Purely narrative but my two shi tzus are 21 and 22 . They’ve been on NMN and joint supplements for last 5 years. Still enjoying quality of life. I have been taking supplements including 1,5000 mg NMN for 20 years, will be 80 in August and recently walked from Vienna to Northern Italy on the European Peace walk. Guess it proves nothing except I’m not stopping and neither are my dogs. Thanks Marcel- you’re not down some rabbit hole-you are chasing the truth!
The WSJ is really very effective as independent journalists. After all, they broke this story for the public broadly... When this article first appeared, I wrote to the authors (any reader can), summarizing the facts about NMN, the letter to the FDA from David Sinclair's company Metro International Biotech (which I saw here), and the action taken by the FDA. I included links to background on NMN, and a link to the "NPA and ANH Petition the FDA Concerning NMN’s Classification as an Investigational New Drug". I received a direct email reply from Alex Janin, one of the WSJ story's authors: He wrote "Thanks for reading and reaching out. We're aware of this and looking into it."
Yes agree with some other followers. You look bright & more young. So we keep on following you & some other podcast owners I find honest. I found many positive effects on my health. With NMN 1 gr a day, I feel lost. I'm 69 this year. So I'm doing well. What happened to Dr David's father? any news? I feel that he'll discover something new in 2024 and then come in front of the public again Thank you from London☔️ Very informative video cause I was beginning to worry as well. 🙏💙💊
I agree something is off. Our high probability of something not creating purely honest journalism. The sad thing is I think these tactics work, the greater public will not get exposed to NMN or best longevity practices. However, “ we” watch this channel, take longevity and health seriously …. We can unearth best practices, …for the most part.
I agree with you about age reversal does not mean longer life span. I had five male rats on NMN for 9 months (equivalent to being on it for human 19 years) from middle age until death. Their lifespan did not increase, nor did improvement of any normal disease process, nor did they escape the usual decline. They got the same usual diseases but maybe lived with them a bit longer which just meant longer treatment time and costs of medication, which just got expensive. This does not mean NMN was working. None lived longer than my longest ever lived rats, (who were never on NMN), none even lived to the accepted span of rats (3 years). All fell well-short. They all died smack bang at about when they usually die. I did not have any running on treadmills while their compatriots failed like Sinclair's mice. Possibly one rat lived longer because when I got him his issues were great and he lived a lot longer than I anticipated, but also heavily medicated with many drugs so it's hard to see if NMN actually helped, but he did not live what is for a rat, a long life. All the rats I've ever kept who made it to three and some well over three had one thing in common: they were not pet shop rats. They did not come from indiscriminately bred stock, like many pet rats do.. My exceptionally long lived rats all came from breeders, who were invested in improving genetic lines for health and longevity. Of course my experiment was anecdotal and not scientific, but it's in the real world where this stuff is used, and my results make me doubt it has longevity effects. I can't know for sure. I should do a video, I documented it. I do still take it myself, I'm not a total naysayer.
It wasn't doing a thing for me (on it for a few years) . I started with half a gram ending with 1.5 grams. Yes took TMC with it. Gave up on it a few months ago. At the moment my go to is Carbon 60 in Avocado Oil. 1 tbsp. in early AM.
Yes he both made it famous and popular and then used the FDA to take it private so there would be no NMN available as a supplement and he could corner the market. Of course he's just trying to help.
@@MarieLamour-cv1jc The ban hasn't completely gone into effect but many institutions have already stopped its sale and due to Sinclair's request with the FDA. And you can call people names if that is what your maturity level calls for but hopefully you will grow out of it with age.
There have been some people, apparently incl. some of Sinclair's former colleague scientists, claiming that (some of) his studies about longevity supplements are likely fraudulent / effect hugely exaggerated (to continue to get funds). There was something e.g. about the yeast stuff that was off, don't remember details. But apparently, there were problems with replicating his studies.
You're right. Resveratrol was the study that coukdn't be replicated. He got huge money when he sold it on but the company he sold it to couldn't replicate the study results so they ended up put of pocket. Sinclair kept the money.
