ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 ม.ค. 2011
- Paul (Kyle MacLachlan) kills Jamis (Judd Omen), and gives Water to the Dead. Most of this sequence appears in the Extended Edition, this segment completes the scene.
See scene 168 of the Sixth Draft of Dune.
The full 6th draft script of Dune is available from www.duneinfo.com
168. EXT. FREMEN PLACE - DEEP DESERT - NIGHT
...
Jamis leaps. Paul easily evades him. Jamis attacks again and Paul stabs, but too slowly because of his shield training. Jamis turns and springs, trying to surprise Paul, but again Paul easily outmaneuvers him but is too slow on his attack. On the next attack, Paul cuts Jamis' hand and Jamis begins to show fear.
JESSICA
(inner voice)
He's never killed a man like this.
The two circle slowly. Suddenly Jamis can wait no longer. He leaps high, strikes down with his right hand but the knife has been expertly shifted to his left hand. Paul shifts beautifully and switches his knife hand. He plunges his knife deep into Jamis chest as Jamis comes down for him. Jamis continues down and crumbles dead on the ground.
Suddenly several of the Fremen rush forward and surround Jamis' body, cover it and whisk it away. Jessica studies Paul. She sees the excitement in him, in Chani and the others.
JESSICA
(inner voice)
He must not grow to enjoy such a victory.
She moves to Paul.
JESSICA (CONT'D)
Well, how does it feel to be a killer?
Paul stands, stunned by his mother's words. He really just then realizes what he has done. Tears begin to fall from his eyes. The Fremen are amazed. They move to Paul and he at first backs away, but then lets them touch his eyes and face with their fingers.
FREMEN #2
(whispering)
He gives water to the dead.
JESSICA
(to everyone)
He has never before killed a man in a
blade.
They stare in disbelief. - บันเทิง
It was a crime this scene was removed from the original cut - Without it, the Fremen acceptance of Paul makes so little sense.
Um, Jessica overpowered Stilgar. Paul beat up a couple guys. Proving their worth. Paul then taught them how to fight better. Paul rides a worm. Jessica becomes their shaman. Fulfilling all the pieces of their prophecy.
true but also, I think they were also honoring their traditions and they were seeing signs of their prophecies. It wasn't one thing that brought them to accept him.
There are a few cut scenes that would really have made a difference.
wtf did they cut so many secenes that would have made Dune a far better film? Giving water to the dead was to my mind a key scene from the books.
There were over 4 hours of good footage edited for the original movie. It was trimmed down so more "showings" could be done in a day at the theatre to make more money. It would be nice if we were to get a "supercut" of the original footage someday.
@The Chairmen
This version is the best i have found
th-cam.com/video/94d77kdmOvU/w-d-xo.html
It would have made it worse. Fremen are idiots.
@@65BAJA I heard there is a fan supercut floating around out there with lots of re-editing and adding deleted scene back in that is excellent, including giving all the Freman their blue eyes.
I think the new movie makes you understand more why Paul is crying after having killed Jamis. At least I felt more emotionally engaged to a character that wasn't even part of the story except for this battle. You empathized with Paul because you saw the visions he had of Jamis. All the things that could have happened and now will never happen. He lost a friend.
no wonder Lynch was so bitter about this. his final cut could've been a masterpiece
I wish the studio who let david lynch down make it up to him, by restoring dune 1984 to the masterpiece that it should be, they could still re edit all the great scenes into the full great movie, even though david lynch does not want to anymore, they can improve the special effects through cgi to fit the whole movie, insert the great deleted scenes, then dedicate it to david lynch. They should hire a competent editor and director who was symphatethic to david lynch interpretation of dune. Although it strays from the dune book, its still great.
"How does it feel to be a killer?" Comforting words from a mother.
Jinnath well, that's why the scene was deleted. In fact, in the book, Paul did not kill the pilot. So it wouldn't have made sense if they added this scene, where Paul is now assumed have killed his first man.
She wanted to make sure he didn't come to enjoy killing, like the Harkonnens
That puts the scene in a completely different context. Paul in the movie looks shocked at what he just did & Jessica comes across as cold. I actually don't mind the scene, as it shows him crossing a threshold that there is no coming back from. She was just stating the fact that now he will have to kill to survive or perish in the deep desert.
