I Paid 5 Designers To Design THE SAME Logo... 🧐 (Interesting Results)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 พ.ค. 2024
- 🚀 First 1,000 people get to watch my class (and thousands more!) free with a one month trial! skl.sh/willpaterson09211
CAPTIONS available on this video: English, Hindi, German and Spanish!
Designers Featured in the video:
MELVIN SOTO: $100 / melvinsotopr
MIFTAH UDIN: $150 / ded.ops
ARNIE LACK: $200 / arnoldlack.design
MO BORBON: $250 / moborbon
JESSICA ST. ONGE: $500 / jk.stonge
Great Graphic Design Resources! creativemarket.com?u=Willberto
Instagram: / willpat
Thanks for watching! Hope you enjoyed this video!
If there's anything you would like me to cover in a TH-cam Video, then let me know by commenting down below!
Edited by Jordan Summers: www.1five.co.uk
0:00 Intro
0:33 The Brief and Rules
1:49 New Skillshare Class Out!
1:58 Melvin $100 Logo
6:44 Miftah $150 Logo
10:22 Arnold $200 Logo
13:06 Mo Borbon $250 Logo
16:57 My Free Skillshare Logo Class
19:03 Jessica $500 Logo
23:50 Final Thoughts
If you like what I do, and you want to partner with me:
BECOME A MEMBER! / @willpatersondesign
Hire me: www.willpaterson.design
If you would like me to design you a logo, poster or anything for your TH-cam Channel or business, then I'm your man! I would love to work with you to make what you want a reality! Check out my website and portfolio for more information.
Hire me: www.willpaterson.design - แนวปฏิบัติและการใช้ชีวิต
![[TH] 2024 PMSL SEA W2D1 | Summer | ถ้าไม่พร้อมลุย ได้ไปคุยกับรากมะม่วง](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/XlkKtVvBxac/mqdefault.jpg)
Hope you guys enjoy the video! Remember to watch my Skillshare Original Class for 100% free! I'm super excited :) skl.sh/willpaterson
CAPTIONS available on this video: English, Hindi, German and Spanish!
yo ,I'm waited class from you
Great video, Will. I love this series. Thanks to all the designers for participating and thanks for your comments on my design 👍🏼
@@MoBorbon you did so good! Well done! 🥳
Hi Mr Will, I am a logo designer and I REALLY want to show myself. When, where and how do you get these designers for these contests? I'm really interested in joining one of these competitions. I will deliver, I swear.
Thanks for sharing this type of video with us. Please how can I participate in this type of videos
I think a nice addition to this series would be that Will also does a design and presents it at the end, it would be nice to see what he had in his mind and compare it to the other designs. Love seeing how people perceive things differently.
He won't, because he's not actually that good of a designer.
@@AshleyTheSwift someone’s salty
Good idea :)
@Mr Swift Plays I hope when you're streaming no one comments the same way to you. Good luck :)
@@willpatersondesign people are nasty only when you have defeated them at something, if it means anything, I think you’re a great designer 😘
The $250 was by far the best and most complete. For 3 hours of work it was exceptional
Thanks, I was stressing hard to complete that in three hours lol
@@MoBorbon Kudos man, super impressive
@@MoBorbon great work
@@MoBorbon Spectacular work!
@-ピンク ja joguei, mas nao usava esse nick
500$ logo designer missed the brief completly, just solely to follow recent 50's design trend. As a designers, we have to solve problems which are stated in brief. I know it's tempting to make something aesthetically pleasing - I fell in that trap many times, but by doing this we tend to create new branding problems. Miftah really nailed this one, everything is in the right place, because he followed the brief. He should be paid more.
The extended letters on Miftah's art is also a recent design trend, although I do agree, his hit the mark pretty well. I'm still partial to Mo's design. His design was clever and the iconography and colors were spot on.
Hlw I am a professional logo designer if you need logo design contact me
I really agree, I'm a Brazilian designer and I think this idea is the great thing about design, in the end it's not an incredible technical work, but a solution to the client's problem.
I don't get the appeal of Miftah's logo, the D looks silly, simple and phallic looking on first glance, doesn't really say futuristic to me.
