Your idea could have mitigated the Mary Sue aspect of Rey throughout the sequels. If Force Ghost Anakin bonded with Rey in The Force Awakens, it could have explained her Force powers and even knack with technology.
It goes to show that people do care for the Sequel characters, but the way they were used was terrible. Rey actually has a lot of potential to be one of the best Star Wars characters but they didn’t utilise her in the right way and they barely explored her weaknesses, not to mention her stories ending in TROS was really badly done.
@@djmace9029 facts, the sequels had so much potential to be better, heck the story from 7-8 could have somewhat worked, with changes and improvements, but instead they just made the sequels an unoriginal copy of the first trilogy
@@neo-fx8qd Indeed, which is why they failed. Had they created a whole new story instead of just carbon-copying the original movies, they might've been good. Disney needs better writers.
"This is the end for you my Master." Shifting that line to target Sidious was brilliant. Just desserts for messing with his head throughout his entire life.
For the love of God...would Disney hire this guy. He single handedly just kicked your ass...what an epic ending that would have been. That was F'ing amazing.
He wouldnt have been allowed to make this if he worked for Disney or Lucasfilm. Thats the problem, the execs want everything to their narrative and not the talent of their own writers
Totally agree, this is the ending we deserved instead of the lazy force voices we got with some having no actually influence on the story, I mean yeah Ahsoka being in there was cool but only cos she was directly linked Anakin and so Obi-wan through the clone wars so it made sense for hers to be there, if she were dead or just connecting through the force wherever she was at the time
This scene in this way and Kylo Ren alive to continue the Skywalker legacy after the last sacrifice of Rey dying, would have saved the errors in this Disney trilogy.
This is damn near exactly what I was expecting when I was watching this movie in the theater. When she started to hear the voices, I fully expected all the force ghosts to line up behind her. JJ really missed it by not going this way.
@@bozotheclown169 I don’t think JJ knew nearly as much about Star Wars as he claims and he definitely didn’t know what he was doing. From what I can tell he just wanted to get it over with, otherwise I’m sure this is the ending we would have gotten.
@@djmace9029 possibly but really it was the writing in general that needed improvement since episode 8, 7 was actually a decent start to the trilogy, but aside from ruined plot, lame choreography (by lame I mean not as good as prequels or clone wars, heck episodes 4-6 seemed better imo)
@@neo-fx8qd I thought The Force Awakens was a decent start. Sure it was basically a clone of A New Hope but I kinda wanted that same feeling I had when I was ten and in the theater seeing Star Wars for the first time in 1977. The biggest mistake was totally downplaying Luke Skywalker in what was suppose to be the wrap up of the Skywalker saga. The three should have been the final adventures of Luke, Han and Leia with the help of the new characters. Then move on to a new trilogy with just the new characters. Instead, Kathleen Kennedy went and got her fingers into it and screwed it all up.
Maul wouldn’t of he hates the sith and came to terms with what he did and found the balance by forgiven obi wan and his last words were he will avenge us talking about Luke
3 minutes. That's all it took. 200 seconds of fanfiction and star wars was star wars again. With tears in my eyes and Chi's down my spine I applaud you good sir. Thank you for what you've created
Nah, they need to adapt the Legends as official canon. Episode 7 just resets everything to a pre episode 4 position. Episodes 4 through 6 are now rendered meaning less thanks to the new trilogy. Nothing is accomplished 4 through 6. The sage can now actually be as follows... episode 1,2,3,7,8,9 without issue. The final part of episode 6 (luke and Anakin face Palp and anakin dying) can be explained in word crawl at the start of episode 7.
The director you're speaking of, who only did the 1st and 3rd, is none other than Jar Jar Abrams (who NEVER should've been allowed to direct ANYTHING Star Wars, including his own childhood playtime with whatever figures mommy and daddy bought for him).
@@WaterboyPhx Ryan Johnson should have also never been allowed to make a star wars movie because he didnt write TLJ as a trilogy movie. He wrote it as a stand alone movie. He is also so obsessed with "subverting expectations" that he undermine everything in episode 7 and left nothing to build upon for episode 9. He also abandoned everyones story arcs and character developments (like Luke). There was no reason for Luke to die and it was completely unemotional and out of place. The saga was always Luke's and Leia's (and Anakins), They should have never been background characters for the final trilogy.
My kids and I always pause the movie right when Palpatine starts his lightning attack in the air so we can switch over TH-cam to watch this version as part of the movie. Such a better experience, even with the interruption of switching from Disney+ to TH-cam and back again
THIS...is the ending we needed and DESERVED. Thank you so much for putting this together- it's beautiful and simply staggering in the way it concludes the entire saga in a more sensical, respectful, and faithful manner. May the Force be with you, always!
Dear God, I’m not one to get emotional about fan edits, but this would have saved the entire movie. I’m not even kidding. This was the ending that brought the entire franchise together and that I needed to see for closure. Thank you so, SO much for whatever you did to create this version. Wow.
Yeah Rey channeling the chosen ones force ghost with the other Jedi who kept their consciousness adding back up makes more sense then just hearing random voices of Jedi who didn’t learn to be force ghosts. Especially seeing Anakins face on her and his voice coming through.
The original trilogy was remastered/re edited/redone. I didn't think the original needed it, but the prequel and sequel trilogies definitively need a re edits and retouched. I cringe at lines like "I wish I could wish away these feelings" and the gungans need to use their environment as a weapon in their battle, doubt the Droids could function well in swamp terrain.
Honestly my biggest peeve with the sequels was how they completely disregarded how Anakin was the Chosen One and just shoved Rey into his role. The original ending of TROS completely destroyed the meaning behind Vader’s sacrifice. Thanks for keeping Anakin’s legacy alive!
i agree with this 100%. But I think they made Luke garbage by making him some old man who didn't want to be found again and just simply gave up on his life.
Eh I disagree. Anakins mission failed in a way either way as Palpatine came back in legends too. But Anakin did restore balance to the force and defeat the Sith when they became the most powerful. The Sith can never truly be destroyed I think. Darth Plagieus said to Palpatine once that if the Jedi found him he'd be another Exar Kun.
Qui-Gon: Gives encouraging words Obi-Wan: Support's her Force connection Luke & Leila: Reminds her that the Force is always with her Anakin: Passing his lightsaber using the Force Windu: Strengthening her grip Ahsoka: Silently holding her And Yoda: Get the job done with a single blast using the Force (just like he did during his last confrontation with Darth Sidious)
Yep same, but Qui-gon being able to show himself as a force ghost is still debated. I guess it would make sense that there'd be a force nexus on Exegol (like that time in Clone wars he appeared) Regardless loved this edit!
Its truly astounding that Disney couldnt figure this out. Even now, how hard would it be to edit something like this in to a special edition on disney plus??
@@jc135276 this is actually the correct answer. The victory in this movie was Rey's. Having all the other Jedi show up for it would have robbed her of this victory and people would forever go on and say how she didn't earn her achievements herself. Fans might not be pleased, but the canon version is completely in line with the narrative they had in mind for Rey. She's the protagonist of the ST. She's the hero. She defeats Palpatine herself.
Exactly. It's sad that their main goal and concern is how much money they can make rather than how much they could please the fans and honor this epic story. You would think they would be bright enough to know if they pleased fans they would just naturally score big bucks, but we dont live in sensible times anymore
loved how Anakin merged with Rey also Love how Luke's ghost calls out to his apprentice knowing something bad is about to happen to her, love that detail of how all the Jedi come to Rey's support and that Luke as a ghost even at the last moments of his life really comes to feel for her
@@magnificentgdc you know I always get confused & completely bewildered why Disney always gets a mention as you too had a say. IT IS JJ ABRAMS that directed rise of Skywalker so the buck stops with him.
True, sad what the damn writers did to Rey, she really would've felt like a true Skywalker. I think the sequels must be altered and modified by people who actually know SW.
