I like this bike, and will probably buy one very soon, depending on availability, but I sure wish that Specialized would add someone to their design team that had some taste. The color choices for their bikes leaves a lot o be desired.
Of all the SJ media blast videos in my feed I clicked on yours first because its not market driven and presents a real world perspective from someone I trust :)
Hows does it compare to Ripley V4??? Have 2019 Stump Expert 29 (upgraded to dpx 2, fox factory 36). Love it. Just bought Ripley v4 to build. let us know your thoughts between 2021 stump and Rip v4 JC!
I really enjoyed the quality and flow of this review. You went over all the equipment and stats thoroughly and quickly went though every thing I wanted to know. You’re rude video was beautiful as well.
Dude, great genuine review. Loved seeing your home trails. Looks like some good flowy fun. I just bought this frame new in an Sworks and about build it up. I’ll check out your other vids. Thx! from SoCal
JC where do you place this relative to the Epic EVO? Is there a big difference in pedal/climbing efficiency between the two? I want something lighter and more nimble than the 2019 SJ 29er, just not sure the 2021 SJ is that bike being longer and slacker. Though I do like the steeper STA
The Epic Evo being so light and having less travel its definitely easier to pedal for longer distances. The new Stumpy isn’t far off in the efficiency department but you are lugging around 4-5 more pounds.
I live in Virginia and ride all types of trails. Some trails are rocky and some tight switchbacks. Mountains to flat. I am thinking the new stumpy, or Pivot 429 pro X01or Giant Trance X 29 pro 0/1? So no too low BB or too long. What say you folks? I do like the swat box. Also I am 6’1” 165 pounds Thank you 🙏
Love your vids and see that you've ridden both the regular Stumpjumper and and the Epic Evo. I've been riding an old school fully ridged Surly Krampus the past 8 years and it's time for this 50 plus year old to upgrade to full suspension. I had my sites set on a Epic Evo Comp and have one on order from my LBS but the owner just told me he could offer me a sweet deal on a new Stumpjumper Expert which component wise is much better then the Evo Comp. Even thought the Krampus was a 29 plus it was still pretty snappy with aggressive geometry. Do you think I'd be happy with a Stumpjumper or will it feel sluggish? I no longer race but love good single track and we have a pretty good selection of all types of trails her in Michigan's Upper Peninsula. I wish I could ride both but it's winter here and nobody has a Epic Evo to be found at a bike shop up here to even look at to compare.
Great POV video to watch. Didn't seem like you were having very much fun, LOL. I wish I was able to be in the market for a bike like this.......$8K plus price I heard, yes? Keep up the good work!
James would you feel comfortable riding your epic Evo on THIS trail? I want to sell my stumpy and get something more pedal friendly but still want to be able to get a little crazy!
I just got the 2021 Stumpjumper comp alloy. I'm 5'10" and went to test out the S4 and S5 and the guy told me I fit the S5 much better and it did feel better. But then you're saying you're 5'10" and the S3 fits you right. Weeeeird! I do have really long arms though so that might be why
Loved the review. I live in the UK and i'm currently looking at this bike, specifically the Comp Carbon version. I currently ride a 6 year old 160/160 Cube Stereo and dont struggle on climbs but im a little concerned about dropping to a 140/130mm travel bike. Looking at the footage, a lot of what i ride is similar but i do like to ride natural trails from time to time and the odd day at bike park. I do small jumps but dont ride Black Trails, i stick to fast Blue & Red trails. Is the lower travel something to be concerned about in your opinion? Thanks.
good luck, though i swear ive just brought the last one in the uk, i was thinking about it for a bit and saw them going out of stock quickly so decided pull the trigger on the last one i could find online glad i did though, awesome bike, makes even a naff rider like myself instantly better, not fell off it once yet :P travel is good enough for my level of ability, i thought the best thing about the bike was it uses the same frame as the s works so will be good for upgrading
Would the 2020\1 PIVOT SWITCHBLADE beat this bike in every aspect? Climbing, sprinting, descending, tight turns, NOT destroyer of pedals and cranks, flat surfaces, roots, rocks, etc. overall quality, quality control...
