Great overview! Really need to get one of these on a playdate. I feel you on being stuck between sizes. I'm always having to size up to an XL for the extra reach.
I haven't bought a mountain bike in years but i sprang for the comp alloy 29 I am glad I did what a great bike, it exceeded my expectations and i am 220 lbs
Wow, a review with the bike being ridden the way it's supposed to be. You stopped and showed it to us, then rode it on a great trail. Nice bike, nice review.
@@jctrails your here for the people ? With money?? Or people in general ??? Because unless you Have money the s works model is a little un affordable......
Mate this review has help me a lot because I don’t know what to get this or the trex remedy 8 but this bike looks brilliant because nowhere in my town has it so I can’t review it myself
@JCTrails I just bought a SJ XL(I put 18 miles on it my first two days), your vid helped me learn about the bike, and MB's in general. I'm a newbie to the community. I'm looking forward to improving my skills, getting out and riding some trails here in NorCal. I appreciate you sharing your passion. Keep posting vids!!!
JC thanks for such a good test on this bike on a large variety of trails!! That other rider was freaking ripping!!! Running into him out there on the same bike is just crazy but it also was great to get 2 opinions on the same bike too! Thanks for doing an excellent job again man!!
MTB Savant thanks brotha! Stayed up to 3am to crank out this edit for you. You definitely need to get on a Stumpy it feels like a 4.5 on steroids. Almost pedals as good too.
Nice review man, I rode the 29er expert yesterday at Sea Otter...the bike rip's and the only issue I have with the build is brakes! A bike this capable, encourages you to go faster a lot faster...more brakes please. Just for the record I'm a big dude, at 235lb the brakes got their work cut out for them! Overall really impressed with the ride.
IMO i cannot tell the difference between SLX and XT in terms of braking power. I'd look at 4 piston options (saint/code) if the slx aren't powerful enough.
I need to try this one- I just rented a sweet #scottgenius 2016 and it was fantastic... However, it was my 1st Squishy. I need to test a few more before committing funds. This vid is impressively supporting the Stumpjumer brand! Thanks!
Hey man, I am looking to get a 150mm travel Specialized Stumpjumper, I am 176cm 5’9 in height and 68kg, 140 pounds, so I don’t know if I should get a M or L sized 29er, also I an coming from a 2016 Scott Genius LT 720, any feedback would be appreciated 😃
I saw that youre jumps (landings) were pretty smooth. Have you had also a hard landing with this bike ? I'm concerned that the frame breaks when you jump hard in a flat.
I have the same issue with Spesh bikes. I’m 6ft 2 and The XL is too long for me and the large too small. I’ve had 2 Spesh bikes and will probably go for a different brand next time
Dang us 6' 2" bros got it tough. I test rode an XL Stumjumper ST with 29" wheels (though I prefer 27.5") and it felt ok, but I'm coming from riding a cheapish XC hardtail so just about everything I tested felt miles better lol
I have this bike and i love it. Out of all the bikes i have had this is my favorite one. I'm Picking up the 2020 stumpjumper st in the next couple months.
Jamie, what made you go ST instead of Comp and how are you liking it? I just moved near Santa Cruz CA, this is on the top of my list, and I'm wondering big it's necessary to spend an extra $700 for an extra 20 mills of travel?
Clay Follmar I own both I have a 2019 alloy comp and the 2020 ST. The reason I have both is cause I work for a bike store. I have customers that ask about the ST and some that ask about the long travel comp. I wanted to buy them for myself as I wanted to be able to show the customers the difference and be able to compare them. I am a hardcore mtb rider I also have an enduro coming in. Just waiting for Specialized to get stock
Man, I love my 2009 Specialized Pitch Comp, and I have always looked at the Stumpy, but that new TREK intrigues me too!!! Although I am looking for a aggressive hardtail like the fuse or stache. But, this video is pretty killer and kinda making me rethink.... damn🤔, lol.. Live-Life-Loud, Bro!!!!
For sure put this bike in the pro-pedal when climbing... horst link is super active and will climb much better with some pedal management. This is why Spesh used to always use the brain.... but it sucked! Nice review James!
MTB yumyum Thanks Jason! Specialized definitely did their homework with this new frame. The stiffened frame accompanied with the tweaked Horst link created an effective pedaling platform that remains very playful and poppy. Hopefully you can demo one, I would love to hear your opinion on how it handles Corner Canyon.
Just got the S3 Evo. Would suggest largest rear volume spacer and 60 mm stem for bigger riders. The 45mm is to darn short for centered balance. I am 6'2" 240
Great review, I plan on doing a demo this week! What do you think between this and your old ride yeti 4.5c? These two are both on my want/need to demo list...
Mark they are both awesome bikes at different ends of the spectrum. The 4.5 is an aggressive XC / fast pedaling trail bike and the Stumpy is an aggressive trail bike that can handle chunk better. So it depends what your going to do with your bike. For where I live the 4.5 was more than enough and could not beat the pedaling characteristics of the bike.
I just picked up the last that i could find here in my area. A SJ comp alloy. 27.5 thesame specs only an alloy. Havent tested it yet but im looking forward to it..🤙😀 Plus its on sale.
Nice review! I'm looking at buying a 2020 Stumpy. Also struggling to choose between L and M giving I'm 5'10'' 32 inseam! Just worried I might want to run a longer stem if going medium.