@@isoutoforbit it looks like a space rocket tbf
i believe the 500 logo missed highlighted key words in the brief, one being zero emissions with the "red blast" in the design saying something else. the Mo Borbon 250 was the most on point
Say whaaat, thanks so much, friend. It means a lot to me to see people enjoy my work :)
If I paid 500 for someone to use the star tool inside of a letter I would definitely be upset. Also the combination of both including the jetsons and the idea of having a predominantly 70’s mood board as the representation of the “future” makes the entire project look like a joke. I agree that the Mo Borbon is the only one I would have been satisfied with and the only one that deserved much more than the value paid!
@@Truen091 I agree that Mo's was the best but I dug Miftah's as well. The only concern I would have with his is the fact that that the extended letters are a very current trend and will likely be out in the near future which may make his brand feel dated in a few years. Arnold's icon was nice but I didn't care for the typeface. The legs on those R's bothered me.
@@Truen091 I agree that Mo Borbons logo is the best one, but I think your first sentence doesnt make a lot of sense. You don't only pay for the execution of a logo. That part is easy for many of the greates, most timeless logos out there. Developing a decent, working concept/idea that fits the brief but can be simplified enough is the difficult part. If you'd pay someone by the amount of tools in illustrator they used, you'd probably get terrible results xD
agree. it looks more like a hippie poster than a corporate logo. she took his money and decided to have fun with it lol
To be honest, I actually think blue is much more of a cliché choice for a futuristic branding package than red is. In contemporary pop media, blue somehow is always used for whatever is supposed to be futuristic, be it in the movies, on book covers, et cetera.
If the logo is good it doesn't matter if it's cliché, what do you think?
I agree. The first logos colors were good. Crimson red with that navy blue would have looked awful.
@@electricimpulsetoprogramming if your logo is cliche it doesn’t stand out and could be forgettable. you want yours to be memorable
@@pineapplejuicebox Sorry I'm very dumb sorry
thats becasue blue is usually used to sumbolise space and novelty, and navy blue is an overall business color
Thank you all for the great feedback and thanks to Will and Naomi for the opportunity! This was a fun project that allowed me to color “outside the lines” as opposed to what I usually do with my clients who are more conservative about what they want. And I usually spend hours and hours on research alone on a logo for a client, including some sketching, multiple concepts and brand research (and charge way more of course), this was a more fun and quick project that I worked directly on Illustrator. I agree with every single critique from Will, thank you for being an inspiration for a long time. And I gotta admit, Mo Borbon won this one 🔥
You did so well! Thanks so much for taking part! Really glad you enjoyed it! 🥳
Thanks, Melvin. I appreciate it!
@@You-dd3jt thanks so much, that means a lot! I’m actually trying to start a new logo/branding business based on all the positive feedback from this video :) thanks again!
@@MoBorbon Do you have a link to your site? or how much do you usually charge for logos? :)
The 500$ really confused me because if she was going for a Jetsons look, there are many great options for retro-futuristic/space-age typography, instead she went for late 60s-70s typography, when The Jetsons are from the early 60s.
Mo Borbon's logo is my favorite. Simple, memorable, distinctive and appropriate. That guy just killed it.
Heyyy! Thanks so much! I’m available for any work you may need haha
Without a doubt, Melvin and Mo Borbon were the better designers in this challenge. No discouragement to the other designers, though. It's just that Melvin and Mo Borbon's designs and presentations were spot on. Arnold could have easily tied up with Melvin and Mo Borbon due to his equally creative design, but his presentation was not as complete as theirs was. Miftah easily ties up with Arnold, and Jessica comes right after Miftah. All in all, this was a great group of designers.
Thanks so much for your kind words! :)
Thanks for the feedback!
Thank you Esteban! Really appreciate that.
Real talk.... Jessica was so bad for that money!! 500 Bucks for this!!! Jeeez...
$500 just for the logo and one mockup? Hmm interesting. I really love the $250 logo, great job Mo Borbon!
Hey! Thanks so much! It was super fun to make and I wish it was real haha
Yes for a logo ! What is wrong with it ?
