Bill Maher BERATES Palestinians As Their Kids Get Bombed | The Kyle Kulinski Show
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 ก.ย. 2024
- Support The Show On Patreon!:
/ seculartalk
Subscribe to Krystal Kyle & Friends On Substack!:
krystalkyleand...
Follow Kyle on Twitter:
/ kylekulinski
"The first time I ever really listened to Kyle Kulinski’s show was in the back of a cab last summer. The driver had his phone hooked up through the stereo and was pumping out an episode through the car speakers - loudly, as if looking to convert a captive audience.
“Do you like Kyle Kulinski?”
The driver, Ahmed, was a recent immigrant and apparently a die-hard fan of Secular Talk, the political talk show that Kulinski broadcasts on TH-cam. I told him, yes, in fact. I do like Kulinski, had come across his show several years ago, and, all things considered, he seemed pretty good.
“He understands what we’re up against,” Ahmed said. “Like Bernie.”
But I was surprised to hear Kulinski’s name mentioned in the same breath as Bernie Sanders, particularly with such adoration. Because what I did remember about Kulinski’s show struck me as mostly capital-P “progressive” takes on the news - the left wing of the Netroots crowd more than the democratic socialism Sanders has popularized.
It’s an impression that wasn’t entirely incorrect.
“I have no time for philosophical, airy bullshit,” Kulinski tells me from his home in Westchester, New York. “I don’t want to hear about Lenin. I don’t want to hear about Marx. I just want a super plainspoken, straightforward agenda with a straightforward way of selling it.”
With over 800,000 subscribers and nearly 670 million total views on TH-cam, selling a progressive agenda is clearly something Kulinski knows how to do - even Democracy Now, the long-standing flagship of progressive media, cannot match his reach on the platform. Chapo Trap House can certainly boast a wildly devoted fan base (and a not insignificant degree of media influence), but their audience is roughly half the size of Kulinski’s.
While Secular Talk might be more likely to be looped in with the progressive networks around Air America and Pacifica alums like Sam Seder than the more resolutely socialist world, Kulinski’s fiery rhetoric, razor-sharp class instincts, and knack for withering takedowns sets him apart from his peers. Judging by his rhetoric alone, he’s closer to a Eugene Debs than a Chris Hayes.
But unlike Hayes, Amy Goodman, or his friend Cenk Uygur of The Young Turks - who began airing Secular Talk on his web network seven years ago - the thirty-two-year-old Kulinski is virtually invisible in the mainstream media. Despite his enormous fan base, his show has never once been mentioned in the obligatory trend pieces on “the Millennial Left” pumped out by the prestige media. Nor has Kulinski’s name ever popped up at all in the New York Times, Vox, the New Yorker, New York Magazine, or the Washington Post, despite his leading role in cofounding Justice Democrats, the organization widely credited with sweeping Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and the rest of “the Squad” to power.
Just last week, his Wikipedia page was deleted. The reason? “There is very simply no [reliable source] coverage of this person,” according to one moderator. In new media, he’s king - the Sean Hannity of the Berniecrat left. In old media, he’s nobody.
I suspect there are a few reasons for that. There is nothing “cool” about Kulinski’s show. (As a friend put it, “‘Welcome to Secular Talk’ sounds like something you’d hear on Egyptian radio.”) His no-nonsense social-democratic politics won’t get him much cred with the Full Communism crowd. He records his show not in Brooklyn or Los Angeles, but in a studio he built himself in his modest Westchester home. His hair is too groomed and his taste in clothes too preppy to qualify as “Dirtbag Left.” Nor has he ever attended an n+1 release party. “Not only have I not attended one,” he says, “I have no idea what that means.”
And yet he’s astonishingly plugged-in for a young man in the suburbs. Wondering how Sanders ended up on the Joe Rogan Experience? Kulinski, a frequent guest on Rogan’s wildly popular show, introduced them. “You make the most sense to me,” Rogan told Kulinski on a recent episode. “You’re a normal person.”
Much like Sanders himself, Kulinski’s show has a massive audience that just doesn’t compute with our media’s understanding of “what the kids want” or even “what the left-wing kids want.”
It’s probably for the best - the very woke and very WASP-ish decorum haunting much of the media world is nowhere to be found in Secular Talk. “Corporate Democrats over-focus on identity as a trick to divert you from the issues that unite us all - class issues,” he said on a recent episode.
Read More Here!:
jacobinmag.com...
#KyleKulinski #SecularTalk #news #politics #youtube #biden #economics #left #progressive #viral
Imagine if Bill Maher said this about Ukraine, ranting from the comfort of his LA studio, as Ukrainians are being bombed and shelled by Russia, telling the Ukrainians to surrender, and deal with being conquered, it would have been a shitshow. They should rename his show from 'Real Time" to "Real Shitty" because that's a true representation of what Maher will give you.
israel and russia isnt on the same side...
ridiculous
@@aaronmcconkey1062what does that have to do with anything?
The amount of attention Ukrainians get compared to Arabs is proof against the White genocide conspiracy theory.
Noam Chomsky was there to say that to Ukraine in many diff worse ways. Bill maher did however make fun of zelensky’s decision to stay with his people.
Maher's argument is that any crime is fine, as long as you get away with it long enough.
No it’s reality
So, can we abolish the illegal settler colonialist state of Turkey then? Can we restore the Byzantine Empire?
#SUBHANALLAH
#CEASEFIRENOW
#STOPTHEGENOCIDE
#STOPKILLINGCIVILIANS
#STOPBOMBINGREFUGEECAMPS
#STOPTARGETAMBULANCE
#STOPTARGETJOURNALIST
#STOPTARGETHOSPITAL
#STOPTARGETSCHOOL
#JUSTICEFORPALESTINE
#STAYSTRONGPALESTINE
#STANDWITHHUMANITY
#ICCWARCRIMES
#ISRAELWARCRIMES
#USWARCRIMES
#EUWARCRIMES
#UNWARCRIMES
#PBBWARCRIMES
#IDFTHELOSSER
#IDFTHERELLTERRORIST
#ZIONISTSHAMEONYOU
#BOYGOTTPIERSMORGAN
You can not claim a land because your supposedly great great ancestors over 3k years ago lived there, the same ancestors that may share less than 10% of your DNA. European Jews coming from Germany, Russia and Australia are less Semitic than the native Palestinians who have lived there for thousands of years. If you claim the land based on your religious beliefs, then how come many Zionists are not even Jewish and some like Maher, don’t even believe in God??