SJ Comp or Hightower or Ripmo AF or Niner Rip 9 RDO? The choices are hard so many good bikes. Wish there were more demos in my area to be able to find the best fit.
lol i saw it right after i sent the comment and i just face palmed a little. I didnt like the white that much until i saw the downtube in your videos and now I'm really abouot it
Nice vid JC! How does the suspension feel compared to a Pike RC fork and a Deluxe RT3? Also the SRAM GX compared to the Shimano on the Spec.? Just picked up a enduro demo from bike barn Friday I’ll be ripping down pine hills tomorrow!
christopher c the pike is going to have better small bump compliance and more plush feel to it. The shock will feel very similar to the fox on the comp. The Rock Shox shock might ramp up a little harder at the end of the stroke. Hopefully I will see you out on the trail.
JC Trails great video! what do you think about do all Bike ? Stumpy can cover cross country lanes or will be to much Bike ? Need to get one Bike for all type rides, xc, trial, all day trips
Lukasz P I would look into getting the Short Travel Stumpy it can handle all the above. The regular Stumpy can handle it too, but with less efficiency.
JC TRAILS thank you for getting back to me, this is the problem as I'm going for alloy frame version :) I know about st with alloy frame but I don't like the spec
What state are you in? That looks like a really fun mountain. I have the specialized fuse and have been looking at these stump jumpers. Thank for the good review.
I know this is unusual question but could u tell me which bike around $4000 full suspension. Is the most comfortable sitting up right position for flat riding. I want one for flat that will be super comfortable crossing sidewalks in city without getting sore now I have specialized bike that has no suspension at all and I’m looking for full suspension! And once in a while I’ll go off road but 95% I won’t. Thank u
ugh, at the end of November, I picked up a New 2018 Stumpjumper Expert with the Carbon Rims. With the winter we have had, it has only been ridden twice. Then I see all this about the new 2019 SJ :(
Great review. My trails aren't enough for a 150mm 29er and I'd prefer the 120mm ST, but the only options are the very poor spec base 1850 or all the way up to the 4200 carbon comp ST. The 3000 Comp Alloy 29 only comes in the LT 150. Do you think I would even notice the difference between the ST and LT? Meaning just get the LT even though it might be too much?
I just picked mine up, same build but with the Roval Traverse SL carbon wheels -- love it. The thing really pops and turns like no other 29r I've ridden.
Hey man great video! I'm getting ready to buy a stump jumper but i'm torn between the "pro" model and the "comp carbon" model. is the pro model really worth it for 2 more grand with it having the DX2 rear shock carbon wheels and 36 factory fox forks? and would the weight be a huge difference from the alloys on the comp to the carbon on the pro? thanks in advance dude keep on shredding!
Hi at first a good video! Can you tell me if there's a big difference to the Hightower LT or are they werry similar espacially on the rear travel because the HTLT has 150mm? Wich one of both would you recoment for a bike to ride Trails, sometimes Park, Enduro races and also often uphill? Thanks for your answer and sorry for my bad english. Cheers!
MilanHorst thanks! If your looking for a bike to ride your local trails 90% of the time and other 10% riding park and racing. I would recommend the Stumpy you can always beef up the suspension at a later date. The LT can also pedal your local trails but you will lose some efficiency and speed through. The LT though is awesome when pointed down, it feels more plush and stable when pushed hard. I hope this helps.
JC Trails, Can you please do a review on the 2019 Stumpjumper Expert 27.5? I was hoping you or MTB Yum Yum would have tested this by now but it seems that the market is in the 29 models because they’re all over the bike shops and TH-cam and no 27.5 LT review. I had 2016 Stumpjumper Carbon Comp 29 with Roval SL Fatties 2.3 Butcher F/2.3 GC R @27.4 lbs and sold that last year and built my all time favorite bike (again). A 2013 Santa Cruz TRC 26. Because the Stumpjumper 29 was too calm and more of a “pedal & plow” kinda bike. At least for me but maybe that’s because I’m short at 5’6”, 30.6” inseam. Although I already have this 2019 Expert 27.5 for a week now and rode it 3x already, I still would like to hear your opinion on it. I feel that it’s my Blur TRC and Stumpy29 combined! It likes to pop of stuff and the rearend is stiff! I leave it open all the time unlike the TRC, I have to switch to pedal or firm mode on the climbs. I haven’t felt this fun in a long time and not to mention I picked up the bike brand new at a LBS for $4500 OTD and they gave me $400 gift card. Total $4100 OTD for an Expert during the Black Friday Sale! I already upgraded the wheels to 38mm Roval Carbon with the OE tires. So much fun!🤘 Please review. Thanks!
Nice ride and awesome review! How did the Fox 34 Rhythm hold up? I am considering the Alloy Comp version of this bike and that seemed to be the only component spec that stuck out as not being so great. Bike is still only $3K for the alloy comp which is sweet!
mike Bussart I’m going Stumpy just enough squish for the big hits but still pedals well. The LT is too much bike for my local trails, but if I was an Enduro racer LT all day.
How does this bike stack up against your Yeti 4.5 you had? I know this one is probably more capable on the down hills but I would love to hear your thoughts. I currently have the 4.5
Mason the 4.5 is one of the best pedaling bikes I have ever ridden, with that being said. The Stumpy is not far off. It’s definitely more capable on the downs, but if you put a better rear shock on the 4.5 (dpx2 or monarch plus) it will help plush out the bike. If I had to pick one bike it would be the Stumpy, it fits my riding style.
mr manny I'm actually comfortable on both. The medium feels just a little a bit more flickable, but the large feels like I could pedal harder on. I'm going to demo the large next.
