You are completely right. I also don't get all the hate she gets. If anything, The Answer just improved her character to me. Before that her personality was boring as hell.
@darklordster You could argue Aigis suffered less, because they did the whole "detached all her emotions so she would feel nothing like a machine" -thing, all of her emotions being in Metis for the duration. I'm kinda sad they did it that way, because I wanted to see Aigis having to deal with this herself like Yukari was doing. (I personally quite liked Yukari here as a character if not as a person. Having seen people go through something similar to this with the same coping methods, these kind of people can be horrible to be around during their time of grieving, but this is ultimately very true to life for some people. I think you're supposed to dislike her behavior here, I mean even she herself apologizes for it in the end. Understand but don't condone" I'd say?)
this moment is so touching and human but since most arent bothered to play this game they mainly see clips and see how they made yukari such a bitchy character and sorta skim over this clip
but when you look over this game and yukaris arc it completely makes sense why she holds resentment against aigis and why shes so broken she started her journey with makoto she was with him at the start, he was the first person that yukari could open up to and he was always there for her its shown how much she values him to lose another person so close to you is so hard and yukari has been hurt before then to see the person who she valued so much's power be given to someone else it makes sense why she would feel jealous to aigis and maybe make her feel as if she was unworthy or less important to him
This is what made Persona 3 truly the most depressing installment: as if it wasn't enough losing Shinjiro, then Makoto (even after all he went through), seeing the effects Makoto's death had on his teammates (ESPECIALLY Yukari) was what really brought the pain.
For those who were confused by Mitsuru's behaviour in this part, that kind of thing is perfectly normal in Japan. They believe that if you owe someone a debt but can't repay it, you should choose to stand by their side as way of true payment. Yukari snapped Mitsuru out of her breakdown after the death of her father, and so she decided she would put aside her own feelings and stand by her side no matter what. It's called the 'pillars of moral'. You could basically call it their version of chivalry. I know it sounds old-fashioned, but Japan have ended up holding on to a lot of old traditions that most other countries have grown out of- ironic, considering how advanced they are.
I'm actually convinced she sabotaged Yukari's chances by fighting like a noob. Spamming Marin Karin and various shit Aigis is immune to. Yes, I'm saying that her dumb AI was actually her attempt to lose intentionally. That's now my headcanon.
@@Uroboro_Djinn I think it's more like, she knew they were gonna lose anyway. I mean Aigis single-handedly sacked all of them when Ikutsuki was controlling her. Also, Aigis is a death machine and now she has the power of the Wild Card too. Good odds? Probably not.
She is normal in our standards, but she is a fucking bitch in game standards. Let's give Ken as an example. He lost his mother, probably lost his father, semi participated in his friend's death, lost Minato, but Yukari still passes the bitch test with the highest score. Yukari? Fucking Yukari? Trying to steal a key from 2 death machines? That girl is stupid, and a bitch in P3 The Answer. In P3, she is good tho, better than Ken
Damn, hearing Yukari said she just wanna see Makoto again was just way so sad, and then her eventual breakdown while hugging Mitsuru just broke my heart.
I feel like the opposite of people, this moment in game made me love Yukari. It was just so human, she was suffering, suffering so much and while the others are trying to move on, Yukari just cant. She doesn't have that closure and it messed her. After losing nearly everyone she loved she made a bond with Minato only to lose him too. What's worse, she actually loved him and was beaten by a robot to stand by his side. She didn't know what happen to Minato, and she was given the chance to bring him back. She didn't know that the seal was in place to save the world, so she was willing to push everything aside for a chance to see the person she love.
I think this is why I like Yukari as character she still remember him while the others feel like they forgot about him even though I know that they just have move on.
Sorry, but as Junpei said, they would have to fight Nyx again and would end up in the same situation leading to Minato's death so their attempt to time travel would be for naught.
So Yukari was a bitch? Try having a loved one die and their most prized posession goes to someone else who loved them as well. Then try working with them, through the jealousy. It's not bitch. It's human.
She lost her dad Then fell in love with the protag, only to lose him so soon Pretty sure life would feel so shitty Im sure most people would act the same way Yukari did ..I know i probably would
@@Mojo1356 good point and true, but I think don't think I could muster up the resolve to kill some of the most important people in my life, but i get Yukari
Sebastian Amada18 precisely. While I don’t think I would do so, I also realize I am older than Yukari and have more self control over her. If I were her age, I very much could have gone over the deep end as badly as her.
@@HealthymemesExe technically, none of the protagonists have canon names considering their names change all the time throughout different forms of media. I prefer it this way, I'd like their names to be ambiguous and be whatever I want them to be.
@@Kruzeda normally its Atlus decides on their canon names (main and Q not involved as you decide). The manga names are placeholders used by the artists until Atlus decide their canon names in future media. Makoto Yuki is the canon name of the P3 protagonist as seen in promotional movie/dancing and game crossovers like Chain Chronicle and Star Ocean Anemesis. Yu Narukami is the canon name used in subsequent media after P4 and P4G as he's no longer self insert in canon timeline games and afterstory of his journey, including crossover games. Ren Amamiya is the canon name as Atlus decides it, perhaps used more in next canon timeline sequels after Phantom Strikers if it involves him talking in full like Yu in Arena. There's an indication that P5 gen is not done with their stories as seen with Royal and Phantom Strikers. All 3 names have some symbolism/meaning in their situations and battles against negative aspects of humanity.
Yukari’s breakdown is just so unbelievably heart-wrenching. From the way she says “his cold hand” to how she falls into just crying that she wants to see him again…great writing elevated further by a great performance. Everyone else struggles with the loss, but to Yukari it’s like she’s that helpless six years old again.
I get so pissed when people say Yukari is a "bitch" in The Answer. Like, I just feel so much sorrow for her. All she wants is to see him again and is willing to throw it all away for that chance.
Nanaki And ergo is why we call her a bitch. I understand of having the desire to see the person you love again, I really do. But willing to risk the entire fucking world of bringing the goddamn apocalypse back from its seal to see Makoto again is not fucking worth it!
