9:Mario 64 DS, haven’t played this one so I can’t say much. 8:Mario 64: Very important game and fun to pick up, but the camera and a lot of stupid stars put it low for me. 7: Bowser’s Fury: I love what it brings to the table, but it’s too short to put it above the others in my opinion 6: 3D Land: I might be a little bias, but I love this one. Really fun to play on the go. But it’s a bit too bland to put above the others. 5: Sunshine: While it certainly has it’s issues, I just love how different and unique it is. 4: 3D World: This is 3D Land times 10. Graphics, Characters, and level design create an excellent game. 3: Odyssey: This one is pretty much perfect, I just prefer the galaxy games. 2: Galaxy 2: This and Galaxy 1 are pretty much interchangeable, I just prefer Galaxy 1. The level design, bosses, and music are all perfect. 1: Galaxy: This game has all that makes Galaxy 2 perfect, but the added bit of story makes this a bit better in my opinion
@@HugeRMCFanBoY-bx3od Ever since the beginning, Mario has been regarded as one of gamings best franchises. Why do you think that is? Traditionally, what have Mario games done better than others?
Super mario galaxy is the best video game I have ever played. Not only is it nostalgia, but every aspect of the game is amazing. The storyline, uniqeness, gameplay, game design, mechanics, everything. I am a 16 year old game developer and gamer, and I have never seen something just like this. When I make more advanced games, I def want to make games like these. Super mario galaxy is part of my childhood. Amazing
My list of all 3d Mario games (not including bowsers fury and sunshine since I haven’t played it) 7: Super Mario 64 ds 6: Super Mario 3d land 5: Super Mario 3d World 4: Super Mario odyssey 3: Super Mario 64 2: Super Mario Galaxy 2 1: Super Mario Galaxy Explanation Super 64 ds has terrible controls. Super Mario 3d land is a very underrated game but it’s up against so many masterpieces that it can’t compete with. 3d world is like a combination of new super Mario bros wii and super Mario 3d land and it is great. I love the chaos that ensues all because of that damn crown. Super Mario odyssey is next and it’s practically just as good as 64. This game has the best movement in the series but it lacks great missions with it focusing more on quantity over quality. It also is too easy. The movement is so good that these negatives hardly matter. Super Mario 64 is a great game. I played this for the first time recently and it was so good. I loved most of the missions in the game (except 100 coins) and the movement was very fun. Super Mario galaxy 2 can be swapped with galaxy depending on what you prefer. Galaxy 2 has better gameplay but it sacrifices the great atmosphere and story from the original. Galaxy 1 is the best due to it being the only Mario game to actually focus on the atmosphere and story and it delivers. It has the most memorable areas in the series. It also has one of the best soundtracks not just in Mario history, not just in Nintendo history but in all of video games. Absolute masterpiece of a game that everyone needs to experience.
@@thesupervideogamenerdmore3171 I played Galaxy 2 first and then Galaxy 1 later. Galaxy 1 kinda felt like a downgrade. The only thing better about Galaxy 1 is the story elements. Galaxy 2 has more exciting and diverse gameplay with Yoshi, better level design and powerups. It also has better visuals.
@@Droobie03 The only thing that makes 1 over 2 for me is the atmosphere. In Galaxy 1, it felt more space-y, but Galaxy 2, it feels like space, but Mario.
My (biased) ranking not thinking objectively 1. Mario Galaxy 2 (nostalgia bias) 2. Mario Odyssey 3. Mario Galaxy 4. Mario 3D World 5. Mario 64 6. Mario Sunshine 7. Mario 3D Land 8. Mario 64 DS 9. Mario 3D All Stars (to some it probably seems dumb to put this last but it’s honestly quite a terrible package and you can imagine how when my favourite is Galaxy 2 you know how I feel 😂)
Only suggestion I have would be to swap sunshine with 3D world. Gameplay alone is not enough to make one game better than another. In my biased opinion, no game in the series has as much personality as sunshine. 3D world was fun as hell, but it really did not have its own identity. Its identity was levels. The gameplay was stellar, but even after playing it to death, I can barely recall anything super memorable. I remember it feeling really good to play and having cat suits. But Sunshine had such a vibrant, believable, atmospheric personality that is unparalleled in the mario universe. Its incredibly compelling personality coupled with its admittedly sometimes questionable level design and frustrating glitches, in my opinion, should boost it above 3D world, but no higher.
