I got one as my first full suspension bike & have nothing to compare it to but in my opinion it’s a fantastic bike that eats the downhill sections & climbs like a beast
Great timing on your review. Just pulled the trigger today and bought the Comp Carbon 29. Specialized sale is ending this week so I saved around $750 bucks.
I love my 2019 stumpy expert 29er. As a taller rider 6"2 and around 105kgs I went for the XL and it fits me perfectly. I'm really glad I swapped my 27.5 order for a 29er. Just a more capable bike. And just as fun as my previous 27.5 enduro. Had the bike around 10 months now, ridden it through a winter and a summer and now coming back into another winter. It performs equally well in all conditions, although in really dry dusty conditions it can get a little nervous due to the stiffness. The only areas I don't like are the rear shock and the amount of water that sits in the frame around the swat box/bottom bracket area. I'm looking at getting a custom tune or replacing with a super deluxe to fix the issue of needing to run 280psi plus even with the max number of reducers to prevent eating through the travel too rapidly. Having such high pressure means the small bump compliance is not great. I also had a seat post failure in mine where it would randomly drop a little from top lockout. Specialized NZ rebuilt it with around a 3 week turn around.
I bought the same model December 2019. I’ve been riding this bike ever since and completely agree with Clint’s analysis. I rode in Florida on Alafaya and Balm Boyette with it during the first couple years. Now riding San Felasco, and Santos a lot. The geometry of the frame really grips the trail and down hills. I feel very confident on it. He’s right about riding cross-country, especially with other fast riders. I have trouble keeping up with them and lose them on climbs. Down hills I can usually smoke everybody else. I had some problems with the guide brakes sticking, so replaced them with Migura Sport and really like those better. One advantage is the master cylinder is folded back on the brake lever and doesn’t stick out like the Shimano‘s and Guide’s. I replaced the rear tire with a Maxxis Assegai 2.6 which really plants the bike even more, however probably slows me down on cross country. When I replace the Butcher on the front, I’m going to try to find a lighter tire with still some grab to try to compensate for the greater weight of the Assegai, possibly a Vittoria.
Just bought this exact bike yesterday ( rocket red ) it will be ready on Friday and im so pumped! Got a sweet end of year deal from Specialized for $3600!!
I have the alloy version and the overall themes describe my experience with the bike. A little slow on acceleration and climbs. Planted and confidence inspiring while still being playful on downhills. Love it.
I've had my 2019 SJ since Nov2018. My first ride was awful... The SJ came with the FlipChip set to Low which, along with the super wide bars and stubby stem made the bike climb like a pig. I was scared that I had made a huge mistake buying it. BUT, I flipped the chip to High and put on a -20deg 90mm stem and swapped on my 160mm Pike and viola, she climbs like an XC race bike and descends like a slacked out enduro rig. I can't believe the difference. I have since put on 33mmID LB rims laced up with Berd spokes on DT240 hubs... and put all of my 1x11 x01 drivetrain back on it w/e13's 9-46 cassette, 175mm Next SL cranks & bar. No pedal strike issues at all while climbing technical, chunky trails here in the Colorado Rockies. The bike weighs 26.5 lbs before I load the SWAT box full of sealant, pump, tube, derailleur hanger, tools, food, etc. With over 20 years of riding and racing all over the Western US, this is the best bike that I've ever ridden by far. This is a bike I'll keep in the stable for many, many years to come.
I suggest regarding climbing... Give a purgatory 2.3 a try on the rear. You won't really notice any grip loss but will really notice the improved efficiency in climbing. It's a change I made on my 2019 comp alloy and like it. Another nice upgrade is carbon bars. The alloy spesh bars it comes with are quite heavy and adds compliance with carbon
Agreed on both counts. I actually went with 2.3 Ground Control tires as my trails are pretty tame compared to some. (Middle Tennessee). Climbs fine. Still Not a scorching xc climbing bike of course. But the fun on the way down is an 11 out of 10 😎
Always love your reviews, I currently own a 2014 Giant Trance and have just test ridden the Specialized Epic and then the Stumpy. I have now ordered the Stumpy Comp Carbon and managed an upgrade to carbon wheels in the deal. Looking forward to enjoying it as much as you Clint
I have the same Bike and completely agree with you on the review. Great review. I love the SWAT storage. You can store there a lot of things. I dont have to wear a backpack anymore.
Absolutely love my '19 expert LT 29er. I dream about riding it and lust to look at it haha. Two changes I made were to swap to the new Shimano XT 4-piston brakes as I just don't like the feel, performance or durability of the Guides. Thought the R's were a bit under-spec'd on a $5,500 bike. Didn't care for the stock tires. They were slow and soft uphill as a result of floppy sidewalls although pretty good on the descent. Put some Maxxis WT 2.5 aggressor rear and Minion DHF front and totally transformed it. Overall best/favorite bike I've ever had.
Great review! I just ordered my Stumpy Expert on Friday. I actually rode Alifia a year and a half ago on an MTB trip to NC where I met family in Tampa at the end of the trip. I was pretty impressed and had a nice ride with some locals!
I’ve got about a hundred miles on the ‘19 Stumpjumper pro. Coming off the 2016 Stumpjumper expert I’m a bit surprised at the difference in feel from the 16 to the 19. The 2019 feels heavier but man the grip on berms, the confidence on flow and fast single tracks and jumps, it’s really just better! The only thing is the weight, I’ve considered shaving a pound by switching out the tires but I keep telling myself why? I’m not a pro, not racing, just out having fun staying fit. The 2.6 tires (I’m running tubeless) weigh almost 4 lbs together. anyone switched out the tires? comments on this are invited. I’d almost say you can turn this into a Xc bike by replacing tires with 2.2 and emptying the swat box. While in the saddle putting down power I’ve had no issues with squash and when outta the saddle it’s still respectable. Going down hill you’d crush anything like a epic or pivot 429sl. I was torn on what to buy, but now I’m happy with my choice. Dark blue with Kashima coating and I added the gold xx1. I’m not the most prolific biker out there but damn I look good doing it!
