Attack On Titan: What If Historia Ate Eren
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 30 ก.ย. 2024
- Attack On Titan: What If Historia Ate Eren
In Season 3, Historia had the option to eat Eren and steal the founder but decided against it because she knew Rod was manipulating her. It turned out to be the right decision, but what if she decided to steal the founder. How does Historia with the founding titan deal with the warriors, Marley's invasion, and suppress dissent within the walls? This video will attempt to explain that scenario.
Timestamps
0:00: Introduction
0:10: Mikasa Sees What Happened
1:08: First King Takes Over
1:40: Memory Wipe
2:50: Levi and Kenny
4:40: Nobility Take Back Control
5:00: Warriors
6:40: Marley Captures Historia
6:57: Wily Tybur Meets Historia
8:00: Marley Unlocks The Founder
8:45: Conclusion
I believe the Attack Titan would have a hand in Historia keeping the will of Historia tbh
But if histoira cant brain wipe ackermans hwo did eren talk to mikasa in the path?
because shes half eldian
really good story but i think that since historia also has the attack titan she wont change and still help the survey corps
I thought about going that route, but the attack titan could resist the founder due to future Eren leading them with memories. I tried to avoid mentioning anything related to paths because of how it messes with what if, as technically Historia eating Eren means future Eren never pressures Grisha to complete the mission which completely breaks this what if.
I was about to comment exactly that lol.
If you want to hear my opinion, here it is, Mikasa will kill her
Hey could you do a video on what if porco had the armored titan or what if marcel survived
I'm already working on if Porco got the Armored Titan, that should be my next video in fact. Marcel Surviving is also on my to-do list
The king would never have paradese killed off, he would start the rumbling through Historia
its literally in the anime that the first king didnt actually intend on rumbling
there's a lot of loopholes with the vow renouncing war. You could do a lot of things in the name of creating Karl's "paradise" such as setting up defenses in the name of keep the eldians inside when in reality its defending against enemy nations. Thats just one of many. You could do all sorts of stuff, such as doing this or that but not against marley in a sense but a loophole if you know what I mean.
I thought mikassa learned her lesson last time eren died
She did and then she didn't. By season 4, she went back to Eren is my world and i can't do anything without him. Also the timing is important. She basically walks into the room as Historia eating Eren making her blamer herself for not saving him, that combined with her realizing she can't avenge him breaks her. If you need a visual, imagine her reaction to Armin almost dying in the SereumBowl, but 1000x worse. She lashes out at first, slowly realizes the situation and completely breaks mentally and emotionally.
One note: the founders ability is limited in that state
It's limited in combat but not in memory wiping, the founder only kicks in when the user attempts to either restore people's memory, wipe out the titans, or get revenge on Marley. All of those actions go against the first king's will, but whenever someone uses the founder in a way that doesn't contradict the will, they can do it. My example is Frieda constantly wiping Historia's memories and when Uri attempted to use the founder to view Kenny's memories.
@@thenenhunter2600 i know my point is that theres not much the founder can do other than wiping memereys as any larger power like memory or the ability to change eldian dna is locked.
@@i.k5696 I get what you mean now. I took a little "liberty" with the ending where the founder euthanized the eldians which is why I included the second more realistic ending. In my opinion, the first king's will only makes sense if he had some contingency to wipe out the Eldians. It's confusing to me how he wanted titans to never exist but was okay with Eren and potentially Marley finding a way around the restriction and potentially unleashing the founder forever. He wanted Marley to wipe out Paradis and end the age of titans but unless he himself intervenes that would never happen.
Oh man imagine a Historia turkey titan
King Karl is a big L, what a Nerd.
what if eren was a girl
The Rumbling won't happen if Historia ate Eren right?
Nah it wouldn't
the moment eren came in contact with historia he can activate the founding titan and freeze her most likely he will be flooded with future memories and use his founding titan
You make AoT What If videos but you keep calling the 145th king Karl Fritz the "first" king?
I mean the first king of the walls, tbh I'm not sure why I remember him as the first king of the wall instead of as the 145th king
5:37 wouldn’t their memories be wiped as well?
Reiner and Bertholdt are attempting to destroy Paradis on behalf of Marley, the first king will prohibits the user from taking to stop Eldia's reckoning at Marley's hands
@@thenenhunter2600 I can see how that would make sense
is reiner the dad?
