapter. Chapter 1: Undecided, probably bad Chapter 2: Full-fledged outlaw, enough evil for one's own good but without harming ours. Chapter 3: Semi neutral, more bad but a little good. Chapter 4: Indecisive again, you lost many and you don't know your path but you have to survive. Chapter 5: Turning point, what's the point of being bad if everything goes to hell and if not, what's the point of being bad if I'm going to die? Chapter 6: You are afraid, you know that you did many bad things and now in your final moments you know that it is not worth your time in life, you do not seek forgiveness you just want to redeem your sins a little. Epilogue part 1 & 2: You are a family man, you cannot risk yourself or your family, you have to be neutral... Although you have a bad feeling (Events of rdr1).
I feel like chapter 6 throws every opportunity to raise your honor so when you were an absolute asshat, you can still "redeem" yourself to get a better ending as the title suggests.
I love the high honor ending when you go back for the money, you get to take Micah’s eye out and leave him with a permanent reminder that he fucked with the wrong one
The high honor death scene is still so heart wrenching. Seeing him drag himself to the rocks so he can see the sunrise as he takes his final breath truly destroyed me. He truly tried to be a better person in his final days and was still betrayed by the one person he trusted the most.
My first play through I was playing scummy up until I chapter 4 and met Dorkins, didn’t know that there would be multiple endings but happy to say I got the good ending. Incredible game.
Arthur always says revenge is a fool's game. That just proves he is afraid of revenge and its consequences. But he indeed is a good and beautiful man even after what happened with him.
I played and finished this game with high honor and then with low honor, in that order, and it is much more enjoyable to play with high honor. Arthur's ending is extremely moving, and i couldn't hold back the tears.
Most cutscenes are the same low honor the music is lower like “Crash of Worlds” and some of the dialogue is different in American venom I like playing low honor as it makes it feel the way Arthur intended himself to be
Subscribe For More RDR Content!
Viedo Game Timeline Pls Made Part4
@@legopower13 i finished that series like 2 months ago unfortunately
@@ryezyyy no
You Have To return this
Song?
Music?????
Song?????
???????
High honour- Run Arthur Morgan
Low honour- Run its Arthur morgan
A mod with invincible arthur and Pinkerton rampage is dope
Low honour - run its Arthur Morgan
High honour - thank you Arthur Morgan
@@EasyEvil0000Way better
😂😂
@@EasyEvil0000 Nailed it
I remember playing as low honor, and then when Arthur was diagnosed with tb it generally left me sad so i started doing good things and was left with one of the best emotional experiences in years
same
Playing second time now and litterally cant be a dick anymore
@@kranx2690exactly you get the point of the game... Arthur was scared of dying a bad person i also dont see the point in being low honor when you can quick save you get the gunslinger grips and all
I always play low honor until the end. It makes the most sense. Arthur Morgan is a violent criminal. He is the gangs enforcer. When the dirty work needs to be done, it's Arthur who does it. Honor has nothing to do with it. It's a game about violent outlaws. If the protagonist of the story was a lawman, chasing down the Van Der Linde gang, you'd see them as nothing but violent degenerates. If we played as Dutch you'd think he was a hero too. In reality they're criminals and at the end they all get what's coming to them. I play the game according to the story. Yes, sometimes I kill innocents and that isn't something Arthur does, but it gets me money. I often have bounties in 3 states and will kill bounty hunters and take the jewels off their bodies. Arthur is not a good man. Even at the end he's not a good man, but he's a bad man whom, at the end of his life, tries to do good for those he loves. The reality is, just like many of you, the Van Der Linde gang are horribly deluded individuals who believe that, despite all the evils they do, they are good people. Charles knows they are nothing but criminals. Even Sadie Adler does. Even Hosea realizes that they became nothing but murderers. While others work for their living, the Van Der Lindes make their living from robbing others. People hate Micah but you know what I think? I think Micah is the purest of them all. He has no grand delusions of being some grand helper of the poor. He knows that he is an outlaw, a vicious killer who does not follow the law or the