The best thing that happened after Chinese aggression is that our government now is clear about Chinese intension and now there is no confusion that China is our enemy. Otherwise our foreign policy was so confusing when it comes to China despite of China's continuous support to pakistan and Chinese claim of our 3 states.
@@fuzzyblue74 There are several reasons for that 1. Import of api for medicines has increased 2. Import of oxygen concentration 3. Instead of supporting boycott China as much as possible (I know complete boycott is not possible for now), our own people opposed it. 4. Government can't ban Chinese products without proper reason as India has to follow WTO rules. But that's not the complete picture , we have got success in some areas like 1. Software Boycott is successful 2. Most of the Chinese investment in Indian startup has been stopped (Remember it happened because of the efforts of the government , without any public support ) Now on next phase I hope make in India program will be a success and we will be able to replace made in china not only here in India but also across the world. I know it might take min 5-10 years but I am still hopeful that after success of software Boycott we will become successful in hardware boycott.
@@fuzzyblue74 I believe the imports from China will raise for few more years bcoz India is trying to store most of the raw materials from China to decrease the dependency in future crisis & also to achieve self-sufficiency we need time.
I just cannot understand the negatives. So the Chinese attacked because Shah said we would take back Aksai Chin. Then why does China have border disputes with all its neighbors (plus a few non-neighbors)? Not all countries have provoked the dragon. China is an expansionist force and its aim is to dominate everyone. Also, I am shocked to see Shekarji forgetting the context of the remake made by HM Shah. What else was he supposed to say on the well of the house when directly questioned about it? Does he want an Indian home minister to concede territory? And how are Kashmiri people not responsible for their own fate? They have consistently received 10% of central funds with just 1% of the population. It was a conflict economy. It is by far the most communal state in the country with ethnic cleansing going back multiple decades. Which businessman will invest within 3 years of removing 370 in such a hell hole? It is a long process. But a process absolutely in the right direction.
From our perspective, we (and all it's terrestrial and maritime neighbours) see china as expansionist. Rotate the map and see from china's persoective, and u will understand why it says it is recreating akhand china. The negatives r clear to left-of-centre ppl. There is no leadership that listens to locals, hence deprived/enraged ppl r easy to be waylaid by isi.
Well said. Shekhar is a secularist of the appeasement type. You can see his dislike for Modi, just like most mainstream media persons. The SIT created by the Supreme Court declared Modi to be innocent of all the charges or accusations levied on him for the Godhra riots, but Shekar way back had already found Modi guilty which is evident from his reporting and writings if you go back and look. So, the Congress, secular parties, and the divisive administrations in J&K got 70+ years to mess up things in J&K, and like you said, they expect miracles from this government in 3 years! "Analysts" like Shekar expect perfection from the current government, but are able to forgive all the corruption, mismanagement and divisiveness that the Congress propagated and kept supporting and alive in J&K for 70 years. It takes time to change a rotten house, you have to rebuild the house from the foundation up, while living in the house. It's not an easy task by any stretch of imagination ... visit it in another 10-15 years, and we'll see that the change that started on Aug 5, 2019 will bring fruits for India and for all the residents of J&K.
@@Dr_Steve.N I think your intellectual capability stops at ad hominem attack on me. I understand that making logical statements without fallacies requires an IQ greater than 80. Possibly that is too high for you.
@@lets_discuss5352 I am not accusing Shekharji of bias --- each one of us is biased. However, I believe his rationale is totally flawed. One can only expect investments if the people say no to violence against the minority (look at the many targeted killings of Hindus in the valley in the past year) and do not hold separatist tendencies. For 65 years, you allowed 370. Give at least 10 years post-370. Then we can assess.
With so much if gunfire, job growth has naturally been slow.... Once law and order sets in, anc infrastructure is done right.. big ticket investments can come
Please don't mislead people by saying a lie that Congress was slowly diluting article 370. There was no such effort from their part. Even BJP was not doing but they tried to involve in local government to get control of the things but Mehbooba Mufti got her way as CM. As that experiment failed BJP came out of the government and worked upon abrogation of article 370. You must appreciate Modi's effort despite your mental allegiance with the Congress party.
Pressuring Hindus not to speak the truth or claim what they genuinely own for the sake of their life is inhumane. Instead ask Muslims to be kind enough to accept the true history and correct their mistakes. Life without dignity is not worth living.
UT status to J&K is temporary, correct? and the word ‘temporary’ has a meaning of 70 years in our constitution .. so let’s give some more time .. to see what would be temporary mean this time ..
If SG thinks that these 9 things are realistic deliverables within a 3-years span, i wonder if he can tell us the progress he would have expected in the last 75 years.
Who built the IITs, IIMs, ISRO, BARC etc? How come so many Indians are highly successful in the US and around the world? All of that happened in the last 5 years?
@@mohmayakibaat8092 Majority of those new IITs and IIMs and AIIMs do not even have campuses yet. Modi's legacy will take shape in the future. I have had the pleasure to attend two of the ones that have campuses and are really good. IIT Kanpur and IIM Calcutta. Both have beautiful campuses and old infrastructure that holds up to this day. Both were built by pandit Nehru, who has my eternal gratitude for literally building my school.
Modi took the brave decision. Now talks in Pakistan is about saving PoK. Earlier it was whether India can keep our position intact. Economic situation is improving and lot of Indian tourists are visiting some even opening small businesses. Next year rail link will be open which will better integrate Kashmir valley to rest of India. This govt has failed on jobs and inflation front but removing 370 is biggest win.