Should Japan continue terrorism against the USA for the atomic bombs? In fact most Arabs left in 1948 to escape a war as does everyone. There are 1.8 million arabs kliving in Israel .What crime?
10k kids dead. And that’s his argument? Bill is a monster
Those numbers are false. You did not count them. It’s reported by Palestinian terror organization.
yeah he has no heart
If you believe Hamas figures but they are dying BECAUSE the muslims cannot forget the past.
The blame is on fucin hamas.
They wanted the war
You just need to be a human with a heart to support Palestine.
But not Hamas
And no brain!
A human!
A heart!
No brain!
then tell Hamas to surrender, and the Pals might have a chance at decent lives.
@@WorshipinIdolsthe fuck kinda statement is that? Like, do you get off on being a heartless pos?
@@dutube99 Exactly!
Thank you Kyle for the truth!
Hilarious.
I luv it man. Its like, why doesnt he say "oh, why are jews crying about what germans did? It happens. It happened. It had been done before"
Imagine telling a 25 y.o. Palestinian prisoner, "There were deals on the table in the 40s."
Imagine a 25 yr old fighting against Isreal in 2023 because he didn’t like the deals in the 40’s
@@GB-es4qzmy friend one of these people is being occupied right now since 1967
First of all there were deals on the table in the 2000's so that's your argument gone.
@@nickcorne6407 tell that to the children
@@thecomfortinthesound bro first of all, I am pointing out a real mistake. Secondly, IDK how to speak arabic and I doubt that they know english. Thirdly, That is always the case. In nazi germany a lot of children died to the allies, is that the allies fault, no!
I'm glad Bill hired that one guy to laugh obnoxiously loud at his jokes, it just highlights how few people are ACTUALLY laughing... Hey Bill, jokes make people laugh, not clap, clapping is what people do when you tell a joke and they don't find it funny...
Every joke Bill Maher reads is like Jeb Bush's "Please clap" moment. I mean, Maher's audience doesn't even wait for a punchline to laugh and clap. Maher is the joke.
Bill has the same 'tells' as Obama. When they lie or tell porkies they both lick their lips. The both wring their hands. They both laugh loudly at their own jokes. And they both surround themselves with those who find them clever. Obama tried to appeal to the 'socially liberal' among the population who then deserted the Dems with disgust, and Bill surrounds himself with bus loads of tourist rubes who are pleased to see a real TeeVee show live. Hence the forced laughter & redneck hoots.
Imagine someone saying that exact Bill Maher monologue but about the Holocaust. Hey things change, your enemies are too strong, get over it! Something tells me that wouldn't go over too well.
Imagine the gall someone must have to make this argument while an entire group of people are being ethnically cleansed.
@@someothername7886 its called hutzpah. They are proud of their gall.
Yeah but the thing is they view the natives as an inconvenience if it was him or jew than it's a different story. It's your typical hypocrisy...
Maher is a hypocrite. For a person who doesn’t believe in God or any holy book, he sure believes that everything in the Jewish holy book is the exact truth! How could he denounce all religions, but support a country that is established on religious nationalism?
@@BertGraefWhen you're full of shit it's called Fakakta
You ever notice that Bill Maher has a arrogant elitist view of every political topic and situation?
Anyone ever forced to endure his garbage content is well aware
His only consistent attribute is smug cynicism
Bill Maher was never George Carlin.
He went to Epstein Island 😂
It's consistent with him being an 🐴🕳️.
Nothing like saying “yeah ethnic cleansing is bad but what can you do”
Ever notice it’s always people in comfort who act like human tragedies are no big deal?
@BillMaher So..., antisemitism is bad but what can you do. Is it ok?
Exactly I can’t stand the smug look on these demons faces
Definitely people can see the evil emanating from his or Whatever it is face.
Is? Lol, he's talking about in the past, he's too cowardly to say it's about now.
@@salam-sl9obWell, the holocaust was bad, but like, der Judden should have stayed in the concentration camps, according to Marsbars
Bill Maher turned into the old angry "GET OFF MY LAWN" guy about a decade ago
I disagree. He was always a fascist. As he got older..and uglier...he couldn't hide it.
he was only popular during the whole atheist/rationalist thing, and he couldn't even get at that low hanging fruit effectively.
@@jonasdowner very true tbh
Not at all, you should actually watch a few shows , Bill Maher is cool in my book 😎
@@mrtambourineman6107 ya, no
Bill maher : i dont believe in god
Also bill maher : bible says Palestine was promised land to israelis 😅
I didn't hear him say that. He said it's the ancestral land, which is historically correct, unrelated to the Bible.
didnt say Plaestine and if he did is to make sure pepole undersatnd. any way it's wrriten
You know, it is so funny to me how the whole basis of Israel's location is supposedly Biblical and that is taken as a given when justifying barbarism against the Palestinians by those who don't even believe in God
@@pinkpickledcauliflower9 So your reply is out of context. that there is no need to argue.
@@pinkpickledcauliflower9
For religious people it's biblical for others it's historical. Not only the Bible say that this was the land of the Jewish people, all history books say that as well
I've said it before and I'll say it again, Bill Maher's ONLY consistent opinion has been *"What hurts Muslims the most?? Oh this does? I'll support it!"*
It’s insane how some people still deny the anti-Muslim bigotry that is present in the “New Atheist” sphere. I would respect them more if they were actually honest about it instead of trying to hide it.
New atheism continues to be validated every single day. It’s a shame you demonize the very people keeping you safe from Islamism
@PseudoSpaceMarine I'm certain there is some anti-Muslim bigotry, but I wonder how much of that is overblown simply based on the context of the conversation.
All religions are BS to varying degrees, but if you happen to be talking to an atheist about Islam specifically, that is what they are going to bring up.
He went to Epsten Island 😂😂
@@mikeylovesit well they aren’t equal. What is the ratio of Muslims moving to Christian countries versus the other way around? In one country, you might be executed for drawing a naughty cartoon, whereas in another country, you have obnoxious religious politicians who can and do get voted out of office in democratic elections. These are not equal evils just because of a woke “oppression” complex and trying to convince everyone that criticizing a religion is equivalent to racism.