rules of society. Dutch is a great and charismatic character. He's capable of convincing nearly all of his followers that they're doing good but in reality Dutch needs the gang because he has a bounty on his head and they are both protection and camouflage. I mean, we play as a character who often kills officers and innocent people who are simply doing their jobs and trying to protect the innocent. Not to mention we badly hurt people and ruin their lives through extortion. You may be deluded enough to believe that Arthur is an honorable man, but tell me what Arthur does in the story that is honorable? Is robbing a man honorable? Is killing law enforcement officers and honorable thing to do? Is beating a dying man senseless and giving another man brain damage honorable? No. None of those things are honorable. Arthur was never supposed to be a good man. If he were then it wouldn't be a game called "Red Dead Redemption"
@@LuisLopez-wn6tzI don't see the point in playing a game where the protagonist is an enforcer in a gang of violent robbers and murderers and trying to be a good guy. Robin Hood is only the hero of the poor, he's not a hero for the proletariat or bourgeoisie. These guys aren't even Robin Hoods. They're robbers and killers. I don't see how you believe they can be honorable just because they are human and have emotions. I believe it's the brave men who seek these guys out, often to their own demise, who are the true heroes. We may be the protagonist of the story, but Arthur is no hero. We play as a villain.
High honor Arthur is the prefect example of tragic hero. He had all the reasons in the world to be evil and ruthless, but still chose the path of redemption...
He's not really one of the best heroes of gaming.
@Deadeye5074 The anti-hero of this game would most likely be Dutch and the Pinkertons. I think Kieran is the hero.
Whaaattttt kieren??..pls tell u were high while writing this comment @@Andrewjapaneserees
@@AndrewjapanesereesDutch is just straight up an evil and manipulative character what do you mean he’s and anti hero
Arthur: "Everything that had happened....was truly my red dead redemption"
Low honor: He accepted his fate, he lived his way, he'll die his way
High Honor: He's afraid, but he still takes a gamble that love exists and does a loving act.
So true
this from suster n the one who saved mostly die by train?
@@jemimowYes
He is still afraid as low honour I’m pretty sure because he says to sister
@@kian_the_superbb you can't have a conversation with Sister while Arthur is low honor even you've done all Sister and Brother missions. You only meet Reverend as being low honor
Your not a good man Arthur but your surely not a bad man
-Reverend Swanson
How the hell do you know he said that boah
@@Arthur._.Morgan1583 He said when they met at the railway station. When arthur gives sendoff to captain monroe
@@nithinkumar591 Remind me of what Irish told John in the first Red Dead. "Your a feck ugly man John Marston.....But not a bad one!"
It's "You're not a good man Arthur but you're not all bad... either"
Arthur was not a good man. But he was always a good man amongst bad ones. High honor ftw
Bro high honor be boring I bought red dead to create bloodshed and have action when you’re high honor you are restricted to being good all the time
EDIT: All of you children are getting upset in my replies talking about “that’s not how the game is supposed to be played” or “Go play something else” in all honesty I don’t care. I’m playing the game to have fun you are playing to make an imaginary video game character a “good man” for a cutscene at the end of the game. Like I’m sorry I offended you by calling it boring I’m not going to let a imaginary ingame social status from stopping me having fun. I get it ooo main character dies at a sunset big deal but at the end of the day everything in the game is fake so play it to have fun not for a goddamn good reputation.
@@jcclips3354perhaps you just don't have the attention span to enjoy a game without murder, and that's okay. but many of us like to play that way 👍
@@JavierEscuella1899 bro really said “perhaps you don’t have an attention span” 🤓👆like Blud 💀
@@jcclips3354 Who hurt you?
@@jcclips3354 stop being butthurt
After my first run being a high honor one, it was really hard to be low honor. This is the only game that makes me feel bad about killing random npc’s.
💀
Agree and it’s just hard because the story line is perfect although arthur was an outlaw u can see that everybody has a sec chance to change to be better for some people
Yeah it made every decision and action you make have consequences
this game feels real, i could get lost in this game for hours.
