"It's completely unlawful," says Chris Daw KC on the Govt's proposed Illegal Immigration Bill
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 มี.ค. 2023
- He tells Sky News' Sarah Jane Mee:
"We are governed by the European Convention on Human Rights.... This legislation breaks every single one of those fundamental pieces of human rights legislation.... The irony of that is that the United Kingdom was the founding signatory of every single one of those documents."
![CAMPปลิ้น | EP.77[2/2] "รับทราบ" แก๊งเพื่อนรัก 10 ปี ที่ไปไหนก็มีตำนาน!](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ifc0ofD51B0/mqdefault.jpg)
![[UNCUT] ที่นี่ที่แรก ปู - หาญส์ พูดถึงมหากาพย์หนี้สิ้น I คนดังนั่งเคลียร์ I 10 ก.ค.67](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/KDNA9DZ0p4U/mqdefault.jpg)
I get the feeling the mainstream media do not like this new bill.
You might as well just say Lugenpresse.
@@coreyc1685 Forget the 40k excess deaths over winter due to the NHS lack of funding.... lets spend £7m per day housing so called refugees in luxury hotels up and down the country.... gotta stay woke.
Dear Chris, would you please consider becoming leader of the opposition? The current incumbent has the constitution of a wet noodle.
I used to work at the Scottish Refugee Council 20-ish years ago, and asylum was a minefield then. The fear and suffering was appalling. This new legislation is horrifying. Thank you for speaking out so magnificently and unequivocally.
If the left want to legalise illegal immigration then what they are essentially saying is that human trafficking should be made legal 😂😂😂😂
Yeah, much easier to move people without papers 🤗
Nope . The left aren’t doing that. International law is already there and was created by us !
You are not listening it isn't Illegal immigration listen again. Brexit the loss of the Dublin accord and cooperation with our fellow Europeans Johnson should have negotiated a returns policy before signing but he ignored that totally, all he was interested in was been able to brag about getting brexit done, not to mention this sorry excuse for a government who have completed failed in processing applications. Tories are playing the public blaming refugees not their own failings. This government is taking the country into the economic gutter and trashing the reputation of the country on the global stage.
@@KentReynolds - I wonder how valid your "international law" would be if we decided to finally balance the books of our public spending... oh and of course you wont be personally taking in any refugees will you... someone in some Government office on a keyboard will type something into a screen and it will all be magically paid for by the flying treasury tooth fairy wont it.
You're clearly incapable of following the article you're commenting on. It is not "illegal" to seek asylum in this or almost any other country, no matter by what means you arrive, no matter how many other 'safe' countries you have passed through, no matter whether or not you have documentation. This is not a matter of opinion, it is a matter of fact, a matter of international law; laws, it should be added, framed and initiated largely by British lawmakers, not least of whom was that well-known "left" political figure (that's irony, I would point out as I fear you may experience difficulty in grasping it) Winston Churchill. So, to pick up on your own 'theme', if the right want make illegal the perfectly legitimate immigration we have currently, "what you're essentially saying" is that they will have to break international, in so doing, this country would immediately become an international pariah state , along with Russia and Belarus, in addition to the mantle of world laughing stock it has assumed since the disastrous Brexit decision. That is not going to happen, of course, because they know very well that what they are proposing is illegal. It's just another part of their culture wars agenda to provide a smokescreen for their appalling lack of any solutions to the real problems facing this country and in order to throw some 'red meat' to their hard-of-thinking voter base. But then I expect you would know all about that.
I witnessed my mother in tears for her brother lost on HMS Hood, fighting fascism, Braverman and the Tory party are now Fascists
I'm not a lawyer but just for specific sources I have found, Article 31 of the 1951 convention states that Countries shall not impose penalties on refugees who entered illegally in search of asylum if they present themselves without delay. In UK court system article 31 has been enforced previously: Regina v Uxbridge Magistrates and Another ex parte Adimi; R v CPS ex parte Sorani; R v SSHD and Another ex parte Kaziu: Admn 29 Jul 1999. My question is would it even reach international courts or would it fail even in UK courts.
The successive UK Gov seem to be keen ignoring domestic as well as international laws. Often we see MPs voting into laws regulations which are unlawful to start with. Lacking knowledge and only guided by greed and keen to keeping their position first they go no matter what then look like fool when they have to back off.
Something is also weir with the system in place.