Those are my thoughts on the 2.6 tires as well. I at first wanted to swap them, but I don't race anymore, and the traction is great. I may throw a 2.3 Purgatory on the back when my 2.6 is worn and see how it feels, but for now I'm content with the 2.6.
Thanks for the review. I’m going to buy a frame and swap out my components from my 2016 STJ . I can’t decide between the Yeti SB130, Niner 29 RIP9 Rdo,or STJ. Every time I see you riding the STJ, it makes me want to get one.
I love that bike, I have a 2016 with the swat, which was probably the main reason I went for the carbon, that and the unique color and no graphics. If I was going to buy a new bike today, at or near the top of my list would be the current stumpjumper. I agree the saddle is good, so good I put the same saddle on my other bikes, I ride without padded shorts. I have the same tires on mine as well, almost too much grip. 2 weeks ago I rode Alifia for the first time and it handled everything there. Cheers.
The Specialized tires seem to be getting a lot of love around the TH-cam community... I think that it is BikeRadar who keeps using them as a baseline "good performer" in its tire comparisons!
Nice review Clint. I love mine so far! Upgraded the fork cartridge to the RCT3 cartridge, so now I have fully open, climb, and locked positions. Not sure if the people watching know that the stock fork only has a low speed compression damping, and that the fork is basically in a "fully open" position all the time in its stock form. It's a proprietary fork made by Rock Shox for Specialized, just like the Fox Rhythm fork as well. Overall, I'm psyched about riding it this season, as I had limited time on it this past Fall when I picked it up. Great bike, which I'd recommend to anyone!
There's a newly released air can upgrade for your rear shock... Rockshox MegNeg air can, which adds more volume to the negative air chamber.... i hope you would try it and review the changes in characteristics of the bike after upgrading the air can.
I'd say that this "upgrade" is really just a fix for it's poor performance. It's a fix that you have to pay for in order for it to get closer to Fox quality design.
Hi Clint, yes my stumpy was also a bit slow on the climbs, I swapped the tyres for XC tyres, grippy one on the front and fast one on the rear and it makes a huge difference on the climbs, staying with guys on XC hardtails, and it still handles fantastic on the rough stuff
At 5'9.5" I have ridden a Med, Large, and XL Stumjumper carbon 29. Loved the medium and XL. Cant jive with the large with any other shock than the Fox DPX2 Factory, which is too much money for me to justify riding. So, I just bought a 2020 Stumjumper Carbon EVO S3 (large/xl) and its the best bike I've ever ridden: based on fit and kinematics. So strange as I've always thought a 66-degree headtube angle is slack!!! Meanwhile, got to recommend this EVO, also the 2020 Reign 29 medium, and ofcourse the Ibis Ripmo size large as being the true standouts. Now in 2020, I see you're riding a new Transition Sentinal 29. Thinking thats a definite solid-choice after riding the EVO. Mindblown how agile a bike with a near 50" wheelbase is! Perhaps bikes are best near 63-65 hta and near 67-69 hta??? As if everything inbetween is somehow "vague" in contrast to the on-point experience of those two angles??? Maybe the EVO is just a special bike based on my size and background? Rides like a dream even with a 51 offset fork! Should seem weird for such a slack angle, or at least that's what Ive expected to experience over years of riding. Anyway, just catching up. Times are adding up and the experiences are starting to stack up into newfound outlooks.
Is this bike "only" a trail bike ? I mean i would like this bike to take me to work everyday and take it to the trails on weekends, even tho i have a Road Bike i would like to use this one to do 40 miles everyday to work and back home. any advise ? Thanks guys !
I think a trail bike with this much travel and tires this big is going to feel slow as a commuter bike. If you were going to do that then I would put on smaller tires, like 2.35.
Spring has its own recoil versus a shock that's what then you do not want at all on a bike unless it's a Spring over a shock... Depending on what you want the bike for going downhill or cross country... Despite the timeframe you could actually have both won for cross-country and for downhill always use a shock because you can really be late the rebound.... Example, if you use a Spring going down Hill and you hit a good bump or rock it could buck you off the bike easily versus a shock that has a slow recoil setting
Thanks for your reviews. Watched them all, although I'm rather after the ST version, but since frames are the same, just suspension travel is different, I figuret I'll check them, and I don't regret it. Very infromative and competent. If you don't mind me asking - how exactly tall are you? You've said you're little over 5ft 8in? It that like around 175cm (I'm not very good with imperial system :) )? I'm 178cm tall, so between the sizes M and L, according to specialized size chart. Which one would you recommend?
Excellent video, just order a Specialized Stumpjumper ST Alloy 29, would you say it’s a reliable and solid bike for trails? I was between the Giant Trance and the Specialized Stumpjumper ST Alloy 29.
I have a 2016 SJ with the swat box and love it. The one thing that I will say is the swat box lid on these 2019's is disappointingly cheesy compared to mine. The opening on my 2016 is completely framed with pretty much a gasket seal. I wash my bike periodically with a pressure washer and never saw a drop of water in there. My buddy has this same 2019 expert and complains of water getting inside and when I looked at it there was no questions as to why.
I own 2 of 2016 SJ, an expert and sworks. And I can attest to this that I never had any water ingested into the swat box either. Now I will stop thinking of buying the 2019 as I will be frustrated if other resonates with your observation.
Nice review, I like that you put the dialogue over actual riding. I recognized most of the trails but was wondering where the rock quarry was located. I see You said balm and alafia, but never saw that.