Yea, R* did a great job when making NPCs in this game, you feel empathy for them because of how realistic they feel. I hope they make them fun to kill again in the next GTA though and leave the realism to thr RDR series
High honor: Better story
Low honor: Better gameplay
Debatable.
High honor and low honor both offer good stories.
It's all up to you how you want to perceive it.
@@thechefwhodoesntcook8233 Agreed
@@thechefwhodoesntcook8233 true, although low honor kinda defeats the whole point of the "Redemption" part of the title
@@eriknorman1690 Yeah that's why i think rockstar didnt really put off the honor system well
@@eriknorman1690 Because low honor makes more sense in chapter 1-5 and high honor in chapter 6. There's no redemption if you're already a good man.
Love how the deer and wolf were used to symbolise both sides
its a coyote but yeah true
@@damian99901 Isn't it a little bit too big for a coyote Mate?
It's a wolf. When Arthur goes hunting with Hamish Sinclair, he kills a large black wolf and says that he sees the beast in his dreams. @@Ibrahim6868
@@Ibrahim6868 nah hes right its a black coyote, the models match. Not that it changes anything.
Arthur:🦌
john:🐺/🦌
Micah:🐀
p.s. lore accurate rdr2
Ever since my brother died life ain't been the same no more
Hey John.
@@topgamer9532 howdy feller
Hey Javier.
what the fuck are you on about
When i played as low honor it was so hard leave John.
Fr John's a real one
My next playthrough ill go high honor back for money cus injure micahs eye
@@not.krosshairit aint worth it hes gonna die in the end
@@choclate3265but he gets an eyepatch then
@@A.0.1.T it still isnt worth it like for what are you hurting him hes gonna stay alive until 1907 and till then he will get used to the eye and the pain goes away
🤠
Me too
I always make Arthur medium honour until he gets TB, then all the way to high honour
Same, this is exactly how I played the game
That was me on my first ever play through i just completed rdr2 as soon as i found out he had tb i *hey mister* *Howdy* the f out of saint denis
I played like this but i brought him to mid honor right before guarma
The best thing about this assessment is it shows when and where the overall story can best be done by being evil and then redeeming yourself in later chapters
Yeah thats what the scene with the nun is trying to get across to the player... Arthur doesn't want to die a bad man
*Friends I did 17 one arm pull ups, please support me*
just doesnt make sense to add chapter 1 as a point since nothing changes
The best way to play is to be a bad man up till the doctors "if you know you know" and then play as a good man so it feels more like a redemption than a corse corection.
I didn't know he would get shot so badly with low honor.
RIP Arthur for making us keep up with the game.
And also get stabed a knife by Micah if you choice "return for the money" with low honor
I finished the game with max honor. RDR2 taught me so many things I didn't know about, like revenge being a fool's game. And the nun's words really hit me deep when she said "take a gamble that love exists and do a loving act". I ended up choosing to help John with high honor. The best game I've ever played.
Mükemmel oyun 👌
After 5 chapters of low honor and then all of chapter 6 fishing and greeting people in Saint Denis, I got to that choice and audibly said to myself "Nah, outlaw for life" and went back for the money. Will admit the death scene on the mountain was much better but I don't regret my choice
I finished the game with Max Honor. The game taught me so many things aswell. And the examples you gave were the things I learnt out of more. Even if I complete 100% of the game and I can do whatever I want, I will still be Max Honor because I feel horrible about killing NPCs. I was Max/high honor in all the chapters and I regret NOTHING about that. The high-honor story really payed off greatly.
I Finished The Game In 2 Saves
Both Were Max Honor And Honestly I Shed Some Tears(8 In Total In The First Save And The Save Second Was 5) In Both When Arthur Dead It Was A Really Sad Scene To Watch
Red Dead Redemption 2 changed me for the better. I can tell you all that. From the moment I wrote this comment until the second you are reading this reply, I just keep on being better and better. Heck this game got me to the point that it fixed my relationship with my religion because of how it changed my mindset. I don't regret playing this game at all.
