A brief history of Kashmir's recent events and accession to India.
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 4 ก.ย. 2019
- A concise summary of political and military events in the history of #Kashmir stretching back to 150 years, though largely focused on #KashmirsAccession to #India and the political events that followed. With this short video, one can truly get a grasp of events. History buffs will find enough intrigue to dig deeper and understand the minds of the men of the day. As always, there are various interpretations of events so do write in your counterpoints and enjoy the end limerick.
Correction:
The leader of the first battalion of Sikh Regiment that flew into Srinagar was led by Lt. Col. Dewan Ranjit Rai, not Ranjit Pai.
Pakistan's Independence is mentioned as August 14, 1946, it should be 1947.
Bisbo regrets the errors.
Sources
Avinash Mohananey
How Kashmir was won from Mountbatten & Jinnah; Economic Times; Aug 7, 2019
Kashmir win: As it happened in 1947; Economic Times, Oct 30, 2018
Indira & VP Singh could have buried 370 but they clung to it as a test of secularism; Swapan Das Gupta; Aug 11, 2019
70 years on, history repeats itself in Kashmir in a strange way; Andrew Whitehead; Aug 11, 2019
What’s next for Kashmir?; Omair Ahmed; Mumbai Mirror; Aug 11, 2019
J&K’s Article 370: Clause for peace is now laid to rest, Dhirendra Tripathi; Mint, Aug 6, 2019
The four eventful days that decided the fate of Kashmir; Times of India;
Books
Mridu Rai: Hindu Rulers, Muslim Subjects
Bisbo's Limerick:
---------------------
Don't forget to watch Bisbo's Limerick at the end of each video, that neatly sums up the topic.
Follow #Bisbo on Twitter:
--------------------------------
@GoBisbo
I am a Dogra from Jammu.... And dogras of jammu share history as Indian army personals..... Maharaja Hari Singh was also a Dogra..... And we dogras are proud Indians.....
L chu le
Na che une bwi cho
@@maaz6480 I didn't get what u said.... But I think u will get this very easily... Tera mera rishta kya: LAaa HILAA MERA LULAAAA ❤️
Is it true that Kashmir was a Muslim Majority state from the beginning????
From beginning I mean to say from 1800-1900s
@@Curious0511 1800-1900 is not the beginning of kashmir. The original inhabitants of kashmir are the kashmiri pandits, my community. There is a history of kashmiri pandits in kashmir which can be traced back to 3000 or even 4000 years. It was around 1200-1300 A.D when the muslims started coming to kashmir and thus the whole scenario started to change. There were killings , conversions and ofcourse, the exodus of kashmiri pandits has been happening since then. The main reason for that is we fucking believe in non-violence which i think should change if we have to survive. Anyways, coming back to the point, we did not have an army or a strong leader at the time of muslim invasion who could have guided us. So it was easy for those fuckers. So what you see today in kashmir are in majority the converted pandits who have still not changed the pandit surnames like bhatt, mattoo etc but call themselves muslims. There are some who have surnames as 'pandit' but are muslims. I have a muslim friend from kashmir whose grandfather's name was krishan maharaj. So you can imagine the degree of conversions that have taken place in kashmir. Then there are some muslims whose forefathers were the invaders and settled in kashmir. There were lots of instances when the genyu (sacred thread) of hundreds of pandits was lit on fire in front of them and even pandits were force fed meat (especially cow meat) to convert them into muslims. There are thousands of things that i can tell but this is enough for now.
@@ashishraina007 yes bro I know that all of the Kashmir was a Hindu Majority state and there were killings and forceful conversations like in Pakistan, Afganistan but I just wanted to know that was it really a Muslim majority state at the time of independence..
One correction sheikh Abdullah was never nationalist
Suhas Joshi and pakistan got it's independence in '14aug 1947' not 1946 as mentioned in the video
SHIEKH ABDULLAH WAS A LOOTER DURING HIS PRIME DAYS. I HOPE THESE PEOPLE DIE OUT FAST SO THAT KASHMIR CAN HAVE REAL CHANCE OF DEMOCRACY
Yes, I am from Jammu and can't tell how he discriminated us
He always was
@P. Ankit Kumar modi wasn’t a nationalist
Indra GandhI exchanged 92000 Pak troops for nothing..... Brilliant Indra....???????
