Let’s bust Soy(a) Myths | Dr Pal
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 มิ.ย. 2024
- Soy, whether it is good or bad for your health. discussed about myths surrounding soy and its impact on cancer, hypothyroidism, and hormonal imbalance. i have explained the importance of protein intake, especially for women and vegetarians, and why soy is an excellent source of protein. Also provided insights on different soy products and their benefits, including promoting good bone and gut health, improving cardiac health, and overall well-being.
Research article: pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18620...
#MakeYourselfAPriority #DrPal
0:00 Introduction
1:00 Protein Intake
2:00 Plant based diet
2:45 Types of soy
4:50 Soy causes cancer?
5:50 Soy causes hypothyroidism?
8:10 Soy causes hormonal imbalance?
10:35 Conclusion
---
Dr. Palaniappan Manickam MD, MPH
Internal Medicine | Gastroenterology & Nutrition
---
Are you interested to join our 90-day weight loss program designed to help you make lasting changes to your lifestyle ?
drpalmanickam.com/new-me/
newme.fit6@gmail.com
For Tamil videos, Subscribe to my TH-cam channel: / @priyapal_vibes
Follow us on
Facebook : / dr-pal-102856268051377
Instagram: / dr.pal.manickam
Twitter : / drpal_manickam
Telegram: t.me/Ask_Doc_Pal
For Collabs & Enquiries
Email: askdocpal@gmail.com
Pls donate to our non profit Vanna Malargal Foundation, here are the details
www.vmfus.org/
#askdocpal #drpal #palaniappanmanickam #IntermittentFasting #WeightLossJourney #BellyFatLoss #TimeRestrictedEating
#IFResults #HealthyEating #IFCommunity #FastingForHealth #LoseWeight #FitLife #FatLossTips #MealTiming #IFGoals #BellyFatBusters #EatClean #IFSuccess #FitnessMotivation #BurnFat #HealthyHabits #MealPlan - บันเทิง
Join me on my Medcom stand up show during my Malaysia tour on October 28th and 29th.
looking forward to meet you all in person !
Ticket 🎟️ links
Book your tickets now at KL: www.excitix.com.my/event/53/Laws-of-Weight-Loss-(Kuala-Lumpur)
🔗 Book your tickets now at JB: www.excitix.com.my/event/54/Laws-Of-Weight-Loss-(Johor-Bharu, near Singapore)
Hlo doc !! Put a video for weight gaining tips nd foods for skinny to look muscle and fit In a healthy way @Drpal
3:23
Dr. My son is short for his 11yrs, what food changes would you recommend, is it possible for me to contact you?Please
Please also mention what type of soy products must be avoided by people with Hidradenitis Suppurativa? I can't exercise much hence started following your videos for diet based weight reduction. Normally we don't get a lot of junk foods in Germany and mostly it's low on sugar in everything. I don't eat fermented or yeast based foods so obviouly no breads and brewed stuff. Not even idly or dosa since it also triggers. I always have to cook fresh and eat and taking a toll on life. Making Chaats with chickpea or yellowpeas. Jogurt (only when needed and not in excess). Vitamin b12, D, Synbiotikum and zinc 75mg as supplements are a must everyday. I'm trying to find natural ways of getting stuff and unable to figure out much. Most south indian foods are perfect with no fermentation.
Dear Dr. Pal, can you please do a video on what time to eat fruits and would they be considered "snakes" if eaten between the 3 meals? Also some best fruit suggestions for old age people, especially diabetic.
1st time I am commenting sir, After seeing ur videos just tried circadian rhythm. After 5 pm IST no eating only water. Tried for 3 weeks and checked my blood, blood results Fasting sugar 94 before it was 109, after food 112 before it was 127, triglycerides 174 before it was 352. Tried almost every statin pills to reduce my triglycerides level, nothing worked. I have to tell u one more thing sir this is without exercise …..
