Attack on Titan Alternate Ending | What If Eren Touched Historia During Training (GOOD ENDING)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 มี.ค. 2021
- A look at what would have happened if Eren and Historia touched during their time training to join the military.
If you enjoyed the video like, comment, subscribe and share!
#attackontitan #manga #anime
Credit to YakiBacki
FOLLOW IDKA:
TWITTER: / idka_yt - บันเทิง
What other moments in the series changed the outcome of the entire story?
If Levi picked Erwin over Armin at the end
If Mikasa's family didn't die
If Mikasa chosen "because I saved you" instead of because we are "family"
If Reiner and Bert were able to take Eren during the events of Season 2 early alongside their former 104th Training Comrades.
if Eren kissed Mikasa instead of saying the whole scarf monologue thingy against Dina
I just realised, Eren didn’t have any form of physical contact with Historia until she was forced to touch him. Damn.
Historia touched Eren in chapter 51
They trained for 4 years, it should be impossible they didn't touch even once
@@papergout-t2200 when was that?
@@holup454 really
@@holup454 when historia asks Eren to bring back Ymir from Reiner and Bertolt. She grabbed his neck and plead him. I think the physical contact is not enough. When Historia touched Eren in the cave I think she had intention to bring his memories back. Also when Eren kissed her hand he was thinking about the situation and finding a solution maybe that triggered the memories. It's just my theory I am not sure
Eren starting the game for the first time: *What we got*
Eren on a new game plus: *Speedrunning the Rumbling.*
Eren upon becoming a professional speedrunner:
"Hey fuck it, let's try it. What's the worst thing that can happen? Granted, I may not thinking clearly due to my *M A S S I V E E R E C T I O N* from finding out humans live beyond the walls."
So that's why the table is uneven
@@vivalavida4503 *visible disgust*
it just heard it while reading this
Hearing this from Erwin....I’m not even surprised 😂
@@vivalavida4503 Anyway, i want the three of you to go back to training and try and convince them ...
Well guys, if Isayama makes the “What if” series then it’ll be released in 4 years...
that would actually be great
i heard there is possibility he prepares 2 different ending. bc manga shows lots of time LINEs and there are x marks where mikasa should go back and restart. but aime shows falco sees the sky. not mikasa and and EREN's memory.
I want him to answer a couple of questions. For example:
1) To become a titan shifter, a pure titan (or another shifter in titan form) must eat a shifter. Specifically, the titan must consume the *spinal fluid* of the shifter's human body in order to gain their power; just swallowing the shifter does *NOTHING* and *WILL NOT* transfer the power of the titan shifter to the pure titan (or other titan shifter). The spinal fluid must be ingested, that is the only thing that matters. *This is common knowledge for anybody who's seen the first few episodes of seaon 4.* So my question is:
If multiple titans consume the spinal fluid of a shifter, will they *both* get the power? For example, titan Armin ate Bertholdt and bit down on his spine, spraying blood & spinal fluid everywhere while swallowing some and becoming the next inheritor of the Colossal Titan. If Eren transformed into a titan and sat under Armin with his mouth open, some of Bertholdt's blood & spinal fluid would've dropped into Eren's titan mouth too (similar to Willy Tybur's sister's death, how her bodily fluids entered Eren's gaping maw despite him not eating her in the traditional way). If Eren did this, would he gain the power of the Colossal Titan or not?
An even bigger example is Zeke Yeager, who's had his spinal fluid extracted en masse. Let's say for example that the spinal fluid from his human body was extracted (just because I'm unsure if the wine had *his* fluid, or his *Beast Titan's* since the giant monkey body produces more fluid). Let's say so much was extracted that we have multiple gallon-jugs and 2-Liter bottles full of his spinal fluid. What would happen if Eren and Reiner (while transformed), as well as a pure titan, all drank the fluid out of those bottles? Also assuming they do it when Zeke's still alive, what would happen to him? Would there be *FOUR* Beast Titans or would Zeke still be the only Beast until dying or getting eaten?