Because she was stupid.
Whole gandhi family is a curse for India
They were naive..... They did wanted our POWs in exchange but she was weak to ask for that to pakistan
chk your facts again cuz this
Fake Gandhi Family is a real burden on INDIA
A note: Towards the end you mentioned that by the logic of partition Kashmir should've gone to Pakistan. There's however a major flaw to this concept: Kashmir was not part of British India per se, to which the partition was applied. It was an Indian princely state which was semi-independent and was not part of the official partition plan. Moreover, Indian leaders were against the concept of dividing India on the lines of religion and were against partition. On top of it, the predominant political movement in the valley was led by the National conference and was secular in nature. So, we cannot just assume that people of Kashmir automatically wanted to be part of Pakistan in 1947 just cuz majority of them happen to be Muslim. It is just the elections of 1987 and anti-India propaganda fed by Pakistani radio and TV channels over time, combined with gradual building up of genuine grievances of the Kashmiri people against the Indian government which has led to the ongoing insurgency.
I mean your theory sounds just ad much of a theory. Only a real election could have answered that. Historically muslims tend to vote for Muslim countries. It's unlikely that Muslim majority would have elected to have a non religious state. But who knows
I think every massive country like India China russia America Brazil should separate into smaller countries because they all remain colonizers. South India wants their own country. Khalistan wants to separate. Kashmir wants to separate. In China definitely Hong Kong and areas that have uyghur majority. Russia has like 10 different peoples occupied. Including bhuddist, Muslim and more paganish beliefs. America should have separated at confederacy and now they should separate such that conservatives have their own states and liberal their own
@@nkinash321 so as per you:- all problem one solution, just divide.
Those who broke India in two parts also thought the same that if they divide India on the basis of religion all the fight of that Hindu-Muslim will end. So did it happen?? No it's never going to solve problems like that (yeah it will make it easier for our enemies to conquer us)
For your knowledge 99% Sikh are loyal Indians ( in case you count those 1 % then we should divide India with every house belonging to a different country), no-one in South India wants a different country it's just a social media hoax mainly created by bot accounts by enemies.
Division never gonna help India.
And more importantly running a govt is not as easy as it looks. For example just check out Pakistan.
So simply keep those idiots thoughts out of your mind and chill India have faced much worse situations in last 75 years but India survived so stay like one we will always be one no-one can break our bond, our pride, our India.
I don't think you know what the definition of coloniser is. India, US, Brazil can't be called colonisers they have federal republic every person has their right to vote, to justice, to do their service without any racism so how can you call them colonisers and yes for china it's true they are following exactly the same path as East-India company, first give give bribe to attract traitors, who are ready to fool their own country then throw the govt under loans with their help and capture them.
Hey! Indians we have to be unite to remove dark times from India territories...Share this video to your friends many people don't aware all of these .
Thanks to #bisbo
I didn't know somebody in India had the courage to make such an unbiased channel. Love your content brother , keep it up.
Except for few mistakes on UN. I guess he made a good video on assassination of Bangladesh first leader who fought for independence after he was denied to be PM for whole Pakistan.
Bisbo is never unbiased. He would honey coat Modi wherever possible.
Another Bhakth. (This is not in reference to this video only).
It's not pakistan lol😂
@@faisalabdullahfarhanbba-3010 Nobody cares about what paxtanis have to say. Who are you guys? What's your awkat?
You dare to beg Indian channels, Indians and government of anything? This isn't IMF that you will swing your katora!
You want Indians to spin off lies about Modi because it suits your paxtani feelings? Go with your katora somewhere else.
And whether Indians are Bhakts or not is none of your business. Your entire constitution is Islamic. Go and sort that out first before asking India to do anything.
SAIBAL,
I dont know what you are calling unbiased. We all Indians know entirety of this. And as the logic goes, it belongs to India. The accession was signed and it belongs to India, including POK.
Major Somnath, independent India's first Paramveer chakra was awarded to him as he saved Srinagar Airport. His small memorial is in front of Srinagar airport.
It will be 14aug 1947 instead of 1946 , these kinds of mistake is unacceptable from a channel like yours.
