2019 BMW X5 xDrive 40i (G05) FIRST DRIVE REVIEW: Closing in on the Porsche Cayenne . . . (2 of 2)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 ก.ย. 2024
- MotoMan drives the 2019 BMW X5 - both on and off road. Yes, he is not a Sport Utility (SUV) or a Crossover (CUV) but has always been a fan of the Porsche Cayenne from a driving dynamics perspective. Now after driving the G05 BMW X5, MotoMan learns a lot about how the many changes charted in the 2019 BMW X5 TECH REVIEW impact the competition between the BMW X5 and Porsche Cayenne.
Subscribe now to experience our adventures in the car world.
www.youtube.com...
For more information, watch our 2019 BMW X4 FIRST DRIVE REVIEW (2 of 2)
• 2019 BMW X4 M40i X Dri...
- or -
2019 BMW X5 TECH REVIEW (1 OF 2) @ • 2019 BMW X5 XDrive 40 ...
Check out our BMW playlist:
• BMW
Follow us at our socials to get behind the scenes video clips, pics and more:
Facebook - / motomantv
Twitter - / motomantv
Instagram - / motomantv
MotoMan. Storyteller of Transport, Travel & Inspired People
Download our MotoManTV App!
iTunes/iOS:
itunes.apple.c...
Google Play/Android: play.google.co...
Amazon App Store:
www.amazon.com...
MUSIC courtesy of Michael Bliss, Kevin MacLeod/incompetech.com & Jahzzar
I have always been a Bimmer fan! I am not interested in SAV’s, but I love there new interior. I am anxiously waiting for your test drive the new 8 8 coupe and I hope it has the sweet inline 6.😍
I currently own a 2015 Turbo Cayenne and have previously owned several BMWs. I switched to the Porsche because I loved the driving dynamics. I do not off-road. Given your price point of 85k I would definitely choose the BMW. If money were no object I would buy a new Cayenne S and spec the hell out of it. Unfortunately that would get the price of the Cayenne closer the 115-120k. The base Cayenne is pretty poorly outfitted. I would want full leather seats, soft close doors, led matrix headlights, air suspension, Burmester stereo etc........Hopefully the Competition from BMW will encourage Porsche to include more options as standard. Thus far Porsche has been able to sell a lot of Cayennes. This segment is becoming huge and now hopefully more competitive.
I currently own a 2015 Turbo Cayenne and have previously owned several BMWs. I switched to the Porsche because I loved the driving dynamics. I do not off-road. Given your price point of 85k I would definitely choose the BMW. If money were no object I would buy a new Cayenne S and spec the hell out of it. Unfortunately that would get the price of the Cayenne closer the 115-120k. The base Cayenne is pretty poorly outfitted. I would want full leather seats, soft close doors, led matrix headlights, air suspension, Burmester stereo etc........Hopefully the Competition from BMW will encourage Porsche to include more options as standard. Thus far Porsche has been able to sell a lot of Cayennes. This segment is becoming huge and now hopefully more competitive.
This review is absolutely spectacular. Entertaining, well spoken, and everything you need to know about the vehicle, along with excellent audio quality. You've just gained a new subscriber.
I test drove this car and absolutely loved driving it, I thought I was completely sold on it...but...the more I looked at it from the outside I realized I was not “moved” by the design. So I waited and kept my eye out to see one driving down the road. So many times I thought I saw one but it turned out to be an X3 and when I finally did see one I had to look real close to make sure it was an X5. That being said they lost me, what I mean is the design is not striking in a way I would want from a flagship type $75K+ SUV. I feel they used a mold that would not offend ANYONE, in doing so it is somewhat “Meh". I test drove a Cayenne and a Range Rover Sport and for me the best overall feel was the X5. If you look around you see large leaps forward in design by companies like Volvo, Mazda, Mercedes, Audi and even the new Chevy Blazer. I feel like the folks at Bimmer were afraid to take a leap and settled for an update instead of a radical redesign...which I feel is needed. I ended up with a Range Rover Sport, I am 52 years with 3 kids but I wanted a little edginess in my ride and felt like the sport delivered (maybe edginess is the wrong word, perhaps I did not want to look old or too suburban. I am only giving my 2 cents in hopes that somehow BMW hears this from me...and others.. and they get a little more daring in their exterior design. So.. in 3 to 5 years I can buy an X5 and have that wow feeling when I walk into the garage.