@@benjaminvillegas6743 Not Skywalker, she's not at all familiar with the Skywalker family. Ahsoka and Rex have more reasons to be Skywalker than Rey. But this altered scene did make her worthy to be alive and continue Jedi line.
Meh? It's still an atrocious ending, with glaring plotholes, cringey dialogue, and even just the fact that Rey and Sidious(at least, the resurrection of Sidious) are characters in this movie AT ALL! Mara Jade > Rey. I'm sorry but Mara Jade is just so much cooler than Rey, and I still feel robbed, cheated, and abused for her getting deleted by disney. I mean they deleted so much content far better than what they replaced it with - Yuuzhan Vong war, actually good mandalorian lore, the Legacy of the Force storyline, obvs Mara Jade, and Luke actually having, you know, an actual life?
If they did this exact thing but with Ben Solo instead of Rey, it would’ve literally been a flawless masterpiece of a scene. The Last Skywalker standing up to face Palpatine with the voices of all the Jedi telling him to *“rise”* would have been amazing, such a missed opportunity. They had him there and literally tossed him away just to give Rey his moment.
@@jerodjordan9570 You wouldn’t be able to spot a good character if you had your eyes glued to a screen for a hundred years…if Kylo was a trash character it wouldn’t be a universal opinion across the entire fan base, from the people who hate the sequels to the people who love them that Kylo Ren was *the* best character to come out of those movies…the only character in the sequels that felt like someone George himself would have created… Star Wars Theory for example, hates the sequels and doesn’t even consider them canon but in a recent stream he literally said word for word *”Kylo Ren is one of my favourite characters across all of Star Wars not just the movies…all of Star Wars…comics, legends, canon, games all of Star Wars, he’s in my top 5”* - and he hates the sequel trilogy with a passion…you know why he said that because he recognises that Kylo Ren is a great character, played by an actor that Martin Scorsese himself is on record praising as one of the greatest actors of his generation - Adam Driver. I’m sorry but it’s just a fact, I don’t like the sequels as whole but I’m not going to sit here and pretend Kylo Ren as a character isn’t top tier Star Wars…I mean have you seen some of the edits on TH-cam on Kylo, they’re jaw dropping.
@@Ivbo lol what’s universal lol NO ONE THINKS HES A TOP CHARACTER THE ONLY THING PEOPLE WANTED TO SEE WITG HIM WAS HIM GETTING DESTROYED BY LUKE WHICH DIDNT HAPPEN
@@jerodjordan9570 Think I just lost a few brain cells reading that…you probably only read like 8 words of my original reply, read the rest of it then go get yourself a block of chocolate, sit down and repeat to yourself *“I’m a bit brain stiff but that’s okay”* should make you feel a bit better.
They should have made Rey kill palpatine with all her hate and turn to the dark side, then make Ben destroy Palpatine's spirit or something with the help of the ghosts, so at the end both Rey and Ben would have been alive and everyone would have been happy.
I love the expressions of Palpatine when the lightning flickers and he sees the ghosts. He's so absurdly irritated and beyond pissed that after 40 years of his plans and deceit, the Jedi STILL stand in his way.
Looking at Qui-Gon taking a stand against Sidious is so poetic. That's the very definition of "If you strike me down, I shall become more powerful than you can possibly imagine".
@@SirBigHead Of what i understand you had to strike him down with anger or hatred for it. That is why Anakin/Vader didn't get possessed when he threw him down the shaft. :)
OMG. Such a tear jerker for all Star Wars fans. This is now Canon.This is insanely incredible with the main jedi throughout the saga helping Rey. I mean no words how blown away i am right now by this EPIC three minutes
Omg, omg, omg!! This was SO powerful I've still got chills and my eyes are watering. I can't believe how just with some simple editing (like the beats of Rey rising to her feet), it makes the entire scene so much more beautiful and dramatic. I absolutely love that you can hear all the former Jedi voices now with such clarity and then you actually see them all! And I just noticed that what she did initially was look "past" all the darkness and evil and destruction symbolized by the Force lightning coming from Sidious, past it all into space to find that place of quiet and stillness where she could connect with all the fallen Jedi in the spiritual realm. What an incredible way to end it all and you can actually see how Anakin possessed her body in that final moment before she destroys Sidious. Absolutely brilliant!
“Alone, never have you been” sounded strange but everything else was great! I’m a huge fan of Anakin, Vader and the Emperor. So I felt you certainly did them justice by literally having Anakin defeat Palpatine. It looks so much better than just Rey.
@@davidbarker2507 you do have a point but since he is the emperor and is very strong surviving somehow and hiding on a sith world is really not that hard to believe 😅😆😛
I agree. Palpy did die in ROTJ, but I loved the idea of Dark Side-infused bio-engineering bringing him back for the sequels. To me, it just made more storytelling sense to have him as the antagonist. I actually felt the return of Sidious was one of the better writing choices for the sequel films. Of course, the canon novelization then had to go and say he's just a "clone", which is a pretty bland and dumb explanation for his return if you ask me. A Dark Side resurrection would have been much cooler.
@@stevennocella5805 He can have survived again. Thats another stupidity of the ST. No mention as why he couldn't repeat his trick from ROTJ. Poe and Finn tease it even in the Novel.
Episode 9 is in desperate need for an extended cut, directors cut or some alternate cut of the movie because what’s there can definitely be turned into something great, just look at this video…and apparently there are loads of deleted scenes that could be finished and added, a great ending to the saga already exists at Lucasfilm it just needs to be finished released…
Rumor is the ghosts WERE supposed to appear, but Disney was more worried about offending the Chinese market. Apparently simply sending them the version without the ghosts while keeping it in for everyone else wasn't an option. And after Lando arrived with the armada, I was expecting the mother of all space battles, and all we got were two quick battle scenes. There had to have been more than what was filmed. And relegating Wedge to a 2-second cameo, then completely forgetting about him at the end (even though he was IN the Falcon!) - they should have had him fly in as Red Leader, leading the remaining members of Rogue Squadron into battle right behind Lando. THAT would have been much more epic!
I think they should release an extended or special edition cut of the Sequels like how Lord of the Rings did. At least an extended cut for the Rise of Skywalker as the film has potential but had an extremely dissatisfactory ending. Had this been the way Palpatine was killed I would have been a lot happier with the film and the trilogy as a whole.
Best end EVER! Even paused the original 9th movie, showed this clip, (fast forward:ed the original movie) and then kept on going with the rest of the movie until the end. Wathed all 9 movies with my 5 year old daughter. She LOVES Star Wars! As I did, her age.. LOL
This is a gem! Father and son standing side by side, Anakin's pass to Rey, Obi Wan's call to Anakin, Luke crying out to Rey... Didn't know we needed this.
Exactly!!! This is literally the first thing I said they should have done and set it up perfectly with the lightning strikes. How did the brilliant minds at Disney miss this opportunity. So glad I wasn’t the only one who imagined this.
May the force be with you. Damn I was about to cry over this beautiful masterpiece as I remembered all the movies in the past. This is so much beautiful. So much overwhelming. Thank you for doing this. Thank you...
What this shows beyond any reasonable doubt, is how much better the film would have been if Abrams/Lucasfilm/Disney had actually done this. These fan edits are straight up proof.
Yeah absolutely I carnt understand why he didn't Seeing the force ghosts would have been so much better than hearing them. Also loved the force push from yoda as they produced the second lightsaber
There was probably thing ABRAMS could have done at the end. He could have reversed the the roles. Kylo ren/Skywalker could have been the one rising & the one to defeat the emperor. It would have made more sense that way.
@@karlfranzemperorofmandefil5547 Is this really true. Never heard about this factoid. It's a shame though, movie writing shouldn't cater to customs of individual countries.
