ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 มิ.ย. 2021
- VERSION 7.0 • Rey Vs. Palpatine - Fo...
Rey Vs. Palpatine - Force Ghost Fan Edit 4.0 | Star Wars: The Rise Of Skywalker
PARTIAL CREDIT GOES TO JON H AND FORCE GHOST LIVE AS THESE ARE THEIR EDITS, I JUST COMBINED THE TWO AND MADE MANY REVISIONS AND ADDITIONAL EDITS
You can all see now, the fans do the best work because they are both passionate and dedicated and know the source material inside and out.
I may have some information that may surprise you.
I agree!!!
So I've learned! Let the fans make the movies!
@@overbank56 I have a feeling it would be very fan service. Consulting fans is best. Like personally, this is a nice idea, but the close ups on each of the force ghosts is odd.
@@samphillips8188 ok
Anakin’s force ghost is like, “Now it’s payback time for everything you took from me.” 😼
Or he could be saying “This is the end for you, my master!”
Images palpitine is sand
Anakin is the Best Villain and the Best jedi
Yoda was a Jedi also but they his skills in one of the movies.
Revenge is not the Jedi way.
This is the real ending.
I was but we couldn’t see the ghosts
Yes
Exactly!!!!!!!!!!!!!
no it's not
Real ending is vi
This is the true ending that should have been done. Even the scoring ties in the scene to be epic.
The music was still courtesy of John Williams, but I can’t deny the way it’s used here.
This is honestly what I was hoping to see and hear when I saw this in theaters, and I ended up disappointed that it didn’t happen. This maybe fan made, but this is what Star Wars is all about! Nicely done! 👍
This would be marvelous in a re-release. But also - I'm still sentimental. I want to see some dialogue between Anakin's Force Ghost, and Luke - - and especially Leia.
Actually that was supposed to happen but Kathleen Kennedy wanted it changed
fax
@@starstuff5371 I hate to see the saga end 😢
You actually went to the movie theaters and gave them money to see this garbage.
This probably the greatest fan edit I've ever seen. Hands down.
Yess
How does a fan edit better than a major motion studio! This is the way it should have been, I got chills when she said "And I am all the Jedi" with the music in the background and all of them with the outstretched hand! Wow!!!!
You can't have it this way, because of "girl power"
@@bongobongo985 It's not girl power, there are countless well written women characters it's just that this was a shamless cashgrab and they had no idea what the hell they were doing. I can forgive the first one being a redo of a New Hope but it was clear beyond that that they had no good ideas and Rian Johnson ruined the rest of it. I don't blame him for it though in a way because he told people what he would do. It's just that Abrahams style of magic box doesn't work in this context and he tried to undo what Rian started. There was poor communication.
Don't get me wrong, I cant stand Last Jedi and Rise, the actors did the best they could with the shitty source material and Rey was clearly not Lame and Gay.
@@circuschris2880 oH no you are wrong. The writers have explicitly stated they want to make "men feel uncomfortable" with these movies. They want ment to hate the new Star Wars??? LOL, What? GIRL POWER!!
Because the Jedi are all boys
Right
Qui-Gon: Gives encouraging words
Obi-Wan: Support's her Force connection
Luke & Leila: Reminds her that the Force is always with her
Anakin: Passing his lightsaber using the Force
Windu: Strengthening her grip
Ahsoka: Silently holding her
And Yoda: Get the job done with a single blast using the Force (just like he did during his last confrontation with Darth Sidious)
Now THIS would have had the fans standing and cheering for a PERFECT ENDING to the Saga!
I agree...
Instead , they tried to get they're money back
@jjosh7707 LOL! Ain't THAT the truth!!!! As Han Solo said in A New Hope: WHAT THE HELL ARE YOU DOING???????
Nah, people still would have complained about it. When star wars fans hate something, nothing really changers their mind.
Now that's a bit of a stretch. That would still be random-fanfic-heroine#6801 looking at us and telling us that she's more significant than the entire cast of all the previously-made material.