This is an odd question, but could you try to compare the Fuse vs the Stumpjumper? I had the Fuse (loved it) but I'm thinking maybe the ST stumpy is the way to go. Where I live is mostly flow, but we do have some rare legit steep stuff too. I really like snappy, playful bikes so jib around on. Thoughts??? Thanks!
Nick F I loved the Fuse, but if you are looking for a full suspension I think ST Stumpy is the bike for you and your terrain. The regular stumpy is very playful so I can imagine the ST would be even more playful.
JC TRAILS Thanks for the fast reply! I'm leaning towards the ST. Just need to try it on the trails. Hopefully it's more lively than the other Full Susp I've tried in the past! Keep making these awesome videos!!
JC Trails , I am looking to purchase new bike soon. I want something playful , poppy and that I can throw around without issue. Think about bmx street riding and dirt jumping. :) Used to a 29 but thinking about 27.5 just because its smaller. Have you demo'd the 27.5 comp alloy? or would the 29 comp alloy fit what I'm looking for?
anthony brady if your looking for a fun poopy bike I would go with the 27.5 short travel Stumpy. I just rode it today at a bike park and it's super fun!
JC TRAILS how was the 275 on the trails? Anything you didn’t like? Or liked? Not the biggest fan that of the st base models setup. But can’t afford comp carbon.
So, would you say the regular model is better than the ST for trails in YOUR area? I'm in the market for a new bike and also happen to be moving to southeast MA from PA in a couple of months. Thanks!
Matthew Perry the ST is more than enough bike for we live, but if you want to go to a bike park or ride some rowdy stuff the regular Stumpy can handle it.
Thanks! I'm really having trouble deciding, I think the regular probably makes more sense, I just really dig the carbon black on the ST expert. I know looks shouldn't matter, but I can't help it, lol.
Bullcity I've never ridden a Jeffsey, but it does come with an awesome spec for the money. It just stinks you can't test ride them before buying it. So money would go to Specialized.
So did Bike Barn Racing make you an offer you just couldn't refuse on the demo bike? I see at the end of the video you have it set up with a Rental cockpit...looks like James got a new bike?
You have a keen eye Dan. I was just trying out a bigger stem on the bike to see if I could get that perfect fit. No new bike sorry. Hopefully new bike day will be soon😏
Right on, good luck! I have been wrestling with the new bike purchase myself, so may good bikes to choose from. The 2019 Stumpjumper is really high on my list... I sold my Bronson and was planning on going HTLT. But last weekend we had a Santa Cruz demo at my local trails in Napa CA...BKXC just posted a video there. and I was blown away by the Tallboy. I rode the HTLT, Tallboy, and the Nomad(really good too pedals beter then the Bronson)... I wasn't even planning on riding the Tallboy, is crazy how good a 110mm rear travel bike can be
landed here bc I thought this was the Stumpjumper ST for ~$1800... the alloy. Now I want this one but it's twice as much lol. Anyone have any experience with the Alloy version?
JCtrails , I am ver close to committing funds to an alloy 29er on on the 29 SJ comp. I’m 5,10 170 lbs. should I go medium or large, my 2016 SJ was large and felt stable but slightly less wieldy than the medium I just demoed. I’m torn! Please advise.
Hey Thomas I would go with a size large and put a 40mm stem on it. You can always move the seat a little forward if you feel if the top tube is a little long.
Gus i’d go with an alloy to start i recommend a bike with 27.5 tires also make sure you buy a bike with at least 130 mm of travel. Possibly a xl frame depending on brand you buy
I would second starting with an alloy frame. It’s hard to swallow the huge price of carbon for your 1st bike. A size XL with 27.5x2.6 tires would be a great fit for you with your bmx back ground.
@@jctrails is your main reasoning for not suggesting carbon because of cost or you think I'm better off with an Alloy because it is stronger? I've had a $500 MTB for years and its a tank so I really do want a light bike just wansn't to sure about strength and reliability of carbon.
Thanks man.... I bought the base aluminum version on 29er (less than 1,700 at local BIke Shop -good deal to be in a budget). I went for the medium at 5’10.5 and 178.... I may change the stem for a few extra mm... I’m more incline to XC style riding but I found this a good do it all bike....
Ok, so VPP or this new FSR link? Is it still a lil rough? That's what I noticed between the 2 suspension designs. VPP was much better than the old FSR design.
Ken Cycles they feel so similar, but I'm liking the new FSR a little better. When your pedaling over the rough stuff the FSR linkage seems to track better.
Great overview! Really need to get one of these on a playdate. I feel you on being stuck between sizes. I'm always having to size up to an XL for the extra reach.
Thanks Joe! Definitely get your leg over one, I think you will really enjoy it. Plus you can run your plus wheels on it, so that's a plus
Same here. I'm at 6'2" so it was hard to choose.
@@thedude8526 what did you do? Im 6'2" and went with xl.
I haven't bought a mountain bike in years but i sprang for the comp alloy 29 I am glad I did what a great bike, it exceeded my expectations and i am 220 lbs
I love watching demos during the new bike search - thanks for taking us along for the ride!
gr8fulhiker no problem man!
Wow, a review with the bike being ridden the way it's supposed to be. You stopped and showed it to us, then rode it on a great trail. Nice bike, nice review.