That's true, but its really sad for Yukari to grieve for him to give his life to save them all and the world, Makoto is the protector. He made his decision and never regret it. He wanted his friends to live there lives.
@@AxalFlameHart thats a really narrow minded view point because of how extreme the consequences of her actions can be. It’s very human to want closure in something that you don’t understand. The game is called the Answer. No one understood why Makoto died and once they did they accepted his choice. That doesn’t make someone a bitch for wanting to know the truth and being resolved in said choice. She had her mind made up from the beginning while the others were unsure of what they wanted to do. This is why I hate when games or anime show the viewer or player what happens before the characters in the game or anime because then people blame them for their stupidity when you literally have prior knowledge that they don’t have.
I feel like the remake didn't have as much of an impact as the original did, you can just hear the pain/desperation in Yukari's voice. The way they did Mitsuru in the remake was good with her extra dialogue, but I just prefer the original sisterhood Yukari and Mitsuru has here.
reload sounded like she just couldn't accept losing a friend fes sounded like she actually loved him, and couldn't handle losing him so soon. cause she lost her dad, then always kept to herself since then, so having minato around probably made her not feel lonely anymore. but when he died so soon, her old feelings probably came rushing in like a truck its kinda like she's had it with losing people she loves (she's the lovers arcana after all) so ofc shed be desperate, and would want him back even if it means wiping the whole world out
@@crucible1084 FES also shown her becoming like her mom who jump from one boyfriend to another after her husband died. Yukari unintentionally follow her footstep.
I hope if this scene reappears again in reload, I hope they don’t change a thing, just in script that is, I want this scene to look as heart wrenching as the original scene sounds. Even for the ps2 her breaking down on the floor I’d like to imagine she’s grasping onto the key as she falls to her knees losing her grip of the key , and you can see the pain in that breakdown. So people might not hate the most human and real character in this series.
I was actually jealous with Aigis being the protagonist and not Yukari. I understood why it has to be Aigis, but I sorta wish there was an alternate take.
Aigis was the one who put Ryoji in minato so she probably was trusted by minato for her to protect yukari and their friends though I am disappointed that the personas didn’t refused to attack yukari but instead help her as minato last wish to the personas was to protect yukari no matter the cost
People hating Yukari because she's want to see someone she's love again 😐. Listen man, I will act the same too if I have a chance to see someone I love again. My egoistic will rise to the top.
She first opened up to Makoto in the hospital, went to the love hotel with him in a dream (because of a shadow), scolded Makoto for being so reckless and telling junpei how worried she is for Makoto in the movies, was surprised when Makoto went looking for her at the yakushima beach, got flustered when Makoto gave her a hug, got a little jealous because of what aigis was saying to Makoto in her first day of school, cried out to Makoto in the final battle with nyx. She really really loved him for sure
I guess she moved on from him and accepted his death like minato did with his parents and wanted him and die with him thanks to the video Fuuka Gave she realized her dad was a hero that sacrificed his life to save others by telling them what to do and now minato has done what he did Also kinda disappointed minato didn’t get mad at yukari or Mitsuru for their parents and their company who basically were the reason why his parents are dead wish we got more development their
I mean all they had to do was use the power of friendship and beat nyx and minato lives and stays with yukari despite the multiple relationships he has been with
8:51 This part was so sad and emotional for Yukari. I mean you can’t blame her for wanting to see someone saved her and help change her life after losing her father. So I don’t care what others say, I still love Yukari
Can I just say, why the heck are people hating on Yukari for her irrational but understandable obsession with seeing Minato again, when everyone ignores Yosuke's irrational and not-as-understandable desire to MURDER someone later in P4?! Both can result in massive reprecussions, like the end of the world, but which sounds better, being an idiot out of grief, or hatred?
Some Asian well yosuke was only aware his actions would kill one person, yukari's actions had the possibility of killing everyone and that's something she should have been aware of, plus she was willing to hurt her freinds to do it unlike yosuke who really didn't try to hurt anyone else than the one guy.
If im cotrect hour taking about when the little girl "died" in P4 everyone was fond of her so it was anger at killing the one that killed a child. Yukari just wants Minato's D not carrying about the whole world that he saved
Some Asian dude I understand her wanting to see Makoto again but she didn’t think this through, going back to ‘save’ Makoto causes everyone to die including him so no matter what he was gonna die either way. For Yosuke his best friends sister ‘died’ in front of him and he was fond of her just like the rest of P4, and may I add if you didn’t complete his social like before that time he was sill getting over saki konisi’s death so him seeing Nanko die probably triggered of how he lost Saki Again before anyone jumps me saying ‘dumbass it’s been months since he lost Dali he’s gotten over it by now’ I said IF you didn’t complete his social link
@@HealthymemesExe Exactly. I don’t think this person payed attention to Aigis’ entire character. Aigis was more close to Makoto. Even Yukari said that Aigis cared for Makoto the most when you beat her.
i remembered being sad over this scene years ago (hell this is what got me to love yukari lol) so as i was talking about this scene to my friend (who's not into persona) and showing this video to them, i didnt expect to be bawling at yukari's "i want to see him" 😭
Everyone in P3 lost someone important, Mitsuru lost her father, Ken lost his mother, Akihiko lost his sister and Shinjiro, Junpei lost chidori, and Aigiz lost minato who was also her closest friend. Everone was effected by minato death as they too have already lost someone they love, considering minato is their rock too. Though I understand yukari anger and coldness to everyone, wish Yukari could have see how everyone is struggling with loss too instead of lashing out expecially to aigis. i remember back in my highschool, one of our clique passed away and our group was really effected but everyone dealt the grief differently. It IS DIFFICULT, havent move on yet. I do understand yukari's action, how she feels minato understands her the most, but I do understand why alot of people was abit annoyed. Persona 3 really hits you emotionally
Before this part, I assumed Mitsuru was following Yukari half because friendship, but mostly to try and save her dad. I feel like this would've fit her character more, for some reason. I get what they were trying to do with her position (also conviniently allows SEES to be paired up), but I really do feel like it would be more fitting for Mitsuru to try and help Yukari _before_ they all fought each other. Of course that's just my idea of the characters, but Mitsuru doesn't seem like the type to go going along with extremely stupid desisions like she does.