The good news is that it probably works on most people and would cheaply and conveniently allow a few more useful years. The bad news is that some other peeople are noticing the potential for controlling what could become a chemical as lucrative as statins, and that might actually work. Sinclair already has form as witnessed by his sale of a previous corporate venture into resveratol that netted a paltry few million. 'Bigger fish to net this time.' Good luck 99%... We'll need it.
Wow, I was halfway thru watching this video and I still do not understand what the issue is about. All I hear is that something is bizarre, a conspiracy, hidden etc, but what is the big issue you are addressing? You are so far down into the weeds I cannot see the main issue.
Since when do commercial news outlets investigate and report the key facts (the ws and the how) of a controversy when there are monied interests involved?
Question?, NMN powder, from DONOTAGE looks to be 2.5 times cheaper than the capsules. 100 grams powder for about $100.00 and 60 x .5 grams for about $75.00. Why??
are you in a coma? this is the man that wants to supress your freedom of speech on behalf of aipac. by banning criticism of that tiny country in the middle east currently conducting a jenoside.
are you in a coma? this is the man that wants to supress your freedom of speech on behalf of apac. by banning criticism of that tiny country in the middle east currently conducting a jenoside.
@@beritmagdalenajohannekuly2980 But not on people. He's been promoting resverotrol and nmn because it's profitable for him. I've seen a video on MNM studies there are no proven effects in long terms whatsoever. I want to stay young and there's a secret somewhere but I don't want to be delusional and spend tons of money on stuff that doesn't work or gives little results
@@ThePulseChannel I know. It’s wild. Gov coverups. Conspiracies. And just like Alex..you’re here to disclose it all. 🤦🏼♂️. I think nmn is showing some side effects?
less rambling please. next time try speaking bullet points because you are hammering long-windedly on the same point. we already Sinclair scammed the whole thing but it is worse listening to your personal venting.
I think don’t believe any drugs or supplements will do magic. Life style is more important that doctor Sinclair talks about on all on his videos eat plants base diet exercise sleep well that is all about living healthier & longer forget as bout NMN & etc
Please, get to the point first, then go on and on and on about the things that you repeat everytime, but at least for the sake of us watching and clicking, give us 1 sentence about the issue or message, then you can tell us this same story over again , no problem
dude please smell the white #NMN powder #MadeinChina by #Uthever: it smells like #STYROFOAM, does not smell very healthy, why? Please visit the factory and ask!
Purely narrative but my two shi tzus are 21 and 22 . They’ve been on NMN and joint supplements for last 5 years.
Still enjoying quality of life. I have been taking supplements including 1,5000 mg NMN for 20 years, will be 80 in August and recently walked from Vienna to Northern Italy on the European Peace walk. Guess it proves nothing except I’m not stopping and neither are my dogs. Thanks Marcel- you’re not down some rabbit hole-you are chasing the truth!
You look great and healthy ( different light). Zhank you for keeping us informed.
Thanks Marcel. I wish I'd known there were dog treats of NMN when my old border collies were near their end. We live our pets. NMN us wonderful.
The WSJ is really very effective as independent journalists. After all, they broke this story for the public broadly... When this article first appeared, I wrote to the authors (any reader can), summarizing the facts about NMN, the letter to the FDA from David Sinclair's company Metro International Biotech (which I saw here), and the action taken by the FDA. I included links to background on NMN, and a link to the "NPA and ANH Petition the FDA Concerning NMN’s Classification as an Investigational New Drug". I received a direct email reply from Alex Janin, one of the WSJ story's authors: He wrote "Thanks for reading and reaching out. We're aware of this and looking into it."
Excellent job following up with them on this Daniel.
Yes agree with some other followers.
You look bright & more young.
So we keep on following you & some other podcast owners I find honest.
I found many positive effects on my health. With NMN 1 gr a day, I feel lost.
I'm 69 this year.
So I'm doing well.
