Gravitas Plus: The genesis of Kashmir issue | Palki Sharma Live | India | Jammu And Kashmir
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 พ.ค. 2024
- Is Kashmir a dispute of India's own making? How did a region that lawfully acceded to India become a pawn in the hands of world powers? On Gravitas Plus, Palki Sharma deconstructs the genesis of the Kashmir saga.
#GravitasPlus #JammuKashmir #PalkiSharmaLive
About Channel:
WION -The World is One News, examines global issues with in-depth analysis. We provide much more than the news of the day. Our aim to empower people to explore their world. With our Global headquarters in New Delhi, we bring you news on the hour, by the hour. We deliver information that is not biased. We are journalists who are neutral to the core and non-partisan when it comes to the politics of the world. People are tired of biased reportage and we stand for a globalised united world. So for us the World is truly One.
Please keep discussions on this channel clean and respectful and refrain from using racist or sexist slurs as well as personal insults.
Subscribe to our channel at goo.gl/JfY3NI
Check out our website: www.wionews.com
Connect with us on our social media handles:
Facebook: / wionews
Twitter: / wionews
Follow us on Google News for latest updates
Zee News:- bit.ly/2Ac5G60
Zee Bussiness:- bit.ly/36vI2xa
DNA India:- bit.ly/2ZDuLRY
WION: bit.ly/3gnDb5J
Zee News Apps : bit.ly/ZeeNewsApps
These 10 minutes gave more clarity on kashmir issue; than thousands of hours of debates on television.
That's because WION is the news media we didn't have for 3 decades.
Also look at Christine Fair. She also gives an unbiased account on this issue.
Exactly. I wanted to make a project on Kashmir issue but there was no clarity on the happenings.
*10th century Kashmiri philosopher Abhinavagupta’s description of Kashmir:*
Where people normally are poetic and wise,
Where even warriors are articulate,
Women of cities are lustrous as the moon
And charming in their gait,
Where accomplished female practitioners of yoga are
Bright as the spark of fire
Particularly due to the complete opening
of the path of the _shushumna_ nerve in them
they are also lustrous as the sky
in the state of the lunar eclipse
Where the wine known as _madrika_
Brings maturity in the talk of love of lovers
In which part of the world people get engaged
Confidently and unobstructed in the fare of love
Where the Gods take interest
in remaining engaged in the delight of the chakras
and where departs the joy of life
and blessedness of liberation
where contemplative practitioners of yoga,
munis dwell at various spots
And where does Shiva dwell himself all the time.
I therefore consider Kashmir
As the proper place of yogic accomplishments _Siddhi_
there is no place on the whole of this earth
Which may compare with Kashmir in this respect
Nor in the respect of contentment
or fulfilment of all aspirations.
CONGRESS LEADERSHIP OF INDIA WAS A BLUNDER WHO HAD NO CAPABILITY TO HOLD A DIGNIFIED POSITION FOR LACK OF SELF -RESPECT AND GOVERNANCE !
Not in history: Osama Bin Laden was captured in Abbottabad, a town founded by the British and named after Major James Abbott in January 1853.. 👽
Wow was this before or after the partition. 😁👏😎
@Water Farmer Thanks.. 🙂
Pakshitstan hid Bin Laden. The biggest state sponsor of terrorism
So Bin Laden was in Pakistan all the time.
Palki Sharma, I always enjoy your detailed analyses of many issues, the Kashmir question being one of them. I grew up in Pakistan and always got a one sided opinion of what actually happened with the fate of Kashmir post partition. I lived through the India - Pakistan war of 1965, it was fought over Kashmir. I was only 9 years old, it was terribly traumatic. Once again, Ms. Sharma, thank you for your great insight, I continue to be impressed.
Very unique personality. If you blog, please your link.
@Noella Monteiro If you don't mind me being curious , Could you please phrase something that is told about kashmir in Pakistan
@@archana2744 it's extremely one sided like the commenter said. India is always painter as an evil force who want to "steal" Kashmir and only want harm in Kashmir. Pakistanis always talk about freedom of Kashmir but the ironic part is that freedom for them means Kashmir being part of Pakistan. I never understood this as a kid but now I'm growing older I'm starting to realize that every conflict has two sides and it's extremely complicated and you can't just pick a side just like that.
Literally look up Kashmir Pakistani songs. The things we are told are almost funny. We are never told about how Pakistan negatively effects Kashmir.
@@8mycereal How is it possible to "steal" kashmir when it is already ours?
@@8mycereal How is it possible to "steal" kashmir when it is already ours?
Two Biggest mistakes of our country:
1. Neharu: First PM
2. Gandhi: Father of nation
No one can be perfect... he thought sheik abdulla was his friend (and the only mistake is that he let friendship have some influence on politics) ... he doesn't have mind reading powers to know exactly about shiek ... its a natural human error ... he is in no way notorious... and these cannot come in the way of his contribution to the freedom movement
And you seem to like pointing fingers
I agreed with you Messi leo! Well said about mistakes of india
@@sheebagr9702 he also thought the same way about Jinnah and then china but never thought that way about Mountbatten 😂
well the "father of nation" title was given by our very own dearly SC bose
@@sheebagr9702 perfect?
They were even Curse for India.
Why is it that a Muslim can openly and freely demand a Muslim nation and any deceit, game, politics is OK for them, but they cry foul when others (Hindus) want the same? The bigger irony is that the world accepts and helps them.
Because we Hindus are minority in this Islamic, christian world and both want to occupy or convert India into their respective religions and are though the they are at each others' throat, united against Hindus.