U shud start your workout .. start with a bit of walking.. u can build up on exercises later.. one step at a time it will help u
Was your diet like low carb or normal diet following circadian rhythm
Great achievement!! 👏👏👏
Awesome
@@wewdgdksdjbdkdk ok sir
My daughter 7 years old saw your video on oreo biscuits by chance and she stopped taking oreo biscuits. She loved ur videos on lays and oreo. Plz give few more videos for kids, dont forget to include ur kids in video😊
Let her eat man kids can digest sugar without any issues
@@innovativeX32Diabeto roll back to kitchen
its good to have better food habits from day one
@@innovativeX32
@@innovativeX32let your kids be unhealthy not everyone's kids should be unhealthy
@@roronoauchiha69 super is unhealthy if consumed in excess and it is proven that suger in kids boast energy more that adults kids can digest sugar easily without any symptoms
Doc Pal, I am following intermittent fasting since 20 days. I could see the difference in energy levels during the daytime and feel lighter during ascending and descending the stairs. Thanks for your movement on intermittent fasting.😊
I wish our college professors had taught like you 🙌It's a pleasure to watch your informative videos doctor! Great job
Great work on debunking myth of Soya effect on Breast Cancer and raising awareness about thyroxine consumption before having meals
Being a transitioning vegan for health, animals and environment, highly appreciate your take on plant-based lifestyle. It clarifies a lot of doubts ❤
Thank you Dr Pal, I have learnt a lot from your videos and have made the necessary changes in my diet. Glad to hear you extend support to our fellow beings in Madurai. I support your cause and would be more than happy to support even more!
Thank you so much for all the information, Dr. Pal. Grateful to you for clarifying all these misconceptions we had
Great Doctor he is like a Family doctor explaining clearly on each subject
Thank you doctor for inspiring us.
I'm 23 year old Engineer.
Time restricted feeding not only reduced my belly fat, but also improved my sleep quality, thus my mental health and reduced my cough due to allergens. I don't know how to thank you. You're doing a social service through this TH-cam Channel. Special regards to your friend Saravana Kumar and his wife Thirupura Sundari.😊
i usually eat Soyabean chunks with vegetables curry 2 times a week
What don't you leave meat ?
Why giving pain to animals just you follow some cult ?
Hello Sir , thank you for all your realistic
talk on all health issues.. I really enjoy watching your short videos that’s quite funny but also very informative.. we use soya granules ( meal maker) .. hope that’s also fine as a protein source
Doctor Pal, your videos are amazingly informative and entertaining as well! I’ve been avoiding Soy because of the several myths around it. Thank you so much for the clarification and superb explanation in your video.
Im nearly 40, after seeing ur shorts started following ur videos, quit sugar and sugar based products, for 2 months of time following intermittent fasting, daily work outs, healthy foods, I can feel lot of changes myself feeling very active, all credits to Dr pal, Saravana kumar, and thirupurasundarai, thanks for being an eye opener. Dr Pal.🙏🙏🙏.
You should also thank his only patient Arockiasamy
@@shaggy75there is also a video about your problem in this channel
May the medical field have many more doctors those truly care for the well-being of their patients and create healthy families and societies. You always mesmerize all your subscribers with your medical inputs seasoned with humour easy to digest into the human senses. May His blessings overflow on you and on all those striving to create a healthy society!
Hi Dr Pal.
Im also a Doc
Consultant Physician
I lost almost 19 kgs over the past 9 months ie from 85 kg to 66 kg by following ur intermittent fasting , high protein diet along with 2 to 2.5 hours of HIIT or Tabata workouts.
You ve been doing a great work to the community.
Also Im proudly saying that Dr Prabhushankar ,the collector cum Ur schoolmate is my UG batchmate ..
Thanks Dr nithya
Interested to know your diet plan details, please share of you don't mind mam
2 hours of hiit is too much of hiit
can you please share your diet and time of eating ?
Can you please share diet need to that I can play with my kid
I’ve been waiting for this for sooo long from you❤ thanks a tonnnn dr
Most welcome 😊
You are just as amazing with wordplay and puns Doc. Respect
Thank you. Dr.Pal your information about Soya. I m pure vegetarian and living in Canada.I m doing intermittent fasting 12 hours.I already sent my donation to Madurai.🥰🙏
Good morning Dr Pal… I am glad to tell you I get excited every time I play your videos and look forward to new ones😊. I have been having left side upper abdominal discomfort early every morning I strictly follow intermittent fasting yet not getting help. Please advice. Thanks Sally
By following intermittent fasting 7am to 6pm I have been able to lose 1.3 kg in just nearly 20 day. Thanks for making such informative videos. Feel like I am very different person- mentally and physically with much more energy and positivity. Thank u😊😊
Do you have 2 meals or 3 meals
@@thiruvetti this is the way to go
Hi Dr.Pal..