My problem with sunshine is that the level design just kinda sucks at times. Which isn't something I would say for any any of the other 3d Mario games. Even beyond stuff like the horrible Pachinko level, most of the other levels don't have anything interesting to them when you look past the visuals. So while 3D world's identity may just be standard, I wouldn't say it's ever bad in the way Sunshine's gameplay can be.
Call the people who grew up playing Super Mario 64 DS like myself, the control seems really aren't that bad, and just because the people who make these videos having grown up with the DS doesn't mean that they're opinions are any more valid. So when they say the controls suck, that's entirely subjective to the consoles that they grow up with
1. Super Mario 64 2. Super Mario Galaxy 3. Super Mario Odyssey 4. Super Mario Sunshine 5. Super Mario Galaxy 2 6. Super Mario Land 7. Super Mario 64 DS 8. Super Mario 3D World I know my list is unique. I adore the top 3 to an extreme. I also find Sunshine underrated.
I value replayabilty a lot with games and mario is one of the best series when it comes to that so I personally am not the biggest odyssey fan. Exploring the kindoms for the first time is really fun and the good controls are movment are nice, but after that, the fun sorta ends for me. Most of the moons feel like getting korok seeds lol so when I went back to 100% it cause of my love for the series I couldn't do it cause of how tedious and repetitve it was. Galaxy the GOAT. Also solid vid, look forward to a 2d/rpg mario ranking
5:06 To be honest, I initially thought the controls would be very awkward. I was able to play it on Nintendo 64 and wow I didnt just think that it's not that bad, I really liked it. I enjoyed this tier list a lot, how about a Pokemon one Next? 🤔
I agree the game is extremely hard controls are absolutely horrible the graphics suck and no stages outside of Jolly Roger Bay Bomb om Battlefield and Whomp's Fortress are memorable
I just realized 3D all stars is probably my favorite game of all time since im not a person to whine about everything and just enjoy the games for what they are
Because everyone knows that Super Mario 64 definitely isn't dated in any way and is even better than both Galaxy games combined. IT'S SUBJECTIVE!!!!1!!1 Seriously though, while obviously there are subjective comparisons for many different things, there is no way on earth that I'm going to slide with "it's subjective, so it's okay" when someone says that Donkey Kong arcade is better than Undertale. Not everything is subjective.
It was surprising seeing Mario 64 at the bottom of the list, but after listening to what he said, I can actually agree with that. A combination of the controls and glitches and the movement being extremely awkward, I can definitely see why he put it at last. Also the fact that it was ran on such an old console doesn’t help either.
Mario Galaxy 2 must be A tier . Its like one of the best mario game ever created . Not due to nastalgia but due to the following mechanics of mario galaxy 1 but added with new ones at the same time .
@@PiggyMccool_XD Yeah, odyssey is a great game as well. And maybe its just the nostalgia why I prefer galaxies, but the movement and the whole atmosphere are on another level. Even though i have all 999 power moons on odyssey I never really warmed to that capture mechanic, like its okay but too radical imo, power ups was better, or maybe im just too conservative :D
Odyssey is good, but not THAT good, I personally don't like the movement as much as galaxies movement, and the "open world" gameplay doesn't fit to mario games that well. Its great game, but galaxies will forever be better imo, and I can only imagine what would galaxy 3 look like, if they would do it on nowdays... (I've completed and even speedrunned galaxies many many times but I have all 999 power moons on odyssey as well)
My ranking on the 3D Mario games I've played: 1. Super Mario Galaxy 1 2. Super Mario 3D World 3. Super Mario Odyssey 4. Super Mario Galaxy 2 5. Bowser's Fury
I swear with more than 64 DS I've heard mixed results on the controls I've heard some people say they're terrible and I've heard other people say they're not that bad