2) [MANGA SPOILER DO NOT READ UNLESS YOU WANT SOILERS]
2) Okay you made it! Now in the final battle, Eren & Ymir revived the previous titan shifters aboard Eren's back. Porco, Grisha, Tom Ksaver, Bertholdt, Marcel, Ymir (freckles), and many more all sprung up and attacked the alliance. My question is: *what's in their napes?* Legitimate question here: is there a human body inside the nape, since they *are* titan shifters? Or are they just the titan *bodies* of each shifter, without actually containing the human shifter piloting from within?
Assuming the answer is: "Yes, the shifters' human bodies *are* inside their titan forms, *just like they were when they were alive and transformed into titan mode. Just like when a normal shifter transforms with their body in the titan's nape, these resurrection shifters inside the napes of their titans too.* ........... What would happen if a titan ate one? What would happen if Titan Jean ate Grisha, or if Pieck ate one of the former Jaw titans, etc? Would they gain the power of the shifter they killed, like they normally would when eating the *current* holder? So then could there be two armoed titans? Two Cart titans? etc etc etc?
If either of these worked, then all Marley would've had to do is: take a massive amount of volunteers, mass extract the spinal fluid of all their shifters' human bodies, and then feed that titan juice to their volunteers (after they become pure titans). Overnight they could have an army of Armored & Cart titans, while officers would have Warhammer powers as well.
@@MarioTheLiopleurodon i think if it was possible to do that, marley would've done it. also, it would be a pretty awful story if there was 100 jaw titans just scrambling around like it was normal
Nah its just going to be some dumb Boruto copy. Eldians : Next Generations. Some crap like that
Kenny: “Well that’s not fair at all”
Erwin: “I’m sorry we don’t give a fuck”
Nice Hellsing Ultimate reference
I’m not the only one who caught onto that!
Ymir is in love with the man that destroyed her village, tried to kill her and used her as a tool to further his own goals.. Isayama you sure know how to write women.
The worst fucking end to this amazing story. I don't think this final was the first final that Isayama had, may be he has been bothered for other people to achieve this atrocious bullshit final. Sorry if my english is bad xD I'm from Spain
It's called Stockholm syndrome. Doesn't explain the other plotholes, but that one's a real thing
@@hellothere-dk4gg What other plot holes
@@orionisaacs9864 Ackerman memory altering, eren doing the rumbling because he felt like it (Isayama clearly tried to tie up the series in a way that eren *and* the alliance would win, but it assassinated Eren's character and took away his reasoning for the rumbling)
@@hellothere-dk4gg No it isn't. Ymir had a slave mentality. It's literally the theme of AOT pre-rumbling until the 139 asspull.
How different could things have been if Marco had managed to get away from Reiner and Bert?
Waaay
Yo godlike theory
Mmm, his word wouldn't be enough, I think.
im sure jean or mikasa would be sharp enough to realize marco aint the type to pull that shit
@@Cash-Chris- what do you mean? I'm curious
"Ymir is gay" is the best writing in histiory of literature and you can't tell me otherwise
Yep 😂😂
I want to believe this is canon especially that levi and zeke scene
😂😂😂
Feels bad man
Kill DIAVLO
NOW
"No daddy, yamete" lol
Lol
For some reason I want this featured in a Slap on Titan. Gosh, I miss that abridged version.
"When we needed him the most. He vanished"
i also miss dbz abridged i wanted a buu saga
Same. It's a shame they just kinda stopped.
I never understood why people thought Eren and Historia would have a kid. If eren gained Vietnam flashbacks just from kissing her hand, imagine what would’ve happen if they....ya know.
Lmao
Brain overloads with knowledge and fucking dies
This comment is underrated
Each thrust is 20 flashbacks
@@DumbWolfPerson BRUH IM DEAD
The answer is obvious: Eren would be charged with sexual harassment and would be dishonorably discharged from the military.