I use mostly Soya chunks for making rice pulav and side dishes.. I hope this form of soy is also not harmful.
Thank you for the valuable topics you have been sharing
no it is not harmful
Thank you so much doc for this yet another highly informative video ! My daughters are into sports and once a nutritionist mentioned that i should avoid soy as it causes harmonal imbalance and I stopped giving them because of that. Thanks for debunking that myth. As pure vegetarians it's actually quite difficult to achieve the required protein level per day and your tips are super helpful. Thanks again.
Thank you so much for your valuable information. I have started watching your videos recently, & l have started following your channel regularly. I am suffering for TSH imbalance from last 7 years & after sever covid I suffered a lot from psoriasis in foot & palms, diarrhea for more than one year plus nostrils block issues. Three months ago I thought I should cure myself will my willpower & I started reading books & watching videos and suddenly your videos came across as gift from heaven. At present my all health issues are getting cured & people around me looking at me as fitness icon. No words to express my gratitude towards you ❤
Hi doctor. I am from USA. I am a big fan of you. Your videos are very knowledgeable. Could you please advise more about crucified vegetables. Many people says it's not good for thyroid. Specially to avoid kale and cabbage. Please can you share you thoughts on this. I really appreciate your service. Stay blessed.
You are awesome and doing great service to humanity.May your family be blessed always ...
You are my motivator ,I hv lost 10 kgs ,my Hba1c is 4 .6 ,My CRP is 3 .The CRP used to be always more than 10 since 10 years.Afyer losing weight I hv achieved the goal.Thank you ❤
How did you did this?
Just follow what Dr said in video about intermittent fasting
Can we have morning coffee after fasting?
@@sudhas244 th-cam.com/video/n9wQrjPlgc0/w-d-xo.htmlsi=EfuLG9z8GfXQ3qz5
How much time did it take to loose 10kgs
Thank you doctor. It was very informative and interesting. Loved the humor in your talk and also the clarity. I use the Nestle Soya chunks available in the market. Hope that is a good source too.
I've been asking to discuss this for a few times :) thank you for this
Big fan of your videos sir , trust me I have reduced 5 kgs only with your guidance and proper diet plan , I follow 14-5-5 hrs plan and haven't given away my carbohydrates as well. I feels light when I follow this diet and thanks to u as well , finally I have healthy guts to comment u now 😀
Sir could you elaborate 14-5-5 plan
14 hours fasting,I.e 5 in the evening to next day 7 clock ..,break fast
12 clock lunch and 5clock evening dinner .
@@LAK19487pm dinner - 9am breakfast- 2pm lunch
I always wanted to have a restricted eating window. I knew the benefits but could never implement. But yours videos and comic factor has helped start and remain consistent.
Phew! Thank you for clearing our fears on soy, Dr! I take soy as soy chunks curry mostly and soya flour chappathis on rare occasions.
Hi Doc! My late father was a dermatologist! Being of Indian Muslim descent, non-vegetarian diet being the norm. However, our diet was pretty balanced and just like your buddy Saravana Kumar, my Dad had a wicked sense of humour! Once as a teen, i announced to my bewildered Amma that i was a vegetarian forthwith! My Atha drawled in his usual amused way,' ...... Dont you know cows and goats eat grass and hence they r veg tooo! I was gob smacked! As usual his wicked sense of humour made light of a an angst ridden teen tantrum! Now i have a balanced diet due to his wonderful parenting! But i agree with u.....as you age a more plant heavy diet does you no end of good! I havent achieved your recommendation of 80/20 but strive for as much as i can as i need the phytoestrogen my gynae has recommended as I i dont want HRT! Btw see you in SEA!
I wanted a non diary paneer alternative. Instead of going for tofu, i tried burmese tofu, made from masoor dal. We can also make from green batani or chickpeas. Tastes pretty good, has good flavour, good protein for vegetarian. Can toast and add to salad.