Yes you are right. Apologies
@@BisboWorld BUT WHAT ABOUT THE MASSACRE OF JAMMU ...... #DISTORTED
yes this is not done
watch your videos thoroughly many times before u upload it cuz it's a channel about facts not a prank show
@@BisboWorld don't just apologize delete this video and make a correct video with correct info. As your also spreading wrong fact about India needs to pull all the force from J&K. So delete this videos check and correct your facts and then post a correct video ASAP because not everyone is aware for these facts and your educating them incorrect facts.
One thing is clear, of all the prime ministers we had, only Modi has guts
No, not for nehru and Patel JK would have been with Pakistan. Small stunts like removing 370 don't make him any great.
@@ajinkyapawar438 small stunt then why pakistan and congress are rattled?
He has the guts to let people die due to lack of oxygen. What a shameful guy modi is.
First time i had saw a Indian creator who has shown us the truth...
I think there will be much more.
I appreciate their works
Ultimately, it is Kashmiris paying the price now. Hope this will end once for all and peace is restored.
They not paying the price. They just reaping what they sowed. What was the fault of Kashmiri Hindus?
@@spawn11 they weren't driven out... Most of them fled... Some still do stay there
@@rohan.8299 It's same thing. No one fled without any reason lol.
How
People forget to mention that the Kashmiri's started a re billion after the massacre of Muslims by the state forces of maharaja who asked all the Muslim soldiers hand in their guns thus starting the war.
Army did it's job explicitly in all four wars against Pakistan but indian bureaucrats screwed up.
Excellent Animation Work From Your Technical Department.As For The Story and Outcome of Entire Drama Of the Past Politics of Kashmir to Present Scenario this Has Became Like a Joker in the Pack for Present Political parties. Peace for Kashmir.
7:56 you are wrong here that the resolution states that India has to pull his all troops from J&K. As the resolution clearly states that Pakistan has to pull out its all troops as well as all irregular people from J&K . also the resolution states that India must keep enough/minimum Troops to maintain Law & Order, also it states to keep troops there to prevent any other pakistani invasion. So please make your facts correct and don't spread lies.
Ya right .... as if UN would do that .... they were readdy deploy their trops and keep law and order under their control and do election under their protection , but y would india allow that .... read the right history...not your fabricated one
@@DocAliAdus people uneducated like you are the dumbest in the world and people like u only mislead the people .. Have you ever read the resolution if yes you would not be saying stupid things like this. Go to the UN website and download and read the UNSC resolution number 47 ( Kashmir Resolution ) and read the full document. On the point 2 it clearly says "Reducing the force to the minimum strength required for the support of the civil power in the maintenance of the law and order". So dont make fool of the people you dumb ass go and read the document first and then speak Idiot.
@@DocAliAdus and also it was not the election which was suppose to happen stupid it was Plebiscite you stupid.
Yes you are right
@@DocAliAdus India never withdraw their army from Kashmir that’s why still we are suffering because of Indian Army
CRPF had shed blood of Every Kashmiri you know send that’s why as a Kashmiri I hate India
❤️ 🇮🇳 from Srinagar ❤️❤️
Kashmiri's Never loved Pakistan. You just love us, we will give you tons back ❤️
Thanks brother
It's legally belongs to India every inch.. why UN couldn't force other nations like Pakistan and china to surrender occupied lands to India ?
People forget to mention that the Kashmiri's started a re billion after the massacre of Muslims by the state forces of maharaja who asked all the Muslim soldiers hand in their guns thus starting the war.
After Independence all Hindu king of India suffers a lot even after giving everything to our country they still recognise as villans and those Mughals who was real villan called hero all muslim rulers left India after independence with their assets
I HAVE BEEN USING TH-cam 4 LONG.....BUT AFTER VIEWING YOUR VIDEOS I FELT...TAT U R THE BEST..TRUST ME.....GOD BLESS
India was not born on 1947 , india got independence from british in 1947 , pakistan was born in 1947
Wasn't India like a bunch of kingdoms before that were not unified into 1 country?
10:32 can anyone name backgorund piano music name
Maharaja Ghulab singh was already the Raja of Jammu in 1821, he bought Kashmir for 75 lakh nanakshahi rupees in 1846
Bisbo makes things very clear ,as clear as it could be !
