I Paid 5 Designers To Design THE SAME Logo... 🧐 & Packaging Design
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 พ.ค. 2024
- VOTING IS CLOSED - SEE WHO WON HERE:
• I Paid 5 Designers To ...
Watch episode two: • I Paid 5 Designers To ...
To find out more about packaging design solutions by DesignBro visit: designbro.com/packaging-design/
Great Graphic Design Resources! creativemarket.com?u=Willberto
Instagram: / willpat
Thanks for watching! Hope you enjoyed this video!
If there's anything you would like me to cover in a TH-cam Video, then let me know by commenting down below!
Edited by PJ Summers: www.1five.co.uk
If you like what I do, and you want to partner with me:
BECOME A MEMBER! / @willpatersondesign
Hire me: www.willpaterson.design
If you would like me to design you a logo, poster or anything for your TH-cam Channel or business, then I'm your man! I would love to work with you to make what you want a reality! Check out my website and portfolio for more information.
Hire me: www.willpaterson.design - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
![ตรงที่เดิม - ฝน พรสุดา [ต้นฉบับ :เบส ขวางหวัน]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/c5YnbGEztI8/mqdefault.jpg)
Hope you guys enjoy the video! Go and vote for your favourite designer here: app.designbro.com/poll/86853da7-246f-436d-a6d0-2c87ff2b1cb1
I want to participate in these contest please tell me how can I participate if I can .
i only watch thius kind of videos in your channel, so please don't stop , thanks.
What’s the keyboard you have there?
Website not working
Miguel's design looks a lot like Skinos - a very popular beverage at the moment. And its greek so it kind of feels like rebrand to me, even though I agree that its very aesthetic
Usually in these types of videos there's always a distinct winner and a distinct loser for me, however all of these designs are great - huge props to the designers. I could picture any of these designs being commercially used in stores.
Couldn’t agree more. Always a obvious winner but all of these designs were literally great. Very tough to pick one because each design goes for a distinctive vibe for the mock company. I believe depending on which design you would go with would heavily impact the demographic of consumers which also makes it a hard choice.
11:55 AU is also the chemical symbol for gold in the periodic table which sort of adds another layer to the logo when its in gold foil, whether intentional or not
Small correction, because the capitalisation matters, is Au, not AU.
@@nextlifeonearth Yes but not in a general format, like branding
As a former bartender, I've seen my fair share of liquor bottles. And I would say the light ones look most professional. The sans serif one does feel a little more generic with the logotype. But the Roman variant would probably look rather well in any bar
Came here looking for another bar person!
I wish they would have done them as 70cl bottles rather than 1L. 1L seems more design friendly, but most back bar bottles are 70s.
The guy with the Roman variant didn’t have anything about it being 0%
@@FNiso yes it does it says it on the cap of each one
@@FNiso it also says it under the main typeface
that roman illustration gives a sense of a premium product at first glace at any bar, agree with you!
I love Miguel's mythology design. I especially love the use of space, the white, bright look and minimalist vibe that looks so fancy and makes up for being non-alcoholic (but nothing wrong with that ofc). It just pops out so much against darker and duller designs we usually see. The second would have to go with JorgeC - again I love the minimalist and high-end look.
Obvs they're all great, but if I'm in a bar or supermarket, I'd gravitate towards Emma's for sure. I like what she said about using the colour of the aurora to denote flavours too, that's a great added bonus
Yes!
I liked her, but I feel like the second one was just so simple and so unique I would probably pick that up and take it to a dinner party easily.
yes
The first one is probably the only one I would pick up in a shop because for me it was the most recognisable as 0% gin and looked high quality. I am not a designer at all, but I am tired of minimalist design.
I think Jorge is the winner! I find it to be the most luxe looking and if I was in a shop I would be gravitated to it but I do think if the label was white and not dark it would stand out even more and look a little more luxe.
I loved number 2 from JorgeC especially the bottle neck detail and the "R" at the logotype.