1. The 3 average rating which Shekhar is talking about are work in progress. Elections will be held soon, as the work of Delimitation Commission is completed. As regards mainstream parties, these continue to be active and talk in forked tongue all the time. 2. Shekhar seems to suggest that there are only two choices for the young, internet savvy, smart Kashmiri youth- Govt of India is not giving them enough job opportunities so either complain or join the terrorism! No one stopped Kashmiri youth from going out and finding jobs anywhere in India, just like any one from UP or Bihar or Haryana or North East does. As industry starts in Kashmir, tourism revives, various infrastructure and developmental programs get going, youth will find jobs locally. 3. That Kashmir is still not considered safe is a fact and if one wants to blame Modi Govt for this, please do so! 4. Chinese incursions in Ladakh is the issue arising probably out of Art 370 revocation. But whatever happened there, India has emerged stronger and better prepared to take on the Chinese. Armed Forces would treat this as a blessing in disguise and history will record this as a grave mistake by Xi Jin Ping, as it changed India's Defense Policy, China became formal Enemy No 1, Pakistan got sidelined, Quad is formalized and push for 'Atmanirbhar Bharat' would make India a formidable power. 5. So overall, Aug 2019 is a watershed for J&K; a lot is now a history but new challenges have emerged. And India is dealing with them. But until Pakistan exists, Kashmir problem (terrorism, militancy, etc) will not be over. So forget this non sense of giving scores to Modi! What Modi did was a long overdue action from say, 1970s. Let us deal with the consequences as we move ahead.
What you mentioned is right, "Govt of India is not giving them enough job opportunities so either complain or join the terrorism! No one stopped Kashmiri youth from going out and finding jobs anywhere in India, just like anyone from UP or Bihar or Haryana or North East does. As the industry starts in Kashmir, tourism revives, various infrastructure and developmental programs get going, and youth will find jobs locally." '
But we can’t live with a fear of China nor make internal decisions with “what China might think about this” attitude. It’s unfortunate that the Chinese got insecure and aggressive, but so be it
China is the natural nation for all Leftists in India. Their hearts beat and bleed for China. SG was so happy about Bangladesh 's per capita is more than India's, barring purchasing power parity. Meanwhile Bangladesh knocks IMF doors
@@Abhishek-qj2iz This is plain stupid Terrorism has not ended Also...terrorism is nuisance but Chins is superpower It capturing Indian land is much bigger deal
Tangible Results 1. Hotels are jam packed in Kashmir 2. Road Rail infra is getting big push 3. Very less news of militancy 4. Pak army agreed for cease fire across border 5. Money being transferred to local government for local development 6. No stone pelting 7. Huriyatt uprooted. 8. Many right groups went jobless Intangible Believes 1. Kashmiris alienated 2. China antagonised 3. Pakistan peace talks stalled not for good
Congress leader Aazad Said even bjp rule for 200 years they can't remove article 370 Bjp : Removed Article 370 within 3months after winning 2019 election 🔥🔥
Well narrated Mr Gupta...this brave decision and govt's delivery and execution is excellent...can't expect everything to happen immediately but the results and the path is absolutely right!
@@pichumanisankar2617 Industrialization is the solution, let it be cosmopolitan like Mumbai, then it will have lot of migration and issue will be resolved
again it's not his fault...it's the bjp who makes such bold promises...again i. have no problem with it...but once you make those promises make sure you achieve it...btw I am not a Cong bakht either...
It is frivolous to think that China has responded to the political move of 371. What was the political initiative from india which angered China in 1962? SG must know that China (or for that matter, any country should) thinks only for the Chinese welfare and dominance in the world. India must do whatever is in its favour and abrogation of 370 is the step in right direction.
The Democratic process is already on and it is tentatively to be held in December22, it is work in progress and hence it is not in negative list, it should have been appreciated. Why no mention of Kashmir Pandits rehabilitation? How can it be forgotten! Why no mention of increase of tourism in multifold? Also the promised investments by Gulf countries which is work in progress. How can you expect such a speed when nothing has happened in the last 70 years. Yes Chinese have come to Ladakh site not for picnic. They thought they are facing a Govt of the past under Congress rule but got a good beating under Modi Govt.
To expect a change in 3 years is probably not realistic. However, bringing in statehood and reducing unemployment might go a long way in bringing the populace to the mainstream. Thank you for the information
After being in ‘special status’ for over seven decades and now after just three years of being rid of that status to expect restoring normalcy like states of Madhya Pradesh or Karnataka is certainly ridiculous.
Million dollar question is can Kashmir remain Kashmir without lakhs of military and paramilitary forces patrolling on the ground?? How long can we afford the high price of maintaining large number of troops in a small part of India particularly now when the border with China is turning hot?
Troops are in Kashmir because Islamabad and Rawalpindi are opposite Kashmir. So that is where most of India's land troops should be. Also terrorism is present in only 5 districts of South Kashmir. Even with peace in Kashmir, the number cannot be reduced by much.
we are all scared of the big bad wolf quipped Hitler. 'I remain concerned by grave violations against children in Jammu and Kashmir and call upon the Government to take preventive measures to protect children, including by ending the use of pellets against children, ensuring that children are not associated in any way to security forces, and endorsing the Safe Schools Declaration and the Vancouver Principles. I am alarmed at the detention and torture of children and concerned by the military use of schools. I urge the Government to ensure that children are detained as a measure of last resort and for the shortest appropriate period of time, and to prevent all forms of ill-treatment in detention. I also urge the Government to ensure the implementation of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015, to address the use of children for illegal activities and the situation of detained children'. 6 May 2021 UNITED NATIONS. In April 2017, General Bipin Rawat the Chief of Army Staff infamously defended Major Leetul Gogoi for tying Farooq Ahmed Dar, a young Kashmiri craftsman, to his jeep bonnet and using him as a human shield to drive through a hostile patch. Later, the army formally commended Gogoi for his widely condemned rights violation against an unarmed civilian. This became standard operating practice as the indian army seemingly went rogue and was roundly condemned by the UN. Both the United Nations and the International Criminal Court consider the way civilians said they were used by the Indian army to search houses in south Kashmir to be illegal under international law, experts said. Many residents of Pinglan village in south Kashmir told Reuters they were used as shields for soldiers as they searched for militants during a crackdown in February. The UN's Geneva Convention states that "the presence of a protected person may not be used to render certain points or areas immune from military operations" "Actions which deliberately endanger the life of ordinary persons - for example, by using them as 'human shields' - can amount to cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment under international human rights law." But India denies that the Geneva Convention, designed for international conflicts, applies to its operations in Indian-controlled Kashmir, and it is one of the few major countries not party to the Rome Statute. Alasdair Pal and Fayaz Bukhari TUE APR 30, 2019 / 7:53 AM EDT REUTERS.
