Unlike Jill, Billy did love his mother and this makes him more human than her. She murdered her own loving mom just for fame, and this is insanely evil.
@KH You saw the first one BIlly turned on Sidney after finding out her mom was sleeping with his dad. His mom left and he felt abandon Roman is Sidney's bio brother contacted Billy showed him the videos of the affair. Roman help manipulate an angry and hurt Billy into murdering Sid & Roman mom for revenge.
@@topguntk870 True but at least with Roman. His mother disowned him and obviously those same feelings of hate went over to Sidney. Since she was the child that Maurine choose to love and raise. While I despise Roman, I understand that he wouldn't have any love lost for Sidney
@@OnyxeBlade who knows it was implied everyone including jills mother all they talked about was sidney so that coulda been just another reason for jill to have bad feelings about her mother. roman was defs the smartest and most superhuman ghostface. but jill may be the most selfish and shocking
@blue owl moon Oh I know that's not Sidney's fault but Roman's hate for his sister is understandable (not right) due to her getting to be raised and acknowledged by Maureen unlike him who Maureen rejected
@@topguntk870 well he didn't really know sidney or maureen so he hadn't that special connection w them to not kill them,not knowing them made it easier for him cuz he didn't got to see what a good and kind person sidney was
I think the craziest killers are the ones without motivation or connection like Mickey or Stu.. Billy, Mrs Loomis, Roman all have the revenge motive and are almost understandable. The scariest killers are ones without motive as it feels like they could kill you just for fun.
im sorry how was jill the most evil? maybe the most self-centered but not the most evil. theres a difference. so many others were far more evil and brutal. mickey comes to mind as the most evil to me. everyone else wanted to get away with it but mickey was the only one who wanted to keep killing even after if he had won. it makes sense because he was a serial killer found by billys mother who she used. its also the way certain ones killed....jill didnt really kill anyone in a gruesome manner.
I'd say Jill. Her motive was ahead of it's time.. killing her friends and her OWN mom just to be famous. Pure evil. She almost got away with it too, but her problem was she just talked too much. Hopefully we get her or even all the killers in flashbacks or some sort of mention in the new Scream movie!
Personally I'd say it was Mickey who was the most evil becomes he showed no remorse as he wanted to get caught and also was found on a website for serial killers. Nothing drove Mickey to do what he did in scream. Mickey did everything because he enjoyed it and enjoyed killing. Just like Michael Myers, who is the pure embodiment of evil, he just killed because he felt like it.
@@sdeluxes8607 Totally respect your opinion! That is why I 100% agree with this list. Mickey killing everyone around him JUST so his college can get paid by Mrs. Loomis? Yeah, that is pure evil, too. True psychopath right there. I just wish he didn't die off so fast. But idk, there's just something about female killers that are more disturbing.
Idk I always thought Roman since he wanted kill his own mother and half sibling. Which lead to many of events of the series Edited: jill wouldn't even gotten the way she did, due to events of maureen prescott murder that influenced woodsboro massacre
I kinda feel bad for Roman. He wasn’t killing just because. He was doing it so he would have something frame Sydney so he can finally have the revenge he had been wrongfully denied. He then would’ve stopped killing. Billy, Stu, Charlie and Jill all would’ve continued killing just because they liked it. But Roman just wanted revenge. He suffered more than any other character.
I couldn't agree more with you about Jill Roberts. She was pure evil - and ego. Killing her own mother off for... Fame? All her closest friends, one by one? There's nothing more psychotic than that. I don't know if I'd put my ranking like yours (Mickey Altieri was sadistic as hell, in my opinion), but I kinda agree with practically all your arguments here. Nice video, friend.
Mickey should be at the top. I might be wrong but I think he was the only Ghostface to be a straight up serial killer before donning the mask. He murdered just for the enjoyment of it. We also don't even know how many people he killed prior to Scream 2.
Not to discredit; I say Mickey is second most evil because technically he’s completely crazy and even while he was playing the role of a college student, was described as “freaky” and similar to Stu. While he and Stu killed for fun, they weren’t “all there” where Jill was clearly in control of her mentality in betraying her accomplices and laying out a plan. Mickey probably wanted to get caught off the basis he knew he wasn’t smart enough to construct the whole thing. He even said to Sidney he knew he wasn’t strong enough alone.
@@Blast2224 I agree although I do think Jill was crazy too. Obviously you have to be a bit crazy to do what she did. It’s just a different kind of crazy than Mickey who was more flamboyant and wild. Ultimately the two of them had very similar motivations and goals. I just think Mickey’s murder count being a serial killer and all is what potentially makes him worse.
Mickey is my personal favorite Ghostface. I love how insane he clearly was before meeting Mrs. Loomis and his deception and manipulation of Sydney clearly left an impact on her since she went into hiding and Scream 3.
@@THANATOS-PRIME The fact that Mickey made Sidney suspect her own boyfriend. It is a shame her boyfriends died because he was genuinely nice to Sidney. I like Roman as well but it is a shame he did not just murder his possible father instead of his mother. He could have tried to reason with Sidney. Stu was a lot creepier as both Ghostface and in public. He did have a lot of funny moments despite being the most obvious choice for the killer. It is funny as the actor channelled the same energy into Shaggy 8 years later. I have not seen the 4th one yet but Jill seems decent but I wish Sidney had some decent family members despite her mother who seemed more like a victim who gets pushed as a type of antagonist.
Jill's monologue at the end is perfection and it shows how she was just really really crazy. and I think her character became more and more believable through the years because all she wanted was basically to become an influencer, and nowadays we see a bunch of tiktokers doing f*ckd up sh*t just for the clout. it's pure psycho behavior and it shows how this movie is brilliant!
I definitely put Stu before Billy in terms of evil. Stu being worried about Sidney telling his mom because she'd be upset and his mannerisms hint at him not being very mentally stable, which would make it easier for Billy to manipulate him.
Stu reminds me of Bubba Sawyer like they are both in a terrible mental state and it leeds to them being easily manipulated into murderering but Bubba was raised to do it and by his family so I feel like Stu is more evil
@@darthmaul8278 Stu is definitely more evil than Leatherface. That's kind of a odd comparison man. Stu is a psychopath who is well aware of his actions. He wasn't manipulated at all. He was a more than willing participant. Leatherface has the mind of an 8 year old. He legitimately doesn't know any better. Besides the original movie, I think Leatherface: Texas Chainsaw Massacre III is the perfect example of his mentality. The electronic See and Spell scene says it all.
For me Jill was the most evil, she didn't care about anyone but herself, she was willing to kill her own mother and that bothered me, and only someone was truely evil would inflict that kind of pain on themselves the way she did at the end, that was hard to watch.
@@topguntk870 she killed her own mother, almost her cousin. she planned from the beginning to trick charlie to do all the killings for her and then turned around and killed him. she didnt do it for "revenge" she did it for fame. she was even going to just kill all the characters at the end simply to kill them cause she had to know if all those characters died someone would be suspicious that jill would be the only one left if she did it. plus she literally beat herself up. shes definitely the most crazy and evil
@@zom808 well mickey had not motive so by your logic hes the most evil. he didnt do it for money, fame, or revenge. also billy and stu beat himself up too. roman tryed killing his own sister sidney. everything your saying can be said about any ghostface. roman was the smartest. mickey was the most pure evil. but perhaps jill may have been the closest because she didnt waste time she just said i wanna be famous and want fans and boom got to the point.
@@topguntk870 they didnt beat themselves up like jill did. they were planning to stab each other (billy was gonna kill stu tho) roman was gonna kill sidney, his sister that he never even met (which u can argue jill didnt know sidney beforehand either but she also killed her mom) mickey had motives too. he wanted to prove that horror movies make people kill. hes not some no motive killer like everyone thinks he is. also ofc most of it can apply to different characters but theres different reasonings and different situations. it also cant be applied to "any ghostface" how does charlie fit into the killing family members, or beating himself up, or mrs loomis, or stu, or even billy
@@zom808 Same thing dawg its clear your a fan of jill i am too but quit making it seem like shes the most evil but atleast i can give you that shes 2nd most evil after mickey. mickey said he wanted to get caught and his motive was he enjoyed killing. jill didnt enjoy killing she had to kill because people were in her way of her wanting fame. however the smartest was roman by far and hes got the highest kill count of any ghostface and hes the only ghostface who acted alone. he planned alone and executed those plans alone. he didnt need a partner with ideas to bounce back n forth off of. he was practically superhuman the way he took on everyone himself in miltons mansion and he managed to kidnap both dewey and gale. he killed 9 people in that movie including a scene where he took on literally 4 people at once and fastest kill after kill without getting caught or a scratch. jills got nothing on roman and neither does anyone else lol
9. Charlie: Weak, easily manipulated his motive was to please Jill 8. Mrs. Loomis: Purely driven by "Good old fashioned Revenge" 7. Richie: Only killed to create fan fiction 6. Roman: Mostly killed because of abandonment issues, went off the deep end 5. Stu: Manipulated by Billy, probably would have never went down that road if not for him yet learned to revel in murder 4. Amber: Devoid of any morality and insanely vicious who's also a complete coward when the chips are down, stab anyone in the back both literally and figuratively 3. Billy: His "motive" was just the catalyst to get him started...he already had his revenge when he killed Sid's mother, but decided to keep going because he thoroughly enjoyed psychologically torturing and killing people 2. Mickey: Brutally murdered people just to bask in fame and infamy 1. Jill: Her motive is similar to Mickey's (Craving fame and petty superficial bullshit)...but went pretty damn far to try and get it. Trying to kill a family member and killing or at least participating in your own mothers death for fame is some Cold Blooded, Black Hearted shit.
I’m so happy everyone can agree that Jill was the most manipulative and vicious ghostface. Jill was just such an interesting character, it’s well deserved that her character is so infamous
For me, I'd say Mickey was the most evil Ghostface. Billy and Stu were a part of Sidney's friend group, and she'd been dating Billy since before her mom's death. She had connections to Mrs. Loomis, Roman, and Jill, and Charlie at least had his connection to Jill (which was even his motive), however Mickey is different. Mickey heard about Sidney, stalked her, inserted himself into her life and her friend group, started dating her best friend, and played mental games with her PTSD (such as in the Casandra scene ). But most of all, he made her lose faith in herself. She probably could've saved Derek, but he manipulated her PTSD to make her believe he was the accomplice. He essentially made her choose Derek's fate. Wes Craven also said that Mickey was the one who had the biggest impact on her,, revealing his psychotic need to track down a total stranger is the reason she's in isolation at the beginning of Scream 3.