Francis Although I agree with your opinion you say 'The successive UK Gov'
I'm sorry but I really don't think as many of UK people do they haven't been that successful up to now We need DRASTIC ACTION now !
yeah, Uk isn't an independent country it should follow laws of other nations😤 How dare they have their own laws😡🤬
Ridiculous. Should we leave NATO then ? And what about the WTO?
so how do you make the distinction between genuine refugees and economic migrants posing as refugees, the greedy have spoiled it for the genuine
You can't, because we don't have a working asylum system.
Look we all know its a ploy . They know this will never happen. Lets hope they do something un forgiving obviously the mchtr arena wasnt bad enough.
This is an excellent summary of the legal position. THANK YOU!
Just pop into 73 Gunnersbury Avenue and they'll make the arrangements
Only America can do that ,we all know that , Guantanomo in Cuba 🇨🇺 they still have prisoners
Well said. Lest we forget.
Love it when someone speaks the truth and isn't scared to go all the way to defend it
God bless the guy!
Totally agree Jethro
When anyone enters UK they have to abide by UK rules & regs It's obvious
Otherwise WE can & will send them back !
@@leakoe3797 It should be that way but on that token the Home Secretary and so-called Prime Minister would've been deported aeons ago even tried for high treason in a perfect world
I live across the sea in Netherlands and on a clear day can see the Eastern shores of the UK from my ivory tower
@@jethrotull2142
Jethro I totally agree with you
How lovely to look out to see that
Sounds beautiful
Try entering a country through an airport without a passport.
You will not be allowed entry.
Stop coming to uk please
Thank god. Someone speaking reason.
This government has already expressed its thoughts on expert opinion.
Chris Daw is talking NONSENDE
UK has NO obligation to these immigrants who arrive illegally
CD is INSANE needs mental help !
the thing is that illegal os against the law then remopving them is the law how can the law be illegal
If people were ' immotive ' they would be on the streets ' they are complacent and addicted to ' The TV ,Sport,Fast food and reading headlines ' a sorry lot your middle of the road British household, a place to avoid if you want to hold any sort of real discussion, l say it as l see it 😀 😉
I don’t see many women and children on the boats. But I stand with Gary, freedom of speech must prevail
Mr. Daw is right on all issues.
It seems that the ECHR is applicable to others but not to any UK citizen 😕
I’m great with sunak remove cross channel and asylum seekers remove
But what but for people living long time more than 12yaers in U.K. is not time to give amnesty help economic pay tax
Many tax have go to Ukrainian. Help
Nether have macron pe s France 🇫🇷 is tick
Many tax U.K.
The right wing press is doing a wonderful job judging by the comments on this broadcast. We have a cost of living crisis, the NHS is in dire straits, the police are underfunded, the fire fighters are underfunded, social services, mental health services and long term care are stretched to breaking point and you choose to focus on migrants who are coming from war torn, countries, faced torture, slavery, rape, hoemlessness...I am quite certain the majority would prefer to stay in their homeland not come to this polluted, xenophobic, not so pleasant land!!
Exactly this, people on here saying get rid of the ECHR not realising what it contains and that doing so will likely affect them in the future
and why youy rhink we have cost of liveing cos all our tax is going on housing thse illegals rather than british homeless , some ppl really have been brain washed and proablly unwashed as well uslally the antifa protesterrs
That is the problem with democracy, unfortunately - not all voters are well informed before voting, and look for easy solutions to complicated problems. They find it complicated and boring to get to grips with what brings inflation up and down, what international agreements apply, and the rights those are supposed to secure for refugees and asylum seekers, so they instead come up with their own explanations and blame it on the immigrants, cause that is easier, and also give them a direction for all the anger they have built up over 13 years of Tory rule. But which the thought that the problem might be the government's incompetency, rather than ill will from the EU, or immigrants taking all the jobs, still hasn't struck them. Even though many seems to starting to wake up. I pity the old style Conservatives, who now feel they no longer has a party, cause they are too well informed to be tricked about nonsense about the small boats danger. They know immigration would have been much more orderly and efficient, if there were legal routes, both for foreigners to apply for seasonal work permits, and to seek asylum or claim status as a refugee.
@@steptay The UnitedS Nations has said that 100 000 people are displaced. But most of those are so either within their own country, or in neighbouring countries. They most of all would like to get home. It is not 100 millions who wants to get to Europe.
@@greentroll9326 what was the excuse for not housing the homeless prior to 2018? You do know that if a government wanted to they could house the homeless and process migrants humanely and quickly and legally if they wanted to and you have the cheek to accuse others of being brainwashed
Watch your back, Chris, as the tories DARK ARTS MACHINE WILL GO INTO COMBAT MODE!!