9. 64 (duh) it is the worst mario game ever 8. 3D land ok but not great 7. 64 DS better than the original 6. Galaxy 2 pretty good but a significant downgrade from the original 5. Sunshine glitchy? Check. fun? Check. unique? Check. 4. 3D world a perfect blend of 2d and 3d 3. Bowser's fury an open world Mario game with a great engine and surprisingly smooth gameplay along with a great story with a cool concept 2. odyssey great movement characters and story and also very unique with plenty of content and challenge 1. Galaxy it. Is. So. Good. The best game ever created smooth gameplay a crazy good story best music of any video game and not to mention the absolutely phenomenal bosses the whole game and s creative and fun and is impossible to put below 1st place. This whole list has no nostalgia bias whatsoever as I never played any before the switch era so this is my list but it is probably more opinions to put on my seemingly infinitely long list of controversial opinions
hey i’m curious, do you prefer the movement speed in 3D world or 3D World+Bowser’s Fury? if you go back and play it on Wii U, it’s a lot slower but honestly I feel like they slightly over corrected on Switch, the game feels too fast sometimes
@@JacobCruise oh yeah another thing about the different movement is that the cat jump dive trick on Wii U is basically just running speed on Switch making it practically irrelevant which honestly is good for casual/semi-casual multiplayer because one person doesn’t just speed away from everyone else also since it’s irrelevant it makes the game less punishing and feel like it has a lot more power up diversity too because you aren’t locked into one suit if you want to go at a quicker pace
I have never watched a video from your channel, yet somehow i got it recommended in less than half an hour of you uploading it. Also btw this video was great.
very good and unbiased tierlist! I wish we could get a version of 64 ds that improves upon the controls and graphics because i think that it's the best way to play mario 64 and i want more people experience it
If you have a pc, I just played the Render 96 mod and it’s the best version ever imo. Makes a game I’ve beat several times feel new and enjoyed it more than ever after unlocking some bonus characters I’ll leave unnamed
I might get flamed for this but, I personally think Galaxy is low A tier, I don’t know what it is but I didn’t really enjoy it, especially since to 100% it you had to play it a second time as Luigi which is why its the only Mario game I've never played more than once
@JacobCruise sorry I wrote that at like 4 am, allow me to elaborateI typically complete Mario games all the way and to complete Galaxy I had to play through a game I already didn't really enjoy a second time
64 ds it’s the definitive way to play mario 64. More levels, more characters, better graphics, mini games, Improved camera, Everyone just seems to think hand held games are below console ones. it’s a slept on game that’s a lot better than the og 64. It controls fine too I’ve had no issue ever playing it.
Just a quick statement on why I’m ok with the not so changed remakes of 3d all stars, it’s because of hardware limitations. I really don’t think that if they were all remade for the switch it wouldn’t be in a collection but rather be individual remakes. The switch isn’t powerful enough like the ps5 and the new xbox, so I believe it was powerful enough, the games for 3d all stars can actually be remakes
1. Super Mario Odyssey 2. Super Mario 64 3. Super Mario Galaxy 4. Super Mario Galaxy 2 5. Super Mario Sunshine 6. Super Mario 64 DS 7. Super Mario 3D World + Bowser's Fury 8. Super Mario 3D Land I won't count 3D All Stars because there's nothing different about it aside from a couple graphical enhancements and people are having outrage over absolutely nothing.
@@Tod_erwartet then don't be annoying. Nostalgia shouldn't be a factor for why the game is better. 64 is "revolutionary" when it first came out, but compared to Galaxy, 3D World and Odyssey, it's just suck.
I feel like perhaps you didn’t play Sunshine much? I think Sunshine makes A tier and is better than 3D World. Without nostalgia, I can see why you put Galaxy ahead of it. I just think you’ve heavily underrated Sunshine. Sunshine is pretty much the first 3D Mario game to really give Super Mario it’s modern lore. Bowser Jr. Pianta and Noki residents. Perfected beach/resort theme. Petey Piranha. Shadow Mario. Mecha Bowser. Peach’s plane. Toadsworth. The main-stream multi-colored Toads. 3D Yoshi. Fludd. Cataquacks. Giant Wiggler. Gooper Blooper. All of these iconic characters/items originated in Sunshine. I think Sunshine might even be the most iconic 3D Mario game ever (Peach’s castle, Whomps, Klepto, and King Bob-omb are the only iconic characters/things I can think of who originated in 64). What it did, it did right. But the glitches and lack of polish are a bit much. 😭😭😭
bro… sunshine was my most played Mario game between the ages of 4-10. before making this video I had played tons of it too. The lore, atmosphere, and music is all amazing. Unfortunately it’s not fun to play for me anymore. I’m sorry bro!