@@reynolddsouza4357 Pellet guns have not been used since so many years . If at all these were used before that it was against those who were involved in stone pelting . Major Gogoi used Farooq Ahmed Dar in self defense and it worked and saved the life of so many soldiers . Children are being used by terrorists and not by Army for illegal activities . India is right , Geneva convention is not applicable in Kashmir because it is not international conflict , it is Indias domestic issue . Where is the doubt . Why are you putting up 2019 report now .
Families of Kashmiri separatists can get indian passports but common Kashmiris can't get the passport easily, sometimes it take years. One of our 17 year girl got passport after three years, she had to go abroad for studies & all the children of separatists are studying abroad.
1) The communal division between Jammu and Kashmir was not sowed in the last 3 years. It has been there since at least 1947. This is a basic historical fact 2)There is a crackdown on the terrorist sympathisers and supporters, and there is little justification to demand to stop the crackdown. If anything, the govt is too lax right now and should do more to tackle this fifth column 3)alienation of youth: there is literally nothing to suggest that this has gotten worse. If anything, the recruitment of youth into militancy is only steadily declining 4)China: revocation of 370 could def be one of the factors that led to the chinese aggression. But it's far from the only one. The border roads being built and India's increasing closeness to QUAD are also important factors
No matter how hard Shekhar Ji try to be an unbiased journalist, but he can't help himself that he is a journalist from The Lutyens era. It is clearly visible in all his videos.
I do not agree with the view of holding elections and giving abdullahs and mehbooba a free run again. The state of J&k should remain as UT for at least 5 to8 years until a visible development takes place , economic, trade, investment wise which shall automatically gel with other states . The fear and view that by making Ladakh a UT we have invited china to take extreme steps of creating a firewall and compelling us to respond otherwise china would have slept happily is not convincing. We should take POK incl. gilgit baltistan to secure India mainland by bringing back mighty himalayan ranges again as our natural protection from invaders. Nothing is gained without a sacrifice and price . God willing Indians do it.
Politicians of Kashmir like Mehbooba Mufti are although leaders of only a small area of round 100 sq km around Srinagar but they pretend to be representatives about the entire Riyasat of Jammu and Kashmir .These politicians, especially Mehbooba Mufti ,often talk, of involving Pakistan in the affairs of J and K but Mehbooba Mufti is absolutely silent on Pakistan having gifted to China , Shaksgam Valley ,an area of 5000 sq km of Jammu and Kashmir territory
I'm surprised that the people commenting here think that a decision can only have positive consequences. Any action will have both pros and cons and we should be able to discuss both to improve further. Is everyone in India gone mad?
so did they promised...again i don't support Cong either...but if bjp promised something it's like their moral responsibility to finish it, which they haven't completely done in case of Kashmir...again i support the change...
@@code-o-maniac6033 Rome wasn't built on a day. Give them time. They still have Pakistan, China and Sri Lanka to contend with. But like what the comments say what has not been achieved for 70yrs miracle are being done now compared the former.
The problem in kashmir is, that we have 3 generations of people growing up believing that kashmir is not a part of india . They are separate, diffrent and azad (thanks to 70 yrs of apatheic rule). It can not be wiped out in 3yrs .. we need a generation of population so give it 20 yrs ..
Cussed in your assessment of the initiative of bringing fundamental changes in #Kashmir 3 years back. Why play up the Chinese reactions on LAC and attribute to this as a downside. No way, it's good that realities were understood by all. Biggest benefit has been that our western neighbour can not manipulate us on "K" any longer and the world is not interested. This has been a major gain others will take a little more time.
अभी अभी अमरनाथ यात्रा करके आया हु 24 जुलाई को । पैसे के आगे न कोई हिंदू है न मुसलमान । सब कुछ पैसा है । घोड़े वाले भाई सारे मुस्लिम है और पूरी सेवा करते है लोगो की ।
Lots of ccp bots in the comments. Dare them to talk about attrocities against Uyghur people in "xinxiang". Its just north of Jammu and Kashmir, you know.
Not separating Jammu from Kashmir is a "miss". Should have separated Jammu, coupled with a population swap between Kashmiri Hindus and Sikhs and Jammu Muslims, for the sake of the safety of the Hindus.
Isn't it funny, congress taking so long is their own serendipitous way of tackling 370. But 3 years of after kashmir abrogation by bjp, so much they should have done by now ....
it is one of the biggest negatives in my opinion. If central government can't even ensure people who originally belong to Kashmir, how do new people or new industries DARE to go to Kashmir?
Based on mr guptas analysis Kashmir is still work in progress.To expect to change a situation which has evolved in 70 years within a span of 3 years is being too optimistic..It will take another 10 years approximately for the situation to be near normal .That’s when a objective analysis needs to be done
How convenient for SG to demand Madhya Pradesh like autonomy for Kashmir. SG first you talk of No more genocide / ethnic cleansing / mass rapes & complete exodus of valley Hindus. Yes then SG can demand Madhya Pradesh like autonomy for Kashmir.
Sir what you said about PLA is what even i think, as a Geopolitical Observer that might be the case for sure we have to make sure to keep our territory safe & have constant eye around the whole area bcoz in coming 20 years they will definitely try to encroach further as CCP's objectives have always remained constantly same throughout their governance even after multiple leader changes, what do you think about this sir? 🙏
The Hindu Buddhist community is under attack in South Asia. 1- In Pakistan, Afghanistan, Bangladesh, the Hindu family has been under attack for centuries. 2- Thousands of Tamil Hindus were killed and oppressed by the Sri Lankan government. 3- Hundred thousand of Nepali-speaking Bhutanese Hindus were exiled from Bhutan in 90's AD. 4- The Madhesi movement was claimed in the front, and the people of Terai Madhesh in Nepal are still being insulted. 5- And the western world has been extensively converting the Hindu Buddhist community to Christianity in this region.y
India should promote Aatmanirbhar not only on corporate level but emphasis on small scale as well as home scale industry in the manufacturing sector for all FMCG, electronics , etc....for local consumption as well as for exports ,thus cutting short the dependency for imports from China...