Wow!! I am blown away! Seriously THIS should have been the original ending! This was perfect... thank you for posting. Please take your talents and imagination to the top.
This was a no brainer. There must have been a reason why this didn't take place. Hearing their voices was NOT effective enough. Did they not want to copy Endgame's finale by having all the heroes return? I actually feel bad for Abrams if they handcuffed his original ending ideas. The movie needed to be a 2 parter imho. The beloved Cariie Fisher's passing did not help things
They didn't use Colin Trevorrow's script because Carrie Fisher died. They didn't use ghosts in Jeffrey Jacob Abrams's script because of China market rules.
i guess they figured just voices would harken back to the original 77 films ending. plus maybe too 'Endgame'... but theres no denying something like this wouldve been far superior (besides theyd already gone full fan service with all kinds of stuff: the emperor, the death star 2 ruins, the han cameo, so might as well have included the force ghosts too)
Idk why they didn’t do this type of ending instead… if it’s because they didn’t want to “copy” the Avengers nobody would really complain as they’re both under Disney…
Positivity? What if you could bring the Jedi to YOUR world? This world? Possibly through Disney, for example? You see, you "fans" just don't think BIG enough.
Friggin Beautifil...When Obi Wan says "Anakin", for the sake of all the Obi-Ani Clone Wars moments, it would have been great if it would've Ewan saying "anakin now" But, still it is beautiful
I wrote a fanfic of the 3rd film for myself before the movie came out since TLJ sucked. Rey wins at the end by fighting the bad guy with the help of force ghosts. Yoda gives her wisdom telling her what to focus on, Anakin gives her real time battle advice, Obi-wan tells her to trust in herself and Luke...Luke gives her hope when she thinks she's been beaten. It's an obvious climatic choice for a universe where force-ghosts exist and you want to wrap up a 9 series saga. It's a visual and impactful way to link every story. It's cool. They didn't do it. Likely because someone didn't want Rey to have help. So instead we got Rey beating Palps with the unmatched power of not one, but TWO lightsabers....what a genius idea...pure narrative perfection. Amazing.
What YOU want, I was perfectly fine with Solo and Roque One, S7 of TCW was mostly perfect, The Bad Batch so far is all right, the sequels definenetly aren't my favourites but they also had their moments. So, yeah there are Problems with Disney Star Wars, but there have been Problems before them
@@Lekawie oh yeah and I agree, the phantom menace wasn’t the greatest either, everyone has their taste. But I was just stating that Disney only focuses for the money not for the audience. As a Film Maker myself I know that if you deliver what the audience would want to see, the film would work.
I'll never understand why Disney didn't put that effort into the actual trilogy, what a HUGE difference it would have made to the reception of it, dank farrik!!
The reimagined end could be better if: - Pryde wasn't dumb as he orders the Steadfast to flip 90 degrees to knock the Resistance space horses out of the ship, leaving no explosives placed - Palpatine's godlike force lightning nearly wipes out all the Resistance fleet but the Millennium Falcon, Poe's X-Wing and the Corellian Corvette, turning the tide against the Resistance - Finn turns the First Order's Stormtroopers against the Final Order - Lando lightspeeds the Falcon against the Steadfast in desperation to stop the Star Destroyers from leaving Exegol - (Bonus) A definitive end to BB-9E
A scene like this would've single-handedly saved the entire movie. How can Marvel Studios be so good under Disney while Lucasfilm are so crap? Ah yeah, Kevin Feige. Lucasfilm need someone like him. If Kathleen Turner had been in charge of Endgame, all the revived Avengers would've cheered on the ones who faced Thanos via phone call, ffs.
The best Star Wars I’ve seen since Disney took over. The way all the Jedi help Rey. When Anakin says bring back the balance. His force ghost goes inside Rey to destroy The Emperor. Well done
Hello, I'm a 16-year-old Star Wars fan living in Korea! Born in 2009, the ending of Star Wars episode 9 'Rise of Sky Walker' was really shocking. But here's the ending I wanted!! Thank you for making such a wonderful edit!! The combination of music is really good Especially from 1:34 I was really cool and overwhelmed!! I was surprised to see how the Jedi's desperation and sacrifice to get rid of the cis from that part went by so well with music!! I enjoyed the video. Thank you again!!😢👍👍😭🫡
@nathanimator That's not a bad idea honestly cause I enjoyed this trilogy. Sure it has its flaws but I thought 7 was a good movie I just don't like what 8 did to the original characters but atleast it was fixed here.
I didn’t care for Rey or the sequel trilogy at all, but the way you had the Rise of Skywalker trailer music play as Rey started to rise made me sob. You fit it in perfectly it seemed so real. Well done.
There’s another alternate ending where Anakin takes control (in a good way) of Rey. After the emperor says, “I AM ALL THE SITH”, Anakin says, “And I’m the chosen one.”
Imagine if disney did this, they would be able to brush off all the mary sue stuff cause theyd be able to say that the jedi were helping here every step of the way, explaining why everything came so easy with 0 training. Bit like the avatar state in atlab or lok
No words. Except....can you imagine the fan reactions to a scene like this in theaters and around the world?? Would have been epic and 100% fitting for the new characters and our beloved OT characters.
A very powerful scene. I'm extremely glad that there are fans who can make a masterpiece ending. I am endlessly disappointed that the people working at Disney are mediocrities who receive millions in fees, but are no match for the fans...
I just caught this now and I have one this to say.... HOLY SH-T!! THIS JUST GAVE ME CHILLS WHILE WATCHING NOW! This is how it SHOULD have been done!! ABSOLUTELY AMAZING! Isn't it sad that fans can do better than KK can and she's the one making millions while (sadly) just being signed on for ANOTHER 3 YEARS !?!!
Yeah, it's fascinating to me. From the different master-student relationships we got (Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan; Obi-Wan and Anakin, Obi-Wan and Luke, Yoda and Luke, Luke and Rey) the one between Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan was probably the best developed one with the least amount of screen time.
Well, she had a relationship with both Skywalker siblings - Luke and Leia. She did that to honor their masters. One was hard on her and the other was softer but both guided her. The Anakin's lightsaber was the one who called her out to take the hero Journey when she picked it up and all those visions.
@@AB-sg7pl I disagree. Luke wasn’t being tough on her he just didn’t want her to be around and all Rey and Luke ever did was fight. As for Leia, Rey and Leia were friends for a few months and Leia never really called herself a Skywalker. She was always either an Organa or a Solo. Plus, Leia was the one who told Rey that ancestry doesn’t define you and not to run away from it which is exactly what Rey proceeds to do. If Leia was such a great mentor to Rey then Rey would’ve accepted the Palpatine name or at least use Solo since she had a relationship with both Han and Leia. Now that I think about it Han was more of a father figure than Luke ever was.
It only made sense for her to use the name Solo if she wanted to adopt the last name of the man who saved her and shared a very strong bond with her, similar to what Rose Dawson did in the movie Titanic. I would definitely go for the option of her adopting Ben's last name, but it would generate a lot of controversy in a relationship already full of controversy. The kiss they gave at the end of the film was already stretching boundaries for many people A mentor doesn't have to be the typical teacher who follows traditional teaching. Luke mentored Rey and even gave Rey a formal lesson and a mission that was later introduced in the extra scenes. Anyone is our mentor if they test our resilience and trigger the wisdom within us. Despite Luke's harshness, he was the one who inspired Rey on her path. Leia was actually of the Skywalker lineage despite having always used the name of her adoptive parents and would not recant the name given to her just because she found out that her real father was Anakin Skywalker. Rey adopted the name Skywalker as a tribute to her two mentors just after they passed away. Obviously, she wasn't going to use the name Palpatine, as probably neither her father nor her mother used that name since what they most wanted was distance from the Emperor.
I salute you, because for your love to the seventh art and Star Wars. Suddenly, this adding images and music makes perfect sense to the entire saga. Thanks for this loving work. I mean it. Greetings from Argentina.