I would like to see how it will look if the logo composition was a little higher so it could breath a little better and form a perfect circle.
personally i think the second has the best design concept and typography -- if they made the text bigger and moved everything up a bit i think it'd be perfect. i liked emma's but i think i'm just sick of seeing that font style from every brand
I love Jorge's. It leans a little art nouveau to me. Im drawn to it because it feels premium. I know a lot of people like the white, but I've seen far too many 'cheap' liquors that go with white. White with a clear liquor is too monochromatic. Prone to being overlooked by my eyes. Maybe its because I personally love blue and gold and have a bottle of Johnny walker blue label sitting on the top of my fridge. Regardless Jorge gets my vote.
Absolutely the first design. Using the aurora literally is what I would expect when a brand call itself Aurora. And it look like a old fashioned classy 50s gin
JorgeC's design: Do you think that the design is bottom heavy to reflect the fact that the earth is busy, while the top conveys the vast "emptiness" of space? Or am I thinking too much into it?
That's right, I didn't explain it, I'm JorgeC :)
@@tecknomedia I am JorgeC too what a coincidence
I think it’s because the brief said night sky. So you’d expect to see more space and more of the sky. Not bright, white and lots of sun.
I agree with a lot of commentators here already: usually I have a clear winner in my head, but all of the designs are REALLY well done and all of them are amazing as is - good job to all of the designers involved 🙌🏻
I literally clicked on this video because I saw Jorge’s in the thumbnail and went “ohhh, pretty! What’s this video about?” And then realized it’s about the graphic design. I wish he’d leaned just a little more into either Art Deco or Art nouveau to add a little bit of design to balance out that bottom but I will admit my eye would have gone to it on a shelf as is. I’m in the creative field as a professional and honestly I think all of them are well done for different reasons🙌
I loved Matt’s (the first) design the most, would love to have that bottle in my room!
Second to me would be JorgeC, also very beautiful. The others seemed too standard to me
I love all the designs and appreciate the designers. I really like Miguel's 1st minimal design. I feel the vertical "AURORA" coming out of the bottle when drinking. I like that feeling. 💛
My choice would be no.2 by Jorge. It has old style look - familiar gin bottle look. It has minimalist look.
Having worked behind a bar throughout this whole gin revival thing, going from stocking 4 gins to 30+, all of these designs definitely follow the same path that the vast majority of these independent distilleries are taking. They're all fantastic, my personal pick would be Emma's, I think that Miguel's, while it would stand out being white, is otherwise a touch bland, but that's just my opinion.
I do think they all run the risk of just blending in a bit, that's no fault of the designers, just the over saturation of the market as it stands. Trust me when I say that when you have 35 bottles of gin all lined up next to and behind each other, especially since the majority use the same style of bottle, it all just becomes muddy.
That's why I think a more unique bottle design is just as important than the label, if not more so
The best advice
Will personally being a Fiverr seller I saw your brief which was elaborated excellently. I wish my clients would also give a brief like this.
It’s so cool seeing all these different designs , but I love Jorge’s the most out of them all because it had some color , minimal, beautiful type and cool design … but overall they all did really good !
Insane quality from all designers! Maybe it's my noobish point of view, but I really like all concepts, and I personally could accept any of them if it was my product.
Striking elements in all designs but I also lean towards Miguel 01. I also look at these not just as in shop but also in a bar lined up alongside other brands. Well done all
I just watched the other one for the first time. Glad you made another.
The third entry (Miguel) misspells alcohol as ALCHOOL on both bottles. Heh…. I mean, yes, is a design competition not a spelling one - just something to be careful about ;)
I am in favour of the clean minimalist look of Miguel’s. I feel the darker backgrounds could get lost amongst each other and the white background with the dark blue logo will really catch the eye.
Rich and Miguel's design is right up my alley. The playfulness or rich's design was just right and not overdone which is extremely tasteful while miguel's just speaks to you even without knowing anything about design, it's that good
i would go for Emma, since there is brand expension options without too much effort. Love miguels aswell just not the borealis in the center
8:37 one thins that must be pointed out on this design is the O in "aurora". With a forward slash line in the middle, it becomes the letter Ø, which is a Norse letter, used in modern Norwegian. Aurora Borealis is also something Norway (and other Nordic countries) are quite known for. Due to this link people could easily start reading it as aurøra.
So to decrease the likelihood of confusion, make the stoke a back slash instead.
