It would seem that Federal has "figured it out" with their defensive ammunition. They now offer many choices at various price points, and all perform at least adequately. Bravo to the folks at Federal. And thanks to Tools&Targets for doing these videos, where the proof is in the pudding, er, I mean the proof is in the jelly.
The terminal performance of the 40 is superior to the 9mm. No debate about that. However, it is interesting that the 9mm gave almost equal penetration. So, if the shooter could get more shots down range with the 9mm (due to the lighter recoil) it might be argued that greater terminal performance could be achieved by the 9mm since more shots would hit the objective. But, for just one single shot the 40 is obviously superior. I own some 9's and a couple of 10's, but no 40's. I need to buy a G23. I am sure I would love the 40 if I gave it more of a chance. GREAT test.
@@RT-gv6us Well that just depends on your shooting abilities.. Some of us can control recoil and shoot 40 just as well as 9mm. Enough to put rounds center mass. The difference in recoil isn't that substantial
@@mdubb4855 I own a G29. I have not tried 40 in it yet, but I have hand loaded some 10mm 155g XTPs at minimum pressures which I think would be very similar to the 40. It was very shootable.
@@RT-gv6us agreed. Two light loads I’ve found: 40mm Syntech 205gr IPSCC is just 329ft-lbs rated out of unknown barrel length, very light for 40 and very clean. 10mm: 431 ft-lbs tested 3.8” Ammo Inc 180gr hollow; 180gr JHP TEB Ammo Inc is 1020fps out of 3.8" Glock G29 for 416 ft-lbs (different reporters). This is very light for 10mm which usually runs 475-550 (not counting the big game loads). It’s kinda scary to a beginner like me. I first shot 40 out of a Shield gen 1 and it was manageable in that IPSCC Syntech but stout compared to a Shield in 9. I asked my instructor to shoot one round of the relatively low energy Ammo Inc 10mm for that training session so I could observe, and decided I would start with 40 in the G29 instead, work my way up to a more standard load like the Punch, then return to 10 and see how farm I can make it up the hierarchy beginning with target and ending with HST. This video reminds me why I have a couple of 40 options even though it is stouter than I like: it hits hard! My next baby project gun is a G27 plus Sig 357 conversion barrel, if I get brave enough. I tried similarly loaded 357 out of a revolver and didn’t like it at all, but maybe the Sig in an auto will tame some recoil. If you get around to loading some 40 in a G29 please share your experience. I think the G29 fat baby Glock falls into a really sweet spot for size.
The FBI and police can claim all they want that 9mm is now equal to 40 and 45, but it’s just not true. They claim that bullet advances have made them equal, but the 40 and 45 have also gotten those same advances.
9mm is a better caliber for the police. Officers come in all sizes, strengths, male or female. They need to be able to control the recoil and put follow up shots on target. 9mm is a goldilocks pistol caliber.
@@jake4194 every single one of you clowns say the same thing about 9mm and follow up shots. It's not impossible to mitigate recoil on 40 cal. You have to be WEAK to not be able to handle it.
@@Ranchpup33 cool they can shoot 9mm like every other small dude and female out there. But guess what. Government didn't switch to 9mm because it's better. They switched because budget cuts. There's plenty of bigger officers out there that are strong and can handle recoil of 40. but they're forced to use 9mm now
I carry 40 primarily and have for nearly 30 years. I will be rotating out of my 165 Gold Dots to the 165 HST at the first of the year. I made a great trade at a gun show for a couple hundred of these. And the run fine and perform great.
Yeah, that was pretty cool. High framerate shows all kinds of crazy stuff. One of these days when I strike it rich, I'll get one of those multi thousand dollar cams that can show a fly flapping it's wings.
@@robwilson3749Sorry? Oh, are you one of those kids that believe the FBI and all the interwebnet silly boys that have been brainwashed into believing 9mm. is AWSOME!!!
Thanks for the great test. Both rounds did really well. Keep the 40 S&W tests coming. It's a good cartridge and deserves the attention. Its additional ft/lbs and momentum over the 9mm is noticeably.
Just started watching, just gotta say brother. I'm in central Texas (San Antonio) I feel ya on the blisterin heat! Thanks for the video! To all that don't know, this southern heat w/humidity can turn a range day miserable!