I agree, the main body of the car looks like an average ..box, the bulbous rectangular "design". The only place where they designed the car is in the front
I am on that exact situation, X5 vs Cayenne S for my daily drive... I ended up going with the X5, I had to build one X5 50i M Sport the sticker price is 93440 and a similar Cayenne S is between 117k to 120. Now I drove both, I love Porsche it is my favorite brand, but on the SAV to me the seats on the X5 are WAY MORE CONFORTABLE than any of the Porsche seat options, inside the BMW feels wider... both of them are a great drive. I do a lot of driving sometimes long distance, so the seating on the X5 is just amazing. It will get here by month end, looking forward for that.
great to see BMW focusing X5 design on comfort now (variable dampers standard now). Great engines, rock solid ZF 8 speed(not 9 speed!) transmission. That sporty speedometer and tachometer does not seem to be connected to the classic dash layout (thanks for not putting another display for climate controls), i hope they will add some classic gauges on the facelift model or something. (In some reviews the tachometer is lagging behind the engine rpm's, laggy responsiveness on the main display, so i believe there will be some headache with those new interfaces for some years now in G05).
Just watched Matt over at Car Wow and the y drive the 50D - nice results - shame we can't have it over here - oh well
9:29 BTW you would be totally surprised how many people take there X5 especially in Europe extremely normal to see them take it off road
Hey dude
This Gen is the best head to head. Cool match.
You are like nobody else.
Always sounds right
Love from Saudi Arabia
Just bought a 2019 X5 . The V6 Turbo is amazing!
Qiao Liu Did you shortlist other mid-size SUVs for comparison before settling on the X5?
Qiao Liu hey what’s the city fuel consumption??
It's an inline 6 not v6
you bought a rare x5 with a v6 😂😂😂 i'm going to go buy a camry with a v10 then 😂😂😂
Definitely X5! Armenia - Yerevan
Only MotoMan can inject a "Death of a Salesman" reference in an X5 review (at the 13:13 videomark). Well played sir 😏😏
How did the X5 pitch go in Atlanta? "Oh Atlanta? I knocked 'em dead in Atlanta! Then I headed out to Savannah... Oh you should see the people out there. Killed it out there as well!" (Not an actual Willie Lowman quote)
@@diegomontoya8889
Did you mean Willy Loman? 🤔🤔🤔
@@ivanlowjonesHim too. :)
BMW X5 for me, great Tech, driving dynamics and seating comfort. in middle East you get 5 yrs service contract and warranty on BMW. The TCO is so much excitingly low on BMW. Plus the M50i version 2020 which I am ordering is speced up massively to deliver 535 bhp!!!
Apple has opened up the NFC stuff in the just released iOS 12 to allow third parties to support using your phone for key access, so I'd expect an update from BMW to allow this.
I love my wife's X5 the air suspension is so comfortable and power train is perfect
X5....test drove both 2019 X5 and base Cayenne. Same driving dynamics. Same interior. But X5 has better tech system.
Another fabulous review. Curious how you didn’t get to drive the 50d. One of the UK people I follow did when he was there; doesn’t seem right as your reviews are far better. Never mind, a trip to the fatherland and unrestricted autobahns might not be such a tough deal!
Lease on my 2017 x5 is up in 2020. Thanks for the thorough review....was debating if it was worth getting one....aside from the “meh” styling it seems like a solid choice of car. Great review
X5 for me as in Islamabad there is no Porsche showroom or aftersales department.They only work in Lahore here in Pakistan:D
Thankyou for giving detailed insight to technology and packages especially suspension part
Anyway I love this configuration I would die for that blue and black seats are a must. It’s pretty optioned up which I always like. Can I buy that press car?
