I love the interviews with Roger Clark (Arthur's voice actor) talking about how the High Honor playthrough cutscenes and specifically the High Honor ending of going to help John should be official cannon in his mind.
Let's not get away from Arthur's complicit responsibility in that act. It's the capstone on his life of ill deeds, sparking his whole, you know, "Redemption".
@@D3wd20p Yeah but let's not pretend Struess wasnt the entire reason Thomas Downes met Arthur. Arthur isn't really to blame for it as it would have never happened if Struess wasn't a pos lending money to people he knows can't afford to repay it.
@@Raytheharbinger0 how can you play the entire game and still miss the point. Arthur took responsibility for his actions and the part he played in everything. Why can't you?
I like high honor better, mostly bc of Arthur’s line: “Me and you, we ain’t decent. But those folk - they was.” It definitely adds to the whole “Redemption” part of the game I feel like
I always kept my honor as high as I could. If you have low honor right now don’t worry. You will have ALOT of side quests and chances to sky rocket that honor.
Nope. I'm playing as the game should be played. Arthor is a bad man, an outlaw, ruthless immoral killer. In a game where you rob banks and trains and kill you want to be the good guy? He's not the hero.
Makes sense, Clark has gone on record saying high honor helping John is his favorite ending, and what he considers canon. He truly took Arthur's redemption and character arc to heart
i cant... i genuinely cannot. of course OP had to strawman in his own delusion & abide the doctrine of what is the general consensus/status quo of setting a higher perceived standard, that gets determined in its absolute form of truth to what it should & shouldn't be as. gotta love the Dogma.
low honor Arthur seems more angry at strauss because he essentially caused Arthur to get TB, but high honor Arthur seems more concerned about the vulnerable people that were exploited rather than himself
@@HAZZY__ he literally did nothing wrong, every single person who took a loan from him, chose to, they knew exactly what they were getting into, and they accepted all the consequences that came with it, strauss was the only good man, because the way he made money didnt require stealing it from someone else against their will
@@bruhbruk4568but he already said it.. he was "taking advantage of the needed" people, reason why he's a snake for me, it's like what the government do to the poor, and arthur is doing the dirty work for strauss
@@rhjn8751 "taking advantage" he was providing oppurtunities to people who didnt have any, how is that taking advantage? is he such an evil guy just because he can make a profit off of it too? if someone goes a lender, borrows money, and has absolutely no plan to pay it back, they deserve everything that comes to them
Got a lot of people in deep financial trouble. Got them beaten. Likely caused some women to end up in prostitution & some men dead. "BuT aTLeAsT hE didNt TaLk tO tHe cOpS"
@@Breakfast.pancake Well Arthur himself spent many years killing innocent people, the game revolves around the concept of redemption, so yeah the fact that Strauss chose death over snitching is remarkable
@@cornm7716 no, that in the theme of the game, Arthur chose to beat a dying man to death for a few bucks, and the whole “red dead redemption” thing is built off of Arthur being a bad man. it’s his fault.
If you notice, the vest on that suit is red for low honor and blue for high honor Just like in the mission where you're at the mayor's party and when you help a man who choke on nut, his suit jack is red if you have low honor but if you have high honer his suit jacket will be blue
I made the choice of Red and Blue myself in my full High, Low honor comparison I made in 2021. He used my content and strikes with the credits of my work
Yes, it is. You can glitch the party suit. If you high honor is blue and red if you low honor, the guy that made the video did it thinking on that@@thesweatbaron8443
I accidentally unlocked some of the low honour cutscene in my game because I tried completing all the bandit challenges despite having high honour otherwise. This was one of them iirc and I found it way funnier than the high honour one. Especially since he was the reason Arthur got tb, it felt so right kicking him out and calling him a parasite
I'll die on the hill that Strauss was the least evil person in that whole camp and was done dirty. He never killed anyone, only gave loans. And the loans though predatory were still only given if the person consented (obviously). And when they defaulted on their loan, it's not like he got the person killed to set an example or whatever, just collected collateral. He was a crappy person sure, but only as crappy as any of your regular predatory loansharks. My man was even loyal till the very bitter end.