Percent slashes are from right to left though, the back slash wouldn’t make sense for advertising purposes.
I love that series ❣️
Wow...great job EVERYONE! I would have to go with #4 and #3 as a backup.
The "o" converted to a "0" with the diagonal line was genius. I would preserve that idea and put it in the first design (which I loved).
I like the first one by Ink the best. I think the traditional gin design with the sort of rainbow/holo colors feels like an innovation/a new twist on an old classic. I think that's very much what non-alcoholic gin is. A new fashioned idea trying to slot into a traditional role / habit.
The third one by Miguel is my second favorite but I don't think it accurately conveys "gin". If I saw that as a consumer, I would assume it was vodka.
Just wanted to say that I love the atmosphere of you background so MUCH!
These are my favourite kind of TH-cam videos, on my favourite channel 😄
Glad you like them!
I'd go with Miguel's san-serif layout 1 design because of the clean look against the white (with the fact that Gin is clear) and the abstract nature of the two symbols either side. Minimal in colour and not too busy. Classy, clear to understand and to the point. Well done, Miguel!
Although Will prefered the bottle with the white label with the more modern minimalist design, that label made me think of Vodka rather than Gin. I preferred the white label with the more classic design.
The vintage one from Miguel the best so far
Thanks miguel for this beautiful piece 🤩
love it!, more of this
wish real life clients gave briefs this detailed
No.2
Colour wise and just the overall feel to it I like no.2 especially because of that blue and gold. Font wise no.4 the one with no caps. I feel no.3 the white colour one to be too simplistic. I cant really see how the sun and moon look, is there a colouring on the sun side and just a cut out for the moon. But the moon being a cut out would look great on no.2 I thinn with that night sky colour, and maybe gold foil for the sun. Maybe the stars are cut out, I imagine it could look pretty cool under the right lighting since the drink itself is clear.
But I also really like how the first one has a very clear hierarchy especially with that huge 0% right under the brand.
The mythology illustration would also look good in gold foil against dark blue like no.2
This is honestly difficult, but I'll go with number 2 just because it left the deepest impression on me based on the short video. I think mostly for the colour, the dark blue immediately makes you think of the night sky, and the gold while can be interpreted as as star it reminds me a lot more of the sun because for 1 its gold and 2 how the lins radiate. So I think it's a very good way to incorporate those 2 without it being too literal.
I love your designs, i see every video of you, thank you
All are winner 😄😄
Thank you for the flash warnings!
Absolutely loved Emma's design!
The last Design is my favourite one
Thank you for that flash warnings ♥
The second one looks very art deco which reminds me of Gatsby and luxury. The last one seems the most unique.
Same. I liked Miguel's design esp the 2nd layout. The 1st layout's cutouts look cool af.
Please do more content like this. Cheers
All these designers are very talented. Personally I prefer the second and the third one
I have to go with Emma, really professional and modern looking indeed
Miguel design looks more like a bottle of a skin care product or a fancy hair product rather then something to drink. Design is great btw.
My vote would be more for JorgeC bottle. His design was my favorite.
i love these videos you do, another great video:)
Light one have unique appeal to it although nothing too fancy but it surely stands out n make me wanna try it out of generic ones.
Love this- great work!
Glad you like it!
All of the designs are super high quality, love them all. I might have missed it during the video, but how much did you pay for each of these?
I have a problem with all of these packages in that the bottles are clear. Would have been nice if the container were also part of the design. I know that there are some Gins that have clear containers but the lux ones seem to have colored bottles. Plus, they missed the opportunity to use a bottle wrap to project that infinite space feeling that some were trying to capture. All said and done though, liked the designs and thought they were well thought out.
best design is definitely the Roman Numeral white design, really well done looks like it should be on the shelf. great video was a good watch
I think the first bottle label design is beautiful... and deco looking, beautiful colors. But I guess design-wise I would take the brutal logo with those cool planet shapes opposite each other!
11:00
"I'm gonna used that on my project"
- Will Paterson
Nice one here!
My favorite is the fourth!
Here in Brazil we have a wine brand called Aurora, and what Miguel did in the second design, reminds me a lot that brand
Well done Will. Keep supporting the industry man 🖤💙🖤💙
.........