I can’t decide which is worse, Bill’s terrible takes or the audience applauding them.
His audience are monkeys that applaud to anything like a trained monkeys
The takes are definitely terrible, but there's something...uncanny about the laughter and applause. It comes slightly late and sounds oddly forced. Disturbing, all of it.
@@LunaBoo12Precisely. I thought the same: oddly forced. All "live" audience television shows commonly prep and prime their audiences and have electronic applause signs etc. But this, this is a little beyond.
And besides being a bit "forced," it actually sounded like it was a minority of the audience that applauded at all. The audience here is trying to give Bill the benefit of the doubt, but they are mostly not onboard.
theyre vetted
Maher at his most morally and intellectually bankrupt
Bill Maher is a Z!onist who advocated that Israel is worth an American life and American dollar in his interview with Michael Scheuer in 2008. Meaning, he wants Americans to sacrifice their health and wealth for the z!onist Israelis.
He is a hypocrite. He claims to be an atheist, makes fun of the Bible, calling it a fairy tale, but when it comes to the Jewish holy book, everything in there is exactly true! Why don’t you analyze the DNA of those European Jews with blonde hairs and see how much of their DNA is European? I bet you Palestinians have more common genes with the original Jews who built the temple.
Because you want to destroy as many generations as necessary? That's NOT morally bankrupt?
Does he even have any morality and intellectual capabilities to begin with? He is a racist Islamaphobe disguised as a liberal all along.
It's not just him though. Just read the talmud to find out how they all think.
Maher doesn’t have an audience it’s a laugh track.
Really?
Are you high? He has a studio audience. You can see it on the show.
Bill is just too smug about the genocide. Luckily he doesn't decide the fate of humanity.
Maher is the kind of wretched individual who would have told Nat Turner to stop complaining about slavery and deal with it.
NO SHIT!
He would've told Frederick Douglass to "be patient."
Then tell Nat Turner after his capture for the rebellion. "Why so divisive ".
You dont get the point at all.. hilarious
@@sandcastledx the cruelty is the point. Goosestep somewhere else
me rolling into bill's mansion with the homies: things change bro
LOL - well if your ancestors thousands of years ago lived there ---- then you are completely in the right for taking it over from him and forcing him to live in the backyard. I mean that's how things work (according to the zionists occupying Palestine) right?
Here’s a fiddle, Bill. You get to keep the balcony.
try doing that where there's armed resistance
The audience sounds so forced when they laugh.
Maybe not your type of comedy. Ever think you're the problem?
@ELTEAESS Sounds like it’s you who is the problem
The real hostages are his audience.
@ELTEAESS When his "jokes" are met largely by applause and not laughter, he's not being funny, he's preaching.
@@ELTEAESS Yeah, I guess I'm not into boomer comedy.
You forgot that in 1995, Israeli PM Yitzhak Rabin-the leader who came the closest to making peace with the Palestinians-reiterated that Israel cannot return to the 1967 boundary. Within the 1967 borders Israel would lose almost all its tactical, strategic, geographic, and topographic military advantages.
The only missing thing that would be the cherry on top of this Bill Maher’s New Rule is that at the end of the video he said “I’m Bill Maher, host of Real Time with Bill Maher, for Prager University”.
Now I expect it, except Maher calls himself Liberal. "I'm Bill Maher, and I agree with Conservativism when it has to do with Israel and Palestine. This is for 'Prager University.'"
lmaooo
Maher's entire show now consists of whining about college kids...
Where have you been? Lol
He became the "grumpy old man".
That's cos they are clueless
College kids are pretty annoying.... get a job ya bums
@@pr-tj5by no they're clued in ,that's why you and zionist bill hate them
3 million Palestinian Christians. I wish his audience would be more educated on this and call him out. Walk out of his studio. Biggest slap to the face when your viewers don't want anything to do with you. But of course... stupid is what stupid does.
Not three million. 47,000, less than 2% of the population. Down from 25% of the population 100 years ago. Facts matter...
OMG the fact that he is literally bragging about horrible things happening and that we should just accept this genocide is so beyond me
what genocide?
@@worriedman75The genocide of the Palestinian people.
You people are so far removed from nature it is insane lol
As an atheist how can Bill reconcile Jews’ claims on Palestine based on god’s promises in the Bible. One would think this is great material for a comedian
He is a fake Athiest. Only when it suits his bit.
He not a comedian either.@kkay1341
BS @@kkay1341
Palestine and hamas go together. They are IS now.
He is a little fascist in the making.
Bill Maher dismissing the Irish partition as unopposed is ridiculous.
Ridiculous is, ridiculous does.
Their graphics team also put the Golan Heights under Palestinian control. It is not. It is occupied by the IDF and used for artillery and air strike spotting into Syria. Some Israelis go on tourism trips to watch IDF air strikes, unless I'm mistaking that for a different hill over looking Gaza.
He said they came to an agreement and stopped fighting not that said agreement is perfect.
Bill Maher is a Z!onist who advocated that Israel is worth an American life and American dollar in his interview with Michael Scheuer in 2008. Meaning, he wants Americans to sacrifice their health and wealth for the z!onist Israelis.
@@loganhall3477Yea that’s the Hill of Shame where z!onist Israelis go to watch the genocide against the Palestinians in Gaza.
Bill Maher became total joke and his ignorance about what Israel is doing in Gaza is just simply pathetic.
What did he say that was wrong?
i used to watch him every week, he's been utterly insufferable for the last 6 years or so.
Why don't you blame Hamas for Palestinians miserable lives? Blame everyone but Hamas. No wonder the islamic world is a pile of burning camel dung. People like you.
All@@Evirthewarrior
He's not ignorant. He could have been, like, 6 weeks ago. Now anyone who holds his position is just someone who gets a boner at the idea of unliving Palestinian children.
Palestinians lost their 1947 borders to a numerical Jewish Minority who were allowed to have Weapons, while the Palestinians were forbidden to have weapons by the British, hence why the massacres and displacements happened, and then those same Palestinians decided to accept 1967 borders; and that peaceful accomadation of enormous loss actually scared Israel, BECAUSE Israelis want the whole thing. Arafat was being seen as too moderate, so Israel helped finance Hamas in the early days to de-legitimize Arafat. The people desperarely but democratically voted tor Hamas (in Gaza) BECAUSE Israel bombed PLO offices in Lebanon to smitherans and killed 20k Muslim.and Christian Arabs; and then Israel placed non-stop brutal economic sanctions on Gaza. Israel doesn't know how to share...and colonial settler terrorism in the West Bank is proof of that.