@@trentvlak Punch is considerably cheaper than the HST's. They are darn near the same projectile design. HST's fantastic and superior but that Punch 9mm is beastly for $13.xx a box.
The Punch turned out to be a really good performer in every caliber I have seen so far. The 45 acp version does really well despite it being heavy and slow.
They tried the 40 S&W but then the agencies dropped it in favor of the 9 mm with improved bullets. Less recoil and blast and less wear and tear in the guns, lower cost, and better qualification scores. Some people may scoff and say the agencies are hiring too many wimps so they had to drop the 40 S&W but the bottom line is that the 9 mm seems to work out best for the agencies.
Nice!! Great performance from both. I was a little worried with the lower velocities but they proved me wrong. Both would be a devastating wound for sure. I like the head to head from time to time. Awesome stuff as always my friend 👍🇺🇸🇺🇸
2 successes. I would like to see a bit more velocity from both but I am not complaining with these great results. Many thanks for the good demonstration & data.
Good Videos as always. I am glad you are able to provide good comparisons between 9mm vs 40 S&W. I've been torn deciding which caliber to conceal carry, ammo tests keep indicating the 40ty is the "problem solver". Now gotta find the right tool to carry.
We really appreciate the updates on rounds you ran without the clothing barrier the first time around, and especially appreciate you running the short barrels! Put'em through the ringer.
Nice one tools!!! I just purchased my first full size 9mm pistol Glock 17 wiff 4.5” barrel it really gets those hot +P loads justa movin down range…I can’t wait to see you test those DoubleTap 147 Grain +P Bonded Defense to show these .40 lovers what a Real 9mm can do when loaded the RIGHT WAY like they used to back in the day💯
the 40 is ok'ish, I don't like the low velocity of the 9mm though. Sure it penetrates the gel, but one rib and that thing is stopping or deflecting. But, that's just me and my Love Affair with HST. rofl. I found a box of winchester SXT last weekend in storage. It was the round they came out with when they stopped selling the Black Talon. Nearly the same round, points aren't quite as pronounced but they were blowing gallon jugs up like they were made of baggies. Maybe I'll send you some to test.
I don't know if you know any ER Doctors, but they are the one you should interview regarding internal Damage. I know what they are going to say, but your views may find it interesting should you locate one to go on camera.
I carry no less than a .40 cal with 165 gr. Ranger "T" or Gold Dots. But my perfered sidearm calibers were the 10mm or the .45 ACP. I like the leverage on the streets Lone Bear!
If on sale I would pick up that 9mm all day. Both even that 40 with the huge cloth catching maw of a hollow point didn't even care about the clothing. Both were exceptional.
I'll stick with my .40S&W for daily carry and backup to a 12ga pump for home defense. The only use I still have for my 9 Minimal pistol is range time as the ammo is cheaper and more plentiful and I can't tell the difference in recoil or muzzle blast between the two.
I carry a G45 for my EDC and I love it but I've been wanting to build a G23X for a while. I like 9mm and I think it's a great choice for self defense but I've always believed .40 S&W is superior to 9mm
A really food representation of how far good bullet technology has pushed the 9mm to perform similarly to 40 and 45. Maybe not quite as much temporary stretch cavity since it has less energy, but a bigger final diameter. Energy in of itself doesn't kill anything when it comes to pistol bullets at pistol velocitys. Once you get into rifle velocity's 2000+ fps the temporary stretch cavity does actually add to the wounding of flesh though. Pistol bullets poke holes in things, find a caliber you can accurately poke holes with that will penetrate deep enough and expand reliably and PRACTICE PRACTICE PRACTICE!
@@randallflores-qr8cs Finding 380 that penetrates deeply enough and expands reliably isn't easy. Most people use fmj's which don't create any wounding at all like hollow points do. 9mm is readily available, low recoil, and has many very good options for self defense.
Both are backup calibers. Fight me. Carry a SP-01 with a extension and 23+1 with a G27 backup ankle gun. Carry a Sig 229 in 40s&w and a PF9 backup ankle gun. I would be fine with either. I only am 9mm currently for handloading purposes, but get asked to make .40 by family leading me to wanting to play the .40 game even though it does nothing for me pleasurably as a shooter. Just how it is.