What happened to Dr David's father? any news?
I feel that he'll discover something new in 2024 and then come in front of the public again
Thank you from London☔️
Very informative video cause I was beginning to worry as well.
🙏💙💊
I agree something is off. Our high probability of something not creating purely honest journalism.
The sad thing is I think these tactics work, the greater public will not get exposed to NMN or best longevity practices. However, “ we” watch this channel, take longevity and health seriously …. We can unearth best practices, …for the most part.
I agree with you about age reversal does not mean longer life span. I had five male rats on NMN for 9 months (equivalent to being on it for human 19 years) from middle age until death. Their lifespan did not increase, nor did improvement of any normal disease process, nor did they escape the usual decline. They got the same usual diseases but maybe lived with them a bit longer which just meant longer treatment time and costs of medication, which just got expensive. This does not mean NMN was working. None lived longer than my longest ever lived rats, (who were never on NMN), none even lived to the accepted span of rats (3 years). All fell well-short. They all died smack bang at about when they usually die. I did not have any running on treadmills while their compatriots failed like Sinclair's mice. Possibly one rat lived longer because when I got him his issues were great and he lived a lot longer than I anticipated, but also heavily medicated with many drugs so it's hard to see if NMN actually helped, but he did not live what is for a rat, a long life. All the rats I've ever kept who made it to three and some well over three had one thing in common: they were not pet shop rats. They did not come from indiscriminately bred stock, like many pet rats do.. My exceptionally long lived rats all came from breeders, who were invested in improving genetic lines for health and longevity. Of course my experiment was anecdotal and not scientific, but it's in the real world where this stuff is used, and my results make me doubt it has longevity effects. I can't know for sure. I should do a video, I documented it. I do still take it myself, I'm not a total naysayer.
It wasn't doing a thing for me (on it for a few years) . I started with half a gram
ending with 1.5 grams. Yes took TMC with it. Gave up on it a few months ago.
At the moment my go to is Carbon 60 in Avocado Oil. 1 tbsp. in early AM.
I think you are full of it.
Resveratrol did nothing for me, NMN does.
Works for me. More energy but I am only 78 so we have to wait and see.
Works for me. More energy but I am only 78 so we have to wait and see.
It's worth noting that it was Sinclair that put NMN on FDA's radar.
@@MarieLamour-cv1jc Did you watch the video? I'm explaining why publications and TH-cam videos like this one avoid the term NMN.
Yes he both made it famous and popular and then used the FDA to take it private so there would be no NMN available as a supplement and he could corner the market. Of course he's just trying to help.
@@RevJack-bz7ew bingo
@@MarieLamour-cv1jc The ban hasn't completely gone into effect but many institutions have already stopped its sale and due to Sinclair's request with the FDA. And you can call people names if that is what your maturity level calls for but hopefully you will grow out of it with age.
@@MarieLamour-cv1jchow do you order it from UK? Which website can I order from?
Totally agree with you.
The name Wall Street Journal should tell you whose side they are on. The truth be damned.
That`s a clear disclaimer printed in bold letters on the front page of every issue of this newspaper.
@@lordjim3109 I think I need a disclaimer too.
A number of my friends have discontinued the WSJ. It is such a shame the state of so called journalism in the US.
Greeting from Fort Wayne/ Sweet Water :)
If I remember correctly, it was March 14 when Julius Caesar made an edict banning all conspiracy theories.
haha, well said.
There have been some people, apparently incl. some of Sinclair's former colleague scientists, claiming that (some of) his studies about longevity supplements are likely fraudulent / effect hugely exaggerated (to continue to get funds). There was something e.g. about the yeast stuff that was off, don't remember details. But apparently, there were problems with replicating his studies.
You're right. Resveratrol was the study that coukdn't be replicated. He got huge money when he sold it on but the company he sold it to couldn't replicate the study results so they ended up put of pocket. Sinclair kept the money.
The good news is that it probably works on most people and would cheaply and conveniently allow a few more useful years.