Hi Clint Gibbs, out of curiosity how tall are you? I have a specialized Stumpjumper 29er FSR evolution and it is a medium frame also. I have always used a large frame with 27.5 wheels but this medium 29er Stumpjumper seems to be ok for size as well.
Great review, thanks. Loving mine! I've never run a tyre this wide before and I am curious whether a slightly narrower tyre would significantly improve the feel of the bike ... that said, the collective knowledge at Specialized isn't something I'd doubt.
I actually do like GX. There's not much difference in shift to performance between GX and XO. The only issue I have with SRAM is there seems to be one gear in the middle of the cassette does not hold very well. It's only with SRAM eagle. Other than that it shifts fine.
Clint, with the current bike shortage, I'm lucky to be getting an opportunity to pick up the new Specialized Status 2020 bike. A friend and bike shop owner tells me that the geo is similar to a Stumpy. The thing is, I do want to race XC. In your honest opinion, do you think this kind of geo would be ok to race (northeast single track - lots of roots & rocks but no big drops) or would you suggest waiting and getting another XC / Trail bike?
In my book pedaling efficiency and bike weight is more important than geo numbers for racing. Check out my video release of the new transition Spur. it has angles I never thought would be fast on a cross-country course, but it proved me wrong.
Clint I’m 5’10.5 with a 31 inch Inseam so kind of mote torso than legs. I sit i between many mediums and large. I ride now a Santa Cruz large 29’er. I felt like a long time like I sit very high but it feels good once I get rolling. I did switch back from clipless to flat 5-10 shoes with good pegged pedals since I feel better in tech areas. So what do you think a large is right for me?
I have the same inseam as you. So it's really going to come down to the reach. Try to ride both. If you feel like you're too squished on a medium as far as the reach then go at the large. If you like a bike that's more maneuverable then go with a medium.
I was looking at the 27.5 and the 29 version, did you ever have a chance to try the other wheel size of this bike model? Was curious how they felt. Thanks!
Not the 27.5 stumpjumper but plenty of other 27.5 bikes. Search my channel for 29 vs 27.5 trailblakes. I've done a few videos that hopefully should help.
Thanks for the great videos! Picked up a Stumpy Expert in April after watching your videos. Great ride! Wondering if you have noticed a slight clicking/creaking in the front suspension when riding over roots or bumps? So annoying and just came on today. Any advice?
The ST/LT frames differ by shocks & yoke. What's the actual difference in the frames between 27.5" frames and 29er frames? Can one put 29er wheels on the 27 w/o compromise?
Thanks for the review. I ride alafia and carter road primarily in FL. I’ve ridden the 27.5 version and it was a ton of fun. Do you think the 29 is too large for some of the tight stuff we have in FL?
I think this bike back wheel will get blocked by various trail elements (ie.e leaves, sticks) because the clearance is very little between the frame and the wheel visible at 2.17. What do you think?
I recently purchased this model and am having trouble getting the suspension dialed in. The front fork seems so stiff. I am about 160lbs and have had the psi set to 25%sag but I still only use a little over half of the travel. I'm thinking the next step is removing the token. I'm assuming it only comes with one. What is your experience with it and any tricks on setting it up?
@@frankschock9981 well, I am using the same amount of travel. There is about an inch that I am not using. However, I haven't been hitting too hard of trails lately. But, my suspension feels a lit more dialed in and even front to back. So, I'm 160lbs and I have no tokens In, with 75psi I believe. And so far it feels great to me.
@@zachel Cool thanks for the update. I also weigh 160 so I'll try the same setup. I just bought a 2019 Pike RC on ebay and was worried I would have to upgrade the damper to the Charger 2.1 RCT3 right away.
You mentioned that you only ride carbon rims...I've never had a set before but I'm considering them for my next bike. Have you ever cracked or broken a carbon rum before?
I actually have alloy rims on my trail enduro bike now since it's what they came with. But to answer your question, no, I have never cracked a carbon rim.
If you put the Maxxis recons 2.6 tires on it you will be set the specialized tires are heavy and not the best grip. The side wall support is un matched they feel like a 2.5 or 2.4 when properly inflated for the type of riding you like. I'm at 19psi for aggressive cornering and jumps
I'm just getting into mountain biking and am thinking about getting the alloy ST. It would be my only bike all-round bike. Would I cope or would the bike be too big?
Had the bike for about 10 months now and to me its awesome.I did my homework and research 3 bikes total. yeti sb 5.5 Santacruz High tower lt and the stumpy.Stumpjumper all the way for me.Sick handling and well rounded all around bike plus carbon wheelset hard to beat at that price point.Keep the good work.Quick question.I upgrade groupset last night.i swaped the cassette and rear derailleur to XO1 that matches exactly with the gx groupset.took my bike to replace the old shifter cable and when i got my bike back the mechanic cut a link off of my chain.I ordered a new chain today but ill get it friday.im planning on riding tomorrow.Is that a big deal?and also i just counted and i have 114 can you tell me how many links yours have because i cant find that info and i want to make sure i got the right lenght on the new chain. thanks
I'm traveling so I can't count it right now. Just put the bike in a stand or something and shift into the 50 and make sure the derailleur isn't stretched past its limit. If it starts to get there just don't go into the 50 till you get the new chain on.
It’s more in the geometry. The fork has a reduced offset on the newer stumpjumper’s and I think the front center is longer. I also really like the liveliness of the newer ones with no Horst Link pivot.
Hey Clint and friends, please guide me: I am inclined to buy a Stumpjumper 2020/2019, I am 5,8ft and normally ride an M bike, but I noticed that the Sumpjumper's reach is normally one size down (425mm instead of 445 for the M size). Should I get one size up (L) to have a similar reach as a normal M bike? ...or... Does the Stumpjumper somehow compensate the shorter reach?
