@@AeroGold1 yeah but full of forgettable characters. They needed some more scenes like that fire camp scene in Solo. Something to make you care for them. Mandalorian looks good so far tho. Best thing disney did with starwars so far.
I know the main characters aren’t the most popular but I think rogue one is the best Disney Star Wars film yet. I never expected Disney to kill all of the protagonists Off but it made the whole story so much better
no it didn't. there's basically no character development whatsoever in this movie so you don't care about the cast when they die. they killed everyone to explain why they don't appear in any other star wars media, it wasn't some "risk" by disney. stop being so naive
@@wolfgangrecordings It's a war movie. Characters don't sit around and espouse their backstory and motivations. Their character lies in their actions during the movie. Besides...it's not like there was such great characterization in ANH... Lucas just stuck to basic archetypes. The farm boy. The princess. The scoundrel. You're just looking for reasons to have a chapped ass.
At The Accident Solo managed to destroy the whole mythos of Han Solo. With that movie every single achievement of his life occurred in one afternoon. Now, He is like the football player that once won a match in high school , and keeps talking about his 5 minutes of glory during his whole life.
there is no heart to this film. the characters are, for the most part, vapid and disinteresting. "what they do" looks spectacular, as everything does nowadays, and that's all. rogue one fans are deluded
I enjoyed Rogue One. It is a great Star Wars film in the tradition of the first episodes released in the 70’s and 80’s. It really helped fill in some of the major gaps between the prequels and the originals. It gave answers to the questions because of the gap between episodes 1-3 and episodes 4-6. It was a very well done movie.
I just rewatched Rogue One, did’nt enjoy it the first time, but found it amazing now. It really is a star wars story. When the rebel alliance showed up at Scarif, not gonna lie….i got choked up, didnt expect to get so emotional. The cameos are just perfect.
Just finished Rogue One for the 2nd time after finishing Andor yesterday. This movie after Andor makes more sense to me. It was superb, the actor who plays as Andor is highly underrated. Enjoyed Andor and Rogue one back to back in last 3 days, what a treat😊
When Rogue one first came out I called it outside of the O.G trilogy the "Most Star Warsy Star Wars movie to have Star Warsed." Because it gives you everything you love about Star Wars often unapologetic in its doing so :).
absolutely i'm glad that this movie is on Disney+ , awesome stuff, and also a lot of brilliant heart to this film, a lot of stuff they really did on their craft of this movie
the T-15/T-17 line is actually a running joke in the movies. i believe there's a line about the T-16 being marked obsolete in the original trilogy (Luke was supposed to have a T-16 sitting in the "garage" but they couldn't finish building it before shooting so, instead, they had Luke play with a toy model of it)
I really dont know why people dont like this movie! This is the best movie Disney has made for Starwars yet Better than TFA, TLJ, Solo, and lets see about TRS
CuppaTeaExe Rogue One is good, it’s a good film. The Force Awakens, however, that’s a great film. And The Last Jedi (being that it’s as good as The Empire Strikes Back) is a brilliant film. Rated; 1. The Empire Strikes Back/ The Last Jedi 2. Star Wars (the original theatrical version) 3. The Force Awakens 4. Rogue One/ Solo 5. The Phantom Menace 6. Revenge of the Sith 7. Attack of the Clones
Yes, because there is no opening crawl to Rogue One and the quoted section you have there was him referring to the plot of Rogue One, not ANH. So it was a random grab of Star Wars' opening crawl text they used for the simple visual; it didn't matter which ones they showed since none of them describe the plot to Rogue One.
I cheered for the Star Wars stuff I recognize from Star Wars in a Star Wars movie taking place during the Original Star Wars Trilogy. And I didn’t cheer and got bored when they tried to do something original that doesn’t remind me of Star Wars stuff from a Star Wars movie taking place during the Original Star Wars Trilogy!
This movie Is how you make me love Star Wars Without the iconic lightsaber duels The fan service of vader helped definitely but still this was a fantastic movie
Hmmm. I did not get the sense the broken door that the rebel fleet troopers could not get through was a result of Vader using the force on it. I just thought it was one of those unfortunate things when a ship gets rocked around in battle. What makes you think it was Vader who was keeping it from opening?
I'm not sure if it relates directly to troopers talking about T-15s & 17s but in ANH in one of the tractor beam scenes two stormtroopers talk about VT-16s.