Eren won't be the only one discharged....
Reiner would’ve snitched so fucking fast
Eren : dammit reinner you ruin my life.
@@tdwwxyz
I don't think Reiner was a Historia simp until she came back with the horses.
What if ymir didn't save the king, she would still be a ruler of the kingdom. And she would teach her daughters about kindness and everything to be a better ruler, and the titan generation would have never occurred
Happy ending
spoiler
ymir saved the king because she loved him in chapter 139
@@bacon_yt2233 ya I know I read the final chapter but if she couldn't save him on time. A few seconds delay would cause everything to change better. But I still don't fully understand ymir's character so this is just my prediction. To be honest the ending feels like it's been rushed and could continue a few chapters for a more understandable ending. Anyway be happy with the ending we got guys the ending could have been worse.
@@darkload1386 I wouldn't call it love, its obviously Stockholm syndrome
@@gdjedehwaeyhweyhrhwshwrjhr1153 or bad writing
I was wondering about that moment when Bert and Reiner were destroying the wall, what if Dina straight moved towards Bert and eat him. She would revert back to human. Annie and Reiner would lose their minds and will either run or let the horde of titans eat them. Assuming Dina survives, she will grasp the situation, go inside the walls and will find Grisha. Now they have a royal blooded titan as well as the founding titan (if Grisha inherits it). Also, just imagine the power of a colossal titan with royal blood. Now they can devise their plans for Eldia's freedom or maybe something else could've happened, after all it's Attack on Titan :D
That's a really good one because in that example Carla Jaeger doesn't die either, which means Grisha would have both of his wives alive at the same time. Would be an interesting encounter/reunion to say the least ahah
@some anime bunny
Ikr
@@IDontKnowANYTHING xd
@some random anime bunny Dina may have been late for the wedding. But at least she visited there house.........
Here after chapter 139 lol. You will get your answer.
this is way more peacefull than the real ending
Lmao Ikr.
Is dina fritz smiling titan in ur pfp
Zeke : atleast we have dad
Levi's berserk mode on.
That was cool.😂😂
"I think... that Ymir is gay"
Thank you Mikasa, very cool!
"There seems to be a lot of daddy issues among the titan shifters"
"Hey, at least we have dads"
lmao Zeke xD, btw great video and hyped for the final chapter as well
dina eats berthold>Touch grisha> solve everything and nobody dies.
Except Bertholdt
Actually they would try to refound the empire
So the cicle of hate continues
@@th3_ph4ntomreborn31 dude, the world already hates eldia, all the time they are 100% correct to fear them. the cicle continues
@@th3_ph4ntomreborn31 after the rumbling, the only way to end the cicle was complete 100%, only eldia lives and they dont need to worry about retaliation or defend themselvs
Then cause a small rumbling and threatened Marley that if they ever try to attack paradise the world will be destroyed,the world fear you and you don't need worry to defend themselves. Wait but that option is too peaceful.
I WANT THIS AS AN ABRIDGE LMAO called 'Speed Run on Titans', and then I'll accept it as the real ending cause my mental state is not okay unless I lie to myself.
I started losing it when Mikasa said, "Yeah, I think Ymir is gay" 😂
😂
To think that a high five could have easily resulted in the utter defeat of Marley before they even knew who had the attack titan
Eren friends: *watch anime
Eren: **Read Manga*
I like how Mikasa just turns into a savage
this is literally better ending than what we got
Happier***
@Keliher ur opinion bud
GAME OF THRONES ALL SEVEN SEASONS 💯🔥♥️😘😍🥳💖
SEASON 8 💩🙏
Shouldn't have been
Lev to Zekei: Grisha might have been your abusive father.... But I am your abusive daddy.