@@subbaraotanguturu9271 to be strong on our feet ,to keep this hold of our culture and traditions, the real history should be taught in schools,the textbooks must be replaced with the real history Of India.
India should learn from china when it comes to these things
@@ami2000vi well said
Short answer Majority and Social psychology....
There is a whole thought due this. Hindus only exist in India and minorities in world. While Muslim are second most and christan being first in world. Thing is they have common law and practices, while Hindus don't...
We Hindu and east Asian keep Honor, respect, follow code. Even if they dont
This lady is great at teaching me the history of India. Thank you!
She speaks lies flawlessly
@@Syedmudasirandrabi Your are a liar
@@Syedmudasirandrabi oh, definitely you are not the one who should tell us that.😂
This is true. ....... Indian history is totally distorted according to the whims and fancy of nehru and company.... The development of a nation was ruined by a coterie.....
@@Syedmudasirandrabi yes she is but you Pakistani can't stop her
I watch Gravitas just because of Palki Sharma , her voice , clarity , briefness , command , confidence and her English in story telling , Superb🙏
We never miss Mrs Palki's post in WION on any topics she takes over. This Kashmir Issues post explicitly narrates complete history of Kashmir. Youngsters must watch it. Jai Hindh 🙏🙏
Gandhi and Nehru left Hindus without a country to protect them or their way of life
Is Nehru a liberandu... I need to know
@@angryanglocanadian7581
Nehru himself said he was a Hindu by mistake,, a Muslim by heart..
He cared more about Mountbatten than India..
@@ChairmanMaow so basically all of indias founders are liberandus
@@angryanglocanadian7581
Even Mau-laana Abul Kalam Azad,, the first education minister of India 🇮🇳,, attempted to whitewash Mugha| rule..
Those were horrific times…
Nehru clandestinely worked against Indian interest and for appeasement of the minority religion, as by heart he was one of its adherents and was an accidental Hindu , so he punished the Hindus
I am a Kashmiri and lost my great grandparents in the 1947 tribal attack on Kashmir.
Yes, certainly historical mistakes have a cascading effect. Because of the blunders of Nehru, we have suffered immensely since 1947. And since 1990 have been exiled from Kashmir !
I must appreciate your unbiased and knowledgeable presentation of the historical mistakes made by our country in Kashmir
What is your nationality?
@@antikamajumdar9586
What is the nationality of those people who were driven out of the Kashmir Valley because of terrorism in 1990 ?
Same is mine
@@humanbeing2947 don't worry we will strike back👊. Hopefully
@@antikamajumdar9586Thanks for your words, but this " Hopefully " word has turned into Hopelessness for us !
Sorry For Your Loss🙏
Hello, Palki ma'am,
Your undeterred determination, stoic demeanour, irrepressible rhetoric, and objective neutrality replete with fastidiously factual information, are pleasantly praiseworthy and ardently admirable. You have deservedly carved an uncompromising niche among the citizens as well as the diaspora who valiantly strive for unbiased and non-partisan coverage of geopolitical issues pervading the planet. You have rekindled our faith in not just journalism, but journalism which should be 'just and fair.'
Thank you.
Great use of words... each and every line of your comment is beautifully garlanded with words.
Gosh, this man is a walking dictionary
Our English teacher's expectations from our essay be like:
Shashi Tharoor here?
Palki Ji. All salutes to you for making things so much understandable. The vocabulary, the delivery, the content. Kudos to the team.
love how Palki said" an integral part of India" .... i watch lot of news channels worldwide... she is one of the best anchors worldwide in my opinion
It's not up to her to decide on Kashmir being the integral part of India, but the kashmiris, in line with the UN resolution to give kashmiris their right of self determination.
@Bedrock Blocks Your response has no relevance to the subject or my comments hence not mandating a response from me. Such emotional reactions are natural when u stand on baseless grounds and don't find any counter argument to defend them.
@Bedrock Blocks you really are adamant in starting a debate on another subject just because you couldn't refute my comments and reality shattered your false pretense of righteousness.
Fine, on the other subject, let me give you a short and decisive answer. Yes Pakistan is much better than India because it doesn't commit humanitarian crimes unlike India, who is responsible for state sponsored terrorism and human rights mutilation in Jammu & Kashmir, who elected a right winged Hindu fascist regime responsible for the brutal Muslim massacre in gujarat. Where religious discrimination is on the rise despite false pretense of modernism and democracy, where voices raised against the govt are silenced, social media accounts censored, where covid wreaked havoc and people died of oxygen shortages and we witnessed heart breaking tragedies O2 generators had to be flown in, inadequate supplies of medical grade oxygen resulted in black fungus pandemic adding to unimaginable sufferings, despite claims of being the largest vaccine producer, supplies went bust even for its own population, vaccine manufacturer fled the country fearing his safety.
In short, despite all your claims of advancement, life of a common Indian is still subject to poverty, lack of healthcare and social and economic inequalities. Where women are gangraped in buses, what else can one write or say, I content myself with what's been said.
Recalibrate your sense of achievements, humanity first and rest later.
@Bedrock Blocks I have to keep coming back to answer your comments, which is a sheer waste of time. This discussion is not going anywhere. Following are the conclusive points, I know you don't have a heart big enough to accept the truth, rather you attempt to escape answering it by picking up irrelevant subjects. This conclusive note is only for those who value the truth and have hearts open enough to embrace it.
1. You consistently avoided answering all arguments related to kashmir, the subject of this video, which in itself is the evidence that facts presented in my comments in contrast to what's been portrayed here are a reality that cannot be countered.
2. Revisit my earlier comments, you didn't answer many points and just focused on gujarat. Guess you couldn't come up with any answers.
