Beethoven Sonata #29 Op. 106 "Hammerklavier" Valentina Lisitsa
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 พ.ค. 2024
- 1. 00:00 Allegro
2. 10:37 Scherzo: Assai vivace
3. 13:12 Adagio sostenuto
4. 28:58 Introduzione: Largo... Allegro - Fuga: Allegro risoluto
Hello all. This is the original complete recording of the Sonata the way it was meant to be. Back in those days there was a 10 minutes file limit and therefore I had to split performance in 5 parts. Playlist does not work in the opposite way and there are hundreds of channels that stole my recording and rebroadcast it in full. So I should post it the way it was meant originally. Enjoy! I think when performed complete the concept of the performance is different. - เพลง
Thank you for playing my piece.
I'm sorry you couldn't listen it. It was really great.
@@saidtoshimaru1832 ouch
I prefer For Elise 😑
@@scottripley5764 😳😧
@@saidtoshimaru1832 Especially fugue. It's simply sublime.
She could easily defeat thanos
Ikr, she'll just snap and boom, thanos ceases to exist
@@Trooman20 believe it
Thanos is too weak. Maybe Shaggy is a better option; and even still it wont be enough
I don't see how that's relevant.
Why?
It’s weird to think that Beethoven and Liszt were the first 2 people to ever play this piece, but now we have dozens of recordings we can listen to at our leisure
Beethoven never played this. Publicly at least. Also, he was very deaf by the time he wrote this so I doubt Beethoven would be able to play it at all. Most likely in his head though
Back in those days I imagine you would have been very lucky or very rich to hear it played
@@lolsup9817 he could probably play it part, definitely not in full, and probably not with technical ease like modern pianists. Even still I wish I could hear Beethoven play even 1 measure of this!
@@ryanguerra2024 of course. The only problem with Beethovens music is that he himself requires a very sophisticated sense of touch. Even Beethoven himself admitted he stopped performing because he couldn’t tell how his musicality was and found that he played way too forte. This is probably why Beethoven embraced using percussion much more in his mid to late years. Wonderfully enough giving his unique style. Also his use of the highest and lowest registers of the piano probably being due to his deafness and range of hearing as well. I did a project on his deafness recently so this is how I know this
@@lolsup9817 Of course Beethoven could play it. He wrote it. I don't see a reason why he wouldn't be able to play his own composition or any other composition for that matter. Maybe not publicly though.
Beethoven: No one can play my piece for the next 100 years
Liszt: Am I a joke to you?
It has been awhile
I would love to hear Liszts and Clara Schumanns interpretation of this work. Lisitsa in any case plays it great.
LOL
50 years *
Lasse Hüllsiek oh ok thanks
Valentina, you must have some extraordinary memory to memorize all the repertoire.
Yes, Valentina has photographic memory: about 6k she knows by heart!!!!
This is one of the most common pianist problems. I need like 2 months to memorize large pieces while grand pianists learn them in a week...
@@nikolainikolaichev Wow. Think about it. In the time frame that it takes you to memorize 6 large pieces, she learns 52. Impossible to compete! Lol
@@Numberonesorabjifan Sorry it was a bad french translation, should be like "known pianists" or "famous pianists"
@@nikolainikolaichev maybe you can practise every day and always 'sing in your heart' with shaped phrases, also try use your fingers' muscle memories. hope this piece of advice helps!!
You can feel the desperation for making every note louder. You can feel the sadness, depression and the anger.
Beethoven hammering on the piano so he could listen to his own work, in a depressive period of his life where he thought he needed to listen to the notes.
So sad, so inspiring, so beautiful
yes it's just heartwrenching! your comment made me burst into tears. but i love that he also threw in a few hilarious sort of f-yous, like the fugue theme in the 4th movement which would make monty python and lenny bruce both fall to their knees in admiration, and my favorite--i don't even know what to call that part at 12:10? 'wait, i have to untangle my fingers'? 'whoa, where was i, i was getting carried away, arrgghh, have to clear my mind and get back to the themes'? 'I've had it with you piano fortes who can't produce a big enough sound, i'm just going to pound for a couple of seconds before I get back to the piece!'? 'grrrrrr, i need to hear SOMETHING'?
You Know that this is not the reason that this sonata is called Hammerklavier, don't you?
@Konstantin Ridaya exactly. You are completely right. Even because this piece has more pianissimo than fortissimo.
