วีดีโอ

Adolf Hitler was DEMOCRATICALLY elected as supreme's chancellor of week the German Republic before becoming Dictator.

A dictatorship is, first of all, order and law, and dictators take care of the people because. the dictator depends on the people, he needs support, without support he will not stay in power for long

Thank you for this video😊😊😊 you helped me realise that a benevolent dictatorship is more important than democracy even if it's not favorable by all people😊😊😊

very good debate

Sadly yes. It has been made. No clue if by accident then swnding It Out by accident or creating it on purpose to creat more fear to trust the government more. But yes it was created.😢

An adult, human, female. You have to be all three to be a woman. A female, human, kid cant be a woman until she is an adult. ❤️ Im not left or right. Its the truth and life.

Because its a terrorist organization..they kill people, burn anything like cars and buildings, loot stores, want more drugs and gang and most of all want more violence. They are bad and evil and has done nothing good for anyone like blacks.

Simple answer, yes. The whole point of democracy is to avoid bad dictators, but it throws the baby out with the bathwater. The biggest problem of a Benevolent Dictator is succession. A benevolent dictator can cut out red tape, implement long term plans without worrying about the election cycle and having his plans erased by new administrations, implement good instead of populist policies, focus on the will of the people instead of the will of lobbyists and campaign donors. Aside from Sankara, Jerry Rawlings in Ghana was a great dictator. Same with Gaddafi, regardless of the lies the Western Press have peddled about him. Even in the Bible, Christ will rule on earth as a Benevolent Dictator for 1000 years.

I do have a setting which does explore this issue, with it being a benevolent dictatorship that emerged after a weak democracy caved in under its own weight. It is good to see this debate so I can properly show the moral complexity, with the key question of the setting being "Would you sacrifice your freedom if it meant that you no longer had to worry about homelessness, gang violence or poverty?", since while the dictatorship is doing purges where officials found to be dissidents are imprisoned or "kill themselves", the dictatorship has made genuine improvements, since it has made sure each citizen gets a roof over their head, food on their plate, free healthcare and the assurance that their children won't be illiterate.

What we call human nature is in fact a mix of coping mechanism and cognitive distortion. That’s not human nature. Human nature is being reasonable. Using reason! Why we use emotions as guide for our life? Emotions are alarm to tell us that something is wrong and that we need to adress but most people make emotional reasoning and instead of taking emotions as alarm, they take emotions as proof. It’s like changing cars everytime a light light up in the dashboard instead of finding the problem and fix it.

Citizens has access to a full load of informations and they still can’t USE their rational thinking ability. Baruch Spinoza - the father of modern democracy, he lived in the 17th century - was truly a rational men. He predicted our times 400 years ago. I explain below… The whole thought of Spinoza is in fact based on the idea that an individual will agree all the better with others that he is well in tune with himself. In other words, our democracies will be as more solid, energetic and fervent than the individuals who compose it will be able to dominate their sad passions - fear, anger, resentment envy, etc. And that they will lead their existence according to their reason. Even if he doesn't says it directly, we also understand that citizens who are more driven by their emotions instead of by their reason could elect dictators or demagogues.

Just focus on *parliamentary democracy.* Problem solved.

Dictatorship is a double edged sword, it's just like King Ruled States. It will be the best or the worst

It's just a simple concept. Democracy can't work in a small and poor country 😞. That's a fact. You need a tough dictator to fight against the world use well resources and do good business. I respect all the Dictators because no one is a saint

Sankara and Tito I knew of. But who's Lee? What country is he from?

"Even if dictators are doing what's best for their country, people will still feel limited." Dictators: "People? What people?😏

This was very interesting, and a very good representation of both sides of the argument. As someone who grew up and had the best years of my life in a dictatorship, I would definitely choose a good dictatorship.

we have benign dictatorship in the congress party in India. God save India from dictatorship; benign or otherwise. There is no substitute to meritocracy.

Are you one or twin

I like this video but I feel it framed in a fashion that make Benevolent Dictatorships look like an unchallenged correct answer.

Best discourse on this matter I came across so far. It's ridiculous how many people spread the message that trans women are "real" women, but are unable to provide a definition or an explanation when they are approached by the other side. I like yours. Though, I must say that I prefer the "old" definition, because it arguably provides more useful information and is less vague. Referring to the past in order to make a definition work, as you have done, is also a reason why I wouldn't necessarily adopt it.

if the dictator is competent and partly benevolent, id argue a streamlined and more efficient system like this could be better

trans women are real women and you people need to stop sating differently !!!!!!especially cis-gender women, the people who work in the insurance an appraisal industries!!!!! I drive a Ferrari ,beautiful, red, worth half a million dollars!!!! but these petty selfish women and trans phobic insurance adjusters are all like....that's not a Ferrari its a 1984 Ford escort with a plastic knight from a chess game glued to the hood and a piece of duct tape with the word Ferari written in it...Ferrari isn even spelled correctly on the tape!!!! those hateful people!!!!

Really loved it . It also helped me with my debate thank you

I really like your channel keep making videos! Unrelated question but I'm curious are you Turkic in ethnicity? e.g Turkish, Dugstani, kurd etc also are you British or American I can't tell by accent...