3. You admit or not with regards to oxygen shortage, this very channel has been raising voice on the subject, just watch their previous videos. You can also find videos of foreign donated O2 generators landing at Indian airports.
3. As for gujarat, it needs further investigation, as the oppressed minority initiating attacks on the oppressive majority defies common sense.
4. Your biased and derogatory style of writing, speaks of no one else but you, grow out of your complexes and hatred towards Pakistan if you can, or live with it, your choice.
5. As for us, we don't hate Indians or Hindus, we ruled them for centuries and were kind to them even when they were our subjects. It's just the tyrant Conservative and intolerant mentality of certain extremist Hindu factions that we criticise, and rightly so. We will continue to take up a clear stance against all tyrants and oppressive regimes or groups regardless of where they originate from.
6. Last but not the least, instead of boasting about things and showing off, which demonstrates a need to improve and mature in character and intellect, try focusing on discovering the truth and appreciating it. Get some grip on things in your country and try to serve and improve the living standard of masses who are living below the line of poverty and suffering everyday under social, economic and healthcare disparities.
All the best.
@Bedrock Blocks As for your misconceptions regarding minorities in Pakistan, they fully enjoy their freedom and we cherish and protect them. Ask the Sikhs who visit Pakistan annually.
She is literally my favorite! Whenever I watch her episode I get excited! I am not Indian but thank you for awesome journalism! I wish the world peace
One sentence said Muhammad Ali jinnah to master Tara Singh. You people saw hundu under Muslims government more than 8 century 2century under British control now you will see real face ☺ of hundu what they will with monarity in India and that example in 1984,
Hey Pamela..Need to know more of Indian history?? I could help!!!
Biased. One simple example of biasness can be seen when she said military of India was superior to Pakistan's in 1947. Not completely true. Pakistan had the same British trained army, and both countries were poor. Even the 1965 was was inconclusive and India had to do a pact in Tashkent. It was only by 1970s that India was more confident, that too with the help of international diplomacy for genocide and Mukti Bahini.
@@grapeshott You get beaten up from day 1. And you still think your army was superior lol. By the end of every conflict India was always on dominant position. Indian army had always been superior. It was Nehru who dismantled Indian army because for the fear of coup that resulted in India's defeat in 62 with China and that too because of weak leadership despite India having air superiority at that time and china having none. Indian army was always superior tactically to Pakistan.
@@mukhtarb6737 rehne de beta, tumhara itihaas hi khooni hai😏
Excellent Palki! No one told me the problem of Kashmir in such simple and clear words. Hats off to you!!
First time I understand what was happened to Kashmir... well explained... hope every indian should know this history.
In the 1920's Jinnah was appeased by Nehru he took part of our country...in 1940's Nehru appeased Sheikh Abdullah resulting in India losing POK...1950's Nehru appeased Mao and we lost Aksai Chin. Why do we still celebrate Nehru again??
Because he loved Children and Making them with Edwina Mountbatten 🙂
Manoj make you right but in 1947 , Nehru ji had the right credential to negotiate with British then after the Independence the Indian citizens fell into loyalty mode and Nehru's dynasty could do no wrong and rest is History.
Top it off, Jinnah was born and raised a Shia Muslim who later converted to hardline Sunni Islam as an adult and his actions sure show as much that he aligned with Salafi/Wahhabi jihadist. No one should have trusted this deceitful scumbag the moment he got any power.
coz he cried to become 1st pm of India even though he got no votes
@@praveenvasistha247 🤣🤣😂
That is the kind of leaders you get when you get freedom without a fight , as a donation . Brits made sure that the true loyalty of future leaders of India should be for the Queen
Hard facts!
Gandhi was a double agent, he turned everyone into non violence and shit. After WW1 began , British were becoming weak, they feared wide spread massacres and rebellions. Hence Gandhi ! He reaching here exactly after WW 1 began says a lot. Just look at dates.
Why was he not here for his country before that? Why come with peace bs, when enemy is in weakest position
( and fighting for British in WW was our duty, according to him.... his form of non violence!. ..hypocrite)
@@Dhksksjjsjjs How he completely ignored the Bengal Famine
@@user-ty1ul4ug6x More Indians died than even Chinese who faced worst stuff at the hand of Japanese
More Indians died than entire Europe ( if you exclude Russia) majority of whom had war at their home.
This was not even our war, still !
Then over and above this we have unaccounted and famine deaths etc
@@Dhksksjjsjjs atleast 10-15 crores and these are british figures (not very reliable)
@@Dhksksjjsjjs horrible
You have put it together so well so every one can understand the history and the kashmir problem. 👌👌👌
One of the greatest reporter of India..Pl.keep doing it..Hats off..Ms palki Sharma..
Making india secular was a good move but any community who is above 5% shouldn't be given a minority status , also india should have included UCC when partition was made.
Yes
Our Mi Lords are not allowing discussion on minority definition, recently the secular Kerala High court imposed 20 K for filing petition to define minority percentage in the state
Then, Muslims be given equality in every sphere of politics, governance, institutions and jobs and economy without marginalization and discrimination. When minorities succeed, India succeeds. When minorities fail, India fails - domestically and internationally.
The makers of the constitution should be dealt with the Muslim right like they dealt with the Hindu right. For some reason, maybe fear, they turned a blind eye on the Muslim right. The citizens of this country are laying the price for it to this day.
India never had the need to be secular, that was for the theocracies in Europe who were ruling the roost! India was always a ‘pleural’ society and was feudalistic as it was with many other parts of the world! So, secularism is a misnomer in Indian context and not a part of the constitution until Mrs Gandhi meddled with it under emergency powers!