Anakin saying "This is the end for you my master" in this context gave me such chills, this is incredible. George Lucas should have let you direct the sequels instead of Disney.
Man especially where they did recycle so many lines and themes from previous movies. That would've been great foreshadowing to switch the context of the Anakin line too and truly make it his rise. Like yeah, he was redeemed in ROTJ, but this would've been so impactful
This.... I got literal chills! How did i not see this until now?? amazing amazing work! Especially with the compositing! I would love to see how you would implement the later part of the scene with Ben and the force ghosts. I'm not a Reylo fan, but I would love to see if you could incorporate Anakin/other Jedi helping Ben heal Rey. Lastly, I realize that including Ahsoka into this scene would probably have been impossible because of the lack of live-action footage currently, but if you would ever do this again and include Ahsoka - that would be amazing. I'm convinced that the force would have allowed her to train to preserve her consciousness after death, especially because of the daughter's life force in her. And giving a chance for Ahsoka, Anakin and Obi-Wan to get another chance at Sidious! Something to consider, but again amazing amazing work. Thank you for giving us such a beautiful piece of content to watch over and over again.
This is almost perfect! I would not have had the past characters do another but be shadows but LOVED the music and LOVED that you could hear the Masters talk!
Only just saw this, absolutely brilliant. If this had been the ending we were given the film would have been considered a classic instead of a failure. Superb. Well done!
Oh where has this been? That was so good it's going on the big screen when I get home. Agreed that's my new ending that brings everything and everyone together. I'm going to watch it again. Very very well done, BRAVO!
![Rey Vs Palpatine [Extended Edition]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/FHr9QI__I60/mqdefault.jpg)
![Rey Vs Palpatine [Extended Edition]](/img/tr.png)
![Rey Skywalker • "Some things are stronger than blood." [Star Wars]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/DHT7swH7-wI/mqdefault.jpg)
Force Ghost: Rey the Force is with you. We are with you
Ghost of Mace Windu: But we do not grant you the rank of master
Underrated comment
You got that right bud hahahaha best comment I’ve seen in a while
THATS UNFAIR.
Citizen
Lol
“This is the end for you, my master”
Such fitting dialogue
Shiiiiiiit. That line made it for me.
I didn't realize that they changed her face to Anakin's when he says that...
@@tonycosta8601 almost as if Rey and Anakin are both ending him. Anakin definitely deserved the satisfaction of killing Palpatine twice
@@iamironman3388 It reminds me of what they did with Man of Steel and Chris Reeves face over Henry Cavill. Very well done.
That would have been a better ending, no offense but still not a fan of the last trilogy. Yet, this would have made more sense.
Palpating: *literally dying*
Count Duku ghost: “ should we help him? “
Darth Maul ghost: “ nah “
Plagueis: lmao karma
Grievous: do it
@@mothmanofaustraliaradio8888 darth pluagus ghost: you ain’t even force sensitive
the real karma is them not having force ghosts because dark side sucks
That's not how the Force works! (LOL)
Having Anakin bond with Ray through the force to help fulfill his prophecy as The Chosen One was well done.
Return of the jedi is the end of it
Your idea could have mitigated the Mary Sue aspect of Rey throughout the sequels. If Force Ghost Anakin bonded with Rey in The Force Awakens, it could have explained her Force powers and even knack with technology.
What explains Anakin's Force powers? Or yoda's?
Ray😂garbagewalkeR
His prophecy was finished in episode 6. Presumably, this is a new balancing of the force.
This bit of footage triggers 1000x more emotion in me than the entire rest of the sequel trilogy.
It goes to show that people do care for the Sequel characters, but the way they were used was terrible. Rey actually has a lot of potential to be one of the best Star Wars characters but they didn’t utilise her in the right way and they barely explored her weaknesses, not to mention her stories ending in TROS was really badly done.
Well said...
Absolutely
@@djmace9029 facts, the sequels had so much potential to be better, heck the story from 7-8 could have somewhat worked, with changes and improvements, but instead they just made the sequels an unoriginal copy of the first trilogy
@@neo-fx8qd Indeed, which is why they failed. Had they created a whole new story instead of just carbon-copying the original movies, they might've been good. Disney needs better writers.
'This is the end for you my master'
Chills. Fucking chills.
Best part of the whole edit. No question.
I suggested this line on Reddit and was told it was cringe 😂 but it fits SO WELL
@Logan Im "probably just saying it because they’re trying to be an asshole for no reason" - the definition of 50%+ of people on Reddit.
@@SuperInfinitezero00 The fact that he combined Rey's looks with Anakin's is cringe, though. Not the line itself.
"This is the end for you my Master." Shifting that line to target Sidious was brilliant. Just desserts for messing with his head throughout his entire life.
Yep. Rey should have said "but WE are the jedi"
That moment when Obi Wan says “Anakin” and then Anakin bonds with Rey….. chills
Especially when he says "Bring back balance to the Force"... poetic justice... just WOW!!!
It really gave me chills too
Perfect Ending
Literally what I imagined and wanted to happen
@@shastasilverchairsg Yes I love that
For the love of God...would Disney hire this guy. He single handedly just kicked your ass...what an epic ending that would have been. That was F'ing amazing.
He wouldnt have been allowed to make this if he worked for Disney or Lucasfilm. Thats the problem, the execs want everything to their narrative and not the talent of their own writers
Totally agree, this is the ending we deserved instead of the lazy force voices we got with some having no actually influence on the story, I mean yeah Ahsoka being in there was cool but only cos she was directly linked Anakin and so Obi-wan through the clone wars so it made sense for hers to be there, if she were dead or just connecting through the force wherever she was at the time
This scene in this way and Kylo Ren alive to continue the Skywalker legacy after the last sacrifice of Rey dying, would have saved the errors in this Disney trilogy.
@@omarperez2757 Disney and they’re narrow minded writers and producers that only care about the politics and money
Damn straight!!
This is damn near exactly what I was expecting when I was watching this movie in the theater. When she started to hear the voices, I fully expected all the force ghosts to line up behind her.
JJ really missed it by not going this way.
JJ must've been too busy to think straight
@@bozotheclown169 I don’t think JJ knew nearly as much about Star Wars as he claims and he definitely didn’t know what he was doing. From what I can tell he just wanted to get it over with, otherwise I’m sure this is the ending we would have gotten.
@@djmace9029 possibly but really it was the writing in general that needed improvement since episode 8, 7 was actually a decent start to the trilogy, but aside from ruined plot, lame choreography (by lame I mean not as good as prequels or clone wars, heck episodes 4-6 seemed better imo)
It wouldn't have lived up to their "woke" agenda. Too much toxic masculinity or some BS... had to be a girl single highhandedly
@@neo-fx8qd I thought The Force Awakens was a decent start. Sure it was basically a clone of A New Hope but I kinda wanted that same feeling I had when I was ten and in the theater seeing Star Wars for the first time in 1977. The biggest mistake was totally downplaying Luke Skywalker in what was suppose to be the wrap up of the Skywalker saga. The three should have been the final adventures of Luke, Han and Leia with the help of the new characters. Then move on to a new trilogy with just the new characters. Instead, Kathleen Kennedy went and got her fingers into it and screwed it all up.
Palpatine:...Lord Vader?
Anakin: THAT NAME...no longer has any meaning to me!
That would have been legit!!!!
Clever
Maul wouldn’t of he hates the sith and came to terms with what he did and found the balance by forgiven obi wan and his last words were he will avenge us talking about Luke
Anakin: “…it is the Chosen One’s duty…to destroy the Sith!”
That line would've saved the Franchise!
3 minutes. That's all it took. 200 seconds of fanfiction and star wars was star wars again.
With tears in my eyes and Chi's down my spine I applaud you good sir. Thank you for what you've created
This is now my head canon. Disney, hire this guy: he’s 10 times the visionary than the director this trilogy.