@@JacobCruise oh bet! Link to video? I’ll give it a watch! I’m a Nintendo fan but also a game designer. So I’m genuinely surprised someone who played it as much as you said ranked it so low. As a game designer, I’d love to hear what you loved/hated more in depth. Helps me make better decisions as a dev. :)
Honestly as much as I LOVE regular Mario, the RPGs are some of the greatest games I've ever played. They have incredible stories, engaging action-twisted rpg battles, fun characters, and loveable (not just Bowser!) Villans that makes Mario's world feel more like a living, breathing place than the main games could ever hope to portray.
Even if super mario oddysey isant an open world game id call it close enough tbh i do still want one tho cause i think id be amazing if you could play as the core mario caracters and just explore the mushroom kingdom as them as well as the surrounding areas like bowsers kingdom and just other one off locations like the bean kingdom from the mario and luigi series or recuring plases like the sesert snow or ocean areas
odyssey is only A tier for me. its quite boring if im being 100% honest, the moons feel about as satisfying to get as a coin since theyre just sitting there most of the time, and the level design isnt engaging enough to make me want to explore much past the main path. the gameplay loop gets old rather quickly
![[Full Episode] The Restaurant War Thailand ศึกพ่อค้าซ่าแม่ค้าแซ่บ Episode 1 | 22 ก.ย. 67](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/BuzQ70v-UZQ/mqdefault.jpg)
9:Mario 64 DS, haven’t played this one so I can’t say much.
8:Mario 64: Very important game and fun to pick up, but the camera and a lot of stupid stars put it low for me.
7: Bowser’s Fury: I love what it brings to the table, but it’s too short to put it above the others in my opinion
6: 3D Land: I might be a little bias, but I love this one. Really fun to play on the go. But it’s a bit too bland to put above the others.
5: Sunshine: While it certainly has it’s issues, I just love how different and unique it is.
4: 3D World: This is 3D Land times 10. Graphics, Characters, and level design create an excellent game.
3: Odyssey: This one is pretty much perfect, I just prefer the galaxy games.
2: Galaxy 2: This and Galaxy 1 are pretty much interchangeable, I just prefer Galaxy 1. The level design, bosses, and music are all perfect.
1: Galaxy: This game has all that makes Galaxy 2 perfect, but the added bit of story makes this a bit better in my opinion
W list
I agree with this list!
Galaxy 2 is EASILY the best Mario game. The others dont even come close.
Some people don't like linear level design overpowered power ups easy stages and a weaker atmosphere than the other galaxy game
@@HugeRMCFanBoY-bx3od Ever since the beginning, Mario has been regarded as one of gamings best franchises. Why do you think that is? Traditionally, what have Mario games done better than others?
Super mario galaxy is the best video game I have ever played. Not only is it nostalgia, but every aspect of the game is amazing. The storyline, uniqeness, gameplay, game design, mechanics, everything. I am a 16 year old game developer and gamer, and I have never seen something just like this. When I make more advanced games, I def want to make games like these. Super mario galaxy is part of my childhood. Amazing
My list of all 3d Mario games (not including bowsers fury and sunshine since I haven’t played it)
7: Super Mario 64 ds
6: Super Mario 3d land
5: Super Mario 3d World
4: Super Mario odyssey
3: Super Mario 64
2: Super Mario Galaxy 2
1: Super Mario Galaxy
Explanation
Super 64 ds has terrible controls. Super Mario 3d land is a very underrated game but it’s up against so many masterpieces that it can’t compete with. 3d world is like a combination of new super Mario bros wii and super Mario 3d land and it is great. I love the chaos that ensues all because of that damn crown. Super Mario odyssey is next and it’s practically just as good as 64. This game has the best movement in the series but it lacks great missions with it focusing more on quantity over quality. It also is too easy. The movement is so good that these negatives hardly matter. Super Mario 64 is a great game. I played this for the first time recently and it was so good. I loved most of the missions in the game (except 100 coins) and the movement was very fun. Super Mario galaxy 2 can be swapped with galaxy depending on what you prefer. Galaxy 2 has better gameplay but it sacrifices the great atmosphere and story from the original. Galaxy 1 is the best due to it being the only Mario game to actually focus on the atmosphere and story and it delivers. It has the most memorable areas in the series. It also has one of the best soundtracks not just in Mario history, not just in Nintendo history but in all of video games. Absolute masterpiece of a game that everyone needs to experience.