Gandhiji's greatest Blunder was to select
Nehru as the Successor to the British.
Both Gandhi & Nehru were great individuals
but catastrophic for India as its leaders
He dint even win the 1st election it was sadar patel who won the 1st election indias first scam also done by nehru
@@barbarik3797 yes,you are correct.
It was the greatest blunders of history to choose Neheru as Prime minister of India .
But what to do Mahatma Gandhi had like Neheru because of his oiling nature .
Saradara Ballava Bhai Patel was the right person for Prime minister post .
Raj Gopalchari the first Viceroy of India said to Mahatma Gandhi that Pandit Neheru was not beffiting candidate for Prime minister of Independence of India . He was very weak mentality person . He was absolutely idiot character . He was childish nature and lack of political sagacity .
Patel was the right person . He knew how to handle Sikha Abdullah and Muslim league and Pakistan .and King of the state and Muslim peoples Jammu Kashmir state
The Genesis is not correct word .the
D.N.A of Kashmir issue is right word or misconception of Jammu and Kashmir or Sabotage of Jammu and Kashmir or historical blunders of Jammu Kashmir state .
@@ajitpani2113 Sardar Patel was extremely sick, could barely walk during last 2 years of his life and he passed away within 3 years of independence.
@@anu9658 yes true that !
These were never thought in any of our history books..they have changed the facts and made every one believes what in books which they published .Thank you mam.
She explains it so well... Without being emotional and sticking to the point 🌟
Sardar Patel would have dealt with Sheikh Abdullah the way he dealt with Hyderabad Nizam. Patel didnt like Nehru taking the Kashmir issue to UN.
Somewhere i heard that Shaik abdulla is actually Nehru's Step Brother .. He was Nehru's Fathers Keep's heir and hence he called him "Blood Brother" ... No idiot would have taken the matter to UN
This is true 200 percent . the history would have different story on Indian point of view . Raman chrakrabati
@@ajitpani2113 My elder brother told me that Nehru was away when the Pak proxy army moved in to capture Srinagar. Deputy PM Sardar Patel was asked to take a decision and he immediately landed the troops there and he who saved Kashmir. Patel instructed the army to recapture the entire Kashmir. But Nehru rushed back and stopped the army. When the Congressmen asked Patel what happened. A furious Patel told them to talk to the Pandit.
@@WhoamItoyouu
This is absolutely true what your brother say .he is your elder brother
he knew many things of history .
@@praveenvasistha247 his ancestor were Saraswat Brahmins
*She did not even mention the biggest point in this issue* : The ethnic cleansing of minority community of Hindus of Kashmir (Kashmiri Pandits) in 1990s done by majority of Kashmir (Muslims) in Rwanda style.
How about the ethnic cleansing of majority community of muslims of jammu region in 1947 done by minority of Jammu (Hindus) in rawanda style??
@@MyKhansaab and did that happened in your madarsa , 🤦🏽♀️🤦🏽♀️
She has not covered that part because she is talking about history. this happened much later
@@MyKhansaab Never happened. Made up story.
@@arundhongde3176 She is talking about Kashmir and terrorism is maim issue there. All the terrorism started with ethnic cleansing against Kashmiri Pandits. This can not be avoided when talking about Kashmir.
Palki Sharma. you have won my heart.. Such beauty and eloquence and filled with information worth in GOLD. A GRAND SALUTE
Such a crisp and to the point presentation. PALKI has without doubt taken journalism to a different level. Her presentation skills are not only unbiased but straightforward. Wishing her good luck and looking forward for more.
today i came to know many hidden facts
NCERT books never mention these facts
India History post indepenance were written by COmmunist supporter
Yeah, it also praises brits, and apparently they know that Akbar's reign was the "golden age".We even had to make a project work on "The great Mughals".
9
why are @@MuzamilRashidWani these comments highlighted
Read old ncert
Gandhi did the first blunder by choosing nehru over sardar vallabh patel as the first pm, despite the fact that patel was recommended by the majority of the congress.
.... because Sardar Patel too was a Gujarati and Gandhi didn't want to do favour to another Gujju.
And also swami shraddhanand. Gandhi and nehru also killed and jailed lots of nationalists who were against their ideology. Mughals destroyed india, Brits looked india, And these people took away peace in india completely.
@@yashvi2048 about nehru, he set people to spy upon subhash chandra bose and his family. He was kind of convinced that netaji survived the crash & he didn't wanted to let the glory of independence go to anyone like sardar patel or netaji. But in fact he was super undeserving.
@@ramakrishnanpk9830 i dont know man gujjus stand for gujjus and clearly gandhi wasn't Gujju enough
Gandhi was a puppet of britishers, that's the reason, the ultimate fraudster
Love this broadcaster bring her back 😢😢😢😢
PALKI SHARMA IS NO DOUBT, ONE OF THE BEST NEWS ANCHOR AND JOURNALIST. RESPECT !!!!
To all the Americans and its Representatives in UN, Imagine if Alaska wanted to be an independent country now, irrespective if its sale to US, would US accept Alaska's decision to let them live independent now? (which already enjoyed the acquisition of Alaskan territory?) Would US betray its people living in Alaska?. Then why should we leave our brother Kashmir?
@赵杨利Yang lee Zhao which map ? Map in your Madrassa ?
@赵杨利Yang lee Zhao have you heard about a country called Taiwan.
Sai plz read how america fought a war for texas
US hypocritic on kashmir
Similarly, even the Brits won't allow North Ireland and Scotland break away from the United Kingdom. There are protests by people in N.Ireland that wants to go back being part of Ireland and not the UK.