Yukari and Makoto's relationship is just like Sun Shang Xiang and Sun Ce as very close like Yukari is Makoto's girlfriend and Sun Shang Xiang is Ce's little sister.
For everyone that is saying The Answer ruined Yukari and is highly unrealistic, may I interest you in Tought Bubble’s video on Yukari? Someone that actually studied psychology explains why this is super in character and realistic.
Now that you mention it, The Answer could be a great Part 5 of the P3 movie series. Between Aigis and Yukari dealing with grief, The Answer could be a very emotional movie.
Because the director or writer had favoritism toward aigis and made minato and yukari interactions like friendship instead of a loving bond which I am still mad about in the movie and now that the answer was the last one they didn’t want to even explain why their version yukari became mean and in love with minato when they acted like friends the entire time and I’m still mad we never got the small interactions with Yuko and the sports club or minato joining the council and helping chirio and playing with that little girl and going to the club meeting the monk or visit the old couple in the bookstore and that sick boy I really wish they did a anime series instead of the movie rushing the story
I mean my dude literally saved her life on multiple occasions and even saved the world at that. I don't think that's someone you can easily forget. Even if Yukari found a new love, she will always be thankful to Makoto.
In persona 4 arena yukari mention him indirect multiple time such as remembering remembering Thanatos and some of yukari battle quote are directed from his loss from makoto
To Yukari, I have to the words of a Wise and positive thinking reporter: "I know now something far worse than being forgotten...It is chaining others down...please forget about me. You can all change your life by believing in yourself and make your dreams a reality. Stay Positive" The memories about Minato/Makoto became a burden for his teammates, which is far worse than anything Nyx had done to him. It's better being forgotten than burdening others with a legacy that leaves wounds and pain behind.
That's like saying they should have killed Ryoji and forget everything about the dark hour and their growth which goes against P3's themes in the first place. P2 is a completely different context,it's quotes don't mesh with P3
This is one of the most Raw and Unironic Examples of such from the Persona Fandom. I never got to complete The Answer back then but I am glad to come back as an Adult after losing so much and feeling my back against a corner. Fuck those people who don't get it. The Answer is necessary.
@@ZX-Gearwe tend to understand things more clearly and deeply when we become adults. Hope those people saying yukari's a bitch actually understands her now
@@ZX-Gear persona 3 is so interesting because of how completely dysfunctional the whole cast is. The MC is the only barrier and this is exactly what happens with him gone and NO ONE is right. That's the point of the original game, I have no idea why people don't like it
Man, i cant wait to see this get fully animated in p3 reload dlc. Its gonna make some people cry especially if they actually showed us how yukari made that promise to makoto Ooh, i cant wait till September
Man, this stuff is good! Hope they really add this one to the game if they're gonna have a remake of Persona 3 Sucks it wasn't gotten animated, may have had a lot of impact
Yukari: he’s gone and he can’t come back, and I have to live with that Igor: oh I keep a backup of his soul in the velvet room and sick him on future wild cards just for the fun of it you know.
Thats what shes doing actually. She left the Velvet room to go revive him. But instead of using her power to just revive him, because im sure she could do that pretty easily,she's going to use her power to kill Nyx too. Then there wont be a need for a seal.
I find this not to make yukari a bad character and I don’t see why people think it does this shows how human she is this is how anybody would react if they lost somebody they loved she loved him and that’s sad to see her like this makoto is missed badly and I can’t blame her
Okay but this moment would've been a lot more sad if I actually cared for Aigis as a character. I never even liked her for some odd reason and was mad salty because she got Minato's power. I feel as though if we could choose from the few characters who were really close to us (Junpei, Yukari, etc) then the moment would be more emotional.
@@GiordanDiodato She just felt so shallow and uninteresting to me. I get why they made it Aigis but I just felt more attached to Yukari who I also hate and Junpei.
Giordan Diodato while I like Aigis, I just don’t think she is as great as many others make her out to be. Although she did get some great moments in The Answer- not quite as well handled as Yukari, but it’s better than what everyone else got.
The only way I win this fight was by getting a double crit attack on Mitsuru using a charged up auto mataru Siegfried. Killed that bufudyne bitch at the second turn.
ABL138 That's the Font problem. You have to go inside the .pnach and put // in front all the ''//Font fix by nemesis2000 (causes spacing errors)'' and below. That should fix it.
ABL138 The game isn't suppose to support wide screen as it only works on the emulator. That's why it breaks some parts of the dialogue because of that, and it can be recorrected with that font fix. It should also fix some portraits as characters/persona's.
yep, had to come back to this because the new one didnt have much impact i hoped shed get angry and try to take it away from aigis but she didnt seemed more like she loved him more as a friend in reload, but loved him as a woman in 3fes. which is why the OG hits that much harder, she sounded so desperate, so angry and so jealous in p3f so it makes it that much more sadder. since she lost her dad, it was even that much harder to let go of a new person she loved so much, already so damn soon. so it makes sense why shed act so immaturely in p3f instead of her just bottling things up like she did in reload
@@hediazafranco8211 Agreed. Cast was amazing in Reload but this part of the scene didn't need to be removed, albeit it is pretty small (it's like 15 seconds long).
I hadn't finished the answer, I only played like a couple of hours of it; however, what i remember was that Yukari was acting like a total BITCH in this mode. Lol Holy crap.
Sooo...Yukari you want to go back un time to see him again and reverse him SAVING THE WORLD AND YOU USLESS PATHETIC ASS. -_- screw off Yukari you had character growth and threw it out the window for more Minato's D
@@michaeljames6737 And That's the part when she enters as a bad character, She don't learn Nyx Lesson, she don't acept Death as Part of Circle of Life.