Hi how to do Burmese tofu pls
@@premasivasubramaniam6621 Soak a cup of masoor dal in water. After 3 hours grind in mixie like idli batter. Cook the mixture on stove for five to 10 minutes, add salt and some seasoning for flavour, I added ginger garlic paste here. It gets hard here and comes a little bit of the pan. Transfer it into a square tray. Allow to cool and keep in the fridge to set for an hour or so. Cut into cubes and toast in pan with butter and enjoy. Same can done with dry green peas or kabuli chana.
Great ideas
Thank you so much for sharing so many important insights with us.
Wow, JUST what i wanted to ask since soooo many years! THANK YOU doc!!!
Dr Pal, Thanks for all the clarification regarding Soy ..I predominantly use tofu as we follow plant based diet and we are also vegan.
Mtlb soya bean is not good
I use Tofu & soya chunks regularly
In this video you clarified many doubts about Soy . Thank you 🙏
soy is very healthy, tofu and chunks is amazing!
Dear Dr Pal
Another fan of yours influenced by your advice has started no food after 7 pm, it is working very well.
I am constantly losing belly fat, blood sugar under control. HbA1c is 6.
My daughter is also understanding healthy gut bacteria and has improved her diet.
Thank you and God bless you.
Hii Sir
I am seriously searching for this all over the net.
Thank you so much.
Thank for removing fear
@DrPal, I greatly appreciate you sharing this informative video. This topic has been lingering in my mind since February 2023. I am a 32-year-old active vegetarian female who has been engaged in weight lifting for the past two years. As I progressed, I found it necessary to increase my protein intake to aid in quicker recovery and muscle growth. Currently, my protein intake is 120 grams (corresponding to my weight of 128 lbs), out of which 44 grams are derived from soya chunks.
In January 2023, my blood work indicated hyperthyroidism. However, it was minimal and I was advised against taking any medication. I introduced soya chunks into my diet in February 2023 to meet the increased protein demand from my workout regimen. However, each time I consume soya chunks, I am apprehensive about their potential impact on my hyperthyroidism.
I would greatly appreciate any insights you might have regarding the effects of soya chunks on hyperthyroidism. I am planning to undergo another round of blood work soon to determine whether my thyroid levels have remained stable or increased.
Don’t forget to update on this. I’m suffering from the same problem except it is hypothyroidism (subclinical). No weight gain issues.
Thank you doc, from the moment I started following you, there has been a positive change in my life.
Thank you Dr. Pal . I am a vegetarian and it was very hard for me to complete my daily protein intake. Also there were rumours about the soya causes man boobs . Your video was really helpful to me. Now I will be able to consume it without hesitation. 😃
Ok soyboy
I'm also vegetarian and have been using an app to track my protein intake. I found it easy to reach .8g/kg/day with no supplements, but getting to 1.2g/kg required me to get a pea protein supplement. My main sources were beans/lentils, as well as chia seeds and ground flax seeds, which I would add to overnight oats for my breakfast. The thing is, we definitely have protein in our Indian vegetarian food, but we tend to eat more rice and less of the protein containing sides. Tracking my food helped me to see this very clearly.
Many thanks Dr Pal for this wonderful information.
Very informative and useful especially for Vegetarians.Thank you Mr.pal.
Hii sir am finally doing a 3day water fasting... 20 hours to go now...
❤
Keep rocking ❤🎉😊
Hi sir
It's been a pleasure to watch ur videos..Lot of info in single video...thanks a ton❤
Thank you Dr. Pal for the medical advice and pieces of humor. :)
Hello Doctor. I started intermittent fasting a week ago....feeling lighter ,better and more stamina. Thank u😊
Nanum thanga
OMG not me learning about soy from past couple of days to know it's benefits and disadvantages as a girl suffering from pcod and here Dr pal literally granting my wish look like I manifested it 😅 Dr please talk about pcod problem too.
Thank you doctor for such a wonderful explanation ❤
Hello doctor,I'm from your native Madurai.. my husband guided me about Intermittent fasting since a year before.. But following after watching your videos 😊
Please say about soya chunks .Is it processed one ?I am Type 1 Diabetic taking chunks and soya daily is it recommended ? (Being a vegetarian) .
I too need clarification on this !!!!