Thanks for the video it is very informative! I think the problem is that what the word 'trans woman' refers to in most people's mind is different from what a trans woman herself would want the word to refer to. To say trans woman is real woman is to acknowledge the womanness in them therefore provide acceptance and recognition to them. Sometimes this becomes the norm that saying trans woman is not a real woman will be taken by the other side as denying the womanness in them therefore othering them and not recognizing them at all. The word 'trans woman' wants to borrow meanings from traditionally-established word 'woman' to justify itself. But once the justification is done, the two words can be detached.

I found your definition of “woman” (one that avoided making reference to physical anatomy) to be a bit cumbersome. I’d like to suggest a definition of “woman” that could also include trans-women as: “Adult females, or those adults who have the will to be female.” Seems to cut to the chase, non?

We need intelligence tests before anyone can run or be appointed for public office, from the community to global level. So much bullshit would be prevented.

You made a lot of good points until you got into the part about the mask mandate. The claim "mask mandate could have saved thounsands of lives" is a completely incongruous statement, and even cite China as an example of how mask mandates are helpful is completely wrong. USA has faced the most severe growth of the covid-19 spread among its population than any other foreign country in spite, or even because of the mask mandate, it has long been proven by scientists that masks are one of the most common carriers of viruses. Sweden never enfocred neither mask mandates nor obligatory vaccination and they are the least covid-19 infected nation among any European country. The only reason why it worked for China is because they were the very first nation to take actions to stop the spread, not because they happen to be a dictatorship. I understand that I have gone far from the topic of benevolent dictatorships and weak democracies, but unfortunately your video carries a certain agenda, which I really wanted to refute. And it is quite ironic that such words come from a benevolent dictatorships apologizer, as if it wasn't obvious enough who exactly would push statist rules even if they backfire on everyone.

Some of the most infamous dictators came from unprotected democracies. Just look at Mussolini and Hitler.

No, change it please .. it shouldn't be a "Debate" actually it Should have been a "Discussion"... Because, "Debate is to find 'who' is right and Discussion is to find 'what' is right"

You are talking so slow….

Afghanistan was example of a weak democracy

Just perfect!! I liked it to the details you have given.

Sad Truth is that most rotten people can live under any government. Also don't forget that National-Socialism come to power through democratic elections and this happened not because of propaganda or some manipulation but because of what the society was back then.

Hey girl, your channel is the most underrated. Love from Nepal. 🙏🙏❤️❤️ Keep it up.. And yeah, why aren't you posting new videos Nowadays ? Please post more and more of debates. It really helps.

Yes it is

It is wonderful to see teenagers so engaged in this sort of thinking, maybe there is hope for the future after all

The moment we choose dictators is the moment we suppressed the voice of the minority, the opposition, the alternate view, the devil's advocate, the counter ideas or call it whatever you like. Our society needs that. And if we think about the labors and time it will spend, still it is worth it. Oppositions play an important role. It gave a different picture, an alternate view. it will expose blind spots and weaknesses. Suppressive regimes are known to crack after years and years of suppressing dissidents. On the other hand, Western Democracy thrived because of the opposition views countering the mainstream views and exposing the weakside of an argument. hence, as Hegel put it any idea (thesis) that may not have been subject to opposition or a test (antithesis) could not attain perfection and certainly be flawed (which is a failure to attain synthesis). In other words, benevolent dictators may not be able to function well. Because even at times of emergency, it is still a rule of the democracy represented by the few. It could be the cabinet, the ministers, or the advisers.

The moment we choose dictators is the moment we suppressed the voice of the minority, the opposition, the alternate view, the devil's advocate, the counter ideas or call it whatever you like. Our society needs that. And if we think about the labors and time it will spend, still it is worth it. Oppositions play an important role. It gave a different picture, an alternate view. it will expose blind spots and weaknesses. Suppressive regimes are known to crack after years and years of suppressing dissidents. On the other hand, Western Democracy thrived because of the opposition views countering the mainstream views and exposing the weakside of an argument. hence, as Hegel put it any idea (thesis) that may not have been subject to opposition or a test (antithesis) could not attain perfection and certainly be flawed (which is a failure to attain synthesis). In other words, benevolent dictators may not be able to function well. Because even at times of emergency, it is still a rule of the democracy represented by the few. It could be the cabinet, the ministers, or the advisers.

(In filters the system to the on unchallenging power) that’s a call dictator

Let me formally thank you for introducing me to Thomas Sankara. He's truly a great man, whom I had no idea even existed, for the past year I've been researching great dictators heavily, my favorite so far being Lee Kwan Yew. Sankara is absolutely stunning tho, thanks a lot😁

Democracy is so good that *NOTHING GOOD GETS DONE* Too many cooks spoil the food.

Would be waay better with no music distracting from the arguments.

Tito also took stalin by the horns Stalin was sending assasins and Tito wrote him this " Stop sending people trying to kill me , we already captured five of them , if you dont stop I'm sendin assasin to moscow and i wont will have to send a second"

Caesar was a benevolent dictator

Thanks for the video I like that you have both sides

I may support Dictatorship over Democracy, but seriously fuck the masks.

Dictatorship is based

It funny when listening to kid debating about politics