High Honor Arthur is One Of The Most Beautiful Stories Ever Told
Low Honor is The Coldest 🥶
The low honor one is more immersive towards the time period
@ethanplays_gamermf that’s assassins creed 3
@ethanplays_gamerThat’s Hytham not Haytham
@ethanplays_gamer bro they do not talking about that fodder they talk about Haytham Kenway from ac 3
@ethanplays_gamer there two completely different people throughout the series so not the same at all
Arthur's death legit had me crying
And his horse
Just steal a random guys horse before the mission👍
@@IHatetomatoes2008 doesnt have the same impact
@@Superlizardy36especially if your using the golden buell horse
Poor Buell 😢
True😢
High honor: "You're a *good* man Arthur Morgan."
Low honor: "You're a *confusing* Arthur Morgan."
You're a good man Arthur..
(not even 5 minutes later throws someone on train tracks)
People forgetting u can just say hi to everyone in the saloon after massacring the town
hahaha
Boring and not efficient. Go fishing and release fish.
Nah saving side quests that give u high honor or involve redemption and then just doing a ton of those (while greeting people and helping those in random encounters) best way to increase honor fast and also way better of a redemption arc and way more emotional then some guy just greeting everyone in a town. Mistakes are actually redeemed (Downes family, Last Strauss mission where u Absolve all debts and kick out that piece of trash, paying debts you have in towns to atleast try to make up for the irredeemable murder sprees)
Save passers by
I challenge myself with low honor by simply not paying off my bounty it's really fun and kinda stressful when you're in the wildness going to sleep and waking up to bounty hunters but I recommend it
Same people should play with 1500 dollar bounty in every state and that would be like playing as the legend of the east
Yeah I like doing this too. You're suppose to be this outlaw on the run.
Not to mention bounty hunters has a chance to interfere with the camp without you even moving out of the camp. Its a nice detail they added
@@Angel19kingcan’t even hunt in peace
That's what I was doing until I started to hunt for the best satchel.
Let me chase my perfect racoon pelt ffs!!
Neutral honor and high honor at the end of the game 🗿
chapter 3 definitely neutral+ because i can’t have arthur not say “he was like a little brother to me”
low honor throughout the game and Greet for hours to gain high honor in the end.
*"That man massacred countless people.....but he said Hello to just as many."* 😂😂😂
@@WATCHMYCLIPSZ😂😂😂so true made my day
I'm playing as Arthur rn like right at this moment and I am on the last mission where I am saving Abgail and I will be emotional because I am high honor and I am planning to save John and this is actually the first time I am high honor
Chapter 1: Low Honor
Chapter 2: Low Honor
Chapter 3: Low/Neutral Honor
Chapter 4: Neutral/High Honor
Chapter 5: High Honor
Chapter 6: High/Very High Honor
3 last missions of Chapter 6: Max Honor
The only game ever where the Story changed my play style.
At first I used to be low honor but throughout the game without even thinking about it, I just got into high honor.
Truly the best story game I’ve ever played.
The same thing happened to me when I played Ghost of Tsushima. At first, I was fighting at open, like true samurai. And then, without realizing that, I became Ghost, who mostly kills stealthily
@@spider-deku4479 I just slaughtered them from the beginning in the most efficient way 😂
I'd get the uncle flashbacks basically instantly after any new ghost skill
Low honor: Badass.
High Honor: *Remembered.*
“We are outlaws, in a world that don’t want us no more”
-Arthur Morgan
"One day we must decide between what is right and what is easy." - dumbledore
Damn. . .
"Revenge is a fool's game"
Arthur Morgan-
Only the weak says that
Situational
@@ineedpowers5151weak people seek revenge, strong people forgive, while smart people ignore.
@@ineedpowers5151Arthur Morgen is not weak. Dutch is weak. Dutch without Arthur cannot do nothing
But I felt different
“Damn you!”