Really really needed this on my weightloss journey with veg protein options. Thanks Dr. 😊 From the hot chennai i take soya milk without sugar tofu and veg chicken😂 honestly veg
😅😢
Hey Pal, looking forward
@DrPal Please make a video on the topic - Hypothyroidism-fasting-diet if possible. Your videos are the absolute best. Thank you!
What about Soya chunks?
they are fine
Whenever I eat soy I get SUPER anxious and paranoid. So, I avoid it for that reason 😅
Doc❤
Thank you, I waited for this video esp for hypothyroidism case vs soy. I use eltroxin 75mcg everyday, and I was skeptical to use soya 2months ago. Now you have cleared my doubt and as well fear of absorption of thyroxine while eating soya.
Thanks a ton❤
So well explained! Thank u sir
Hello Dr Pal ,thanku for providing us with amazing information .I am an Indian vegetarian who is forced to become vegan coz dairy gave me acne and gut issues ...i really struggle to eat enough protein and calcium in my diet ..can you plz suggest how can I include enough protein in my diet on daily basis .Thanks in advance ..
try vegan protein powders and make a shake for breakfast
I am also vegan by default (vegetarian but allergic to dairy and egg) in the USA. It isn't really hard to reach and exceed the recommendations given for me (50 kg/110 lbs body weight, 40 grams protein per day is my minimum target), so make sure your protein goal isn't set too high. (Meat eaters tend to think they need too much protein so they will recommend too much to everyone.) Get a free food tracker for your phone or computer that tracks protein and fiber and you will be surprised at how quickly it all adds up, including smaller amounts of protein from vegetables. This should make you feel better about your diet and help you see ways to improve as needed.
These trackers are usually sold to people wanting to lose weight, but I've been using such trackers for many years without wanting to reduce calories. I always started using them in the beginning and later to make sure I was getting enough food after or during an illness or with pain issues! (I am a "stress non-eater" and so my appetite seriously decreases when under stress or feeling unwell. Nothing stopped my brother from eating! So I am a genetic anomaly in my family.) Trackers really are useful for monitoring other things besides calories since they track "macros" (protein, fiber, sugars, total carbohydrates, fat and sometimes more). I find LoseIt has been very easy for me to add "customized foods" to the food database, which may be useful for you unless you find a tracker that has a database with typical Indian foods already in it. I just look for nutritional info on the internet to enter for my foods.
Legumes/beans/lentils of all sorts (including peanuts) are good protein sources. Nuts and seeds add up also. Whole grains also. And flatbreads can be made out of anything you can grind into a flour/make into a batter if you can't tolerate much wheat like me. (Wheat is otherwise high in protein, whether whole-grain or white). TH-cam has many videos showing how to make flatbreads this way as well as anything else you need to know about making food.
Mushrooms have a reasonable amount of protein also.
I keep vegan protein powders on hand in case they are needed, especially if I am sick. Sometimes I add them to vegan yoghurt that is low in protein (such as if not made with soy or almond milk) or vegan pudding rather than mixing them into drinks. But I don't rely on them otherwise. So you can eat vegan and get your protein without them, but they might be helpful for you.
Just use such a tracker even if only to occasionally check your eating, and you will easily see if you are getting enough protein and how to get more if needed.
Also to mention, I started intermittent fasting since last week with my eating window being 11 am to 5pm only. I'm taking detox water( lime lemon, ginger, cucumber, mint in it) at least 2-3 ltrs. In 8 days I lost close 2 kgs.
Consistency is the key.
How about your diet and sleep schedule
@LAK1948 I'm eating mostly 1 full meal in the eating window and rest of the day only detox water, 2ltrs at least
@LAK1948 I'm sleeping 5-6 hours every night
Wow!!! Great Information as usual in a very comical way!!! Thanks Dr.Pal!!
Much needed video doc thanks 👍
Is soy different from soya chunks?
Same
Is soy chunks contain maida when it's processing?
Hi, is this Soy the same as Soya nuggets, we buy here in India?
Yes
God bless you doctor......you are really making changes in indian society ......
Highly informative doctor had lots of doubts about soya now it’s clarified thanks doctor
Sir is Soy and soya chunks are the same?
No !!!!!!!!!!!