I use the .45 Punch for my EDC. My wife uses the 9mm Punch for her EDC. This just confirms my decision. I still wish you would do a carbine test on the 9MM Punch
Recently, my big box store prices on these nearly match the HSTs. But I picked up some of these in 45 a couple years ago. So happy to see good results on this test. Thanks Tools.
Good one Mr. Tools, I got a few boxes of the 9mm on sale earlier in the year, not my primary but awesome for a backup plan when the gold dots and HST’s run dry. I’m impressed with the 40, I’m a gold dot guy for 40 all day but that’s a good demonstration for penetration.
I love my 40, but I've got some 9MMs for just in case use, because they have much more ammo availability. I would do 40 all day long though, as my preferred round. Mr. Tools&Targets has really got me wanting to try out 10MM with Buffalo Bore. That's the biggest pistol caliber needed, I'd say.
I'd carry either one with confidence. I have some of the 9mm, got'em when I couldn't find HSTs. They ride the bench now, playing second string to the HST and Elite Defender. My go-to in 40 is HST and Ranger. Another excellent test!!
Judging by the comments I’ve read your “fistfight” title is genius, I don’t own a 40 myself I prefer 9mm but what I can say is one shot center mass from both of these rounds would to the job.
If you can handle the 40 and accept a couple less rounds, it is a very good defense round. I carried one for many years. But as my friends aged they began having more trouble. More recently, I noticed my split times significantly increased with the 40 vs 9mm so I too have changed. Although the 40 has more energy, the 9 does very well and the impact on the bad guy has generally not shown much difference in effectiveness. So you cannot go wrong either way. Thanks Federal!!!
Physics dictates that during expansion as the petal are perpendicular to the C/L of the bullet the 40 will have a greater momentary diameter, thus creating a larger wound cavity until the petals fold back against the bullet. Once again, another great video. .40 S&W rules.
Using the shortest barrels does make the most sense. My worry with not testing in longer barrels is if the bullet gets too much velocity from the longer barrel it won't penetrate properly bc of too much expansion. If the hollow expands out of a short barrel and the penetration is at least 15inches I would trust it to penetrate fine out of a longer barrel
Both of these rounds penetrate adequately through longer barrels. Through my Beretta92FS I got around 15" & my Glock22 16.50" both same Federal punch rounds.
What’s really weird., I’ve been seeing boat loads of .40 law enforcement trade ins on the market lately in particular G22s I mean if you want a .40s&w man you can find some deals when it comes to G22 LE trade ins,,, I think PSA was just selling them for 299 the other day .I also see G23 sprinkled in .. of course you also see a lot of G17 but some of those must be upgrades because a lot of them are like Gen3
I carry 9 and 40 depending on where im going and what im wearing. Hornady critical defense in both. Glock 23 and ruger ec9s. Sometimes I can't get away with a double stack. I also believe in having firearms in more than one caliber in part because of COVID. Had all the 40 in the world to choose from.
Both rounds performed nicely. Have some 9mm Punch to back up my HST’s, haven’t tried any 40’s yet. Carry 9’s mainly because that’s what our dept issues. Was disappointed when we switched from 40’s to 9’s, due to current trends. No doubt the 40 hits harder. Thanks for the jelly test Tools!
I've been at this testing expansion many,many years. the bigger the expansion and most retaining weights is the perfect combination for any given calibers. this 40 and 9mm test are perfect performance. I trust this testing so much I wouldn't hesitate to deer hunt with either one which is legal here in north carolina during deer rifle season. because of my disabilities I considering this deer season pistol/ revolver hunting only during rifle season. what better way to test your self defense ammunition than live deer. gained experience and groceries from the field ,that's win,win. if this is not the best test video I have seen it would run a very high second place.lol. as always, papa wishing you well. 😊
40 S&W FTW ... again ... 💪😃👍 The test definitely shows how modern bullet designs and lead alloys have improved the 9mm. I'll continue standing by the 40S&W ... just superior performance even in short barrels.
Nice revisit test I had no doubt they would perform and no doubt the 40 is superior I still don't understand the 40 s&w haters other than price I prefer them
I wonder if the projectiles were a bit out of spec, both were overweight after expansion so I would assume they were heavier before expansion too. Might contribute to the lower velocities.
Thanks for another great review! Can you do some Herters 9mm 115grain from bass pro, just the basic range ammo they put out or the Herters 380 flat nose ammo? These are always easy for me to pick up and I wonder how they compare to others.