When you try to go for Arthur (One of the people who loaned from Strauss) he had already passed away and his wife even mentioned that he worked himself to the grave to pay off his debt. There was even that hunter that died because he was hunting a dangerous cougar to pay off his debt. He might not have killed him directly, but the anxiety and fear that instills in a man, especially through Arthur (our boah) can and will kill a man. P.s hi :) it's 3 am and i should prolly be asleep
I like how even tho arthur got low honor, he still can forgive the debt of (another) Arthur's family, and threw away strauss, shows that even low honor Arthur is still better than others
I always felt bad for Strauss, I’m not saying what he did wasn’t bad but at the end of the day they were basically friends or partners or whatever you wanna call it for quite a while and he looked so confused when Arthur was kicking him out and even after getting arrested he never talked so yea I do feel really bad for him when I saw this
I’ve only ever played high honor, so it’s cool to see that even low honor Author didn’t send Strauss away penniless. That’s far more merciful than Strauss was to those he lended to.
The fact that Strauss actually took that clip of money Arthur threw at him sealed the deal for me. Ik he didn’t snitch but damn if he wasn’t a greedy little maggot of a character. Honestly pretty good depiction of how a lot of real life loan sharks operate.
Fun fact: If you don’t kick Strauss out (by ignoring the optional mission), in the epilogue, Charles mentions that he got captured by Pinkertons and was tortured. However, he didn’t speak a word about the gang’s remaining members. I guess by kicking him out Arthur did Strauss a favour 😅
Thsi is the mission that alwasys pushes me from low honour to high honour. Chaps 1-5 i play low honour. After arthur gets sick, high honour. Its called red dead REDEMPTION (2) for a reason.
Depends you can choose to take the debt from the first guy and not give the widow money to get lower honor. So I think its great they do not force to go High honour.
High honor Arthur seems like he was written much better, i understand why since story-wise it is what he should be trying to become. But it must be a bit disappointing for the people who replayed the game just to see how different it is. No blame on the devs tho, it's a lot to have 2 different lines for each instances
There's allot different dilalogues with low honor it was well worth a new Playtnrough plus all the new things I came across in the game. Low honour Arthur is still really well written as he is more like William munny from unforgiven. He comes to aspect who he is a person and becomes much more selfish.
Streuss wasnt a good man but i respect him. For those who dont know, shortly after this, he gets picked up by the pinkertons. They tortured him to death, and he never spoke a word about the gang. Even after being kicked out, he stayed loyal, a true comrade.
I feel bad for Strauss. He did what everyone in the gang did but in a different way. Stole from people. Except Strauss literally had to learn to do it after being left alone in a different country he had never know . His own sister had to be sold to stave off poverty. Then they kick him out like they were better than him.
Strauss’ poor business practice is what led to Arthur’s illness in the first place. Even without the other people being hurt, Arthur has every right to want Strauss gone.
Strauss was not great obviously. Hell even a terrible person but he was definitely loyal. Even after being thrown out like that, he never once snitched after being captured by the Pinkertons. And even died during the interrogation
Notice the high honor version tells Stauss to change his ways and get a job. And the low honor version just doesn't want to see his face anymore, likely because that Arthur is bitter wants someone to blame for getting sick.
When I played that part of the game, I was high honored and well I prefer the high honored one he said you and me we ain’t decent but those folks they was
I absolute hate Strauss. I know a lot of people say that Arthur got TB for his own choices and whilst I agree Arthur would have probably died young anyway from his wreckless lifestyle, I still think Strauss is somebody you can never forgive or forget because he hurt so many people, he he made drove families further into poverty under false pretenses that he would help them and probably caused more deaths than anybody in the gang. Fans have a valid reason to hate Strauss.