w list
Galaxy 2 is my most favorite largely due to nostalgia. I had a friend that owned Galaxy 1 so I got 2 and I have a lot of memories from it.
Galaxy 2 is Mid S tier. Galaxy is High S tier.
@@thesupervideogamenerdmore3171 I played Galaxy 2 first and then Galaxy 1 later. Galaxy 1 kinda felt like a downgrade. The only thing better about Galaxy 1 is the story elements. Galaxy 2 has more exciting and diverse gameplay with Yoshi, better level design and powerups. It also has better visuals.
@@Droobie03 The only thing that makes 1 over 2 for me is the atmosphere. In Galaxy 1, it felt more space-y, but Galaxy 2, it feels like space, but Mario.
1- Galaxy 2
2- Odyssey
3- Galaxy
4- 3D World (WiiU)
5- 64
6- 3D Land
-
-
-
-
-
-
53819- Sunshine (sorry not sorry)
LOL
K but you wrong tho
My (biased) ranking not thinking objectively
1. Mario Galaxy 2 (nostalgia bias)
2. Mario Odyssey
3. Mario Galaxy
4. Mario 3D World
5. Mario 64
6. Mario Sunshine
7. Mario 3D Land
8. Mario 64 DS
9. Mario 3D All Stars (to some it probably seems dumb to put this last but it’s honestly quite a terrible package and you can imagine how when my favourite is Galaxy 2 you know how I feel 😂)
8. 3D Land
7. Sunshine
6. Mario 64
5. Mario 64 DS
4. 3D World + Bowsers Fury
3. Mario Galaxy 2
2. Mario Odyssey
1. Mario Galaxy
Only suggestion I have would be to swap sunshine with 3D world. Gameplay alone is not enough to make one game better than another. In my biased opinion, no game in the series has as much personality as sunshine. 3D world was fun as hell, but it really did not have its own identity. Its identity was levels. The gameplay was stellar, but even after playing it to death, I can barely recall anything super memorable. I remember it feeling really good to play and having cat suits. But Sunshine had such a vibrant, believable, atmospheric personality that is unparalleled in the mario universe. Its incredibly compelling personality coupled with its admittedly sometimes questionable level design and frustrating glitches, in my opinion, should boost it above 3D world, but no higher.
i kind of agree with you tbh
My problem with sunshine is that the level design just kinda sucks at times. Which isn't something I would say for any any of the other 3d Mario games. Even beyond stuff like the horrible Pachinko level, most of the other levels don't have anything interesting to them when you look past the visuals. So while 3D world's identity may just be standard, I wouldn't say it's ever bad in the way Sunshine's gameplay can be.
Call the people who grew up playing Super Mario 64 DS like myself, the control seems really aren't that bad, and just because the people who make these videos having grown up with the DS doesn't mean that they're opinions are any more valid. So when they say the controls suck, that's entirely subjective to the consoles that they grow up with
1. Super Mario 64
2. Super Mario Galaxy
3. Super Mario Odyssey
4. Super Mario Sunshine
5. Super Mario Galaxy 2
6. Super Mario Land
7. Super Mario 64 DS
8. Super Mario 3D World
I know my list is unique. I adore the top 3 to an extreme. I also find Sunshine underrated.
My current Ranking:
1.) Galaxy
2.) 64/64 DS
3.) Galaxy 2
4.) Sunshine
5.) 3D World
6.) Odyssey
7.) 3D Land
I value replayabilty a lot with games and mario is one of the best series when it comes to that so I personally am not the biggest odyssey fan. Exploring the kindoms for the first time is really fun and the good controls are movment are nice, but after that, the fun sorta ends for me. Most of the moons feel like getting korok seeds lol so when I went back to 100% it cause of my love for the series I couldn't do it cause of how tedious and repetitve it was. Galaxy the GOAT. Also solid vid, look forward to a 2d/rpg mario ranking
My RPG Mario ranking already exists !