A good attempt at making a 3 year report card! But, Missing Kashmiri rehabilitation and omitted prosecution of perpetrators of genocide/exodus is surprising. Isn't calling Mufti's and Abdullah's mainstream politicians without confirming their allegiance to India and it's constitution rather hasty?
Nice Shekhar. It's good to see you have taken this challenge to call spade a spade on the Kashmir issue. The only fact is your have disappointed scores of Modi-Shah supporters who still live in their own world of fantasy. I know many Kashmiris who are outside of the J&K. Their anger is palpable. Many still see this as a land grab exercise by Modi - Shah. Unless there's is a healing touch by the center, expect some tumultuous times ahead.
Sekhar ji pls give us your opinion and perspective on what the kashmiri politicians are saying that Indians from other states cannot vote in Jammu and Kashmir! What does law say ..how do think things should progress further
Its ridiculous on your part Mr Shekhar... How can you expect a great change in just 3 years ? It is the fate of over 7 decades. How can you say its Modi's failure ? It is 100% success.
BJP has my vote for the next 20 years on this one decision alone. I have low expectations about everything else from everyone! Such a poor monologue. No reference to the fact that every political party called the move unconstitutional. What happened to those claims?
SK u have ignored the ground reality. Im a KP. Kashmiri youth have and always had all the opportunities. There was and is no bias. They choose to side with the militants and choose the war cry of Azadi. It's their fault and not GOI. GOI has always pampered Kashmir Valley and you have seen the result. Good the gov. is doing delimitation and rebalancing the one sided power equation before fair elections can be held...let them finish that before doing elections. You carefully choose to ignore this fact as it Suites your narrative.
@@hke.4475 Like syria ? pakistan ? Libya ? Iraq ? Nigeria ? Sudan ? Egypt ? Yemen ? Very few muslim countries without oil and gas and without huge non-muslim populations are more developed than India.
The best thing that happened after Chinese aggression is that our government now is clear about Chinese intension and now there is no confusion that China is our enemy. Otherwise our foreign policy was so confusing when it comes to China despite of China's continuous support to pakistan and Chinese claim of our 3 states.
Chinese imports have gone up by 45%
@@fuzzyblue74 There are several reasons for that
1. Import of api for medicines has increased
2. Import of oxygen concentration
3. Instead of supporting boycott China as much as possible (I know complete boycott is not possible for now), our own people opposed it.
4. Government can't ban Chinese products without proper reason as India has to follow WTO rules.
But that's not the complete picture , we have got success in some areas like
1. Software Boycott is successful
2. Most of the Chinese investment in Indian startup has been stopped
(Remember it happened because of the efforts of the government , without any public support )
Now on next phase I hope make in India program will be a success and we will be able to replace made in china not only here in India but also across the world. I know it might take min 5-10 years but I am still hopeful that after success of software Boycott we will become successful in hardware boycott.
@@ShowTranscript Yet Our PM is still like a Coward not uttering the word China?
@@fuzzyblue74 I believe the imports from China will raise for few more years bcoz India is trying to store most of the raw materials from China to decrease the dependency in future crisis & also to achieve self-sufficiency we need time.
Those claims are based on Panchsheel agreement. So why blame China for it?
I just cannot understand the negatives. So the Chinese attacked because Shah said we would take back Aksai Chin. Then why does China have border disputes with all its neighbors (plus a few non-neighbors)? Not all countries have provoked the dragon. China is an expansionist force and its aim is to dominate everyone.
Also, I am shocked to see Shekarji forgetting the context of the remake made by HM Shah. What else was he supposed to say on the well of the house when directly questioned about it? Does he want an Indian home minister to concede territory?
And how are Kashmiri people not responsible for their own fate? They have consistently received 10% of central funds with just 1% of the population. It was a conflict economy. It is by far the most communal state in the country with ethnic cleansing going back multiple decades. Which businessman will invest within 3 years of removing 370 in such a hell hole? It is a long process. But a process absolutely in the right direction.
From our perspective, we (and all it's terrestrial and maritime neighbours) see china as expansionist. Rotate the map and see from china's persoective, and u will understand why it says it is recreating akhand china.
The negatives r clear to left-of-centre ppl. There is no leadership that listens to locals, hence deprived/enraged ppl r easy to be waylaid by isi.
Well said. Shekhar is a secularist of the appeasement type. You can see his dislike for Modi, just like most mainstream media persons. The SIT created by the Supreme Court declared Modi to be innocent of all the charges or accusations levied on him for the Godhra riots, but Shekar way back had already found Modi guilty which is evident from his reporting and writings if you go back and look.
So, the Congress, secular parties, and the divisive administrations in J&K got 70+ years to mess up things in J&K, and like you said, they expect miracles from this government in 3 years! "Analysts" like Shekar expect perfection from the current government, but are able to forgive all the corruption, mismanagement and divisiveness that the Congress propagated and kept supporting and alive in J&K for 70 years. It takes time to change a rotten house, you have to rebuild the house from the foundation up, while living in the house. It's not an easy task by any stretch of imagination ... visit it in another 10-15 years, and we'll see that the change that started on Aug 5, 2019 will bring fruits for India and for all the residents of J&K.
You would have understood well if all he did was wah modiji wah.
@@Dr_Steve.N I think your intellectual capability stops at ad hominem attack on me. I understand that making logical statements without fallacies requires an IQ greater than 80. Possibly that is too high for you.