This sonata (Opus 106) along with the preceding sonata (Opus 101) were both titled for the "Grosse HAMMERKLAVIER" indicating that they were not to played on harpsichord, but on the pianoforte, or hammerklavier in German.
@@joanwendt2028 😂😂😂
the great tragedy of any artist is to never know what your art means for people of the future. I'm sure with all the recognition Beethoven got, he'd never imagine he'd be considered one of the top composers of all time and probably the most Famous (maybe Mozart). and yet, he had died, his body has turned to nothing and the worms have eaten his flesh, and yet he lives on, i can feel him now, and its glorious. what a mind. what an artist.
I Agree
Really? Died and worms ate his flesh... that had to be said? Jeez.. way to make a point 🤨💭
K
Beautifully said. I felt that.
Colin Weiss I think he is the greatest artist, regardless of the medium, off all time
Hello from Poland... The tempo is blindingly fast. The touch is delicate, but fierce. She hammers at the keys, but never too hard. The utter balance of her playing style lends itself to Beethoven’s works so very well. They demand so many different emotions, and she is able to bring them all out when she needs to, and then in the next breath is able to delicately play the lightest of musics...but where she truly excels is when she has free reign to play as fast and as powerfully as she can get away with, and then the true zest for the music comes out. I am so glad I live in an age where I can just watch a world class pianist perform a legendary piece of music instantly...as many times as I like...at any time I like...truly we should all take a moment to be grateful for the lives we live.
Прекрасно сказано!
Абсолютно с вами согласна!
Somehow it does make the rental for the internet time seem trivial. My piano studies would have been greatly stimulated were this glorious wonder been available in the 1950's.
*The Hammerklavier sonata, is well known for being one of the most complicated technically, also lasts approximately 40 minutes, the interpretation of Valentina, it is simply great*
*La sonata Hammerklavier, es bien conocida por ser una de las más complicadas a nivel técnico, además dura aproximadamente 40 minutos, la interpretación de Valentina, simplemente es genial*
*La sonata Hammerklavier, è ben nota per essere una delle più complicate tecnicamente, dura anche circa 40 minuti, l'interpretazione di Valentina, è semplicemente fantastica*
Also in italian? Wow! It's quite rare to see someone on internet that writes in italian! I'm so happy, because finally I found someone that writes also in my language!
Thank you! Grazie
In german: Die Hammerklavier Sonate ist sehr dafür bekannt eine der am technischsten schwierigsten zu sein, und dauert 40 Minuten. Valentinas Interpretation ist einfach nur gut (genial).
@@stefamart7 google translate
@@theartgoose ist 40 Minuten Lang und technisch am schwierigsten
It's meant to last for only about 30 minutes. But that tempo is ridiculously hard, especially for the 1st and 4th movement, so hard in fact that I don't think it's even possible to play the piece at that tempo.
oh boy, looks like my night's lasting about 39 and a half minutes longer lmao
I have collected the Beethoven's sonatas since late 90s and by now I might have these for over 400 performers, bigger part of them playing the complete cycle. The 'Hammerklavier' is my personal favourite for many reasons. I can say for sure that the first time I heard Lisitsa's playing the Hammerklavier, I listened to that many times in a row and I found that steadiness, bravery and expression I've never heard before. I'm pretty sure that this one of the best performances of Hammerklavier I've ever heard.
I’m in complete agreement, and I’m loving that I’m seeing other comments like this confirming that they too believe this to be the greatest performance of this piece ever. It’s astonishing when played at this level of clarity and tempo and dynamics. I’m amazed by her talent.
omg i thought i was the biggest beethoven piano sonata nerd with about 30 complete sets and the hammerklavier being the most obsessive! you are my idol! I agree that this is one of the best recordings. which other ones do you find amazing and powerful?
@@joanwendt2028 Being passionate about something doesn't make you a nerd
i think the only one to have a chance to compete with this is gilels
the recordings are both absolutely amazing
very nicely put and largely (imo) true
It's more a symphony for piano solo rather than a sonata. Amazing.
@@ValentinaLisitsaQOR And your interpretation is simply breathtaking! Thank you for sharing!
She is among the greatest.. but let's imagine what Beethoven had in mind when composing this incredible piece of music, where each note is a masterpiece, the Everest being the 3rd movement, which I can't hear without tears.