Personally I would say Billy is more evil than Jill. Jill is less evil and more of a bratty child. Billy killed Sidney's mother while successfully framing someone else for it, waited an entire year, gaslit Sidney into feeling guilty about not being intimate with him because she was dealing with the upcoming anniversary of her mother's murder, killed her friends and people around her, all the while playing the part of the "loving and caring boyfriend". Jill was just the bratty cousin who was jealous. "Harumph, I waaant what SHE has. No fair!". I guess it could be argued that Jill is more evil just because her motive is so petty compared to other Ghostface motives, but I think Billy had the biggest impact on Sidney. Which, in my mind, makes him more evil than Jill.
Okay, Billy killed Sidney’s mother, but Jill killed (or had killed) her OWN mother. Billy did what he did because he was heartbroken that his family was torn apart, while Jill did it just for the fame. Jill cared about no one but herself, and that definitely shows just how much more evil she was than Billy. Plus, Jill definitely had a greater impact on Sidney. Sidney literally went the entire movie trying to protect her, only to get backstabbed. And Jill came the closest to killing her out of all the Ghostfaces. Stu was the only other Gf to land a stab on Sidney, but it was never enough to knock her unconscious. I get that y’all love Billy because he was the first Ghostface, and he’s iconic. But let’s give credit to others where it’s due🤷🏽♂️
@@knightwxtch Billy's my favorite but I 100% agree with you. Plus I thought that Scream 4 was the most disturbing movie in the franchise (so far, since I haven't seen the new one yet 😅).
@@emiscommentingaccount96 Yea, Scream 4 definitely had the darkest and most serious tone. I guess we’ll have to see this Friday if Scream 5 will surpass it as being the most disturbing. But I’ve been hearing that it’s the perfect combination of Scary and comedy, so I’m very excited for it.
Billy also nearly got Cotton executed by framing him for the murder of Maureen and him and Stu basically rubbed that they were going to frame her dad Neil for the murders in her face.
Billy's motive was revenge though. That doesn't constitute evil. Jill just done it to be famous, and even killed her own mother. Being a maniac and being evil at heart are two completely different things.
@@s_.777 yeah, she did, as she was the mastermind. But that just makes her psychotic, not evil. Despite seeming to be the same both are 2 different things
I think Mickey is the most evil Ghostface. 1. He was already a serial killer before he took up the Ghostface mantle. 2. He tracked down Sidney and managed to infiltrate her friend group. 3. Mickey was playing mind games with Sidney and gaslight her into mistrusting Derek, which ultimately led to his demise. He also took genuine joy in this, taunting her with the "if you had a mother" line. 4. He went on this rampage just so he could have some elaborate trial and blame the movies.
I def agree with you and plus after he shot Derek he chastise sidney for not trusting or believing Derek i honestly think hes one of the main reason why sidney cut everybody off to be alone in scream 3
Great video, and pretty great ranking! I've seen all 4 in the movie theaters when they were released and can't wait for next weekend to see the 5th. Jill may have been the most shocking reveal of all 4 films, and her self-mutilation scene still stands as one of the most awesome moments to see in a movie theater full of screaming people (plus she killed her mom). The 2nd film is my favorite re-watchable one, and the 1st film is undeniably the best, but the last act of the 4th is batshit crazy because of Jill.
roman and mickey are the most underrated. could you imagine if they were in one movie together as both ghostfaces just them two! that woulda been the scariest and most evil ghostface duo!
Without even having started the video, I'm going to have to say...for me...its a tie between Mickey and Jill. The two of them essentially had the same motive for ruthlessly slaughtering multiple people: fame. Jill at least had somewhat of a personal motive, though one could argue she's the most psychotic due to the sheer pettiness. Mickey however meticulously planned every single step. Heck, even being utterly psychotic was an act for him. Had it not been for his partner turning on him...he would have succeeded.
I feel like Jill was s'pose to embody what millennials were like but her character was more the attitude of a lot of GenZers/Zoomers. Makes Scream 4 kinda ahead of it's time
Scream 4 was definitely ahead of its time. So many references and motifs that are so big now. For the killers motives, specifically Jill, she just encompasses the current rage right now which is to do anything to be famous... this was just not as appreciated when it first came out.
Scream 4 was so ahead of it's time it's only gotten better. Think about what some people do for "clout". The technology in the first 3 date those movies, but the technology in Scream 4 only makes it timeless, which is ironic because showcasing tech usually dates things. Me in 2010 was rolling my eyes at the notion that someone would live stream their whole day.
What makes the Scream series so unique is that they created a slasher icon to carry on the franchise (like Freddy Krueger, Michael Myers, and Jason Voorhees) while also maintaining a ‘who done it’ scenario (like The Prowler, Prom Night, or Friday the 13th part 1) for each movie.
Mickey was the most evil to me. He's the only one who wanted people to know he was a serial killer whilst at the same time getting away with it via the Insanity defence. He was at least the most mentally unstable.
That doesn't mean he's evil, he's just a psychopath. Jill murdered her own mother and friends just to play the victim and become famous. Now that's evil at heart.
@@ojmcclanahan689 well when you have problems with parents as a kid to where you cant fix that relationship they just end up as regular people to you and i think thats how jill thought because when her mom died she said “tell jill im sorry” which at that time it was too late to fix anything between jill and her mom and i know this may sound heartless but this is really how some kids think 🤣 so i stand by my mickey comment
@@shelbysweatt5934 There weren't any problems between Jill and her mother though. She was killed just to further Jill's evil plot of becoming famous. There was no other reason.
@Darren Reddix Being a legit psychopath takes away from the evil aspect because it's a psychological disorder. A person can't necessarily help being a psychopath. They're just acting in accordance with their own nature. Saying a psychopath is "evil" would be like saying a cat is evil because it killed a bird. Someone who would make the choice to systematically murder their friends and family members just so they could frame someone else for it and get famous playing the victim is as evil as it gets. "I don't care if my mom has to die, as long as I get interviewed on TV and the world throws me a party, I'm good!" I feel like there's a lot more to "evil" than just taking a life.
@LilT Marshall I’m sure she was heavily involved with plotting who would die in the film, but (and again, according to Cherry.. maybe not my personal beliefs) Charlie is the one who literally killed her. That’d be like saying Stu and Mickey killed no one in Scream and Scream 2, because Billy and Mrs. Loomis were the ones with the ideas. I’m pretty sure Charlie, Stu, and Mickey would all be guilty of murder, if they’d gotten arrested, instead of killed.
Good ranking! I think Mickey and Roman could swap, Mickey is the evilest one after Jill. He's just psychotic and enjoys killing people and playing mind games like messing with Sidney's trust issues.
Mickey was tough to place. I placed him lower because the movies just don't tell us enough about him. I felt Roman was instrumental in creating so much and was happy to pretend like nothing happened, even after he killed his own mother. But now you have me thinking about Mickey haha 🤣
@@BeyondTheMask The movie tells enough of Mickey so we can see he was completely evil. He wanted to kill his friends and be caugh so he can blame the movies and get way with it. He even says talks about what lawyers wold defend him, his defense witnesses and how christian coligtion will pay his legal fee. He talks as if the his trial would be a show he would enjoy
I'd put Stu in there as well despite his motive of revenge on his ex girlfriend. All three liked killing just because they could. The others had proper motives although Roman is the one that started Billy and Stu off on the killings which then led to Mrs Loomis, which he never planned. Mickey just wanted to kill people and get fame whilst in jail, Jill set up her thing (which is a consequence of Roman's actions although Jill could be considered Sidney's rival whereas the others were mostly based upon her mother). Jill is a more calculative version of Mickey. Roman is also more dangerous because he did not need a partner. He was the only Ghostface in the film. I wonder how many we will get in Scream 5. Hopefully more than two which will be different and make things more dangerous for the trio.
id say mickey is more evil then jill. atleast jill had a motive. mickey just loved killing for the sake of killing. if jill didnt have a motive she wouldnt have killed but she wanted to be famous so she did. mickey had no motive so even without being used by billys mother he still woulda continued killing. god knows how many people he killed and would have had he survived. by far mickey was the most evil and cold hearted.
@@midcuber8320 yeah I mean for me the way I see it was that billy was the pushing point for Stu, I feel like with how he agreed while knowing nothing really about Billy’s motive shows that he might have already been planning on committing an act of murder or violence soon anyway, it kind of in his nature. I’m not sure if it was this channel that posted a video where he said Stu would have nearly been commuting murders before billy found him but personally I think Stu was evilest out of all of them
Mrs Loomis doesn't get enough credit for how smart she was. She kept herself out of thé investigation completely, set up thé copycat narrative beautifully (distracting from an obvious revenge motive) and had a perfect fall Guy with Mickey. She's thé one ghostface who really could have gotten away with it, and that makes her pretty evil to me
@KH yea but i dont think Billy would have gotten away with everything in the end. Jill had all of it planned out and was made out to be the victim. Billy would have likely gotten caught by the cops eventually.
Jill was the best then Billy and stu like Billy and stus kills were more ferocious but Jill revealing herself at the end of S4 and the way she even beat and bruised herself to make it look like she was the survivor/victim was Insane and So Creative !! And she woulda got away with it too if she didn't slip and say something about Gail's Injury like Jill was the Most Iconic and Genuis 4real
billys mother was much scarier then jill. how can anyone forget those evil eyes they reminded you of her sons blank stare. plus she murdered randy so brutally i dont think jill really killed anyone in a horrific way
I use to think Stu’s character was truly scary because he had no motive, but I think “peer pressure” was code for love in the 90’s. I think Stu loved Billy and that’s why he was involved to simply help Billy plan his revenge, and why he didn’t care if Tatum died. It could argued that Mickey’s motive is pre-Jill. Not famous in a reality tv or influencer sort of way, but courtroom famous (a la OJ, Casey Anthony).