Another great test! I think if federal dropped the premium tag and nickle plated case from the punch lineup they should also drop the price. Federal is on my shit list lately. Been testing some new hunting loads because the partitions I usually use are so hard to find. Federal even in their premium hunting rounds never come close to listed velocities. If it was just a little bit I’d understand but I’m talking about 100s of fps and im constantly seeing it from everything they sale. Out of a 24” barrel I shouldn’t be 220 fps slow in 308 or 243. Even much cheaper Winchester power point is measured much better and more consistent. lol sorry for the rant I’d love to see you test a few hunting type rounds like you did leading into deer season last year. Either way you are the best on this platform!!!
Watching these balistic tests has become a serious addiction
The 40 S&W demonstrated more than a third more energy.
It delivered a third more mass at equal or better velocity.
Interesting.
Not messin around.😎👊
Also has about a third more mass and volume lol.
@@nigeltheoutlaw
And hits harder.
This is my exact EDC thanks to Tools highly educated jelly testing, G27 with 👊.
Looks like either one would be a good choice for a defensive load.
Yessir
It would seem that Federal has "figured it out" with their defensive ammunition. They now offer many choices at various price points, and all perform at least adequately. Bravo to the folks at Federal. And thanks to Tools&Targets for doing these videos, where the proof is in the pudding, er, I mean the proof is in the jelly.
I like the tests using 3-3.5 barrels l live in Florida so 90 percent of the time I'm carrying a micro 9mm for ease of concealment
The terminal performance of the 40 is superior to the 9mm. No debate about that. However, it is interesting that the 9mm gave almost equal penetration. So, if the shooter could get more shots down range with the 9mm (due to the lighter recoil) it might be argued that greater terminal performance could be achieved by the 9mm since more shots would hit the objective. But, for just one single shot the 40 is obviously superior. I own some 9's and a couple of 10's, but no 40's. I need to buy a G23. I am sure I would love the 40 if I gave it more of a chance. GREAT test.
Thank you sir.😎👊
Try a G29 10mm but with 40 which shoots fine (but stresses the extractor) or with a Lone Wolf conversion barrel.
@@RT-gv6us Well that just depends on your shooting abilities.. Some of us can control recoil and shoot 40 just as well as 9mm. Enough to put rounds center mass. The difference in recoil isn't that substantial
@@mdubb4855 I own a G29. I have not tried 40 in it yet, but I have hand loaded some 10mm 155g XTPs at minimum pressures which I think would be very similar to the 40. It was very shootable.
@@RT-gv6us agreed. Two light loads I’ve found:
40mm Syntech 205gr IPSCC is just 329ft-lbs rated out of unknown barrel length, very light for 40 and very clean.
10mm: 431 ft-lbs tested 3.8” Ammo Inc 180gr hollow; 180gr JHP TEB Ammo Inc is 1020fps out of 3.8" Glock G29 for 416 ft-lbs (different reporters). This is very light for 10mm which usually runs 475-550 (not counting the big game loads).
It’s kinda scary to a beginner like me. I first shot 40 out of a Shield gen 1 and it was manageable in that IPSCC Syntech but stout compared to a Shield in 9. I asked my instructor to shoot one round of the relatively low energy Ammo Inc 10mm for that training session so I could observe, and decided I would start with 40 in the G29 instead, work my way up to a more standard load like the Punch, then return to 10 and see how farm I can make it up the hierarchy beginning with target and ending with HST.
This video reminds me why I have a couple of 40 options even though it is stouter than I like: it hits hard!
My next baby project gun is a G27 plus Sig 357 conversion barrel, if I get brave enough. I tried similarly loaded 357 out of a revolver and didn’t like it at all, but maybe the Sig in an auto will tame some recoil.
If you get around to loading some 40 in a G29 please share your experience. I think the G29 fat baby Glock falls into a really sweet spot for size.
The FBI and police can claim all they want that 9mm is now equal to 40 and 45, but it’s just not true. They claim that bullet advances have made them equal, but the 40 and 45 have also gotten those same advances.
They are lying to themselves. They switched to 9mm because of budget cuts.
9mm is a better caliber for the police. Officers come in all sizes, strengths, male or female. They need to be able to control the recoil and put follow up shots on target. 9mm is a goldilocks pistol caliber.