Kinda says a lot about Strauss that he views high honor Arthur as a friend, and low honor Arthur as just business partners. You can tell almost everyone in the gang, even Micah, respect high honor Arthur more than low honor
The thing you have to wonder is, would all these people have been better off not taking the gangs money? Especially the Downes’s who were already in massive debt and Thomas was already sick. Surely these people knew taking money from a loan shark wasn’t gonna end well and if they owed a bank money they would loose everything anyway like Downes lost their farm. The people that take Straus’s offer are desperate and know better but do it anyway. I just don’t blame him as much as the story does. If anything I blame Thomas Downes for taking money he knew he couldn’t pay back and got Arthur sick.
Yeah, that's one of my problems, even with the endings, the outcome is the exact same no matter what you do, Rockstar really lovs forcing their stories and it's boring the hell out of me.
@greekzeus9818 there very differnt low and High honour Arthur have very differnt chracter archs. In this scenes have very different dilalogues and Arthurss motivation for kicking strauss out is different. They are not forcing Arthurs Story at all he becomes Far more selfish and bitter. The story needs to tie into RDR1 however so there are limits otherwise they would have taken it much further.
Strauss feels like someone who's least justified to be in the Van Der Linde gang. He simply didn't need them. Sure, when he immigrated info this country he wasn't accepted but he cpuld turn it around for sure, a smart, financially educated man who knows his clocks, a competent "fence" of stolen goods...Strauss could have gotten a job. But he stayed until Arthur three him out because he felt like his place was among these people. He felt like he belonged there. That's probably why he stayed loyal to the very end. Personally I don't have the heart to hate Strauss. And neither does High Honor Arthur, who's more disgusted with the entire ordeal than anything else.
The low honor kinda breaks the most important part of the story wich is Arthur's Redemption side. Low honor just seems he doesn't care enough and see them as waste of time
![[RP] I NEMICI DI SIRVIO 🤣 | LIVE con MatteoHS](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/-yLcXwN81bM/mqdefault.jpg)
![[RP] I NEMICI DI SIRVIO 🤣 | LIVE con MatteoHS](/img/tr.png)
i prefer High Honor
he said "you and me, we ain't decent but those folks, they was"
I love the interviews with Roger Clark (Arthur's voice actor) talking about how the High Honor playthrough cutscenes and specifically the High Honor ending of going to help John should be official cannon in his mind.
@@DragonSt3althred dead “redemption”
It's called redemption because of the first one soooo. Not really a point there@@prapp1974
Yeah, but i am too lazy to get high honor
Thats the point halfwit its high honor
Streuss did basically give him tuberculosis after sending him to thomas downes
Let's not get away from Arthur's complicit responsibility in that act. It's the capstone on his life of ill deeds, sparking his whole, you know, "Redemption".
@@D3wd20p Yeah but let's not pretend Struess wasnt the entire reason Thomas Downes met Arthur. Arthur isn't really to blame for it as it would have never happened if Struess wasn't a pos lending money to people he knows can't afford to repay it.
@@Raytheharbinger0 how can you play the entire game and still miss the point. Arthur took responsibility for his actions and the part he played in everything. Why can't you?
@@Raytheharbinger0 thats a jew for you
@@Chiefmummy bros antisemitic in the year 2024 LMAO. Bro thinks its 1200s
I like high honor better, mostly bc of Arthur’s line: “Me and you, we ain’t decent. But those folk - they was.” It definitely adds to the whole “Redemption” part of the game I feel like
yeah that is obvious
Plus, makes no sense that low honor Arthur gave money to Strauss.
i do not agree
@@ggfacilitytyyyy did anyone ask?
@@abc18792 it was still the gang, his family
I always kept my honor as high as I could. If you have low honor right now don’t worry. You will have ALOT of side quests and chances to sky rocket that honor.
Nope. I'm playing as the game should be played. Arthor is a bad man, an outlaw, ruthless immoral killer. In a game where you rob banks and trains and kill you want to be the good guy? He's not the hero.
Just do what you think is good or bad and you'll find out what devs think it is. There's no good and bad in the world.
Just go to Saint Denise and greet anyone in sight lol
First play through low honor is better
@@maksymalnybul6145 "There's no good and bad in the world" That's the dumbest thing I've heard today lol.