Did you test ride the S4 at the shop? For 5'10 that seems like the ideal fit. I'm 5'10 And always struggled between Medium and Large... They say S2 is like the old medium, S5 is the large and S4 is the in-between... What do you think?
It’s hard to suggest a size for you. It depends if you like a long bike for stability or a short bike to flick around. The S3 is comfortable to pedal around for my 5’10” size, but I would probably go with a S4 with a short stem if I was doing extended descents.
Thanks for the response. What would you say are the key differences between the 2021 stumpy vs stumpy evo? From a riding perspective, uphill and downhill?
Love your reviews JC, thank you for what you do! How does this new stumpy climb vs. the Tallboy 4? Curious what your opinion is between these two bikes. Currently have a TB4, but thinking about this new Stumpy.
The TB has a sturdy planted feel like a mini enduro bike. The Stumpy feels lighter and not as stiff as the TB, which makes for a more playful ride. They climb about the same I would say, but the TB does provide better traction thru rock gardens.
@@jctrails I did get to ride a 2021 pro and your assessment is spot on. The bike did feel more poppy and playful than the Tallboy. Thanks for doing these reviews JC!
JC, excellent review. I am thinking about getting my first Stumpy, need your advice regarding the frame size. I am 5’11” and am pondering whether S3 will suit me better or the S4. Understanding that you are 5’10”, what made you choose the S3 over S4?
I'm really between this new stumpy and a hightower carbon. Any feedback on the pedaling performance between the two especially with the flex stays now?
I would say If your looking for pedal efficiency go with the Stumpy it has a light playful feel. The Hightower pedals well but feels heavier. It can for sure handle more chunk though.
Its another step up in frame capability/travel. From what I can gather, only 2’ish lbs heavier...at same price point. Stumpie is right in the middle, Jack of most, master of most. In order from least travel to most (Specialized): Epic (100) Epic evo (110) Stumpie (130) Stumpie evo (150) Enduro (170) Demo (200)
Do you still have your Evo? I remember you said you had a way to raise the bottom bracket. Did you ever follow through with that? Currently have the Evo and had a ton of pedal strikes this past weekend lol.
I’m new to MTB and looking for a full suspension. I’ve tested the Santa Cruz Hightower and was wondering your thoughts on this vs. the Hightower. Hopefully you’ve had a chance to take this one out. Any info would be great. Thanks.
The Delano has a more plush feel, but the new Stumpy does pedal better. So if your looking for a bike to handle more technical terrain I would go with the Delano.
True. They are also poor value for the money. Great frames with poor to average kit. I have watched a few reviews now and JC didn't talk about climbing much. Most other reviews have said this is it's weak spot. I live where you have to climb everywhere to descend. Not a lot of fire roads.
My epic evo and this Stumpy actually feel quite similar. Obviously the Stumpy feels a little more plush , but for some reason the stumpy feels easier to get off the ground. I think the shock tune and the geo contribute to that.
help me. I can't decide between this and Trek top fuel. I need one cool bike in my life. I have simple trails, nothing special, nothing fast and crazy. which one you pic?
@@jctrails I'm rockin a 2020 Rockhopper. It does just fine on trails, however I got on the 2021 stumpy and now. Well let's just say I'm searching for options to buy one.
Thanks for the review. This is the first I’d heard about the new Stumpjumper. Did you weight it? I’ve had a 2019 Stumpjumper Comp Alloy and I really like it, but I’m about to buy a 2019 Carbon Expert Stumpjumper for 4100 (new bike). I see the price for the new Expert is 4700, so not much more money. How would these bikes compare?
The new one pedals quite a bit better with the flex stay design. It’s also a bit easier to get off the ground. I weighed the expert build at a little over 28lbs
@@mb7762 Thanks for your thoughts and advice. I really value your perspective on the various bikes that are available these days. Keep up the good work!
If you could only pick one bike and mostly ride choppy single track trails full of roots and rocks, do you pick the Epic Evo or the Stumpjumper? No major jumps/doubles either.