Then there would be no hope for humanity, marley would win.
Could you do one on what if eren Yeager never died
Why would Kenny and Levi and mikasa forget they’re Ackermans
Can you do a vid if what if the scouts got the armoured beast and colossal at the end of season 3? Due to them nearly capturing all 3
That's an interesting what if, I have a lot of recommendations already but I'll try to work that in.
Kenny was injured since Levi stabbed him earlier and Mikasa would to attempt finish off Historia
Also I don't think Rod and Historia can escape unless Levi's squad was manipulated to fight Levi and Mikasa would keep them distracted until they reach Erwin's men but I don't think they would get this far since Mikasa would most likely kill Historia and Rod
Either Levi and Mikasa flee as fugitives or they somehow convince the Survey Corp of everything that happened before their memories got wiped out
Either way , when the warriors attack and demand Eren , either everyone dies or the scouts would simply tell them (if they believed Levi and Mikasa's words) that Eren and Historia are dead and the founder is lost which would lead to the warriors failing and Marley invading Paradi for it's resources
Wow it's the same ending but no founder for Marley
Wait, I thought Erwins family was imun against the memoory change/erase from founding titan...
Erwin is a normal eldian so he's not immune. Levi being an Ackermann could resist better.
@@thenenhunter2600 But Pixis said "The govermantmember tell us all the same. It's like you and your father thought. The family Reiss can change the memory of humans if they want. And some familys, you includet, shall be imun against it" (Sorry if it was not litarally i watcht aot with german subtitle because i'm a german) and Erwin new then, that, that was the reason, why his father was the only one, who thought like this, because his ancestors where imun, and remembert it, and teacht it their kids.
Edit: I think in S3 E43 - "Sin" pixis said that.
I see where the confusion happened, I’ve read the uprising arc like a thousand times for these what if’s. Basically, Erwin’s dad was a teacher who noticed inconsistencies in the textbooks and told Erwin about them. In the manga, Kenny and his father have a conversation about the certain families being immune from the King’s brainwashing. I think you mixed the two conversations up. I can link the chapter to u if u need it.
@@thenenhunter2600 I know, that Kenny and his (Grand)father (I'm not sure if it was his father or grandfather) said him, that some familys are imun, but Pixis told it to Erwin, that his (Erwins) Family is imun too.
@@zu_cool_fur_nix2673 Ne ist so wie der Channel Owner sagt, Erwins Vater hatte gemeint das die Geschichtsbücher voller inconsistencies sind und hatte daraus geschlussfolgert, dass die königliche Regierung die Erinnerungen der Menschheit manipuliert hatten. Kenny und sein Großvater hatten ebenfalls ja ein Gespräch, in dem gesagt wurde, dass die Familien dessen Erinnerungen nicht gelöscht werden können, sich mittlerweile ebenfalls nicht mehr Erinnern können, da die "Geschichte der Welt" von ihnen nicht an ihre Nachkommen weiter gegeben wurde, also kann sein Vater, selbst wenn er ein Ackermann wäre oder einer aus diesen besagten Familien (was er ja nicht ist) sich nicht dran erinnern, da es ihm niemand gesagt hatte. Entschuldigung, dass ich hier noch nach 3 Monaten antworte und hoffe du konntest mir Folgen und kanns es jetzt besser verstehen.
and after that. Marley would lose war against the world. As titan power will slowly lose against technologie.
Her Titan would be 15 meters cause she would inherit the Attack Titan as well wonder what the design would be
Marley wouldn’t be able to use the founder the only reason the Yeager brothers could use the founder was because Zeke was so strong willed he simply overrode the king command of peace after spending what felt like an eternity in the coordinate meanwhile Eren connected to Ymir which allowed him to get around the need for royal blood and the kings vow
How exactly would Mikasa see Eren's corpse if Historia ate him??
That was definitely an oversight from me. A lot of my first what if videos had similar mistakes.
his arms and legs would be hanged on chain@@thenenhunter2600
@@thenenhunter2600 she could have just chomped his upper body consuming his spinal fluid but still keeping a corpse
best aot content ever
Thank you!!!
If he died the series ends
Facts bro