Hey really nice edit, as usual. I don't think people are aware of how much time it takes to make edits that looks really simple, but this one was a piece of art!
How is Mickey only number 4? Mrs. Loomis met him online in a serial killer chat room. He most likely killed people before he even became Ghostface. His body count could be higher than all of the Ghostfaces combined for all we know.
In my opinion from revenge to crazy it would be… 1. Roman (killed because of jealousy and neglect) 2. Mrs. Loomis (Revenge for sons death but seemed to have a loose screw) 3/4. Charlie (killed based on love of the films and love for Jill) 3/4. Richie (Killed based on love of films and wanting to correct the course of the future films) 5. Mickey (Killed because he was fan of films but also wanted to be famous, also apparently psychopath but not buying it) 6. Amber (Killed to correct the franchise but also was obsessed with Stu’s house and the whole arc which gives me OCD and actual psychopath vibes) 7. Billy (Revenge killed but also after killing Sid’s mother realized he enjoyed it and started to kill them all off to get back at Sid as well. Gave off serial killer psychopathic vibes like his mother) 8. Jill (First to plot an entire fantasy outcome that worked in her own favor to make her become the next Sidney and famous and killed her own mother to achieve that goal. She gives me the biggest split personality/bipolar vibes because she was able switch on and off her personality of being the good girl so easily and showed it in the final act. As well as being the only ghost face to actually be successful in her plan originally and defeating Sid originally until she woke up.) 9. Stu (Killed based on pure ecstasy and joy for murdering while having a good time and with no reason other than to bond and come closer to billy. He played stupid but was able to flip the switch easily) So for me the most evil killers were those with the heaviest mental disorders that were caused by their obsession with either killing, being with, or becoming sid.
As much as Jill, Stu and Mickey are my favorite Ghostfaces... I think Billy had the MOST evil plan... murder his girlfriend's mother framing innocent Cotton Weary, THEN a year later: murder all your girlfriend's closest friends, then try to kill her and frame her father for the second string of murders.
That wasn’t his plan tho The plan was kill moreen and frame Cotten so he doesn’t get caught But he wasn’t satisfied with that … So that’s why he planned his real attack to get revenge on sid to fill the void in him because killing her mom didn’t fill him not for long anyway he was still angry and needed a new target If he survived the next spree would been killing his dad probably the next person to blame Then his mother who abandoned him Billy killed to fill a void in himself that was never going be filled by killing
Imo I think Mickey was the most evil of them all, especially since He was the first to kill for the fame before there was Jill. Besides the point that I think Mickey was the most brutal killer and he was very skillful as well if you notice, I feel like he moved so well and was the most aggressive while chasing his victims. Also people seems to forget that he was already a well established serial killer when Mrs loomis found him. Mickey took her offer knowing who she was gave him the great idea that hopefully he'd be a famous killer and have his story and murders done in movies, books and documentaries. He's also very smart and the way he played with Sid's mind, he was under her skin and also he did pretty good with acting like the good guy and choosing the same class as Randy was very smart as well but because it certainly made Randy not suspect him. And when he made sure Sid suspect Derek at the hospital. I think Mickey was the most dangerous because he came out of nowhere with ZERO connections to any of the woodsboro survivors or victims. Jill and Stu comes second for me. Roman on the 4th
Mickey was the most disturbing ghostface and the most evil one. He broke and damaged sid the most , he was completely psycho. Mickey is definitely my all time favorite ghostface
I find Charlie really disturbing sense he feels so real sense he’s basically the orginal incel killer considering he did it because Kirby never loved him
I'd rather say that Amber is the most evil Ghostface. Just the savage way she kills her friends and her just being completely insane just like stu. ( don't get me wrong she's not my favourite ghostface thats stu but I think she's the most evil one)
For me, it’s Roman. He gives up his tragedy by switching his motive to envy after getting revenge on his mom, and is indirectly responsible for most of the bad stuff that happened in the series
Mickey should absolutely be number 1. It shouldn't even matter that not much more information was given about him, what we do know already easily beats out Jill. The guy actually is a psychopath, he committed a massacre for the thrill and wanted to be caught and to have the world know what he did. Everyone else on this list wanted to get away with it except for Mickey. Stu should probably be 2nd because he most likely is psychotic and loved what he was doing, even wanting to plan a "sequel"
I feel like Ms Loomis isn't as simple as people think because after his husband had an affair she obviously left him but she didn't even try to get custody of Billy as far as we know and at one part she yelled that she is not a bad mother which might mean she thought Billy murdering people made her look bad and that was why she wanted to kill but it still could be just like she says it is
I feel like her and micky probably had more intense relationships behind the scenes micky seems like he has mommy issues himself which could be why he decided to work with Nancy
Hmm, so your “Best Ghostface” also wins the “Most Evil” award…. Lol The most evil are the ones who have no real motives. They just do it, because they like to. Mickey would be #1, with Stu being a close 2nd. But, in terms of Best Ghostface (as they should be 2 different categories!), that’d be Billy for me!
Yeah but stu was manipulated into killing(I can't argue that he was already crazy),and Mickey was crazy but I don't think that he would kill his own parents maybe,and Jill's motive is almost equal to the motives of those who killed without reason,and she either killed her mother or let her die,she's not my fav ghostface but it obvious that she's evil at heart
Very curious to see your take on this now that Scream 2022 is out. Wish I could say more but I don't want to spoil it for anyone. Personally, I'd put Stu about where Charlie is on the list as they were both manipulated by the other killer in their duo. I'd also put Mickey second to Jill and put Roman further down on the list comparatively. While roman also killed his mother, it was only after she rejected him. So if personal revenge motives are less evil, I think that would put him lower on the list than someone like Mickey who has more similar fame-oriented motives like Jill. I do agree she's at the top of the list for being able to kill her own mother for no reason other than fame, and for killing her own accomplice just so he couldn't share the spotlight
As much as I hate Jill as Ghostface, she sure was an evil one. Actually killing her own mum was enough to be labelled the most evil. It's a shame her acting chops were too cringe and had an unrealistic structure to be the killer, otherwise she'd of been a pretty good ghostface.
Wasn’t the line “even my own mother had to die” meaning Charlie killed her mother. Jill only killed Charlie and Trevor (because they were the Billy and Stu of the movie).
@@subjectdelta4758 she still allowed it to happen, which is enough. But Roman also killed his mother, so I'm actually stuck between Jill and Roman, honestly.
@@abrimfulofasha | I’d probably say Jill is more evil. Jill manipulated Charlie into killing all her friends plus Sidney’s publicist all for 15 mins of fame. Roman did it because he wanted revenge on Maureen for rejecting him. Originally, Angelina was going to be Roman’s accomplice but I’m guessing since scripts of SCREAM 3 was leaked (like SCREAM 2’s script) so they had to redo/rewrite the script several times even rewriting the script mid shoot).
@@subjectdelta4758 yeah I know that about Scream 3. Roman was my favourite Ghostface, to me he was the perfect ambodiment of Ghostface. All the killers killed their friends apart from Miss Loomis, so no difference their. It was more to do with the fact that Jill actually knew and spent her whole life with her mum, as Roman didn't. So yeah, the pyschotic brownie points go to Jill for sure.
@@subjectdelta4758 That doesn't line up though because Jill would have still been in the area (waiting for a Kirby pickup) where Charlie would have still been at the barn for Stab-a-Thon. Jill was definitely the one to kill her mom, as well as Hoss & Perkins.
Right off the bat I have to say something. When Mrs. Loomis is the one who kills the psycho Mickey you've got to question, how psycho is she?! And why didn't Mrs. Loomis kill Mr. Loomis? I guess she could've and we just never hear about it because she made it look like an accident or something. But it just amazes me that at least 3 killers go on a killing spree and try to kill Sidney because of the mistakes or wrong doings of someone else. It's the most illogical and insane part of the franchise.
In the first one, it was because Stu wanted to kill his ex. In the sequel, Mickey wanted to kill others to gain fame but I'm not sure about Roman. Randy died because he mocked Billy Loomis to the mother posing as Ghostface.
You do realise every ghostface apart from Miss Loomis killed their friends, so no difference there. But yes.. the killing of her own mother was pure evil.
@@abrimfulofasha They all killed a shitload of people, motive is the main factor for me in regards to who is most evil. Using motive as main factor I think Mrs. Loomis (played magnificently by Laurie Metcalf) is the least evil of them all.
A pretty solid list for the most part, personally though I'd id put mickey alteiri above both stu and Roman, because imo even though he wasn't as well known, his petty motive and thrill for killing makes him way more evil pluss of the 7 killers he was already an active serial killer that Mrs loomis looked up and tracked down. Pluss he was incredibly psychotic as well. The unkown as well makes it definitely a case of at least near pure evil and or imo pure evil for all these killers, so imo of these 7 id put him at number 2, he also didn't seem tragically evil either. Sometimes enforcers have a higher evil rating then the brains of the operation imo or of the partners of ghost face minus Roman from that because he worked alone Ps Random note let's not forget that it was Roman who truly orcastrated the events of scream 1as revealed in scream 3 spoiler alert. Thanks for hearing me
@@jayharden6278 every ghostface killed their own friends apart from Miss Loomis, but I get what you mean with her killing her own mum. That takes true evil mentality.
That’s not what this was about tho lol I wish y’all gave it a rest, every list y’all always say Billy without even reading or listening to what the list is about 😂😂
I would personally put Mickey 2nd only behind Jill. Because Roman ultimately wanted revenge. Mickey killed just to do it. And was excited to get caught and go to trial.
Really enjoyed the video. My list from evil to most evil. 7. Charlie 6. Mrs. Loomis 5. Billy 4. Mickey 3. Roman 2. Stu( my favorite character and ghost face) 1. Jill
I think you’re severely underrating Billy on this list. Just to go through a list of his deeds against Sidney alone: - He murdered Sidney’s mother Maureen. - He framed Cotton for Maureen’s murder, which caused Sidney to testify against Cotton and put him in prison for a year. - He continued to stay in a relationship with Sidney in the aftermath of her mother’s murder and pressure her to let it go. - He killed Sidney’s best friend Tatum. - He planned to kill Sidney on the anniversary of her mother’s murder. - He seduced Sidney and took her virginity, despite planning to still kill her before the night was through. - He planned to kill Sidney’s father and frame him for all the murders. As far as personal vendettas go, no one has gone as far as Billy did against Sidney. He should at least be # 2.