The bad news is that some other peeople are noticing the potential for controlling what could become a chemical as lucrative as statins, and that might actually work.
Sinclair already has form as witnessed by his sale of a previous corporate venture into resveratol that netted a paltry few million.
'Bigger fish to net this time.'
Good luck 99%... We'll need it.
Where can I get the special dog treats ?
Interesting assessment.
Wow, I was halfway thru watching this video and I still do not understand what the issue is about. All I hear is that something is bizarre, a conspiracy, hidden etc, but what is the big issue you are addressing? You are so far down into the weeds I cannot see the main issue.
How does one spell obtuse?
@@rudyhenderson5002 same as spelling rude, Rudy!
Gotta agree. Not sure what this really about. Now I have to google.
me too, a long long bla bla of what we know already or hear from him in every video but what the main issue here ?
Poor background from a not so loyal David Sinclair supporter. Tiring.
Since when do commercial news outlets investigate and report the key facts (the ws and the how) of a controversy when there are monied interests involved?
Question?, NMN powder, from DONOTAGE looks to be 2.5 times cheaper than the capsules.
100 grams powder for about $100.00 and 60 x .5 grams for about $75.00. Why??
Support R F Kennedy Jr. Champion of free speech! 🇺🇸 🌎 🇺🇲
There are no safe and effective brain worms.
The guy whose brain has been partly eaten by a worm can be a champion only for people whose brain is even less intact...
are you in a coma? this is the man that wants to supress your freedom of speech on behalf of aipac. by banning criticism of that tiny country in the middle east currently conducting a jenoside.
are you in a coma? this is the man that wants to supress your freedom of speech on behalf of apac. by banning criticism of that tiny country in the middle east currently conducting a jenoside.
I no longer find David Sinclair to be credible in this field.
I'm happy I didn't buy all the products he promoted
ehhmmm hello, he reversed aging in mice, he is credible.
@@beritmagdalenajohannekuly2980 And Resveratrol is a proven anti aging supplement. He's a con-man.
@@beritmagdalenajohannekuly2980 But not on people. He's been promoting resverotrol and nmn because it's profitable for him. I've seen a video on MNM studies there are no proven effects in long terms whatsoever. I want to stay young and there's a secret somewhere but I don't want to be delusional and spend tons of money on stuff that doesn't work or gives little results
Facts facts and facts, not slick shaved versions of facts.
What are you on about!
For someone who “doesn’t get into conspiracies”…You clearly do. You’re becoming the Alex Jones of nmn.
Good grief.
@@ThePulseChannel I know. It’s wild. Gov coverups. Conspiracies. And just like Alex..you’re here to disclose it all. 🤦🏼♂️. I think nmn is showing some side effects?
@@ThePulseChannel hi Marcel David Sinclair is my favorite have you heard about his chemical cocktail
less rambling please. next time try speaking bullet points because you are hammering long-windedly on the same point. we already Sinclair scammed the whole thing but it is worse listening to your personal venting.
Marcel, how about to telling us straight up, what the WSJ says? As your title advertises?
I think don’t believe any drugs or supplements will do magic. Life style is more important that doctor Sinclair talks about on all on his videos eat plants base diet exercise sleep well that is all about living healthier & longer forget as bout NMN & etc
too repetitive. 2 sentences repeated over and over ............
exactly
Please, get to the point first, then go on and on and on about the things that you repeat everytime, but at least for the sake of us watching and clicking, give us 1 sentence about the issue or message, then you can tell us this same story over again , no problem
Just call it “Eminem” it’ll go up in the seo 😂😂 everyone will know what it means
it's basically a version of fox news. owned by murdoch. this is how they roll.
idk why not mentioning nmn is in any way shocking
Old media 😂is ded we can't trust them
In your case grammar is dead
dude please smell the white #NMN powder #MadeinChina by #Uthever: it smells like #STYROFOAM, does not smell very healthy, why? Please visit the factory and ask!
Yes, you are talking and talking and telling nothing
Sainclair is a scammer.