@@jake4194 every single one of you clowns say the same thing about 9mm and follow up shots. It's not impossible to mitigate recoil on 40 cal. You have to be WEAK to not be able to handle it.
The agency I worked for, the smaller stature officers had a harder time qualifying with the 40 compared to 9.@ArmedAndIndigenous
@@Ranchpup33 cool they can shoot 9mm like every other small dude and female out there. But guess what. Government didn't switch to 9mm because it's better. They switched because budget cuts. There's plenty of bigger officers out there that are strong and can handle recoil of 40. but they're forced to use 9mm now
I carry 40 primarily and have for nearly 30 years. I will be rotating out of my 165 Gold Dots to the 165 HST at the first of the year. I made a great trade at a gun show for a couple hundred of these. And the run fine and perform great.
40 is the correct answer vs human sized questions
💥🥇🧟♂️🧟♀️🥇💥
🇺🇸🙏❤️🩹🙏🇺🇸
I would not want to be on the receiving end of either. Both performed very well.
Anyone that says .40 Short and Weak, needs a brain transplant.😂
Agree. There was a 120 ft lbs of energy difference between those rounds.
It was crazy how that 40 bounced around at the end of its travel in the block, I’ve never seen a round do that before.
Yeah, that was pretty cool. High framerate shows all kinds of crazy stuff. One of these days when I strike it rich, I'll get one of those multi thousand dollar cams that can show a fly flapping it's wings.
Good video. I've been carrying 357 SiG for the last few months.
Sorry.
Thank you sir.😎👊
Try not to be sorry @@robwilson3749
@@robwilson3749Sorry?
Oh, are you one of those kids that believe the FBI and all the interwebnet silly boys that have been brainwashed into believing 9mm. is AWSOME!!!
Thanks for the great test. Both rounds did really well. Keep the 40 S&W tests coming. It's a good cartridge and deserves the attention. Its additional ft/lbs and momentum over the 9mm is noticeably.
Just started watching, just gotta say brother. I'm in central Texas (San Antonio) I feel ya on the blisterin heat! Thanks for the video! To all that don't know, this southern heat w/humidity can turn a range day miserable!
Thank goodness it's finally cooling down some around here.
@@ToolsandTargets no doubt, cool 70° here in S.A. Texas.
San Antonio is South Texas.
Tools - the Punch has turned out to be a pretty consistent line. Really appreciate the test. Hope it's a good weekend for you all over that way.
Thank you sir. You too!😎👊
Great Test! I carry the Punch in 9mm. Love it! Appreciate you being in the heat running these tests buddy! Thank You
😎👊
Why do you carry this when HST is proven and cheaper?
@@trentvlak Punch is considerably cheaper than the HST's. They are darn near the same projectile design. HST's fantastic and superior but that Punch 9mm is beastly for $13.xx a box.
@@Balticblue93 I can get HST for 50 cents a round at Crate Holdings. I don't see Punch anywhere for less than 65 cents.
The Punch turned out to be a really good performer in every caliber I have seen so far. The 45 acp version does really well despite it being heavy and slow.
I have handguns in 9, 40, and 357 so I appreciate you putting these head to head. Thanks!
They tried the 40 S&W but then the agencies dropped it in favor of the 9 mm with improved bullets. Less recoil and blast and less wear and tear in the guns, lower cost, and better qualification scores. Some people may scoff and say the agencies are hiring too many wimps so they had to drop the 40 S&W but the bottom line is that the 9 mm seems to work out best for the agencies.
DEI at work long before it was cool.
@@ToolsandTargets Exactly.
My agency ran Glock 22/23 for 10/12 years with no issues at all. They did change out the recoil springs periodically.
Nice!! Great performance from both. I was a little worried with the lower velocities but they proved me wrong. Both would be a devastating wound for sure. I like the head to head from time to time. Awesome stuff as always my friend 👍🇺🇸🇺🇸
Appreciate ya, brother.😎👊
2 successes. I would like to see a bit more velocity from both but I am not complaining with these great results. Many thanks for the good demonstration & data.
Punch seems to do pretty well across the board.😎👊
With the penetration and expansion they showed, there's no reason for more velocity.
People get too hung up on velocity.
Im in the uk and find this fascinating. You have such knowledge and passion for what you do. Always fun to watch
Thanks for the tests.