“Damn us both!”
-Get’s shot in the head
this is not really ending
high honor really ending
Even though this is the low honor ending and I hate it, this is actually a badass last word and fits low honor Arthur very well. Better than getting stabbed to death as he tries to crawl away in the go for the money ending.
I just finished the story last night and I started getting all choked up when this happened
TRNNIS BOAT 🛥️🎾
Your not better than me Morgan
My first playthrough was low honour because I didn’t see a way for Arthur to change, the low honour death genuinely shook me, throughout the game I didn’t even realise I was getting attached to Arthur’s character and the end cemented my hate for Micah, I didn’t like him from the start even when I was doing the exact same things as him and sometimes even worse, revenge was a bitter happiness. My second playthrough was high honour and I’m glad it wasn’t my first since I don’t think I would’ve became a better person in the real world if it was my first. The game changed my view on everything in life which is why I’m actually trying to pursue something that I still think is impossible to reach but I won’t give up until I’ve done all I can to achieve it.
Wow, Although I don't know you, I'm glad that you want to change yourself for the better.
I wish you luck in your life see ya
@ thank you, an I wish you luck in your future.
While playing with low honor gives way more freedom, it kinda makes you feel guilty, yet when you play with high honor you could just ball your eyes out from it all the emotional experience. This game really knows how to hit you in the feels.
High honor reduces the prices on the stores, some loot beneficies, a special grip for cattleman revolver, etc; when low honor gives you just a skull grip for double action, so it's easier have high honor. And the cutscenes about death of gang members and other stuff in all chapters make a lot more sense
Well if you play a high honor character you'll need those lowered costs. In my current gameplay I have $30k. I have enough to buy everything in the game, whether it comes with a discount or not. And the double action is a great weapon. It's an upgrade of the single action. And I use those right now. They're great weapons
The cutscenes of death of other gang members don't make any more sense. When Arthur talks about the members who died before the game started he doesn't talk like he does in the high honor cutscenes
Low honor gives you valuable stuff if you loot someone
@@rocketjumpmaster34 It is half true, low honor increase the chances of valuable items, tobacco, cigars and decrease the chances of medicines. With high honor, the chance of medicines is increased and don't decrease the chance of valuable items, from the moment you have filled your medicine inventory, literally 90% of time will drop only jewels and other valuable items like clocks, rings, buckles and other stuff. I literally made 60K looting the bodies of bounty hunters and seelling the items and 98% of the game I was High Honor.
@TheReaICowfish Canonically Red Dead Redemption is about redemption, so High Honor is more canon than Low Honor
The song is summertime sadness X i wanna be yours (slowed) thank me later
Thanks friend, all the best to you
Tanks mate
Giga Chad mate thank you
God Bless you King
God bless you, boah
"Dutch...Micah...Come and get me you bastards."
Easily one of the best lines in gaming history.
perfect song for a great edit
name?
@@crzvm1lk
Summertime sadness x I wanna be yours
@@Weslery245 ty im gonna tell some ppl the name too
Playing high honor and hearing arthur say thanks to the horse i kept throughout the entire game made me cry for a full hour
On my first playthrough I genuinely played with high honor until the end, all I wanted was to help others who couldn't help themselves which made it sadder when my Arthur couldn't help himself and no one was able to help me.
For me it’s always high honor
Me to sadie i am sorry btw
@silasworld2200that’s cool! In rdr2 epilogue I did the most bad things I could think of so I could reach the lowest honor then I kept creating people. I got a diamond achievement
@@Dutchvanderlinde121it’s ok
@@Sadie__Adlerare you a girl mate?
Why are you in everi comment section i go
High honour is probably the lore accurate way but playing not caring about honour is just more fun
A normal person will anyways have a high honour.
@@himanshugurjar9002 cry
Low Honour : I Am a Survivor
High Honour : I Am a Savior
I will always play high honor, it's my 3rd playthrough and still, i'm sticking with the high honor path. I refuse to destroy the picture of the masterpiece rockstar created in the high honor path.