EJ Cena thanks man!
Thanks for not testing the s-works that most people can not afford.
I'm here for the people! This bike is still pretty pricey.
@@jctrails your here for the people ?
With money??
Or people in general ???
Because unless you Have money the s works model is a little un affordable......
I literally just got this bike used two days ago.mines from 2019. So far it’s insane. It climbs well and shreds the downhills
Mate this review has help me a lot because I don’t know what to get this or the trex remedy 8 but this bike looks brilliant because nowhere in my town has it so I can’t review it myself
Nice job! Hearing a lot of good things about the stumpy, especially how snappy and quick it steers for a 29'er.
PukesNukem bike rips! If you have a chance to demo one, do it.
@JCTrails I just bought a SJ XL(I put 18 miles on it my first two days), your vid helped me learn about the bike, and MB's in general. I'm a newbie to the community. I'm looking forward to improving my skills, getting out and riding some trails here in NorCal. I appreciate you sharing your passion. Keep posting vids!!!
Awesome Chris! Enjoy that Stumpy in NorCal!
JC thanks for such a good test on this bike on a large variety of trails!! That other rider was freaking ripping!!! Running into him out there on the same bike is just crazy but it also was great to get 2 opinions on the same bike too! Thanks for doing an excellent job again man!!
I was crazy running into him on the day the Stumpy was released. I'm glad you enjoyed the review.
Specialized makes some nice tires. I run purgatory in front and a slaughter in the back. Even on my trek fuel. Nice review and video work
Thanks man!
Nice! I'm from mass living in Australia, nice to see BikeBarn on here. Looks awesome.
Jay Mueller so awesome!
Glad I didn't have to wait long to hear your feedback on this bike. Great review.
MTB Savant thanks brotha! Stayed up to 3am to crank out this edit for you. You definitely need to get on a Stumpy it feels like a 4.5 on steroids. Almost pedals as good too.
I know. I'm afraid I'll like it too much lol
MTB Savant come on just try it!
Nice review man, I rode the 29er expert yesterday at Sea Otter...the bike rip's and the only issue I have with the build is brakes! A bike this capable, encourages you to go faster a lot faster...more brakes please. Just for the record I'm a big dude, at 235lb the brakes got their work cut out for them! Overall really impressed with the ride.
Dan Williams I hear you. The guide r’s are ehh, throw some XT brakes on there and that would be one sick bike.
IMO i cannot tell the difference between SLX and XT in terms of braking power. I'd look at 4 piston options (saint/code) if the slx aren't powerful enough.
Wow this stumpy looks like a blast to ride.
JF Rides this thing is super playful but can still crush some downhills.
This bike looks amazing! You were flying out there. Now I know what I want to demo next chance I get.
♥️ the threaded BB, death to press fit lol
BlindstuffMTB it seems that Specialized actually listened to the people!
Awesome video and informative. This is the bike i'll probably get. SUBBED !!
Roger S thanks! It’s an awesome bike, I’m sure you’ll love it.
Im 5'9" and went for the large frame. It felt better than the M for some reason.
I need to try this one- I just rented a sweet #scottgenius 2016 and it was fantastic... However, it was my 1st Squishy. I need to test a few more before committing funds. This vid is impressively supporting the Stumpjumer brand! Thanks!
AllynGoo Martin it's a great bike, give it a ride.
Hey man, I am looking to get a 150mm travel Specialized Stumpjumper, I am 176cm 5’9 in height and 68kg, 140 pounds, so I don’t know if I should get a M or L sized 29er, also I an coming from a 2016 Scott Genius LT 720, any feedback would be appreciated 😃
Same here...help!!!
I love Specialized MTBs. Great bikes.
JuliusCesar2781 Specialized killed it with this one!
You was that fast on the trail that I wonder how you achive not hitting the trees. Good job !!!!! 1a+
JuliusCesar2781 I have hit my share of trees.
I saw that youre jumps (landings) were pretty smooth. Have you had also a hard landing with this bike ? I'm concerned that the frame breaks when you jump hard in a flat.
JuliusCesar2781 it can handle anything you can throw at it.
Great video. Where are these trails, look so fun!
I have the same issue with Spesh bikes. I’m 6ft 2 and The XL is too long for me and the large too small. I’ve had 2 Spesh bikes and will probably go for a different brand next time
Pricey 78 so many good bikes out there these days.
Dang us 6' 2" bros got it tough. I test rode an XL Stumjumper ST with 29" wheels (though I prefer 27.5") and it felt ok, but I'm coming from riding a cheapish XC hardtail so just about everything I tested felt miles better lol
Same here, bro. What bike did you go with in the end? Thanks
I have this bike and i love it. Out of all the bikes i have had this is my favorite one. I'm Picking up the 2020 stumpjumper st in the next couple months.
Love the ST!
Jamie, what made you go ST instead of Comp and how are you liking it? I just moved near Santa Cruz CA, this is on the top of my list, and I'm wondering big it's necessary to spend an extra $700 for an extra 20 mills of travel?
Clay Follmar I own both I have a 2019 alloy comp and the 2020 ST. The reason I have both is cause I work for a bike store. I have customers that ask about the ST and some that ask about the long travel comp.
I wanted to buy them for myself as I wanted to be able to show the customers the difference and be able to compare them.
I am a hardcore mtb rider I also have an enduro coming in. Just waiting for Specialized to get stock
@@jamiealite Out of the ST and the COMP, which do you recommend as a better all rounder?