No one should invade kashmir neither india nor Pakistan.. But it's history now the people of kashmir suffering...
Those who still thinks that Nehru's fault was china but not but if u see the timeline of indipendence u will notice that India got independent in 1947 ,at the time of independence,india was suffering from caste discrimination child marriage and Illetracy. When india ws moving to industrialization, china attacked india but nehru knew that they will attack but nehru was trying to be defensive but at that time india could not produce China's ammunition like artillery,tanks and rpg. We cannot blame nehru,we should blame defence minister Krishna Menon who was in England.
India dint get birth on 1947.
India only got Independence from British in 1947....
India was there since Vedic age.
India is mentioned in Garud puran also.from Himalaya to Sea, its clearly mentioned.
Only pakistan got birth in 1947 and also got independence on same day
Tune kbhi school ki kitab bhi pdi
*Republic* of India came into existence on 1947.
Everyday I am learning new facts from this channel 👍
But someone else in your comment section has pointed out that you missed Simla accord 1972 which is crucial for this subject, without that the video is incomplete.
Kashmir is a border state. India will defend it at any cost. Terrorism, Pakistan support etc wont deter India.
bold contents!! kudos to you brother!!
hai baiya i need this video for my class project presentation can i have the copyrights
pleas
In fact we Kashmiris have been deceived by everyone we trusted. 😢
@Amardeep Pandey Don't say like this, we are their's and they are our's. We both should love and need each other. Aisa zabardasti ka aisaan nhi dikhana chahiye.
Right to education came into existence after repealing of 370.
now Kashmir is Heaven, Happy and Safe.
Both countries are responsible for current situation in #Kashmir
Spare us you both 👏🏻
You explain so welll
Why indiragandhi exchanged 90000 pak prisoners for nothing?Big blunders in indian history
Shaikh Abdullah a pro India leader!!!
Waah....
Yes
Haha...such a joke this video creator made 😅
Get the 3 steps on kashmir resolution passed in UN proprerly.your no 2 point is completely incorrect
Good topic and very nice bisbo 👌
Thanks Shashi
9:59 Stupid Bisbo people, Indira Gandhi was forced to hand-over the 93000+ Prisoners of War (PoWs) because 🇵🇰 went to the International Court of Justice and also because of diplomatic pressure from the 🇺🇸. In exchange, both 🇮🇳 and 🇵🇰 signed the Simla Agreement in 1972 according to which all disputes between 🇮🇳 and 🇵🇰 must be resolved bilaterally.
😂 😂 Poor brainless people of paadistan.. You believe everything your politicians say! 😂
RitzZy Channel u do too
@@mohammadali3711 true...this thing happens in both the nations but the people have to be smart about it,hell in india media is bought by modi govt. But idk much about Pakistan
Lure Gamsta the governments in both countries are less of democracy and more like a dictatorship where the government pays the Media hires mobs to take down opponents and but modi has brought hell in india i Remember manmohan singhs government things were better pak india relations were getting better between the two now the people are suffering
ps where did china came from into this
Please Make A Video On China Occupied Kashmir
It doesn't have any story, nobody, literally no one, lives there. It's just a barren land. That's why nobody talks about it.
You mean aksai chin, it's just a barren land like tibet
@@apogeelord7013
Even Nehru said d same in order to cover it's defeat.
If aksai chin has no importance they v did China captured it in first place?
Aksai chin is strategically very significant as it connects east Turkistan (now Xinjiang) with Tibet, both captured by PLA.
@@rohandalvi8045 I don't know much about the conflict, but, based on my limited understanding, i know that there are hardly any people living there, it's a barren land and whole region has a population of not more than 100-500 people, and those people are just nomads who minds their own business, they dont care about India or China, that's why none of them raise their voice.
Even Geographically, this region is easily accessible to China, due to relatively flat area between Aksai Chin and rest of the nearby cities/towns of China. In India's case, there are lot of geographical obstacles to reach Aksai Chin from Ladakh. That might be the reason why China was able to capture this region, Another fact is that India didn't even realize that the Chinese had already occupied this land, until 1950s.
Half of j and k is ladakh which is barren land like tibet..lush green heavrly areas of kashmir is the gilgit baltistan
@bisbo An unbiased view of theKashmir issue. Really proud of you man. Keep up the good work.