He is vengeful but not pure evil. If he pure evil, he will not through all of that. He lost love from his mom that makes him pissed. But you right about he murder Tatum. Is not Stu who doing it.
@@davidariyan7915 yeah I think he was also the one who killed Kasey but Stu probably was there two because it would be impossible for one person to do all that stuff so Stu probably killed Steve
No, he was the one who got Billy provoked to starting the killing spree. Not saying Billy decided to do it on his own, cuz he did, but Roman was also pulling the strings, telling him to find someone to frame(Cotton Weary) and a buddy to frame if things went wrong(Stu)
I would say that it’s a toss up between Mickey & Jill. Mickey is already a prolific serial killer by the events of Scream 2,but Jill planned and then maliciously executed nearly all of her friends,and butchered her own mother who was loving and kind,you gotta be seriously evil to do some shit like that.
I like your list, but honestly I switch Roman and Jill. For my personal opinion. I also think that Mickey should be above Stu only because you have to be a sick person to just go out and want to kill people just for the fun of it.
I mean come on. Anyone willing to scratch themselves, rip out a clod of hair, stab themselves, throw themselves into a picture and a glass table is absolutely pure evil. Jill Roberts was the epitome of cray cray!!!!
I feel Mickey is the most as he has no connection to the other killers. Roman orchestrated the whole thing and influenced Billy. There would be no Billy, Stu, Mrs Loomis, or Jill without Roman initiated everything. Billy killed because he saw videos of his father with Maureen Prescott and his mother left the family. Billy manipulated Stu who seemed unstable but I don't think would have killed anyone if not for Billy. Mrs Loomis killed for revenge for Billy's death. Jill killed to become the new Sydney which would have never crossed her mind if the original killings never took place. Mickey may have been influenced by Billy but Mickey was already fascinated with serial killings, movie violence, and the sensational aspects of serial killing. He is waiting around stalking innocent people to kill . He was the only who was headed down this path, it was just a matter of time. One thing:killers having a motive as re no less evil than those without a motive. Hitler is no less evil because he had a motive. There is always some event or strange fascination that all of these serial killers has in common. One of them being they feel they are smarter than everyone else and can get away with it. Mickey reminds of Dahmer who was fascinated with having the power over life and death. That was his motive. Mickey was fascinated with murdering people and testing the limits to of sanity vs insanity. Mickey, like Dahmer was going to kill at some point.
i think the most evil and shocking reveal was JILL…i mean that performance was everything she killed her own mother, her accomplice and her boyfriend just to get famous and loved. I love scream 1 but the best killer in my opinion was jill.
they all were really close to getting away with it. i think roman or billy was the closest. billy wasted too much time talking when he had her on the ground coulda killed her but his psycho mentality got in his way
@@topguntk870 pretty sure all the killers spend time too much time talking 🤣🤣🤣 they could've just straight to the point and bam kills everyone. Piece of cake.
For everyone saying jill isn't the most evil,think again,her mother was either killed cuz of her or she did it herself,she tried to kill her maybe last alive relative,killed her closest friends,and all other stuff just to get fame,idk how you can't get it even after she told her motive,and for everyone saying roman is the most evil for getting his mother killed and trying to kill sidney,he never meet them,so he never saw if maureen was a good person and he never saw how nice sidney is,so that made it easy for him to do it all,and he was angry and hateful and jealous cuz sidney was the one to get that nice happy life he didn't have before she got involved into the killings,and after thatt too cuz she became famous,and he became crazy cuz first he got abandoned,second his mother didn't want him after he found her,and other ghostfaces weren't completely evil like mrs.Loomis,billy,like they were more made evil,the other ghostfaces (amber,Mickey,stu,Charlie,and richie)didn't seem that evil too cuz they didn't seem like the type of people that would kill they own parents or even a child,and I think jill wouldn't even blink if she had to kill a child
@KH yup,both of them have literally almost the same motives,but they did kill people who weren't involved in everything.I think billy hated sidney cuz maureen,the woman who destroyed his family is the mother of his gf,and I think that what made him slowly hate her
Please in the coming days will you remove any comments that reveal spoilers? Would deeply appreciate if you could. Spoilers matter for this franchise given its format. Thanks for the content, as always
I'd say Billy was the most evil Ghostface. Even though Maureen had an affair with his dad she didn't deserve to die. That was also his only kill with a motive. He killed all his other victims because he liked killing. Stu was as evil as Billy but Billy managed to manipulate Stu into helping him kill probably by saying they'd create their own real life horror film when really Billy just wanted to go out and kill. It wasn't horror related. At the school he mocks Sidney's mother's death acting like it was no different to his mother leaving his dad while pretending he's just an angry boyfriend making an insensitive comparison. He's the one who kills Tatum with the garage door then later he has sex with Sidney because he believes the "sex equals death" rule and thinks taking her virginity will allow him to kill her by horror rules. Then him and Stu rub how they're going to frame her dad for the murders in her face.
I’m a firm believer Stu was gay for Billy or at least bi. Because I think we all agree he wanted Casey dead for breaking up with him, and he dated Tatum and he tells Sidney “I always had a thing for you.” But idk he acts pretty sus around Billy. Then again he could’ve just been very deranged. Also I’m a firm believer that Billy killed Casey and that Stu killed Steve.
Lol no,jill motive wasn't even personal,and she did it all for fame,and not to mention,she killed her own mother,a horrible act that no one of the ghostfaces did or would do,except Mickey maybe
Unlike Jill, Billy did love his mother and this makes him more human than her. She murdered her own loving mom just for fame, and this is insanely evil.
@KH You saw the first one BIlly turned on Sidney after finding out her mom was sleeping with his dad. His mom left and he felt abandon Roman is Sidney's bio brother contacted Billy showed him the videos of the affair. Roman help manipulate an angry and hurt Billy into murdering Sid & Roman mom for revenge.
She didn't kill her mother, but she didn't care
Jill killed her own mother. None of the other Ghostfaces did such a horrific act. That alone made her the most evil in my eyes
well in all fareness roman tryed to kill his own flesh and blood hlf sister in sidney.
@@topguntk870 True but at least with Roman. His mother disowned him and obviously those same feelings of hate went over to Sidney. Since she was the child that Maurine choose to love and raise. While I despise Roman, I understand that he wouldn't have any love lost for Sidney
@@OnyxeBlade who knows it was implied everyone including jills mother all they talked about was sidney so that coulda been just another reason for jill to have bad feelings about her mother. roman was defs the smartest and most superhuman ghostface. but jill may be the most selfish and shocking
@blue owl moon Oh I know that's not Sidney's fault but Roman's hate for his sister is understandable (not right) due to her getting to be raised and acknowledged by Maureen unlike him who Maureen rejected
@@topguntk870 well he didn't really know sidney or maureen so he hadn't that special connection w them to not kill them,not knowing them made it easier for him cuz he didn't got to see what a good and kind person sidney was
I think the craziest killers are the ones without motivation or connection like Mickey or Stu.. Billy, Mrs Loomis, Roman all have the revenge motive and are almost understandable. The scariest killers are ones without motive as it feels like they could kill you just for fun.
I agree. The no motive killers are scarier.
@@tonyurbina2187 indeed
Yep
"It's scarier when there's no motive Sid."
@@Halloqween_13 yep, Billy's words💯
This was a great video. I think Jill was definitely the most evil over the bunch. Billy and Stu are my favourites though.
Agreed. “Don’t fuck with the original”
Facts
im sorry how was jill the most evil? maybe the most self-centered but not the most evil. theres a difference. so many others were far more evil and brutal. mickey comes to mind as the most evil to me. everyone else wanted to get away with it but mickey was the only one who wanted to keep killing even after if he had won. it makes sense because he was a serial killer found by billys mother who she used. its also the way certain ones killed....jill didnt really kill anyone in a gruesome manner.
@@topguntk870 💯
Jill killed her mom..like when she ran out the door and her mom got it through the slot..that was Jill who did it
I'd say Jill. Her motive was ahead of it's time.. killing her friends and her OWN mom just to be famous. Pure evil. She almost got away with it too, but her problem was she just talked too much. Hopefully we get her or even all the killers in flashbacks or some sort of mention in the new Scream movie!
Personally I'd say it was Mickey who was the most evil becomes he showed no remorse as he wanted to get caught and also was found on a website for serial killers. Nothing drove Mickey to do what he did in scream. Mickey did everything because he enjoyed it and enjoyed killing. Just like Michael Myers, who is the pure embodiment of evil, he just killed because he felt like it.
@@sdeluxes8607 Totally respect your opinion! That is why I 100% agree with this list. Mickey killing everyone around him JUST so his college can get paid by Mrs. Loomis? Yeah, that is pure evil, too. True psychopath right there. I just wish he didn't die off so fast. But idk, there's just something about female killers that are more disturbing.
Idk I always thought Roman since he wanted kill his own mother and half sibling. Which lead to many of events of the series
Edited: jill wouldn't even gotten the way she did, due to events of maureen prescott murder that influenced woodsboro massacre
@@danwarner7816 100%
Well charlie killed her mom
Roman is my favorite out of the Ghostface killers ..In my opinion I think he was the most clever and cunning out of all of the Ghostface killers…
He was the only solo killer, so you have to give him that.
I kinda feel bad for Roman. He wasn’t killing just because. He was doing it so he would have something frame Sydney so he can finally have the revenge he had been wrongfully denied. He then would’ve stopped killing. Billy, Stu, Charlie and Jill all would’ve continued killing just because they liked it. But Roman just wanted revenge. He suffered more than any other character.
@@arcticwolfplays5519 nancy loomis only wanted to revenge of sidney, so she would stop killing too
I couldn't agree more with you about Jill Roberts. She was pure evil - and ego. Killing her own mother off for... Fame? All her closest friends, one by one? There's nothing more psychotic than that. I don't know if I'd put my ranking like yours (Mickey Altieri was sadistic as hell, in my opinion), but I kinda agree with practically all your arguments here. Nice video, friend.