Alaska is not a dispute territory and isn't divided into two countries so wrong comparison
The "Jodi of Nehru and Gandhi" was the worst thing happen to Indian in the last Century.
They sidelined Bheem Rao Ambedkar and Subhash Chandra Bose both were Gem to India
NEHRU loved kashmiri Roses always he was not bothered about others
Gandhi was a pseudo saint…….. period
@@rameshdesai4037 bro saying lie is not ok. Of you hate a person hate him but don't spread lies to defy him
Whatsoever happened we all really don't know the real circumstances they were in so to judge is easy dont really like congress but they are the leaders all of them ... Under their leadership only INDIA got its Independence and there's nothing greater than Freedon..JAI HIND... India has bright future...just don't lose the patriotism ever 🙏
@@sushminaha1409 under their leadership???? Then why did so many young lives had to be laid. Nehru gandhi were never under any threat to their lives by the British. Only those people lost their lives who actually fought for the independence and they are our only heroes and freedom fighters. At best these w two could only be a curse to the nation even after 70 years. Glorify them if you wish but do not thrust them upon us as our saviours
She is so lucid n strait in her narration makes the incidenses very photogenic .Her voice too is pleasing n enlightening .
That's why The Kashmir Files movie is a must watch.🇮🇳❤🥺
Kashmir belongs to Kashmiri Pandits not Madraschaps. 😉
@Afghan Taliban Zindabad🇦🇫 we will see😂
Thanks India for advertising kpl without any monetary benefit. Your sincere effort always be appreciated 😉
@Afghan Taliban Zindabad🇦🇫 do you remember the time when you had a whole country?
When your soldiers made a world record 😂
Stop barking
@Afghan Taliban Zindabad🇦🇫
India donated a consignment of 45 million COVID vaccines to Pakistan 🇵🇰,,
which has P|G GELATIN 😉
@Afghan Taliban Zindabad🇦🇫
But I’m sorry to tell you that Pakistan lost four wars against India,, all of which were launched by Pakistan..
India is too big to be ruled over.. and now that India 🇮🇳 is the 4th strongest Army.. it’s just invincible to beat India… and waging war against India 🇮🇳 amounts to marring yourself with a chainsaw….
The NCERT has left so much details..sad, that until we research we aren't taught small but major details to understand the topics better.
So true, they don't mention how the extermely socialistic system pretty much dragged the economy up to 1991 to the point of barely surviving and opening up because we had no choice. We should have opened up our economy in 70s. They also don't mention how the 5 year plan was a flop just like Mao's "Great Leap Forward".
I grew up studying NCERT and can clearly say it was a curriculum totally designed by Congress Politicians to keep children unaware of facts and real heroes of Indian civilisation and freedom struggle for decades in this country.
@@vasanthkrishna7809 they have glorified mughals in ancient history. they have not talked about a single thing about local rulers like cholas, vijayanagra empire etc..
in our kannada textbooks we had detail about vijayanagara empire. Atleast the local state board textbooks had something of the truth
@@abinavrooney8556 yeah in Maharashtra we had Great Shivajis history and that was best part of my school curriculum
if you still dependent on NCERT to form your opinions means you will leanr what a political part want to say and nothing more. there are so many historians to talk about and better books. but you just need to free from this bias that someone was good and other was to understand
Can't be expressed better than this in fewer words. Bravo!
Amazing ! Thank you for this 🙏
Mistakes were made, but we can overcome them, only if we stand together! Jai Hind.
rightly said brother jai hind
Mr. Muslim for your kind information hope you know who your ancestors were. You people got converted to Islam at sword point like how Persia means parsi who are hindu follwers agni followers in just short span of time got converted to Islam and like Indonesia who are Hindus who got converted to Islam at sword point. So mr. Muslim you and half of the world is not original Muslim. You are all converted people. Hope your Allah and maulvi tell you the truth...
Correct the mistakes of your ancestors. Ghar wapasi karo yahi solution hai.
@@beautifulbangladesh5838 By the way are you
SHIA , SUNNI OR AHAMADI ?
@Abhishek K Super True bro
I only belive that QURAN should be Baned or AT LEAST RE WRITTEN
For the sake of mankind
If the personal ambitions of the leader are greater than nation's welfare, then it is bound to doom the nation... Mahabharat already taught us that ages ago!
10th century Kashmiri philosopher Abhinavagupta’sthus described Kashmir:
Where people normally are poetic and wise,
Where even warriors are articulate,
Women of cities are lustrous as the moon
And charming in their gait,
Where accomplished female practitioners of yoga are
Bright as the spark of fire
Particularly due to the complete opening
of the path of the shushumna nerve in them
they are also lustrous as the sky
in the state of the lunar eclipse
Where the wine known as madrika
Brings maturity in the talk of love of lovers
In which part of the world people get engaged
Confidently and unobstructed in the fare of love
Where the Gods take interest
in remaining engaged in the delight of the chakras
and where departs the joy of life
and blessedness of liberation
where contemplative practitioners of yoga,
Munis dwell at various spots
And where does Shiva dwell himself all the time.
I therefore consider Kashmir
As the proper place of yogic accomplishments Siddhi
there is no place on the whole of this earth
Which may compare with Kashmir in this respect
Nor in the respect of contentment
or fulfilment of all aspirations.
Kashmir, Sri Lanka, Nepal, Bhutan, Aksai Chin and Maldives all rightfully belong to India and will inevitably be reincorporated into India.
Love and regards to all Indian patriots from Mexico!
Very well said and documented, without any fear of any political party or any communal organization. We need desperately such kind of news channels in India.