@@blackin6253 its shit. thats what he meant. but he chose to be polite with it. LOL
@@ripjjjsphrbggsk6292 What you mean it was shit? Why exactly was it shit? I'm a bit confused to which one you're referring to pls help
@@O.G.H. The very last one, that cost $500 to do.
You keep mentioning wanting to use red for Mars and I think that would be a mistake. In space travel, colors are often selected for the purpose of high visibility. The white space suits and ships against the black of space, the orange landing suits are easily to spot during water landings. With that in mind, my first instinct with a Mars-focused brief like this one would be to head to the opposite side of the color wheel. See if we can get some bright greens and blues working so the design really pops not only in space, but also when contrasted against the red planet.
This is a great thought, and definitely something that (if this was a real client) you could try and convince them of during the process.
I think that's the difference between an appealing design and appropriate design. A red/orange is kind of obvious but at the same time I would expect it in a Mars design. Maybe if/when we do colonise Mars we would be sick of every Martian adjacent service having it and that contrasting blue would be welcome. That's too many layers deep in conscious thought. In a real life 2121 yes to blue, in our hypothetical 2021 then go for the red before any other colour.
Surely white space suits and craft are more to do with heat reflection over any aesthetic value. A dark suit would bake the occupant once exposed to the Sun.
3 and 4 totally nailed it. 5 just didn't come across as a logo and I agree, the scalability of it wasn't good.
The 500 USD one was the worst among all. 250 USD concept was amazing and the best among them.
That last one would be fitting for a boardgame. It's hard to believe the rest took just 3hrs, some really great presentations there.
Personally I liked the $250 one for overall design. But the $200 one hit the mark when seen in situ on the rocket. Thanks for the great video. Very interesting.
500 for the logo and 1 mockup. Wish i got that much for doing that lol. I usually get half to present a 15 page pdf. Last one would be great if it was a clothing brand maybe? Just missed the brief i think. The 150 one deserved more. He did a great work .
dude you should charge more if you believe in your work
Thanks for the feedback! Love seeing the other logos! Everyone did so well
Thanks so much for taking part! Well done! 🥳
Your logo was awesome! Keep it up !
I'm a bit late but yea, I really liked your work! Spectacular work!!
@@kophullloh516 thank you!
The 500$ one definitely missed the mark compared to the other ones, great job Mo!
Thank you! :D
If I want to send a package I would 100% avoid the delivery company with an explosion in the logo.
In the first logo, the O with the dot in the middle is the alchemical symbol for the sun (solar).
there is no sun in the brief, and even if we say that is a sun, that logo represents no center that we can relate to.
@@aymanezbakh2394 Well this guy here has clearly made the connection, so he related to it. Also, Solar literally means "related to the sun", so the brand name is 50% 'sun'. It couldn't be more in the brief than that.
yeaa truee my bad , i didn’t pay attention to the brand name
I feel like I'd love to do something like this because you get to have feedback not only by Will, but also his community; but hate it at the same time because I'd get to have feedback not only by Will, but also his community
Love that $200 icon, only thing that slightly annoyed me is the animated one has the internal planet moving slower than the external ones, which is the opposite to how they would actually move. Still an awesome logo though! Also love that $250 one, nailed the brief 🙌🏽
depends on their density, doenst it?
There are 2 objects on 1 orbital track, thats one was ticking my ocd.
@@cromwel4422 Kepler's second law. It depends solely on the distance from it's star.
@@ralphvercauteren9267 two planetary objects could share the same orbit if they are diametrally opposite to each other (i.e. Lagrange point L3)
To say everyone did all of this in 3 hours is crazy! It takes me hours to decide on a typeface, that might even be customised. And colours. They sketched, drafted, researched, chose fonts and colour palettes, created documents, mock-ups and mock landing pages? This is a woooow. Thanks for sharing! I always find the cheaper ones, feel like they have to prove something or feel that they aren’t worth more and then produce amazing work to combat that and prove or evidence why your idea is like that. Which is cool and confident (but not if coming from a place of insecurity) Guys. Raise your prices if you’re going to be doing all that, raise them. It’s a lot of work. The 500 dollars, was beautiful but didn’t hit the brief and still didn’t explain how she got there at all. A brand identity does normally mean mock ups and variantion of logos, but not to that extent. Which is why 500 dollars only created one. Raise your prices!
