Political Rumble Debate: Record Suspension of MPs From Parliament Explored
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 19 มิ.ย. 2024
- In this riveting episode of Political Rumble, speakers tackle the burning issue that has dominated the political newscape recently - the unprecedented suspension of 146 Opposition MPs during the winter session of Parliament. The debate probes into the underlying reasons for this situation, including the MPs' demand for a statement from Home Minister Amit Shah on a security breach in Parliament, and the government's counterclaim about violation of Parliament rules by these MPs. The dramatic tableau of slogans, placards, and heated confrontations in the well of the house forms the backdrop to this episode. The discourse brings fresh insights into the practices and dynamics of parliamentary proceedings and controversies, offering viewers a chance to understand their significance in the larger scheme of political dynamics. #PoliticalRumble #WeekendDebate #Parliament #WinterSession #RecordSuspension #OppositionMPs #AmitShah #SecurityBreach #Government #Violation #Rules #Slogans #Placards #rajdeepsardesai
Subscribe to India Today for NEW VIDEOS EVERY DAY and make sure to enable Push Notifications so you'll never miss a new video.
All you need to do is PRESS THE BELL ICON next to the Subscribe button!
India Today TV is India's leading English News Channel. India Today TH-cam channel offers latest news videos on Politics, Business, Cricket, Bollywood, Lifestyle, Auto, Technology, Travel, Entertainment and a lot more.
Stay tuned for latest updates and in-depth analysis of news from India and around the world!
WhatsApp Channel: whatsapp.com/channel/0029Va2A...
Download App: indiatoday.link/wHaj
Follow us: Official website: www.indiatoday.in/
Twitter: / indiatoday
Facebook: / indiatoday
Yogendra looks sick mentally,physically let him rest😅
U looks sick too
Salim wants democracy till his community is in majority and then the “book” will be everything
JP sir..is gold...valid points...not like sadak chaap chapri khangressi
The 141 MPs were asking for trouble all along by jumping into the well and displaying plycards. Where as there were many from the opposition parties including Congress , DMK, and others who continued to attend the Parliament proceeding till the last day due to there moral courage and to maintain a clean image vis a vis that of a spoiled wealthy urchins. Were these pleople Wrong Mr Sardesai ?
Jayaprakash opening comments are spot on, we need such people and such ideas
Stupid idea to suggest taking away anti defection law.
JP is excellent 👌
Mr yogendra yadav it's high time consult a psychiatrist
Hitler also did the same thing to the German parliament.
It took 50 years for Germany to recover from the effects of that mad man.
Listening to Jayaprakash is like sona nikal raha ho muh se and listening Yogendra Yadav is like 'guu kha aaya hai'. The constructive criticism raise by Mr Jaya Prakash should be heard by opposition and Yogendra Yadav type people.
But not by bjp .right ?
@@SenthilKumar-pb3nu BJP is in majority so you cannot dictate terms. If opposition get in line BJP automatically get in line.
@@anujkurchania6955 what an argument ?. Thats why ur a bjp supporter. U have no understanding of democracy.
@@SenthilKumar-pb3nu you are same as Yogendra yadav type, living to which wonderland, that is also a question mark...
JP is great always. He suggests solutions to problems and reality of the current situation.
His suggestion to take away anti-defection law is so naive. BJP will simply rule every state with help of ED/CBI/IT and money power.
Why should any MP be threated by IT/ED to begin with unless he is a goon, and so rule of law should apply ?
@@JasG-fi6dp u must be very naive. Bruj Bhushan with umpteen rape/molest cases roaming freely while opposition leaders are in prison without bail. Assam CM himanshu Biswa joined BJP in 2015 after corruption charges levelled by BJP. Current DY CM Ajit pawar joined BJP coalition after BJP accused him of mega corruption charges and putting numerous cases. Once they bend to BJPs's will all charges will be dropped. So many instances like that.
@@JasG-fi6dp Threatening with any institutions is unacceptable. As a common man, any institution helping to punish goons, scammers, loan evaders etc. is welcome. Somewhere I read ED has attached around 1 lakh crores till now. Let us appreciate their work!