Pedalling uphill and moderate blasting hills. Paris Mtn State Park in Greenville SC. I just sold my Trek Stache hardtail so either bike would be a huge difference.
But that question was also for you. Pretend you had to pick between the two bikes. You can only pick one bike to ride all year. What would you (JC) pick?
Great review, although I wish someone that sucked and was old would review these bikes so I knew how it would preform for me.
I like this bike, and will probably buy one very soon, depending on availability, but I sure wish that Specialized would add someone to their design team that had some taste. The color choices for their bikes leaves a lot o be desired.
Did you like it more than the 2020 Tallboy?
Of all the SJ media blast videos in my feed I clicked on yours first because its not market driven and presents a real world perspective from someone I trust :)
Thanks James! That means a lot coming from one of the best tubers around. 👊
Incorrect
Hows does it compare to Ripley V4??? Have 2019 Stump Expert 29 (upgraded to dpx 2, fox factory 36). Love it. Just bought Ripley v4 to build. let us know your thoughts between 2021 stump and Rip v4 JC!
Doesn’t climb and pedal as well as the Ripley but it provides a ton more confidence on the downs.
I really enjoyed the quality and flow of this review. You went over all the equipment and stats thoroughly and quickly went though every thing I wanted to know. You’re rude video was beautiful as well.
Dude, great genuine review. Loved seeing your home trails. Looks like some good flowy fun. I just bought this frame new in an Sworks and about build it up. I’ll check out your other vids. Thx! from SoCal
Thanks Albert!!!🤙
prob one of the only honest reviews on here. thankyou ....subbed
JC where do you place this relative to the Epic EVO? Is there a big difference in pedal/climbing efficiency between the two? I want something lighter and more nimble than the 2019 SJ 29er, just not sure the 2021 SJ is that bike being longer and slacker. Though I do like the steeper STA
The Epic Evo being so light and having less travel its definitely easier to pedal for longer distances. The new Stumpy isn’t far off in the efficiency department but you are lugging around 4-5 more pounds.
Do you think the stumpjumper is much more capable than the epic evo. Does it ride smoother?
Thanks
I live in Virginia and ride all types of trails. Some trails are rocky and some tight switchbacks. Mountains to flat.
I am thinking the new stumpy, or Pivot 429 pro X01or Giant Trance X 29 pro 0/1?
So no too low BB or too long.
What say you folks?
I do like the swat box.
Also I am 6’1” 165 pounds
Thank you 🙏
Love your vids and see that you've ridden both the regular Stumpjumper and and the Epic Evo. I've been riding an old school fully ridged Surly Krampus the past 8 years and it's time for this 50 plus year old to upgrade to full suspension. I had my sites set on a Epic Evo Comp and have one on order from my LBS but the owner just told me he could offer me a sweet deal on a new Stumpjumper Expert which component wise is much better then the Evo Comp. Even thought the Krampus was a 29 plus it was still pretty snappy with aggressive geometry. Do you think I'd be happy with a Stumpjumper or will it feel sluggish? I no longer race but love good single track and we have a pretty good selection of all types of trails her in Michigan's Upper Peninsula. I wish I could ride both but it's winter here and nobody has a Epic Evo to be found at a bike shop up here to even look at to compare.
Stumpjumper looks like it performs like a fast moving Sasquatch w/ wings...
-Great review JC!👍
Great POV video to watch. Didn't seem like you were having very much fun, LOL. I wish I was able to be in the market for a bike like this.......$8K plus price I heard, yes? Keep up the good work!
I am unable to afford a bike like this but love your videos and enjoy my hard tail. Bicycle geometry and engineering is fascinating to me. Thanks!!!
Thanks for watching
Hi Thanks for the review. Would you recommend the 21 stumpjumper comp carbon over 21 epic evo? I’m in Massachusetts...
Might be my next bike. Like my 2019 5010 but leaning more and more towards 29er. Love riding my fuse 29.
It feels like a 29er 5010
James would you feel comfortable riding your epic Evo on THIS trail? I want to sell my stumpy and get something more pedal friendly but still want to be able to get a little crazy!
