@@fazliddinerkaboyev6568 You have misunderstood the commenter's point. Fazil Say is a composer and Alain Altinoglu is a conductor. And it most certainly is fun.
Der zweite Satz hat es bewiesen: Bach hat nicht nur das Barock vollendet, sondern die Romantik gleich mit erfunden. In diesem Satz war ich im Paradies.
Lebhafte und wunderschöne Aufführung dieses perfekt komponierten Konzerts mit klaren Klänge beider genialen Soloklaviere sowie gut harmonisierten und perfekt entsprechenden Tönen der anderen Instrumente. Der zweite Satz klingt besonders schön und echt beruhigend. Im Kontrast klingt der dritte Satz echt lebhaft und auch begeisternd. Der intelligente Pianist-Dirigent leitet das kompakte und ausgezzeichnete Orchester im veränderlichen Tempo und mit perfekt kontrollierter Dynamik. Einfach wunderbar!
Außergewöhnliche und wunderschöne Aufführung dieses perfekt komponierten Konzerts mit klar artikulierten Tönen der beiden virtuosen Soloklaviere und perfekt entsprechenden Tönen des ausgezeichenten hr-Sinfonieorchesters. Die Miteinanderwirkung zwischen dem türkischen Komponisten-Pianisten, dem französischen Dirigenten-Pianisten mit dem deutschen hr-Sinfonieorchester ist wirklich bewundernswert. Danke fürs Hochladen!
This really makes no sense. Do harpsichordist perform the Brahms concertos on the harpsichord? Of course they don't. So why do modern pianists still dare to bother us with Bach on the Steinway? Apart from the organological problem there is a musical one. There no phrasing in this performance, it sounds like a never ending factory of 16th notes, no the slightest touch of rubato not counting the "romantic" ritardandi at the end of the movements. The least one would expect are the trills taken from the upper notes, but even this moat simple rule of historical performance practice has been ignored here. A total anachronism.
You are absolutely right in every musical aspect. But the thing with Bach is that his music is so heavenly beautiful that it sounds good even this way. And if that makes more people listen to Bach, it makes our world a better place..
If Brahms on a harpsichord would sound great (or at least interesting), who would object? As long as it is expressing an artistic idea, I don't mind the occasional anachronism.
@@niek024 but Brahms on the harpsichord doesn't sound great. Does Bach on Steinway sounds great? No more than Brahms on the harpsichord, people are just used to it without reflecting too much.
@@rubreaker1 It clearly also is a matter of taste. I know that, puristically, Bach 'should' be played on a harpsichord, but I think it sounds amazing on a modern grand piano.
Why not have a go at the orchestra, while you're at it. Gut strings? Baroque bows? And then, what type of harpsichord? One that Bach would have used in the 1730s, or just any old harpsichord? Bach was quite happy to transcribe Italian violin concertos for harpsichord and organ. This very two-harpsichord concerto was (probably) originally composed for violin and oboe. Bach was no pedantic purist. I enjoyed this performance; I disagree that there was no phrasing; I even noted a few touches of expressive alterations of tempo (which I suppose is what you mean wrongly by rubato). I thought the jury was out about final ritardandi, but perhaps you can point me to the latest definitive statements of musicologists. In any case, it is a performance for today, not a museum replica. Of course it is anachronistic. Brahms on a harpsichord? Some pieces, possibly. But it is easier to imitate a harpsichord on a Steinway (if that is what you want to do) than the other way round.
Beeing a person who believes Bach also can be played on modern pianos I like this very much!
Alain Altinoglu conducting and playing the piano~ Nice~~!
A musical feast! Fantastically played!!❤❤
L'orchestre est une nouvelle fois excellent. Merci.
Les pianistes illuminent cette œuvre de Bach. Bravo.
Das Schönste was ich in der letzten Zeit gehört habe,vielen Dank❤
Two brilliant musicians playing harmoniously together! Thanks to both of them.
Ay algo más que dos músicos ahí, quítales la orquesta a ver si te gusta tanto, aunque no te fijes en ella
Composer and conductor as soloists? How fun!!
It's not fun. Even Zimmerman did this while Beethoven's piano concerto №2 was being performed by him.
@@fazliddinerkaboyev6568 You have misunderstood the commenter's point. Fazil Say is a composer and Alain Altinoglu is a conductor. And it most certainly is fun.
@@willcwhite Aha, now I got. 😄🫶
Einfach überwältigend schön! Vielen herzlichen Dank 🤗 👍 🌻
Meisterklasse👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Der zweite Satz hat es bewiesen: Bach hat nicht nur das Barock vollendet, sondern die Romantik gleich mit erfunden. In diesem Satz war ich im Paradies.