😎👊
Federal Punch 9mm fan here, it's what I carry everyday
Love that Punch stuff, I use the 9 and 40 for both of my tools
Good Videos as always. I am glad you are able to provide good comparisons between 9mm vs 40 S&W. I've been torn deciding which caliber to conceal carry, ammo tests keep indicating the 40ty is the "problem solver". Now gotta find the right tool to carry.
Thank you sir.😎👊
I cut my teeth carrying .40 S&W, until I started reloading 10MILL.
💥😎👊💥
We really appreciate the updates on rounds you ran without the clothing barrier the first time around, and especially appreciate you running the short barrels! Put'em through the ringer.
Love the 40 test Tools!
Appreciate ya, brother!😎👊
😎👊
That cavity at the end of the 40 track was huge.
Thanks Tools for another great vid......Lordy Lordy I love me some of that freakin' 40!!....mercy.........
💥😎💥
Nice one tools!!! I just purchased my first full size 9mm pistol Glock 17 wiff 4.5” barrel it really gets those hot +P loads justa movin down range…I can’t wait to see you test those DoubleTap 147 Grain +P Bonded Defense to show these .40 lovers what a Real 9mm can do when loaded the RIGHT WAY like they used to back in the day💯
Nice to see two good ones! Since I don’t own a .40, the 9mm. will do just fine. And I do have some for the LC9 so I’m glad to see it works well.
Usually priced good too.😎👍
the 40 is ok'ish, I don't like the low velocity of the 9mm though. Sure it penetrates the gel, but one rib and that thing is stopping or deflecting. But, that's just me and my Love Affair with HST. rofl. I found a box of winchester SXT last weekend in storage. It was the round they came out with when they stopped selling the Black Talon. Nearly the same round, points aren't quite as pronounced but they were blowing gallon jugs up like they were made of baggies. Maybe I'll send you some to test.
I don't know if you know any ER Doctors, but they are the one you should interview regarding internal Damage. I know what they are going to say, but your views may find it interesting should you locate one to go on camera.
I'm sure they're some TH-cam videos of that exact scenario.
😎👊
Enlighten us uncle fuster
I carry no less than a .40 cal with 165 gr. Ranger "T" or Gold Dots. But my perfered sidearm calibers were the 10mm or the .45 ACP. I like the leverage on the streets Lone Bear!
💥😎👊💥
Thanks
😎👊
If on sale I would pick up that 9mm all day. Both even that 40 with the huge cloth catching maw of a hollow point didn't even care about the clothing. Both were exceptional.
I'll stick with my .40S&W for daily carry and backup to a 12ga pump for home defense. The only use I still have for my 9 Minimal pistol is range time as the ammo is cheaper and more plentiful and I can't tell the difference in recoil or muzzle blast between the two.
I carry a G45 for my EDC and I love it but I've been wanting to build a G23X for a while. I like 9mm and I think it's a great choice for self defense but I've always believed .40 S&W is superior to 9mm
Both are great rounds, job well done, thanks brother
Thank you sir.😎👊
Interesting. I was just thinking about .40S&W the other day. I might consider getting one sometime.
40/357Sig , I do carry 9mm and 380acp at times ...
😎👊
Do federal hydrashock deep in 9, and .40 please .
P.s fly high Paul !
😎👊
So bossy
@@LogisticallyMisrepresented I've already invested in the ammo because I got it for a good deal. I'm just keeping the mountain man busy.
The 40 is peeled more back in the end which means while traveling through it expanded more and peeled back further .
A really food representation of how far good bullet technology has pushed the 9mm to perform similarly to 40 and 45. Maybe not quite as much temporary stretch cavity since it has less energy, but a bigger final diameter. Energy in of itself doesn't kill anything when it comes to pistol bullets at pistol velocitys. Once you get into rifle velocity's 2000+ fps the temporary stretch cavity does actually add to the wounding of flesh though. Pistol bullets poke holes in things, find a caliber you can accurately poke holes with that will penetrate deep enough and expand reliably and PRACTICE PRACTICE PRACTICE!
😎👊
By that logic, why not carry .380? lighter/easier to conceal guns, less recoil.
@@randallflores-qr8cs Finding 380 that penetrates deeply enough and expands reliably isn't easy. Most people use fmj's which don't create any wounding at all like hollow points do. 9mm is readily available, low recoil, and has many very good options for self defense.