I am wondering the same thing
@@kristopherquintero5688 I need to know! Lol.
@@kristopherquintero5688 I’m finding my stumpy to be too much bike for where I live now.
Can you post your Trailforks route for this day if you get a chance? All the best at Pine Hills in one clip.
Man I’m digging this one! Got a ‘19 Stumpy right now that I love. Maybe next year
Nice clean trails, i went riding yesterday at Uwharrie National forest in NC and there were so many leaves it was hard to follow the trail
I just got the 2021 Stumpjumper comp alloy. I'm 5'10" and went to test out the S4 and S5 and the guy told me I fit the S5 much better and it did feel better. But then you're saying you're 5'10" and the S3 fits you right. Weeeeird! I do have really long arms though so that might be why
So much innovation coming out of Big S. Might be time for a other stumpy
Awesome review, thanks! Also, I like the picture & the sound. Can u tell which camera do u use on your helmet while riding?
You definitely got the skills to ride a bike. Fun video.
Thanks!
Loved the review. I live in the UK and i'm currently looking at this bike, specifically the Comp Carbon version. I currently ride a 6 year old 160/160 Cube Stereo and dont struggle on climbs but im a little concerned about dropping to a 140/130mm travel bike. Looking at the footage, a lot of what i ride is similar but i do like to ride natural trails from time to time and the odd day at bike park. I do small jumps but dont ride Black Trails, i stick to fast Blue & Red trails. Is the lower travel something to be concerned about in your opinion? Thanks.
good luck, though i swear ive just brought the last one in the uk, i was thinking about it for a bit and saw them going out of stock quickly so decided pull the trigger on the last one i could find online
glad i did though, awesome bike, makes even a naff rider like myself instantly better, not fell off it once yet :P
travel is good enough for my level of ability, i thought the best thing about the bike was it uses the same frame as the s works so will be good for upgrading
New stumpy or ibis Ripely for riding in northern VT?
Just saw this review and totally swayed my decision towards the stumpjumper carbon evo and the trek fuel ex 9.7.
Hey man..hope the recovery is going well. Looking at this bike but curious how you think it would handle Nam in Milford..like C4, Mind the Gap, etc.
What a great time to be a mountain biker 🚴♀️
Sure is
Great video,. What is the tire clearance ?
Would the 2020\1 PIVOT SWITCHBLADE beat this bike in every aspect? Climbing, sprinting, descending, tight turns, NOT destroyer of pedals and cranks, flat surfaces, roots, rocks, etc. overall quality, quality control...
Did you test ride the S4 at the shop? For 5'10 that seems like the ideal fit. I'm 5'10 And always struggled between Medium and Large... They say S2 is like the old medium, S5 is the large and S4 is the in-between... What do you think?
It’s hard to suggest a size for you. It depends if you like a long bike for stability or a short bike to flick around. The S3 is comfortable to pedal around for my 5’10” size, but I would probably go with a S4 with a short stem if I was doing extended descents.
Thanks for the response. What would you say are the key differences between the 2021 stumpy vs stumpy evo? From a riding perspective, uphill and downhill?
Stumpy EVO or regular for your one quiver bike??
Love your reviews JC, thank you for what you do! How does this new stumpy climb vs. the Tallboy 4? Curious what your opinion is between these two bikes. Currently have a TB4, but thinking about this new Stumpy.
The TB has a sturdy planted feel like a mini enduro bike. The Stumpy feels lighter and not as stiff as the TB, which makes for a more playful ride. They climb about the same I would say, but the TB does provide better traction thru rock gardens.
@@jctrails I did get to ride a 2021 pro and your assessment is spot on. The bike did feel more poppy and playful than the Tallboy. Thanks for doing these reviews JC!
Might be picking one up on Friday the... 13... Maybe I should wait til Saturday.
Will 2.6 tires fit.
Thanks for the great videos
Thanks Walter. I’m not sure about the 2.6 in the rear.
how does it compare to the Delano peak?