@@SenthilKumar-pb3nuwhy act like this is first time ever all things like that are happening? This was always the case regardless of who are in power. Infact Indira Gandhi & Jawaharlal Nehru were worse than Modi infact its not even close.
Yogendra needs a reality check and a proper day job!
I am just wondering why this action was delayed for so long.. Public is fool as per Yogendra & co. 😂😂
Yeah stupid congress shud have done this during 2010 ..and bhakths wud have screamed democracy
I would request the anchor to stop intersecting and allow the panelists to answer.
The right thing happened in parliament. Elected representatives can't misbehave.
They were forced to do that. It was well planned n fabricated n well master minded. Willfully, purposefully done by government. They can not justify.
But they can rape and molest and bjp will keep them in their party
Good to hear from Dr Narayan and Rajat Sethi.
These are true debates , respect to each other appreciation for each other abd then Rajdeep giving enough time to each speaker for their opinions, wonderful to listen such intellectual conversations, hope Arnab and other pro govt screamers listen and learn a thing or two from this . Thank you sarsesai. You continue to hold journalists flag high. Best wishes
This presstitute says - we didn't bring Congress or BJP representatives.
Who is Salim Urf Yogendra then?
From where he is running his house? His party? His elections? These people are funded by foreign interests.
You cannot expect anything good from this Presstitute or Salim.
Very good panel. People like Dr Jayprakash Narayan should be on every debate.
True. He is an ias officer 👮
@@vvk594was, he voluntarily retired and doesn't even take Pension. He is a very honest man.
You can't use the past wrong doings as a shield to do nonsense now. As individuals show maturity as they grow, the nation too must show maturity as years go by.
Hope u will stick to this moral high ground when BJP is in opposition.
Parliament was dead when kangress closed its doors and bifurcated AP.
What is electoral monarchy,what’s the problem when we are choosing.
This should be read as record misbehaviour of opposition !
What do u call what bjp did during 2010 to 2014 ?
Hahahahahaha you haven't brought congress because you represent congress, Yogendra yadhav is an Andolan jeevi and the other guy 😂😂😂😂
But he did balance with 2 bjp panelists
Since 43% are in Parliament , irresponsibility persisted .
* Congress and it's Allies of I.N.D.I.A. instead of taking actions through Police and Court of Law against Culprits of Parliament attack FIGHTING AGAINST RULING PARTY in Parliament Backing the Culprits on the Pretext of Unemployment .
* This is absolute irresponsibility on the part of Oppositions to defend the Culprits.
* The two Culprits were handed over to Police and another 4 involved in the Plot are arrested and investigation is in progress.
* I.N.D.I.A. Parties should realise their gross mistake of Protests in Parliament.
We had couple of sessions completely washed out due to opposition. So yes it is not a correct way to do, but I guess govt. Had only this way of getting the business done.
Dr JP exposes valid points that the political parties & individual members of the should act independently, follow the rules, debating properly and finally make the on basis of merits
Are u living in India where MLAs are bought by BJP to form govt in karnataka and mizoram, etc ?
In every house there should be good discipline to be in order to run effectively and fruitfully. Parliament house also has to be in order to run effectively and get coveted outcome.
I wish elected governments can use Dr.JPN's brilliance to design frameworks, whether it is parliamentary committees or propose changes for safeguarding our democratic values. He is always well prepared and factual, his debates are a treat and is highly respected by the polity. Yogendra Yadav over the last couple of years has lost his neutrality and relevance, it is only English with no facts.
Having said that, opposition simply got desperate and legislature is simply a glorified party meeting where opposition wants to block anything and everything the ruling govt proposed, even if is good for the population.
Pathetic suggestion by JP to take away anti-defection law. He is completely cutoff from reality in indian politics.
Impressed by Jayprakash Narayan
Taking a neutral stand will not make a person great and prudent. Warning will not work either. Democracy is at real danger. Listen to the whistleblower and need action right away.
So what 140/150 are suspended...