Rogue One is the second best Star Wars movie after Empire Strikes Back. It has everything a good space sifi movie needs. That Vader scene is beyond compare to any other scene in the collection
In the book Star Wars from a certain point of view you find out in the first story that the ship was under repair (hence why it was docked in the profundity) and is leaking some easily traceable energy signature. They knew that it would happen and also knew their hyperdrive would break but hoped they could make it to tatooine, dock the ship and change ship. Unfortunately for them it broke just seconds to early, the devastating arrives and the rest is history
Rogue one movie gives you the beginning that was missing from the first star wars movie to see how it started from the ships shooting at each other what happened before
rogue 1 I'd by far the best Disney star wars film that they have done and I think that it absolutely will stand the test of time.... When it was a kid, and had the trilogy on VHS, I used to watch them over and over and over. I can do that with rogue one. I think that it's done so well. From the plot... To the time period... It's amazing
Maybe an Easter egg that only recently shed light... one of the file names from the vault on Scarif was Black Saber, referencing the fact that the Empire was in possession of the dark saber. Is this actually correct?
I consider ROGUE ONE as Episode 3.5 of the Star Wars saga. Orders of magnitude better than any of the crappy movies in JJ Abrams ending trilogy. And ANDOR as the best of all the Star Wars TV series.
Outstanding movie. Only one thing bothers me.... They transmitted the plans up from the surface. Why didn't EVERY ship in the fleet receive them? And then bolt off in different directions.
The escape pods were gonna be used by the crew and dignitaries to escape when they arrived but in their rush to escape they ended up to far out from the planet which allowed Vader to catch them.
Hey, I just want to point out that 11 minutes 15 seconds in to Rogue One one of the giant statues from the latest trailers of rise of Skywalker shows up.
Still think the Tauntive should have been just outside of the system and another com ship kicking that signal to them. It should never been onsite at the battle. It’s too risky given Leia’s standing as member of the Organa family and nullifies the whole pretense thing going on at the beginning of ANH. It would be pointless to argue with Vader is he SAW your ship at the battle. It also nullifies the statement of the Imperial Officer to Vader about word of them capturing the ship getting out to the Senate. What would it matter if they were seen at the battle?
rogue one is so underrated. i rarely ever hear people say it’s their favorite Star Wars film, but it’s definitely one of the best!
It's literally one of my favorite movies
Interesting, almost half of my friends say it’s their favorite
It’s easily my fave Star Wars film by far
It is my favourite Star Wars film, by far.
yeah there's a reason for that mate hahahahahahaha
This movie really put the war in star wars
Agreed.
Best of the Disney made Star Wars movies by far.
@@AeroGold1 yeah but full of forgettable characters. They needed some more scenes like that fire camp scene in Solo. Something to make you care for them.
Mandalorian looks good so far tho. Best thing disney did with starwars so far.
without this movie, star wars would just be...stars
@@AeroGold1 couldn't agree more
Anyone remember how emotional the ending was seeing it in the theater for the first time?
I remember how bored and disappointed I was... does that count?
I saw it and then a few hours later the news that Carrie had had a heart attack on the plane came through. I was in bits.
Not going to lie. I teared up
I didn't see it in theatres. TFA drained all of my trust in Disney and Star Wars. I wish I had seen it in theatres though.
@@mykiamoto7145 Same. I expected that they would get away somehow. Then they got incinerated. Really shocked me.
I know the main characters aren’t the most popular but I think rogue one is the best Disney Star Wars film yet. I never expected Disney to kill all of the protagonists
Off but it made the whole story so much better
no it didn't. there's basically no character development whatsoever in this movie so you don't care about the cast when they die. they killed everyone to explain why they don't appear in any other star wars media, it wasn't some "risk" by disney. stop being so naive
@@wolfgangrecordings they also fixed a plot hole long lasted 30 years. Plus that usage of old red-squadron footage is out of this world..
@@wolfgangrecordings It's a war movie. Characters don't sit around and espouse their backstory and motivations. Their character lies in their actions during the movie. Besides...it's not like there was such great characterization in ANH... Lucas just stuck to basic archetypes. The farm boy. The princess. The scoundrel. You're just looking for reasons to have a chapped ass.