I had to scroll way too far to find at least this one comment mentioning the three hours! The last one was the only one that somehow felt like it could have been done in three hours. All the other ones MUST have spent way more time on all that they delivered.
I wish that this was talked about in the video instead of leaving the impression that the last one kinda ran with the money and didn’t really deliver for it -- kinda the opposite, the last one was the only one approaching this in a professional way and also applying freelance living-wage hourly prices, too.
500$ one was trash, barely worth 5 cents
500$ one was trash, barely worth 5 cents
I love this series.. Mo Borbon Nailed it, I loved his sketches too, great concepts you got there..
Thanks, James! I appreciate it
I agree with a lot of the comments and like the $250 logo best. The $500 logo seems a bit too trendy to me, like something that might not last for 10, 15 years.
Women and their work. I am not sexist but the logo is off the chart. She just put a star on O.
@@Sanjay_Singh_Bisht
“women and their work”
“i am not a sexist”
@@olivephio2960 Yes, thank you for showing my hipocrisy but still she made shit logo.
The 500$ one is an insult to every skilled designer. I could have made that one in MS Word and it would look the same. The cartoonish style isn't fit for a holistic appearance. He said it right it might work for T Shirts but they are not mainly in clothing business. The only woman in this competition and she failed miserably. Ouch
This is your third video I watched in a row for graphic design and had a grin all the way through. Currently looking for a logo design for a future brand and I'm amazed and in awe of Mo's design it just hits the spot for me in every way for your design brief. His presentation was above and beyond too. Credit to all the graphic designers for all their hard work and creativity. Amazing work, love the videos Will and the way you analyse and critique, in a positive light of course lol!
Mo Borbon 250$ is the best solved logo, he followed the brief the most and for 3 hours of work, it is an excellent job!
Thank you very very much :)
Always my fave kind of videos to do! The designers did so well and are all so lovely! 🧡
I would agree that the $500 seems like it might be following a current trend of 'retro' design, but it was absolutely unique. And that's worth something. In a time when there's a space delivery company between earth and mars, won't every logo out there for any company feature something space-related? Won't everyone have that 'futuristic' look and futuristic typography? It's going to become cliche very quickly. Sort of like how every almost every real estate company nowadays has a roof in their logo (and they all look the same). I just finished watching the video and I can't even remember which of the other four had which type.
I agree, but it feels like it would suit a more niche company, like ModCloth in space. The brief doesn’t say that the company is niche so a mass appeal is the goal. Jessica’s was the most playful, and fun which is why I like it best. It’s just missed the brief.
Do more of these, I love watching them. Seeing how different designers interpret the brief. My favorite is number 3.
500$ one was trash, barely worth 5 cents
Okay, Im an older one here (52) who lived through the entirety of 70s and 80s... I have to correct you.
That last one: It's not 70's/80s. It' 50's/60s. It's loungey space-age.
When I saw the first one I was like "wow I haven't seen any others but this is my favourite" like I really love that! (after having seen the others, it's not my favourite but I think it is exceptional for the price! Raise your prices!)
For the second one, I think it is really well made and fits the brief, but is personally my least favourite just because of my preferences!
The third one is...!!!! I love it so much! Honestly, the idea of the pin location with the orbiting planets is one of the most creative ideas I've seen in a long time and it is SO pleasing to the eye. I also think it's one of the best logos in terms of brand identity and icons, as it is so recognisable!
For the fourth one...just wow. It's a tough choice between this one and the third one but I am a sucker for those colours (the cyan and coral) so I'm gonna have to pick this one. It is so smooth and modern, SO pleasing to the eye, extremely creative AND very recognisable and brandable. I love it!
For the last one -- it is good, I do really like it! It's really pleasing to look at and I love the hippie-style font. However, as Will said, it doesn't really fit the whole vibe of the brief. If it was for something else spacey it would be awesome
Appreciate your comments! Thanks a lot! 😁
Thanks for your kind words! I agree, all the logos were awesome in their own ways!