Over and over again, I'm simply amazed that the fans can make better star wars movies than big name directors and studios.
Fans didn't make a better "movie" haha. It was one scene edited. You can't compare the two. But yes, this scene was better.
So many chills. When they’re all standing in that line, nostalgic lightening bolt. Brilliantly done.
THIS should be the scene we watched theatrically! So good!!!
Absolutely gorgeous. I am now telling myself that this is what actually happened and you have given me the opportunity to do so with such a powerful and emotional piece of work. Thank you.
Fan’s do the best work
This small 2 min clip had more emotional weight then the entire Disney trilogy
I legit think if big movie companies just got like 40 of the biggest nerds of whatever franchise they are doing a movie for, movies would be a billion times better. This was a masterpiece for example. The back and forth of the ghost Jedi, with the perfect music intro, all the way to the last push by Yoda. Absolutely amazing
If this was the actual ending people would have loved this movie not hated on it every second of every day until the end of time haha
Actually I think it's more line people are divided on it. Also JJ Abrams actually gave a reason for then not being seen.
@@disneyboy3030 what was that reason? Can you link me to an article? I know the reason for not showing Ben as a Force Ghost which I think is bull. I also know in Legends force ghosts eventually turned to nothing but George obviously didn't care about legends or see it as cannon.
@@disneyboy3030 not mention vast majority of people see this movie as a disappointment. Last Jedi is what I'd call a divisive film.
@@mukkywater here is the link.
th-cam.com/video/GLncYjAjfYA/w-d-xo.html
But people will still hate episode 1
I Really got Goosebumps from your Scene.
In one word Perfect. All the jedi combined in perfect scene.
Leia:😬
I would dare Industrial Light & Magic to try and top this.
Whoever created this….. thank you.
if the director and disney had done this for that movie many original fans would have gone and seen it and it would have tied into the lucas timeline and made it legit. could you imagine the feeling of having those chracters back rey in the movie , it gave me goosebumbs and rey would be a recognized jedi and not a laughing stalk. well done and thank you!
OMG this was freaking amazing, this without a doubt would have had the whole theater going crazy!!!
The final duel was fantastic...
SO many wonderful emotions come to me when I see this. But for now I'd like to just say....Leia, in her White.....as a Force Presence....looks so....pure, distinctive, poised, powerful. She was, and will always be our Princess and General.
I agree
In Memoriam:
Carrie Fisher (1956-2016)
“The Force will be with you, always.”
Oh, the look on the face of Anakin's force ghost was like a great big BLEEP you to Sheev.
As a decades old Star Wars fan, this seriously brought tears to my eyes.. Well done!
This person needs to be in charge of the whole of redoing the last 3 episodes!!! Amazing!
This is what we all wanted in the cinemas .
This makes me go yes.
When I watch this movie, I will pause before this moment and just play this.
I'm really taken back how much better of a ending this is.
Crying at how good this is. Petition for an official re-release!
No, forget about this movie!
petition to delete the secuels and do wut GL had write
They should add this and put it together with the rest of the film. Fans would have love it!
This is absolutely wonderful. I really feel goosebumps watching it. That's the perfect scene to end the story, all the Jedi giving the force!!
Up there with Luke returning in The Mandalorian.
Well done.
A marked return to the true Star Wars.
Holy editing! This was more believable, and theatrical. Just wow. I even have goosebumps now--👍😳
I found the original scene boring, but THIS... this gave me goosebumps. Thank u for creating this masterpiece. It would have been a proper ending for all us star wars fans😐❤️
thanks i love your comment thanks
Concordo plenamente
Im so thankful that there are Star Wars fans, that are literally correcting scenes from the sequels and stuff, and that we are actually getting to see this edits come to life
you made me cry, thank you, its being a long time since star wars made feel anything but hate for disney
This is amazing and it should have been the proper ending, Seeing Leia brought a tear to my eye
You are not me.
I can’t be the only one who literally watched this 40 times in a row.