I wish that Sardar Patel would have handled the Kashmir issue
He was not interested in Kashmir, its Nehru who gave importance to Kashmir with India.
@@nabeeltc85 lol u idiot
Read history
If he wasn't interested in Kashmir, then why did he force to make article 370 a temporary one
Just because he wanted to add Kashmir completely n permanently to India
Patel was Farsighted, not like Nehru who created ever-lasting hindu muslim conflict in Kashmir.
@@babulidas5191 I think sardar Patel knew kashmir will cost India he agreed to swap other Muslim states in India for kashmir
@@babulidas5191 sardar patel was not interested he wanted to focus on hyderabad and other princely states but nehru wanted to annex the kashmir, finally patel agreed to it and joined nehru's appeal for kashmir
Sardar Patel wanted to handle Kashmir, but he was also involved in princely state of Hyderabad around that time. He had already liberated 550 princely states but Nehru being Nehru, didn't like giving Sardar Patel the due importance, so decided to bungle through J&K himself. Nehru only liked to surround himself with 'yes' men and never listened to a single counsel of Sardar Patel or even his cabinet. Nehru let China capture a part of Himalayas, allowed China to win the 1962 war by supplying Indian army with no weapons and pushed J&K issue to UN, despite strong opposition from Sardar Patel and his cabinet ministers. All of these facts can be verified.
I am right wing inclined, but one thing till date fascinates me how would have Subash Chandra Bose, Bhagat Singh if had come to power would deal with all such stuff, as they were hardcore Nationalists before being left wing Communists.
Telugu?
Shaheed Bhagat Singh was Marxist Leninists. Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose supported a democratic India.
@赵杨利Yang lee Zhao it's marked as disputed territory, which would be rectified initially on map and then completely in future but what about Taiwan, it won't ever be part of China and is already a country 😉
left and hardcore nationalist are contradictory words all over the world.
@@JosephStalin-io5fp Bro, our Reddy ji is an Indian first with his mother tongue of Telgu :)
Just a few words.....thanks a lot Ms Palki Sharma for bringing forth the clarity of the historical facts about Kashmir. Thank you wholeheartedly🙏
Impressed with your knowledge and analysis of prior conflicts and contraversies. Keep it up. Good job
But even before removing the article 360 from Kashmir, it was a legal part of India as per the agreement signed between it's king and Nehru. Still Pakistan was trying to take it away. Very strange.
Article 370
But will never succeed
@@riyashah7486 True
Well said
They claim on the basis of majority muslim population in kashmir
When selfish and characterless people become leaders, the country suffers. Because of one such leader, immediately after independence, the country is suffering even after 70 years.
@Hindu Kush if pathetic ppl were there.. Ofc ppl have to cry..
They are not selfish and characterless. They are what their ideology is. Usually a Hindu ideology is extremely nonchalant and doesnt take any threat seriously, resulting is mass exodus and extinction level massacres and disputes.
@@RAIRADIO Hindus are non - violent and tolerant ....and we have some secular and characterless leaders who ruled us for 70 yrs and ruined us ...n had the whole media in their pockets ...
Very aptly said
@@user-we8gi3xt5b leaders are a reflection of the masses in democracy. Nobody pops up out of the blue and starts ruling you.
She is the best anchor in the world .matchless .kudos
I had a lot of doubts regarding the Kashmir related issues but now all my doubts are cleared. Thank you, for this information 😍🤔
Wao. Great journalism. For first time, I got understand reasonably, the Kaahmir root of tears, sorrow, bitterness and deaths. Thank you from across the Atlantic coast.. Concise history indeed.
Nehru must have been wrongly quoted in Indian history. seems like he was the stupidest leader of all times in Indian politics.
No Nehru ji was one of most qualified to deal with the British , yes he did let his emotions get in his way and thus the blenders he has made in Kashmir, One always talks on the negative of a person when a situation get's out of hand and they forget all the right things he done, We see that even in todays world with Modi ji .
@@roshnivalder1394 Nehru was definitely the most Stupid person, a British stooge, the 1st Pappu of India.
Sahi pakde hai
@@thedroidbha The first pappu of India, well said 😂😂
He was a clearly a british stooge. All these years we have lost thousands of our brave soldiers and civilians because of a stupid decision of Nehru.
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️love this vocabulary from Pakistani under administration Jammu & kashmir,
Independent Jammu & kashmir 🤲🏻✌🏻
Knew it. Reheard it. You summarized it so eloquently. Hard hitting words. Abrogation and breaking it into two UTs required stealth leadership. God Bless…
Nehru was a naive highly emotional, sentimental man given to tobacco and alcohol. He resented the Iron Man of India. Sadar V.Patel. Destroyed Patel politically.
You forgot his addiction to young girls 😂😂😀😀😃😄
@Nostalgia for Infinity which he was .
Read.about how he ratted on INA and subhash chandra bose in singapore and swindled 50 kg of gold collected as contributions to INA by patriotic indians
Nehru was the original pappu Indira was his brother s daughter aaj ka pappu rahul
A Womanizer. How did you forget that!!
Very well said!!! Long live Sardar Patel. He saw Nehru's foolishness.
Question:
Once M population reaches 51% in India, will the country remain secular?
No way
If m population surpasses 50% , the country will break into parts.
@TMR Videos
One and only 👍🏻 that is yours only 😉
@TMR Videos
Agan one and only 👍🏻 that is yours keep it up .
@TMR Videos
@TMR Videos
Agan one and only 👍🏻 that is yours keep it up .