If 100s of people commit something unruly, should they be allowed to go scot-free...?
The intellectual horsepower has overwhelmed Rajdeep's logic circuits!
20:20 What mr.yadav do not realize is, whatever he is saying has already happened. People were frustrated, angry and came out and kicked the asses of congress out of power. Same may happen to BJP if they behave like congress. But the power is not gonna go back to congress in its current form. Howmuch ever mr. yadav wishes, time of political brokers is over
Hats off to Parliament, major bills passed. Great points discussed as part of those bills. Congratulations MPs.
Very impressed with Rajat Sethi and Jayprakash Narayan.
Why is program was just 26 mins when you are a 24 hour channel?
Laal Gamsha is becoming more and more communist.
Mr. Sardesai, on one hand Mr Chidambaram says the new criminal laws promulgated are copy paste of earlier laws whereas Mrs Mamta Banerjee who is also part of I.N.D.I Alliance says the news laws are draconian. Have they really treat at least the highlights of the new pass which is making everyone accountable. Any law can be improved and amendments can be brought in etc. Mr. Chidambaram says the IPC laws are colonial and never revamp but now the Govt has copy pasted the old laws. What where they doing for 75 years in these colonial laws? Rather than trying to sosupport the opposition on their suspension which was because 🎉of gross indiscipline and insults and prayers hurled at the Speaker and VP you can spend as much time in discussing the new IPC laws.
Opposition loosing everything also because their media partners neither changing narrative nor faces. Rajdeep Pl listen your friend Tahsen Poonawala describing Yougendra with Barkha in Inside out. On what criteria you select your panel ?
Yes he shud select like the great journo Arnab
Rules are to be followed in any system if they are not followed one should be punished . Yoginder is not a sane person
It does not apply to bjp and likes of bruj bhushsn, right ?
The only idiot was yoya
YoYa is a congressi
Yogendra Yadav is a clairvoyance to see the future of India. Unfortunately he becames jobless so writing obituary of parliamentary democracy. How hypocrite and paid narrative builder
5th Grade Teachers Don’t Allow Anarchies in Class !!
How About Super Cabinet Top on PM Manmohansing ???
Super PM Soniya ?? Salim Was Part of it ??
Your Thought Good For Gutterchap ! Not For Majority
What is the justification for suspension? Can speaker justify? Do the speaker follow the rules in constitution to suspend MLA or MP?
Bjp gives excuses that in 1989 , 63 MLA suspended? Can , bjp or speaker equate suspension in 1988 to suspension of 146 in 2023?
The motive of PM , HM and speaker is just to clear passage to pass new bill . They know the is not constitutional.
1989 was not the same. There were no other resort left but to suspend.
Accomodation of dissenting views is missing. Intolerence is the watchword. Demoracy is the casualty.
He can only create disruption for his gains.. what a man this is ohh my God
Modi ?
Sir why don't you discuss rules of functioning of parliament during this video
Why he had parted away from AAP everyone knows.. was forced to leave by kejriwal and company.. a dejected flop neta
Mr jogesh & rajdeep . Where was the democracy when njac was rejected by 5 nepotisim judges & enteire pros media was silent.
After all the political jibber jabber by yogendra yadav, he basically said:
1. congress did not follow rules, so BJP should not
2. Congress let everyone loot, so BJP can not limit the looting to adani or ambani
3. In congress governments, middlemen are everything , even though they add ZERO value to the system. So BJP can not communicate or deliver benefits to public directly. After all there are crores of brokers in India
Your panelists’ backgrounds are well known. This issue doesn’t call for any debate for the simple reason that the suspended MPs repeatedly violated the House rules. Discussions must focus around that and not some oft repeated jargon like ‘parliamentary democracy is in danger’. Why can’t the MPs behave? They are indulging in shouting continuously while issues are being debated besides carrying placards and storming the well and misbehaving with Speaker/Chairman. Is that what we expect from elected representatives? That’s the danger to democracy and you ought to discuss that instead of trying to build a false narrative Mr Sardesai. Readers now understand the sinister motives behind all that so please behave. The bottom line is that even if the Home Minister had agreed to a debate on the security breach in Lok Sabha, would that have been the end of the story? No, no and NO. Opposition would either have interrupted the discussion by shouting or would have walked out or demanded a statement by PM. Purpose is not to engage in some meaningful discussion but to disrupt the Houses to prevent passage of important bills. Yes that’s how democracy is in danger and please do discuss that. Thanks
Arrogance will be trampled upon
Yogendra Yadav is opposition, so his views are bound to be parallel to Congress et al though in a sweetly convoluted manner
It should be made mandatory that anyone entering the well is suspended automatically.