It's taken me 72 years more or less but I've finally fallen in love with Opus 106. And what a performance! The scales have fallen from my eyes. (And the trills they rattle my brain.)
I was skeptical but there are 'famous' recordings that this is better than.
I can’t get over how loose your hands look! I want my hand to be that relaxed. I can’t only imagine how it feels to play with such fluidity and liberty.
@Konstantin Ridaya I'm all too familiar with the 'orange' analogy; never really thought about it that way though.
Do the Taubman approach
There solved the problem for ya
Her voicing and fluidity is incredible. The effortless, relaxed demeanor is how it should look if one has mastered whatever piece is being performed. If one looks strained, it is a sign they did not take adequate time to really know how each note sounds and feels. I struggle with this in my own playing. I have only come close to such a demeanor in a few pieces, none of which were nearly as difficult as Beethoven's 29.
indeed
@Konstantin Ridaya Its cuz we asians have smaller hands😭
This woman is a gift from God,,,,
I get shivers from the way she shapes some of those lines.
The definitive Hammerklavier
music from another world
Valentina Lisitsa is the greatest pianist I have ever heard in all my 71 years. And in addition, she is a beautiful woman. And I have heard most of the great pianists of the 20th and 21st centuries. Even including Rubinstein, Horowitz, and so many others. I have never ever heard anyone who plays Beethoven like she does!!
17:47 checking the cameras still running, I've been there!
😂😂😂
She is the greatest. The way she navigates around the keyboard is inspiring, to say the least.
Her fugue absolutely astounding. My goodness.
If my piano teacher had lived to witness the Internet and TH-cam, she probably would have told me to turn the sound off and just watch her hands for at least one rendition. They are just spectacular, and overall Valentina is a joy to just watch her perform, let alone hear. This was awesome.
I know that is exactly what my teacher would say too! Amazing connection between the keys, the hands, and the player!
A performance for the ages of an ageless masterpiece. Thank you, Beethoven. And thank you, Valentina.
Валентина! Вы восхитительны! Огромное спасибо за ваше исполнение , качество съемки и звук!
Fantastic performance, but what I can't get over is the technical side of this, especially for the 1st and 4th movements, its just unbelievable how consistent and how accurate each note is
Просто улетела..душа успокоилась.. Божественно! Благодарю, Валентина 🧚🏻♀️💐
One of the many things I can't forgive this pandemic for is delaying my opportunity to listen to this sonata played by you a second time. You have displayed such spectacular improvement in all the sonatas you had already played before, which leads me to believe your Hammerklavier will be even greater yet. Words cannot describe how much I long to hear it!
13:28 is heartbreaking passionately just Beethoven‘s soul into the piano.
If there was room just for a single piano work, it should be the Hammerklavier.
Beethoven actually talks with God.
And Valentina plays out of this world... thank you!
Mesmerising performance. The quality of the sound is perfect, I couldn’t wish for more. Thank you Valentina for that pleasure and experience❤
The first time I watched this video long ago, I was only familiar with the first movement. I instantly loved the third movement; it is so beautiful. But the fourth movement made no sense. ‘What on earth are you doing, Beethoven? This is terrible!’ I thought. But since I loved the rest of the sonata, I also listened to the fourth movement several times, and then suddenly I understood it: It’s Bach, Extended Version! Now I actually listen to the fourth movement over and over. It’s like it opened up a new place in my brain. Wonderful performance, too!
Thanks for sharing, I love Beethoven (and you).
Thank you.
@@ludwigvanbeethoven926 thank you for your compositions...can you give me personal tuitions
@@ludwigvanbeethoven926 you're okay. Not too easy on the eyes.
Simp
Valentina, si Beethoven escuchara su sonata ejecutada con una técnica elevada, la impronta que le da tu personalidad, se sentiría orgulloso y seguramente te abrazaría. Una manifestación de arte sublime.-
Ein geniales Werk, das ab und zu an Wahnsinn grenzt mit der utopisch schöner Melodie, die das Chaos durchbricht, gespielt
von einer fantastischen Pianistin. Alle Hochachtung und Dank für ihr einfühlsames Spiel.
*You are great! I realy love your plaing. After watch your Hungarian Rhapsodies I after only 4 years of playing practice Hungarian Rhapsody no.2. I'm 14 years old and not bad playing this Rhapsody. Thanks you for this. Never Stop Playing! Greetings from Poland for the greatest pianist in the world ❤*
lol, I'm 15 and I can barely play Pathetique second movement.