Nah, they need to adapt the Legends as official canon. Episode 7 just resets everything to a pre episode 4 position. Episodes 4 through 6 are now rendered meaning less thanks to the new trilogy. Nothing is accomplished 4 through 6. The sage can now actually be as follows... episode 1,2,3,7,8,9 without issue. The final part of episode 6 (luke and Anakin face Palp and anakin dying) can be explained in word crawl at the start of episode 7.
@@kevinshirley9344 This right here
not disney, we need dave filoni.
The director you're speaking of, who only did the 1st and 3rd, is none other than Jar Jar Abrams (who NEVER should've been allowed to direct ANYTHING Star Wars, including his own childhood playtime with whatever figures mommy and daddy bought for him).
@@WaterboyPhx Ryan Johnson should have also never been allowed to make a star wars movie because he didnt write TLJ as a trilogy movie. He wrote it as a stand alone movie. He is also so obsessed with "subverting expectations" that he undermine everything in episode 7 and left nothing to build upon for episode 9. He also abandoned everyones story arcs and character developments (like Luke). There was no reason for Luke to die and it was completely unemotional and out of place. The saga was always Luke's and Leia's (and Anakins), They should have never been background characters for the final trilogy.
My kids and I always pause the movie right when Palpatine starts his lightning attack in the air so we can switch over TH-cam to watch this version as part of the movie. Such a better experience, even with the interruption of switching from Disney+ to TH-cam and back again
THIS...is the ending we needed and DESERVED. Thank you so much for putting this together- it's beautiful and simply staggering in the way it concludes the entire saga in a more sensical, respectful, and faithful manner. May the Force be with you, always!
Agreed
The key was having Anakin deliver the final line "This is the end for you, my master". I also enjoyed your reaction to the finale of Mando Season 2.
@@jamesbellefeuille2926 Thank you so much!
Holy crap I got insane goosebumps when all the Jedi put their hands up to help Rey. I honestly would have preferred this ending.
Me too without a doubt this should have been in the movie & then there was the push from yoda.
Me too!!!!!
Would definitely seem more realistic
Would have definitely put a maraschino cherry on top of a plate of dogshit
Agree, This was better, with the forse ghost and the music.
Dear God, I’m not one to get emotional about fan edits, but this would have saved the entire movie. I’m not even kidding. This was the ending that brought the entire franchise together and that I needed to see for closure. Thank you so, SO much for whatever you did to create this version. Wow.
My sentiments exactly!
Yeah Rey channeling the chosen ones force ghost with the other Jedi who kept their consciousness adding back up makes more sense then just hearing random voices of Jedi who didn’t learn to be force ghosts. Especially seeing Anakins face on her and his voice coming through.
@@joshkrause2977 And Anakin gets to fulfill the prophecy bringing balance to the force at last!
Damn i have the same thought...
Totally agree, that's EXACTLY what I thought!👍😁
This just shows why this film is in desperate need of an ‘alternate cut’ or at least just give us all the deleted footage already.
Alternate tri
The original trilogy was remastered/re edited/redone. I didn't think the original needed it, but the prequel and sequel trilogies definitively need a re edits and retouched. I cringe at lines like "I wish I could wish away these feelings" and the gungans need to use their environment as a weapon in their battle, doubt the Droids could function well in swamp terrain.
Honestly my biggest peeve with the sequels was how they completely disregarded how Anakin was the Chosen One and just shoved Rey into his role. The original ending of TROS completely destroyed the meaning behind Vader’s sacrifice. Thanks for keeping Anakin’s legacy alive!
i agree with this 100%. But I think they made Luke garbage by making him some old man who didn't want to be found again and just simply gave up on his life.
STAR WARS just needs to be re-done completely
The original meaning was to save his freaking child ...
Eh I disagree. Anakins mission failed in a way either way as Palpatine came back in legends too. But Anakin did restore balance to the force and defeat the Sith when they became the most powerful. The Sith can never truly be destroyed I think. Darth Plagieus said to Palpatine once that if the Jedi found him he'd be another Exar Kun.
@@samdickenson5852 yeah i mean if i see it Rey is his successor indirectly too tho, aside from Luke and Ahsoka
Qui-Gon: Gives encouraging words
Obi-Wan: Support's her Force connection
Luke & Leila: Reminds her that the Force is always with her
Anakin: Passing his lightsaber using the Force
Windu: Strengthening her grip
Ahsoka: Silently holding her
And Yoda: Get the job done with a single blast using the Force (just like he did during his last confrontation with Darth Sidious)
Mickey from Rocky IV: Get up you SOB!!
Better than the original by far. Brought tears to my eyes.
True.
Same!
Same. The algorithm delivered.
Yep same, but Qui-gon being able to show himself as a force ghost is still debated. I guess it would make sense that there'd be a force nexus on Exegol (like that time in Clone wars he appeared)
Regardless loved this edit!
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Rey with Anakin's face??? "That's why you fail"
Its truly astounding that Disney couldnt figure this out. Even now, how hard would it be to edit something like this in to a special edition on disney plus??
That means that would have to acknowledge they were wrong, something they WOULD NEVER do.
Rey doesn’t need help from all those dead stale male Jedi…. Goes against the Disney narrative
@@jc135276 this is actually the correct answer. The victory in this movie was Rey's. Having all the other Jedi show up for it would have robbed her of this victory and people would forever go on and say how she didn't earn her achievements herself.
Fans might not be pleased, but the canon version is completely in line with the narrative they had in mind for Rey. She's the protagonist of the ST. She's the hero. She defeats Palpatine herself.
I didn't think I would ever say this, but we need someone like George Lucas editing stuff for special editions thirty years after release.
Exactly. It's sad that their main goal and concern is how much money they can make rather than how much they could please the fans and honor this epic story. You would think they would be bright enough to know if they pleased fans they would just naturally score big bucks, but we dont live in sensible times anymore
This was the ending the franchise deserved. I teared up seeing Obi-Wan acknowledge Anakin.
Outstanding job!
Watch the victory celebration in ROTJ (most recent edition) to see Obi look over at young Ani as friends again!
loved how Anakin merged with Rey also Love how Luke's ghost calls out to his apprentice knowing something bad is about to happen to her, love that detail of how all the Jedi come to Rey's support and that Luke as a ghost even at the last moments of his life really comes to feel for her
That hand motion from Anakin right as Rey catches his old saber... perfect! As though he guided it to her. This is the scene we should have gotten...
Yepp
If this happened the movie theater would have been going crazy
They would have literally died. I mean dead as in their heart stopped. Especially me. I would have just spontaneously combusted
Yeah me too. I just got chills watching it. I know we heard the voices only it was better to see the force ghosts
I have to say, the ending could have been way better. This is only a glimpse of the possibilities that Disney could have chosen that would be better.
@@magnificentgdc you know I always get confused & completely bewildered why Disney always gets a mention as you too had a say. IT IS JJ ABRAMS that directed rise of Skywalker so the buck stops with him.
That’s what I thought. Everyone would have gone nuts. Brings the whole story together
The reaction in theatres would’ve been Avengers: Endgame ‘Portals’ level epic
True, sad what the damn writers did to Rey, she really would've felt like a true Skywalker. I think the sequels must be altered and modified by people who actually know SW.
@@benjaminvillegas6743 Not Skywalker, she's not at all familiar with the Skywalker family. Ahsoka and Rex have more reasons to be Skywalker than Rey.
But this altered scene did make her worthy to be alive and continue Jedi line.
So.. not epic at all and predictable?
Meh? It's still an atrocious ending, with glaring plotholes, cringey dialogue, and even just the fact that Rey and Sidious(at least, the resurrection of Sidious) are characters in this movie AT ALL!