Clay Follmar I prefer the comp way better ride. A lot cushier suspension
Man, I love my 2009 Specialized Pitch Comp, and I have always looked at the Stumpy, but that new TREK intrigues me too!!! Although I am looking for a aggressive hardtail like the fuse or stache. But, this video is pretty killer and kinda making me rethink.... damn🤔, lol.. Live-Life-Loud, Bro!!!!
Only The Bold Project thanks man! That Stache looks pretty sweet!
New review...thanks. looks like a great bike. All for the threaded BB. press fit is such a ball ache.
parsnips rides even better!
For sure put this bike in the pro-pedal when climbing... horst link is super active and will climb much better with some pedal management. This is why Spesh used to always use the brain.... but it sucked! Nice review James!
Also, is this 60pfs?
MTB yumyum Thanks Jason! Specialized definitely did their homework with this new frame. The stiffened frame accompanied with the tweaked Horst link created an effective pedaling platform that remains very playful and poppy. Hopefully you can demo one, I would love to hear your opinion on how it handles Corner Canyon.
MTB yumyum I actually left the camera on full auto 4K 30fps. I forgot to turn on protunes where I usually adjust the sharpness to Low.
MTB yumyum They've revamped the horst link on this tho!
Trevor Bohnsack this revamped link is more progressive now , makes the bike feel so poppy.
I sat on that same model in Large on Tues. Too small for me ( 6'7")... Picked up an XL Comp Alloy yesterday. Ready to ride it!!!
Alden Wilkins yeah I can imagine the large being way to small for you. Congrats on the new bike, it's sick.
Alden Wilkins How is alloy in your opinion ?
Lukasz P I am loving it. But I have never ridden a carbon bike, soni can't really compare them.
Alden Wilkins Thank man, I am looking for my first FS, not sure about travel, 29er comp alloy waiting for me in the shop
@Alden Wilkins I'm 6'7 too how are you finding the bike?
Just got the S3 Evo. Would suggest largest rear volume spacer and 60 mm stem for bigger riders. The 45mm is to darn short for centered balance. I am 6'2" 240
Thanks for the info Daniel.
Rear hub sucks
Daniel May it does that's why I replaced the wheels immediately
Nice! This bike is top of my list at the moment.
Joshua Ryan buy it you won’t regret it.
It's an end of the year purchase for me and of course I need to test it out myself too but so far I really like what I'm seeing, great review, thanks!
Joshua Ryan no problem.
JC TRAILS Is there a frame only option for this other than sworks green?
Trevor Bohnsack nope I think the Kiwi green and purple is the only frame option.
What's the SJ like going downhill? Pretty stable? Looking for a trail bike I can hit up the occasional bike park with, is the SJ that bike???
Toogy Howser MTB oh yeah the Stumpy can handle the park. Especially if you put a fox 36 or lyrik fork on it.
Great Review. #1 on my list with #2 being IBIS Ripmo - now if I only can find a demo bike here in NJ! :/
Steven Kim that Ripmo looks awesome, I need to throw my leg over one. It's so hard to pick a bike these days they are all so good.
Looking forward to your review on one!!!
Steven Kim stay tuned!
The all important gundle ventilator seat!
LiveFreeandShred my taint loved it! 👌🏽
JC TRAILS I use specialized saddles on all of my bikes.
I love the bike. A reminder i havent had my bike in a year in a half.
Bought one two years ago 2300 great bike wheels are heavy only thing I'd change
thanks for the great review; where is this trail ? awesome terrain..
Great review, I plan on doing a demo this week! What do you think between this and your old ride yeti 4.5c? These two are both on my want/need to demo list...
Mark they are both awesome bikes at different ends of the spectrum. The 4.5 is an aggressive XC / fast pedaling trail bike and the Stumpy is an aggressive trail bike that can handle chunk better. So it depends what your going to do with your bike. For where I live the 4.5 was more than enough and could not beat the pedaling characteristics of the bike.
I just picked up the last that i could find here in my area. A SJ comp alloy. 27.5 thesame specs only an alloy. Havent tested it yet but im looking forward to it..🤙😀 Plus its on sale.
Hey man, you should do a bike check of the whole JC TRAILS family fleet!
ibanez2010 good idea
Nice review! I'm looking at buying a 2020 Stumpy. Also struggling to choose between L and M giving I'm 5'10'' 32 inseam! Just worried I might want to run a longer stem if going medium.
MikaD93 go with a large and a 40mm stem feels perfect.
SJ Comp or Hightower or Ripmo AF or Niner Rip 9 RDO? The choices are hard so many good bikes. Wish there were more demos in my area to be able to find the best fit.
We heard that the better climbing came at a price, it doesn't feel quite as "Plush" as it was before. Did you notice that ? or not.
really awesome overview did u get a chance to see the black comp carbon because i want to get it but Im so torn on the colors
dCip my friend Tommy rides it layer in the video. I personally like the white.
lol i saw it right after i sent the comment and i just face palmed a little. I didnt like the white that much until i saw the downtube in your videos and now I'm really abouot it
Nice Review ! Have you tested the new SC Bronson ? interested to hear how it compares to the new stumpy ?
Keith McDowell not yet but the new Bronson and 5010 are on my shortlist.