At least someone knows part of the truth
People laughed at Ben Affleck when he called out Maher's atheism as just veiled Islamophobia. Well...looks like Batman was right.
...what...atheism has nothing to do with hating Muslims.
@@emhu2594 Well there's atheism and then there's "atheism".
@@emhu2594tell that to Maher
I remember that. It was quite a heated debate
It was Sam Harris who obliterated Ben Affleck not Bill!
Maher is the old man yelling at the cloud meme.
You are ignorant. Most of Israel was the negev desert
Someone should take over Bill’s home and tell him “times change”.
Yes tell him “you have to cope with injustice man ! others did in the past history !”
Best comment 🇵🇸
You should see how POOR LOW INCOME are treated in America they literally come in and steal all your stuff YES your already POOR and the case workers steal your items????? I had two apartments worth of items stolen from me by the case workers at Downtown Women's Centre in Los Angeles just because they could it's CORRUPT SO CORRUPT and America is a system that only benefits and works for the 1% and is very bad for working class especially poor people there is no where to complain and no one to monitor what they are doing
Exactly
Replaced watching Bill Maher with watching Kyle.
You forget a very important matter: Palestinians did not reject the Clinton proposal. They asked for more time to negotiate, but Clinton was 3 months away from ending his term and did not want amy further negotiations.
There's a PBS documentary called, Netanyahu's War. It has to do with that. It says how Netanyahu instigated violence after that, then sabotaged.
No American president nor any Israeli prime Minister have ever pursued a just peace. Stonewalling and a facade.
I don't remember it that way. Clinton broke Barak's arm to offer Arafat 97 percent control of West Bank and Gaza but Arafat turned it down then greenlighted the 2nd intifada.
Yeh nah the Palestinians rejected it from Arab states not wanting peace
@@russe19642why should Palestinians negotiate with terrorists?? Youre all invaders from europe for 75 years ... algeria vomited out the french after 150... not your lands just like "rhodesia" has no right to exist its ZIMBABWE neither does israel its PALESTINE
Thanks Kyle.
Zionst take this position always.
Like
Why you care about palastinians?....
I can only imagine the screaming, crying, kvetching & temper tantrums Maher would perform for all of us if someone came knocking on his Beverly Hills door insisting him to GTFO and don't come back.
I remember when I thought the accusations of islamophobia against Maher and Sam Harris were ridiculous. Turns out they were completely accurate.
Those accusations were basically proven fact 10 years ago already. Where have you been?
@@seeibe I was 16
I thought the same too, one thing is to be critical of Islam (I’m critical of all religions and in an atheist so I don’t believe in any of them) but saying that in glad I no longer agree with idiots like bill Mayer and Sam Harris.
@@heatheraldazabal358as someone who doesn’t listen to Sam Harris, but is very familiar with Christopher Hitchens / Maher and many others openly critical of Islam, what exactly is it he said that you take issue with?
It was unbelievable to watch people defend Harris’s stances on torture and racial profiling. If it were someone else saying those things, people would have rightfully gone after them.
Honestly Bill has to officially be one of the most disgusting and ignorant people in politics. He is so smug yet ignorant on literally everything I have heard him speak on. To make jokes about the number of deaths is a new level of unsettling for him.
His viewership has got to be down. Or there is something wrong with humanity.
it's the latter.@@republica13
@@BillyBowlsterfor all our sakes I pray your wrong!
Bill is great. Almost always.
He's more uninformed than even most fox news hosts. He's not like tucker putting on a persona, he's genuinely dumb.
"Currently on Going", u are a man of facts & reason. Remember the "Cold War" betwen Russians & the U.S.A., they played with the Palestinian Problem. Bill 👎👎👎👎👎
bill Maher is the henry Kissinger of talk show.
The whole world is mourning the war between Israel and Palestine and Bill Maher tries to use the sad situation for his comedy program.
I have watched Bill Maher's monologue, and it was pathetic! 🤮🤮
Palestinians are litterally being massacred by the thousands, BUT it happened in history, so let's move on. Bill Maher, you should at least have the decency of being horrified by what's going on in Gaza and call for a ceasefire.
Bill Maher: SHAME ON YOU! 🤦♂🤦♂
Call for Hamas to surrender......
When you vote for a terrorist to run your country.. that’s what you get
Yeah he acts like these are all past grievances as if Palestinians aren't being killed and colonized right now.
Its typical of these national J funded court jesters like Maher and Colbert . They seem to be very smug in thinking zionism is the last glorious chapter in the history of a place that only sees fleeting victory for anyone that gets involved with it. They are all in for a very rude shock .
Youre asking literal demons to show compassion
You made some good points but also used lazy arguments while criticizing Maher for the same. Lekud is awful but being constantly attacked every few years has pushed Israel further and further to the right.
The main point is that what’s happening in Gaza is deplorable and needs to stop immediately. Agreed.
The " Jews were kicked out of Arab countries " argument just ignores that most of them came from Morocco and other regions that did not force the jews to leave nor discriminated against them. Even the expulsion in some Arab countries happened as a reaction to 1948 NAKBA and 1967 where Israel expanded into Egypt and Syria, and it was still wrong.
Another completely buried facts were that some anti-semitism in the Arab world were orchestrated by Mossad so that the Jews in the Arab nations would flee to israel, most unearthed example was the synagogue bombing in Iraq by Mossad members.
European Jews were forced to leave Germany and not welcomed by other European nations. Since they wanted a state of their own, the European and US was too happily to accommodate and enforce for the last 75 years.
That whole thing is a myth. It was Mossad causing all the problems in Arab countries for Jews and using it to fear monger them. Jews lived in Arab countries just fine until that evil settler colonialist apartheid ethnostate came around. Zionists lie more than they breathe. There is nothing they tell the truth about. Everything they indoctrinate into the minds of their Jewish cultists is total debunkable bullshit. That’s why they work overtime trying to silence any opposition to the terrorist state of Israel and their tall tales.