@@richiemakyura724 Which doesn't make her a bad cause there are how many people relate to her. It's quite a possibility you and many others would do the same thing as she did. Grief does so much to people
Newsflash, everyone deals with grief in different ways.@@dde8721Doesn't make Yukari any special. Also, Grief ain't a good excuse for going on a potentially dangerous, and foolish time loop just to see your "beloved" again.
![Persona 3 FES The Answer FINAL Boss Erebus [Final Door]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/XbA-wohdHFI/mqdefault.jpg)
![Persona 3 FES The Answer FINAL Boss Erebus [Final Door]](/img/tr.png)
![Persona 3 FES: Vs Yukari & Mitsuru [The Answer]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/G9TKcGV-aDc/mqdefault.jpg)
![Persona 3 FES The Answer Boss ??? (Protagonist) [Empyrean]](/img/n.gif)
I don't understand why people say this ruined Yukari's character. She was showing the 7 stages of grief after losing the man she loved.
You are completely right. I also don't get all the hate she gets.
If anything, The Answer just improved her character to me.
Before that her personality was boring as hell.
@darklordster You could argue Aigis suffered less, because they did the whole "detached all her emotions so she would feel nothing like a machine" -thing, all of her emotions being in Metis for the duration. I'm kinda sad they did it that way, because I wanted to see Aigis having to deal with this herself like Yukari was doing.
(I personally quite liked Yukari here as a character if not as a person. Having seen people go through something similar to this with the same coping methods, these kind of people can be horrible to be around during their time of grieving, but this is ultimately very true to life for some people. I think you're supposed to dislike her behavior here, I mean even she herself apologizes for it in the end. Understand but don't condone" I'd say?)
See, that proves she's P3's best girl
this moment is so touching and human but since most arent bothered to play this game they mainly see clips and see how they made yukari such a bitchy character and sorta skim over this clip
but when you look over this game and yukaris arc it completely makes sense why she holds resentment against aigis and why shes so broken
she started her journey with makoto she was with him at the start, he was the first person that yukari could open up to and he was always there for her its shown how much she values him
to lose another person so close to you is so hard and yukari has been hurt before then to see the person who she valued so much's power be given to someone else it makes sense why she would feel jealous to aigis and maybe make her feel as if she was unworthy or less important to him
This is what made Persona 3 truly the most depressing installment: as if it wasn't enough losing Shinjiro, then Makoto (even after all he went through), seeing the effects Makoto's death had on his teammates (ESPECIALLY Yukari) was what really brought the pain.
Idk the previous entry had a pretty depressing ending.
For those who were confused by Mitsuru's behaviour in this part, that kind of thing is perfectly normal in Japan. They believe that if you owe someone a debt but can't repay it, you should choose to stand by their side as way of true payment. Yukari snapped Mitsuru out of her breakdown after the death of her father, and so she decided she would put aside her own feelings and stand by her side no matter what. It's called the 'pillars of moral'. You could basically call it their version of chivalry. I know it sounds old-fashioned, but Japan have ended up holding on to a lot of old traditions that most other countries have grown out of- ironic, considering how advanced they are.
I'm actually convinced she sabotaged Yukari's chances by fighting like a noob. Spamming Marin Karin and various shit Aigis is immune to.
Yes, I'm saying that her dumb AI was actually her attempt to lose intentionally. That's now my headcanon.
♞ Go Fuck Yourself ♞ I think so too. Mitsuru is strong and she probably just want Yukaki to realize and go back to her usual self again.
@@Uroboro_Djinn I think it's more like, she knew they were gonna lose anyway. I mean Aigis single-handedly sacked all of them when Ikutsuki was controlling her. Also, Aigis is a death machine and now she has the power of the Wild Card too. Good odds? Probably not.
@@bubbleteacore It also explains why her AI is too stupid: she secretly screwed Yukari over hoping they would lose.
That and Mitsuru is a very traditional girl.
Yukari's breakdown is really sad. One of the most human characters in the game I think. Nice video quality by the way, so crisp and smooth.
Most people said she turned into a bitch.
She did. But grief that fresh is gonna twist anyone a little.
+BuffMaister Hey, don't forget that not only did she lose Makoto, she lost her father before that, and her mother wasn't exactly good...
She is normal in our standards, but she is a fucking bitch in game standards. Let's give Ken as an example. He lost his mother, probably lost his father, semi participated in his friend's death, lost Minato, but Yukari still passes the bitch test with the highest score. Yukari? Fucking Yukari? Trying to steal a key from 2 death machines? That girl is stupid, and a bitch in P3 The Answer.
In P3, she is good tho, better than Ken
Charielity she wanted to see Makoto again. Nuff said.
Damn, hearing Yukari said she just wanna see Makoto again was just way so sad, and then her eventual breakdown while hugging Mitsuru just broke my heart.
Let's hope they have it be a full anime cutscene in the DLC
@@davidtimmer596 It was very underwhelming unfortunately.
Mitsuru: has one hp left.
Also mitsuru: MIND CHARGE!
She could have healed herself but ok.
I thought she'd use Marin Karin
Both should they spam Megidolaon if either player or team have no weakness, using mirror or any reflect attacks.
She’s going down swinging 😂
I feel like the opposite of people, this moment in game made me love Yukari.
It was just so human, she was suffering, suffering so much and while the others are trying to move on, Yukari just cant. She doesn't have that closure and it messed her.
After losing nearly everyone she loved she made a bond with Minato only to lose him too.
What's worse, she actually loved him and was beaten by a robot to stand by his side.
She didn't know what happen to Minato, and she was given the chance to bring him back.
She didn't know that the seal was in place to save the world, so she was willing to push everything aside for a chance to see the person she love.
I think this is why I like Yukari as character she still remember him while the others feel like they forgot about him even though I know that they just have move on.
I felt great that I maxed out her social link
thx for this! =)
Sorry, but as Junpei said, they would have to fight Nyx again and would end up in the same situation leading to Minato's death so their attempt to time travel would be for naught.