Mara Jade > Rey. I'm sorry but Mara Jade is just so much cooler than Rey, and I still feel robbed, cheated, and abused for her getting deleted by disney.
I mean they deleted so much content far better than what they replaced it with - Yuuzhan Vong war, actually good mandalorian lore, the Legacy of the Force storyline, obvs Mara Jade, and Luke actually having, you know, an actual life?
Palpatine: I am all the Sith!
Old Ben: you're my speciality!
If they did this exact thing but with Ben Solo instead of Rey, it would’ve literally been a flawless masterpiece of a scene. The Last Skywalker standing up to face Palpatine with the voices of all the Jedi telling him to *“rise”* would have been amazing, such a missed opportunity. They had him there and literally tossed him away just to give Rey his moment.
Hell no Kyle I mean kylo is trash!
@@jerodjordan9570 You wouldn’t be able to spot a good character if you had your eyes glued to a screen for a hundred years…if Kylo was a trash character it wouldn’t be a universal opinion across the entire fan base, from the people who hate the sequels to the people who love them that Kylo Ren was *the* best character to come out of those movies…the only character in the sequels that felt like someone George himself would have created…
Star Wars Theory for example, hates the sequels and doesn’t even consider them canon but in a recent stream he literally said word for word *”Kylo Ren is one of my favourite characters across all of Star Wars not just the movies…all of Star Wars…comics, legends, canon, games all of Star Wars, he’s in my top 5”* - and he hates the sequel trilogy with a passion…you know why he said that because he recognises that Kylo Ren is a great character, played by an actor that Martin Scorsese himself is on record praising as one of the greatest actors of his generation - Adam Driver.
I’m sorry but it’s just a fact, I don’t like the sequels as whole but I’m not going to sit here and pretend Kylo Ren as a character isn’t top tier Star Wars…I mean have you seen some of the edits on TH-cam on Kylo, they’re jaw dropping.
@@Ivbo lol what’s universal lol NO ONE THINKS HES A TOP CHARACTER THE ONLY THING PEOPLE WANTED TO SEE WITG HIM WAS HIM GETTING DESTROYED BY LUKE WHICH DIDNT HAPPEN
@@jerodjordan9570 Think I just lost a few brain cells reading that…you probably only read like 8 words of my original reply, read the rest of it then go get yourself a block of chocolate, sit down and repeat to yourself *“I’m a bit brain stiff but that’s okay”* should make you feel a bit better.
They should have made Rey kill palpatine with all her hate and turn to the dark side, then make Ben destroy Palpatine's spirit or something with the help of the ghosts, so at the end both Rey and Ben would have been alive and everyone would have been happy.
I love the expressions of Palpatine when the lightning flickers and he sees the ghosts.
He's so absurdly irritated and beyond pissed that after 40 years of his plans and deceit, the Jedi STILL stand in his way.
Looking at Qui-Gon taking a stand against Sidious is so poetic. That's the very definition of "If you strike me down, I shall become more powerful than you can possibly imagine".
And here I can accept that bacouse Rey killed him with the help of the ghosts, he couldn't possess her.
Bacouse? What
Rey could kill him in the movie because he attacked her, its self defense, she isn't striking him down like he needed her too
@@SirBigHead Nope, she reflects lighting directly into him, and makes the final blast by herself.
@@SirBigHead Of what i understand you had to strike him down with anger or hatred for it. That is why Anakin/Vader didn't get possessed when he threw him down the shaft. :)
But Vader did kill Palps in anger. Hence why Palps' spirit survived in the first place and possessed his clone.
The thought of seeing Hayden as Anakin on the same screen as an older Mark Hamill nearly brings me to tears.
YES OMG
😭😭
Why, Hayden was a disaster. Worst actor in any Star Wars film. Even JarJar was better!
Colin bruh screw off
@@Colin-Fenix Hayden is Anakin, shut up
OMG. Such a tear jerker for all Star Wars fans. This is now Canon.This is insanely incredible with the main jedi throughout the saga helping Rey. I mean no words how blown away i am right now by this EPIC three minutes
Omg, omg, omg!! This was SO powerful I've still got chills and my eyes are watering. I can't believe how just with some simple editing (like the beats of Rey rising to her feet), it makes the entire scene so much more beautiful and dramatic. I absolutely love that you can hear all the former Jedi voices now with such clarity and then you actually see them all! And I just noticed that what she did initially was look "past" all the darkness and evil and destruction symbolized by the Force lightning coming from Sidious, past it all into space to find that place of quiet and stillness where she could connect with all the fallen Jedi in the spiritual realm. What an incredible way to end it all and you can actually see how Anakin possessed her body in that final moment before she destroys Sidious. Absolutely brilliant!
This deserves so many more views. This is incredible.
Yeah! The scene gave me chills. Should have ended this way
Absolutely agree. Very well done.
"This is the end for you, my master".
Indeed!
“Alone, never have you been” sounded strange but everything else was great!
I’m a huge fan of Anakin, Vader and the Emperor. So I felt you certainly did them justice by literally having Anakin defeat Palpatine. It looks so much better than just Rey.
Anakin defeated Palpatine in ROTJ. Killed him dead. These last three movies were just a BS money grab.
@@davidbarker2507 you do have a point but since he is the emperor and is very strong surviving somehow and hiding on a sith world is really not that hard to believe 😅😆😛
I agree. Palpy did die in ROTJ, but I loved the idea of Dark Side-infused bio-engineering bringing him back for the sequels. To me, it just made more storytelling sense to have him as the antagonist. I actually felt the return of Sidious was one of the better writing choices for the sequel films.
Of course, the canon novelization then had to go and say he's just a "clone", which is a pretty bland and dumb explanation for his return if you ask me. A Dark Side resurrection would have been much cooler.
It might have sounded better as “never alone, have you been.” But it’s hard to get Yoda’s odd way of talking right.
@@stevennocella5805 He can have survived again. Thats another stupidity of the ST. No mention as why he couldn't repeat his trick from ROTJ. Poe and Finn tease it even in the Novel.
Episode 9 is in desperate need for an extended cut, directors cut or some alternate cut of the movie because what’s there can definitely be turned into something great, just look at this video…and apparently there are loads of deleted scenes that could be finished and added, a great ending to the saga already exists at Lucasfilm it just needs to be finished released…
Rumor is the ghosts WERE supposed to appear, but Disney was more worried about offending the Chinese market. Apparently simply sending them the version without the ghosts while keeping it in for everyone else wasn't an option. And after Lando arrived with the armada, I was expecting the mother of all space battles, and all we got were two quick battle scenes. There had to have been more than what was filmed. And relegating Wedge to a 2-second cameo, then completely forgetting about him at the end (even though he was IN the Falcon!) - they should have had him fly in as Red Leader, leading the remaining members of Rogue Squadron into battle right behind Lando. THAT would have been much more epic!
Episode 9: The Lucas Cut
I think they should release an extended or special edition cut of the Sequels like how Lord of the Rings did. At least an extended cut for the Rise of Skywalker as the film has potential but had an extremely dissatisfactory ending. Had this been the way Palpatine was killed I would have been a lot happier with the film and the trilogy as a whole.
@@djmace9029 Bitch please, just cos you Star Wars geeks hate Disney.
@@richallenxbox1976 🤣🤣🤣 WHAT
Best end EVER! Even paused the original 9th movie, showed this clip, (fast forward:ed the original movie) and then kept on going with the rest of the movie until the end. Wathed all 9 movies with my 5 year old daughter. She LOVES Star Wars! As I did, her age.. LOL
Still MY Official ending! I will NEVER watch the oroginal ending again! Always paus and se this before returning to the actual movie.
This is a gem! Father and son standing side by side, Anakin's pass to Rey, Obi Wan's call to Anakin, Luke crying out to Rey... Didn't know we needed this.
I would’ve forgiven the whole movie had this been in the movie
Possibly even the entire sequel trilogy.