Do you prefer the 2021 Hightower or this new Stumpjumper?
Do you know what the cassette ratio is on the 2021? I just ordered a comp alloy.
JC, excellent review. I am thinking about getting my first Stumpy, need your advice regarding the frame size. I am 5’11” and am pondering whether S3 will suit me better or the S4. Understanding that you are 5’10”, what made you choose the S3 over S4?
I could ride either size but for tight twisty trails I prefer the smaller size. If I was 5’11” I would go with the s4
@@jctrails Thanks JC for your prompt reply. Well understood! Thanks again.
I'm really between this new stumpy and a hightower carbon. Any feedback on the pedaling performance between the two especially with the flex stays now?
I would say If your looking for pedal efficiency go with the Stumpy it has a light playful feel. The Hightower pedals well but feels heavier. It can for sure handle more chunk though.
You loved the 2021 Epic Evo - how much more does the Stumpjumper give you?
Its another step up in frame capability/travel. From what I can gather, only 2’ish lbs heavier...at same price point.
Stumpie is right in the middle, Jack of most, master of most.
In order from least travel to most (Specialized):
Epic (100)
Epic evo (110)
Stumpie (130)
Stumpie evo (150)
Enduro (170)
Demo (200)
Random question but from new what did it come with for the swat
Thanks for this review. I'm torn between the Epic Evo and this bike. How much better does the Epic Evo climb?
The Epic climbs a little bit better due to having less travel and weight. If I had to put a percentage on it maybe 10% better than the stumpy.
@@jctrails Thanks. And how much does it perform better downhill?
Makes me want one bad. Great review, thank you.
How did this bike compare to the ripley?
oooh the new new! And to think I haven't finished my long term review of my 2020 yet LOL!
Haha get on it!
@@jctrails I tell ya, I don't think I'm ever doing a project with interviews cuz it's taking a century to edit!
What are the names of the trails you did the descending runs on?
Do you still have your Evo? I remember you said you had a way to raise the bottom bracket. Did you ever follow through with that? Currently have the Evo and had a ton of pedal strikes this past weekend lol.
I’m new to MTB and looking for a full suspension. I’ve tested the Santa Cruz Hightower and was wondering your thoughts on this vs. the Hightower. Hopefully you’ve had a chance to take this one out. Any info would be great. Thanks.
Hey, would you suggest this or the Delano Peak for super chattery trails? I know this has a 34 and the peak has a 36
The Delano has a more plush feel, but the new Stumpy does pedal better. So if your looking for a bike to handle more technical terrain I would go with the Delano.
Great rider at speed. There is no room for error at speed with trees on both sides of the trail
How is it compare to Ibis Ripley V4?
Doesn’t climb and pedal as well as the Ripley but it provides a ton more confidence on the downs.
Had a 19’ stumpy, got. SC Hightower 21’ . I’ll never own a specialized again !! Those stumpy’s only climb well on fire roads .
2 different bikes now. The HT is more comparable to the new Stumpy Evo.
True. They are also poor value for the money. Great frames with poor to average kit. I have watched a few reviews now and JC didn't talk about climbing much. Most other reviews have said this is it's weak spot. I live where you have to climb everywhere to descend. Not a lot of fire roads.
JC would you consider it more of a Tallboy than a 5010 29er though ?
No more of a 5010. The Stumpy has a light and energetic feel to it. The Tallboy feels more planted and heavy in a good way though.
where are these trails at!? these are insane
I have a 2020 epic, how would you compare this setup in the stumpy vs your epic? I have a Pro stumpy in order!
My epic evo and this Stumpy actually feel quite similar. Obviously the Stumpy feels a little more plush , but for some reason the stumpy feels easier to get off the ground. I think the shock tune and the geo contribute to that.
Be cool to see AL version with a swat box like the new Trek Slash
Thanks for the review 👍
Great review, thank you.
What trail is this and where?
Omg that Intro & that transition killed me.. 😂😂😂
I normally get a large, this makes me want to try a S4 instead of a S5.
Cool review. Autumn leaves were awesome. How do you like the new Fox 34 with Grip 2. Notice a difference?