I agree
5:06 To be honest, I initially thought the controls would be very awkward. I was able to play it on Nintendo 64 and wow I didnt just think that it's not that bad, I really liked it. I enjoyed this tier list a lot, how about a Pokemon one Next? 🤔
i believe I’m scheduled for one In January 😉
mario 64 was ok, but not the masterpiece that people make it out to be
I personally think it’s a masterpiece saying it’s “ok” is crazy
I agree the game is extremely hard controls are absolutely horrible the graphics suck and no stages outside of Jolly Roger Bay Bomb om Battlefield and Whomp's Fortress are memorable
Super Mario Sunshine will always hold a special place in my heart 🌞
Well it’s fun other than those glitchy, hard or straight up shitty levels you have to do to progress
Sunshine is the GOAT. Best settings, music, characters and atmosphere
@@remitto8367goat is cap 90% of Mario games are better than that shit
Your opinion becomes irrelevant if you use the word "cap"
@@remitto8367ight whatever you say lmao
I just realized 3D all stars is probably my favorite game of all time since im not a person to whine about everything and just enjoy the games for what they are
w mentality
You can't review/rank objectively everything is subjective
yes but no
Everybody knows that all of my opinions are objectively correct. However, who “my” is seems to be subjective.
@@JacobCruise explain
Because everyone knows that Super Mario 64 definitely isn't dated in any way and is even better than both Galaxy games combined.
IT'S SUBJECTIVE!!!!1!!1
Seriously though, while obviously there are subjective comparisons for many different things, there is no way on earth that I'm going to slide with "it's subjective, so it's okay" when someone says that Donkey Kong arcade is better than Undertale. Not everything is subjective.
@coltonk.3086 bro what 💀
It was surprising seeing Mario 64 at the bottom of the list, but after listening to what he said, I can actually agree with that. A combination of the controls and glitches and the movement being extremely awkward, I can definitely see why he put it at last. Also the fact that it was ran on such an old console doesn’t help either.
Ok!
Mario Galaxy 2 must be A tier . Its like one of the best mario game ever created . Not due to nastalgia but due to the following mechanics of mario galaxy 1 but added with new ones at the same time .
💀
🗿
Mario Odyssey is the game that brought me to the mario franchise
Definitely the best mario game
Galaxies>
@@aapopaunonen8404 Say what you want, I prefer Odyssey
These are opinions after all
@@PiggyMccool_XD Yeah, odyssey is a great game as well. And maybe its just the nostalgia why I prefer galaxies, but the movement and the whole atmosphere are on another level. Even though i have all 999 power moons on odyssey I never really warmed to that capture mechanic, like its okay but too radical imo, power ups was better, or maybe im just too conservative :D
@@PiggyMccool_XD And yeah, these are opinions, and every Mario player is already a friend in general
Omg same here
Odyssey is good, but not THAT good, I personally don't like the movement as much as galaxies movement, and the "open world" gameplay doesn't fit to mario games that well. Its great game, but galaxies will forever be better imo, and I can only imagine what would galaxy 3 look like, if they would do it on nowdays... (I've completed and even speedrunned galaxies many many times but I have all 999 power moons on odyssey as well)
My ranking on the 3D Mario games I've played:
1. Super Mario Galaxy 1
2. Super Mario 3D World
3. Super Mario Odyssey
4. Super Mario Galaxy 2
5. Bowser's Fury
You can use a joystick for mario 64 ds on 3ds
I swear with more than 64 DS I've heard mixed results on the controls I've heard some people say they're terrible and I've heard other people say they're not that bad
My Rankings
1 Galaxy
2 Odyssey
3 Sunshine
4 Galaxy 2
5 3D World
6 3D Land
7 64 (I just really hate the graphics and controls)
I will admit sunshine is extremely hard somehow even moreso than 64
w list
64 > Odyssey
9. 64 (duh) it is the worst mario game ever
8. 3D land ok but not great
7. 64 DS better than the original
6. Galaxy 2 pretty good but a significant downgrade from the original
5. Sunshine glitchy? Check. fun? Check. unique? Check.
4. 3D world a perfect blend of 2d and 3d
3. Bowser's fury an open world Mario game with a great engine and surprisingly smooth gameplay along with a great story with a cool concept
2. odyssey great movement characters and story and also very unique with plenty of content and challenge
1. Galaxy it. Is. So. Good. The best game ever created smooth gameplay a crazy good story best music of any video game and not to mention the absolutely phenomenal bosses the whole game and s creative and fun and is impossible to put below 1st place.