Great Job!
Your play is so amazingly convincing. This sonata gives much more meaning to me when I listen to your recording here. ❤
Desde el minuto 19:50 empieza mi parte favorita de toda la pieza, al escucharla me sorprendo a mi mismo ahogado, me transmite no solo delicadeza y belleza, sino tambien melancolia y un profundo sentido de perdida.
Tambien te agradezco mucho haber subido toda la pieza en un solo video, ya he visto tus videos fragmentados de esta pieza al menos 300 veces desde hace varios años jeje
pienso igual, cada vez que la escucho siento que es la única música muestra la humanidad en todo su esplendor, sin ninguna intención, sino solo expresión. Pero más me gusta la versión de richter o de baremboim ya que el es bueno para las secciones lentas y richter es bueno en todo. Al fin el vídeo completo, ya van años que lo esperaba XD
Tal cual, es mi parte favorita de la pieza también, es una delicadeza inexplicablemente dulce y fantasiosa.
Valentina this just makes me soooooo very Happy & Thankful to be on your mailing-list 🎉🎊🙌
and of course thank-you again 🙏🏻💖
28:09 Thank you Valentina for adding the B0 to the moment of greatest despair in this piece.
So hauntingly beautiful. I listen to this recording over and over. Thank you for all of the hard work you put into perfecting every last note of this performance.
Valentina, your interpretation of this masterpiece has a deep poetic brilliance to it. The 1st movement’s massive landscape, you play with nuance and passion; the 2nd movement lilting lightness, yet still poignancy, and the 3rd, I found myself moved to tears, heartbreaking beauty and tragedy of the Adagio. The final prodigious intensity of the fugue, it is as if you were guided by Beethoven himself. You are truly the best of our times. ❤️
This isn't easy music -even for the listener (and understatement for sure) but having listened now to a number of great interpretations -Ashkenazy, Schiff, even the ponderous half-speed interpretations of Gould -and slower, I think this may just be the best. Valentina really seems to get to the heart of this often inaccessible masterwork. Beethoven truly poured his heart and soul and supreme musical intelect into this music, but never intended to give his audience an easy ride!!!
Valentina videos are the best things you can find on you tube!
This is one of the two or three greatest performances of this gigantic work I have ever heard! Bravissima!!!!
OMGOSH, that was magnificent Valentina!! Your interpretations always seem to be just what the composer wanted, in my opinion. Bravo!! 👏🎹
This is good indeed. After hearing this wonderful sonata many times by various pianists this remains fresh and clear. All surely would like to hear Franz Liszt's performance of the sonata about eighteen years after it was written and nine years after Beethovens death. There were not many pianists who would play it.
Amazing Valentina! Love how you're giving more and more emotion through your body movement
Valentina, OMG, Beethoven is listening carefully to his interpretations. Not just his music, but everyone else's. Congratulations on your wonderful work and for sharing.
Thank you for this. Amazing, as always.
Her fingers are like ballerinas on toe across the stage. Paradise!
That performance of the Adagio is sublime. A brief trip to heaven to hear the music of the gods.
If there is a better performance of this complex piece, I've not yet heard it. Many bravos and much thanks for your gift that you've developed with great dedication. Valentina, you are a master and an inspiration.
I can't tell you how happy this piece makes me. If I could have it looping endlessly in the background of my life, I would. Bravo - marvelous interpretation.
One of the best performances of this well-nigh impossible work you are likely to hear. Brava.
What an accomplishment ❤️❤️the amount of work and practice to get to this level, just so admirable! Amazing Valentina ♥️!
This is the Best of the Best version of "Hammerklavier" I ever heard, and saved to Watch it later.
My God Valentina, you take my breath away!
wow the introduction to the last movement for once really does sound like an improvisation. i have never heard the passage after the trills in the bass played that way before. such an impressive performance as usual Ms Lisitsa.
this adagio is everything to me
This is just fantastic playing from a great artist. Thank you, Valentina
Your hands like your music, are ageless! Thank you so much!
Fabulous performance. With all the fire and strength it was meant to have. Thank you!
Thank Valentina, for give us this whole pièce .❤
Проникновенно, как всегда, спасибо!
Valentina Lisitsa😊 beautiful playing！！
Simply grandiose! Memory of fingers, movement and soul...