Always against current government and not critical to opposition leaders irresponsible behaviour
Suppose 100 thieves are caught you don’t say record people unfortunately caught you say record theft in the country !
Problem is the erstwhile thieves have caught new thieves and claiming justice
Khobish in action
My take democracy should win
JP tusi great ho tohfa kabool Karo jokes apart JP has hit the nail on the head
good discussion Rajdeep! Nice choice of guest panelists.
Except when he said that all three panelists made good points. YoYa can not go beyond his usual rhetoric and just wastes everyone’s time.
Yogendra Yadav here too
Andolanjeevi Dev Das Yadav came straight forward conclusion -- Death of Parliament.. No ! Dev Das. It's the way our Maharaja goes about doing business without breaking any law. Islamic congress held the record of 62 suspension for too long
I disagree with JP on criminal laws. Thousands of hours spend on these laws, all MPs were contacted, lot of beaurocrats were included, states were included...thousands and thousands of meetings were conducted, documents were prepared, all parties were consulted. That is the reason why opposition parties did not scold govt for passing criminal laws even at the time of suspension.
I have never come across such a hasty benching of law/bills before this 2 nd term of govt.
They are just power hungry and changing the names and claiming they are doing good. Heart in heart there is nothing that is being in good faith.
The only and only Big achievement of BJP's in the world since 2014
these people are so disconnected that when congress have the full majority. They did too much chaos then what Current govt did. Now what opposition is doing they have got a good chance in parliament to corner govt. Instead they do sloganeering.
Jamyang Tsering Namgyal, who know this person until he gave an iconic speech in the same parliament.
So opposition missed a great opportunity.
R u in reality ?. How will they corner bjp when speakers don't allow opposition dissent or speech ?.
@@SenthilKumar-pb3nu useless opposition is asking for HM statement. Tell me are they so ignorant that, there are 3 bills under HM purview, he is bound to come in the house to present them. They should have strategies there move.
But worthless guys start sloganeering and showing placard.
They handed over there a--s---s to BJP.
@@anujkurchania6955 opposition accomplished do much with this suspension actually...bjp did a stupid thing in suspending so many MPs...this gets talked more than debates which is hardly watched by any common man.
@@SenthilKumar-pb3nu haaaa, parliament debate goes into record. Suspension of MP you think is a big issue. Suspension is a regular thing for this term opposition. People will call opposition nuisance if not BJP will make them belief.
What opposition have achieved. Its the govt who passed crucial bills without any obstruction.
Y'all of the silly opposition must learn to speak from y'all seats in Parliament.
Why the opinion of yogendra yadav is asked ? Lost the only election he fought now giving dialogues as if he won 3 to 4 elections
The parliament is an institution where issues are debated, amendments are suggested, and a bill is passed or rejected based on the number of votes. Sloganeering, placards, disrupting the proceeding, threatening another member or the Speaker, etc. are not parliamentary procedures ... something that has been going on in both houses of the Indian Parliament. Should a disruptive MP be suspended? Why not? What is the alternative?
Simple - negotiate with opposition .why HM cud not speak ?.
It is people’s choice YY.
Rajdeep talk less than your guests, otherwise become an analyst and come as a guesg!
Yogendra is right when he said trampling of freedom of opposition to display it's feelings is not Democracy,. P
It means that the opposition behaved better before 2014.