Mickey is worse than Stu at least.
@@paxte5896 agree to disagree
@@BullyMaguire2024Yes he is, the man was already a serial killer before Scream 2.
Mickey should be at the top. I might be wrong but I think he was the only Ghostface to be a straight up serial killer before donning the mask. He murdered just for the enjoyment of it. We also don't even know how many people he killed prior to Scream 2.
Not to discredit; I say Mickey is second most evil because technically he’s completely crazy and even while he was playing the role of a college student, was described as “freaky” and similar to Stu. While he and Stu killed for fun, they weren’t “all there” where Jill was clearly in control of her mentality in betraying her accomplices and laying out a plan. Mickey probably wanted to get caught off the basis he knew he wasn’t smart enough to construct the whole thing. He even said to Sidney he knew he wasn’t strong enough alone.
@@Blast2224 I agree although I do think Jill was crazy too. Obviously you have to be a bit crazy to do what she did. It’s just a different kind of crazy than Mickey who was more flamboyant and wild. Ultimately the two of them had very similar motivations and goals. I just think Mickey’s murder count being a serial killer and all is what potentially makes him worse.
Ecactly Mickey had ZERO ties to the story and still went the hardest out of any of the killers tf they talkn bout man
Mickey is my personal favorite Ghostface. I love how insane he clearly was before meeting Mrs. Loomis and his deception and manipulation of Sydney clearly left an impact on her since she went into hiding and Scream 3.
@@THANATOS-PRIME The fact that Mickey made Sidney suspect her own boyfriend. It is a shame her boyfriends died because he was genuinely nice to Sidney. I like Roman as well but it is a shame he did not just murder his possible father instead of his mother. He could have tried to reason with Sidney. Stu was a lot creepier as both Ghostface and in public. He did have a lot of funny moments despite being the most obvious choice for the killer. It is funny as the actor channelled the same energy into Shaggy 8 years later. I have not seen the 4th one yet but Jill seems decent but I wish Sidney had some decent family members despite her mother who seemed more like a victim who gets pushed as a type of antagonist.
Jill's monologue at the end is perfection and it shows how she was just really really crazy. and I think her character became more and more believable through the years because all she wanted was basically to become an influencer, and nowadays we see a bunch of tiktokers doing f*ckd up sh*t just for the clout. it's pure psycho behavior and it shows how this movie is brilliant!
I definitely put Stu before Billy in terms of evil. Stu being worried about Sidney telling his mom because she'd be upset and his mannerisms hint at him not being very mentally stable, which would make it easier for Billy to manipulate him.
That one thing told me that Stu wasn't evil at all. Just psychotic. Jill killed her own mother and friends just to play the victim and become famous.
@@ojmcclanahan689 I think Jill was because she manipulated Charlie into killing most of them, with the plan to take him out all along.
Stu reminds me of Bubba Sawyer like they are both in a terrible mental state and it leeds to them being easily manipulated into murderering but Bubba was raised to do it and by his family so I feel like Stu is more evil
@@darthmaul8278 Stu is definitely more evil than Leatherface. That's kind of a odd comparison man. Stu is a psychopath who is well aware of his actions. He wasn't manipulated at all. He was a more than willing participant. Leatherface has the mind of an 8 year old. He legitimately doesn't know any better. Besides the original movie, I think Leatherface: Texas Chainsaw Massacre III is the perfect example of his mentality. The electronic See and Spell scene says it all.
@@darthmaul8278 I honestly believe Bubba Sawyer deserved better
For me Jill was the most evil, she didn't care about anyone but herself, she was willing to kill her own mother and that bothered me, and only someone was truely evil would inflict that kind of pain on themselves the way she did at the end, that was hard to watch.
she was definately the most selfish but wouldnt say the most evil
@@topguntk870 she killed her own mother, almost her cousin. she planned from the beginning to trick charlie to do all the killings for her and then turned around and killed him. she didnt do it for "revenge" she did it for fame. she was even going to just kill all the characters at the end simply to kill them cause she had to know if all those characters died someone would be suspicious that jill would be the only one left if she did it.
plus she literally beat herself up. shes definitely the most crazy and evil
@@zom808 well mickey had not motive so by your logic hes the most evil. he didnt do it for money, fame, or revenge. also billy and stu beat himself up too. roman tryed killing his own sister sidney. everything your saying can be said about any ghostface. roman was the smartest. mickey was the most pure evil. but perhaps jill may have been the closest because she didnt waste time she just said i wanna be famous and want fans and boom got to the point.
@@topguntk870 they didnt beat themselves up like jill did. they were planning to stab each other (billy was gonna kill stu tho) roman was gonna kill sidney, his sister that he never even met (which u can argue jill didnt know sidney beforehand either but she also killed her mom) mickey had motives too. he wanted to prove that horror movies make people kill. hes not some no motive killer like everyone thinks he is.
also ofc most of it can apply to different characters but theres different reasonings and different situations. it also cant be applied to "any ghostface" how does charlie fit into the killing family members, or beating himself up, or mrs loomis, or stu, or even billy
@@zom808 Same thing dawg its clear your a fan of jill i am too but quit making it seem like shes the most evil but atleast i can give you that shes 2nd most evil after mickey. mickey said he wanted to get caught and his motive was he enjoyed killing. jill didnt enjoy killing she had to kill because people were in her way of her wanting fame. however the smartest was roman by far and hes got the highest kill count of any ghostface and hes the only ghostface who acted alone. he planned alone and executed those plans alone. he didnt need a partner with ideas to bounce back n forth off of. he was practically superhuman the way he took on everyone himself in miltons mansion and he managed to kidnap both dewey and gale. he killed 9 people in that movie including a scene where he took on literally 4 people at once and fastest kill after kill without getting caught or a scratch. jills got nothing on roman and neither does anyone else lol
9. Charlie: Weak, easily manipulated his motive was to please Jill
8. Mrs. Loomis: Purely driven by "Good old fashioned Revenge"
7. Richie: Only killed to create fan fiction
6. Roman: Mostly killed because of abandonment issues, went off the deep end
5. Stu: Manipulated by Billy, probably would have never went down that road if not for him yet learned to revel in murder
4. Amber: Devoid of any morality and insanely vicious who's also a complete coward when the chips are down, stab anyone in the back both literally and figuratively
3. Billy: His "motive" was just the catalyst to get him started...he already had his revenge when he killed Sid's mother, but decided to keep going because he thoroughly enjoyed psychologically torturing and killing people
2. Mickey: Brutally murdered people just to bask in fame and infamy
1. Jill: Her motive is similar to Mickey's (Craving fame and petty superficial bullshit)...but went pretty damn far to try and get it. Trying to kill a family member and killing or at least participating in your own mothers death for fame is some Cold Blooded, Black Hearted shit.
Roman and Jill ate pure evil
Amber is no better than Richie tbh. They should both be below Mrs Loomis
@@silverstrike5904 agreed.
Plus Stu cared about Bully and his parents and was shocked to hear Billy’s mother left him.
Nice list, in my opinion Stu is more evil than Billy just because he has no motive but I respect your opinion
I’m so happy everyone can agree that Jill was the most manipulative and vicious ghostface. Jill was just such an interesting character, it’s well deserved that her character is so infamous
She was definitely not the most manipulative.Billy was insanely manipulative.And Mickey was up there too
Roman planned out the killings of the first movie by getting Billy to bring along Stu for them.
For me, I'd say Mickey was the most evil Ghostface. Billy and Stu were a part of Sidney's friend group, and she'd been dating Billy since before her mom's death. She had connections to Mrs. Loomis, Roman, and Jill, and Charlie at least had his connection to Jill (which was even his motive), however Mickey is different. Mickey heard about Sidney, stalked her, inserted himself into her life and her friend group, started dating her best friend, and played mental games with her PTSD (such as in the Casandra scene ). But most of all, he made her lose faith in herself. She probably could've saved Derek, but he manipulated her PTSD to make her believe he was the accomplice. He essentially made her choose Derek's fate. Wes Craven also said that Mickey was the one who had the biggest impact on her,, revealing his psychotic need to track down a total stranger is the reason she's in isolation at the beginning of Scream 3.
Personally I would say Billy is more evil than Jill. Jill is less evil and more of a bratty child. Billy killed Sidney's mother while successfully framing someone else for it, waited an entire year, gaslit Sidney into feeling guilty about not being intimate with him because she was dealing with the upcoming anniversary of her mother's murder, killed her friends and people around her, all the while playing the part of the "loving and caring boyfriend". Jill was just the bratty cousin who was jealous. "Harumph, I waaant what SHE has. No fair!". I guess it could be argued that Jill is more evil just because her motive is so petty compared to other Ghostface motives, but I think Billy had the biggest impact on Sidney. Which, in my mind, makes him more evil than Jill.
Okay, Billy killed Sidney’s mother, but Jill killed (or had killed) her OWN mother. Billy did what he did because he was heartbroken that his family was torn apart, while Jill did it just for the fame. Jill cared about no one but herself, and that definitely shows just how much more evil she was than Billy.
Plus, Jill definitely had a greater impact on Sidney. Sidney literally went the entire movie trying to protect her, only to get backstabbed. And Jill came the closest to killing her out of all the Ghostfaces. Stu was the only other Gf to land a stab on Sidney, but it was never enough to knock her unconscious. I get that y’all love Billy because he was the first Ghostface, and he’s iconic. But let’s give credit to others where it’s due🤷🏽♂️
@@knightwxtch Billy's my favorite but I 100% agree with you. Plus I thought that Scream 4 was the most disturbing movie in the franchise (so far, since I haven't seen the new one yet 😅).
@@emiscommentingaccount96 Yea, Scream 4 definitely had the darkest and most serious tone. I guess we’ll have to see this Friday if Scream 5 will surpass it as being the most disturbing. But I’ve been hearing that it’s the perfect combination of Scary and comedy, so I’m very excited for it.