Low honor feels more sad because after all Arthur did, he's still accepted by the last of the gang, but you wish he wishes he did more to deserve it.
High honor is logical ending of character,like he was bad,but turned into still bad,but a person with good deeds.
Just that song hits hard😢
the conversations with sister calderon are very powerful. felt good to be told God is everybody and everything & love does exist.. it's within us all
I once heard a youtuber say that it was best to play with low honor until Arthur got tuberculosis and from there you do it with high honor.
If you have high honor when you fight Micah Arthur lands more punches it’s way more satisfying despite the best character in the whole series dying
That's not true
The song name - Summertime sadness x I wanna be yours ( slowed+reverb+bass boosted )
Channel - Melody's temptation
Thank you
Holy shit, you're an angel sent from the skies. Thanks so much
Thank you so much
Thanks dude
@@sanchesgt2621 Glad to help you 😊
This game truly can bring out a persons true self if played on how you truly want to. Thos game lets you see true humanity and that its possible to change but its up to you if you want to change.
Arthur was the furthest from a Saint but he knew and accepted that. But tried to do what he felt was right. Even Bad men can do good.
Imagine If Arthur only stayed alive if he had bad honour
Dude, This Edit is so chill, I'm so addicted to It😩😩.
I love the wolf/buck imagery throughout the game and in like the cutscenes between chapters and stuff.. man this game is a masterpiece. I liked playing my first time because I was naturally low honor for a long time, cuz I wanted to go around doing cowboy stuff, robbing and killing. By the time I got TB, I realized that continuing to do all that on the level of the “common man” had no meaning anymore, and started doing good deeds, refusing payment for services, and giving money to those who needed it. At the end of the day, I was dying, so why do I need all this?
@scarletgoat173well idk about that friend. In game it’s definitely a wolf and buck
agreed thats how i think its meant to be played it fits the story a lot more imo and also its a black coyote not a wolf
It’s called redemption for a reason 😭🙏🔥
Rockstar cooked so good it made Gordon Ramsay cry 💀
Arthur doesn't want to redeem his self. He wants to be punished. Instead, he redeems JOHN.
Source? Journal
I had the low honor ending so it means I didnt Play the Game Right?
Play low honor for the entire game until arthur gets diagnosed with tuberculosis then it's high.
Red Dead Redemption@@vasilije7401
True tho. I don’t care what I do until I reach chapter 4. After that Arthur needs to have his redemption
I like playing low honor at the beginning and then high honor slowly to emphasize the change in arthur
It also really correlates with the high honor dialogue with the nun when she said “you don’t know you”
I definitelt feel like the narrative works way better with a high honor path.
"Face me to the west so I can watch the setting sun and remember all the fine times we had that way."
"Sean's been killed...head shot half off in a ambush" -low honor
"He was like an annoying little brother to me...what fun we had riding together...what a goddam mess were making of things" -high honor
dialogue is definitely cooler with low honor, arthur killing someone “ill see you in hell my friend”
Imo the low honour death for Arthur was better than high honour cuz when you kill Micah if you shoot him once in chest it goes hard af and when Dutch shoots Micah it feels like he was avenging Arthur for Micah shooting him
I played high honor the whole way and achieved highest honor. But with the way Arthur talks and feels about his actions at the start of the story, i feel like it makes more sense to play low honor. It validates the redemption thats needed
Low honor is really fun to play but high honor feels right
Low Honor: Fuck the world
High Honor: This world won’t make me a bad person
Arthur Is the most loyal Vander Linde Gang member.
Just finished this game for the first time yesterday morning. I shed some tears for Mr Morgan getting his good ending Redemption. That was a true man who just wanted to do the right thing
High honour - one of the greatest stories
Low honour - one of the coldest
Low honor at first, but Arthur needed a break saw the buck right at the end💯🤧
In my tenth game of story mode, these were my reflections on each chapter.