Lebhafte und wunderschöne Aufführung dieses perfekt komponierten Konzerts mit klaren Klänge beider genialen Soloklaviere sowie gut harmonisierten und perfekt entsprechenden Tönen der anderen Instrumente. Der zweite Satz klingt besonders schön und echt beruhigend. Im Kontrast klingt der dritte Satz echt lebhaft und auch begeisternd. Der intelligente Pianist-Dirigent leitet das kompakte und ausgezzeichnete Orchester im veränderlichen Tempo und mit perfekt kontrollierter Dynamik. Einfach wunderbar!
Amazing performance!
Very interesting communication and coordination of the two pianists! Thank you!
Чудесный оркестр исполняет божественного Баха! Большое спасибо!
Ich war live dabei.
Außergewöhnliche und wunderschöne Aufführung dieses perfekt komponierten Konzerts mit klar artikulierten Tönen der beiden virtuosen Soloklaviere und perfekt entsprechenden Tönen des ausgezeichenten hr-Sinfonieorchesters. Die Miteinanderwirkung zwischen dem türkischen Komponisten-Pianisten, dem französischen Dirigenten-Pianisten mit dem deutschen hr-Sinfonieorchester ist wirklich bewundernswert. Danke fürs Hochladen!
Браво❤ пианистам и оркестру! Bravo❤
Very joyfull!! Thank you for posting!
I like Fazil Says expressions and moves, specially in the second movement. Contributes to the music.
Wonderful!!
Fantastic performance!
Großartig!
Üstadladlar, müzikalitenize sağlık! ❤
Lovely beautiful thankyou🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤❤❤
Splendid !!! 💐
Danke für die Möglichkeit zur kostenlosen Musikbildung aus dem Wohnzimmer!
I just which I was there. Pure joy 1:42
Amazing! 👍🏻👍🏻🔥🔥🔥🤯
Enjoyable
Excelente
А как современно звучит здесь Бах..!
🎉Foarte interesant.
Bach si the GOAT
🙏
Wait, Bach himself also arranged the Double Violin for two pianos?
♥️🌹
❤
Alain Delon in der musikalischen Welt!
😂😂😂
❤💃💃
亡き愛川欽也さんにそっくりと思うのは自分だでしょうか？ ピアノうまいねー😂
Der neue Glenn Gould?
This really makes no sense. Do harpsichordist perform the Brahms concertos on the harpsichord? Of course they don't. So why do modern pianists still dare to bother us with Bach on the Steinway? Apart from the organological problem there is a musical one. There no phrasing in this performance, it sounds like a never ending factory of 16th notes, no the slightest touch of rubato not counting the "romantic" ritardandi at the end of the movements. The least one would expect are the trills taken from the upper notes, but even this moat simple rule of historical performance practice has been ignored here. A total anachronism.
You are absolutely right in every musical aspect.
But the thing with Bach is that his music is so heavenly beautiful that it sounds good even this way.
And if that makes more people listen to Bach, it makes our world a better place..
If Brahms on a harpsichord would sound great (or at least interesting), who would object?
As long as it is expressing an artistic idea, I don't mind the occasional anachronism.
@@niek024 but Brahms on the harpsichord doesn't sound great. Does Bach on Steinway sounds great? No more than Brahms on the harpsichord, people are just used to it without reflecting too much.
@@rubreaker1 It clearly also is a matter of taste. I know that, puristically, Bach 'should' be played on a harpsichord, but I think it sounds amazing on a modern grand piano.
Why not have a go at the orchestra, while you're at it. Gut strings? Baroque bows? And then, what type of harpsichord? One that Bach would have used in the 1730s, or just any old harpsichord? Bach was quite happy to transcribe Italian violin concertos for harpsichord and organ. This very two-harpsichord concerto was (probably) originally composed for violin and oboe. Bach was no pedantic purist.
I enjoyed this performance; I disagree that there was no phrasing; I even noted a few touches of expressive alterations of tempo (which I suppose is what you mean wrongly by rubato). I thought the jury was out about final ritardandi, but perhaps you can point me to the latest definitive statements of musicologists. In any case, it is a performance for today, not a museum replica. Of course it is anachronistic.
Brahms on a harpsichord? Some pieces, possibly. But it is easier to imitate a harpsichord on a Steinway (if that is what you want to do) than the other way round.
Großartig!
❤