The question is will india exist after they reach 51%
Book on Nehru must be called-
"The Most Dumb Uneducated English Speaker Ever Existed "
Now i understand the true meaning of good journalism. Thanks to you miss sharma you make it easy to understand about this issue.
Nehru's role towards our nation is totally doubtful, no wonder he's getting more and more notorious with the influx of proper information.
Nehruvian socialism held India back. BR Shenoy should've been prime minister.
@@JK-gu3tl Vallabhai Patel or pretty much anyone. Socialism was necessary for the beginning as the Indian economy was weak and we couldn't let big companies exploit the poor. So not opening up the economy was good in the beginning but it should have opened up in the 70s just like China.
Indira's husband used to raise his voice against corruption in the Nehru govt.
He has created many problems but make no mistake, he laid out the foundation of modern India. Today we criticize him but we forget that we are nowhere as capable as he was.
@@notyourfriend-li7rq he gave us division and was so incompetent that he didn't even get us freedom, not laid any foundation of any modern India. He was just following his British masters order. There were more capable people but Nehru was the most greedy and wanted the PM post.
This video removed so many doubts and issues with the timeline I got with various "sources". Thanks TeamWION for this amazing 10 min info filled video!
Wion presents unbiased news!
Story teller did not mention arrest of prime minister of Kashmir Shaikh Abdullah by the orders of Indian prime minister Pandit Nehru. Shaikh Abdullah was kept inside jail for 10 and half years.
Why India has more than 800,000 regular military in Kashmir. Is not because of mistake made by Shaikh Abdullah for annexing Kashmir to India? It is but you would not accept. Kashmiris are in great trouble only because they are Muslims and do not want India military occupation. It is true but you would not accept.
@@MrWashraf 800,000 Regular Military in Kashmir ? You can't just quote numbers out of thin air mate. As for the military that is actually present there ( a force much smaller than what you just quoted )..., Ever heard of Pakistan ? It's a country right next to Kashmir that is now in the FATF grey list along with several other islamic nations. It's more of terrorist manufacturing site at this point though.
I fell in love with this journalist Palki Sharma way of presenting news.. She makes many points in a appropriate order and bring to connect them beautifully at the end to conclude the talk.. Hats off to her..
It's wrong WION you let go Palki like that, she is the reason we start seeing your channel
But the First Question here is Who’s Jinna and how could someone agree to split their own country just because one person demanded
Peaceful people demanded a separate country for themselves.
Jinnah was the governor of Pakistan. He was born and raised a Shia Muslim who later converted to hardline Sunni Islam and his actions sure show as much that he aligned with Salafi/Wahhabi jihadist. No one should have trusted this deceitful scumbag.
Well Jinnah was only given the leadership , but the idea was of every Muslim ( almost 95% ) who did vote for Muslim league in favour of partition prior to independence and British took this as a referendum & insisted partition as condition for independence.
Ah yeah the same Muslims of India who stayed back post partition did vote for partition actually . Once they got a separate nation they decided to stay back guess why .
@@preethishetty6179 They stayed back despite claiming their separate Islamic country becoz of "GAZWA-E-HIND" !
@@preethishetty6179 election under foreign occupation is no election, it was biased and not free and fair. It was not a referendum, and not all muslims were given a chance to vote. It was u der British occupation. So tell me how was it even fair, it wasn't even referendum.
So.... the Muslim's wanted a Muslim nation.... Their mentality is the same till date..... Good job by the Modi govt.
What is exactly wrong with that?
@Anurag Kumar Singh Wow!
@@kekecoo5681 after partition muslim got two nations what did we get........
@@kekecoo5681 if nothing is wrong with that muslims shouldn't cry about rise of Hindutva in India
@@kekecoo5681 nothing is wrong with that but then hindu should have hindu nation too. India was originally for Hindus only, Islam , Christianity etc came from outside so they should leave india and go to their respective countries where they came from. Nothing is wrong with living in islamic nation at all. In fact its more peaceful that way.
WoW. Such a clarity 👍🏻
You are so versatile Palki
Time you introduced us to your team members involved in research and writing
Every disaster, every tragedy starts with the accursed Nehru.
Chor nehru looted azad hind fauj treasure gathered by Netaji for india
We should start a new festival. Just like on deshehra we burn effigies raavan we should start doing the same for this idiotic pair of Gandhi and Nehru.
@@Priya-cm3tr nice idea
exactly he caused too many disasters - Kashmir conflict (1947- present) , adopting a socialist system , failures of the third five year plan and fourth five year plan and failure in the 1962 war , if Netaji had become the PM of india instead of that weak and corrupt old peice of sh*t , India would have already become a superpower instead of still being a "Rising superpower"
The chor is responsible for destroying India's industrial base through his license Raj policy.
Electronics was a no no. Need Licence for everything.
Very clear and informative. Support to India from Israel. The historical parallels are impressive! She was humble to not even mention that Pakistan is just an acronym with no historical backing. Like the word Palestine, which actually comes from the Hebrew word for "invaders".
Nice logics ....do mention if you have any for Israel's barbaric killing of innocent Kashmiris?
@@sabahatzahra7802 Israel "barbaric killing" of Kashmiris? Nice joke. The world is laughing at you.
Aahaa, thank you for telling Indian history in the spirit of the word.
Better news channel than rest of the Indian news channels… 👍🏽
hope journalism will remain alive in this channel…
Shameful of our 'so called great' leaders who put their appeasing politics over nation.Our leaders lacked foresight and wit which costs india generations and on.Whats the use of crying over spilt milk.Needless to say about the west.
kashmir issue did not start im 1947 it started in 1846 when british sold kashmir to gulab singh in south asia's biggest slave trade
They are all human like us they made their own mistakes which they regretted but you can't say that they put their own interests first, their sacrifices are too great for us to point out their mistakes
@@mayank.9203Yes but they have huge responsibility on them.There is a difference between us making mistakes and leaders that too at a nascent stage of partition.They should have thought.Because of those decisions Kashmiris are suffering.