João Paulo Adler Gomes da Costa
If I remember correctly, you are mistaken. In the book, Paul dominates the fight. But since he does not realize at first, that it's a fight to the death, he is hesitant and expects Jamis to give up. The Fremen misinterpret this hesitation as "Paul playing with his prey".
Vaultboy101
Yeah in the book you get to follow her thought process and what she says makes a lot of sense.
It seems that a lot of things got lost between the book and the movie, not sure I'm going to like watching it.
This is the one bit I wish they had repeated for the 2021 movie. “He gives water to the dead” was such a character defining trait.
Maybe it'll be in part 2.
Yea, they fucked that up after a really emotional death scene. It sets the tone to the Freman that Paul wasn't there from the beginning to oppress them, but to understand them and stand with them.
@@DrSardonicus to be fair the scene happens at the funeral so most likely we will see it in part 2
@@DrSardonicus it doesn't matter that Paul doesn't see it as a huge deal. It's a huge deal to the fremen, further building the legend of Muad'dib.
@@DrSardonicus faulty logic? This is emotion, man. Logic doesn't come into it! If you had just killed a man in self defense and your mother rightfully scolded you to ensure you not turn into a sadist, you'd cry too. It has nothing to do with knowing Jamis. Its about empathy and a loss of innocence.
This is one of my favorite scenes from the book, like others have mentioned, "giving water to the dead" is such a central concept to the Fremen. The relationship with Jamis' children and wife was also interesting. In the DL movie, you can see scenes where the two boys are in a scene but never addressed. I love that when Paul is in his "coma" after drinking the water of life, the two boys served as his body guards.
Paul showing sorrow for killing for the first time shows how compassionate he is and how strong it makes him in the future. Wonderful part of the book and captured perfectly in film, a shame they cut this out.
In a 2021's, I really like the way the shown an alternative path, when Paul sees friendly looking Jamis, who promises to show him the ways of the desert.
I thought he was seeing through chani's eyes but yeah, I could see that being an alternate timeline where he doesn't have to kill jamis, they should've accepted Paul and his mom after she bested stillgar 🤦🏻
I saw this in theater; Seattle hosted the 'long cut' during a film-festival.
Tickets to 'Dune' were a pass to visit the theater at any time while the movie was in progress.
I saw it over three days, a few hours at a time.
It was fun, seeing the same people come and go throughout the day.
People screamed in genuine shock when Thufar saved Paul's life...I was one of them!
I felt like a friend had passed before my eyes.
There were many moments among the Fremen that I don't recall from the Book, but felt so real and solid in the movie.
Because I've read the book many times, this scene looks absolutely perfect to my eyes. Reading the comments though, I can tell that a lot of people who haven't read the book were confused by Jessica's coldness and the Fremen reaction, and I can see why... without the proper context this scene has a totally different meaning. I can also see why people seem to find this movie impenetrable.
Argonova jessica is trying to make sure paul dosent enjoy killing. The fremen in are in religous awe
Jessica's coldness is sooo ... Harkonnen ...
You don't even have to read the book to understand the context of this scene. Either you have few cell brains or not.
@@hadeseye2297 You're dumb, context is everything. Get off your high horse, asshole, and fuck off.
@@flybeep1661 the film provides enough context as it is. Without having to read the book. “Never one drop of rain on arrakis”
They shouldn't wear stillsuits during the fight. It's against Fremens' law and tradition.
Exactly, suit can be damaged and faulty suit would leak the water, and water belongs to the tribe.
In the miniseries they basically fight in their underwear.
@@Alkonium lol "fighting trunks" which I suppose are worn under the stillsuits.
The SyFy version has the fight as close to the book as possible.
The crying part was a super powerful scene from the books. Really cemented the reverence of the peeps for Paul.
My favorite part of the Dune story and they don’t even put it in the final cut
Wish Paul shed a tear in the new Dune.
I wish that too, would have made it more impactful, however you could still see he was torn about it. I think the fact that Villaneuve added a bunch of visions of Jamis made the audience feel Paul's loss. He didn't have to do that. But throughout the film we are constantly seeing Jamis. I hadn't read the books but the whole time I was expecting to see this character later on. And I felt robbed. Just like Paul felt robbed of all the mentorship and friendship he could have had with Jamis. but no, in this reality he had to kill him.