@@ClintGibbs Thank you, I got a Stumpjumper Carbon Blue Chamalion 12-Speed (NX-Eagle). It's a little different than yours, mine came with FOX FLOAT Rhythm 34 Forks with 150mm of travel and FOX FLOAT DPS Performance Shocks with 140mm of travel. Sram guide R brakes as well. Not sure if those differences are better or worse. Another point is the Aloy (mine) vs. carbon wheels, no discussion witch is better here, you have compared them in your video.
I love stump jumper i have old one 26r and still doin what is supposed to do i love to have one of the 27.5 or 29r someday so i can enjoy riding on the trail like that nice bike. 👍🏼👍🏼👌👌
My favorite aftermarket wheel set would be from Stan's. Carbon is ideal if it fits in your budget. But their alloy rims are good too. I-9 wheels are also on the top of my list. Scwhalbe and Maxxis are my favorite tires. The Nobby Nics are a good all around trail tire.
@@ClintGibbs thanks for the information, I wanted to congratulate you for the excellent work you do in your channel, these videos of the stumjumper have given me good references for my purchase, they have been great, hey but with which you stayed for the project? giant or specialied
I noticed the same differences between Rockshox and Fox. Fox forks are a lot better with small bump performance, but I'd also say they're just better overall in performance.
I believe most of them were shot at either Alafia State Park or Hailes Trails in Newberry Florida, which are only open a couple times a year. This coming weekend is one of them!
@@ClintGibbs wow, that is a good way to put it, thanks. So the burly descending beast (Stumpy) would probably compare more to the Trance you think? of is it burlier then that one even?
Honestly the new frames are sick.
Yes yes they are!
Clint, the kind of guy that ACTUALLY links the videos in the comments that he SAYS he's going to link in the video. Well done.
One of the beautiest trail I've ever seen. Just want to be there.
EllasPOSEiDON too flat
Pretty sure most of the clips in this video are at Mala Compra in Palm Coast FL
Looks like Ocala, FL
Haha no dude. You don’t want to go to Florida to ride a mountain bike
Bought the Stumpjumper ST version, and it fixes everything negative you had to say about it, its the perfect bike for 80% of all trails.
yeah buddy!!!!
I also just got one on the Covid sale and am VERY stoked with my ST Stumpie
I got one as my first full suspension bike & have nothing to compare it to but in my opinion it’s a fantastic bike that eats the downhill sections & climbs like a beast
Great timing on your review. Just pulled the trigger today and bought the Comp Carbon 29. Specialized sale is ending this week so I saved around $750 bucks.
I love my 2019 stumpy expert 29er. As a taller rider 6"2 and around 105kgs I went for the XL and it fits me perfectly. I'm really glad I swapped my 27.5 order for a 29er. Just a more capable bike. And just as fun as my previous 27.5 enduro. Had the bike around 10 months now, ridden it through a winter and a summer and now coming back into another winter. It performs equally well in all conditions, although in really dry dusty conditions it can get a little nervous due to the stiffness.
The only areas I don't like are the rear shock and the amount of water that sits in the frame around the swat box/bottom bracket area. I'm looking at getting a custom tune or replacing with a super deluxe to fix the issue of needing to run 280psi plus even with the max number of reducers to prevent eating through the travel too rapidly. Having such high pressure means the small bump compliance is not great.
I also had a seat post failure in mine where it would randomly drop a little from top lockout. Specialized NZ rebuilt it with around a 3 week turn around.
TheHamishnz my command post failed too. Even after a “warranty” claim, it still didn’t work. Cost a bomb to fix.
I'm 6'2" as well but went for large this time. I wanted the shorter wheelbase. Worked out just fine. Love the bike!
I just got the 27.5 aluminum and love it. Thanks for putting out the videos, it helped in making my decision.
I bought the same model December 2019. I’ve been riding this bike ever since and completely agree with Clint’s analysis. I rode in Florida on Alafaya and Balm Boyette with it during the first couple years. Now riding San Felasco, and Santos a lot. The geometry of the frame really grips the trail and down hills. I feel very confident on it. He’s right about riding cross-country, especially with other fast riders. I have trouble keeping up with them and lose them on climbs. Down hills I can usually smoke everybody else. I had some problems with the guide brakes sticking, so replaced them with Migura Sport and really like those better. One advantage is the master cylinder is folded back on the brake lever and doesn’t stick out like the Shimano‘s and Guide’s. I replaced the rear tire with a Maxxis Assegai 2.6 which really plants the bike even more, however probably slows me down on cross country. When I replace the Butcher on the front, I’m going to try to find a lighter tire with still some grab to try to compensate for the greater weight of the Assegai, possibly a Vittoria.
Just bought this exact bike yesterday ( rocket red ) it will be ready on Friday and im so pumped! Got a sweet end of year deal from Specialized for $3600!!
Getting this exact bike today for $3k brand new, its a 2019 model
Rubber Side Down But how? It’s out of stock?
I have the alloy version and the overall themes describe my experience with the bike. A little slow on acceleration and climbs. Planted and confidence inspiring while still being playful on downhills. Love it.
I've had my 2019 SJ since Nov2018. My first ride was awful... The SJ came with the FlipChip set to Low which, along with the super wide bars and stubby stem made the bike climb like a pig. I was scared that I had made a huge mistake buying it. BUT, I flipped the chip to High and put on a -20deg 90mm stem and swapped on my 160mm Pike and viola, she climbs like an XC race bike and descends like a slacked out enduro rig. I can't believe the difference. I have since put on 33mmID LB rims laced up with Berd spokes on DT240 hubs... and put all of my 1x11 x01 drivetrain back on it w/e13's 9-46 cassette, 175mm Next SL cranks & bar. No pedal strike issues at all while climbing technical, chunky trails here in the Colorado Rockies. The bike weighs 26.5 lbs before I load the SWAT box full of sealant, pump, tube, derailleur hanger, tools, food, etc.