Both are backup calibers. Fight me.
Carry a SP-01 with a extension and 23+1 with a G27 backup ankle gun.
Carry a Sig 229 in 40s&w and a PF9 backup ankle gun.
I would be fine with either. I only am 9mm currently for handloading purposes, but get asked to make .40 by family leading me to wanting to play the .40 game even though it does nothing for me pleasurably as a shooter.
Just how it is.
Nice test. Federal seems to doing a good job of engineering their products.
I use the .45 Punch for my EDC. My wife uses the 9mm Punch for her EDC. This just confirms my decision. I still wish you would do a carbine test on the 9MM Punch
Awesome ballistic gel test. Would be confident in either. 👍👍
Recently, my big box store prices on these nearly match the HSTs. But I picked up some of these in 45 a couple years ago. So happy to see good results on this test. Thanks Tools.
Good one Mr. Tools, I got a few boxes of the 9mm on sale earlier in the year, not my primary but awesome for a backup plan when the gold dots and HST’s run dry. I’m impressed with the 40, I’m a gold dot guy for 40 all day but that’s a good demonstration for penetration.
I love my 40, but I've got some 9MMs for just in case use, because they have much more ammo availability. I would do 40 all day long though, as my preferred round. Mr. Tools&Targets has really got me wanting to try out 10MM with Buffalo Bore. That's the biggest pistol caliber needed, I'd say.
BB wakes up a 10mm for sure.😎👊
4d 4 the win
😎👊
This review is highly useful for me. Great job!
Just about everything Federal makes seems to perform well
😎👊
I'd carry either one with confidence. I have some of the 9mm, got'em when I couldn't find HSTs. They ride the bench now, playing second string to the HST and Elite Defender. My go-to in 40 is HST and Ranger. Another excellent test!!
😎👊
They did great Thank's Brian, have a good weekend. 👊🇺🇸
Judging by the comments I’ve read your “fistfight” title is genius, I don’t own a 40 myself I prefer 9mm but what I can say is one shot center mass from both of these rounds would to the job.
It definitely brings out some opinions.😎👊
Very impressive on both caliber 's
Hard to argue with Federal products. Great job Tools!
Excellent test. I'd love to see the same test using HST.
Good test Tools God Bless and take care.
Thank you sir.😎👊
If you can handle the 40 and accept a couple less rounds, it is a very good defense round. I carried one for many years.
But as my friends aged they began having more trouble.
More recently, I noticed my split times significantly increased with the 40 vs 9mm so I too have changed. Although the 40 has more energy, the 9 does very well and the impact on the bad guy has generally not shown much difference in effectiveness. So you cannot go wrong either way. Thanks Federal!!!
😎👊
The same reasoning can be applied to carrying. 45acp instead of .40 . Just saying . :)
Both are impressive 👍
😎👊
I'm sticking to my HST's
Physics dictates that during expansion as the petal are perpendicular to the C/L of the bullet the 40 will have a greater momentary diameter, thus creating a larger wound cavity until the petals fold back against the bullet. Once again, another great video. .40 S&W rules.
Finding 40 for $20/50 rounds law enforcement grade top quality branded JHP. Loving it. 40 still defeats 9 in every test. Thanks for your hard work!
What brand and where are you finding it?
Yep. That's what I get it for at my local shop. Don't tell.🤫
Yep, don't tell.
A good test might be the same caliber, brand, and variety, but at different weights. Heavy vs mid vs light.
I have been thinking of doing some bigger tests like that.
Even though I like rounds loaded to the upper limits, I'm impressed with both. Nice expansion
Using the shortest barrels does make the most sense. My worry with not testing in longer barrels is if the bullet gets too much velocity from the longer barrel it won't penetrate properly bc of too much expansion. If the hollow expands out of a short barrel and the penetration is at least 15inches I would trust it to penetrate fine out of a longer barrel
😎👊
I feel like you just contradicted yourself
Both of these rounds penetrate adequately through longer barrels. Through my Beretta92FS I got around 15" & my Glock22 16.50" both same Federal punch rounds.