At The Accident Solo managed to destroy the whole mythos of Han Solo. With that movie every single achievement of his life occurred in one afternoon. Now, He is like the football player that once won a match in high school , and keeps talking about his 5 minutes of glory during his whole life.
RedNine To be fair, we didn’t need to have that plot hole filled lol.
There is a brilliant heart to this film; one about the characters, more about what they do, rather than how it looks when they do it.
AND the best two robots.
there is no heart to this film. the characters are, for the most part, vapid and disinteresting. "what they do" looks spectacular, as everything does nowadays, and that's all. rogue one fans are deluded
@@wolfgangrecordings thank you!
Rogue One is awesome. I rank it right up there with the original trilogy.
It may just be my favorite SW movie. It's a behind the scenes documentary. Loved it
This did so much for the whole plot. It really makes Episode 4 a lot more understandable.
I enjoyed Rogue One. It is a great Star Wars film in the tradition of the first episodes released in the 70’s and 80’s. It really helped fill in some of the major gaps between the prequels and the originals. It gave answers to the questions because of the gap between episodes 1-3 and episodes 4-6. It was a very well done movie.
I just rewatched Rogue One, did’nt enjoy it the first time, but found it amazing now. It really is a star wars story. When the rebel alliance showed up at Scarif, not gonna lie….i got choked up, didnt expect to get so emotional. The cameos are just perfect.
I’ll say it - Rogue One is my favorite Star Wars film! There’s just something so special about it among Star Wars movies.
Rogue One is my favorite Star Wars movie, easily.
Yes. I agree.
I might agree ( outside of the OT )
Got to see this on opening day at the cinemas. Got the dvd on day of release & took the day off work & watched it 4 times in a row!!! BEST DAY EVER!!!
Rogue One is probably my fav Star Wars movie. It took a world I've loved since childhood and made it better and more "real".
I like how they had the Star wars Rebel cameos
Fr I loved that it really foreshadowed it alot.
Rebels is garbage though
As of now Rogue One is the best Star Wars yet although the ending broke my heart into pieces I may never recover from. Well until I saw baby Yoda.
That wasn't baby Yoda tho ... it was the same species ...
@@RegulaRegz732 a baby "yodian"?
@@RegulaRegz732 baby yoda
Don’t forget that “Baby Yoda” is the 3rd “Yoda Species” (Unknown) we have seen. Yoda, Yaddle (Jedi Council Member), and Now this little thing 👍
cooltriplets_2 I didn’t know what else to call it lol so it’s baby yoda till they tell us differently lmbo
The ghost is also shown in the overhead hanger shot
Just finished Rogue One for the 2nd time after finishing Andor yesterday.
This movie after Andor makes more sense to me.
It was superb, the actor who plays as Andor is highly underrated.
Enjoyed Andor and Rogue one back to back in last 3 days, what a treat😊
When Rogue one first came out I called it outside of the O.G trilogy the "Most Star Warsy Star Wars movie to have Star Warsed." Because it gives you everything you love about Star Wars often unapologetic in its doing so :).
rogue one is my favorite movie of all time
Rogue One is the best film in a long time. It is more adult themed, and has a very good plot with tie ins to the canon movies
No way did he use Monday to prepare this video.
Very, very underrated Star Wars movie in my opinion
Well this just makes me love it more.
I just watched this video again after Andor season 1 finished. This movie is even more strong and emotional after it!
So this is just a 12 minute advert for a f*cking spreadsheet?
basically yeah
nice
"I'm on a diplomatic mission to alderon" Vader like....seriously.....I followed you here from the rebel fight
absolutely i'm glad that this movie is on Disney+ , awesome stuff, and also a lot of brilliant heart to this film, a lot of stuff they really did on their craft of this movie
Yes, yes, and yes. I missed so many of these. Thanks.
Rogue One deserves even more credit considering a good chunk of the original cut was re-shot to become the final product.
Hoss Windu why does that give it extra credit
Rogue One is hands down my favorite star wars film
Lah’ Mu is a Nemoidian word for “Prosper”
What's "Nemoidian"?