That second Solar Drop logo, would have been phenomenal with some jet flames coming out of the D of Drop. It looks like a rocket on its side.
I think he was going for a more simplistic type font so a putting jet flames wouldn't really work. Nice idea though.
Maybe for an animated logo for marketing, but it being more simplistic is better
I agree with this. Doing that with the D was actually one of the ideas I had but figured it would take me over the 3 hour challenge to execute well.
@@melvinsoto I struggle to see how a lot of these are completed in 3 hours. Maybe I'm just a slow assed designer, but I have shit loads of experience and know how long artworking and mockups take.
The most expensive one was the worst one if you should ask me🤷🏽♂️
as a graphic design uni student, this video is awesome and very helpful. thank you so much!
I am a uni student and Ive been in a creative block but I decided to try create a design based off this brief and it was genuinely so, so fun to create!!! It feels like some competition I am part of coz it pushes me past my limits, I would love to show you!!
I'd love to see it! Upload it to the Reddit page if you like - www.reddit.com/r/WillPatersonDesign/
@@willpatersondesign I just did! Its not very professional or anything but I had fun making it :)
Man, everyone loves the 250$ but for me i fall in love with the 150$ logo's remembering the price and the time he spent on.
I agree. The 250 is the most beautiful to me, however it might be a bit “modern”? The 150 one looks very futuristic, which was a key detail in the brief.
i think it would be pretty cool if you dont know the prices paid for the designs and your final task is to rank them and to tell which one is the most expensive or cheapest.
perfect video, as always, keep up the great work
greeting from germany
I like that too haha sounds fun
Melvin, Arnold, and Mo all knocked it out of the park. Hard to pick a favorite between the three.
Scammed on 5, Mo was probably my favorite with a close second to Arnold. Miftah's mockups were really good and Melvin had great color choice
Yay this is my favorite series!
It's actually crazy how as the price gets higher the effort in presentation sort of drops. I'd rate 4th as 1at place, the 2nd as, well, second. And 3rd as 3rd place. Price doesn't always mean quality. Great video Will! Would love to see your design for this :)
Thanks for the feedback will, it's an honor to work with you
The one before the is the end was creative enough and easy to remember! And yeah I agree with you about the last one! Keep up the good job!
Love the detail on the 3rd logo's typography - it uses that 'keep calm and carry on' typeface as it's a british company!
150$ is the best.
500$ is overpriced. Lack of effort and quality
Nope, 500$ is not overpriced, jfc. 150$ designer is just underpriced, that's it. We, designer have no future at all, when 500$ for logo is too much.
@@pashquelle461 i just meant for what the quality and effort she put into designing.
At least the 100$ designer made more than one mockup with different usages of the logo.
I know quality is better than quantity, but trying to make more with the same conditions needs better recognition.
Khalil Hanna, thanks for pointing that out. I've been looking for this opinion and for a long time it seemed like I was the only one who thought the $150 one is the best
2nd 3rd 4th worth it
Also, on the last one I didn't quite get the link between the mood board and the actual logo. The mood board's examples were really really playful whereas the final product was kind of average in that aspect.
That last logo is the one you pay for. It implies all the fast, friendly, fun, easy to use, non-threatening TV Sci-fi of the 50s to the late 70s. People will want to use the service because it seems inherently trustworthy. Most of the others went with corporate sterility and the 'perfect' design shown on the big screen since the 80s with it's threatening, controlling, objectionable, anything-goes-for-profit mindsets that made things like the uncaring Weyland-Yutani the ideal megacorporation of the dystopian cyberpunk future. I'd use the services of a Solar Drop from the last logo because it would feel easy, fun and caring. The others would have me worried that someone would have to die each time I sent a package.
THIS.
First one (Melvin) all day long. Loved the mockups. The logo being in the text... mind blown.
wow! wait for the next part of this concept
The best one for me is the $120 one, it's clean, simple and futuristic. Plus that awesome presentation is just perfect I think he should rise his price!
500$ one was trash, barely worth 5 cents
120 one... You mean 150 one??