Hold up, you're saying I don't need a passport or a visa to go wherever I want in Europe 🤯
Not if you claim asylum
@@KentReynolds But I don't have to claim asylum in the 1ste country I arrive in, thus I can take a tour of Europe and go home🤗
Parliament decides what is lawful, not a single lawyer!
Eh eh except when it agreed upon and signed international laws which are scrutinized, accepted and voted in by this very parliament .🤷♂️🤷♂️🤷♂️🤦♂️🤪
But Parliament is supreme and no parliament can bind a future parliament.
@@franciscouderq1100 Then drop those international laws. I would rather be slightly poorer but live in comfort and a peaceful society.
Europe has become a joke. Economic stagnation for 10 years. Huge influx of migrants with 0 powers to remove them.
Toothless police across the continent leading to rampant crime.
Australia was able to block them from coming in by boats. US is pushing them back in Mexic. Poland/Hungary are building fences.
But we are the bad guys for saying enough. Give me a break
th-cam.com/video/jXqVGtxFppQ/w-d-xo.html
@@barnham9388 Parliament laws have to be in compliance with international laws to be respected internationally.
UK citizens want them returned .regardless of what this guy tells us. This guy lives in a huge home not next door to these thugs and criminals. If he did live near them he would be worried about his children specially girls as this culture have zero respect for women's rights
Gino doesn't sound like a white name pal. Why don't you get out of our country?
Are you also talking about yr Mp and PM ?
@@WaheedAli-lx4hh what's a name or colour of skin got to do with this you racial Muppet. I am actually black and a Muslim and I cam to UK legally. You racial spin
@@franciscouderq1100 Goverment.
th-cam.com/video/jXqVGtxFppQ/w-d-xo.html
No problem. The government will just withdraw from the relevant UN conventions that prevent this being implemented. Job done. 👍
But then we also lose the other human rights like freedom not to be tortured or discriminated against etc . You don’t want the majority able to do these things just because they are the majority or sooner or later fascism may take over
Kick em out.
YOU should be kicked out.
And the lawyers
Kick em all out and leftys.
I’m so hurt.
Says someone who has a vested interest in keeping them coming/making money out of stopping them from being sent back
There speaks the true voice of National Front.
@@californiadreamin8423 I just the truth you don’t like. And using the typical you are racist if you disagree. Legal migration is fine. Illegal migration is not especially via a SAFE country. No one in there right mind would let a complete stranger into there house who just rocks up, cannot prove who they are and where they are from and what they have been upto. No one
@@MrMarcusWWW And there you are wrong….if you are seeking asylum, you can travel through as many “safe” countries as you choose, until you reach the country of your choice. It’s a bit like Dominic Raabs father who fled Mein Kampf in the late 30’s, and sought asylum here, a choice his son denies to others. Odd that. When half this Tory Cabinet are barely off the boat themselves, their policies are bizarre, as if they have a stain they’re trying to remove….and they need bigots like you to wash away their sins.
Thank you. Genuinely made me proud to be british for a moment (not that often atm with this govt). We need to fight these morally bankrupt, inept and devisive tories!
Me, white British born British citizen, have had my human rights breached by British courts. And nobody runs to my defence.
Which human rights? Do tell
Yea please do tell ? And I’m guessing because no body ran to your defence , you attack other marginalised groups? You think you the good guy here ?😂
Ooooh you too, Chipotle ????
hmm, I wonder if this country had been hit by bombs from putin and you were desperate to find somewhere safe - where would you go?
@@kitglare8800 Dude, please 😆😆 I went on holiday to Ukraine twice last year. To Kyiv and Odesa. Had a great time. War? What war..... It's like The Truman Show out there. The exact time you were watching your choice of Mainstream Media, being told these cities were under daily drone attacks, I am there looking to the sky and asking "what drones"?... I am going right up to the actual Russian border this summer. I am already seeing TH-camrs doing exactly that.. Someone has to go bust this war myth.
Well to rain 🌧 on his parade the simple solution is to pull out of the ECHR and all the other convention this country has signed up to.
hmm, I wonder if this country had been hit by bombs from putin and you were desperate to find somewhere safe - where would you go?
th-cam.com/video/jXqVGtxFppQ/w-d-xo.html
Pulling out of the ECHR will do nothing as he is quite clearly talking of the UN as in UNITED NATIONS.