Billy also nearly got Cotton executed by framing him for the murder of Maureen and him and Stu basically rubbed that they were going to frame her dad Neil for the murders in her face.
Billy's motive was revenge though. That doesn't constitute evil. Jill just done it to be famous, and even killed her own mother. Being a maniac and being evil at heart are two completely different things.
Probably Jill
Mickey actually
@@LA_Vandal562 jill killed her own mother lol
@@s_.777 she literally didnt😂 there was no way she could have
@@toastghost342 ok well she orchestrated her mother’s death
@@s_.777 yeah, she did, as she was the mastermind. But that just makes her psychotic, not evil. Despite seeming to be the same both are 2 different things
I think Mickey is the most evil Ghostface.
1. He was already a serial killer before he took up the Ghostface mantle.
2. He tracked down Sidney and managed to infiltrate her friend group.
3. Mickey was playing mind games with Sidney and gaslight her into mistrusting Derek, which ultimately led to his demise. He also took genuine joy in this, taunting her with the "if you had a mother" line.
4. He went on this rampage just so he could have some elaborate trial and blame the movies.
I def agree with you and plus after he shot Derek he chastise sidney for not trusting or believing Derek i honestly think hes one of the main reason why sidney cut everybody off to be alone in scream 3
@@daboiielcamo i think amber most evil imo
@@wreckRBX1234 imo… nah
Great video, and pretty great ranking! I've seen all 4 in the movie theaters when they were released and can't wait for next weekend to see the 5th. Jill may have been the most shocking reveal of all 4 films, and her self-mutilation scene still stands as one of the most awesome moments to see in a movie theater full of screaming people (plus she killed her mom). The 2nd film is my favorite re-watchable one, and the 1st film is undeniably the best, but the last act of the 4th is batshit crazy because of Jill.
roman and mickey are the most underrated. could you imagine if they were in one movie together as both ghostfaces just them two! that woulda been the scariest and most evil ghostface duo!
Ohhh god, if they were a ghostface duo they would win. They would wipe out sid, gale, dewey all in 1 movie.
no doubt
Without even having started the video, I'm going to have to say...for me...its a tie between Mickey and Jill. The two of them essentially had the same motive for ruthlessly slaughtering multiple people: fame. Jill at least had somewhat of a personal motive, though one could argue she's the most psychotic due to the sheer pettiness. Mickey however meticulously planned every single step. Heck, even being utterly psychotic was an act for him. Had it not been for his partner turning on him...he would have succeeded.
I feel like Jill was s'pose to embody what millennials were like but her character was more the attitude of a lot of GenZers/Zoomers. Makes Scream 4 kinda ahead of it's time
Scream 4 was definitely ahead of its time. So many references and motifs that are so big now. For the killers motives, specifically Jill, she just encompasses the current rage right now which is to do anything to be famous... this was just not as appreciated when it first came out.
Scream 4 was so ahead of it's time it's only gotten better. Think about what some people do for "clout". The technology in the first 3 date those movies, but the technology in Scream 4 only makes it timeless, which is ironic because showcasing tech usually dates things. Me in 2010 was rolling my eyes at the notion that someone would live stream their whole day.
What makes the Scream series so unique is that they created a slasher icon to carry on the franchise (like Freddy Krueger, Michael Myers, and Jason Voorhees) while also maintaining a ‘who done it’ scenario (like The Prowler, Prom Night, or Friday the 13th part 1) for each movie.
Mickey was the most evil to me. He's the only one who wanted people to know he was a serial killer whilst at the same time getting away with it via the Insanity defence.
He was at least the most mentally unstable.
mickey was the most evil he was literally on a serial killer website and actually enjoyed killing 🤣
That doesn't mean he's evil, he's just a psychopath. Jill murdered her own mother and friends just to play the victim and become famous. Now that's evil at heart.
@@ojmcclanahan689 well when you have problems with parents as a kid to where you cant fix that relationship they just end up as regular people to you and i think thats how jill thought because when her mom died she said “tell jill im sorry” which at that time it was too late to fix anything between jill and her mom and i know this may sound heartless but this is really how some kids think 🤣 so i stand by my mickey comment
@@shelbysweatt5934 There weren't any problems between Jill and her mother though. She was killed just to further Jill's evil plot of becoming famous. There was no other reason.
@Darren Reddix Being a legit psychopath takes away from the evil aspect because it's a psychological disorder. A person can't necessarily help being a psychopath. They're just acting in accordance with their own nature. Saying a psychopath is "evil" would be like saying a cat is evil because it killed a bird. Someone who would make the choice to systematically murder their friends and family members just so they could frame someone else for it and get famous playing the victim is as evil as it gets. "I don't care if my mom has to die, as long as I get interviewed on TV and the world throws me a party, I'm good!" I feel like there's a lot more to "evil" than just taking a life.
7:46 What's really evil about Jill killing her mother is she did it solely to copycat Billy's murder of her aunt Maureen.
More to become like Sydney. She wanted the fame that came with what happened to Sydney (which Sydney rejected the fame).
Jill was super lame
@LilT Marshall so if ghostface jill took you out itd make sense to you? Lol
Charlie killed Jill’s mom, if you agree with Cherry’s video about who killed who in Scream 4.
@LilT Marshall I’m sure she was heavily involved with plotting who would die in the film, but (and again, according to Cherry.. maybe not my personal beliefs) Charlie is the one who literally killed her.
That’d be like saying Stu and Mickey killed no one in Scream and Scream 2, because Billy and Mrs. Loomis were the ones with the ideas. I’m pretty sure Charlie, Stu, and Mickey would all be guilty of murder, if they’d gotten arrested, instead of killed.
Jesus, when you break it down in detail, Jill truly was the darkest of the dark. No character has been at her level.
Agreed, Jill was very cold heartless. I actually had Roman as my number 1 until I watched this video.
Wow, that's some awesome editing! Great job!
Good ranking! I think Mickey and Roman could swap, Mickey is the evilest one after Jill. He's just psychotic and enjoys killing people and playing mind games like messing with Sidney's trust issues.
Mickey was tough to place. I placed him lower because the movies just don't tell us enough about him. I felt Roman was instrumental in creating so much and was happy to pretend like nothing happened, even after he killed his own mother. But now you have me thinking about Mickey haha 🤣
@@BeyondTheMask The movie tells enough of Mickey so we can see he was completely evil. He wanted to kill his friends and be caugh so he can blame the movies and get way with it. He even says talks about what lawyers wold defend him, his defense witnesses and how christian coligtion will pay his legal fee. He talks as if the his trial would be a show he would enjoy
I'd put Stu in there as well despite his motive of revenge on his ex girlfriend. All three liked killing just because they could. The others had proper motives although Roman is the one that started Billy and Stu off on the killings which then led to Mrs Loomis, which he never planned. Mickey just wanted to kill people and get fame whilst in jail, Jill set up her thing (which is a consequence of Roman's actions although Jill could be considered Sidney's rival whereas the others were mostly based upon her mother). Jill is a more calculative version of Mickey. Roman is also more dangerous because he did not need a partner. He was the only Ghostface in the film. I wonder how many we will get in Scream 5. Hopefully more than two which will be different and make things more dangerous for the trio.
id say mickey is more evil then jill. atleast jill had a motive. mickey just loved killing for the sake of killing. if jill didnt have a motive she wouldnt have killed but she wanted to be famous so she did. mickey had no motive so even without being used by billys mother he still woulda continued killing. god knows how many people he killed and would have had he survived. by far mickey was the most evil and cold hearted.
@@EmperorOfChaos Stu would neevr have killed without Billy.
I would have said Stu, simply bcos he had no real motive. He was more of a ‘joy killer’ who did it for the thrill. Jill would have been a close second
@@midcuber8320 yeah I mean for me the way I see it was that billy was the pushing point for Stu, I feel like with how he agreed while knowing nothing really about Billy’s motive shows that he might have already been planning on committing an act of murder or violence soon anyway, it kind of in his nature. I’m not sure if it was this channel that posted a video where he said Stu would have nearly been commuting murders before billy found him but personally I think Stu was evilest out of all of them
Stu seemed to show some remorse at the end before he died
You could just as easily be describing Mickey. Mickey and Stu clearly the top 2.
But Stu never killed his family members
@@bradydefelice2944 Neither did Jill. At least according to Zach Cherry, that was Charlie.
Can’t wait to see scream 5 at the movies on Friday with my sister on her birthday
Mrs Loomis doesn't get enough credit for how smart she was. She kept herself out of thé investigation completely, set up thé copycat narrative beautifully (distracting from an obvious revenge motive) and had a perfect fall Guy with Mickey. She's thé one ghostface who really could have gotten away with it, and that makes her pretty evil to me
Jill would've gotten away with it if she shut up and landed the kill stab
@KH yea but i dont think Billy would have gotten away with everything in the end. Jill had all of it planned out and was made out to be the victim. Billy would have likely gotten caught by the cops eventually.
@KH i do admit the cops arent very sharp in scream, but even though that couldve worked, jills plan was airtight up until the sydney surviving part.
Nancy and Jill both could have gotten away with it
Jill was the best then Billy and stu like Billy and stus kills were more ferocious but Jill revealing herself at the end of S4 and the way she even beat and bruised herself to make it look like she was the survivor/victim was Insane and So Creative !! And she woulda got away with it too if she didn't slip and say something about Gail's Injury like Jill was the Most Iconic and Genuis 4real
billys mother was much scarier then jill. how can anyone forget those evil eyes they reminded you of her sons blank stare. plus she murdered randy so brutally i dont think jill really killed anyone in a horrific way
The amount of times he said evil in the video lmao
i do love this channel though keep up the great vids
I appreciate how dedicated you are to this franchise
I wish Mickey had more of a backstory. He is definitely my favorite killer.
Maybe he’ll be mentioned in the new movie
@@bradydefelice2944 he was not mentioned if I recall correctly.
@@lynnettepaonessa8226 I haven’t seen it yet so
@@bradydefelice2944 I really did enjoy it though.