Meanwhile Saravana Kumar says Hai to paya and Bye to soya...😂
It’s all a MAAYA 😂
Thanks dr pal for the detailed explanation..all misconceptions cleared ..thanks again 👍
Dr Pal, love your sense of humour, I used to have one soya cappuccino a day but now have almond milk instead coz I have hypothyroidism and soya is always in the limelight for one thing or another and that’s quite scary.
Thankyou sir, for sharing the valuable information!
Thank you Doctor for the information.
Thank you so much. I am hypothyroid and being a vegetarian I was in a dilemma, whether to take soya or not.
Thanks for clearing up. Thanks a bunch.
Very good content sir. Thanks
Thank you so much doctor for your valuable guidance.
Thanks Dr Pal,you your God's gift to humanity.
Thank you sir. For your indepth videos and knowledge. You have a lot of following here in India and wish to see your NGO succeed also sir. Good work. 😊😊😊
Dr first of all thank you for the knowledge and the way you address the concerns which also makes us want to change our bad habits. You are some of the doctors I respect with the way you are concerned about individuals and not just about money.
Dr can you make a video on hemoglobin. Upto what level is normal and things to eat and avoid. Thank you.
Dr Pal. U are an amazing human being and such a inspiration sir. Have lost 10 kg over 9 months thanks to you inspirational videos . A big follower of intermittent fasting.
Sir any time if u plan to come to Cochin do let me know
Hai Dr. Pal.... Thank u so much for ur eye opening videos related to 12 hour fasting.... Which made so much magic with my IT husband and my family as a whole..... Our total family including my brother's family also.... and i started sharing my magic experience with as many friends as possible.... Thanks for ur wonders❤
Thank you so much for this knowledge sharing 🙏🙏
Dr Pal, please come to London as well sir. Thank you so much for educating us about myths of soya.
Dr. Pal, your video about soy was excellent! I suggest looking into soya chunks too. They pack about 52g of protein per 100g, more than chicken breast, which usually has around 31g of protein. Soya chunks not only equal but also surpass chicken breast in protein content. Moreover, they are low in fat, high in fiber, and loaded with essential nutrients. Comparing soya chunks directly to chicken breast could give viewers a better view of different protein sources. Good job on sharing such informative content, Dr. Pal!
Hello Dr. Pal!
Thank you so much for the clarification on soy intake. I have been keeping soy products at minimum level due to all of the above mentioned reasons. Feels like missed on the rich benefits all these years😮. I would like to request your opinion on multigrain breads. Is our gut not tuned to digesting too many grains at one time? Looking forward to see your next video soon. Thank you again !
Thank you so much Dr. Pal, very informative video. My Question is what about using soya sauces, in our foods,as I have hypothyroidism.Thank you.
❤ excellent message doctor
First time bought Tofu sir, and got ur video in notifications... really useful one. I'm a thyroid patient sir . I thought of cooking for my children. .now after this video I will happyily have my tofu...thank u sir.
Glad to hear from you about soy. Thanks for this video sir.
One request, can you please make a video about herbal life products please
So many different opinions and so many methods, yet for most normal humans it is so challenging to stay trim among tempting processed foods and food centric social culture. Supplements, potions, programs, products, fads, diets, you name it.. Well.. if you find something that works for you, and it's sustainable - then go for it!
We are learning soooooooo much from you Doc . 🙏🙏
Excellent video!! Thanks so much for clarifying things about soya - now I can eat required amount of protein!! God bless you! 🙏
Your explanation is clear 🎉
Thank you sir for this video 🙏🏻🌺
Thank you for the video..very helpful..i want to know Is it good for piles patients?
Thanks palaniappa... for clarifying soy myths
Doctor, I can't thank you enough 🙏
Most people eat soy for the protein and if I want 50g of protein I will have to eat 98.6mg of isoflavones which will destroy my testosterone, even if I decide to take 25g of protein from soy, that is still 44.3mg of isoflavones.
So, in conclusion, if you are a male who does not want his testosterone to plummet, avoid soy at all cost.
Of course, their is more to the story and I can explain further if someone asks for it.
Hi Doc,
I was confused too of the facts on Hypothyrodism. I do take Levothyroxine 25mg, and make sure I have my soy products for lunch or dinner. I have stopped using soy milk as I was a bit sceptical on it. I use oats/almond milk now. Many many thanks for your efforts sir and we are extremely thankful for the amount of knowledge you share with us.+