This whole list has no nostalgia bias whatsoever as I never played any before the switch era so this is my list but it is probably more opinions to put on my seemingly infinitely long list of controversial opinions
This is a list of
Skill issue for 64
hey i’m curious, do you prefer the movement speed in 3D world or 3D World+Bowser’s Fury? if you go back and play it on Wii U, it’s a lot slower but honestly I feel like they slightly over corrected on Switch, the game feels too fast sometimes
I genuinely don’t remember, I’d have to check
@@JacobCruise oh yeah another thing about the different movement is that the cat jump dive trick on Wii U is basically just running speed on Switch making it practically irrelevant which honestly is good for casual/semi-casual multiplayer because one person doesn’t just speed away from everyone else
also since it’s irrelevant it makes the game less punishing and feel like it has a lot more power up diversity too because you aren’t locked into one suit if you want to go at a quicker pace
They should have analog control for the speed to compensate the 20% faster top speed
LOVED This Video!! You should rank the 2D Mario Games next!!
Yeah!
I have never watched a video from your channel, yet somehow i got it recommended in less than half an hour of you uploading it. Also btw this video was great.
Thanks!
S- Mario 64, Mario 3d World A- 3d land B- Mario sunshine C- Mario 64 ds
very good and unbiased tierlist! I wish we could get a version of 64 ds that improves upon the controls and graphics because i think that it's the best way to play mario 64 and i want more people experience it
Yes!
If you have a pc, I just played the Render 96 mod and it’s the best version ever imo. Makes a game I’ve beat several times feel new and enjoyed it more than ever after unlocking some bonus characters I’ll leave unnamed
Nobody:
Me: *here to make sure Sunshine isn’t last, and if it is, reporting channel for false/misleading information*
nahh its DEFINITELY not the worst game
I might get flamed for this but, I personally think Galaxy is low A tier, I don’t know what it is but I didn’t really enjoy it, especially since to 100% it you had to play it a second time as Luigi which is why its the only Mario game I've never played more than once
That Luigi point doesn’t really make any sense, but I mean you can’t really control if you don’t enjoy it so that’s fine
@JacobCruise sorry I wrote that at like 4 am, allow me to elaborateI typically complete Mario games all the way and to complete Galaxy I had to play through a game I already didn't really enjoy a second time
@@crsntmoon744 ohh gotcha
64 ds it’s the definitive way to play mario 64. More levels, more characters, better graphics, mini games, Improved camera, Everyone just seems to think hand held games are below console ones. it’s a slept on game that’s a lot better than the og 64. It controls fine too I’ve had no issue ever playing it.
Fair
The controls are shit 64 is way better than
@@MadPaperMario not even close
@@EpicCamraManit’s true most people would prefer ds if it had good controls
Just found you channel, and all I can say is how do you not have more subscribers. Well, at least you gained one more.
W
Just a quick statement on why I’m ok with the not so changed remakes of 3d all stars, it’s because of hardware limitations. I really don’t think that if they were all remade for the switch it wouldn’t be in a collection but rather be individual remakes. The switch isn’t powerful enough like the ps5 and the new xbox, so I believe it was powerful enough, the games for 3d all stars can actually be remakes
this is true
I think Mario 3D world is a sequel to Mario 3D land
like...this video is better than the others,why is he not famous yet?
:)
1. Super Mario Odyssey
2. Super Mario 64
3. Super Mario Galaxy
4. Super Mario Galaxy 2
5. Super Mario Sunshine
6. Super Mario 64 DS
7. Super Mario 3D World + Bowser's Fury
8. Super Mario 3D Land
I won't count 3D All Stars because there's nothing different about it aside from a couple graphical enhancements and people are having outrage over absolutely nothing.