Thanks
I would love to do a video on how u where born or on your family and telling anything i feel like in that video as you did in this video .. what is your source of information ?
Biggest blunder of His excellency Maharaja Hari Singh.Not signing the merger agreement and wanting kashmir a independent was the biggest blunder of modern Indian history....
He was hoping to have a strong economy selling Saffron 🤣
@@DIYBill No reality is that,Maharaja wanted to Make J&K like Switzerland and don't liked both nehru and Jinnah , We would be More Richer if pakistan didn't attacked us .
Please make a video on how Aksai Chin is made
@Kashif jihadis calling themselves kashmiris having pakistani daddys😂😂😂😂. Anyway the dispatch of jihadis in kashmir is in full swing. Save urself too otherwise ur arse will be handed to jannat. Lmao
Apart from many pronunciation mistakes like Thermo-pee-laye is how it's actually pronounced... There are grave misinterpretations and inaccuracies about the policies and events.
Pradhanmantri II in my opinion has the best report on this.
In that series Karan Singh clearly mentions that Kashmir had already acceded to India but Nehru refused to accept it until Sheikh Abdullah was made the PM. That was Nehru's demand. He was also the one who proposed the plebiscite while SVP clearly mentioned that the accession is complete under British authorities.
The animations add cheer to the video. Good job 👍
Thanks Ferdinand
I love your content.
Your last line is wrong. Kashmir issue is still not over. What do you think with removal of article 370 the Kashmir issue is solved. Only God knows when this issue will be resolved amicably.
One correction: it's col. Devan Ranjith Rai and not Pai.
From a secular standpoint....it can either be an Indian state or Independent....but the way the majority has behaved ...it should certainly be part of India as we know how to live with each other despite our differences.
Jammu and Kashmir never ever merged in India or agreed upon merging.
Good information 👍🙏
Love from j&k
Bisbo is my fav channel
Thanks Sangeetha
Sangeetha Garu plz don't fall for screen hypnosis ,plz do your own research about everything and then only come to conclusion !
Thank you for unbiased content!!
Outstanding dear
Aug 1946? Did you turn back the clock to grant Pak nationhood a year earlier
2 countries were not born rather 1 small part was cut from a bigger country by force(DA day)
Yeap hindu colonialists definitely like to think that way
Unfortunately we people of J&K hardly know about the sacrifice of Brig. Rajinder Singh. Had he not been there, we would have lost our land.
Xcllent explanation
Repeat with me Jammu and Kashmir princely state , Jammu is not Kashmir, Ladhak is not Kashmir
As a Nation, Pakistan it's first decision on 12th September, 1947 and bloddy war is thier first decision after being formed as a Nation.
WoW !! The first decision was to remove the army checkpoints in the northern areas so that the people do not feel captured and join Pakistan which they did !!
People forget to mention that the Kashmiri's started a re billion after the massacre of Muslims by the state forces of maharaja who asked all the Muslim soldiers hand in their guns thus starting the war.
200,000 Muslims were driven to Pakistan where their horror stories led the pashtuns to invade Kashmir on their own !!
@@omerashraf9357 ksko samjya rahey bhai ye indian ko jhoot k ilawa aata he kya hai bolna even this one is propaganda video keh kya raha suno tou jinnah said eid Srinagar mein manaounga 😂😂👌lolz matlb sirf eid mananey karachi se srinagar jatey mjhe tou smajh nai aati en indian ki ab tou ye chutiyon se zyada masoom lagte hain lolz👌😂or enki public talinya bhe bajati hai aesi cheezein dekh kr bger sochay samjhe chalo kher hamarey liye tou entertainment ka saman krdete hain parosi kmaz km
Gr8 video
Jai Nehru! The world of today can never realize the struggles of India in 1947. With just a Corona we are struggling. Imagine those times!!
Fuck Nehru he just created problems Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel was the one trying to solve the problems. I mean Nehru was also trying to but in a wrong and blind way.
But I am happy that Modi solved the problem but to gain the full territory India must start a war with Pakistan coz Pakistanis ain't gonna give it up easily.