Lol 🤭
Oh god
☠️☠️☠️
Levi is 39 how old is zeke
Speedrun Eren Yeager be like : *Casually approach Historia*
tbh my ending is just Eren waking up in the beginning of the story but without the walls or titans just a kid living a simple life, and having an extraordinary imagination. or the other one i though of just him waking up as an adult laying next to mikasa with her arms around him, then him laying back down with a smile on his face.
Now that I see this ending, it feels better than the actual ending.
You just copy comments and hope to get more likes. Honestly, stop
@@lennard8066 what are you even talking about
@@AssadEwais OOP the original bruh
@@lennard8066 uhuh, i copied a comment does that make you ANGRY?
@@AssadEwais i thought you were a bot , damn. Chill
All right now I’m imagining what will happen if this took place in modern day like they’re still cut off from the outside world but every other country is pretty much just modern
North korea would be an example
I was just thinking of that like North Korea they’re like decades behind the rest the world because they cut themselves off from the outside world but I’m seriously just imagining like some United Nations or American ships just landing I’m sure and I’m freaking out about the technology the outsiders have
Nuclear bomb can beat rumbling
@Twinnu Yeah I mean if their military find any other government military now a couple of factors going to that one the military was mostly made to fight against Titans and they have guns but they’re The flintlock Rifles so they will get more down by M-16 is and any other thing sure they may have Titans on their side but those guys can easily get destroyed by any other saying
@@theshockerpit7274 except maybe instead of everyone wanting to kill North Korea, most people would actually want to help them? And then North Koreans and outsider will see how nice they all are and never have an equivalent to the Rumbling?
I haven't felt this strong about a fan work since Extra Life (any hardcore Danganronpa fan knows what that is).
I don't care what anyone says: THIS is how Attack on Titan truly ended
The audience was right. Kaede should have lived and even Kodaka seems to have realized what a mistake it was since he puts her front and center on the cover of Danganronpa Decadence with Shuichi nowhere to be seen
Imagine Levi or even the garrison was at the wall for some reason when The warriors made their first attack. They just see a female titan running towards the wall with 2 kids riding on it.
um
Imagine the survey corps going on a mission and finding 3 little children on a horse heading to Shiganshina. What would have Reiner do then?
What about what if survey corps was on mission outside walls while moment when Marcel was eating by Yimir ex. Levi could save him without know that he's titan shifter, then take Marcel, Annie, Berthold and Reiner with other members of survey corps inside the walls so Reiner didn't have to break wall.
honestly this is way better than the ending we got
Lmao this is fucking hilarious
but its one of thing can happen lmao in AoT when u include time travell thingging and i hate when they didnt explain why this thing can and cant be happen
I wish there is a movie to continue with the ending. There is so many hole in the ending. It did not mention about ymir intention, what keep eren drive to this ending, what is mikasa doing during the 3 year
@@kennethsim7097 search the meaning of 140 and tell me do we have chapter 140?
0:56
Doesn't Erwin's head seem a little too small to be that close with Eren?
So many theories are better than the ending we got....
Yeah. The ending just destroys eren's character development
@@megatbasyarullah4859 from chad to simp
He was never a chad, we didn't see his true feelings, just how he wanted to be seen, and needed to be seen and thats the difference. After he became 'chad', we no longer can see his inner dialogue, compared to the past. His true feelings were shown in the last chapter and even then, he made sure to make everyone, mainly Armin, to forget, cuz they might hesitate to kill him. He knew, what he must have done and must have been seen like, but thats what he chose to do and to be, there was no other way for him, but to distance himself from them and make himself the ultimate enemy.
Al chp 💖🥳🔥
Chp 139 and 138 🥺😅💩
@@kiraqueen117 so killing people is Chad? Get some help with your brain :)
I've wondered about this too but i think Eren seeing memories in the future is already destined to happen like literally his life is scripted to the letter. I feel bad that i think Eren might be living a death loop.
Thank you for this video.
Better ending. No arguments.