Dominic Crimmings nute gunrays language
Rogue one needs more credit. I loved it better then the anakin origins except when he becomes vader.
no it doesn't
@Leopold Black. Let people have their opinions and stfu
Rogue One is my favorite Star Wars... and I have seen them all when they initially came out.
i live the fact that it features chopper the ghost hera etc because it just brings more “good” to it
the T-15/T-17 line is actually a running joke in the movies. i believe there's a line about the T-16 being marked obsolete in the original trilogy (Luke was supposed to have a T-16 sitting in the "garage" but they couldn't finish building it before shooting so, instead, they had Luke play with a toy model of it)
The continuity is just fascinating
Thanks, I’m a huge Star Wars fan, so this is amazing. Again thanks
Rogue one is my favorite star wars film. PERIODT!
I really dont know why people dont like this movie!
This is the best movie Disney has made for Starwars yet
Better than TFA, TLJ, Solo, and lets see about TRS
CuppaTeaExe Rogue One is good, it’s a good film. The Force Awakens, however, that’s a great film. And The Last Jedi (being that it’s as good as The Empire Strikes Back) is a brilliant film.
Rated;
1. The Empire Strikes Back/ The Last Jedi
2. Star Wars (the original theatrical version)
3. The Force Awakens
4. Rogue One/ Solo
5. The Phantom Menace
6. Revenge of the Sith
7. Attack of the Clones
I recommend the book rebel rising for the backstory of Jyn Erso. Its really good
Cmc PRO-ductions is it good?
@@igonzalez0 if I say it's really good, what do you think
@@movieguyproductions4865 that it is better than that hehehe ... Cheers!!
I thoroughly enjoyed it. The visuals were on point for a star wars film while also making it somewhat a war documentary.
Rogue One is among my favorites.
"Described in a few yellow words"
Shows opening crawl to ESB not ANH, lol.
Yes, because there is no opening crawl to Rogue One and the quoted section you have there was him referring to the plot of Rogue One, not ANH. So it was a random grab of Star Wars' opening crawl text they used for the simple visual; it didn't matter which ones they showed since none of them describe the plot to Rogue One.
Garreth Edwards did such a great job so tv this movie. It’s definitely one of my favorites in the Star Wars line up
8:57 I really went crazy when i saw those guys again!
7:44 Weird how nobody noticed that the 2 stormtroopers that entered the shuttle got replaced by an Enforcer Droid.
"Rogue One" and "Rebels" are the only disney star wars that are worth anything. I LOVE BOTH OF THEM!
You totally forgot about The Mandalorian
@@darthmalus2198 You're right, I forgot. From what I've seen, I won't pay for disney +, it looks and feels like STAR WARS should.
This movie gets better with time. I remember wanting to watch the originals immediately after this.
Hammerhead corvettes were stolen by Leia in an episode of Rebels
no, they were stolen by the rebels. Leia didn't steal anything
stolen from leia
I cheered for the Star Wars stuff I recognize from Star Wars in a Star Wars movie taking place during the Original Star Wars Trilogy. And I didn’t cheer and got bored when they tried to do something original that doesn’t remind me of Star Wars stuff from a Star Wars movie taking place during the Original Star Wars Trilogy!
After seeing this I can’t wait to see Andor on Disney+
In MY opinion, it's my favorite movie, PERIOD! Not just of SW, but it's my favorite movie of all time! So so so good!
Excellent video. Certainly this movie has one of the best Vader moments of all the movies.
If Jin’s mom had been a better shot and killed Krenick, this would have been so different!!😂
2:36 I actually spotted that in the movie!
This movie
Is how you make me love Star Wars
Without the iconic lightsaber duels
The fan service of vader helped definitely but still this was a fantastic movie
Hmmm. I did not get the sense the broken door that the rebel fleet troopers could not get through was a result of Vader using the force on it. I just thought it was one of those unfortunate things when a ship gets rocked around in battle. What makes you think it was Vader who was keeping it from opening?
Rogue One is one of the best star wars movies!'
Rouge One is a really good Star Wars story. Maybe not a full Star Wars movie, but at least its story. It feels like the original Trilogy
There's no movie called Rouge One.
I think that k2S0 copied himself into the other droid and he somehow got away
It would be amazing if that happens
thats wut hishe did
Who?
@@krustykfc8911 how it should have ended. They are a great channel. Check em out
Ohhhh them
Im ligit subbed to them
I didnt know they did rouge one tho lol
The end of this movie was so sad. We knew everyone would die as they weren’t in any other films, which just made it more painful.
I'm not sure if it relates directly to troopers talking about T-15s & 17s but in ANH in one of the tractor beam scenes two stormtroopers talk about VT-16s.