@@AnIndianPatriot things weren't so easy then.... India was a toddler..Sardarji had the skill to unite India and Nehruji had the skill to rule a country of various ethnicity and religions.. that's why we are still not a religious fundamentalist state like Pakisthan...we are born here to correct the mistakes of last generations not to blame everything on them
fuck nehru, tibet gone, kashmir gone
@@rhvc2734 What did Gandhi said about the Moplah Massacre of Hindus or the Direct Action Day? When Sardar Vallabhbhai Patelji was the most favoured one to become PM, why Gandhi chooses Nehru as PM? Why Waqf Board have so many powerful rights given but not a single Hindu board is there in existence and about rights, it's far talk?
Please remove the video and reupload it after making correction.
Everything is fine
Bisbo please make a video on violent Exodus of Kashmiri Pandits and the atrocities committed against them
He must also include how the governor at the time didn't do anything about it. He didn't appeal for PR to be imposed or the centre send in the army.
i think you should convert this video in hindi language also............its a very good and effictive, and informative video......
India a secular country
Pak a Islamic country
If pak declared as Islamic Republic... What is the need to talk about Hindus and other minorites there.....
But in India Govts(Congress govts) we're given First priority to MINORITIES.... Then where should Hindus go......
Nice video
1947 aug 14
Yes
He wanted our state to be beaautifull and neutral like switzerland
Nice
Than people say don't vote BJP 🙄 oo bhaii modi ne kmal kr diya jo congress ke itne log na kr paye
Ha bhai pura desh ka satyanash KR diya
this is true.....
Sir one video for annexation of goa
Nice piece of history between India and Pakistan. Love from Nepal.
Lieutenant Colonel Dewan Ranjit Rai, not Pai
I love u bisbo
14th August, 1947... these kind of mistakes are not acceptable from a channel like yours.
Yes apologies
@@BisboWorld you should re-upload instead of apology
All they have done is, they didn't listened to people of Kashmir. just for some worldly pleasures.wah..
Chachaji was aspirant of Nobel peace prize, so he let China to capture Aksaichin. Behenji was on the foot steps of Chachaji so she released prisoners of war. None got Nobel peace prize. But India lost its territory. So sad.
India lost the 1962 war. That's why china occupied as aksai chin.
Animations are so sweet! Love from Jammu!
Well , Kashmir is an inseparable part of India and it is never going to be taken away from us now .
Great work bisbo
Thanks Sreelatha
Sorry brag. Rajinder Singh is from jammu kashmir inflaintry which was king army
Why don't u make a video on Nepal??
Hibro. start with little earlier history from kashmiri pandits who were driven out from their homeland
I feel sorry for hari singh
Why? He wasn't a popular king anyway and was largely detested by the people.
Jawahar lal nehru is the biggest mistake india have ever made🥵🥵
Sardar vallabhai you are only excellent leader of INC
everyone has an opinion about Kashmir, other than kashmiris
Kashmiri Pandits 😭
@@sakshathprabhu4989 bro kashmir is incomplete without them
@Factfully Indian 4,00,00,000 pandits refugees in their owncountry...its a shame on all successive govts
@@priyajoseph7108 j k population 1.25 crores already a muslim majority how can there be 4 crore kashmiri pandith refugees
@Krish Mehta 4 lalkh zero lgta gya 😂😂😂
I have criticized Bisbo on a few videos, but this one is beautifully and aptly made. Congrats.
Long live PM. Modi, For he has finally recognized Kashmir is ours (INDIA) and is doing whatever possible to keep it ours .....................
Jai Hind.
Dude, if you are to cover something that is very debated about from history, you should do better research and get your dates right.
I can't understand why people never blame Hari Singh for todays Kashmir's situation
Ancient Hindu Buddhist periods of Kashmir should have been depicted in the first few slides
Nehru didnt want to go beyond valley coz Sheikh Abdullah said he (Sheikh) didnt have influence beyond that. Asshole Nehru agreed and stop Indian Army from moving forward. Because of him and listening to Mountbatten, India still cries today!
Make video on junagadh and haidrabad independence . And one more Goa independence 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 please sir. I request you 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Some light on 1947 Jammu massacre?
Refer A G Noorani
Why Carol of bells in the end?
Yea why?
I thought it had some deep meaning.
3:11 this could have not been possible ,as the flow of jehlem is opposite,
This one video scrapped away the good opinions on all of your other videos raising doubts of authenticity and facts