If Eren would say about Marley and Rumbling stuff all of sudden, during training. Then, First, he would be declared insane and second he would be secretly killed either by Rod Reiss's men or by Reiner, Bertholdt and Annie.
1:52 this is honestly my favourite part till the end
much better than the 139 ending
At 2:55 WAS THAT A FUCKING HELLSIG ABRIGED REFERENCE?!?!
They agree to monopolise ice burst stone, selling out to capitolism and become the world super power with money, make ice burst bombs and long range aircraft effectively starting a cold war by ending a world war with anime style nuclear device
This ..... this is ... a master piece
ymir death changed the story, so christa become historia. if its when eren joined the survey corps his mom would already be dead..um when eren ordered grisha to kill everyone but rod reiss. If Rod would of died also in the cave. Past Eren would of never got touched by rod reiss and historia in the cave at that moment to get both memories from rod and historia. Historia might not of even been there and that hold act would never had happen . if erwin was chosen, he would had levi kill zeke asap and then the merge would of never happen. no rumbling.
This was truly something, but It's also funny that the fanbase never considers that last panel in a different light.
Technically the guy was right, the Eldians always have an ultimatum, which is technically a forced truce, with Eldians back in power. It ends with the world eventually forced to adhere to Eldian demands like they used too for millenia.
I figure I'd just share this as a slightly different perspective, to show a deeper alternative way of interpretation.
actually better then the real ending
Oh cool, I never saw that you made a video reading my edit. Glad you enjoyed it! And yeah, I've made a number of "what-if" edits for that exact reason but I always focus more on the humour instead of actually going in-depth on what would've happened.
Source?!
@@jessicag.3694 My profile - YakiBacki on reddit,
Also this compilation of all of my edits: www.reddit.com/r/titanfolk/comments/irivdz/dont_mind_me_nothing_to_see_here/
If Ymir didn't save the first king. The world would be similar our world...
yes
Yes
When you crack your back 4:01
Blackmail peace is the best peace.
Eren could touch historia at any time, it would never changes the story because the founding is like the destiny, past influence futur and futur influence past, so there is only one timeline that can’t change, Eren would just act to make futur evenement happened.
better then what we got
still better than the official thing
What if Isayama makes different endings and just make the fandom choose what they like the most and decide what's cannon in their minds? But, eh I guess thats asking for too much.
3:01 this sound was awesome 🤣🤣🤣
I enjoyed this lol
“That’s for your input, Mikasa.” Why am I laughing so hard at this? 😭
You got a new subs bro
This is unironically better than chapter 139
How
With reading the manga
I am at the conclusion that no matter at what point of time even touch historia the ending would be the same
Eren basically said so himself they even showed you that eren was the one who directed the influence flow of events to get the outcome he wants
It's like avengers end game out of all the possible future he chose the follow the one path he thought was right
Eren and Armin BEFORE Chap 139
Armin: NO, EREN STOP! GENOCIDE IS WRONG! THIS IS TERRIBLE, EVEN IF YOU'RE DOING THIS FOR US WE WANT TO STOP YOU!
EREN: I will keep moving forward to gain my freedom. The only way to stop the cycle of revenge is to bury it deep in the ground. My actions will save eldia, but it's more than that When I also learned humanity lived inside the walls, I was disappointed, I wanted to wipe it all away
Eren and Armin In 139
Eren: lmao why am I doing this again? Oh right I am playing the devil and let my friends be the heroes, just forget that I literally let ymir fucked you guys up in chap 135
Armin: You destroyed 80% of the world for us😳? ThankYou eren you are literally our saviour😭
Bruh
it makes me feel way better，thank you！i love this alternate ending ！
Damm I never would've guest that this ending was better than the real one
Anyone remember the ova that historia was kidnapped by those thugs during those three years of training??
Think about it...
I do
Wouldn't work. He had handholding sessions with her after uprising to see more memories but he saw nothing. the reason the hand kiss gave him those memories cause he was finally in the right mental state for it, that being he was looking for a solution to the Eldian Issue and not sacrificing Historia.