In the book he cries later at the funeral, which hasn't happened yet where the movie ends. Hopefully the whole funeral will be in the next movie. I just reread the book and got teary eyed at that part of the book.
This is one of the most emotional scenes from the books, it's silly that they cut it for whatever reason from whatever version
In the book, the crying and this comment doesn't happen right after the fight. It happens when they are sitting around saying how they are thankful for Jamis. So, in the reboot, this scene might still happen at the beginning of the sequel (to the 2021 one). But the proper scene in book - not this one.
@@Pasan34 You have to abridge many scenes to fit them in a feature length movie. I'd say this scene retained the main point from the book without adding much screentime.
It is a rather significant event, strange that they cut it.
in Fremen Culture it is a sign of sincere respect to cry and "give Water to the dead."
The fight was just a generic fight scene. Seeing Paul's tears, that loss of innocence, that made me tear up too..
One of the best moments in the book, in my opinion.
That was a beautiful scene. Tore me up.
All these years later and I still have never found anything so cool as this version of the Fremen stillsuit.
I thought it way back then and I still think it now. The stillsuit. The ultimate lazy-bums survival uniform. One you rarely ever have to take off, and one that you are encouraged to piss and poop in for it to work right. . and I still want one, only now I'd need to have the mid-riff let out a tad so that the paunch can have room to "express" itself.
Actually, if they added a cap over the head so that it covered the forehead & neck, it would be pretty much exactly how they were described in the book - a skin-tight black suit with catch-pockets on the chest & legs. The Fremen also wore a robe over the stillsuit, with a sash tied around the waist. Instead of pockets, they stuffed items into the sash. The outer-wear and the head-cap were about the only things the mini-series version got right.
Dirty stinking fremen.
I wonder how you two feel about the new still suits?
I agree, they were great. Still my favorite cosplay I ever did. Took nine months to build. It didn't capture pee and poop or sweat. But I did have an integral camelbak I drank via a "catchtube", and a nose hose.
@@Privatepain1234 I wasn't in your "you two" but wanna chat about the new ones :-) they're okay, really very like the '84 ones, and they include masks (that the principal actors rarely use LOL). I didn't think they did anything "better" or worse but the '84 ones look more "organic" and right, somehow.
I was a friend of Jamis.
Jamis. That'd been the man's name...Jamis. What an odd immortality death had earned for Jamis. Knowing death to be inevitable,had Jamis carried that particular one in mind?
When I first watched Lynch's Dune I laughed at how bad it was but seeing more and more of these deleted scenes I realize how much potential it had
Thank you, I did not know this shot existed. Glad to see they had made a good effort in the book’s lore.
Mad that “how does it feel to be a killer?” Is not in the 2021 film
That would really jar with how Jessica is depicted in it, honestly. She’s not as cold as in the other versions.
@@Lyendith Agreed. I think the Fremen touching Paul’s tears saying “He gives water to the dead.” would be more interesting to keep. Maybe in part two
Man, I was waiting for this part in the 2021 version. They set it up perfectly...then never deliver. Ahhhh well.
Still well worth a watch.
I hadn't read the books but I can agree with this. However I think it was smart that Villaneuve added a bunch of visions of Jamis. It made the audience feel Paul's loss. A clever tactic to make the audience empathize with what the main character is battling with, how confusing these visions are. Villaneuve didn't have to do that. But throughout the film we are constantly seeing Jamis. The whole time I was expecting to see this character later on. And I felt robbed. Just like Paul felt robbed of all the mentorship and friendship he could have had with Jamis. but no, in this reality he had to kill him. I think the goal in this instance or rather the main focus was loss. It's suppose to be more emotionally impactful and less showing he is worthy to the Fremen. Let's say for argument's sake, David Lynch left this scene in the older movie. As a person who hasn't read the books, I still don't understand why he would be crying even so I would understand that him sacrificing his body of moisture proves something to the Fremen. It still feels empty to me. Although Paul didn't cry in the newer film, I still felt his frustration and reluctance to kill Jamis. As I was feeling my own frustration lol.