Master Chief Petty Officer Spartan John-117 agreeeeeed
Ohh man...I felt sorry for them. Especially Yukari. She does not hold the lovers arcana for nothing.
I don't feel bad for yukari
@@josiahharris3151GET OUT 🗣️ 🔥🔥
So Yukari was a bitch?
Try having a loved one die and their most prized posession goes to someone else who loved them as well.
Then try working with them, through the jealousy. It's not bitch. It's human.
thx!
Finally someone with a brain
Yeah your right but I will call her a simp
@@sonicelimario2892 Another 8 year old who doesn’t know the definition of the words they say! Funny joke, go back to watching tiktoks you zoomer.
@@Vincent-vn7xo so killing your own friends over a guy that probably doesn't like you is not simping
Yukari says she's gonna tear them apart but in less than two turns she's almost out of HP, poor choice of words.
I barely even feel a thing!
*dies*
So true
"I barely even feel a thing! Seriously, I think I'm going numb!"
*passes out*
i thought “then why are you leaning
Me when im pretending to be fine on a bad day
She lost her dad
Then fell in love with the protag, only to lose him so soon
Pretty sure life would feel so shitty
Im sure most people would act the same way Yukari did
..I know i probably would
her mom barely cares about her
But i dont think id try and kill my friends for a chance
Sebastian Amada18 in your right mind, perhaps. But keep in mind that many of us do horrid things when we are not in our right minds.
@@Mojo1356 good point and true, but I think don't think I could muster up the resolve to kill some of the most important people in my life, but i get Yukari
Sebastian Amada18 precisely. While I don’t think I would do so, I also realize I am older than Yukari and have more self control over her. If I were her age, I very much could have gone over the deep end as badly as her.
It would be more touching if Minato/Makoto actually had an in game name instead of *him*
Andrew that would ruin the point of naming them.
Enclave Communications Officer I thought P3’s canon name was Minato, and P5’s was Akira
@@HealthymemesExe technically, none of the protagonists have canon names considering their names change all the time throughout different forms of media. I prefer it this way, I'd like their names to be ambiguous and be whatever I want them to be.
@@Kruzeda normally its Atlus decides on their canon names (main and Q not involved as you decide). The manga names are placeholders used by the artists until Atlus decide their canon names in future media. Makoto Yuki is the canon name of the P3 protagonist as seen in promotional movie/dancing and game crossovers like Chain Chronicle and Star Ocean Anemesis. Yu Narukami is the canon name used in subsequent media after P4 and P4G as he's no longer self insert in canon timeline games and afterstory of his journey, including crossover games. Ren Amamiya is the canon name as Atlus decides it, perhaps used more in next canon timeline sequels after Phantom Strikers if it involves him talking in full like Yu in Arena. There's an indication that P5 gen is not done with their stories as seen with Royal and Phantom Strikers. All 3 names have some symbolism/meaning in their situations and battles against negative aspects of humanity.
@Enclave Communications Officer
I love the manga names, but the Canon names are pretty lame
Yukari’s breakdown is just so unbelievably heart-wrenching. From the way she says “his cold hand” to how she falls into just crying that she wants to see him again…great writing elevated further by a great performance.
Everyone else struggles with the loss, but to Yukari it’s like she’s that helpless six years old again.
I get so pissed when people say Yukari is a "bitch" in The Answer. Like, I just feel so much sorrow for her. All she wants is to see him again and is willing to throw it all away for that chance.
Nanaki And ergo is why we call her a bitch.
I understand of having the desire to see the person you love again, I really do.
But willing to risk the entire fucking
world of bringing the goddamn apocalypse back from its seal to see Makoto again is not fucking worth it!
That's true, but its really sad for Yukari to grieve for him to give his life to save them all and the world, Makoto is the protector. He made his decision and never regret it. He wanted his friends to live there lives.
@@AxalFlameHart thats a really narrow minded view point because of how extreme the consequences of her actions can be. It’s very human to want closure in something that you don’t understand. The game is called the Answer. No one understood why Makoto died and once they did they accepted his choice. That doesn’t make someone a bitch for wanting to know the truth and being resolved in said choice. She had her mind made up from the beginning while the others were unsure of what they wanted to do. This is why I hate when games or anime show the viewer or player what happens before the characters in the game or anime because then people blame them for their stupidity when you literally have prior knowledge that they don’t have.
@@AnthonyKagegariVT Just so you know that was like 3 years ago
3:49
Yukari: "I barely even feel a thing!"
Also Yukari: (Cries in died in 2 turn)
1:35 to 1:43 seems like a pretty good summary of Persona 3.
“What’s the matter!? Is that all you’ve got!?”
Girl, you just lost half of your health in only 2 turns AND got paralyzed
And the “I barely even feel a thing!” is pretty literal lol
I feel like the remake didn't have as much of an impact as the original did, you can just hear the pain/desperation in Yukari's voice. The way they did Mitsuru in the remake was good with her extra dialogue, but I just prefer the original sisterhood Yukari and Mitsuru has here.
reload sounded like she just couldn't accept losing a friend
fes sounded like she actually loved him, and couldn't handle losing him so soon.
cause she lost her dad, then always kept to herself since then, so having minato around probably made her not feel lonely anymore.
but when he died so soon, her old feelings probably came rushing in like a truck
its kinda like she's had it with losing people she loves (she's the lovers arcana after all)
so ofc shed be desperate, and would want him back even if it means wiping the whole world out
@@crucible1084 FES also shown her becoming like her mom who jump from one boyfriend to another after her husband died. Yukari unintentionally follow her footstep.
People I want to hug in this game:
Komomaru
Aigis
And now,
Yukari
Me too 😢😢😢
Espacially ken too because *Shinjiro* who protect him
Well all she needs is a hug from makoto
Mitsuru may not actually agree with Yukari but she made a promise to stand by her just as Yukari did in her darkest moment when her father died.
Mitsuru is an absolute QUEEN for this. The ultimate Wing Woman.