With over 20 years of riding and racing all over the Western US, this is the best bike that I've ever ridden by far. This is a bike I'll keep in the stable for many, many years to come.
I totally bought one because of your recommendation and love it . But I don't race and I mow over stuff so it fits my needs perfect.
I suggest regarding climbing... Give a purgatory 2.3 a try on the rear. You won't really notice any grip loss but will really notice the improved efficiency in climbing. It's a change I made on my 2019 comp alloy and like it. Another nice upgrade is carbon bars. The alloy spesh bars it comes with are quite heavy and adds compliance with carbon
Agreed on both counts. I actually went with 2.3 Ground Control tires as my trails are pretty tame compared to some. (Middle Tennessee). Climbs fine. Still Not a scorching xc climbing bike of course. But the fun on the way down is an 11 out of 10 😎
I put a 2.4 Rekon in the rear of my Carbon Comp with i9 wheels. Feels great!
@@invaderzimrocksify I've actually been loving either Maxxis dissector or nevigal2 both light and good grip
Always love your reviews, I currently own a 2014 Giant Trance and have just test ridden the Specialized Epic and then the Stumpy. I have now ordered the Stumpy Comp Carbon and managed an upgrade to carbon wheels in the deal. Looking forward to enjoying it as much as you Clint
Love the trail, man and thanks for the good feedback...helping me to decide to buy this bike from our local shop in Johannesburg.
great review!
Just upgraded my comp alloy stumpy 29er with a DPX2 at the rear and a fox 36 fork. super dialed now ! YEW
I have the same Bike and completely agree with you on the review. Great review. I love the SWAT storage. You can store there a lot of things. I dont have to wear a backpack anymore.
Absolutely love my '19 expert LT 29er. I dream about riding it and lust to look at it haha. Two changes I made were to swap to the new Shimano XT 4-piston brakes as I just don't like the feel, performance or durability of the Guides. Thought the R's were a bit under-spec'd on a $5,500 bike. Didn't care for the stock tires. They were slow and soft uphill as a result of floppy sidewalls although pretty good on the descent. Put some Maxxis WT 2.5 aggressor rear and Minion DHF front and totally transformed it. Overall best/favorite bike I've ever had.
Great review! I just ordered my Stumpy Expert on Friday. I actually rode Alifia a year and a half ago on an MTB trip to NC where I met family in Tampa at the end of the trip. I was pretty impressed and had a nice ride with some locals!
Another quality review with beautiful trail footage to go along with the informative commentary.
This one is on my shortlist, so I really appreciate the videos you've done on it. Thanks!
I’ve got about a hundred miles on the ‘19 Stumpjumper pro. Coming off the 2016 Stumpjumper expert I’m a bit surprised at the difference in feel from the 16 to the 19. The 2019 feels heavier but man the grip on berms, the confidence on flow and fast single tracks and jumps, it’s really just better! The only thing is the weight, I’ve considered shaving a pound by switching out the tires but I keep telling myself why? I’m not a pro, not racing, just out having fun staying fit. The 2.6 tires (I’m running tubeless) weigh almost 4 lbs together. anyone switched out the tires? comments on this are invited. I’d almost say you can turn this into a Xc bike by replacing tires with 2.2 and emptying the swat box. While in the saddle putting down power I’ve had no issues with squash and when outta the saddle it’s still respectable. Going down hill you’d crush anything like a epic or pivot 429sl. I was torn on what to buy, but now I’m happy with my choice. Dark blue with Kashima coating and I added the gold xx1. I’m not the most prolific biker out there but damn I look good doing it!
Those are my thoughts on the 2.6 tires as well. I at first wanted to swap them, but I don't race anymore, and the traction is great. I may throw a 2.3 Purgatory on the back when my 2.6 is worn and see how it feels, but for now I'm content with the 2.6.
Yep! Dont care for these tires. HEAVYYYY!!!There are definitely better choices for those of us who like a lighter feel that still grips.
Thanks for the review. I’m going to buy a frame and swap out my components from my 2016 STJ . I can’t decide between the Yeti SB130, Niner 29 RIP9 Rdo,or STJ. Every time I see you riding the STJ, it makes me want to get one.
Thank you for the thorough, thoughtful review!
I love that bike, I have a 2016 with the swat, which was probably the main reason I went for the carbon, that and the unique color and no graphics. If I was going to buy a new bike today, at or near the top of my list would be the current stumpjumper. I agree the saddle is good, so good I put the same saddle on my other bikes, I ride without padded shorts. I have the same tires on mine as well, almost too much grip. 2 weeks ago I rode Alifia for the first time and it handled everything there. Cheers.
The Specialized tires seem to be getting a lot of love around the TH-cam community... I think that it is BikeRadar who keeps using them as a baseline "good performer" in its tire comparisons!
They're good value too.
The specialized tires have been great for years and very well priced (although I guess not for long)
I have this same ride and the tires are very similar to the Maxxis Minions, but less expensive.
Excellent review, I just got a 2019 stumpjumper, thanks for you review.
I have this bike in 27.5. I love it!
Nice ... demoed a stumpjumper while visiting FL and I would consider it especially awesome for the mountain biking terrain there for sure.
Nice review Clint. I love mine so far! Upgraded the fork cartridge to the RCT3 cartridge, so now I have fully open, climb, and locked positions. Not sure if the people watching know that the stock fork only has a low speed compression damping, and that the fork is basically in a "fully open" position all the time in its stock form. It's a proprietary fork made by Rock Shox for Specialized, just like the Fox Rhythm fork as well. Overall, I'm psyched about riding it this season, as I had limited time on it this past Fall when I picked it up. Great bike, which I'd recommend to anyone!