For 85,000 I would drive the X5 beamer and the reason why because of the engine that the BMW have. My aunt has a BMW 7 series that she bought back in 1991 and it's still 🦉 running today no lie .🙂
Awesome video can’t wait for more
I am currently driving a 2016 Porsche Cayenne S and have enjoyed the last three years with the vehicle. However, I am strongly leaning towards the new X5 50i as opposed to the new Cayenne S as my next vehicle. A few of the factors I'm taking into consideration include cost, ergonomics/functionality/comfort, technology, ambiance and practicality. In order to get a comparable new Cayenne S to the X5 50i I'd have to spend at-least an additional $15-20k. I prefer the button layout and functionality of the equipment of the new X5. Seating comfort is better in the new BMW. REMOTE START, to my knowledge, is still unavailable on the Cayenne! I appreciate the technology BMW has put into this latest X5. The interior LED accent lighting really adds something more to the ambiance over the Cayenne interior. Finally, for practicality sake, I'm considering the smallish third row for the X5 for my family of five. Best regards, Matt
Between the two? Cayenne. Had 2 previous X5. E70 was si much fun to drive but interior was cheap. F15 had good interior but it was a boat. Steering was bad, suspension was bad. The G 05, they probably improved suspension but heard the steering is still very bad.
Drive train and infotainment, X5 win. Everything else, Cayenne. Overall, Cayenne is still a better car.
Great content and analysis.
I would choose this X5 over the Cayenne. Exterior and interior looks nicer and yes I would go for this blue colour too. This engine with its power delivery will be enough and the setup will perform better of the kind of roads I drive on.
#I am from Ghana.
Someone with a family, this would be the perfect balance. Sports car, mixed with some decent off-road capacity (not that I would every take any of my cars off road), and way more luxurious than the Porsche. That’s my personal option, I’m sure if you ask a Porsche or a BMW enthusiast, they would never switch to the other brand.
Can you ask your contacts at BMW about the stories I’ve seen about their cars catching fire. It seems some of the older models (2006-2011) have cause a few house fires that have burned the garages and sometimes house to the ground. BMW claims it was a maintenance or modification issue, but recently I saw a video of a parked 2016 catch on fire. There are some pretty scary videos on TH-cam regarding BMW fires. Some reference cars that have not been started for days and just suddenly burst into flames. I would appreciate hearing your views on this issue.
hello , one thing I'm confused about the black panel on the top of the digital cluster on x5? what is the function?
Can I haz an X6 instead? If not, I'd definitely go with an X5 x50i M-Sport Individual. Though to be honest, I'd rather wait until next when the M50i replaces the x50i, 523hp !!! I don't like the new Cayenne at all.
I'm not into Diesels, but if I was looking into one & had the means, I'd definitely import an M50d BMW.
No, I wouldn't take the X5 off road, I'm not into that.
Regarding the smart access thing, apparently new BMWs come with a back up CreditCard-like nfc key & some iPhone users put it in one of those iPhone cases with credit card cutouts in the back to achieve the same results without buying a Samsung phone.
As always, Excellent work, M.
We need to work on you and diesels . . .
@@MotoManTV hahaha
In my defense, Diesel stations are not widely available outside industrial areas around here.
If I can only pick between the BMW and Porsche, I'd pick the Porsche. But I'm anxious to see a review of the new GLE and G class.
Orthodox brother! Lol keep up the good work sir
Key with android phone but no android auto and only Apple CarPlay
Bulls Bears that’s what I was thinking. Makes no sense forcing you to choose one option or the other.
Bulls Bears IKR, it's probably the stupidest idea BMW has ever thought
Very confusing
They usually come with Apple CarPlay but don't support Android Auto at all, but that CarPlay is optional you have to pay for it. As for phones yes it looks awkward that they don't support Android Auto but support it with key function.
This is the reason:
techcrunch.com/2017/02/28/bmw-says-nein-to-android-auto
Good reason or bad? You decide.
X5 for sure, Switzerland
I like to you and kumo. What are your thoughts on the split tailgate. Like or don't like. good video
X5 over Cayanne for me... Riyadh,
Do you know if this new BMW will eventually have the optional third row seats?
It will. Read somewhere online that they're not selling it for the first few months to help the sell of the X7.