@@WoWGirl6 I actually didn't take much note of Jamis the first time I watched the movie, I think b/c I was more focused on Chani and there was just generally a lot going on.
When I watched Dune the 2nd time, I watched for Jamis specifically. (Cause of your comment. ;) ) He pops up twice in the later visions, and I think you're right that they help the audience understand the loss more fully.
Also, as someone who HAS read the book (albeit, a very long time ago), Jamis's presence in the visions is a clever way of hinting at how Paul's visions actually work.
The 2nd movie will probably clarify things, as Paul himself starts to understand, but I the way the visions were handled very well.
I STILL wanted "water for the dead" though, and I'm pretty sure audiences would have gotten it if it had been included. After all, it's been 20 years since I've read Dune and I still remember that part. Obviously, it made an impact.
I wonder if perhaps they removed it b/c, after the emotional outburst Paul has with his mother in the tent, they thought crying again would make him seem weak. (I don't think that outburst is in the book, though I think it was well done.)
Anywho, I'm just glad they did the book justice and the movie's getting good reviews. :)
You should check the book out. It's good stuff! ;)
@@cmay7429 It's possible Villeneuve has Paul's crying scene early in Part 2. In the SyFy Dune Miniseries from 2000, which I rewatched just this week after seeing the new movie, they don't show Paul crying until Jamis' funeral during the whole "I was a friend of Jamis..." speech. It seemed like Villeneuve wanted the final shot we see to be of Paul, Jessica and the Fremen walking off into the desert like an old 'walking off into the sunset' scene you'd get in old movies. They were definitely carrying Jamis' body with them so they hadn't turned him to water yet.
@@mrquirky3626 Lol. Perhaps. I'll have to watch for it now. Looking forward to the sequel.
It'll likely be in the beginning of the second movie, it actually hasn't happened yet at this point in time in the movie.
Good Job Francessa ! Book line! very good venom and contempt!
Beautiful scene!!
I hated this movie when I first saw it years ago. Now it's my favorite. I wish they'd reedit it to its maximum glory.
The REdux fan edit is quite good.
I come from the year 2020, my friend, with good news!
I do not know how many times I have read Dune! That seen gives me chills everytime! The gift is scared beyond measure!
"he gives water to the dead", what an amazing phrase. Should not have been cut from the film.
I remember that Jamis chap from the movie actually. Anyway, I wish that every movie would be accompanied by the "Deleted Edition" in which every single deleted scene or idea(drawing) would be included. It may become a 3-hour version then, but it'd still be great to see every single thing in the movie that was made.
Imagine what the Fremen would have done if Paul pissed on Jamis after killing him.
I agree with you 100%. I could not take my eyes off of her.
Daniel
Would that they'd ever release a complete and uncut version....
Who would pay to see that come into being for an anniversary release?
Not sure if you know yet, but you can watch the 3-hour fanmade 2012 Spicediver alternative redux cut. You can find the 4k-upscaled video version here on GW's youtube channel. It gets the movie a bit more closer to the book, even with some of the movie's artistic liberties still in it.
04/21/24
Gods, Francesca Annis was so beautiful.
"Gee, thanks mom. It feels GREAT to be a killer. Happy?"
She saw that killing exhilarated him, she had to make sure he didn’t come to enjoy being a killer. It explains it in the novels
My favourite film of all time so exited about the remake
"He gives water to the dead" is the message of this...
Paul- "That's for abandoning my ancestor Pee-Wee on the side of the road!"
One of my favorite scenes from the book. "He gives water to the dead"
My condolences...
Why weren’t scenes like this included in the original movie? I know it was over two hours long, but there’s some really good stuff that just got cut. I wish Lynch would consider a directors cut. Probably will never happen.
The line, in any iteration of the story, that bothers me was that "how does it feel to be a killer?". I just wanted him to lose his shit on her. "BITCH IT WEREN'T MY IDEA!" Shit in the newest movie the only reason he was even fighting was as her champion. Then she guilt trips him?
Maybe as part of his formal education and military training could have included someone talking to him about the burdens of command. If I'm training someone so they can kill I'm also going to talk to them about the when's and why's as well as what to expect emotionally.