Nice vid JC! How does the suspension feel compared to a Pike RC fork and a Deluxe RT3? Also the SRAM GX compared to the Shimano on the Spec.? Just picked up a enduro demo from bike barn Friday I’ll be ripping down pine hills tomorrow!
christopher c the pike is going to have better small bump compliance and more plush feel to it. The shock will feel very similar to the fox on the comp. The Rock Shox shock might ramp up a little harder at the end of the stroke. Hopefully I will see you out on the trail.
JC Trails great video! what do you think about do all Bike ? Stumpy can cover cross country lanes or will be to much Bike ? Need to get one Bike for all type rides, xc, trial, all day trips
Lukasz P I would look into getting the Short Travel Stumpy it can handle all the above. The regular Stumpy can handle it too, but with less efficiency.
JC TRAILS thank you for getting back to me, this is the problem as I'm going for alloy frame version :) I know about st with alloy frame but I don't like the spec
Love to see people shredding the p hills
Love seeing pine hills dirt bike rotary.....
Jacob Eufrazio I wish I had dirt bike to ride there.
Yeah I sold mine 2 years ago, getting back into MTB, w/ my asthma I want an ebike. Great videos I haven’t 🚵♀️ those trails since 1997😁
Have you ridden the Scott genius bikes? If so, How do they compare? Trying to figure out my first bike to buy, a those seem to be the contenders.
Quick on the review. Looks pretty nice.
I know the people want to know how this bad boy rides. Thanks for watching
What state are you in?
That looks like a really fun mountain. I have the specialized fuse and have been looking at these stump jumpers. Thank for the good review.
I know this is unusual question but could u tell me which bike around $4000 full suspension. Is the most comfortable sitting up right position for flat riding. I want one for flat that will be super comfortable crossing sidewalks in city without getting sore now I have specialized bike that has no suspension at all and I’m looking for full suspension! And once in a while I’ll go off road but 95% I won’t. Thank u
ugh, at the end of November, I picked up a New 2018 Stumpjumper Expert with the Carbon Rims. With the winter we have had, it has only been ridden twice. Then I see all this about the new 2019 SJ :(
Lee Forrest that 2018 is still a sick bike.
Great review. My trails aren't enough for a 150mm 29er and I'd prefer the 120mm ST, but the only options are the very poor spec base 1850 or all the way up to the 4200 carbon comp ST. The 3000 Comp Alloy 29 only comes in the LT 150. Do you think I would even notice the difference between the ST and LT? Meaning just get the LT even though it might be too much?
Thanks MrBojangles the ST pedals a little bit better, but having a higher end LT will ride better than a lower end ST.
I just picked mine up, same build but with the Roval Traverse SL carbon wheels -- love it. The thing really pops and turns like no other 29r I've ridden.
Steven Peyton those wheels really lively up the ride
Yep, I did a demo with the alloy wheels and loved it, but the carbon rims really transformed it! Great review BTW.
Steven Peyton thanks
Did you get the ST or regular version? Any regrets?
I just got one today and its so good
KrY so good!
I think about changing Guide R to Magura Trail sport.
Looks great , im a fan but would you b able to review on 2019 rock hopper pro 1x as I'm looking to get one before February
Harvey Peeler I’ll work on it.
Hey man great video! I'm getting ready to buy a stump jumper but i'm torn between the "pro" model and the "comp carbon" model. is the pro model really worth it for 2 more grand with it having the DX2 rear shock carbon wheels and 36 factory fox forks? and would the weight be a huge difference from the alloys on the comp to the carbon on the pro? thanks in advance dude keep on shredding!
Hi at first a good video!
Can you tell me if there's a big difference to the Hightower LT or are they werry similar espacially on the rear travel because the HTLT has 150mm?
Wich one of both would you recoment for a bike to ride Trails, sometimes Park, Enduro races and also often uphill?
Thanks for your answer and sorry for my bad english.
Cheers!
MilanHorst thanks! If your looking for a bike to ride your local trails 90% of the time and other 10% riding park and racing. I would recommend the Stumpy you can always beef up the suspension at a later date. The LT can also pedal your local trails but you will lose some efficiency and speed through. The LT though is awesome when pointed down, it feels more plush and stable when pushed hard. I hope this helps.
JC TRAILS Thanks for the fast answer. I Think Next Week i will Test the new Stumpy.
MilanHorst 🤘🏼
JC Trails, Can you please do a review on the 2019 Stumpjumper Expert 27.5? I was hoping you or MTB Yum Yum would have tested this by now but it seems that the market is in the 29 models because they’re all over the bike shops and TH-cam and no 27.5 LT review.
I had 2016 Stumpjumper Carbon Comp 29 with Roval SL Fatties 2.3 Butcher F/2.3 GC R @27.4 lbs and sold that last year and built my all time favorite bike (again). A 2013 Santa Cruz TRC 26. Because the Stumpjumper 29 was too calm and more of a “pedal & plow” kinda bike. At least for me but maybe that’s because I’m short at 5’6”, 30.6” inseam.
Although I already have this 2019 Expert 27.5 for a week now and rode it 3x already, I still would like to hear your opinion on it. I feel that it’s my Blur TRC and Stumpy29 combined! It likes to pop of stuff and the rearend is stiff! I leave it open all the time unlike the TRC, I have to switch to pedal or firm mode on the climbs. I haven’t felt this fun in a long time and not to mention I picked up the bike brand new at a LBS for $4500 OTD and they gave me $400 gift card. Total $4100 OTD for an Expert during the Black Friday Sale! I already upgraded the wheels to 38mm Roval Carbon with the OE tires. So much fun!🤘
Please review. Thanks!