So you just demonstrated how completely clueless you are.
Congrats.
You want to lose your human rights???
I propose, you first read them.
@@Nice0n3 Yes. Its unbelievable.
You don’t get any asylum from any country I go to on vacation.
Try North Korea
Ryanair/Wizz/Easyjet don’t fly there….
That s because of Brexit, surely you can’t easily rerun to the Continent, sad frustrated Brit
@@franciscouderq1100 You can't fly to North Korea because of Brexit? Did you really just say that?
Leave the ECHR it's the only way
hmm, I wonder if this country had been hit by bombs from putin and you were desperate to find somewhere safe - where would you go?
th-cam.com/video/jXqVGtxFppQ/w-d-xo.html
@@kitglare8800 hmmm yes hmmmm why would I be attached by Russia .
Yer I agree with you completely then I can bring in a law to get you hung
The ECHR founded by Churchill.
Seems you would prefer to live in a state like Russia.
Its not unlawful just morally correct.
You are clearly an expert on morals. Where did you qualify ?
This guy isn’t an apolitical lawyer at all, just saying….
Why would he when talking about Int’l Rules accepted agreed and signed up into UK laws ?
@@franciscouderq1100 I haven’t seen the government’s legal advice but I would assume the Home Office have at least had an equally eminent lawyer on their team tell them it’s at least arguable. Pay two different lawyers for two different opinions and you’ll get two different opinions. All I’m saying is this guy is probably gunning for being appointed A-G in a Keir Starmer government….
Or some other legal sinecure in the next (Labour) government….
He is very Left leaning, just from looking at some of his previous videos. He wants the courts to go easier on criminals. Oh good grief. 🙄
@@barnham9388 Are you serious? How can you even imagine any - ANY - lawyer with integrity to claim locking up people for 28 days, without access to legal advice or appeal, before sending them out could be legal?????? Likewise how can you expect sending asulym seekers away without even allowing them to apply for asylum, and describe what they seek protection from, to be in accordance with international law??????
We don’t need any new migration bill. We just need to enforce the existing laws.
Trouble is the French won't listen to us when we try and tell them to do just that
@@dylanharper1274 You are no longer an EU member. Had you been, you could have returned asylum seekers to the first EU country the asylum seeker came to, since that is where they should asylum according to EU rules (remember the EU has internal free float of people, so after having been granted asylum, the asylist is free to travel or relocate to other EU countries. That is why sending asylum seekers to the first EU country they arrived in is possible within the EU - but does not include countries outside the EU.).
Exactly….we need to enforce Human Rights Laws.
@@dylanharper1274 Yeah... I wonder why? :D
Probably because the French understand their responsibilities under international law? And the British try not to? Even though it was the British who played the leading role in creating those very same laws that the French (and so many other countries) signed up to and actually take seriously.
Yup. Helluva country the UK has turned into. When Parliament is asked to introduce laws that are, themselves, unlawful. And then expects people to respect the laws it passes thereafter.
As if.
@@Tvjunkieful12 There was no need to leave the Dublin regulations when we left the EU, but the extremists wanted the hardest possible brexit regardless of the consequences. There are about half as many asylum-seekers now as there were 20 years ago. The Home Office used to process 90% of claims within six months, now it's 4%. The small boats are a very recent phenomenon. This entire "crisis" is deliberately manufactured.
Lets give asylum to 200 million refugees, sure, why not……
I'm surprised that more people aren't fleeing the UK at this moment
Now you are a typical Daily Mail reading gullible muppet. Right wing racist too most probably.
@David: How stupid one can be. If all idiots could fly you would probably be a squadron leader.
god you are a sponge that absorbs rubbish - check the statistics of that statement - quite easy to find out how inaccurate it is
th-cam.com/video/jXqVGtxFppQ/w-d-xo.html
The current right wing government and it PR machine (Daily Mail etc) are making this country so bad it hurts. It feels like Germany in the 1930's.
was you alive in 1930s germany i tink not so stfu . only british tax money spent on illegals shopuld be to deport them ,,,
It more or less is like Germany in the 1930s. High inflation, politically isolated, economic problems, and an extremist government which goes after anyone who oppose them from unions to independent voices like Lineker, and push forward immigrants as scapegoats the same way the Nazis blamed Jews.
🙄
Gary, is that you?
Other way around other countries ignores laws that suits them we can't keep taking these migrants this country is like a dumping ground it's finished