@@lets_discuss5352 I am not accusing Shekharji of bias --- each one of us is biased. However, I believe his rationale is totally flawed. One can only expect investments if the people say no to violence against the minority (look at the many targeted killings of Hindus in the valley in the past year) and do not hold separatist tendencies.
For 65 years, you allowed 370. Give at least 10 years post-370. Then we can assess.
I am from rajouri j&k, things have changed for positive in j&k after Abrogation except for unemployment rate.
Article 370 doesn't deal with unemployment
Not only in j&k...entire india is facing unemployment...
@@akeshravi9640 scrapping the laws brought in liberalisation and promoted buisness.
@@chukkagowriharunkumarreddy but J&k has 2nd highest unemployment rate in india.
With so much if gunfire, job growth has naturally been slow....
Once law and order sets in, anc infrastructure is done right.. big ticket investments can come
Please don't mislead people by saying a lie that Congress was slowly diluting article 370. There was no such effort from their part. Even BJP was not doing but they tried to involve in local government to get control of the things but Mehbooba Mufti got her way as CM. As that experiment failed BJP came out of the government and worked upon abrogation of article 370. You must appreciate Modi's effort despite your mental allegiance with the Congress party.
This guy is congress backed guy always critics Modi
During those years, BJP understood the activities and intentions of local politicians as well individuals in bureaucracy. The time was used wisely.
What can you expect from an armchair pseudo liberal ?
Pressuring Hindus not to speak the truth or claim what they genuinely own for the sake of their life is inhumane. Instead ask Muslims to be kind enough to accept the true history and correct their mistakes. Life without dignity is not worth living.
UT status to J&K is temporary, correct? and the word ‘temporary’ has a meaning of 70 years in our constitution .. so let’s give some more time .. to see what would be temporary mean this time ..
Stop talking shit 💩💩💩
Dimag ka gobar khi pe bhi kr dete ho
Kashmir will be separated from india very soon
If SG thinks that these 9 things are realistic deliverables within a 3-years span, i wonder if he can tell us the progress he would have expected in the last 75 years.
Who built the IITs, IIMs, ISRO, BARC etc? How come so many Indians are highly successful in the US and around the world? All of that happened in the last 5 years?
@@kyabe5813 majority of IITs and AIIMS,
were initiated by NDA. You can check which government was in power during the proposals.
@@mohmayakibaat8092 Majority of those new IITs and IIMs and AIIMs do not even have campuses yet. Modi's legacy will take shape in the future.
I have had the pleasure to attend two of the ones that have campuses and are really good. IIT Kanpur and IIM Calcutta. Both have beautiful campuses and old infrastructure that holds up to this day. Both were built by pandit Nehru, who has my eternal gratitude for literally building my school.
Kashmir will be separated from india very soon
Modi took the brave decision. Now talks in Pakistan is about saving PoK. Earlier it was whether India can keep our position intact. Economic situation is improving and lot of Indian tourists are visiting some even opening small businesses. Next year rail link will be open which will better integrate Kashmir valley to rest of India. This govt has failed on jobs and inflation front but removing 370 is biggest win.
1. The 3 average rating which Shekhar is talking about are work in progress. Elections will be held soon, as the work of Delimitation Commission is completed. As regards mainstream parties, these continue to be active and talk in forked tongue all the time. 2. Shekhar seems to suggest that there are only two choices for the young, internet savvy, smart Kashmiri youth- Govt of India is not giving them enough job opportunities so either complain or join the terrorism! No one stopped Kashmiri youth from going out and finding jobs anywhere in India, just like any one from UP or Bihar or Haryana or North East does. As industry starts in Kashmir, tourism revives, various infrastructure and developmental programs get going, youth will find jobs locally. 3. That Kashmir is still not considered safe is a fact and if one wants to blame Modi Govt for this, please do so! 4. Chinese incursions in Ladakh is the issue arising probably out of Art 370 revocation. But whatever happened there, India has emerged stronger and better prepared to take on the Chinese. Armed Forces would treat this as a blessing in disguise and history will record this as a grave mistake by Xi Jin Ping, as it changed India's Defense Policy, China became formal Enemy No 1, Pakistan got sidelined, Quad is formalized and push for 'Atmanirbhar Bharat' would make India a formidable power. 5. So overall, Aug 2019 is a watershed for J&K; a lot is now a history but new challenges have emerged. And India is dealing with them. But until Pakistan exists, Kashmir problem (terrorism, militancy, etc) will not be over. So forget this non sense of giving scores to Modi! What Modi did was a long overdue action from say, 1970s. Let us deal with the consequences as we move ahead.
Succinctly put!
What you mentioned is right, "Govt of India is not giving them enough job opportunities so either complain or join the terrorism! No one stopped Kashmiri youth from going out and finding jobs anywhere in India, just like anyone from UP or Bihar or Haryana or North East does. As the industry starts in Kashmir, tourism revives, various infrastructure and developmental programs get going, and youth will find jobs locally."
'
But we can’t live with a fear of China nor make internal decisions with “what China might think about this” attitude. It’s unfortunate that the Chinese got insecure and aggressive, but so be it
China is the natural nation for all Leftists in India. Their hearts beat and bleed for China. SG was so happy about Bangladesh 's per capita is more than India's, barring purchasing power parity. Meanwhile Bangladesh knocks IMF doors
Correctly said.
Well..
They killed our soldiers
@@anshuraj4277 It is unfortunate. But more soldiers and people would have died in the Kashmir valley had it not been for this
@@Abhishek-qj2iz
This is plain stupid
Terrorism has not ended
Also...terrorism is nuisance but Chins is superpower
It capturing Indian land is much bigger deal
Tangible Results
1. Hotels are jam packed in Kashmir
2. Road Rail infra is getting big push
3. Very less news of militancy
4. Pak army agreed for cease fire across border
5. Money being transferred to local government for local development
6. No stone pelting
7. Huriyatt uprooted.
8. Many right groups went jobless
Intangible Believes
1. Kashmiris alienated
2. China antagonised
3. Pakistan peace talks stalled not for good
One of the best comments, very well spoken sir..