Chapter 1: Undecided, probably bad
Chapter 2: Full-fledged outlaw, enough evil for one's own good but without harming ours.
Chapter 3: Semi neutral, more bad but a little good.
Chapter 4: Indecisive again, you lost many and you don't know your path but you have to survive.
Chapter 5: Turning point, what's the point of being bad if everything goes to hell and if not, what's the point of being bad if I'm going to die?
Chapter 6: You are afraid, you know that you did many bad things and now in your final moments you know that it is not worth your time in life, you do not seek forgiveness you just want to redeem your sins a little.
Epilogue part 1 & 2: You are a family man, you cannot risk yourself or your family, you have to be neutral... Although you have a bad feeling (Events of rdr1).
Yes, a lot of text, but I really spent a lot of time on that game.
First play in low honor and when Arthur gets tuberculosis start playing high honor that will créate the perfect gameplay
I feel like chapter 6 throws every opportunity to raise your honor so when you were an absolute asshat, you can still "redeem" yourself to get a better ending as the title suggests.
I love the high honor ending when you go back for the money, you get to take Micah’s eye out and leave him with a permanent reminder that he fucked with the wrong one
i love high honor gameplay, it’s what i do, but it feels like i’m walking on eggshells
I always felt that the low honor ending makes more sense.
I like the darker low honour story myself, about a bad man who even when dying couldn’t change his ways. But I like both endings a lot.
The high honor death scene is still so heart wrenching. Seeing him drag himself to the rocks so he can see the sunrise as he takes his final breath truly destroyed me. He truly tried to be a better person in his final days and was still betrayed by the one person he trusted the most.
I play game with both. High honor make me cry and feel like so good
i liked the low honour ending, it goes with the theme of the game, and it goes with what milton says in chapter two
Fr
My first play through I was playing scummy up until I chapter 4 and met Dorkins, didn’t know that there would be multiple endings but happy to say I got the good ending. Incredible game.
Nah you know what’s the best? Starting with low honor then finish with high honor, I did that and it was so satisfying
Arthur always says revenge is a fool's game. That just proves he is afraid of revenge and its consequences.
But he indeed is a good and beautiful man even after what happened with him.
I was always low honor but u can't argue that low honor Arthur is cold as fuck
I gave Arthur beautiful honor ending ❤
those people who would have been high honor if they didint kill every npc in sight 💀
This edit was so emotional
You were said earlier that revenge is a luxury we can't afford
~Arthur Morgan
I love low honor but next play through I’m going try going high honor at chapter six
“Easier” Nah bro trust me nothing is easy when 12 bounty hunters following you everywhere
The bounty hunters dont follow you for your honor . They follow you by the price on your head
@@rodrigobatista4904 yes and you won’t have a high bounty if you don’t make crimes and you won’t have high honour if you make crimes
@@Demigod_HunterBut you can have it again by greeting ramdon people for 5 minutes
It’s easier to be mean but it’s harder to be nice
Coyote cutscenes all the way until Arthur’s diagnosis, then buck scenes till the end is the way to go
This is without a doubt the greatest red dead redemption edit I’ve ever seen
Low honor wolf looks badass tho
Damn this song hits, whats the name of it?
Summertime sadness by Lana del rey
@@MILINDFNThanks.
What a creative comparison
I played and finished this game with high honor and then with low honor, in that order, and it is much more enjoyable to play with high honor. Arthur's ending is extremely moving, and i couldn't hold back the tears.
The moment when you realise in the later chapters how bad you was and change your road and becoming good
Song name?😢
Wanna Be Yours x Summertime sadness
what is this remix so beautiful ?
Summer time sadness
He sayd remix not song
Low Honour = Nothing is true, Everithing is permitted
Most cutscenes are the same low honor the music is lower like “Crash of Worlds” and some of the dialogue is different in American venom I like playing low honor as it makes it feel the way Arthur intended himself to be
I know my words won't be able to do it justice, but this edit is beautiful and Summertime Sadness suits it so well!