I'd go for Miguel 🖤💙🖤💙
Damn. I loved all these, with a slight bias towards the minimalistic white one (maybe I’m just boring).
I could see any of those on shelves!
Definitely going with Miguel design number 1 on this. It’s just beautiful. Very clean. I now want gin.
I am gonna vote for this design 6:39 it looks so elegant, luxury, the style of the font he used I like it very much (I think he used San Fransisco, sorry if I'm wrong) And the vector image he used is perfectly matches to the brand.
2nd one is the best for me
First Design reminds a bit of Outer Worlds in-game Brand Logo Designs, such as Spectrum Series from Rizzo's.
Cant decide. They are all winners for me.
Love these videos.
All of these looks incredibly straight forward yet amazing.
I skimmed through the video, but wouldn’t placing your design on the bottle the the most difficult part? Drawing the bottle, the lighting on the label etc.
Omg!! All of them are pro designer but Miguel & Emma was in other level ( in my opinion) One more thing This is the kind of videos I love to watch...please keep making this kinda videos doesn't matter how much the price amount is? But when someone get paid they work for real....👍👍👍👍🔥🔥🔥🔥💘💘💘💘
6:49 the 0 in the Aurora typography is pretty neat. But i wouldn´t recognize this on the first look in the marketshelf. Is there some way to change the r to an actual % symbol? This would maybe add the nuance the shopper would need to see the 0% alcohol directly.
Btw I like this concept the most
Emma, absolutely great!
9:20 Is the best design, (Capital A should be there) but still its the best with Aurora Borialis 3D effect.
That last design's custom typeface reminded me a lot of Braun's logo actually (German electronics company). That A is pretty unique.
Would love to see credit to the designers social links so we could follow and support their work. These packages and designs are amazing,
We don't have their socials unfortunately!
i absolutely loved the first one if i was in a store and i saw that bottle i would have taken it home
What keyboard do you use because it looks really cool
I like the Roman mythology one, but I would have put the % sign inside the "O" of AURORA. There's enough space to do so, and would explain clearly that it's a non alcoholic drink
AH yes, because that's what the art fields needs, to be turned into a popularity contest. I am sure that will be great for creativity.
Mate, this is a competition for the design of a label and packaging, it's not art - it's communication using artistic principles.
Plus, there have been art competitions with popular votes for decades, I don't think this is the nail in the coffin of creative expression
Why u have to be mad
The modern one is great
Suggestion for the video, would be nice if you could just put all results next to eachother at the end :D
I'm not really a fan of tilting my head to see what's on the bottle, so Miguel's first design is off the table first.
Weird, considering it's the best in your opinion... Does show how hard this job is.
Would like to see a place to see the Logo design requirements handed out to the artist for these videos, so I can try and come up with a design before watching the video to see how my attempt holds up with the ones shown. Would be fun.
They’re on screen between 1:35-1:55 :)
@@naomipaterson9300 Thanks Naomi, I would prefer to have it as a text document or pdf prior to watch this video but this will do for now, cheers
eu amei o vídeo, muito inspirador!
Tmb achei!
my favorite is the first one
Miguel #2, the roman mythology one feels the most high end.
I like the 1 one the most 😂
I like JorgeC and Emma's designs🥰
In Miguel's 2nd design with the Roman engraving, what does he mean by "image bank"? And when a company gets a license for a detailed design like that, can other companies still use that same engraving? Much thanks!
Emma by far the best
Nice!
All of the submissions were solid but to me the last two were easily at the bottom. The styles of both weren’t really on trend for right now and reminded me a bit of stock library designs.
Woooo! 💃🏻
I know I am in the minority but Ink aka Matt's design is my favorite. From a marketing standpoint, it would be the easiest to build a solid campaign around. Although a little generic it still works really well. Followed by Jorge's design for 2nd. Miguel's is great but as far as Gin, it seems more like vodka or tequila.
These were all amazing. But, hands down for me, Emma won this. The logo is memorable. The colors are amazing. I love these videos and hearing why you like things, you are always a fair and kind reviewer of the designs!
Any links to the designers? I’d like to see some more work.
@Will Peterson Can you give us please the links to the designers (website or instagram)? Thanks!