These young Kashmiri youths are better educated and articulate than their compatriots in HINDI HEARTLAND. Where did you get this sir?
Congress leader Aazad Said even bjp rule for 200 years they can't remove article 370
Bjp : Removed Article 370 within 3months after winning 2019 election 🔥🔥
He didnt realise how brainless they were.
Well narrated Mr Gupta...this brave decision and govt's delivery and execution is excellent...can't expect everything to happen immediately but the results and the path is absolutely right!
But SG doesn’t seem to think so. Kashmir would remain a difficult nut to crack and its integration still. Far thing.
@@pichumanisankar2617 Industrialization is the solution, let it be cosmopolitan like Mumbai, then it will have lot of migration and issue will be resolved
@@millennialmind9507 seems to adopt Israel guidelines
Thank god this is not a old episode posted as new i really hate those
sahi pakde hai
Phundak aati hai lagta hai kisi ne basi puri dedi
😅
You are expecting neutralization of 70 years of wrong doings in 3 years , your expectations from Modi is real high, you are a true Modi Bhakt!
again it's not his fault...it's the bjp who makes such bold promises...again i. have no problem with it...but once you make those promises make sure you achieve it...btw I am not a Cong bakht either...
It is frivolous to think that China has responded to the political move of 371. What was the political initiative from india which angered China in 1962? SG must know that China (or for that matter, any country should) thinks only for the Chinese welfare and dominance in the world. India must do whatever is in its favour and abrogation of 370 is the step in right direction.
My salute to the soldiers who established LOC, at last shekar speaks openly with his usual style.👍
Sir, one correction rest of Indians were also direct victims.....brave supreme sacrifice of our parents in thousands cannot be taken so lightly...
The Democratic process is already on and it is tentatively to be held in December22, it is work in progress and hence it is not in negative list, it should have been appreciated. Why no mention of Kashmir Pandits rehabilitation? How can it be forgotten!
Why no mention of increase of tourism in multifold? Also the promised investments by Gulf countries which is work in progress. How can you expect such a speed when nothing has happened in the last 70 years.
Yes Chinese have come to Ladakh site not for picnic. They thought they are facing a Govt of the past under Congress rule but got a good beating under Modi Govt.
Very well said 👌
But UAE's Emmar Group, already invested in the infrastructure of Kashmir. It is a good start, at least?
only agreemnets yet! no real infra on grounds.
@@pp_01123 lol... you seems to as a abdool.
2 years of COVID did impact our nation and so we have to take that into account too.
true
Very true
To expect a change in 3 years is probably not realistic. However, bringing in statehood and reducing unemployment might go a long way in bringing the populace to the mainstream. Thank you for the information
Hi Vivekanand,
Thanks for writing in.
After being in ‘special status’ for over seven decades and now after just three years of being rid of that status to expect restoring normalcy like states of Madhya Pradesh or Karnataka is certainly ridiculous.
Kashmir will be separated from india very soon
@@Acts17Apsychopathics Before which Papisthan will cease to exist 🤡
Million dollar question is can Kashmir remain Kashmir without lakhs of military and paramilitary forces patrolling on the ground??
How long can we afford the high price of maintaining large number of troops in a small part of India particularly now when the border with China is turning hot?
Troops are in Kashmir because Islamabad and Rawalpindi are opposite Kashmir. So that is where most of India's land troops should be. Also terrorism is present in only 5 districts of South Kashmir. Even with peace in Kashmir, the number cannot be reduced by much.
we are all scared of the big bad wolf quipped Hitler. 'I remain concerned by grave violations against children in Jammu and Kashmir and call upon the Government to take preventive measures to protect children,
including by ending the use of pellets against children, ensuring that children are not associated in any way to security forces, and endorsing the Safe Schools Declaration and the Vancouver Principles. I am alarmed at the detention and torture of children and concerned by the military use of schools. I urge the Government to ensure that children are detained as a measure of last resort and for the shortest appropriate period
of time, and to prevent all forms of ill-treatment in detention. I also urge the Government to ensure the implementation of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection
of Children) Act, 2015, to address the use of children for illegal activities and the situation of detained children'. 6 May 2021 UNITED NATIONS.
In April 2017, General Bipin Rawat the Chief of Army Staff infamously defended Major Leetul Gogoi for tying Farooq Ahmed Dar, a young Kashmiri craftsman, to his jeep bonnet and using him as a human shield to drive through a hostile patch. Later, the army formally commended Gogoi for his widely condemned rights violation against an unarmed civilian.
This became standard operating practice as the indian army seemingly went rogue and was roundly condemned by the UN.
Both the United Nations and the International Criminal Court consider the way civilians said they were used by the Indian army to search houses in south Kashmir to be illegal under international law, experts said.
Many residents of Pinglan village in south Kashmir told Reuters they were used as shields for soldiers as they searched for militants during a crackdown in February.
The UN's Geneva Convention states that "the presence of a protected person may not be used to render certain points or areas immune from military operations"
"Actions which deliberately endanger the life of ordinary persons - for example, by using them as 'human shields' - can amount to cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment under international human rights law."
But India denies that the Geneva Convention, designed for international conflicts, applies to its operations in Indian-controlled Kashmir, and it is one of the few major countries not party to the Rome Statute.
Alasdair Pal and Fayaz Bukhari
TUE APR 30, 2019 / 7:53 AM EDT
REUTERS.
@@reynolddsouza4357 Okay, Abdul. Now go back to your hole.
@@reynolddsouza4357 Pellet guns have not been used since so many years . If at all these were used before that it was against those who were involved in stone pelting . Major Gogoi used Farooq Ahmed Dar in self defense and it worked and saved the life of so many soldiers . Children are being used by terrorists and not by Army for illegal activities . India is right , Geneva convention is not applicable in Kashmir because it is not international conflict , it is Indias domestic issue . Where is the doubt . Why are you putting up 2019 report now .