Nice ride and awesome review! How did the Fox 34 Rhythm hold up? I am considering the Alloy Comp version of this bike and that seemed to be the only component spec that stuck out as not being so great. Bike is still only $3K for the alloy comp which is sweet!
Phillip Moore the rhythm fork is pretty good, but a fox 36 will transform the bike, especially if your an aggressive rider.
Cool! Thanks for the help on that!
JC TRAILS doesn’t the evo come with a 36?
jackboeker83 yeah it comes with a 36 rhythm with 44mm offset.
Gorgeous machine! I wish I could justify the price..
gmax876 just buy it, totally worth it 😜
really beautiful trails
Gabriele D'Alessio they are!
Nice riding and took the guy a bit to pull away from you. Santa Cruz Hightower LT or Stumpy ??
mike Bussart I’m going Stumpy just enough squish for the big hits but still pedals well. The LT is too much bike for my local trails, but if I was an Enduro racer LT all day.
I wish the medium Comp was about 5 lbs lighter. An Ibis Ripmo reviewer coming up soon?
mwinner101 im afraid to ride it, another bike to fall in love with. But to answer your question hopefully soon.
Cool color .
jaasun71 looks better in person too.
How does this bike stack up against your Yeti 4.5 you had? I know this one is probably more capable on the down hills but I would love to hear your thoughts. I currently have the 4.5
Mason the 4.5 is one of the best pedaling bikes I have ever ridden, with that being said. The Stumpy is not far off. It’s definitely more capable on the downs, but if you put a better rear shock on the 4.5 (dpx2 or monarch plus) it will help plush out the bike. If I had to pick one bike it would be the Stumpy, it fits my riding style.
I know this was the carbon version, but how do you think the aluminum version would stack up to the Trance 2?
I would go aluminum Stumpy all day!
With a 425 reach, are you really more comfortable on a medium?
I'm also 5'10", and believe the 445 reach from the large would be a better fit.
mr manny I'm actually comfortable on both. The medium feels just a little a bit more flickable, but the large feels like I could pedal harder on. I'm going to demo the large next.
Looking forward to your review of the Large :)
This is an odd question, but could you try to compare the Fuse vs the Stumpjumper? I had the Fuse (loved it) but I'm thinking maybe the ST stumpy is the way to go. Where I live is mostly flow, but we do have some rare legit steep stuff too. I really like snappy, playful bikes so jib around on. Thoughts??? Thanks!
Nick F I loved the Fuse, but if you are looking for a full suspension I think ST Stumpy is the bike for you and your terrain. The regular stumpy is very playful so I can imagine the ST would be even more playful.
JC TRAILS Thanks for the fast reply! I'm leaning towards the ST. Just need to try it on the trails. Hopefully it's more lively than the other Full Susp I've tried in the past! Keep making these awesome videos!!
Nick F will d o
JC Trails , I am looking to purchase new bike soon. I want something playful , poppy and that I can throw around without issue. Think about bmx street riding and dirt jumping. :) Used to a 29 but thinking about 27.5 just because its smaller. Have you demo'd the 27.5 comp alloy? or would the 29 comp alloy fit what I'm looking for?
anthony brady if your looking for a fun poopy bike I would go with the 27.5 short travel Stumpy. I just rode it today at a bike park and it's super fun!
JC TRAILS how was the 275 on the trails? Anything you didn’t like? Or liked? Not the biggest fan that of the st base models setup. But can’t afford comp carbon.
anthony brady the 27.5 rips, the aluminum version can still party just a little heavier.
JC Trails , thanks for your input! greatly appreciated!
Would you reccomend the 2018 SJ expert 29er. I can get one for $3300 new with carbon rims vs a Hightower LT carbon S.
I would personally go with the HT LT. The rear linkage on the HT pedals better and you have 15mm more travel.
Nice looking ride JC. I ordered my Expert ST 29er, waiting for its late May arrival. After seeing this video I'm glad I did.
Christian Bishop nice! What color did you get? Hopefully the blue one 😜
JC TRAILS yes the blue
Christian Bishop I think that's the best looking one out of the whole line up.
So this Stumpy or a Hightower LT? So hard to choose!
So, would you say the regular model is better than the ST for trails in YOUR area? I'm in the market for a new bike and also happen to be moving to southeast MA from PA in a couple of months. Thanks!
Matthew Perry the ST is more than enough bike for we live, but if you want to go to a bike park or ride some rowdy stuff the regular Stumpy can handle it.
Thanks! I'm really having trouble deciding, I think the regular probably makes more sense, I just really dig the carbon black on the ST expert. I know looks shouldn't matter, but I can't help it, lol.
@@macbhocheese did you make the move? Expert?
@@kentao4 Made the move to Freetown, right outside the state forest. Demo'd a Stumpy and a Santa Cruz Hightower LT, ended up going with the LT.
Matthew Perry congrats. Carbon comp on sale for 3770. I think my decision is made.
What do you think about this price wise for what you get compared to the Jeffsy 29 Cf and CF pro?
Bullcity I've never ridden a Jeffsey, but it does come with an awesome spec for the money. It just stinks you can't test ride them before buying it. So money would go to Specialized.
Looks fun! I wish I could ride that well. :)
T Nordquist it's all the bike😜
That's what I try to tell my wife!
T Nordquist haha!