I threw him out in his Pajamas. Bro thought he was cozy.
me too
“Bro thought he was cozy” 😂
Hearing the low honor lines makes it kinda clear that the high honor lines coincide with the mocap and body performance of Roger Clark
Makes sense, Clark has gone on record saying high honor helping John is his favorite ending, and what he considers canon. He truly took Arthur's redemption and character arc to heart
i cant... i genuinely cannot.
of course OP had to strawman in his own delusion & abide the doctrine of what is the general consensus/status quo of setting a higher perceived standard, that gets determined in its absolute form of truth to what it should & shouldn't be as.
gotta love the Dogma.
low honor Arthur seems more angry at strauss because he essentially caused Arthur to get TB, but high honor Arthur seems more concerned about the vulnerable people that were exploited rather than himself
so there's separate linings here especially with being just or are they just an inverse of each other & still share the essence of each other?
He was at least loyal, I'll give him that.
bro never snitched i ain't know he was built like that
@@Cuunke that’s what I was gonna say. He never snitched to the Pinkertons
I kinda felt bad for Strauss. When he was in prison and died there, he didn’t snitch. He wasn’t a good man but who was in the gang except for Charles
I don’t feel a shred of sympathy for Strauss. Apart from c5/6 Dutch, he was the only one who preyed on vulnerable people
@@HAZZY__but tbh no one in the the gang was good just different shades of gray he wasn’t the worst wasn’t the best
@@HAZZY__ he literally did nothing wrong, every single person who took a loan from him, chose to, they knew exactly what they were getting into, and they accepted all the consequences that came with it, strauss was the only good man, because the way he made money didnt require stealing it from someone else against their will
@@bruhbruk4568but he already said it.. he was "taking advantage of the needed" people, reason why he's a snake for me, it's like what the government do to the poor, and arthur is doing the dirty work for strauss
@@rhjn8751 "taking advantage" he was providing oppurtunities to people who didnt have any, how is that taking advantage? is he such an evil guy just because he can make a profit off of it too? if someone goes a lender, borrows money, and has absolutely no plan to pay it back, they deserve everything that comes to them
"died in custody after years, never.. said.. a.. WORD"
Got a lot of people in deep financial trouble. Got them beaten. Likely caused some women to end up in prostitution & some men dead. "BuT aTLeAsT hE didNt TaLk tO tHe cOpS"
@@Breakfast.pancake He would have been spared his life if he talked, and he never did i aint saying he has high honor but DAMN he has balls
@@Breakfast.pancake Well Arthur himself spent many years killing innocent people, the game revolves around the concept of redemption, so yeah the fact that Strauss chose death over snitching is remarkable
@Breakfast.pancake that don't sound nearly as bad as what most of the gang has already done lol
@@Breakfast.pancakehow do you get ratiod twice in one sitting😭
1nd Play through.....100 hours until the end
2nd Play through......100 hours in Chapter2
IKR
1nd??
@@diamondsimon020 1nd and 2st
@@schulme123 Lol
Honestly, that guy is a reason that Arthur had tuberculosis think about it if he never sent them to that dude’s house he never would’ve gotten sick
it’s arthurs fault, he chose to do it, that’s literally the point of the game
@@greeneyeballsIf Strauss wasn't a debt dealing maggot ,he never would have had to do the debt in the first place.
@@Idk.lol7689 bait or lack of media literacy?
@@greeneyeballs so you're telling me that Arthur would've got TB if Strauss never existed?
I personally don't think he would've.
@@cornm7716 no, that in the theme of the game, Arthur chose to beat a dying man to death for a few bucks, and the whole “red dead redemption” thing is built off of Arthur being a bad man. it’s his fault.
You find out that he was captured and tortured by the Pinkertons until he died.
He didn't spill.