🤣
Biggest reason I will laud BJP government for ever.
Families of Kashmiri separatists can get indian passports but common Kashmiris can't get the passport easily, sometimes it take years. One of our 17 year girl got passport after three years, she had to go abroad for studies & all the children of separatists are studying abroad.
1) The communal division between Jammu and Kashmir was not sowed in the last 3 years. It has been there since at least 1947. This is a basic historical fact
2)There is a crackdown on the terrorist sympathisers and supporters, and there is little justification to demand to stop the crackdown. If anything, the govt is too lax right now and should do more to tackle this fifth column
3)alienation of youth: there is literally nothing to suggest that this has gotten worse. If anything, the recruitment of youth into militancy is only steadily declining
4)China: revocation of 370 could def be one of the factors that led to the chinese aggression. But it's far from the only one. The border roads being built and India's increasing closeness to QUAD are also important factors
No matter how hard Shekhar Ji try to be an unbiased journalist, but he can't help himself that he is a journalist from The Lutyens era. It is clearly visible in all his videos.
Thanks SG
Very insightful discourse
Congress doing in halal certified way where's BJP did zhatka style no certificate required.......
I do not agree with the view of holding elections and giving abdullahs and mehbooba a free run again. The state of J&k should remain as UT for at least 5 to8 years until a visible development takes place , economic, trade, investment wise which shall automatically gel with other states . The fear and view that by making Ladakh a UT we have invited china to take extreme steps of creating a firewall and compelling us to respond otherwise china would have slept happily is not convincing. We should take POK incl. gilgit baltistan to secure India mainland by bringing back mighty himalayan ranges again as our natural protection from invaders. Nothing is gained without a sacrifice and price . God willing Indians do it.
Then kashmir will destabilize again'
This UT thing should then be done for all the bottom 10 states of our country then till we see improvements in trade, investment and growth.
@@jyotirmoysahoo What are on going on about?
Do you really believe that centralising the whole thing just magically solves all the issues?
@@mss17405 Exactly
Mine was a sarcastic reply
The division between "Jammu" and "Kashmir", especially politically, has always been there since 1947, or since Sheikh Abdullah or NC took over.
Ye ad please remove karo, so annoying
Politicians of Kashmir like Mehbooba Mufti are although leaders of only a small area of round 100 sq km around Srinagar but they pretend to be representatives about the entire Riyasat of Jammu and Kashmir .These politicians, especially Mehbooba Mufti ,often talk, of involving Pakistan in the affairs of J and K but Mehbooba Mufti is absolutely silent on Pakistan having gifted to China , Shaksgam Valley ,an area of 5000 sq km of Jammu and Kashmir territory
I paid for TH-cam Premium for no ads but still I was made to watch it.
Ad was part of the video. Hence. But yeah, it’s frustrating.
Did Shyama Prasad Mukherjee died in Kashmir, mysteriously ONLY to his followers? Just seeking clarification here.
Shekargupta ji as a senior man how you can say that is it 3 yrs are sufficient to heal all the wounds when the old scholars not able to do in 7decades
I am from UP and I always feel poor whenever i visit Maharashtra or South India whenever I see people from UP and Bihar working there as labourers
Shekhar ji you are so “secular” that you didn’t mention atrocities on Kashmiri pandits? Your viewers are not stupid sir.
Good video, qualitative analysis
Hi, thanks for writing in.
Kashmir is an integral part of Bharath, we also have to achieve POK.
Shekhar gupta should be made pm of kashmir and all problem will be solved.
I am feeling very bad for the people of Jammu and Kashmir. It should be immediately given statehood and elections should be done as soon as possible.
I'm surprised that the people commenting here think that a decision can only have positive consequences. Any action will have both pros and cons and we should be able to discuss both to improve further. Is everyone in India gone mad?
शेखर जी आप बहुत अच्छे आदमी है।
What Congress could not do in seventy five years, SG wants BJP to do in three years. 😂😂.
With high responsibility comes high expectations.
so did they promised...again i don't support Cong either...but if bjp promised something it's like their moral responsibility to finish it, which they haven't completely done in case of Kashmir...again i support the change...
@@code-o-maniac6033 A person who never made a mistake never tried anything new........... Albert Einstein
@@dsvikas maybe
@@code-o-maniac6033 Rome wasn't built on a day. Give them time. They still have Pakistan, China and Sri Lanka to contend with. But like what the comments say what has not been achieved for 70yrs miracle are being done now compared the former.
Good analysis
The problem in kashmir is, that we have 3 generations of people growing up believing that kashmir is not a part of india . They are separate, diffrent and azad (thanks to 70 yrs of apatheic rule). It can not be wiped out in 3yrs .. we need a generation of population so give it 20 yrs ..
Cussed in your assessment of the initiative of bringing fundamental changes in #Kashmir 3 years back. Why play up the Chinese reactions on LAC and attribute to this as a downside. No way, it's good that realities were understood by all. Biggest benefit has been that our western neighbour can not manipulate us on "K" any longer and the world is not interested. This has been a major gain others will take a little more time.
अभी अभी अमरनाथ यात्रा करके आया हु 24 जुलाई को । पैसे के आगे न कोई हिंदू है न मुसलमान । सब कुछ पैसा है । घोड़े वाले भाई सारे मुस्लिम है और पूरी सेवा करते है लोगो की ।
What you think? Are his observations okay?
A unified economically strong nation is the key to having fewer strife.
Excellent analysis Shekhar!!
Lots of ccp bots in the comments. Dare them to talk about attrocities against Uyghur people in "xinxiang". Its just north of Jammu and Kashmir, you know.
Not separating Jammu from Kashmir is a "miss". Should have separated Jammu, coupled with a population swap between Kashmiri Hindus and Sikhs and Jammu Muslims, for the sake of the safety of the Hindus.