I drove the first X5 model for 3 years (loved the V8), followed by a Cayenne S and GTS (both with air suspension > uncontested winner on rough US roads). I'm now looking at 2019 models and typically would choose the Cayenne S (with air suspension)...but for 10K less I could get a better equipped 2019 BMW X5, with a V8 and with air suspension!! Problem: BMW does not offer the air suspension in combination with the M-Sport Design and that's a deal breaker for me.
X5 only! I own Porsche and I adore driving my BMW 26 much more!!!
I think BMW needs to make it a little more capable off road because every year BMW sends these cars through Africa but a Land Rover at its side. BMW needs to make it more capable especially since it’s made in South Carolina where there’s people who off road and tow a lot. The VW Toregue from last gen was a good example of Off road like but also a street car.
X5 for me. I've never driven a cayenne or any other Porsche for that matter. So, I might be a little biased. To answer your earlier question. No, I would not take my $85k x5 off-road. It may be off-road capable. But, I don't see it as an off-road vehicle. However, I did buy a 2003 Hummer H2 when they came on market in the fall of 2002. And I absolutely took that off-roading. Many people thought I was crazy. I would always reply, "This thing was built to go off-road. And that's why I bought it. To take off-road and join the Hummer club." I'm from upstate South Carolina and live 30 miles south of the BMW plant.
A BMW with four turbos :D That's an adventure in ownership ;)
C'mon Motoman! We need some design-related, behind-the-scenes episodes like the Hyundai one! Plz lol
Be careful what you wish for because you may just get it . . . :)
My next car after my 550i m sport or a range rover sport. Either of the two but I might get the bimmer.
I would pick the BMW X5. I like the looks and to match the Porsche I get the twin turbo v8. Sweet.
Why isn't the big 4 turbo diesel beeing sold in us ? Or any x5 diesel for that matter ?
Sadly, ALL diesel is a no go for BMW at this point. They didn't say a flat out 'no' - they gave us some sort of statement that 'they are still evaluating it'. Translated: We are all still reeling from the VW scandal and going to push PHEV in the US for now.
@@MotoManTV Yes ..thats a big shame though . ..a big a diesel would have made a lot more sense in a big heavy car like that ..diesel tech has gone a long way performance wise ..with sequential turbos . even electric turbos in the sq7 4.0 tdi...but it seems they just can't reduce emissions low enough ..
They can reduce the emissions, but the tech stresses the engine and needs to be replaced ever 5000 miles or so. Basically a maintenance nightmare. Europe should really crackdown on diesel engines so that these car manufacturers start giving us real clean diesels instead of causing insane pollution everywhere.
I like diesel, especially TDI Q7. But when we talk about bmw, i do not think diesel is a good idea. People buy BMW is because of its performance and fast responding. Diesel lack the power at high RPM which reduces the fun when you push the gas down to floor. I would not buy a diesel BMW, but diesel other brands are quite welcomed. I almost bought a diesel Grand Cherokee, the $7000 premium on diesel engine stopped me, hahahaha.
Base model X-5 over Cayenne. However, as the price rises, the Cayenne is differentiated (does not look like all the other Porsche models)while the BMW looks like so many other BMW's then choose the Porsche. Also, BMW are lease cars (70%) and pile up on used ca lots that drive the price down-so good if you are buying 3 year old low mileage auto but not so good if you are selling your BMW! The Porsche will hold value longer.
I would choose the BMW X5. Because I would use for family duty and I like the front better and look. New York.
I am a Samsung Galaxy Note 8 owner and I would tell people not to worry about switching to Samsung - It is that good. :-) Also, I am also an owner of 2017 Ford F250 Platinum 6.7 diesel from Alabama and when I stop pulling heavy stuff, I wouldn't mind to have the BMW X5 with v8 - no M package, just comfort and quietness. It seems to be that good. :-)
I would choose the bmw x5 cause I find it more luxurious than the cayenne and more usable as a family car for long distance travelling and that's what I would uee it for. Also I am from Greece.
This or the Q8?
used car sellsman / honey and normal engine don t go together but if it is a v12 yep, and are you from greece?
What the fuck are you saying?
MotoMan, you should meet up with Autogefuhl to get a European perspective on these cars. Personally, I would go for the BMW, mostly because I like the way it looks more and the interior seems nicer. If I wanted a Porsche, it's 911 or bust.