If you notice, the vest on that suit is red for low honor and blue for high honor
Just like in the mission where you're at the mayor's party and when you help a man who choke on nut, his suit jack is red if you have low honor but if you have high honer his suit jacket will be blue
nah not at all...the strauss mission is way after the mayor's party
I made the choice of Red and Blue myself in my full High, Low honor comparison I made in 2021. He used my content and strikes with the credits of my work
Yes, it is. You can glitch the party suit. If you high honor is blue and red if you low honor, the guy that made the video did it thinking on that@@thesweatbaron8443
Its nice that he give the money even with low honor
That was debt money
I accidentally unlocked some of the low honour cutscene in my game because I tried completing all the bandit challenges despite having high honour otherwise. This was one of them iirc and I found it way funnier than the high honour one. Especially since he was the reason Arthur got tb, it felt so right kicking him out and calling him a parasite
I'll die on the hill that Strauss was the least evil person in that whole camp and was done dirty. He never killed anyone, only gave loans. And the loans though predatory were still only given if the person consented (obviously). And when they defaulted on their loan, it's not like he got the person killed to set an example or whatever, just collected collateral. He was a crappy person sure, but only as crappy as any of your regular predatory loansharks. My man was even loyal till the very bitter end.
That's exactly what I've always said, you all murder people yet the guy giving out loans is vilified?😂
When you try to go for Arthur (One of the people who loaned from Strauss) he had already passed away and his wife even mentioned that he worked himself to the grave to pay off his debt. There was even that hunter that died because he was hunting a dangerous cougar to pay off his debt. He might not have killed him directly, but the anxiety and fear that instills in a man, especially through Arthur (our boah) can and will kill a man.
P.s hi :) it's 3 am and i should prolly be asleep
It's been a while since I played, but as far as I remember, I'm pretty sure Charles, Lenny, and Sean seem pretty good hearted as well
@@dark-bi7fcnope...
also, there's no such thing as the concept of 'Good' & vice versa.
Low honor Arthur said "time waster" several times, because his time on earth was significantly shorter because of Strauss.
High honor Arthur was disgusted. Low honor Arthur was furious
Even as an evil playthrough Arthur is still nicer than your typical bad ending route
Arthur taking care of the money lenders.
He is truly a man of jesus christ
Extra clean shaven Arthur is a sin, you'll burn in the lakes of fire forever for this one, OP
Clean shaven and beard 1 and 2 are the best for Arthur. Even Rockstar had him clean shaven in the trailers.
I feel like the clean and extra clean are the canon ones
Just till chapter 5 and 6
I go for a level 2 beard
How do you get him clean shaven like that?
@@floraxfn go to a barber shop. Specifically the one in saint denis..
@@mcshayne6668 any barber after the riverboat mission
I like how even tho arthur got low honor, he still can forgive the debt of (another) Arthur's family, and threw away strauss, shows that even low honor Arthur is still better than others
'better than others' that doesn't mean anything... especially in regards to who in juxtaposition.
Clean shaven Arthur isn't real and can't hurt you
Clean shaven Arthur:
Me who always keeps Arthur cleans shaven:🧍🏿♂️
(I hate facial hair)
@@roxas303how do you get it? I’m in chapter 2 so do I maybe get it later? Bc now I can shave his beard off but it isn’t clean like that
@@floraxfn you have to wait until after a certain mission in chapter 4
@ ah okay thank you
If you have high honor stay away from Butcher Creek 😂
yeah i fist fought those mongoloids after they cussed at me and those maggots pulled out guns.
I kicked out Strauss when he was in his pajamas xd
High Honour: “I was your friend”
Low Honour: “We were business partners!”
"...I'm-"
"Leaving." 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Everyone says Micah is the worst character, but if it weren't for Strauss, Arthur wouldn't have tuberculosis.
Strauss wasn't a rat 🐀
@SAHILKHAN-mp6kc I didn't say he was
@HenryVallaster another pathetic glamorizer.
Arthur was more than just a video game character
Arthur said "Let's make it 110"
I always felt bad for Strauss, I’m not saying what he did wasn’t bad but at the end of the day they were basically friends or partners or whatever you wanna call it for quite a while and he looked so confused when Arthur was kicking him out and even after getting arrested he never talked so yea I do feel really bad for him when I saw this
I’ve only ever played high honor, so it’s cool to see that even low honor Author didn’t send Strauss away penniless. That’s far more merciful than Strauss was to those he lended to.