@@katiehelms8903 No, still way too many unanswered questions.
yes
Exactly!!! This is literally the first thing I said they should have done and set it up perfectly with the lightning strikes. How did the brilliant minds at Disney miss this opportunity. So glad I wasn’t the only one who imagined this.
May the force be with you. Damn I was about to cry over this beautiful masterpiece as I remembered all the movies in the past. This is so much beautiful. So much overwhelming. Thank you for doing this. Thank you...
What this shows beyond any reasonable doubt, is how much better the film would have been if Abrams/Lucasfilm/Disney had actually done this. These fan edits are straight up proof.
Well they planned this but China Doesent allow ghosts to be good guys.
Yeah absolutely I carnt understand why he didn't Seeing the force ghosts would have been so much better than hearing them. Also loved the force push from yoda as they produced the second lightsaber
There was probably thing ABRAMS could have done at the end. He could have reversed the the roles. Kylo ren/Skywalker could have been the one rising & the one to defeat the emperor. It would have made more sense that way.
@@karlfranzemperorofmandefil5547 Is this really true. Never heard about this factoid. It's a shame though, movie writing shouldn't cater to customs of individual countries.
@@Sutefan7 it's not confirmed by Disney but they made trouble for several other movies that included them.
Wow!! I am blown away! Seriously THIS should have been the original ending! This was perfect... thank you for posting. Please take your talents and imagination to the top.
1:55 that music is so powerful
This was a no brainer. There must have been a reason why this didn't take place. Hearing their voices was NOT effective enough. Did they not want to copy Endgame's finale by having all the heroes return? I actually feel bad for Abrams if they handcuffed his original ending ideas. The movie needed to be a 2 parter imho. The beloved Cariie Fisher's passing did not help things
They had already ripped off the portals ending big time
They didn't use Colin Trevorrow's script because Carrie Fisher died.
They didn't use ghosts in Jeffrey Jacob Abrams's script because of China market rules.
i guess they figured just voices would harken back to the original 77 films ending. plus maybe too 'Endgame'... but theres no denying something like this wouldve been far superior (besides theyd already gone full fan service with all kinds of stuff: the emperor, the death star 2 ruins, the han cameo, so might as well have included the force ghosts too)
Idk why they didn’t do this type of ending instead… if it’s because they didn’t want to “copy” the Avengers nobody would really complain as they’re both under Disney…
@@xfinity319 China market
This is a million times better than the ending we got wow
I’m telling you *THIS* is what everyone wants! If we got *THIS* it would have increased the positivity 10000 fold!
Positivity? What if you could bring the Jedi to YOUR world? This world? Possibly through Disney, for example? You see, you "fans" just don't think BIG enough.
@@dreamingforward uhhhh what do you even mean? He's just saying that this is what he wanted to see in the movie
But with Ben Solo instead of Rey.
Nah still shit!
I think fans just wanted a good movie and not this absolute total dumpster fire. This scene would’ve changed nothing.
Friggin Beautifil...When Obi Wan says "Anakin", for the sake of all the Obi-Ani Clone Wars moments, it would have been great if it would've Ewan saying "anakin now" But, still it is beautiful
I wrote a fanfic of the 3rd film for myself before the movie came out since TLJ sucked. Rey wins at the end by fighting the bad guy with the help of force ghosts. Yoda gives her wisdom telling her what to focus on, Anakin gives her real time battle advice, Obi-wan tells her to trust in herself and Luke...Luke gives her hope when she thinks she's been beaten. It's an obvious climatic choice for a universe where force-ghosts exist and you want to wrap up a 9 series saga. It's a visual and impactful way to link every story. It's cool.
They didn't do it. Likely because someone didn't want Rey to have help. So instead we got Rey beating Palps with the unmatched power of not one, but TWO lightsabers....what a genius idea...pure narrative perfection. Amazing.
God this was perfect. Disney actually sucks to deliver what WE want in a Star Wars film.
Gosh*
@@iamdeathstreak 😑
What YOU want, I was perfectly fine with Solo and Roque One, S7 of TCW was mostly perfect, The Bad Batch so far is all right, the sequels definenetly aren't my favourites but they also had their moments. So, yeah there are Problems with Disney Star Wars, but there have been Problems before them
@@Lekawie oh yeah and I agree, the phantom menace wasn’t the greatest either, everyone has their taste. But I was just stating that Disney only focuses for the money not for the audience. As a Film Maker myself I know that if you deliver what the audience would want to see, the film would work.
@@Lekawie SW may have had "problems" before, but the prequels were *way* better than the sequels.
Give this guy a medal 🥇disney. He saved the ending of this movie.
I'll never understand why Disney didn't put that effort into the actual trilogy, what a HUGE difference it would have made to the reception of it, dank farrik!!
Absolutely brilliant! Everything that ending should have been!! Thank you for taking the time to deliver this badass epic to us!
The reimagined end could be better if:
- Pryde wasn't dumb as he orders the Steadfast to flip 90 degrees to knock the Resistance space horses out of the ship, leaving no explosives placed
- Palpatine's godlike force lightning nearly wipes out all the Resistance fleet but the Millennium Falcon, Poe's X-Wing and the Corellian Corvette, turning the tide against the Resistance
- Finn turns the First Order's Stormtroopers against the Final Order
- Lando lightspeeds the Falcon against the Steadfast in desperation to stop the Star Destroyers from leaving Exegol
- (Bonus) A definitive end to BB-9E
The Tantive 4 should also have survived. Also, a droid showdown would be entertaining.
Bringing Anakin’s line to life made this moment so much more powerful😊
I literally had chills that's the ending I only dreamed of, kudos to the editor of this master piece
A scene like this would've single-handedly saved the entire movie. How can Marvel Studios be so good under Disney while Lucasfilm are so crap? Ah yeah, Kevin Feige. Lucasfilm need someone like him. If Kathleen Turner had been in charge of Endgame, all the revived Avengers would've cheered on the ones who faced Thanos via phone call, ffs.
Kathleen Turner? LOL
Thou art an idiot, 2015 called, they want their "Bitching about Disney is cool" period back.
Kathleen Turner is the actrice, Kathleen Kennedy is the head of Lucas Films .
Jon Favreau and Dave Filoni as directors would've made the sequel trilogy 1000x better
It wouldn't have saved the entire movie for me, but I would have forgiven a LOT of things about it.
This gives me goosebump, the starwar themem and edit match so well
The best Star Wars I’ve seen since Disney took over. The way all the Jedi help Rey. When Anakin says bring back the balance. His force ghost goes inside Rey to destroy The Emperor. Well done
Ahsoka Tano five minutes later: *Guys, I totally could've helped.*
Ahsoka Tano Ghost be like: Hello there, boys. What did I miss?
If she's even dead
Windu: I'm sorry, citisen. These matters are for council to discuss.
She was nothing until clone wars….
Why didn’t they do this in the movie? It would’ve tied it up better to have all of the great Jedi come back as ghosts.
They probably didn't want to pay for the actors to use their likeness
Dude hell yeah! 👍🏼
They did it the way they did for Chinese box office. Censors over there are not keen on the depiction of ghosts in films.
They didn't want to visually have men helping the waman in the final battle.
@@espy0008 ⬆️⬆️⬆️ This. It was all woke nonsense from the beginning.
I hate the sequels but this litterally gave me chills
I just went on a journey today that I wasnt expecting, today was a good day
Hello, I'm a 16-year-old Star Wars fan living in Korea! Born in 2009, the ending of Star Wars episode 9 'Rise of Sky Walker' was really shocking. But here's the ending I wanted!! Thank you for making such a wonderful edit!! The combination of music is really good
Especially from 1:34 I was really cool and overwhelmed!! I was surprised to see how the Jedi's desperation and sacrifice to get rid of the cis from that part went by so well with music!! I enjoyed the video. Thank you again!!😢👍👍😭🫡
Give this man the money to make the star wars equivalent of a Zack Snyder Cut!!!