Extraordinary rendition. I like the ballsy tempo and the energy a lot. Also the sound quality is excellent.
THIS CAN ONLY BE THE DEFINITIVE INTERPRETATION
I AM OVERWHELMED VALENTINA
AND NO DRAMATICS, NO EXCRUCIATING GRIMACES, JUST FOCUS CONCENTRATION, SHEER BRILLIANCE
AND THE HEAVENS OPEN BRIEFLY BUT MEMORABLY
I discovered VL about a decade ago. She frightens me with her brilliance. Beethoven frightens me with his genius. I listen to his work and wonder how such creations are even possible. It's disturbing and exhilarating.
Beethoven was not a normal person. Amazing masterpiece.
13:00 That section is so powerful!
This is so amazing and wonderful. A sublime performance of an extremely difficult work.
Wooow
I've read the whole 593 comments and we are still on the first movement!
My eyes are tired and Valentina's fingers still look so fresh.
My deepest respect.
Bravo Valentina. Thank you!
I have been a massive fan or hers for many years and I am still amazed at how easy she makes these very complicated and beautiful pieces look.
Genio absoluto Beethoven por crear esta maravilla y usted por poder interpretarla tan maravillosamente que parece fácil aunque todos sabemos que NO lo es. Saludos desde Argentina.
Wow! Beautiful hands that are strong and supple. This is real quality. Superb opening sets the bar high and strong line right through the piece to the epic finish -so helpful for listeners like me. The connoisseurs rate Solomon Cutner's 1956 recording of this piece very highly, and I think Valentina Lisitsa is at those heights of achievement. Thank you so much for sharing this recording which I hope to watch for years to come.
absolutely breathtaking ❤
Absolutely brilliant and beautiful! 👏👏👏👏
Dear Valentina, God has given you your photographic memory and your divine given gift of playing piano with so much emotion! You don't just play, you become the piece. You draw us into your music.
Your mighty fingers, like you said in an interview, mighty black stallion - left hand - and mighty white horse, right hand... are amazing. Timing, tempo, from soft pauses to great cadences to full out runs... you are using His gifts - you are definitely not competing for a medal, as you said in an interview, but you're using your beautiful imagination connected with inspired music... to display God's love for you!
You are truly one of the most talented artists I've ever heard. Thank you so much for recording these on You Tube so we can hear.
May God continue to bless you and your family in every way. Thank you Jesus!
Absolutely stunning, once again!
Hello Parabéns belíssimo seu canal 🌷 obrigada por compartilhar lindos vídeos 👍 super
Saudações 🇧🇷 🎧 💖 beijos com carinho 😘 Love
This shall be played during our 2-week vacation, a *RELAXATION* moment, As a 24/7 playback in our head 👏👏
amazing performance. the 3rd movement is almost literally mesmerizing. wow.
Simple, precise, noble - great performance
Great, thanks for it.
Thank you Valentina!
Valentina, I love this beautiful performance 👏👏. Thank you dear for sharing ☺️❤🌹🌹
Such an extraordinary slow movement. I get the feeling that Beethoven could have gone on exploring it for ever....
Marvelous. Hats off Valentina Lisitsa .
This sonata is so beautiful and your intrerpretetion is amazing
Thanks for playing like you play
I got to know Valentina some years ago via TH-cam and since then she is by far the best pianist I have ever heard... I am not an expert at all but there is feeling in every single key she touches... Amazing! 🇧🇷❤️
I've heard this sonata performed by many of the best pianists in the world, but no one has ever reached the level you have reached Valentina.
The music master always talks to me and he says: that's exactly what I composed. Congratulation. great. Not even Daniel B. played so well.
No one can play so good!
Man you wrote the exact words I was thinking! Not even Daniel Barenboim has reached this level. Valentina has just performed the greatest performance of this piece I’ve ever heard, and it’s shocking how far ahead she is from all the greats!
@@JcFiscus42 I prefer Barenboim. He plays it slower, but better. I would love to hear him play on his custom Barenboim piano.
@@yannaischrire7327 I tend to agree with you, too. Daniel B is something special
@@JcFiscus42 have you heard Sviatoslav Richter -
Thank you, Valentina!
La Divina Valentina!!! She's Just PERFECT!!!
al fin lo publico completo, esto alegró mi día inmensamente
You're brilliant. Thank you for sharing.
Валентина, спасибо большое Вам за Ваше творчество!