So no diesels for the US :(
They're coming
X5. 5.0 interior ,power.
Why couldn’t they just make a BMW key app to unlock & start the car on the iPhone like Tesla did. Using Bluetooth?
Bluetooth is not very safe or protected.
Used car salesmen 👍 you’ve sold it
Very easy for me: X5 over Cayenne. Feature for feature, Porsche will make you pay more than anybody else.
Welcome to Atlanta 😍😍
Thank you . . . It was a great visit!
Strange, there‘s the difference between the US attitude to cars and that of us Europeans. You say that this car will be driven by mums picking kids up from school etc, and „Dudes“ probably less. This car, especially with the spec you‘re demonstrating, is driven by successful businessmen and businesswomen here. Yes, also Dads with families but very few Mums as her daily for the kids etc. The camera by the way, when you‘re off-road, is only there to see whether you‘ve got enough room at the front when maneuvering in tight situations and not to constantly stare at. The X50D is the M Version and those turbos take the performance up to Stupid Level! As a BMW driver of over 12 years, 7 cars in all, I can honestly say and without any bias, they have become better than Audi or Mercedes. It is an industry confirmed fact that the iDrive is the best of any Infotainment controllers, they have pepped up their interiors to look as interesting as Audi. But above all, it is the absolute symbiosis of all that electronic stuff working in harmony that is a cut above the rest. Good review Mr Motoman. 👍👍👍
Ps. Just an afterthought. That Cayenne from Porsche is, without doubt, a beautifully designed and engineered vehicle. It also costs a whole lot more than the comparatively equipped X5!
4800 pounds? That is full size truck weight right there. Getting close 3 row full size suv weight as well. Should be closer to 4500 pounds in my opinion. Also backseat seems disappointing, my edge has as much room overall. Its not as fancy or nice but it has leather lol
Taking the X5 for the better interior and tech
X5 any time of the day, i mean it's a BMW by the way.
The Automann-TV channel got to review and test drive the X5 M50D... It's just you :)
As I said in the video . . . ALL outlets *based* in the US were forbidden from driving the diesels. One look at the channel you mention clearly shows they are based outside the US.
The X5 is not a”baby buggy”. This vehicle is too aggressive for most women.
Porsche every time, I live in the UK, BMW has not got the the rep a Porsche has, important in the car parks of up market shops when my wife is using it to shop! 😆
BMW rather than Porsche because the windows are larger and it doesn’t have all those touch screen buttons. Eliot. NY.
I would take my mine off road
thats whats COOL 😎
IT CAN REALLY GO OFF ROAD?
im not even a X5 FAN for that
THEY GET A G PIONT
For $85k, I wouldn't get either an X5 or a Cayenne. I'd just get a new Land Cruiser. I have a 2013 Land Cruiser and I take it on far more severe off-roading than that little dirt track you took the X5 on.
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA 85k for a tractor with less equipment and performance than a VW polo, spectacular choice, lol
The pop up screen looks so out of place. Badly designed. Seems like an after thought.
Cayenne is a reference point . BMW is gooood but .....
I have a huge BMW issue. No Android auto which is dumb as hell, yet they had to go to Android as a key. At what point do u cut the crap and offer both Carplay and Android auto like most sensible car manufacturers?😑
AGREE 100%
The kidney shaped grill up front is a bit oversized in my opinion...mimicking the upcoming X7? Just a matter of taste
X5 for me plzze,thks.
x5
willy lohman edition, lol
Stelvio vs cheyenne
Sitting on the side of the road vs Driving.
Verstehen Sie dass? Hahahaha Eigentlich nicht!
Porsche Cayenne over X5 for me.....Georgia, USA
Too much over.
A used car salesman
Always Porsche over all the other car brands. Porsche is a Premium car. Porsche, There is no substitute
You need to crash a Porsche and see if you still have that opinion!
C, a used car salesman
한국선 잔고장의 대가 수리비최고 개떡같은차입니다.
Answer is C. A used car salesman
Used Car Salesman!
Definitely a used car salesmen 🤣
1st generation is the best idk wtf your talking about. They need to stop ruining the good designs.
Its not designed for rock crawling, test a Jeep for that, sheesh !
C