This is somewhat true, any Iraqi will tell you, they did not want the jews out. It was a conspiracy, where jews were attacked and made to believe it was no longer safe to stay, and after that things went to hell. I've heard numerous Iraqis say they cried when their Jewish friends left.
It also doesn't mention that in certain cases, the jewish migration was initiated by jewish/zionist terrorist attacks (to feed the zionist project).
Bill Maher should be sent back to the retirement home he escaped from😂
Oh God I hate Bill Mahar I can't stand him anymore
Bill Maher is brilliant and totally correct here. Kyle is arrogant, ignorant and cherry-picks his "facts." And he totally ignores Bill's main points which are inconveniently true.
Maher finds more ways to be disgusting.
"The Jews ancestral homeland." That's it. When Maher starts citing the bible, you're done.
Was Jesus born in Bethlehem? Was Mohammed alive 1400 years ago?
It literally was, the Roman's documented it outside of the Bible.
Dude, have you done any historical research? Even if you discount the Bible, there is no debate that it was the Jews' homeland. There is so much archeological evidence for that. The fact that your comment got any likes shows how little many people on this side actually care about truth and how people believe a lie if you parrot it enough.
@@James-ny2xldude it was never a homeland for any particular religion, yes it did have a high population of jeeish peopIe thousands of years ago but it also had pagans as well
and jewishpeopIe didnt only live in that region, they lived all over europe and the mediterranean. To think that any RELIGION has the capacity to cIaim a piece of Iand is hilarious.
Any US citizens that uses the Ancestral Bible stuff should keep the same energy for the Native Indians
Why is he boo-hooing the fact that Bethlehem, the "birthplace of Christ" isn't majority Christian anymore, and that's sad for Christians? Didn't this guy make a whole movie that just talked ahit about the 3 major religions and laughed at everyone's beliefs? What a hypocrite.
Someone please tell Bill Maher that talking down to us only works only if we were looking up to you in the first place
I’m a Palestinian Christian I was supposed to be in living in Bethlehem today but the Israelis kicked me out. Not the Palestinians.
Thanks for doing this Kyle it means a lot
And what do the Palistineans allow you to do??
@@divad1818 be rich
@CapriSunnPapi how do the Palistineans allow you to be rich? Aside from the billionaire corrupt Hamas at the top most Palistineans are poor because they dont like to do much aside from hate and blame others. Most unproductive society in the world.
@@divad1818 All Palestinians say this line to the World and I learned from Palestinians that God is not a real estate agent.
However Christians in the West want to wipe out Palestine and its people off the map, by giving the land to refugees who landed in boat load when German kicked them out. When Israel was created Arabs were 70 percent majority those who landed in boat load were 30 percent however in year 1880 Js were 2 percent of the population in Palestine, compare to Arabs.
See how much injustice done to people of Palestine.
@@CapriSunnPapi All Palestinians say this line to the World and I learned from Palestinians that God is not a real estate agent.
Yeah I just watched a video of a Palestinian Christian priest in Jerusalem who literally stated that if the mosque was bombed in Gaza and there wasn’t the person there to ring out the call for prayers, he would ring the call for prayers at the correct time “for my Muslim friends”
Palestinian Muslims, Christians and Jews lived in peace together and were friends and helped each other just fine before the Zionist came and caused chaos
I'm sorry but you seem to be lacking in history. The Ottoman empire in World War I sided with Germany. Launching an unprovoked surprise attack on allied forces. They lost, dissolved, and thus we're conquered.
The attacked, became owners of the land. Because the previous owners attacked them and lost. That's how that works.
So your last paragraph about them living in peace with each other. Sure There was lots of peace and prosperity going on back in 1914.
@@philipchesleyiiiYou’re the one lacking in history. It seems you don’t even understand what you were replying to. Maybe you should learn to speak like an adult, not like a 5 year old.
Well said ❤thanks 💯
@@philipchesleyiiiYour absolutely right. You are a 5 year old.
The zionists did indeed fuck everything up.
Thank you ! 🙏 I stopped making comments to bash the u.s. government and the Nazionist regime cuz I get censored. But thanks for saying it out loud!
Thank you for addressing Bill's hypocrisy and lies, Kyle. Respect.
How?
I stand with Bill Maher.
I stand with Bill Maher. We know the only one who doesn't like him are FOX-viewers and racist.
You can stand alone@@thomasbaader6629
@@thomasbaader6629 and i stand with your mom 🗿
I couldn’t understand how Maher was cheered for saying those things. To say that we shouldn’t fight for our very lives because everyone in the past who fought imperialism ended up losing or giving up anyway is a joke…
Vietnam didn't lose, and it's one of the closest comparisons to Gaza right now
He's saying Palestinians need to be okay with compromising. There was never a Palestinian state that controlled the River to the Sea, so why do they somehow get rights to all of it? The Jews were there long before the Roman, Greek, and Muslim Arab invaders came (they all later took on the Arab identity after being conquered by the Arabs and in the mid 1900s took on the name Palestinians), and they had the land taken from them too. Is the solution to take it from them again and give it to the descendents of those who took it from them or came later on during their exile? Why can't the land be shared? Both group have historical claims to it and both have been mistreated. As long as either group rejects the option of splitting the land, there will not be peace.
@@James-ny2xlNah, compromise is not what Maher was talking about. The whole monolog was about migration and how some groups had to that and cope. However, at 9:45 , he makes an exception for Israel: "They're not going anywhere." The clear implication is that the Palestinians have to go somewhere else.
@@shumoon1 No, that's not at all what he said. Did you watch the original video? He was saying there needs to be a 2-state solution, and radical pro-Palestinian supports demanding the entire land (from the River to the Sea) be given to Palestine and continually rejecting agreements for a 2-state solution are holding them back from peace and from setting up a Palestinian nation. Saying Israel is not going anywhere means it's going to continue to be a country. If those radical supporters insist the only way for peace is to eradicate Israel and once again kick out Israelis from their ancestral homeland, there will not be peace. Both sides must compromise and accept a 2-state solution that doesn't include the genocide of the other side. Both sides have failed, and both must reform.
Maher's audience is like a cult. Maher can say literally _anything_ and they will laugh, snort, guffaw and clap like trained seals - even when Maher is trying to be serious. They're clearly not the brightest candles in the menorah, and they're one of the biggest reasons why I stopped watching his show. It was tough just getting through the clips that Kyle played for us here.