Does the open setting on the RCT3 version feel identical to the RC model?
There's a newly released air can upgrade for your rear shock... Rockshox MegNeg air can, which adds more volume to the negative air chamber.... i hope you would try it and review the changes in characteristics of the bike after upgrading the air can.
I'd say that this "upgrade" is really just a fix for it's poor performance. It's a fix that you have to pay for in order for it to get closer to Fox quality design.
Great review and great cycling footage Clint, all good
this will def be my next bike, i currently have a 2020 rockhopper comp which i love. but full suspension im eye balling this model
Hi Clint, yes my stumpy was also a bit slow on the climbs, I swapped the tyres for XC tyres, grippy one on the front and fast one on the rear and it makes a huge difference on the climbs, staying with guys on XC hardtails, and it still handles fantastic on the rough stuff
Great review. Would You do a review about Trek Fuel EX? So interrested how it would be compared to Trance nad Stumpjumper
motomarek trek makes bikes too expensive for their spec
Thankyou for this video , you’ve convinced me to get it 😍
Have you tried the Stumpjumper ST? Would like to know your thoughts on difference especially for FL trails.
I have not but the trance 29 is similar in travel. It's a really really good trail bike for Florida.
At 5'9.5" I have ridden a Med, Large, and XL Stumjumper carbon 29. Loved the medium and XL. Cant jive with the large with any other shock than the Fox DPX2 Factory, which is too much money for me to justify riding.
So, I just bought a 2020 Stumjumper Carbon EVO S3 (large/xl) and its the best bike I've ever ridden: based on fit and kinematics. So strange as I've always thought a 66-degree headtube angle is slack!!!
Meanwhile, got to recommend this EVO, also the 2020 Reign 29 medium, and ofcourse the Ibis Ripmo size large as being the true standouts.
Now in 2020, I see you're riding a new Transition Sentinal 29. Thinking thats a definite solid-choice after riding the EVO. Mindblown how agile a bike with a near 50" wheelbase is!
Perhaps bikes are best near 63-65 hta and near 67-69 hta??? As if everything inbetween is somehow "vague" in contrast to the on-point experience of those two angles??? Maybe the EVO is just a special bike based on my size and background? Rides like a dream even with a 51 offset fork! Should seem weird for such a slack angle, or at least that's what Ive expected to experience over years of riding.
Anyway, just catching up. Times are adding up and the experiences are starting to stack up into newfound outlooks.
Is this bike "only" a trail bike ? I mean i would like this bike to take me to work everyday and take it to the trails on weekends, even tho i have a Road Bike i would like to use this one to do 40 miles everyday to work and back home. any advise ? Thanks guys !
I think a trail bike with this much travel and tires this big is going to feel slow as a commuter bike. If you were going to do that then I would put on smaller tires, like 2.35.
Question?? If I want to change the rear suspension to a spring on a ST stump jumper, what would you recommend? Would you do a "How to video"?
Spring has its own recoil versus a shock that's what then you do not want at all on a bike unless it's a Spring over a shock... Depending on what you want the bike for going downhill or cross country... Despite the timeframe you could actually have both won for cross-country and for downhill always use a shock because you can really be late the rebound.... Example, if you use a Spring going down Hill and you hit a good bump or rock it could buck you off the bike easily versus a shock that has a slow recoil setting
Beautiful trail footage
Thanks for your reviews. Watched them all, although I'm rather after the ST version, but since frames are the same, just suspension travel is different, I figuret I'll check them, and I don't regret it. Very infromative and competent. If you don't mind me asking - how exactly tall are you? You've said you're little over 5ft 8in? It that like around 175cm (I'm not very good with imperial system :) )? I'm 178cm tall, so between the sizes M and L, according to specialized size chart. Which one would you recommend?
I'm 173 cm. At your height I would go with a large.
Excellent video, just order a Specialized Stumpjumper ST Alloy 29, would you say it’s a reliable and solid bike for trails? I was between the Giant Trance and the Specialized Stumpjumper ST Alloy 29.
I have a 2016 SJ with the swat box and love it. The one thing that I will say is the swat box lid on these 2019's is disappointingly cheesy compared to mine. The opening on my 2016 is completely framed with pretty much a gasket seal. I wash my bike periodically with a pressure washer and never saw a drop of water in there. My buddy has this same 2019 expert and complains of water getting inside and when I looked at it there was no questions as to why.
I own 2 of 2016 SJ, an expert and sworks. And I can attest to this that I never had any water ingested into the swat box either. Now I will stop thinking of buying the 2019 as I will be frustrated if other resonates with your observation.
Nice review, I like that you put the dialogue over actual riding. I recognized most of the trails but was wondering where the rock quarry was located. I see You said balm and alafia, but never saw that.
I forgot I had some footage of Hailes Trails near Gainesville
Hi Clint Gibbs, out of curiosity how tall are you? I have a specialized Stumpjumper 29er FSR evolution and it is a medium frame also. I have always used a large frame with 27.5 wheels but this medium 29er Stumpjumper seems to be ok for size as well.
5'8". Medium SJ.
Great review, thanks. Loving mine! I've never run a tyre this wide before and I am curious whether a slightly narrower tyre would significantly improve the feel of the bike ... that said, the collective knowledge at Specialized isn't something I'd doubt.
Do you like the SRAM GX? I haven't heard good things about how well it changes gears compared to Shimano Deore.
I actually do like GX. There's not much difference in shift to performance between GX and XO. The only issue I have with SRAM is there seems to be one gear in the middle of the cassette does not hold very well. It's only with SRAM eagle. Other than that it shifts fine.