So did Bike Barn Racing make you an offer you just couldn't refuse on the demo bike? I see at the end of the video you have it set up with a Rental cockpit...looks like James got a new bike?
You have a keen eye Dan. I was just trying out a bigger stem on the bike to see if I could get that perfect fit. No new bike sorry. Hopefully new bike day will be soon😏
Right on, good luck! I have been wrestling with the new bike purchase myself, so may good bikes to choose from. The 2019 Stumpjumper is really high on my list... I sold my Bronson and was planning on going HTLT. But last weekend we had a Santa Cruz demo at my local trails in Napa CA...BKXC just posted a video there. and I was blown away by the Tallboy. I rode the HTLT, Tallboy, and the Nomad(really good too pedals beter then the Bronson)... I wasn't even planning on riding the Tallboy, is crazy how good a 110mm rear travel bike can be
Dan I actually love the Tallboy. It pedals so well and your right it's very capable.
so good experience. thanks
landed here bc I thought this was the Stumpjumper ST for ~$1800... the alloy. Now I want this one but it's twice as much lol. Anyone have any experience with the Alloy version?
JCtrails , I am ver close to committing funds to an alloy 29er on on the 29 SJ comp. I’m 5,10 170 lbs. should I go medium or large, my 2016 SJ was large and felt stable but slightly less wieldy than the medium I just demoed. I’m torn! Please advise.
Hey Thomas I would go with a size large and put a 40mm stem on it. You can always move the seat a little forward if you feel if the top tube is a little long.
Fairly new to MTB BmX background. I'm 6' 220-250lbs any suggestions? Alum or Carbon? Or another bike? Any advice appreciated. Thanks
Gus i’d go with an alloy to start i recommend a bike with 27.5 tires also make sure you buy a bike with at least 130 mm of travel. Possibly a xl frame depending on brand you buy
I would second starting with an alloy frame. It’s hard to swallow the huge price of carbon for your 1st bike. A size XL with 27.5x2.6 tires would be a great fit for you with your bmx back ground.
@@jctrails is your main reasoning for not suggesting carbon because of cost or you think I'm better off with an Alloy because it is stronger? I've had a $500 MTB for years and its a tank so I really do want a light bike just wansn't to sure about strength and reliability of carbon.
The carbon is about a 1/2 pound lighter. Are you going to notice it probably not. I would also check out the Giant Trance great bike for the money.
Lol that's a sock speed hole, it makes you faster!
Kenny Fetsurka it also provides air conditioning ❄️
How does it compare to the giant trance 29er and which one would you choose James & why? Thanks
Tonyo Boy I will let you know once I ride the Trance 29er
JC TRAILS thank you and always enjoy watching your videos.. stay safe!!
Does the Comp carbon come in a 27.5 option? or only a 29er?
Drake Spriggs it also comes in 27.5
Nice review. Good riding too. Looks like you were really enjoying this test ride.
Twitchy Nick thanks man. I felt immediately comfortable on the Stumpy, it's super playful.
JC TRAILS I sensed you may have found your bike.
Twitchy Nick 🤫
hey what trail is this? Plymouth Ma?
Chris Murphy pine hills in Plymouth
whats up with the camera tripod set up at 13:34?
Getting some Instagram shots
Did you tried the ST model? Apparently the ST is replacing the Camber .
J O yeah ST rips. It's the same bike as the LT with a different shock yoke and fork.
do you think the ST has a bit of XC feeling ?
J O it feels like 100%. trail bike
Thanks man.... I bought the base aluminum version on 29er (less than 1,700 at local BIke Shop -good deal to be in a budget). I went for the medium at 5’10.5 and 178.... I may change the stem for a few extra mm... I’m more incline to XC style riding but I found this a good do it all bike....
Ok, so VPP or this new FSR link? Is it still a lil rough? That's what I noticed between the 2 suspension designs. VPP was much better than the old FSR design.
Ken Cycles they feel so similar, but I'm liking the new FSR a little better. When your pedaling over the rough stuff the FSR linkage seems to track better.
JC TRAILS what!!! Really, spesh really upped there game then. I think you're stumpy might be up for sale soon 🤣🤣🤣
Ken Cycles it's been gone for a couple of weeks now I'm bike less.
JC TRAILS oh! You'll have a new one in the stable soon I bet 😉.
Ken Cycles 🤔
Can i ride this kind of bike on pavement to go to work on weekdays and take it out there on weekends or not recommended ?
Short travel or long travel? Just picked up my 18 stumpy in December 😏
sterling7231990 I’m going LT, but the ST is no slouch. Have fun on that 18 it’s a sick bike!
JC TRAILS I'm still enjoying it the only problem I've had is with the cables on the bottom rubbing off
sterling7231990 you have to replace those cables regularly it stinks
JC TRAILS somehow my cable rubbed off and the metal is exposed now....I thought I might have cased it but I don't see anywhere where I hit it
Here in Sweden we dont get the Shimano on these bikes :( We get Sram NX Eagle
Yeah Spec changed to all Sram a couple of months after this bike came out.
Anybody know of a good fox rear shock that fits. 7.5 in. Need one with a resivore, can't find one. HELP.....
@JC Trails is this near Serious? What side?
Yup behind the shop
Is the mountain bike also good for being on the road?
william polanin a hardtail mountain bike would be ok on the road.
great to watch.
Calem Bates thanks!
could you please make a comparison test with the EVO version? How it feels on the same trail
Is, no comment. Pearl white or white