Maher's cheerleading for this this genocide will define his legacy. I'm embarrassed and ashamed for the times I've promoted him.
What you speechin' about?
@@BudHillTerrenceSpencer he's speaking about reality, the truth.
"Genocide"? Its a war that was started by Hamas! Did the Allies commit genocide against the Germans in WW2?
Bleached hair, ridiculous earrings, hitting a vape 3 mins into the video. Is Kyle okay? Mid life crisis. Looks like a middle schooler...
When people say things that are morally bankrupt like Maher did I can no longer even look at them because I’m filled with so much disgust.
Same. 🤮
I wasn't even able to watch or hear him speak.
Feel the same!
I mean he’s been a pos for a while now. Just a privileged and entitled moron that dismisses human suffering as if he has experienced even a fraction of what a lot of people go through.
Maybe he's, like Allen Dershwitz, ridiculously defending an apartheid state because of his association with and Kompromat obtained by Epstein.
Who is his comedy for? Like, good one bud, you really roasted the Ottoman empire with that one...
It’s for rightwing boomers, always was.
😂😂
Like he had a ghost writer. I've never seen him be so clever. Distasteful yes, he's constantly that. I don't know what losers watch his show. Maybe Blinken needs something to go home to, after being an accessory to genocide.
Bill thinks that when he gets a laugh from his tame, trained audience, he must have made an excellent point.
😂
DEAREST , HELLO . ANYONE , ANY NATION , ANY KINGS , ANY RULERS , WHO HATE ISRAEL IS AT WAR WITH THE ALMIGHTY HOLY POWERFUL GOD. FROM THE KING JAMES VERSION HOLY BIBLE READ : DEUTERONOMY 7 : 6 . WHO ARE YOU TO QUESTION ❓⁉️ AND ARGUE WITH THE ALMIGHTY HOLY POWERFUL GOD ? HE CREATED THIS WORLD AND THE ENTIRE UNIVERSE, AND HE SPOKE WITH AUTHORITY AND POWER , AND HIS WORD STANDS FOREVER .
And Maher calls himself a liberal. 🙄
The US regime is a racist right wing country
Liberal means right wing light
He believes in Jesus
He believe in money. Mamon is the only God in USA. @@unsolvedmystery7408
@@unsolvedmystery7408Fake white Jesus, sure.
@@unsolvedmystery7408 Funny since he said he is an atheist!
Damn. I actually haven’t watched Mahers show since he went off the deep end. His blood thirst is crazy
Watching Bill Maher turn from George Carlin into George Bush, makes me hurl slightly less than watching than Jeff Goldblum turn into The Fly.
Same thing happened with Joe Rogan. Disappointing.
Damn, great comparison.
Even w bush pushed back on west bank settlements
And somehow Seth Brundle was more human.
He was never George Carlin. Not even close
Bill is a comedic satirist. Kyle, if you think you have something intelligent to say, why don't you debate someone who knows the facts.
As an Irish person, I was disgusted about what Bill Maher said about Ireland... We had over 800 years of oppression and colonialism in the whole of Ireland... We fought the British tooth and nail to get our country back. We were starved, oppression, slaughtered and dehumanised until we clawed back most of the country. All but the tip as he so callously said... The British held on to Northern Ireland and they weren't blowing each other up as he put it. It was just as complicated as the situation in Palestine. Catholics had NO civil rights. They had homes taken off them and given to the Protestants. They weren't given jobs and they were terrorised, tortured and killed... After 30 years of "the troubles" people who hated each other and killed each others friends and family, sat together and finally fought hard "politically" for peace. That is why Ireland was the first European country to stand up for the Palestinians... Ireland supported Israel until 1967 while they were the oppressed. Now Ireland stand with the Palestinians. They are the oppressed so we will support them... Bill Maher is a joke! I won't watch his show again.
I stopped watching his show also. It appears Maher thinks that anyone who disagrees with his support of ethnic cleansing must be ‘woke’.
It is so good to see that the Irish are staunch protesters against the genocide in Palestine. They know what it is like to be oppressed and killed. But the Israelis are just doing the same genocide ( if not worse ) that happened to them in WW2 on Palestines. It says a lot about the mindset of the Israelli.
Just because somebody is "oppressed" doesn't automatically put them in the right. What a stupid take. If the Palestinians have been offered peace deals multiple times that they've rejected because they somehow think they'll get it all "from the river to the sea", and they continue to think violence is the way to achieve that goal, then their oppression is on them. But hey, it's a free country, please continue to be useful idiots for the arab world, who could have solved this issue easily 70 years ago by taking in an equal number of palestinian refugees as jews they'd just kicked out.
Well said
Whether an Irish or Palestinian a human who is oppressed and dehumanized will lash out. The rage that we witnessed on October 7 was pure hatred.
Thank you for defending Palestinians 🙏🙏🙏
Why don't you blame Hamas for Palestinians miserable lives? Blame everyone but Hamas. No wonder the islamic world is a pile of burning camel dung. People like you.
why? they are terrorist
I love how progressives will run Dave Chappelle out of show business for making a joke about trans people but defend the living crap out of Muslim radicals who would throw trans people off of a building
Why should they be defended? They were the attackers. IDF has a lot of work on its hand
@@amitpadgaonkar8830I'm gonna touch you with my hand inappropriately and you won't like it
Bill Maher is doing quite well in a non-Jewish state.
Kinda ruins the argument that there is a need for ethnic cleansing to have a Jewish state.
People have a right to exist.
Also, the fact that Jews are much safer in the diaspora than they are in Israel blows the main Zionist argument for the necessity of the creation of Israel
Maher isn't Jewish though
@@anshuecon His mom is Jewish but he found out later in life
@@anshueconHe is.
@@anshueconhis mother was, which technically makes him Jewish by Jewish law.
Kyle kulinski it doesn't matter if Jews were only one third of the land the fact is Jews were all over Europe in North Africa extreme hostility and many more would be coming home which incidently you leave out is their traditional Homeland as they were there well before Arabs
BM does a great job diverting viewers to explain how “because injustices existed in the past (do you all remember those..ha ha ha)” we can all sit back in our easy chairs and not be so hard on Israel as they kill Palestinian children. I hope his show is cancelled so he can longer spread his broken justifications.
I am sure his Hollywood backers are pleased to hear in monologue.