The star & planets icon that Mo Borbon presented completely knocked it outta the park👌
Always enjoy these. Would be cool to see you have a go at the same brief sometime to see how you'd go about it.
12:00 That logo is insane! Not only did it hit the mark very well. It went beyond the future by adding some animation to it.
Loved Mo Borbons design but the last ones mockup looks like it is a family card-game box, reminds me of Sequence 😂
I can spend the rest of my life watching you criticize logos, I'm almost 22 btw, brilliant! and looking to take your course
Regarding the 150$ option "the Blue One".. I guess the author probably choose the blue because it is the complementary color of orange (that we actually see in mars footage - and not red actually).
these videos are the best!
I love Mo Borbon's logo! On point and aesthetically pleasing. I think that Mars also represents 1 and the Earth 0, the binary code used by computers. I may be wrong on this. Great work and sorry if i wrote something wrong but im not english.
Ngl one of my favourite series in all of TH-cam
I loved Arnold's and Mr Bourbons Logos, but Mifthas Mockups were just incredible. Didn't like the logo that much but he still sold me with his presentation of the ID cards and space suit
500$ one was trash, barely worth 5 cents
thhe 200 is really spot on
Delivery (the locaion) examplified and Planets marked
The third one was my favorite. And animated?! Beautifully done.
I think the thing about the 500 logo thing was that it was the one that appealed to me the most, but in a sense that it looks really nice to me, but it doesnt fit the brief. Its almost like a fallout-style logo, but if the brief is similar to a space amazon shopping service sort of thing, then it missed the mark, which is a shame.
Awesome job to all these designers.
But, i doubt they spend only 3hours, sorry.
3 hours is needed only for searching images to use for mockups (i mean look miftah mockups!).
I think the only honest "3hours job" was Jessica's logo.
They all agreed to 3 hours and were very aware of the time limit to create a logo in three hours :) we can’t exactly sit them down in an exam hall can we!
I agree. But that's their choice and shows ambition.
This! Together with the pretty low prices of the first ones, it’s clear they are rather desparate, so they put in lots of work to compensate. Such a shame this practice got praised in the video instead of criticized.
Borbon and Arnold blew my mind! Amazing work guys!
Thanks!
Thank you very much 🙏🏼
In a time when we have interplanet travel... you really think san serifs are still going to be seen as "futuristic"? I like the idea of the 60s, psychedelic font. It achieves one of the most important things you need for a brand and that is to STAND OUT.
Sans serif has been around since the 1800s, so while it certainly may not be popular in future years, it has been very stable over the past couple hundred years :) It’s more likely a fundamental font like that would age better than a psychedelic font. That’s just my personal design opinion though. But I agree that it stands out that most and is super aesthetically pleasing. I loved that logo the most, but I agree with others it’s not what comes to mind when I think of futuristic planetary travel haha
The last one especially with the boxes looks like a card or board game to me. A current one but with retro inspiration.
The $250 one is the one that caught my eye the most, its simple, the colors are nice and fitting and the logo fits for a huge black background or white one too
Good video will. For three hours the work presented here is exceptional.
Wanted to try out the next time you are doing such a video but I cant find the link to fill the form.
the last one looks more like a board game box or something like a kiwi co. crate than a general delivery company, like it doesn't look like the box is supposed to be recycled, it looks like it's meant to be kept
Speaking completely as a non designer here, but rather as an engineer / historian. I think if I had been hired to do this exact task, I would have had to ask the client if he was sure he knew what he wanted. It seems to me a complete juxtaposition to want to have your brand thought of as futuristic while at the same time naming your company with a phrase that brings to my mind (at least) the idea of cold-war-era airdrops of food and supplies.
The $150 one was killer, but i would have aligned the letters on the second row with the top row, really tightening the stacked characters. Making it look crazy tight.
I’m sorry…. Is your brief so good it’s inspiring a sci fi short story/universe? Good gravy, this is awesome!
Really like this serie
Okay Mo and Miftah, you did that. Love those.
I agree with your take on the final one, seems like it was designed in the 1980's or was a logo from a film in that period.