1:40 got me good
Well, the "original" plan was to make a mini-rumbling to make the world shit bricks and leave them alone.
If anything. That would have given the world even MORE reason to attack paradis. They could rumble the world any time they want. No way they would leave Paradise alone after that.
No i am 100% sure erwin was going to belive on eren's plan
@Twinnu Erwin was fine with sending soldiers to their death
I think he’d be fine with the rumbling, his just different from the rest of the survey corps
@Twinnu how does the intentions of erens intention makes Erwin against his plan
Erwin would find out the rest of the world wants everyone on paradise island dead and they are more advanced in technology
So Erwin who already sent his men to death more than once would agree with the rumbling if it meant the people on paradise island lives even if eren is only doing to save his friends, Erwin would look at the end result not the intentions of the plan so he’d agree with the rumbling plan
I got my own personal alternate ending in mind. What if Eren suggests to his brother (while in the paths) that instead of taking away the Eldians' ability to have any more children, we take away their ability to transform or be transformed into Titans after an all out rumbling, albeit with far less bloodshed. It'd be mostly for show and only really deal heavy damage to the military of the world and Marley, to show the world that I would love to do this to you all, but I'm not. Also, we're no longer going to have the power of the Titans and to show this, I'll transform a bunch of my people into pure Titans then remove the ability so everyone beyond the several shifters becomes human again before your very eyes.
Also, said rumbling is for another reason... so the Wall Titans would also become free, becoming human again, no longer bound within in the walls.
Speaking of which, it bothers me to some degree that we never got any indicator if the Wall Titans became human again or not. Weren't they humans to begin with as well?
3:33 pfffff
Imagine the amount of hell that would lose against a team of Armored , attack, female, jaws, collosal titans and the two ackermans 😬
Only two problems
1. Eren wouldn't act rational with all the information in his mind
2. I doubt it'd be easy to convince the warriors and even more difficult for convincing historia to become queen (also the fact it happened during the training arc so all the characters don't know eachother wel)
“so thats why the table is uneven”
i cant...
'I'm sorry we don't give a fuck' killed me.
Would've never happened, there's no way Eren would act this rational after seeing all of that.
idk who made this but its so funny and so well done. it remains me alot of TFS dragon ball abridge parodies. same awesome narrative hilarious quality. now someone go and animate this ASAP! xD
“So that’s why the table is uneven”
I've thought long and hard, and this ending is now my headcanon.
Honestly, This would've been Attack on Titan if it was a comedy series
THIS. I want this.
So thats why the table is uneven. Yeah this is my Canon now
This is amazing
This is so funny cause Eren is like "This is a surprise for sure but a welcome one" and he's like "Guess I can seee into the future now"
The uncertainty in the way he says Monkey is halarious
You know we could’ve actually gotten something like this if Diana actually ate Berthold
it’s funny because things still would’ve ended up the same way
If I could change 2 things for Aot. I'd change these
1. The Santa titan never tried to eat Armin and Eren
2. Grisha never gave Eren the Attack Titan and Founding Titan
So that Eren never did the Rumbling, and never die! Eremika would be true... Eren would have a nice life... Everything would be better... But I do need Grisha to not be captured by Marley so they won't have that power
THATS WHY THE TABLES UNEVEN IM DYING
Imagine if Eren Krueger didn't cover grisha's mouth.
The story would end a lot quicker here but what if Reiner was eaten by Ymir instead of Marcel
1:25 oh man this part was so funny jsjs, excellent video
0:34 Monke
Eren become an speedrunner
Still better than last chapter.
I like how the situation reverse from erwin and eren
If Erwin had the colossal Erwins election would be cannon
This is so much better than the "real" ending
To you two thousand years from now, facing that tree on the hill.
Damn this is awesome. And I would happily believe this to be alternate canon if everything went all right.