You've actually got me in tears. Like floods of tears. You made this scene have so much more emotional impact, it hit in the same way that in Ghostbusters Afterlife seeing Egon's ghost with the lineup. Yes, they may be fan-service, but they are in the best way. They hit our nostalgia at a peak when so many things are changing with new characters in this trilogy, that is allow us closure and resolution to the years we've dedicated ourselves to this universe. It allows the franchise itself to say thank you to the characters on which it has been built, and allow us to join in unity as we close a very major and significant chapter of this universe. Additionally, not only did it hit all those emotional notes, it all served purpose for the plot. It simply made more sense that as powerful as Rey is, she is still a rookie and needed the support, and to show a physical, visual representation of the force flowing through her did so much justice to the scene. Just such an astounding job, and so glad I finally came across this.
I've seen this at least a dozen times and it is truly what we as Star Wars fans deserved. Tears lol.
Thank you for giving us what we wanted. Still have chills.
This version is so incredibly powerful and really elevates Rey's character. I remember going to see this to just sort of get it over with and it was an absolute slog. But I ended up getting full body goosebumps when Rey said, "And I'm all the Jedi". I was sure all of our beloved Jedi heroes were about to appear behind her. Instead she pulled out a second lightsaber. So, she had two of them. Ya know, instead of one. She had two.
What a waste.
Dude, en edit like this is destined for the Oscars, not joking, the time and the dedication you invested in this 🤟
I'm a 54 year old man and a Star Wars fan since I was 8. If this was the ending shown in theaters, I would have been in tears. The fallen Jedi standing with her, the characters we spent decades with, united as one. As well as the triumphant rendition of the Star Wars theme. It would have been the emotional payoff fans deserve.
This... This is almost exactly what I was looking for in the theater when watching this scene for the first time. Well done!
This is how it's done. This is how you pay tribute to something that came before while moving forward with something new in it. You honor what allowed to make what you did in the first place, not try to tear it down and make your version better for some "Culture of the time" message. This simple (not to downplay any effort that went into this) addition would have made ALL the difference for me personally. Shame the filmmakers didn't have that same mindset.
HELL YEAH!!! This is so much more believable and much more enjoyable! So excellent i got tears in my eyes!! Thankyou!
The Kung Fu Panda III vibes are strong with this one, and that's not a bad thing. At all. Amazing job.
this truly makes me want to cry, guys
now that would have been fantastic to see this version in the cinematic version. fantastic and creative work from the fans who made this possible.
Loong time fan here, I like this version the best (i've seen 5), it was a great touch and what really should have been in the movie, well done.
Thank you MSWGA for this masterpiece
Way above and beyond expectations. Thank you!
After watching this a year ago and almost forgetting the video to today watching the movie thinking I'm sure there were ment to be ghosts. The realising this is a fan edit. You sir did a better job then the movie. It works so well. Thankyou for enhancing the experience. Keep up the amazing work
This is incredible. It adds SO much to this scene!
All right folks this is the greatest fan edit we will ever see in any genre. Too late to explore the world too early to explore the stars but just in time to watch this masterpiece of an edit.
This adds weight emotion and compaction behind the work the fans commit to creating.
Saved in favorites and hopefully never taken down, by far the best edit! And this is how it should have been
Wow ... what an impactful and touching improvement on this scene ... very moving and powerful ... love it !!!
this needs to be added in on Disney+ att the least. makes the scene SIGNIFICANTLY better
Disappointing that fans did better than Disney them selves
Why didn’t the directors hire this TH-camr for this amazing ending… 👍🏼
I think that even George Lucas needs to see this.
Omfg that was awesome...that resonated soooo much...when Yoda lifted his hand at the end off "and i'm all the Jedi" i gasped out loud. It all felt natural. Well done to whoever created this.
Goosebumps everywhere.
This is how it should be , o nearly cried so good was this 👌 👏 😄
I liked this 10x wayyyy better then the original scene from Star Wars Rise of the Skywalker's cause I am a Star Wars fan since when it all started back in the 80s what a good way to have put it this all the Jedi's Masters Jedi's together as One.