3:58 the battle its more emotional when they said "Isis" and "Artemisia" in the same turn
I hope if this scene reappears again in reload, I hope they don’t change a thing, just in script that is, I want this scene to look as heart wrenching as the original scene sounds. Even for the ps2 her breaking down on the floor I’d like to imagine she’s grasping onto the key as she falls to her knees losing her grip of the key , and you can see the pain in that breakdown. So people might not hate the most human and real character in this series.
Persona 3. The most depressing installment in the series.
I was actually jealous with Aigis being the protagonist and not Yukari. I understood why it has to be Aigis, but I sorta wish there was an alternate take.
Yeah. If only the version where Yukari was with Makoto when he died in portable was cannon, maybe things could have turned out differently slightly.
the FeMC route in portable was originally gonna be the Yukari route instead, really playing into the "sides of a story" idea
On ng+ in portable you can spend time at the end if you maxed out the link with Yukari, Mitsuru or Fuuka 😀👍
Aigis was the one who put Ryoji in minato so she probably was trusted by minato for her to protect yukari and their friends though I am disappointed that the personas didn’t refused to attack yukari but instead help her as minato last wish to the personas was to protect yukari no matter the cost
Fun fact Atlus confirmed all social links are cannon
Kind of give this dlc a little more context
People hating Yukari because she's want to see someone she's love again 😐.
Listen man, I will act the same too if I have a chance to see someone I love again.
My egoistic will rise to the top.
Watching this after beating the one in Reload.
This is so much easier by comparison.
bruh yukari is probably my favorite in p3 she felt the most real😭😭
Michelle Ruff SLAYED those lines.
INEEDYOURHALP
Meen Lord **g a s p** ThE eNeMy
Persona!!!@@miriam4341
Persona!!!@@miriam4341
The part where she breaks down confirms that she loved him (MC) from the beginning
She first opened up to Makoto in the hospital, went to the love hotel with him in a dream (because of a shadow), scolded Makoto for being so reckless and telling junpei how worried she is for Makoto in the movies, was surprised when Makoto went looking for her at the yakushima beach, got flustered when Makoto gave her a hug, got a little jealous because of what aigis was saying to Makoto in her first day of school, cried out to Makoto in the final battle with nyx. She really really loved him for sure
@@theadmiral4157There's a few extra episodes in Reload where she becomes determined to cook him a delicious meal.
Mitsuru being the one to console her makes this scene all the more powerful.
At first I thought Yukari wanted to see her dad again but it was makoto
I mean, she just wanted the love of her life back in her life.
Robo-Knight YT thats why I love Yukari
@@slickyami1877 dude, I wished Persona had a character creator in the game lol
I guess she moved on from him and accepted his death like minato did with his parents and wanted him and die with him thanks to the video Fuuka Gave she realized her dad was a hero that sacrificed his life to save others by telling them what to do and now minato has done what he did
Also kinda disappointed minato didn’t get mad at yukari or Mitsuru for their parents and their company who basically were the reason why his parents are dead wish we got more development their
Minato: (this isn't right. This wasn't supposed to happen)
I mean all they had to do was use the power of friendship and beat nyx and minato lives and stays with yukari despite the multiple relationships he has been with
Makoto: *Uses Great seal so his friends can live and be happy*
His Friends: *Tries to kill each other*
Makoto: *Surprised Pikachu face*
o baby whos ready to experience this once more in modernized graphics high quality in 2024?
yukari suffering 4k HD
3:02 she sounded so happy seconds ago...
I don’t care what anyone says, Yukari was the heart of The Answer.
8:51 This part was so sad and emotional for Yukari. I mean you can’t blame her for wanting to see someone saved her and help change her life after losing her father. So I don’t care what others say, I still love Yukari
Can I just say, why the heck are people hating on Yukari for her irrational but understandable obsession with seeing Minato again, when everyone ignores Yosuke's irrational and not-as-understandable desire to MURDER someone later in P4?! Both can result in massive reprecussions, like the end of the world, but which sounds better, being an idiot out of grief, or hatred?
Some Asian well yosuke was only aware his actions would kill one person, yukari's actions had the possibility of killing everyone and that's something she should have been aware of, plus she was willing to hurt her freinds to do it unlike yosuke who really didn't try to hurt anyone else than the one guy.
Nikkolas Karvalho yeah, cept Yosuke didn't go through as much childhood trauma as Yukari did.
If im cotrect hour taking about when the little girl "died" in P4 everyone was fond of her so it was anger at killing the one that killed a child. Yukari just wants Minato's D not carrying about the whole world that he saved
Neva Lavalley first re edit your comment and I may take you seriously.
Some Asian dude I understand her wanting to see Makoto again but she didn’t think this through, going back to ‘save’ Makoto causes everyone to die including him so no matter what he was gonna die either way.
For Yosuke his best friends sister ‘died’ in front of him and he was fond of her just like the rest of P4, and may I add if you didn’t complete his social like before that time he was sill getting over saki konisi’s death so him seeing Nanko die probably triggered of how he lost Saki
Again before anyone jumps me saying ‘dumbass it’s been months since he lost Dali he’s gotten over it by now’
I said IF you didn’t complete his social link
Only played the remake which I think gameplay wise is better, but definitely felt Yukari's breakdown more here than the remake.
wow the quality is so god like! you could have fooled me if you told me this was a PS3 Game.
But it's ps4 graphics :(
@@BuffMaister lol
@@BuffMaister how do you do it? Plzzz tell me
I was actually jealous with Aigis being the protagonist and not Yukari.
Ramen Forever how in what way is Yukari more deserving then Aigis smh
@@HealthymemesExe Exactly. I don’t think this person payed attention to Aigis’ entire character. Aigis was more close to Makoto. Even Yukari said that Aigis cared for Makoto the most when you beat her.
This is actually lampshades by Yukari herself in The Answer.
> gets absolutely wrecked for half her health
>is that all you’ve got?
How can people hate Yukari after this I just don’t get she is the most human character ever.