The Grip 2 feels fantastic, but the 34 has a little too much flex for me. The pike would match up with this frame perfectly.
@@jctrails good insight. Thanks.
Where in MA is that trail? Looks really flowy for MA riding lol
Pine hills in Plymouth
@@jctrails awesome thanks man! I've been meaning to check that place out! I normally ride wompy!
Ice cream sandwich on the lip is an mvp move! Saving it for later! Love the stumpjumper
Haha! It was a yummy sandwich.
Boa noite teria como passar em português?
help me. I can't decide between this and Trek top fuel. I need one cool bike in my life. I have simple trails, nothing special, nothing fast and crazy. which one you pic?
Top fuel
@@jctrails Thank you so much!
Was thinking of a trek fuel ex 7/8 but this bike look good tho Alloy mite be a lot cheaper only new to this mtb
Are you going to try out the stumpy evo? S3 or s4?
If I do try it S4
What was the weight?
Nice review and bike man 🙏
Sick riding man
I legit just road this bike at my bike shop. It's F*@KING AWESOME
It sure is!
@@jctrails I'm rockin a 2020 Rockhopper. It does just fine on trails, however I got on the 2021 stumpy and now. Well let's just say I'm searching for options to buy one.
The was dope editing to fix your narration mistake 😂
What camera set up is this? Awesome to see it so smooth through the trails. You make it look way too easy!
GoPro karma grip and hero 7
Great video. Gorgeous bike.
Damn, that was intense!
the only cons i see on this bike is the crank set although its full carbon the crank is way way heavy.
Kind of makes me wonder if I should've waited for this to come out instead of pulling the trigger on my Occam...Too many bikes in this segment!
So many good bikes in this segment. Occam looks like a dope bike too, I’m sure you will have a good time on it.
That looks like so much funnnnnnn!!!
Oh she likes to jump!
How much did this size weigh?
About 28.5 pounds
@@jctrails thanks, Boss
Great vid 👍👍
Ur a really good rider
Thanks for the review. This is the first I’d heard about the new Stumpjumper. Did you weight it? I’ve had a 2019 Stumpjumper Comp Alloy and I really like it, but I’m about to buy a 2019 Carbon Expert Stumpjumper for 4100 (new bike). I see the price for the new Expert is 4700, so not much more money. How would these bikes compare?
The new one pedals quite a bit better with the flex stay design. It’s also a bit easier to get off the ground. I weighed the expert build at a little over 28lbs
@@jctrails thanks for the quick reply and useful information. Is the weight with tubes?
I’d go with the new expert. You get x01 and a grip 2 damper. My 19 stumpy expert had all gx stuff and basic level rockshox fork and shock.
@@mb7762 Thanks for your thoughts and advice. I really value your perspective on the various bikes that are available these days. Keep up the good work!
Love the vid
Thanks
Great vid
Thanks
If you could only pick one bike and mostly ride choppy single track trails full of roots and rocks, do you pick the Epic Evo or the Stumpjumper? No major jumps/doubles either.
It depends are you pedaling thru the rocks and roots or blasting thru it on a down hill?
Pedalling uphill and moderate blasting hills. Paris Mtn State Park in Greenville SC. I just sold my Trek Stache hardtail so either bike would be a huge difference.
But that question was also for you. Pretend you had to pick between the two bikes. You can only pick one bike to ride all year. What would you (JC) pick?
I like that shirt.
I need one in yellow😜
Next order I'll get you some yellows.
the silence of this bike is pure porn
Guys ...so .... I bought this bike last year, i only used it twice, it's looking beautiful in the garage ...sorry
Not sure why I would buy this bike in the comp version @ 3,200$ there are other brand’s giving more for that money.
You referring to mail order/direct to consumer?
@@Jacob99174 nope
@@strix2035 which then?
@@Jacob99174
It’s a secret. He is obviously a hater.
@@Jacob99174 Giant has two alone the Reign/ Trance X and trek fuel EX how’s that for a start
Specialized has the worst customer service at least here in the usa