So partition within India? Jammu acts as a counter to Kashmir
Isn't it funny, congress taking so long is their own serendipitous way of tackling 370. But 3 years of after kashmir abrogation by bjp, so much they should have done by now ....
Not being able to settle Kashmiri Pandits would have been a negative to speak of.
it is one of the biggest negatives in my opinion. If central government can't even ensure people who originally belong to Kashmir, how do new people or new industries DARE to go to Kashmir?
Good analysis Sir
Based on mr guptas analysis Kashmir is still work in progress.To expect to change a situation which has evolved in 70 years within a span of 3 years is being too optimistic..It will take another 10 years approximately for the situation to be near normal .That’s when a objective analysis needs to be done
So shock and awe worked ?
How convenient for SG to demand Madhya Pradesh like autonomy for Kashmir. SG first you talk of No more genocide / ethnic cleansing / mass rapes & complete exodus of valley Hindus. Yes then SG can demand Madhya Pradesh like autonomy for Kashmir.
Sir what you said about PLA is what even i think, as a Geopolitical Observer that might be the case for sure we have to make sure to keep our territory safe & have constant eye around the whole area bcoz in coming 20 years they will definitely try to encroach further as CCP's objectives have always remained constantly same throughout their governance even after multiple leader changes, what do you think about this sir? 🙏
So you mean we should buckle under Chinese pressure?
The Hindu Buddhist community is under attack in South Asia.
1- In Pakistan, Afghanistan, Bangladesh, the Hindu family has been under attack for centuries.
2- Thousands of Tamil Hindus were killed and oppressed by the Sri Lankan government.
3- Hundred thousand of Nepali-speaking Bhutanese Hindus were exiled from Bhutan in 90's AD.
4- The Madhesi movement was claimed in the front, and the people of Terai Madhesh in Nepal are still being insulted.
5- And the western world has been extensively converting the Hindu Buddhist community to Christianity in this region.y
NOW THAT GENRE IS THE TRUTH AND FACT
Myself not an expert on this subject. But felt he has done a good analysis
Shekhar ji i am big fan of your journalism, especially explaining the clutter. You are a stateman and in my opinion an Journalismargument
The Print team. Please start adding timestamps
Hi Sanket,
Thanks for the suggestion.
Kashmir for Kashmiris, both India and Pakistan needs to understand this.
Same Kashmiri who conducted Hindu genocide
India should promote Aatmanirbhar not only on corporate level but emphasis on small scale as well as home scale industry in the manufacturing sector for all FMCG, electronics , etc....for local consumption as well as for exports ,thus cutting short the dependency for imports from China...
A good attempt at making a 3 year report card! But,
Missing Kashmiri rehabilitation and omitted prosecution of perpetrators of genocide/exodus is surprising. Isn't calling Mufti's and Abdullah's mainstream politicians without confirming their allegiance to India and it's constitution rather hasty?
Undoing 75 years of pain will take time 🧘
An honest analysis!
Nice, simple explanation, thank you SG.
Why am I being subjected to ads when i have a paid subscription??!!!
This makes sense...
hope Modi government is listening and understanding.
Great analysis sir.
Expecting 30 years of rot to be removed in 3 years is too much
Did you deliberately not mention the 'homecoming of Kashmiri Pandits?'
Nice Shekhar. It's good to see you have taken this challenge to call spade a spade on the Kashmir issue. The only fact is your have disappointed scores of Modi-Shah supporters who still live in their own world of fantasy. I know many Kashmiris who are outside of the J&K. Their anger is palpable. Many still see this as a land grab exercise by Modi - Shah. Unless there's is a healing touch by the center, expect some tumultuous times ahead.
you are definetly living in reality created by ndtv, the wire, burka dutt
Not bad.
At 8:03 i think SG meant surreptitious rather than Serendipitious.
Sekhar ji pls give us your opinion and perspective on what the kashmiri politicians are saying that Indians from other states cannot vote in Jammu and Kashmir! What does law say ..how do think things should progress further
Blinkit is using Cut The Clutter's Beginning Jingle since few days....
Good analysis..
I marvel why people like Shekhar think we want Muftis and Abdullahs back?
I hope student Modi takes the teacher's feedback to heart.
Lol
How was congress in support of A-370? Or what were the steps taken by them(Referring to the slowly slowly-term)
Any commentary on the demography of JnK is incomplete without mention of restoring the Kashmiri Hindus in the Valley.
Today I can buy an Apple orchid in Kashmir but cannot do it in HP. WHY? Is HP not part of India?
Its ridiculous on your part Mr Shekhar... How can you expect a great change in just 3 years ? It is the fate of over 7 decades. How can you say its Modi's failure ? It is 100% success.
Out of which 2 were COVID years.
BJP has my vote for the next 20 years on this one decision alone. I have low expectations about everything else from everyone!
Such a poor monologue. No reference to the fact that every political party called the move unconstitutional. What happened to those claims?
Superb topic sir & rightly said
❤️ U
@theprint Can you do a video on CRZ issue of Goa
SK u have ignored the ground reality. Im a KP. Kashmiri youth have and always had all the opportunities. There was and is no bias. They choose to side with the militants and choose the war cry of Azadi. It's their fault and not GOI. GOI has always pampered Kashmir Valley and you have seen the result. Good the gov. is doing delimitation and rebalancing the one sided power equation before fair elections can be held...let them finish that before doing elections. You carefully choose to ignore this fact as it Suites your narrative.
Please cover Nagaland also
Extremely off-putting first 5 seconds of the ad. Please get rid of it
Muslim countries and Muslim majority areas will not get investment due to law and order issues.
Yet most of the Muslim majority countries are more developed than india
@@hke.4475 Like syria ? pakistan ? Libya ? Iraq ? Nigeria ? Sudan ? Egypt ? Yemen ? Very few muslim countries without oil and gas and without huge non-muslim populations are more developed than India.
Thanks for your insight. Now I understand the situation
What change you want in just limited time.everything take time
Why are you in a hurry for change? Change will happen gradually. 70 years is enough.