Good joke...bjp disrupted for entire sessions during cong regime ...u must have selective amnesia😂
Problem is not that we are becoming autocratic nation . Problem is that opposition know nothing about the fight. If same thing happened with BJP then I am 100% sure that BJP would jamm the whole the nation bcz BJP knew that how to fight the political battle . Congress ruled this nation for more then 50 year or they knew how to rule but they don’t know how to fight the political battle as an opposition. Congress need to learn the political battle.
Problem is godi media criticize opposition for everything
True bjp is good in opposition...not in power
Only Dr. JP was making sense. Yogendra Yadav was bullshitting as always. Wonder why he is still called to debates.
Why u'are crying..why opposition rising unnecessary noise.. they also responsible..in 1980's period opposition use tools very nicely... remember..
Only India today and particularly Rajdeep invite such people to oppose modi government indirectly to settle his score and for sure not going to succeed at all n day will come that media channel will show him his real place
He had 2 bjp panelists...
Notorious anchor who terms most others as godi’ media. All he does is satiate the dark matter siccupying most of his brain.
Multiparty system with current arrangements in constitution does not work. Political surviving matters most in current scenario.
Regional politics and national interest clashes.
JP is great citizen of this country. It is lot opportunity for Andhra Pradesh and india.
The Union Indian government's debt-to-GDP ratio projection by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) exceeding 100% by 2027-28 is “misconstrued”, the Union finance ministry said while adding that the predictions by the UN's financial body correspond to a worst-case scenario which is not a “fait accompli”, or not something ...🤔😷😭
How constitutional was NAC ,Salimbhai?
Opposition was doing only politics in parliament. Opposition was happy when they were punished by law. Why pannalist's are unhappy I dont understand.
Disruptors r not required in parliament
The heading should be record of disrupting business in parliament. It is not the birth right of opposition.
That's what arun jaitley and sushma Swaraj said. U have forgotten or it applies only when bjp is in opposition ?
Nobody is ready to listen anymore with Saleem’s logic and mindset. His theory is expired! Cheer up Saleem (Yadav).
Five members having llb degree from substandard law college & getting judgeship for their father & uncle.
Five judges thinks that they have more wisdom than 700 mp . Our judges thinks they r not accountable to anyone as they r judges for their father.
Interesting mr yadav still has face to show.. has been taking to all channels like joker. He has lost touch of people
INDI Alliance?
Say I.N.D.I.A. or INDIA like UNESCO.
Yogendra is from Congress .. he is the convener of India Jodo
U had to use the word clever in ur handle...says lot about u 😂
I had to call out as these guys says we don't call people from Congress or BJP where as they are calling hardcore Congress people
@@cleversachin yogendra said 'congress must die for a stronger opposition party to emerge' only couple of years back...since there is no such opposition party emerging many are aligning with consolidated opposition to oppose BJP. Many are against congress but to defeat evil party, ppl have no other choice than supporting them.
@@cleversachin u missed to call out Rajat, an hard-core bhakth and JP, a shadow boxer for BJP
Ha ha .. defending corrupt people is more dangerous than corruption
Rajath sethi is taking the discussion to some other direction.
Sethi seems to be not good enough to express the real politics of the present situations.
He expressed his political theory.
He himself accepted the he is a student
He is a bjp student who has entire political science degree
Do we opposition party in India ?
There seems that nobody wants prevalence of rule of law!.
Yogendra Yadav get up and smell the coffee........
The new bills are being passed with suspension of 146 opposition members. This new position only confirms that the Parliament democracy is over. No opposition is required which is hallmark of Parliament democracy. Such a major suspension has never happened in the history of Parliament democracy Even the dictators have not shown such major action of suspension. We all accept that the Parliament is definitely a talking shop. There is nothing wrong if opposition talk. Where it will lead to?
This Rajat Sethi is a rogue who is calling INDIA alliance INDI. What can you expect from this Sanghi?
Sethi expect something for
Yogendra Yadav is the immature panelist
Yes the Jp said issues are important but rajdeep and yogi yadav thinks they are issues if only congress is in opposition
Salim bhai yadav Lol! 😂😂🤣🤣
Duggal saab aka yogidera yadav.