I agree. The sad truth is that not everyone deals with loss rationally.
11:19. ...I mean you also get the power to summon Satan and stuff so...
i remembered being sad over this scene years ago (hell this is what got me to love yukari lol) so as i was talking about this scene to my friend (who's not into persona) and showing this video to them, i didnt expect to be bawling at yukari's "i want to see him" 😭
Everyone in P3 lost someone important, Mitsuru lost her father, Ken lost his mother, Akihiko lost his sister and Shinjiro, Junpei lost chidori, and Aigiz lost minato who was also her closest friend. Everone was effected by minato death as they too have already lost someone they love, considering minato is their rock too.
Though I understand yukari anger and coldness to everyone, wish Yukari could have see how everyone is struggling with loss too instead of lashing out expecially to aigis.
i remember back in my highschool, one of our clique passed away and our group was really effected but everyone dealt the grief differently. It IS DIFFICULT, havent move on yet. I do understand yukari's action, how she feels minato understands her the most, but I do understand why alot of people was abit annoyed. Persona 3 really hits you emotionally
Couldn't have said it better myself.
Everyone except fuuka. She didn't lose her parents and her closest friend
Before this part, I assumed Mitsuru was following Yukari half because friendship, but mostly to try and save her dad. I feel like this would've fit her character more, for some reason. I get what they were trying to do with her position (also conviniently allows SEES to be paired up), but I really do feel like it would be more fitting for Mitsuru to try and help Yukari _before_ they all fought each other. Of course that's just my idea of the characters, but Mitsuru doesn't seem like the type to go going along with extremely stupid desisions like she does.
Yukari and Makoto's relationship is just like Sun Shang Xiang and Sun Ce as very close like Yukari is Makoto's girlfriend and Sun Shang Xiang is Ce's little sister.
There is no cannon girlfriend in P3, but it is cannon that Yukari truly loved Makoto.
For everyone that is saying The Answer ruined Yukari and is highly unrealistic, may I interest you in Tought Bubble’s video on Yukari? Someone that actually studied psychology explains why this is super in character and realistic.
Or just having to lose someone suddenly by any circumstances and have to pick up the pieces afterwards. I know I have been in Yukari's shoes myself.
Im a few years late i love mitsuru but seeing her suffer makes me sad but it is the only way to get the true key dang only if i could play fes
Why we don't have a movie about the answer? Atlus Why?
Now that you mention it, The Answer could be a great Part 5 of the P3 movie series. Between Aigis and Yukari dealing with grief, The Answer could be a very emotional movie.
Because the director or writer had favoritism toward aigis and made minato and yukari interactions like friendship instead of a loving bond which I am still mad about in the movie and now that the answer was the last one they didn’t want to even explain why their version yukari became mean and in love with minato when they acted like friends the entire time and I’m still mad we never got the small interactions with Yuko and the sports club or minato joining the council and helping chirio and playing with that little girl and going to the club meeting the monk or visit the old couple in the bookstore and that sick boy I really wish they did a anime series instead of the movie rushing the story
3:02 Did they have to use Heartful Cry as boss battle theme? :'(
Yes they had to do it
Yes.
That's why this battle exists in the first place.
Heartful cry was made for this battle
At Least yukari didn't say I'll show my true power
I wonder if yukari still has makoto in her memories after becoming the pink featherman and going to showbiz part time
I mean my dude literally saved her life on multiple occasions and even saved the world at that. I don't think that's someone you can easily forget. Even if Yukari found a new love, she will always be thankful to Makoto.
In persona 4 arena yukari mention him indirect multiple time such as remembering remembering Thanatos and some of yukari battle quote are directed from his loss from makoto
Waifu wars
Literally
Quality of this Video So Good :)
Watching this make me wanna play this game again
i remember i beat final boss everytime i love it 'the answer' story
Oh no what’s Mitsuru gonna do
_Marin Karin?!_
Same thing with Yukari “I wOn’T mIsS” Takeba.
To Yukari, I have to the words of a Wise and positive thinking reporter:
"I know now something far worse than being forgotten...It is chaining others down...please forget about me. You can all change your life by believing in yourself and make your dreams a reality. Stay Positive"
The memories about Minato/Makoto became a burden for his teammates, which is far worse than anything Nyx had done to him. It's better being forgotten than burdening others with a legacy that leaves wounds and pain behind.
That's like saying they should have killed Ryoji and forget everything about the dark hour and their growth which goes against P3's themes in the first place.
P2 is a completely different context,it's quotes don't mesh with P3
Persona fans when women act like humans and not sex objects:
This is one of the most Raw and Unironic Examples of such from the Persona Fandom. I never got to complete The Answer back then but I am glad to come back as an Adult after losing so much and feeling my back against a corner. Fuck those people who don't get it. The Answer is necessary.
@@ZX-Gearwe tend to understand things more clearly and deeply when we become adults. Hope those people saying yukari's a bitch actually understands her now
If only certain "fan artists" could see this.
@@ZX-Gear persona 3 is so interesting because of how completely dysfunctional the whole cast is. The MC is the only barrier and this is exactly what happens with him gone and NO ONE is right. That's the point of the original game, I have no idea why people don't like it
@@ExtremeEnthusiast704 Too bad the one loudest about this is not only suspended but also got caught liking porn of a minor.
Man, i cant wait to see this get fully animated in p3 reload dlc. Its gonna make some people cry especially if they actually showed us how yukari made that promise to makoto
Ooh, i cant wait till September
3:31 “All they’ve got” just lowered her to half lol
Man, this stuff is good! Hope they really add this one to the game if they're gonna have a remake of Persona 3
Sucks it wasn't gotten animated, may have had a lot of impact
Yeah... good & bad news
and now, kiss
Demn. Yukari and Mitsuru is
When You Use Attack Mirror And Magic Mirror Yukari And Mitsuru Start Spamming Megidolaon
Yukari: he’s gone and he can’t come back, and I have to live with that
Igor: oh I keep a backup of his soul in the velvet room and sick him on future wild cards just for the fun of it you know.