That’s literally the light you see on people when you look into their eyes in real life. The attention to detail is real
I like the high honor cutscenes but low honor is so much fun
He actually just saved Straus's life. Just left the gang
Until the Pinkertons got a hold of Strauss, where they tortured him to death, but Strauss never said a word to them.
High honor: Good, friendly Arthur but Broken
Low: Angry, Broken..
I like how with high honor Arthur kicks Strauss out of the camp for Strausses own safety.
Him not having a beard is criminal
Clean shaven Arthur is PEAK
No matter what he looks handsome
He still looks good
The fact that Strauss actually took that clip of money Arthur threw at him sealed the deal for me. Ik he didn’t snitch but damn if he wasn’t a greedy little maggot of a character. Honestly pretty good depiction of how a lot of real life loan sharks operate.
Fun fact: If you don’t kick Strauss out (by ignoring the optional mission), in the epilogue, Charles mentions that he got captured by Pinkertons and was tortured. However, he didn’t speak a word about the gang’s remaining members. I guess by kicking him out Arthur did Strauss a favour 😅
Thsi is the mission that alwasys pushes me from low honour to high honour. Chaps 1-5 i play low honour. After arthur gets sick, high honour. Its called red dead REDEMPTION (2) for a reason.
Depends you can choose to take the debt from the first guy and not give the widow money to get lower honor. So I think its great they do not force to go High honour.
High honor Arthur seems like he was written much better, i understand why since story-wise it is what he should be trying to become. But it must be a bit disappointing for the people who replayed the game just to see how different it is. No blame on the devs tho, it's a lot to have 2 different lines for each instances
There's allot different dilalogues with low honor it was well worth a new Playtnrough plus all the new things I came across in the game. Low honour Arthur is still really well written as he is more like William munny from unforgiven. He comes to aspect who he is a person and becomes much more selfish.
Streuss wasnt a good man but i respect him. For those who dont know, shortly after this, he gets picked up by the pinkertons. They tortured him to death, and he never spoke a word about the gang. Even after being kicked out, he stayed loyal, a true comrade.
I watched interaction between Strauss & Micah in Shady Belle. Where Micah didn't like "loan shark" that Strauss been doing
Hahaha… that low honor “don’t annoy” me was scary 😅💀
I feel bad for Strauss. He did what everyone in the gang did but in a different way. Stole from people. Except Strauss literally had to learn to do it after being left alone in a different country he had never know . His own sister had to be sold to stave off poverty. Then they kick him out like they were better than him.
Never did his quests, felt dirty. It was nice to know his end
Static shading vs dynamic shading
low honor Arthur is just pain, I don't have the courage to play a run like this.
They literally went from being outlawed Robin Hood's to loan sharks when they added Strauss to the gang.
After the clip finished*
“He’s over here! Get on the ground now! Suspect of grand theft is being detained”
only if Arthur did this in Chapter 2 he would still be happy ,healthy and alive
Strauss’ poor business practice is what led to Arthur’s illness in the first place. Even without the other people being hurt, Arthur has every right to want Strauss gone.
People can say they didn’t like strauss for his business doing. But one thing you can’t call him a rat 🐀
Strauss was not great obviously. Hell even a terrible person but he was definitely loyal. Even after being thrown out like that, he never once snitched after being captured by the Pinkertons. And even died during the interrogation
This is a game they could re-release with different missions and different outcomes and I would still pay top dollar
I believe that Arthur still tried to spare Strauss from the life of outlaws, just like he tried to save other members of the camp
Strauss still dies even if you don’t kick him out of the gang, he was captured by the Pinkertons and beaten to death
Good thing I chose the High Honor. It was more emotional that way.
High honor makes it about the people low honor insults Strauss and makes it about himself
Yo that suit that arthur wears is so cool
i tried to play again with low honor this time but damn its so hard to be evil with that character im always turning into good honor
IMAGINE DAN SAID THAT TO STRAUSS IRL! goosebumps everytime!
I like how low honor Arthur is mostly upset that he spent some of the little time he had left running errands for this fool.