Clint, with the current bike shortage, I'm lucky to be getting an opportunity to pick up the new Specialized Status 2020 bike. A friend and bike shop owner tells me that the geo is similar to a Stumpy. The thing is, I do want to race XC. In your honest opinion, do you think this kind of geo would be ok to race (northeast single track - lots of roots & rocks but no big drops) or would you suggest waiting and getting another XC / Trail bike?
In my book pedaling efficiency and bike weight is more important than geo numbers for racing. Check out my video release of the new transition Spur. it has angles I never thought would be fast on a cross-country course, but it proved me wrong.
Clint I’m 5’10.5 with a 31 inch Inseam so kind of mote torso than legs. I sit i between many mediums and large. I ride now a Santa Cruz large 29’er. I felt like a long time like I sit very high but it feels good once I get rolling. I did switch back from clipless to flat 5-10 shoes with good pegged pedals since I feel better in tech areas. So what do you think a large is right for me?
I have the same inseam as you. So it's really going to come down to the reach. Try to ride both. If you feel like you're too squished on a medium as far as the reach then go at the large. If you like a bike that's more maneuverable then go with a medium.
I was looking at the 27.5 and the 29 version, did you ever have a chance to try the other wheel size of this bike model? Was curious how they felt. Thanks!
Not the 27.5 stumpjumper but plenty of other 27.5 bikes. Search my channel for 29 vs 27.5 trailblakes. I've done a few videos that hopefully should help.
Thanks for the great videos! Picked up a Stumpy Expert in April after watching your videos. Great ride! Wondering if you have noticed a slight clicking/creaking in the front suspension when riding over roots or bumps? So annoying and just came on today. Any advice?
I have not experienced that. I know it sounds really simple but check to make sure your front axle is tight enough.
Simple it was...it was coming from the plastic tail of the SWAT wrap inside the frame flapping around! Haha. Drove me nuts!
The ST/LT frames differ by shocks & yoke. What's the actual difference in the frames between 27.5" frames and 29er frames? Can one put 29er wheels on the 27 w/o compromise?
Thanks for the review. I ride alafia and carter road primarily in FL. I’ve ridden the 27.5 version and it was a ton of fun. Do you think the 29 is too large for some of the tight stuff we have in FL?
Are you locking out both shocks when you go for xc speed???
I believe that is why its there, to improve speed when on flat or incline terrain.
I would like your comments on the 2020 Trance Advanced Pro 29 3 ? Seems like a price that is too good to be true?? thanks!
I think this bike back wheel will get blocked by various trail elements (ie.e leaves, sticks) because the clearance is very little between the frame and the wheel visible at 2.17. What do you think?
I recently purchased this model and am having trouble getting the suspension dialed in. The front fork seems so stiff. I am about 160lbs and have had the psi set to 25%sag but I still only use a little over half of the travel. I'm thinking the next step is removing the token. I'm assuming it only comes with one. What is your experience with it and any tricks on setting it up?
Yes, absolutely remove a token. Easy to do and will most likely make the changes you're looking for
@@ClintGibbs hey thanks for the quick response. I appreciate your input and your videos.
@@zachel Did removing the token take care of the issue?
@@frankschock9981 well, I am using the same amount of travel. There is about an inch that I am not using. However, I haven't been hitting too hard of trails lately. But, my suspension feels a lit more dialed in and even front to back.
So, I'm 160lbs and I have no tokens In, with 75psi I believe. And so far it feels great to me.
@@zachel Cool thanks for the update. I also weigh 160 so I'll try the same setup. I just bought a 2019 Pike RC on ebay and was worried I would have to upgrade the damper to the Charger 2.1 RCT3 right away.
Bike shop recommended a medium for me, I’m 5’10 32” inseam. Seems many have large. Any thoughts (not able to test prior).
Medium sounds right. You could ride a large but it may feel less maneuverable
You mentioned that you only ride carbon rims...I've never had a set before but I'm considering them for my next bike. Have you ever cracked or broken a carbon rum before?
I actually have alloy rims on my trail enduro bike now since it's what they came with. But to answer your question, no, I have never cracked a carbon rim.
Swapped the tyres for minion dhr and dhf completely game changer 👌
Also, Assegai front, DHR rear, works even better for the Stumpy than DHF/DHR pairing, based on my experience
If you put the Maxxis recons 2.6 tires on it you will be set the specialized tires are heavy and not the best grip. The side wall support is un matched they feel like a 2.5 or 2.4 when properly inflated for the type of riding you like. I'm at 19psi for aggressive cornering and jumps
Do you know the maximum chainring with this bike?
I'm just getting into mountain biking and am thinking about getting the alloy ST. It would be my only bike all-round bike. Would I cope or would the bike be too big?
Good choice for a very versatile bike
Where are the trails that you did this review?
Alafia River State Park and Balm Boyette
Great video Clint. Question... I’m 6’3 230, I own the same bike in XL. Would you recommend me upgrading the rear shock? Or leaving it alone?
If you are getting proper sag on the shock I would just leave all the volume spacers in there and use it.
Had the bike for about 10 months now and to me its awesome.I did my homework and research 3 bikes total. yeti sb 5.5 Santacruz High tower lt and the stumpy.Stumpjumper all the way for me.Sick handling and well rounded all around bike plus carbon wheelset hard to beat at that price point.Keep the good work.Quick question.I upgrade groupset last night.i swaped the cassette and rear derailleur to XO1 that matches exactly with the gx groupset.took my bike to replace the old shifter cable and when i got my bike back the mechanic cut a link off of my chain.I ordered a new chain today but ill get it friday.im planning on riding tomorrow.Is that a big deal?and also i just counted and i have 114 can you tell me how many links yours have because i cant find that info and i want to make sure i got the right lenght on the new chain. thanks
I'm traveling so I can't count it right now. Just put the bike in a stand or something and shift into the 50 and make sure the derailleur isn't stretched past its limit. If it starts to get there just don't go into the 50 till you get the new chain on.