Been looking to see if anyone mentioned this :)
Rogue One is the second best Star Wars movie after Empire Strikes Back. It has everything a good space sifi movie needs. That Vader scene is beyond compare to any other scene in the collection
I honestly thought rogue one was top 2 of the whole star wars saga.
given how the movie ends it seems like they already had some early hyperspace tracking. how else would Vader have tracked them down so quickly.
The force
In the book Star Wars from a certain point of view you find out in the first story that the ship was under repair (hence why it was docked in the profundity) and is leaking some easily traceable energy signature. They knew that it would happen and also knew their hyperdrive would break but hoped they could make it to tatooine, dock the ship and change ship. Unfortunately for them it broke just seconds to early, the devastating arrives and the rest is history
its not one of my fav star wars film but this film has so many easter eggs and cool scenes and probably my favorite scene “the hallway scene”
Your favorite scene is Darth Vader being incompetent?
@@andymiller6661 Oh no people like something you don’t 😱 lol 🤡
Rogue one movie gives you the beginning that was missing from the first star wars movie to see how it started from the ships shooting at each other what happened before
Damn all those little details connecting it to other films. Fine attention to detail there.
that was a really good video, gripped me all the way, made me wanna watch rogue again
loved the BWAINO moment
i've seen it twice since
I think Destroyer of Worlds would have been a pretty good title for this movie. And I wish it didn't have the hit you over the head cameos
It didn’t hit you over the head…it was making small connections from the prequels and the original trilogy
i rewatched rogue one for the first time since I watched it in cinema. I've been avoiding rewatching it bc I cry everytime I think about this movie.
Such a coincidence I was literally up to the Death Star destroying Scarif when this video dropped and just got to the credits
This is the Vader we knew was around and wanted to see!
Warwick is pronounced “Worrick”.
rogue 1 I'd by far the best Disney star wars film that they have done and I think that it absolutely will stand the test of time.... When it was a kid, and had the trilogy on VHS, I used to watch them over and over and over. I can do that with rogue one. I think that it's done so well. From the plot... To the time period... It's amazing
I feel that Rogue One was pretty dismissed but I rank it in my top three Star Wars films after Empire Strikes Back, and Return of the Jedi.
Maybe an Easter egg that only recently shed light... one of the file names from the vault on Scarif was Black Saber, referencing the fact that the Empire was in possession of the dark saber. Is this actually correct?
I liked listening to you talk about this movie way more than I liked the actual movie.
Literally watched this movie yesterday
so good so much information that I did not even know
My favorite star wars movie
Good job...i did not think about Oppenheimer....
I am seeing Star Wars IX opening night.
Ah, so you're the one
I honestly thought this was a re-upload
I almost spit out my coffee at 2:10
BWAINO!!
This was a great video. Love this guys fire!
I consider ROGUE ONE as Episode 3.5 of the Star Wars saga. Orders of magnitude better than any of the crappy movies in JJ Abrams ending trilogy. And ANDOR as the best of all the Star Wars TV series.
Leia's ship is pronounced Tan Tiv Vee its first named that way in the Radio adaptation.
Chopper being in this movie makes it so much better.
Outstanding movie. Only one thing bothers me.... They transmitted the plans up from the surface. Why didn't EVERY ship in the fleet receive them? And then bolt off in different directions.
The escape pods were gonna be used by the crew and dignitaries to escape when they arrived but in their rush to escape they ended up to far out from the planet which allowed Vader to catch them.
When they are naming project names they also say "black saber" which is from the books.
petition to get the same team that worked on this movie to make the rest of the star wars films?
Hey, I just want to point out that 11 minutes 15 seconds in to Rogue One one of the giant statues from the latest trailers of rise of Skywalker shows up.
Rogue One is my favorite Star Trek film.
Love you guys. Got no moneys now, but when I do, I'll give you some of it.
I love this film!
True Star Wars saga in Rogue one.
Still think the Tauntive should have been just outside of the system and another com ship kicking that signal to them. It should never been onsite at the battle. It’s too risky given Leia’s standing as member of the Organa family and nullifies the whole pretense thing going on at the beginning of ANH. It would be pointless to argue with Vader is he SAW your ship at the battle. It also nullifies the statement of the Imperial Officer to Vader about word of them capturing the ship getting out to the Senate. What would it matter if they were seen at the battle?
Hmmm….