It's like, all these atrocities happened in the past, why not say anything about that? Lmfaoooo. He is parroting the same talking point as all Zionists.
@@chakesluvcuz they’re all Jeebs
when "never again" means "actually sometimes again don't worry about it"
Left unsaid is that none of the peace deals on the table permitted Palestinian state sovereignty over the air (meaning no airport), no control over water resources, no standing defense force, no control over borders & trade, and no right of return for the Palestinian refugees in Jordan, Lebanon, and elsewhere from past wars.
All these peace deals were one-sided shams. Israel never wanted a Palestinian state, and their underlying intentions were to grab as much land before the world woke up to their antics. It's a text book apartheid terror state.
Finally someone who says this. I am sick and tired of people making it seem like Palestinians rejected peace and just hate Jews and want them all dead. It is like people do not read. The proposals were all dumb, and nobody would have accepted that.
Facts 🎯 Accepting those terms would’ve still fucked over the Palestinians.
Why don't the Palestinians simply ask Egypt and Jordan to annex Gaza and the West Bank? Then they'll be absorbed into countries with access to air space and water.
Yup, the only answer to "Palestinians should just accept the deal." in my opinion is "Replace Palestinians with Ukranians. Sounds familiar?"
When I saw this segment on Bill Maher I couldn't believe how simplistic his point was. Like: wtf kind of framing is this?
I have to agree with Bill on that one, everything he said made sense. Not sure what point you are trying to make, but I don't hear any message on your part. I don't even agree with you on what you present as historical facts. At least I am starting to understand why we are done as a society, so let it burn then. I don't believe anymore that we can stop it.
See how he can say THIS and not lose his show? Disgusting times we live.
I'm worried about the folks that clapped at those lines and the people on the comment section that are cheering for him. bill maher brings out the bigots out of cave.
The Zionist backed up personalities are protected. For now. But it will be us, us who will bring these narcissists, these proxies to justice
What he's saying is, unfortunately, totally in line with the mainstream rhetoric. If anything, he just ensures continued job security for continuing to carry water forAIPAC.
Lose his show? For what? You are exactly the people he rails about. Thanks for the reinforcement.
@@Chriscraft50 I guess you are not familiar what happened couple decades ago. Google it.
Bill never fails to disappoint and make me cringe.
Making you cringe is one of the things that make him great.
Tell me you are racist without telling me you are racist.
@@thomasbaader6629 If that's the case then you're cheering him on for being a genocidal fascist supporter.
Hello Nazi.
@@thomasbaader6629 found the Zionist. Y'all are no different than white supremacists.
He can't disappoint you once you realize he's crap.
“If your people got kicked off the land, you need to get over it. Also you can’t kick people off their land anymore now because I guess morality is relative”
Or, alternatively, national borders are totally arbitrary lines that infringe on the human right to travel and live freely.
Agreed.
Kyle is thousands of light years behind Bill Maher. MAher is genius, Kyle and his wife are cliche
Bill Maher quite suits to the definition of "fascists coming back under the cover of liberals"
He's the same lefty he's always been. The problem is we have lots of illiberal people in this country, who think they're liberals. To be honest it's really not their fault. They were pushed through the school system and are the most illiterate generations.
So of course they have no idea what the words mean. Who would honestly expect them to.
That's not to suggest that I think you're younger. You could be older, but then it'd be entirely your own fault for being the way you are.
He's not a liberal, he takes shots at both left and right.
agree - they have many faces
Liberal ? Maher is a libertarian he's also Jewish.
He likes to emphasize his Catholic side.@@breakingbadheisenberg9703
He is not a human. He is an animal.
Don't insult animals.
Using Bill Maher' analogy, if squatters were to kick him out of his house, he wouldn't create too much of a fuss. Interesting.
That's not what he said. It is interesting that's what you think he said, though. Very telling.
@@philipchesleyiiiVery telling of what? Stop trying to sound smarter than you are with half baked statements. But you’re right in a way, a better analogy would be if Bill Maher was kicked out of his house, then he only have a limited amount of time until the statute of limitations is up and he should *get over it.* Oh and the house thief is a wife/child beater who still has his family…
@@philipchesleyiiithat's exactly what he said. By any change are you a member of the maroon club of america?
It actually is, he's just not Palestinian in this case.@@philipchesleyiii
No offense but it is very difficult to listen to you talk with a e-cig or whatever it is in your hand; just does not look very professional.
He's not dumb he completely understands he doesn't view Palestinians or any Muslim especially if they've got darker skin than him as human.
I can't watch certain south park episodes because Muslims suck......
I disagree respectfully; in my observation he seems to be unaware of things such as historical analysis and personal reflection.
I agree---Maher knows (exactly) what he is saying, as he knows that his words are racist, destructive and enable more genocide and ethnic cleansing from those who do such evil work.
Maher is an atheist, but you don’t have to believe in God to be a Zionist! He claims all religions are BS and man made, but when it comes to the Jewish holy book, everything in there must be factual and accurate!! How can you prove that a typical Blond European Jew is the same Jew that lived there thousands of years ago? Palestinians have more original Semitic genes than Polish Netanyahu!!
@@greenscene5215when he said muslim us the bigest colonizer 😅😅
When I saw Bill Maher accept the definition of CRT from Ben Shapiro over an actual educator he had on the panel that very day, I realized he was too far gone. Accepting the definition without the nuance that takes to be a leftist, sorry bill. You want a complicated world to fit inside a neat little box, you're not on the team you think you are to begin with, but you are letting the opposition Define what that box is? That's the mental retirement that keeps Fox News in business.
The problem is that "critical race theory" in practice, as taught in SOME schools, often does go into fringe territory. I haven't seen the clip in question, but as a leftist myself, I've always viewed identity-based politics as a way to belittle class consciousness, because that's precisely how it's utilized. It's a lot easier to succeed in passing legislation that supports gay rights than it is to succeed in passing legislation that supports workers rights. You'd have to be a complete buffoon in order to deny that in the face of recent history.
Maher and Shapiro are still goofballs, though.
MLK said it best.