Just now saw this. Brought on goosebumps. Very nice
Whoa! 😳😢🫡 that was awesome!
OMG. The Force Gost,The Music. Brought Tears to my eyes. Thank you.
This had me crying like SW Theory when he saw Qui-gon in the Kenobi finale
Fantastic edit! This is your best version of the scene. definitely worthy of any future re-edits of the movie. Fan justice for sure!!
Now if this was in the movie (the Force Ghosts), it would have been worth watching. It’s why I clicked on this vid. I wanted to see who you’d include as a Force Ghost. And that shit was EXCITING!!!! I’ve never seen the disney ABOMINATIONS, never will, but this has MY SW faves in it!!! To see them all side by side, using their powers against Palps, SOOOOO DAMN COOL!!!!!! Gave me chills seeing Ahsoka and Anakin fighting together again, to see Mace and Yoda giving off major Force attitude, Obi-Wan there between father and son, our beloved Princess Leia, and Qui-Gon 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜. Absolute joy!!!
Im not a Star Wars fan, but this almost makes me cry. Amazing work! 😊👍❤
That's beast. That would have made me so happy and made me cry
WOW.. I really really like this! Disney should absolutely let the fans make the movies
I would have been on my feet in the theatre had this been the ending. Just epic. The score is phenomenal!
OMFG!!!!!! I actually got goosebumps from head to toe!!!! 👏 👏
Beautifully done. 😢
This was PHENOMENAL!!!!!!! ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
That was so bad ass man all the Jedi from like the 2000s and the ones from the 80s so cool man
I keep watching this, and it never ceases to amaze me.
I like that Palpatine’s death scream is so beastly
I agree
Best one I've seen mate. Well done.
Now that’s an ending I would have been absolutely been in awe off…wow great job
this is a million times better for outcome. fancy seeing this at the cinemas, youd have tingles.
This ending would have rocked.
I also wish in The Last Jedi when they had Luke talking to the Force Ghost Yoda that they also included a Force Ghost Obi-wan and Anakin sitting around the fire advising Luke. Maybe even add Qui-Gon but the other two were necessary and would really have been a great scene.
Epic
@@d1malcriao Yeah I think it would have been.
rhoonah
Ashoka Tano left out
@@zsoltkiss545 Until The Mandalorian we didn't know that Ahsoka had any interaction with Luke and the average fan didn't even know who she was or even what became of her. Luke had frequent interactions with a force ghost Obi Wan in the Empire and RoTJ so it doesn't make sense that he isn't here. He then saw a force ghost Anakin at the end of RoTJ so that would fit. I added Qui-Gon purely because Yoda said that he was the one that discovered the ability to return. We don't know if Ahsoka ever learned the power either.
@@rhoonah5849 There's a good chance that Luke taught this power to Ahsoka, though it's also possible that Obi-Wan or even Anakin taught her.
THIS IS AMAZING!!!
I've watched this so many times. It's so amazing.
The music made the scene, for sure.
Finally a ending star wars fans can be proud of bravo well done this is the end of Darth disney strong in the dark side but fans are stronger with the force and we are meny
Hats off to you my man. This is actually amazing.
This was one of my favorite scenes
Actually got me choked up watching that!
Wow, just wow. Perfection. This is what should have been.
Espectacular !!!
👏👏👏👏
Asi debio terminar
Thank you so much. This is amazing. Absolutely perfect.
awesome edit .... gives deep meaning to the "I am all the jedi"
Whoever made this video,deserves to be working at Walt Disney!!! I mean quite frankly,raw talent is hard to come by especially when it's this good!!!👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿 Please keep up the good work,because I'd like to see more videos like this!!!✌🏿✌🏿✌🏿✌🏿✌🏿 On tha real!!!
That would’ve made the scene truly epic! On the other hand, I hear, “I am all the Sith,” and “And I am all the Jedi!” I couldn’t help but say, “And I….am…..Iron Man!” 😂
Holy crap that was freaking amazing.
And here I am crying to an amazing fan edit. Bravo