Imagine if you could make fun of their dads during the fight.
You can't show me this and convince me Mitsuru isn't in love with her.
As much as I sound like a little kid, It would be kind of cool for Elizabeth to use up all her power to revive “Him” all the whole sacrificing herself
Thats what shes doing actually. She left the Velvet room to go revive him. But instead of using her power to just revive him, because im sure she could do that pretty easily,she's going to use her power to kill Nyx too. Then there wont be a need for a seal.
@@ihavenonamestilldonthaveon8970 maruki reality
I find this not to make yukari a bad character and I don’t see why people think it does this shows how human she is this is how anybody would react if they lost somebody they loved she loved him and that’s sad to see her like this makoto is missed badly and I can’t blame her
The Answer really bothers me with how they ketp pushing Aigis and Yukari as romance options for the Mc. Feels bad to be a Mitsuru fan
I mean, maxing out all the Social Links requires Minato/Makoto to bang everyone he can anyway. Does it really matter?
@@colonelmustang854 Ugggh don’t remind me about his shit
@@colonelmustang854 or getting banged
They're hinting at mitsuru and akihiko in the game so
Especially considering the fact that their English VAs are married in real life.
Okay but this moment would've been a lot more sad if I actually cared for Aigis as a character. I never even liked her for some odd reason and was mad salty because she got Minato's power. I feel as though if we could choose from the few characters who were really close to us (Junpei, Yukari, etc) then the moment would be more emotional.
@darklordster lmao everything about you screams "I'm 13 and this is deep." Learn to respect an opinion boo.
@darklordster and I never said anything was wrong with the game nor the characters.
I kinda see where you're coming from. She's just not that interesting as a character.
@@GiordanDiodato She just felt so shallow and uninteresting to me. I get why they made it Aigis but I just felt more attached to Yukari who I also hate and Junpei.
Giordan Diodato while I like Aigis, I just don’t think she is as great as many others make her out to be. Although she did get some great moments in The Answer- not quite as well handled as Yukari, but it’s better than what everyone else got.
I can't with the soundtrack... I really feel so sad fighting with the SEES while that song plays in the background :'c
I think its called "heartful cry"
@@senko-san5095 exactly
came back cuz the remake didnt have the same impact (still loved it tho ;))
in my opinion, the remake was better than the original except for removing the part where Yukari tries to rip the key out of Aigis' hands.
The only way I win this fight was by getting a double crit attack on Mitsuru using a charged up auto mataru Siegfried. Killed that bufudyne bitch at the second turn.
Damn.... adachi was right
It breaks my heart thinking this, but if she didn’t have her friends behind her back, Makoto’s death might’ve been Yukari’s 13th reason why…
The graphics is so pretty. I wonder what hardware is used and the emulator settings.
Did you get any huge space between words/text? I been trying to solve this issue and have similar settings as you.
ABL138 That's the Font problem. You have to go inside the .pnach and put // in front all the ''//Font fix by nemesis2000 (causes spacing errors)'' and below.
That should fix it.
BuffMaister Thank you that solved my problem. I dont see the point of this "fix" I wonder if it causes any negative effects when turned off.
ABL138 The game isn't suppose to support wide screen as it only works on the emulator. That's why it breaks some parts of the dialogue because of that, and it can be recorrected with that font fix. It should also fix some portraits as characters/persona's.
And now the remake has proven it's uselessness. Toning down this scene also really highlights that the new cast just doesn't cut it.
yep, had to come back to this because the new one didnt have much impact
i hoped shed get angry and try to take it away from aigis but she didnt
seemed more like she loved him more as a friend in reload, but loved him as a woman in 3fes. which is why the OG hits that much harder, she sounded so desperate, so angry and so jealous in p3f so it makes it that much more sadder.
since she lost her dad, it was even that much harder to let go of a new person she loved so much, already so damn soon. so it makes sense why shed act so immaturely in p3f instead of her just bottling things up like she did in reload
true that, p3r's aigis dlc just don't have that impact p3 fes has. they basically, in my opinion, made p3r dlc like a watered down version of p3 fes.
The new cast is phenomenal. The thing that is the problem was atlas' direction with that scene.
@@hediazafranco8211 Agreed. Cast was amazing in Reload but this part of the scene didn't need to be removed, albeit it is pretty small (it's like 15 seconds long).
The cast has nothing to do with it bruh, blame the script changes.
Yukari: Give me minato's D!
Give her the door knob
8:56
Poor yukari 😔
Bro yukari keep getting the L"s
9:33 I don't remember these lines :(
I hadn't finished the answer, I only played like a couple of hours of it; however, what i remember was that Yukari was acting like a total BITCH in this mode. Lol Holy crap.
Mother's daughter indeed.
why is the quality 1080p this isnt normal persona 3 quality
Girl was so real for this
Just I think aegis make the wrong decision?
is she a p5 persona user? the one with mask?
No
She is simple just like Aigis and doesn't need and evoker
😭😭😭
When someone uses those emojis I image a wrinkly toe looking guy crying.
Sooo...Yukari you want to go back un time to see him again and reverse him SAVING THE WORLD AND YOU USLESS PATHETIC ASS. -_- screw off Yukari you had character growth and threw it out the window for more Minato's D
The Answer is terrible dude. And Yukari was never a good character.
well i mean her friend/lover is gone and there's a chance to bring him back its natural for her to do that
@@michaeljames6737 And That's the part when she enters as a bad character, She don't learn Nyx Lesson, she don't acept Death as Part of Circle of Life.
@@richiemakyura724 Which doesn't make her a bad cause there are how many people relate to her. It's quite a possibility you and many others would do the same thing as she did. Grief does so much to people
@@richiemakyura724 im sure if you lost both your dad and the love of your life you'd be very cheerful and think straight all the time
Newsflash, everyone deals with grief in different ways.@@dde8721Doesn't make Yukari any special. Also, Grief ain't a good excuse for going on a potentially dangerous, and foolish time loop just to see your "beloved" again.