"First, I must confess that over the last few years I have been gravely disappointed with the white moderate. I have almost reached the regrettable conclusion that the Negro's great stumbling block in the stride toward freedom is not the White Citizen's Council-er or the Ku Klux Klanner, but the white moderate who is more devoted to "order" than to justice; who prefers a negative peace which is the absence of tension to a positive peace which is the presence of justice; who constantly says "I agree with you in the goal you seek, but I can't agree with your methods of direct action;" who paternalistically feels he can set the timetable for another man's freedom; who lives by the myth of time and who constantly advises the Negro to wait until a "more convenient season."
@@ignatiusjackson235 Critical Race Theory is not about identity politics, but more about class difference originated in racism.
Critical race theory (CRT) is an interdisciplinary academic field devoted to analysing how social and political laws and media shape (and are shaped by) social conceptions of race and ethnicity. CRT also considers racism to be systemic in various laws and rules, and not only based on individuals' prejudices. The word critical in the name is an academic reference to critical thinking, critical theory, and scholarly criticism, rather than criticizing or blaming individuals.
The mental retirement that keeps Fox News in business... Just a spectacular sentence. And hilarious and true.
@@zensoredparagonbytes3985 a.k.a. Identity Politics. Are you seriously that daft, or do you just expect the rest of us to be so?
I'm not trying to be rude either. I genuinely don't understand how anybody could lack so much in the way self-awareness. Are you trying to redefine "identity politics" or do you really think that what you described doesn't qualify as such? Either way, those mental gymnastics are impressive.
Most importantly, however, it's worth noting that race-baiting is by far the EASIEST way to divide the working class. More often than not, CRT ends up playing right into that time-tested divide-and-conquer tactic, regardless of how well-intentioned it may be.
You can pretend that's not the case all you like, but every development in recorded history and basic human psychology suggests otherwise.
Wait i can think of plenty of bigger colonizers then Muslims. English empire, spainisj empire, the mongles empire, the french empire, russian empire.
British: Not true!
French: not true!
Russian: not true!
Spanish: probably true!
Mongol: yes, but wrong context!
@WorshipinIdols those are the largest empires by land area. Not to mention the qing dynasty which was larger then any Muslim empire.
@@zkapsh exactly why you are wrong. The Muslim empire is completely of a different nature. It is an evil empire that has intentionally conspired to wipe out the cultures and religions of other people. And exterminated and enslaved more people that could ever be counted, including 90% of all African slaves that have ever been enslaved went to Arabia and died there. Including the single biggest genocide in history against the Hindus that killed between 60 and 100 MILLION people over the course of about 100 years of Islamic conquest whether by timurlane of the Mughals etc…
This is a uniquely ideologically evil empire.
@@WorshipinIdolsBritish of course. The British Empire was the real cause of the WWI. They were the bad guys and win.
I love to watch this Kyle dude get triggered. 😂😂😂
Money doesn’t buy morals…nor class
I guess the holocaust wasn't such a big deal to Maher or maybe he makes an exception for that event.
It was bad, jet we don’t hear them complaining on Germany today
@@inteallsviktigtbecause Germany has changed and no longer harbors/elects evil terrorist militia groups. Whereas many Muslim countries still do. Liberals love to separate hamas from the people of Palestine but in ideology they’re the same.
Because it involved his people and everyone else be damned
@@inteallsviktigtyeah because nazis aren’t really rounding up people in the streets these days
@@addimesorho no, because they are irrelevant minority
I think there are many parallels with how the native people in the Americas were treated and the Palestinians now and in the last century. Considering the original people who inhabited the Americas were murdered in great numbers, and the ones who were left god ‘reserves’ where they were forced to go to. Usually the worst lands in remote regions.
True words here, millions of people reduced to thousands in such a short time throughout the Americas.So much knowledge and culture lost forever, yet nothing gained except the normalization of violent ignorance, hate and racial domination.
It's parallel to how a lot of other groups of people on the planet have been treated by Western Europeans.
The so-called Palestinians have ~85% of the British Mandate of Palestine - Jordan alone got 77%
@@riiraa881 I absolutely agree that many Western European nations have done horrible things, including slave trade, genocide and oppression thought there colonies. But please don’t forget this has been done by many other nations in the world.
Japan for example, with its long period of slaughter in most of Asia. Including horrible concentration camps with crimes similar to that of Mengele. Or what about the genocides in the Balkans? Or the Armenian genocide?
Earlier the Vikings murdered and pillaged all throughout Europe, or the Arabs taking most land around the Mediterranean in the Middle Ages. Southern Europe obviously also has a large history of conquest, with the Roman Empire and in the late Middle Ages Spain.
Then there is Russia with many Tsars murdering like there was no tomorrow. Not to mention Stalin who is responsible for more killings than the nazis. Than there is MAO who is world champion in killing the most amount of people. Or what about Pol Pot who murdered over 2 million people. Rwanda comes to mind, but to be fair, this was mainly caused by colonialism and the Catholic Church.
That last party is also responsible for millions of deaths, and the Vatican is an official country so I assume that counts. So it is a global phenomena, genocide and mass murder, not just Western Europe.
Name one muslim majority democracy.
Name one year where Isr*el didn’t ki*l innocent Palestinians?
Hell.
Turkiye
Someone needs to tell bill maher. Wrong stays wrong.
Bill Maher’s audience sounds like a load of clapping & whooping seals.
I'm an American attorney who has been a champion of Palestinian rights (and realities) for 30 years. Thank you for speaking up. 🙏
How about israel rights and their rights to not be murdered? They gave back GAZA and vacated jews and the palestinians spent their UN money on weapons and tunnels in order to attack. Are you a Hamas supporter?
In other words, you have been a scumbag for at least 30 years. If you don't stand with Israel, you're an enemy of humanity.
Thank you for being fair
Why do you support Hamas? What led you to support terrorism?
@@carladams9345 It is not a matter of supporting Hamas per se, but understanding what caused their formation in the first place.
Is not the IDF a terrorist force? Sanctioned by the State of Israel, and fueled by American dollars, it represents some of the worst of humankind.
How unfortunate that the once persecuted have become the persecutors.
I can't stand watching him or giving a second of my life listening to his hateful agenda
To be clear, Maher includes all of these topics in his monologue because he has his writers back after their strike ended.
P. S. Hahaha! ‘Imaginary dreams!?!’ Reality check Bill; all dreams are imaginary, more or less by definition.
Good job Kyle. 👏🏿 👍
Maher's take on genocide: eh, shit happens.
Maher’s position sounds psychotic