@@lynnettepaonessa8226 I’m glad to hear that
I use to think Stu’s character was truly scary because he had no motive, but I think “peer pressure” was code for love in the 90’s. I think Stu loved Billy and that’s why he was involved to simply help Billy plan his revenge, and why he didn’t care if Tatum died. It could argued that Mickey’s motive is pre-Jill. Not famous in a reality tv or influencer sort of way, but courtroom famous (a la OJ, Casey Anthony).
Thank you for posting such great content you are always such a good source for info
Hey really nice edit, as usual. I don't think people are aware of how much time it takes to make edits that looks really simple, but this one was a piece of art!
oh and I didnt mean that this looked simple, I meant that this must have taken so much more time than the simple ones since it was so beautiful!
What is even more evil than Jill planning to kill her mother was when she said "no great loss there" lolllllll
How is Mickey only number 4? Mrs. Loomis met him online in a serial killer chat room. He most likely killed people before he even became Ghostface. His body count could be higher than all of the Ghostfaces combined for all we know.
Love this video! Please do a best kills ranking of the first 4 Scream film's! 🙌😃
Id say my man mickey! Just plain insane like in scream 5. Im glad it was a simple twisted motive.
In my opinion from revenge to crazy it would be…
1. Roman (killed because of jealousy and neglect)
2. Mrs. Loomis (Revenge for sons death but seemed to have a loose screw)
3/4. Charlie (killed based on love of the films and love for Jill)
3/4. Richie (Killed based on love of films and wanting to correct the course of the future films)
5. Mickey (Killed because he was fan of films but also wanted to be famous, also apparently psychopath but not buying it)
6. Amber (Killed to correct the franchise but also was obsessed with Stu’s house and the whole arc which gives me OCD and actual psychopath vibes)
7. Billy (Revenge killed but also after killing Sid’s mother realized he enjoyed it and started to kill them all off to get back at Sid as well. Gave off serial killer psychopathic vibes like his mother)
8. Jill (First to plot an entire fantasy outcome that worked in her own favor to make her become the next Sidney and famous and killed her own mother to achieve that goal. She gives me the biggest split personality/bipolar vibes because she was able switch on and off her personality of being the good girl so easily and showed it in the final act. As well as being the only ghost face to actually be successful in her plan originally and defeating Sid originally until she woke up.)
9. Stu (Killed based on pure ecstasy and joy for murdering while having a good time and with no reason other than to bond and come closer to billy. He played stupid but was able to flip the switch easily)
So for me the most evil killers were those with the heaviest mental disorders that were caused by their obsession with either killing, being with, or becoming sid.
I love how the art style of blood stain through out the video
I couldn't agree with you more. I think she was the most sadistic Ghostface.
As much as Jill, Stu and Mickey are my favorite Ghostfaces... I think Billy had the MOST evil plan... murder his girlfriend's mother framing innocent Cotton Weary, THEN a year later: murder all your girlfriend's closest friends, then try to kill her and frame her father for the second string of murders.
0
That wasn’t his plan tho
The plan was kill moreen and frame Cotten so he doesn’t get caught
But he wasn’t satisfied with that …
So that’s why he planned his real attack to get revenge on sid to fill the void in him because killing her mom didn’t fill him not for long anyway he was still angry and needed a new target
If he survived the next spree would been killing his dad probably the next person to blame
Then his mother who abandoned him
Billy killed to fill a void in himself that was never going be filled by killing
Imo I think Mickey was the most evil of them all, especially since He was the first to kill for the fame before there was Jill. Besides the point that I think Mickey was the most brutal killer and he was very skillful as well if you notice, I feel like he moved so well and was the most aggressive while chasing his victims. Also people seems to forget that he was already a well established serial killer when Mrs loomis found him. Mickey took her offer knowing who she was gave him the great idea that hopefully he'd be a famous killer and have his story and murders done in movies, books and documentaries. He's also very smart and the way he played with Sid's mind, he was under her skin and also he did pretty good with acting like the good guy and choosing the same class as Randy was very smart as well but because it certainly made Randy not suspect him. And when he made sure Sid suspect Derek at the hospital. I think Mickey was the most dangerous because he came out of nowhere with ZERO connections to any of the woodsboro survivors or victims.
Jill and Stu comes second for me. Roman on the 4th
Mickey was the most disturbing ghostface and the most evil one. He broke and damaged sid the most , he was completely psycho. Mickey is definitely my all time favorite ghostface
@KH You’re opinion. Mickey was definitely the most evil ghostface and he was a complete psychopath
I find Charlie really disturbing sense he feels so real sense he’s basically the orginal incel killer considering he did it because Kirby never loved him
I'd rather say that Amber is the most evil Ghostface. Just the savage way she kills her friends and her just being completely insane just like stu. ( don't get me wrong she's not my favourite ghostface thats stu but I think she's the most evil one)
Nah Jill will always be the most evil one,I don't think she'd kill her mom or both parents like jill did with her mom
For me, it’s Roman. He gives up his tragedy by switching his motive to envy after getting revenge on his mom, and is indirectly responsible for most of the bad stuff that happened in the series
Mickey should absolutely be number 1. It shouldn't even matter that not much more information was given about him, what we do know already easily beats out Jill.
The guy actually is a psychopath, he committed a massacre for the thrill and wanted to be caught and to have the world know what he did.
Everyone else on this list wanted to get away with it except for Mickey.
Stu should probably be 2nd because he most likely is psychotic and loved what he was doing, even wanting to plan a "sequel"
exactly.
If they met Satan in hell, he would be proud of all of them, but Jill would probably become his queen.
I feel like Ms Loomis isn't as simple as people think because after his husband had an affair she obviously left him but she didn't even try to get custody of Billy as far as we know and at one part she yelled that she is not a bad mother which might mean she thought Billy murdering people made her look bad and that was why she wanted to kill but it still could be just like she says it is
I feel like her and micky probably had more intense relationships behind the scenes micky seems like he has mommy issues himself which could be why he decided to work with Nancy
Hmm, so your “Best Ghostface” also wins the “Most Evil” award…. Lol
The most evil are the ones who have no real motives. They just do it, because they like to. Mickey would be #1, with Stu being a close 2nd. But, in terms of Best Ghostface (as they should be 2 different categories!), that’d be Billy for me!
Yeah but stu was manipulated into killing(I can't argue that he was already crazy),and Mickey was crazy but I don't think that he would kill his own parents maybe,and Jill's motive is almost equal to the motives of those who killed without reason,and she either killed her mother or let her die,she's not my fav ghostface but it obvious that she's evil at heart
Stu and billy are my favorite they had such a motive
Very curious to see your take on this now that Scream 2022 is out. Wish I could say more but I don't want to spoil it for anyone.
Personally, I'd put Stu about where Charlie is on the list as they were both manipulated by the other killer in their duo. I'd also put Mickey second to Jill and put Roman further down on the list comparatively. While roman also killed his mother, it was only after she rejected him. So if personal revenge motives are less evil, I think that would put him lower on the list than someone like Mickey who has more similar fame-oriented motives like Jill. I do agree she's at the top of the list for being able to kill her own mother for no reason other than fame, and for killing her own accomplice just so he couldn't share the spotlight
As much as I hate Jill as Ghostface, she sure was an evil one. Actually killing her own mum was enough to be labelled the most evil.
It's a shame her acting chops were too cringe and had an unrealistic structure to be the killer, otherwise she'd of been a pretty good ghostface.
Wasn’t the line “even my own mother had to die” meaning Charlie killed her mother. Jill only killed Charlie and Trevor (because they were the Billy and Stu of the movie).
@@subjectdelta4758 she still allowed it to happen, which is enough. But Roman also killed his mother, so I'm actually stuck between Jill and Roman, honestly.
@@abrimfulofasha | I’d probably say Jill is more evil. Jill manipulated Charlie into killing all her friends plus Sidney’s publicist all for 15 mins of fame. Roman did it because he wanted revenge on Maureen for rejecting him. Originally, Angelina was going to be Roman’s accomplice but I’m guessing since scripts of SCREAM 3 was leaked (like SCREAM 2’s script) so they had to redo/rewrite the script several times even rewriting the script mid shoot).
@@subjectdelta4758 yeah I know that about Scream 3. Roman was my favourite Ghostface, to me he was the perfect ambodiment of Ghostface.
All the killers killed their friends apart from Miss Loomis, so no difference their. It was more to do with the fact that Jill actually knew and spent her whole life with her mum, as Roman didn't. So yeah, the pyschotic brownie points go to Jill for sure.
@@subjectdelta4758 That doesn't line up though because Jill would have still been in the area (waiting for a Kirby pickup) where Charlie would have still been at the barn for Stab-a-Thon. Jill was definitely the one to kill her mom, as well as Hoss & Perkins.
Jill by a mile she was evil af I loved scream 4 my second favourite scream movie
Jill was one crazy girl
Was Billy ever really in love with Sidney? I mean, they were dating before he discovered about his dad and her mum.
Stu wanted Tatum dead because she was keeping Billy away from Syd.
Right off the bat I have to say something. When Mrs. Loomis is the one who kills the psycho Mickey you've got to question, how psycho is she?! And why didn't Mrs. Loomis kill Mr. Loomis? I guess she could've and we just never hear about it because she made it look like an accident or something. But it just amazes me that at least 3 killers go on a killing spree and try to kill Sidney because of the mistakes or wrong doings of someone else. It's the most illogical and insane part of the franchise.
Exactly. Roman should have killed that guy who was possibly his father and others who was involved.
What i don't understand is why kill all these extra people and save Sydney for last 🤣 why not go for her first
In the first one, it was because Stu wanted to kill his ex. In the sequel, Mickey wanted to kill others to gain fame but I'm not sure about Roman. Randy died because he mocked Billy Loomis to the mother posing as Ghostface.
@@EmperorOfChaos Roman did kill his father, but going after Sidney was just him being a psycho like the rest of them lol.
Jill killed her friends and her own mom so she could be the equivalent of a Tik Tok celebrity.
Based on that I'd say she's the most evil.
You do realise every ghostface apart from Miss Loomis killed their friends, so no difference there. But yes.. the killing of her own mother was pure evil.
Jill didn't kill her own mother. That was Charlie.
@@rahbeeuh she still allowed it to happen though didn't she.
@@abrimfulofasha
They all killed a shitload of people, motive is the main factor for me in regards to who is most evil.