I know everyone has their own opinions but I personally think 64 is overrated AS HELL. How tf is it better than Galaxy?
@@anordinaryuser5818 1 word. Nostalgia.
@@Tod_erwartet if you're not a prick then you must know that nostalgia doesn't make a game any better.
@@anordinaryuser5818 dude you don’t have be fucking rude like that
@@Tod_erwartet then don't be annoying. Nostalgia shouldn't be a factor for why the game is better. 64 is "revolutionary" when it first came out, but compared to Galaxy, 3D World and Odyssey, it's just suck.
Only played 64, my family had Nintendo 64 when i was 6
AYEE YOU DID MY IDEA TTHANKS BRO
i saw it 😉
pls make a ranking of all 3 luigis mansion games
i need to play 3
I feel like perhaps you didn’t play Sunshine much? I think Sunshine makes A tier and is better than 3D World. Without nostalgia, I can see why you put Galaxy ahead of it.
I just think you’ve heavily underrated Sunshine. Sunshine is pretty much the first 3D Mario game to really give Super Mario it’s modern lore. Bowser Jr. Pianta and Noki residents. Perfected beach/resort theme. Petey Piranha. Shadow Mario. Mecha Bowser. Peach’s plane. Toadsworth. The main-stream multi-colored Toads. 3D Yoshi. Fludd. Cataquacks. Giant Wiggler. Gooper Blooper. All of these iconic characters/items originated in Sunshine. I think Sunshine might even be the most iconic 3D Mario game ever (Peach’s castle, Whomps, Klepto, and King Bob-omb are the only iconic characters/things I can think of who originated in 64).
What it did, it did right. But the glitches and lack of polish are a bit much. 😭😭😭
bro… sunshine was my most played Mario game between the ages of 4-10. before making this video I had played tons of it too.
The lore, atmosphere, and music is all amazing. Unfortunately it’s not fun to play for me anymore. I’m sorry bro!
I suggest you watch my full video on sunshine, I speak more in depth there.
@@JacobCruise oh bet! Link to video? I’ll give it a watch! I’m a Nintendo fan but also a game designer. So I’m genuinely surprised someone who played it as much as you said ranked it so low. As a game designer, I’d love to hear what you loved/hated more in depth. Helps me make better decisions as a dev. :)
@@Itsuchi2 th-cam.com/video/YThOyFsf9UQ/w-d-xo.html
1:13
i used the 3DS with this game
Even though it’s the hardest one, Super Mario Sunshine is the best for me!
i respect it 🗽
if you had to pick 1 side what side would it be all the mario rpgs or all the 3d mario games
damn man idk that’s a tough one
Honestly as much as I LOVE regular Mario, the RPGs are some of the greatest games I've ever played. They have incredible stories, engaging action-twisted rpg battles, fun characters, and loveable (not just Bowser!) Villans that makes Mario's world feel more like a living, breathing place than the main games could ever hope to portray.
dope ranking :)
Geeat video and an excellent critical review of all the 3D Mario games! 👏👏
Thank you!
mario odyssey should be C tier
Smoking
@@JacobCruise what
I WAS HEEREEEE
yes
W list
Agree on sunshine, but galaxy is too linear
Does linear = bad though ?
@@JacobCruise not necessarily, no. But it takes away the charm from 3d marios
@@ndre90 Gotcha
i prefer galigy 1 than 2 and i playd 2 ferst
galigy
W List
Thankz
Mario jump less run 😅
Fire
Even if super mario oddysey isant an open world game id call it close enough tbh i do still want one tho cause i think id be amazing if you could play as the core mario caracters and just explore the mushroom kingdom as them as well as the surrounding areas like bowsers kingdom and just other one off locations like the bean kingdom from the mario and luigi series or recuring plases like the sesert snow or ocean areas
Rosalinas storybook puts Galaxy 1 at the top of the list
W.
odyssey is only A tier for me. its quite boring if im being 100% honest, the moons feel about as satisfying to get as a coin since theyre just sitting there most of the time, and the level design isnt engaging enough to make me want to explore much past the main path. the gameplay loop gets old rather quickly
it feels good to be here this early hahaha
welcome