THANKS
Are the hubs DT swiss 340s with specialized logos?
Приветствую! Скажите по прошествии времени разница между поколениями Stampy 2019 vs 2021 сильно чувствуется?
The geometry for descending on the 2021 is better in my opinion. It’s not a huge difference but it is noticeable.
@@ClintGibbsа работа подвески на спуске? Ведь в новом убрали FSR и хода меньше стало. Только из за углов рулевой трубы стало лучше на спуске?
It’s more in the geometry. The fork has a reduced offset on the newer stumpjumper’s and I think the front center is longer. I also really like the liveliness of the newer ones with no Horst Link pivot.
Hey Clint and friends, please guide me: I am inclined to buy a Stumpjumper 2020/2019, I am 5,8ft and normally ride an M bike, but I noticed that the Sumpjumper's reach is normally one size down (425mm instead of 445 for the M size). Should I get one size up (L) to have a similar reach as a normal M bike? ...or... Does the Stumpjumper somehow compensate the shorter reach?
Medium for sure
@@ClintGibbs Thank you, I got a Stumpjumper Carbon Blue Chamalion 12-Speed (NX-Eagle). It's a little different than yours, mine came with FOX FLOAT Rhythm 34 Forks with 150mm of travel and FOX FLOAT DPS Performance Shocks with 140mm of travel. Sram guide R brakes as well. Not sure if those differences are better or worse. Another point is the Aloy (mine) vs. carbon wheels, no discussion witch is better here, you have compared them in your video.
@@APOCLAG congrats!
Sweet review. Would it be alright if you change the front suspension from 150mm travel to 160mm? Thoughts?
I don't think it would throw off the geo too much. But I would check with specialized to make sure it doesn't void the warranty.
thanks for the info, i ridden a 29er and i love it, i am 5'4" height, can i use 27.5 tyres on a 29er stumpjumper?
I would not recommend it unless the manufacturer specifically makes a frame that allows for both.
@@ClintGibbs thanks
I love stump jumper i have old one 26r and still doin what is supposed to do i love to have one of the 27.5 or 29r someday so i can enjoy riding on the trail like that nice bike. 👍🏼👍🏼👌👌
2:18 maybe put motofoam or something similar in there to keep things from getting in, I ahven't tried stuff like this.
Where are the trails this was filmed at?
Alafia River State Park
@@ClintGibbs thankyou
I have this and agree about the tyres. It’s slow on the flat - what tyres or wheels should I swap for ?
My favorite aftermarket wheel set would be from Stan's. Carbon is ideal if it fits in your budget. But their alloy rims are good too. I-9 wheels are also on the top of my list. Scwhalbe and Maxxis are my favorite tires. The Nobby Nics are a good all around trail tire.
Nice review. One question: hoy much does it weigh?
Can't remember off the top of my head but I did mention it in the first look video I believe.
Hey clint! What do you think about this bike in 2024? Worth purchasing second hand?
Yes. The geometry is still relevant. Just make sure the person who had it took good care of it.
What trails are these?
Do you think this bike can be set as a xc bike, 130 front, 120 rear?
Yes for riding XC trails; no for competitive XC racing. My opinion.
What trail are you riding on? It’s a great trail and I’m in FL!
I think most of those shots were Alafia and Hailes Trails.
Clint Gibbs Thanks I’ll look them up
How much does it weigh?
HEY CLINT, IN WHICH PLACE YOU PUT ON TRIAL TO THAT MACHINE
The trail is Alafia River State Park
@@ClintGibbs thanks for the information, I wanted to congratulate you for the excellent work you do in your channel, these videos of the stumjumper have given me good references for my purchase, they have been great, hey but with which you stayed for the project? giant or specialied
What trail is this? I must go there.
I have the stump jumper evo and I love it.
what size is the shock?
I noticed the same differences between Rockshox and Fox. Fox forks are a lot better with small bump performance, but I'd also say they're just better overall in performance.
iS DIT MOONTLIK DAT DIE RALIEGH mxr dc 29er KAN OP KRY om uit te toets
Sick bike, can anybody explain why they make the handle bar so wide.
Lots of control and leverage. Standard on today's trail and enduro bikes
spec does have some the nicest paint colors.
What width are those handlebars they look huge.
780. Pretty standard for a trail bike with 150mm travel.
Do all specialized comes with a shock pump?
No
Tested this bike on Happy Bike Days in Belgium Houffalize and I can confirm it is a great bike
Would love to see ya ride and review a canyon or yt..your bike reviews are top notch
So which would you would buy the stumpy or trance?
If I needed longer travel I would use the stumpy LT, for shorter travel the trance
Best Bike EVER.....
What’s the name of that stand?
That's the scorpion stand by feedback sports. Here's my review on it:
th-cam.com/video/45Hkka6MbdE/w-d-xo.html
where are those trails?
I believe most of them were shot at either Alafia State Park or Hailes Trails in Newberry Florida, which are only open a couple times a year. This coming weekend is one of them!
How is the ride different then the Anthem 29"?
Very very different. Long travel 29er versus short travel. One feels super light and agile. The other one feels burly and a descending beast.
@@ClintGibbs wow, that is a good way to put it, thanks. So the burly descending beast (Stumpy) would probably compare more to the Trance you think? of is it burlier then that one even?
@@31acruz Yes, more similar to the trance 29. Stumpjumper does not climb as well but is more capable on rough descents.