I love how Rey’s face turns into Anakins for a second at 2:53
He could technically still be the chosen one with this ending.
@nathanimator That's not a bad idea honestly cause I enjoyed this trilogy. Sure it has its flaws but I thought 7 was a good movie I just don't like what 8 did to the original characters but atleast it was fixed here.
@@albertoquinones8541 you're a fake fan
@nathanimator I hate that theory and any real star wars fan would hate it as well.
@nathanimator cringe
I didn’t care for Rey or the sequel trilogy at all, but the way you had the Rise of Skywalker trailer music play as Rey started to rise made me sob. You fit it in perfectly it seemed so real. Well done.
There’s another alternate ending where Anakin takes control (in a good way) of Rey. After the emperor says, “I AM ALL THE SITH”, Anakin says, “And I’m the chosen one.”
Imagine if disney did this, they would be able to brush off all the mary sue stuff cause theyd be able to say that the jedi were helping here every step of the way, explaining why everything came so easy with 0 training. Bit like the avatar state in atlab or lok
This is freaking awesome!
I can’t believe how much they butchered this franchise
At least the Mandalorian is bringing the essence of Star Wars back
No words. Except....can you imagine the fan reactions to a scene like this in theaters and around the world?? Would have been epic and 100% fitting for the new characters and our beloved OT characters.
This is so powerful I had to watch it 4 times in a row. Thank you for making this!!!!
Same, watched it 3 times. Chills each time, wow.
A very powerful scene. I'm extremely glad that there are fans who can make a masterpiece ending. I am endlessly disappointed that the people working at Disney are mediocrities who receive millions in fees, but are no match for the fans...
I just caught this now and I have one this to say.... HOLY SH-T!! THIS JUST GAVE ME CHILLS WHILE WATCHING NOW! This is how it SHOULD have been done!! ABSOLUTELY AMAZING! Isn't it sad that fans can do better than KK can and she's the one making millions while (sadly) just being signed on for ANOTHER 3 YEARS !?!!
I would’ve been fine with her taking the name of Skywalker if she had actually had a long and developed relationship with Luke
Yeah, it's fascinating to me. From the different master-student relationships we got (Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan; Obi-Wan and Anakin, Obi-Wan and Luke, Yoda and Luke, Luke and Rey) the one between Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan was probably the best developed one with the least amount of screen time.
Well, she had a relationship with both Skywalker siblings - Luke and Leia. She did that to honor their masters. One was hard on her and the other was softer but both guided her. The Anakin's lightsaber was the one who called her out to take the hero Journey when she picked it up and all those visions.
@@AB-sg7pl I disagree. Luke wasn’t being tough on her he just didn’t want her to be around and all Rey and Luke ever did was fight. As for Leia, Rey and Leia were friends for a few months and Leia never really called herself a Skywalker. She was always either an Organa or a Solo. Plus, Leia was the one who told Rey that ancestry doesn’t define you and not to run away from it which is exactly what Rey proceeds to do. If Leia was such a great mentor to Rey then Rey would’ve accepted the Palpatine name or at least use Solo since she had a relationship with both Han and Leia. Now that I think about it Han was more of a father figure than Luke ever was.
It only made sense for her to use the name Solo if she wanted to adopt the last name of the man who saved her and shared a very strong bond with her, similar to what Rose Dawson did in the movie Titanic. I would definitely go for the option of her adopting Ben's last name, but it would generate a lot of controversy in a relationship already full of controversy. The kiss they gave at the end of the film was already stretching boundaries for many people
A mentor doesn't have to be the typical teacher who follows traditional teaching. Luke mentored Rey and even gave Rey a formal lesson and a mission that was later introduced in the extra scenes. Anyone is our mentor if they test our resilience and trigger the wisdom within us. Despite Luke's harshness, he was the one who inspired Rey on her path.
Leia was actually of the Skywalker lineage despite having always used the name of her adoptive parents and would not recant the name given to her just because she found out that her real father was Anakin Skywalker.
Rey adopted the name Skywalker as a tribute to her two mentors just after they passed away.
Obviously, she wasn't going to use the name Palpatine, as probably neither her father nor her mother used that name since what they most wanted was distance from the Emperor.
I salute you, because for your love to the seventh art and Star Wars. Suddenly, this adding images and music makes perfect sense to the entire saga. Thanks for this loving work. I mean it. Greetings from Argentina.
I would have gone to the theater about a dozen times if this was what they'd done.
actually got chills watching this
1:43-1:56 This part really knows how to give me goosebumps.
This actually gave me chills. THAT was all they had to do to make it truly epic. Put the faces in there! I needed this. :D
This is the canon version in my heart
Awesome-! Thanks for a very well done remake. I am sure I'm not the only old fan, that approves, and welcomes your work. Very well done indeed.
Dang, just finding this in late 2023 and this sparked more emotion out of me than 8 & 9 combined.
Obi-Wan really needed to make sure Anakin didn't do a little bit of trolling and help Palpatine with his force lightning again
Ya know something... That didn't suck. In fact it was better than the original at got stuck with.
Big props, yo!
Lmao right !!!
Anakin saying "This is the end for you my master" in this context gave me such chills, this is incredible. George Lucas should have let you direct the sequels instead of Disney.
Man especially where they did recycle so many lines and themes from previous movies. That would've been great foreshadowing to switch the context of the Anakin line too and truly make it his rise. Like yeah, he was redeemed in ROTJ, but this would've been so impactful
@@gael7w802 Exactly. Disney made many bad decisions with regards to this franchise, but scrapping Anakin's character is quite possibly the worst one.
@@katiehelms8903 Agreed. Honestly I liked the sequels as sci-fi movies, but not as a part of Star Wars
@@gael7w802 I know, right? They're good movies, just not good STAR WARS movies.
@@katiehelms8903 the last Jedi though is a horrible movie
Now that is true"Star Wars" writing! Absolutely the BEST ending, as it should have been written.
This.... I got literal chills! How did i not see this until now?? amazing amazing work! Especially with the compositing!
I would love to see how you would implement the later part of the scene with Ben and the force ghosts. I'm not a Reylo fan, but I would love to see if you could incorporate Anakin/other Jedi helping Ben heal Rey.
Lastly, I realize that including Ahsoka into this scene would probably have been impossible because of the lack of live-action footage currently, but if you would ever do this again and include Ahsoka - that would be amazing. I'm convinced that the force would have allowed her to train to preserve her consciousness after death, especially because of the daughter's life force in her. And giving a chance for Ahsoka, Anakin and Obi-Wan to get another chance at Sidious! Something to consider, but again amazing amazing work. Thank you for giving us such a beautiful piece of content to watch over and over again.
2:56 I would have lol if he said "This is where the fun begins" 🤣
This is almost perfect! I would not have had the past characters do another but be shadows but LOVED the music and LOVED that you could hear the Masters talk!
Obi wan should have said "Anakin, YOU have the high ground!"
That would've been kriffing awesome...and poetic!
good job man! I really like your version, congratulations friend! you master the after effects !!
Ho, thanks you so much my friend! I really appreciate that you like my video, together we brought balance to the force....
Looks amazing, very nice editing skills👍
"This is the end for you my master" gives me chills! 🔥🔥🔥🔥
Only just saw this, absolutely brilliant. If this had been the ending we were given the film would have been considered a classic instead of a failure. Superb. Well done!
Holy crap man, this is incredible.
Oh where has this been? That was so good it's going on the big screen when I get home. Agreed that's my new ending that brings everything and everyone together. I'm going to watch it again. Very very well done, BRAVO!
I have seen many, many edits of this. But THIS one is by far the best, good job man!
When TH-cam fan edits are better than what Disney & Hollywood directors brought us.