@@versexx413 Yes they should have but they did not, we should accept this and work on how not to do such things in future rather than blaming them for things forever. We tend to overlook their good deeds just for a few mistakes which no one knew would turn out to be such huge matters and be problematic for decades to come .
All I say is that we can't just say that they did things for selfish gains afterall all they did was what they thought was best for the nation at the time. No one is always right but atleast they had nations best interests in mind
So what has changed ?, Congress Party still put their gains before the Country and Gandhi Dynasty has continued that path even now as we speak.
Why did Congress not do a total population exchange?
We've been asking the same
Because gandhi wanted to be seen as messiah , peace loving blah blah
If people choose to live in India and believe in the idea of India, then why should they leave? For them country was bigger than religion - isn't that patriotic? Sad to see comments like this
@Jio Boy those who are bringing gold medals or posted on borders are not the only one who are doing something for the country.
@@Miguel-uj2qp all the Muslim constituencies of that time voted for separate Islamic country
Beautiful presentation on Kashmir...full of fact...Thanx
This is the truth... Thank u Wion for all ur guts n courage to publish this... 🙏
Everywhere Mountbatten went he left a trail of destruction, even while in the British Navy during the Second War.
Yeah exactly he was just an over confident cock head
He was assasinated by the IRA in a bomb blast.
@@naturelover7979 Who is the IRA?
@@mohitarora5145 Irish Republican Army. Call it karma.
Draft of partition made by Congress person Menon and Nehru went away with it.. And Mountbatten sent it in England
Biggest mistake of Nehru was his decision to approch UN.
Nehru is a big mistake in indian politics. Just because of him, dynasty politics got started & became a family buisness model for many other parties & individuals.
Nehru himself was a Mistake 🤣🤣
Yes Nehru made mistakes but if not for him, India would have ended up like Myanmar or Pakistan. What do you prefer ? Nobody can be perfect.
Sometimes Nehru comes across an insecure guy, who knew he was incompetent but hellbent on proving he was not...and kept on making a series of disastrous blunders one after another. a historical version of modern day Trump.
Very true information thank you Palki Sharma for the teaching us Kashmir history
Thanx Palki for such thoroughly researched pieces told in clear cut explicit language.
Nehru was not Hindu...no body knows mysterious of NG family
he is liberandu
I know. I can share a link with you, if you want.
They are Khan not Gandhi
Nehru was parsi
@@erichhere I agree.
The UN is the master of making and serving foot-sandwich.
IF YOU CANNOT SOLVE YOUR PROBLEM, PLEASE DONOT EXPECT FROM OTHERS !
SIMPLE AND CLEAR ON FACT'S ..YOU ARE DOING A GREAT JOB PALKI SHARMA ..BIG SALUTE
Crystal clear with facts and on to the point...
This sense's what a unbiased Media is...
Finally, a news channel explains it as it is.
Thanks.
Not only this he has made so many mistakes, by allowing China as the permanent member of UN. Perhaps should be not a good PM. Aug 5th should be day 2nd independence day for Great
India. Credit goes to Amit Shah, Ajit Doval and Modi government
He didn't allow airforce otherwise aksai China could be ours today.... Same in Kashmir
Untill someone betray him he used to think we are brothers
Hindi chini bhai bhai, he did nothing when Tibet were taken by China and many more
😂👍🏻
Each word she said is true. We cannot forget the chain of events that brought of all us here.
Informative. Thank you.
Literally I curse nehru daily that guy ruined the peace of many generations..I curse him and his generations may all of them don't find the peace
ignorant girl
@@abhijeetanand9877 jaare ❤day
@@abhijeetanand9877 ha... Bada acha karke gye Nehru chacha... Jyada to dhingana karke hi gye
If that’s you’re dp I would walk into fire with you my queen
Don't believe it is media lie
During Partition, the M population got 2 new countries. What did Hindus get?
Us sanatanis go nothing because of SICKULARISM... Read pakistan or partition of India the great BLUNDERS of Gandhi and Nehru🤬
@TMR Videos So can we reclaim our temples??
@TMR Videos
Agan one and only 👍🏻 that is yours keep it up .
@TMR Videos
Agan one and only 👍🏻 that is yours keep it up .
India got development
Your Simply Genius Ms Palki! Aapko Saadhuwaad🙏🏽
Amma we Indians only Hindus need u n ur contribution god bless you.
I've learned a lot about that part of the world with this excellent channel.
Palki is the best reporter of our time. 🎯✨
That was great revelation. ,,,
I appreciate the way you discribe the topic.
She dealt with facts which is rare on desi journalism today
She is well informed and read not like other robot anchors who just read whats provided to them
Polite reminder: Nehru don't deserves to be the PM of India and all honors and awards.
@Jio Boy why you are so obsessed with covering crimes of Nehruji ? And how came Modiji be option he was born in post independence era !
@Jio Boy Nice jk bro, I didn't realize it was a jk until you said it to him.
@Jio Boy Sardar Patel should have become the PM in 1947 itself. He would have been a great PM and even the people loved him, just like they loved Bose. Shastri too was a great PM and an excellent Revolutionary, no wonder the Nehru clan got him out of the way by siding with the KGB.
Crisp, clear and on point ☝️
Tulsi, you are so clear, precise and pure to put facts as they are! Exceptionally short yet complete!