Using motive as main factor I think Mrs. Loomis (played magnificently by Laurie Metcalf) is the least evil of them all.
@@oliviav.3565 yeah, miss Loomis's motive was more relatable for sure.
Always and forever my insane fave...Jill 👏 ICONIC
A pretty solid list for the most part, personally though I'd id put mickey alteiri above both stu and Roman, because imo even though he wasn't as well known, his petty motive and thrill for killing makes him way more evil pluss of the 7 killers he was already an active serial killer that Mrs loomis looked up and tracked down. Pluss he was incredibly psychotic as well. The unkown as well makes it definitely a case of at least near pure evil and or imo pure evil for all these killers, so imo of these 7 id put him at number 2, he also didn't seem tragically evil either. Sometimes enforcers have a higher evil rating then the brains of the operation imo or of the partners of ghost face minus Roman from that because he worked alone
Ps
Random note let's not forget that it was Roman who truly orcastrated the events of scream 1as revealed in scream 3 spoiler alert.
Thanks for hearing me
The way Casey Becker was killed was very cruel and violent. The kills in Scream 3 lacked the violence
The most evil?? I agree with your list but billy was the best ghostface by far
Agree but Jill did kill her friends and her own mother to get fame
@@jayharden6278 every ghostface killed their own friends apart from Miss Loomis, but I get what you mean with her killing her own mum. That takes true evil mentality.
That’s not what this was about tho lol I wish y’all gave it a rest, every list y’all always say Billy without even reading or listening to what the list is about 😂😂
@@Dayzus91 exactly people worship him
@@Dayzus91 but he says he agrees with the list soo...
And the thing is Jill said to Sidney “I had to kill my own mother not a great lost there “ like she didn’t even care
I would personally put Mickey 2nd only behind Jill.
Because Roman ultimately wanted revenge.
Mickey killed just to do it. And was excited to get caught and go to trial.
Really enjoyed the video. My list from evil to most evil.
7. Charlie
6. Mrs. Loomis
5. Billy
4. Mickey
3. Roman
2. Stu( my favorite character and ghost face)
1. Jill
7. Charlie
6. Mickey
5. Mrs loomis
4. Billy
3. Jill
2. Stu
1. Roman
7. Charlie
6. Mrs. Loomis
5. Stu (co-favorite)
4. Billy (my favorite)
3. Roman
2. Mickey
1. Jill
@@emiscommentingaccount96 only good comment here.
I agree with you 100%!
So killing your own mother cuz she rejected you and becoming evil off of that is more evil than killing your friends and girlfriend for fun?
I think you’re severely underrating Billy on this list. Just to go through a list of his deeds against Sidney alone:
- He murdered Sidney’s mother Maureen.
- He framed Cotton for Maureen’s murder, which caused Sidney to testify against Cotton and put him in prison for a year.
- He continued to stay in a relationship with Sidney in the aftermath of her mother’s murder and pressure her to let it go.
- He killed Sidney’s best friend Tatum.
- He planned to kill Sidney on the anniversary of her mother’s murder.
- He seduced Sidney and took her virginity, despite planning to still kill her before the night was through.
- He planned to kill Sidney’s father and frame him for all the murders.
As far as personal vendettas go, no one has gone as far as Billy did against Sidney. He should at least be # 2.
He is vengeful but not pure evil.
If he pure evil, he will not through all of that. He lost love from his mom that makes him pissed.
But you right about he murder Tatum. Is not Stu who doing it.
@@davidariyan7915 yeah I think he was also the one who killed Kasey but Stu probably was there two because it would be impossible for one person to do all that stuff so Stu probably killed Steve
@@darthmaul8278 he was as the Ghostafce stabbed her like Billy stabs his victims.
@KH He's a psychotic.
I LITERALLY laughed out loud at 08:10, "...when you're killing people randomly, you know, that's just something that's fine..."😆
Stu wasnt peer pressured by Billy he was killing for the same reason as Mickey
No Roman didn’t orchestrate the any of the killing sprees other than his own. The first killing spree was all Billy and Stu’s idea.
No, he was the one who got Billy provoked to starting the killing spree. Not saying Billy decided to do it on his own, cuz he did, but Roman was also pulling the strings, telling him to find someone to frame(Cotton Weary) and a buddy to frame if things went wrong(Stu)
I would say that it’s a toss up between Mickey & Jill. Mickey is already a prolific serial killer by the events of Scream 2,but Jill planned and then maliciously executed nearly all of her friends,and butchered her own mother who was loving and kind,you gotta be seriously evil to do some shit like that.
I like your list, but honestly I switch Roman and Jill. For my personal opinion. I also think that Mickey should be above Stu only because you have to be a sick person to just go out and want to kill people just for the fun of it.
While Stu had redeeming qualities.
I mean come on. Anyone willing to scratch themselves, rip out a clod of hair, stab themselves, throw themselves into a picture and a glass table is absolutely pure evil. Jill Roberts was the epitome of cray cray!!!!
Even after the most recent movie, Jill is the most evil ghost face. IMO
My rankings from most evil to least- jill, micky, amber, billy, stu, roman, charlie, ritchie, ms loomis
i’d love to see a kills ranking
surprised by your choices but you make sense there!
Piper, Kieron, and Beth were so robbed from this
Say anything you all want but jill will always remain in top 3 most versatile killer of scream
I feel Mickey is the most as he has no connection to the other killers. Roman orchestrated the whole thing and influenced Billy. There would be no Billy, Stu, Mrs Loomis, or Jill without Roman initiated everything. Billy killed because he saw videos of his father with Maureen Prescott and his mother left the family. Billy manipulated Stu who seemed unstable but I don't think would have killed anyone if not for Billy. Mrs Loomis killed for revenge for Billy's death. Jill killed to become the new Sydney which would have never crossed her mind if the original killings never took place. Mickey may have been influenced by Billy but Mickey was already fascinated with serial killings, movie violence, and the sensational aspects of serial killing. He is waiting around stalking innocent people to kill . He was the only who was headed down this path, it was just a matter of time.
One thing:killers having a motive as re no less evil than those without a motive. Hitler is no less evil because he had a motive. There is always some event or strange fascination that all of these serial killers has in common. One of them being they feel they are smarter than everyone else and can get away with it. Mickey reminds of Dahmer who was fascinated with having the power over life and death. That was his motive. Mickey was fascinated with murdering people and testing the limits to of sanity vs insanity. Mickey, like Dahmer was going to kill at some point.
i think the most evil and shocking reveal was JILL…i mean that performance was everything she killed her own mother, her accomplice and her boyfriend just to get famous and loved. I love scream 1 but the best killer in my opinion was jill.
Mickey was a good boy, but my God, the whole blame the movie motive?
Can you just believe that after 1 second?
I agree with you about this list but you may have to do another 1 after the 5th movie comes out this week
It's the fact that Jill could've easily gotten away with everything that puts her at the top
they all were really close to getting away with it. i think roman or billy was the closest. billy wasted too much time talking when he had her on the ground coulda killed her but his psycho mentality got in his way
@@topguntk870 pretty sure all the killers spend time too much time talking 🤣🤣🤣 they could've just straight to the point and bam kills everyone. Piece of cake.
@@adamazri928 yupp lol
For everyone saying jill isn't the most evil,think again,her mother was either killed cuz of her or she did it herself,she tried to kill her maybe last alive relative,killed her closest friends,and all other stuff just to get fame,idk how you can't get it even after she told her motive,and for everyone saying roman is the most evil for getting his mother killed and trying to kill sidney,he never meet them,so he never saw if maureen was a good person and he never saw how nice sidney is,so that made it easy for him to do it all,and he was angry and hateful and jealous cuz sidney was the one to get that nice happy life he didn't have before she got involved into the killings,and after thatt too cuz she became famous,and he became crazy cuz first he got abandoned,second his mother didn't want him after he found her,and other ghostfaces weren't completely evil like mrs.Loomis,billy,like they were more made evil,the other ghostfaces (amber,Mickey,stu,Charlie,and richie)didn't seem that evil too cuz they didn't seem like the type of people that would kill they own parents or even a child,and I think jill wouldn't even blink if she had to kill a child
@KH yup,both of them have literally almost the same motives,but they did kill people who weren't involved in everything.I think billy hated sidney cuz maureen,the woman who destroyed his family is the mother of his gf,and I think that what made him slowly hate her
@KH I agree on both comments especially the first one
I think you forgot that Billy and Stu committed S.A. against Maureen Prescott.
Tbh after scream 2022 killers,Jill is still at the top as the most evil ghostface
Please in the coming days will you remove any comments that reveal spoilers? Would deeply appreciate if you could. Spoilers matter for this franchise given its format. Thanks for the content, as always
Jill all day. She was truly frightening
I'd say Billy was the most evil Ghostface. Even though Maureen had an affair with his dad she didn't deserve to die. That was also his only kill with a motive. He killed all his other victims because he liked killing. Stu was as evil as Billy but Billy managed to manipulate Stu into helping him kill probably by saying they'd create their own real life horror film when really Billy just wanted to go out and kill. It wasn't horror related. At the school he mocks Sidney's mother's death acting like it was no different to his mother leaving his dad while pretending he's just an angry boyfriend making an insensitive comparison. He's the one who kills Tatum with the garage door then later he has sex with Sidney because he believes the "sex equals death" rule and thinks taking her virginity will allow him to kill her by horror rules. Then him and Stu rub how they're going to frame her dad for the murders in her face.
I’m a firm believer Stu was gay for Billy or at least bi. Because I think we all agree he wanted Casey dead for breaking up with him, and he dated Tatum and he tells Sidney “I always had a thing for you.” But idk he acts pretty sus around Billy. Then again he could’ve just been very deranged. Also I’m a firm believer that Billy killed Casey and that Stu killed Steve.
Lol no,jill motive wasn't even personal,and she did it all for fame,and not to mention,she killed her own mother,a horrible act that no one of the ghostfaces did or would do,except Mickey maybe
billy and jill where the evil ones
Micky is definitely number one. He was already a serial killer before becoming Ghostface.
That is why Scream 4 is my favorite. The ending made me understand how evil she is.