He's the reason he got TB while going on that one mission to collect debt.....damn
low honor makes arthur face dark and sicker look
I just did this yesterday and now it pops up in my feed lol.
Notice the high honor version tells Stauss to change his ways and get a job. And the low honor version just doesn't want to see his face anymore, likely because that Arthur is bitter wants someone to blame for getting sick.
In the end Arthur probably saved his life by kicking him out
That "Wut?? o_O" From him gets me everytime 😂
He's the reason Morgan got sick
When you watch these videos, and realize you had high honor the whole time lol, but never knew it
Damned if you do, damned if you don't.
Strauss was the only person that didnt do anything illegal
Arthur Morgan is one scary dude
This scene truly makes sense only with high horor Arthur
When I played that part of the game, I was high honored and well I prefer the high honored one he said you and me we ain’t decent but those folks they was
This is Athur’s least favorite parasite
Arthur had no right to kick him out without talking to dutch but he actually saved strauss's cheeks
I absolute hate Strauss. I know a lot of people say that Arthur got TB for his own choices and whilst I agree Arthur would have probably died young anyway from his wreckless lifestyle, I still think Strauss is somebody you can never forgive or forget because he hurt so many people, he he made drove families further into poverty under false pretenses that he would help them and probably caused more deaths than anybody in the gang. Fans have a valid reason to hate Strauss.
Kinda says a lot about Strauss that he views high honor Arthur as a friend, and low honor Arthur as just business partners. You can tell almost everyone in the gang, even Micah, respect high honor Arthur more than low honor
“Get up.”
“Wot?”
The thing you have to wonder is, would all these people have been better off not taking the gangs money? Especially the Downes’s who were already in massive debt and Thomas was already sick. Surely these people knew taking money from a loan shark wasn’t gonna end well and if they owed a bank money they would loose everything anyway like Downes lost their farm. The people that take Straus’s offer are desperate and know better but do it anyway. I just don’t blame him as much as the story does. If anything I blame Thomas Downes for taking money he knew he couldn’t pay back and got Arthur sick.
Also remember, Strauss essentially Killed Arthur. He's the reason Arthur got TB
Literally the same exact thing
Yeah, that's one of my problems, even with the endings, the outcome is the exact same no matter what you do, Rockstar really lovs forcing their stories and it's boring the hell out of me.
@greekzeus9818 there very differnt low and High honour Arthur have very differnt chracter archs. In this scenes have very different dilalogues and Arthurss motivation for kicking strauss out is different. They are not forcing Arthurs Story at all he becomes Far more selfish and bitter. The story needs to tie into RDR1 however so there are limits otherwise they would have taken it much further.
Arthur is savings struasses life, I didn’t know you could kick that nasty maggot out, and I saw him get turned into emisis blue medic
This man is what gave us the sickness!!
No he wasn't lol
The fact that I never knew there was a low honor scene
Strauss feels like someone who's least justified to be in the Van Der Linde gang. He simply didn't need them. Sure, when he immigrated info this country he wasn't accepted but he cpuld turn it around for sure, a smart, financially educated man who knows his clocks, a competent "fence" of stolen goods...Strauss could have gotten a job. But he stayed until Arthur three him out because he felt like his place was among these people. He felt like he belonged there. That's probably why he stayed loyal to the very end.
Personally I don't have the heart to hate Strauss. And neither does High Honor Arthur, who's more disgusted with the entire ordeal than anything else.
I like low honor more but i really like the last part of high honor
Probably the only interaction with MORE dialouge for low honor
How did I miss this after complete whole RDR2 story?
I would have thought the low honor Arthur wouldn’t have given him any money
I did not see this when I played... But to be fair I did not played Strauss missions except when necessary.
The low honor kinda breaks the most important part of the story wich is Arthur's Redemption side. Low honor just seems he doesn't care enough and see them as waste of time
Is it just me or Arthur looks more scarier
"Sending me after losers like that"😂
i always play low honor in chap 1-6 but high honor in the ending
I would like to see more of a difference. This feels very similar.
There actually really differnt both dilagues and Arthurs chracter motivation.
@@Ronuk1996 Not from what I see here.