I always watch and I’m not a designer in any way, I just enjoy your videos thank you💥 💫
WAIT IS IT?... Yes it is, spot on. I love how passionate he is about kerning. That skill makes no sense to me, and I need it. I'm never sure what letters should be closer and which ones should be further apart as a general rule, you know?
Thank you for the feedback, and the opportunity to work on this project! Really enjoyed the process, just wish I had more time to work on it!
You did an amazing job! 3 hours is tough, but you managed to present a really nice finished and polished logo at the end. Good job!
@@NouammAA thank you for the kind words!
You did so well! Great job! 😻
You're definitely skilled but I think you could learn a decent amount from some of the comments.
super excited for your skillshare class
Me too!
Mo B. definitely hit a home run!
I like the logos but man the company names William comes up with are amazing!
mo borbon maked an amazing job dudeeee i love his logo !!
Thanks! 😄👍🏼
Really enjoyed the video! I'll surely sign up to design a logo too!
The 250 package was the best in terms of the logo, concept and execution. The 150 package has the best presentation. The person with the 500 package made out like a bandit.
Mo Borbon’s design all the way. He made it work in various color presentations, a “complex” and “simple” version, and clearly captured the idea in the icon.
😁👍🏼 thanks!
The 250$ one was the best IMO
I’m very honored by your opinion :) thanks!
lol i just realised when everyone uses modern fonts they will eventually become old and new font will become modern
Lol... This is actually very true.
Miftas Typography with Arnold's or Mo's Logos would look really good !
A bit late to the party, but I just had to comment that in Melvin's logo - which I really like! I also love the packaging - whenever I look at the black circle with the red dot, my brain sees it as a vinyl record (I grew up in the 80s). I can't unsee it! :-)
Also a little bit surprised about the color critique... yes, red is the color of Mars, but couldn't that also be a little cliché - ? Plus orange is used for SOLAR, which seems to be appropriate. Of course I'm sure all of these designs would get tweaked again and again (and again) before being finalized anyway :-) Fantastic job done by all, and great video!
Oddly enough, Mo’s design hit more of the themes in Jessica’s mood board than Jessica’s logo did with the atomic star and background orbit. I feel like Mo, Jessica, and Arnie would be great as a team.
"for us the sky is NOT the limit".... freaking genius
Mo's logo with no star would be epic. I like it, but take away the star and even include a 'special use' animated logo that is entwined with the font. The 2 O's are in a great position.
THE most important part of this video is your hair. It's excellent! Where do you get it done / what do you use?
I just have a lot of hair! I don't really use anything on it haha!
love the last one. Very 60s jazz album. The origin of space... star trek. It also reminds me of a guitar strings case, or package. The thing that is missing from all of them is variations, and 2 to 3 other completely different logos. Plus, logo's are always soiled by clients who think they're designers. I always save my originals.
The Jetsons one could have worked but with a different design. It could have brought a futuristic feel and a familiarity with the retro aesthetic like in Fallout or like in Loki with the TVA.
I also want to share my thoughts. I ll put logos from the least successful to the most.
3d logo for $200: Looks like an icon and therefore just dull and not modern. Also just not beautiful, to me looks very busy.
1st logo for $100: Has more individuality compared to the one for $200. The concept is pretty nice-using two planets in high contrast.
However, I think it would be better if Mars was more heavy then Earth. It is logical, as goods drop in Mars, so mars is heavy. This would add more balance to the logo.
Also just not very appealing.
5th logo for $500: Looks amazing, great for food deliveries but doesn’t signal for high-tech stuff. So it is misleading, although has nice personality.
2d logo for $150: Looks clean, has a futuristic vibe. But it signals of hi-tech, expensive things, like Tesla. However delivered goods can be everything like food or kitchen stuff. I thing something more universal would fit.
4th logo for $250: the best option among those in my opinion. It signals that it is a delivery service, any product can be under a package with this logo. However, the design is busy and not so appealing to one’s eye, $150 and $500 look better. But it would work for the company.
I think what Jessica was going for was novelty. It isn't futuristic at all, but your description was science-fiction-esc, and the Jetsons are also science fiction. Like you said, she went with a less serious take, and it was really imaginative IMO.
This logo subverts expectations, and I think that is its strength.