What’s really weird., I’ve been seeing boat loads of .40 law enforcement trade ins on the market lately in particular G22s I mean if you want a .40s&w man you can find some deals when it comes to G22 LE trade ins,,, I think PSA was just selling them for 299 the other day .I also see G23 sprinkled in .. of course you also see a lot of G17 but some of those must be upgrades because a lot of them are like Gen3
I carry 9 and 40 depending on where im going and what im wearing. Hornady critical defense in both. Glock 23 and ruger ec9s. Sometimes I can't get away with a double stack. I also believe in having firearms in more than one caliber in part because of COVID. Had all the 40 in the world to choose from.
Punch does it again
Both rounds performed nicely. Have some 9mm Punch to back up my HST’s, haven’t tried any 40’s yet. Carry 9’s mainly because that’s what our dept issues. Was disappointed when we switched from 40’s to 9’s, due to current trends. No doubt the 40 hits harder. Thanks for the jelly test Tools!
Love me the Friday evening tools show🍻
Appreciate ya, brother!😎👊
The 9 is a pretty projectile!😮❤❤❤
I've been at this testing expansion many,many years. the bigger the expansion and most retaining weights is the perfect combination for any given calibers. this 40 and 9mm test are perfect performance. I trust this testing so much I wouldn't hesitate to deer hunt with either one which is legal here in north carolina during deer rifle season. because of my disabilities I considering this deer season pistol/ revolver hunting only during rifle season. what better way to test your self defense ammunition than live deer. gained experience and groceries from the field ,that's win,win. if this is not the best test video I have seen it would run a very high second place.lol. as always, papa wishing you well. 😊
40 S&W FTW ... again ... 💪😃👍
The test definitely shows how modern bullet designs and lead alloys have improved the 9mm. I'll continue standing by the 40S&W ... just superior performance even in short barrels.
Nice revisit test I had no doubt they would perform and no doubt the 40 is superior I still don't understand the 40 s&w haters other than price I prefer them
Good stuff.😎👊
Please try the G2 Research Civic Duty for gel test. Way better than the RIP rounds.... 🙏
Nice performing rounds , glad i have a few . Thanks for info !
😎👊
I wonder if the projectiles were a bit out of spec, both were overweight after expansion so I would assume they were heavier before expansion too. Might contribute to the lower velocities.
Very cool comparison between the 40 Smith & Wesson and the 9 mm. 👊🇺🇸. Thanks Tools.
Thank you sir.😎👊
Keep up the good work
😎👊
You da man 👨🏼 with the master plan 👊🏽💪🏽🙌🏽😁
Punchy punchy...... the wireless hole puncher!
I use the 9 in my P938 Scorpion and the 40 in my G27
10mm ftw👍🏆
Thanks for another great review! Can you do some Herters 9mm 115grain from bass pro, just the basic range ammo they put out or the Herters 380 flat nose ammo? These are always easy for me to pick up and I wonder how they compare to others.
Very interesting test. Although I use the HST, the Punch in any caliber is a good option.
Both look like good choices. As far as 9 vs 40. I'm a 9 guy. If I shoot a 1cm bullet it is out of a 10mm case. As always, excellent test sir!
I have carried both of these rounds, like them both, just depends on the situation and the right tools.
Id love to see some tests with these 9mm's from carbines
Pretty cool bullets. I still stick with Ranger-T for my 9mm. I think they’re hard to beat. They are more difficult to get your hands on though 🤔
Either one of these rounds look like a great choice for defense. We appreciate your tests, so we don't waste our money on crappy ammo.
If I remember correctly Federal created the 9mm punch for the Hellcat lineup?
I still take the9mm
😎👊
Another great test! I think if federal dropped the premium tag and nickle plated case from the punch lineup they should also drop the price. Federal is on my shit list lately. Been testing some new hunting loads because the partitions I usually use are so hard to find. Federal even in their premium hunting rounds never come close to listed velocities. If it was just a little bit I’d understand but I’m talking about 100s of fps and im constantly seeing it from everything they sale. Out of a 24” barrel I shouldn’t be 220 fps slow in 308 or 243. Even much cheaper Winchester power point is measured much better and more consistent. lol sorry for the rant I’d love to see you test a few hunting type rounds like you did leading into deer season last year. Either way you are the best on this platform!!!
I'd like to see a Corbon Pow'r Ball vs Federal Punch in 40 S&W as I've been carrying Pow'r Ball in my. Gen 3 Glock 22.
I have 9mm stocked up because we have to😅 but my primary will always be 40cal 155-165 grain. My specialty is 10mm in 180grain.