I can understand why people don't like this movie. It is so complex that a person would almost have to have read the novel to know what was going on. I read it when I was about 13 and had to keep going back and forth between the story and the glossary just to figure out what the heck was going on. The acting is great, the FX are either very disappointing or flipping amazing. I hope it gets remade by someone who knows and loves the material with the budget to fill it out. I could see it being two separate movies. I don't think there is enough material for the three books of the original novel. But it is certainly to much for one movie.
Well buddy, it looks like you got your wish.
@@cee_jay_mcc7914 Not for me. As a person who read the books, this new movie was a visual and sonic feast that supersedes any fanboy's wildest dreams.
But as an avid filmgoer, I also believe the movie really fails to stand on its own as a storytelling experience. The pacing is glacial, the characters are mostly throwaway, the conflict is kinda muddled, the buildups lack payoff, and it ends on a weird, unsatisfying note.
I think Denis Villeneuve's film is mostly saved by the otherworldly production design and body-thumping acoustics (if you saw it in a theatre). It delivers the Michael Bay experience of "looks good--sounds loud"--which is often enough to titillate and delight audiences. But the characters themselves are mostly immemorable.
In the end, I was riveted with what I saw on-screen, it was a sci-fi dream come true for me as a person familiar with the franchise.
But for those unfamiliar with the story, I wouldn't be surprised if they loved the visuals and sound--but found the story vague and characters less than stellar.
@@cee_jay_mcc7914 I don't believe there is anything inherently edgy about disagreement.
The distinction between our views is that you are content if a movie is faithful to the book.
I expressed that--when it comes to screen adaptations of books--I value films being able to stand on their own and meet certain storytelling standards of their medium; Villeneuve's Dune didn't do that for me and others, and I outlined why.
I very much enjoyed it as a fan who can fill in the film's measurable gaps in storytelling and pacing with deep knowledge of the books and the story's eventual direction.
But I can easily see how audience members who haven't read the books received a far more incomplete experience--because the film by itself lacks some critical elements of being a story that stands fully on its own.
I work in tech. The underdeveloped elements of Villeneuve's Dune parallel the tension I often face at work. And that is the difference between knowing things in your head and being able to explain them to others.
Sure, I can convey things in the technical jargon my peers are accustomed to, but translation is required when I'm going to communicate outside that circle of people. An acquired skill for many in higher levels of tech management is being able to translate their knowledge and insights into a language that conveys priority, stakes, and consequences to their non-technical bosses, clients, and peers.
Using that analogy, I believe that Denis Villeneuve's Dune was an excellent adaptation for the fans who have a priori technical knowledge so-to-speak from the books.
But I think he very much unnecessarily skimped on parts of filmmaking language that fashion a story all people can engage.
So, there we have us. A fan who is very satisfied with a movie created for established fans.
And a fan who is disappointed that the film was created without really trying to engage people who have the potential to *become* fans.
Regardless, though, I believe Villeneuve's Dune achieves a baseline of the moviegoing experience: It gives everyone an audiovisual spectacle.
@@tympanumeffect it seems to be getting a lot of good attention. Judging from the TH-cam reactions. People just find the so called “world-building” interesting. They are ready for world-building new worlds in their heads for each move after a good diet of marvel etc.
@@tympanumeffect I agree with you in principle btw. I remember thinning the fellowship of the ring was an amazing book adaptation. But not a truly great movie .. due to the ‘shape’ of the movie not giving me the best experience. That’s how I felt after first seeing it.
He's the Kwisatz Haderach!
Damn people, wash your hands.
I wish they restored it to its full vision, ( i was talking about the david lynch movie, i love the dune books, and adaptations, even though not perfect) i feel for david lynch, he was pressured to cut scenes and not been given final cut. Of course it hurt him so he refused when he was requested to do a directors cut, when they should have given it to him in the first place. They should have a competent director, i wish like denis villeneuve to re edit, restore and remaster dune 1984, to include great deleted scenes, as compensation and tribute to david lynch effort. Even though he does not want to do a directors cut. Give the man his due. I respect the efforts of the filmakers, even though its not perfect.
@goldenscales Dune was directed by David Lynch, an American. It was produced by Raffaella De Laurentiis though, who is Italian.
@darkjediMIK Jessica's motive was to keep Paul from enjoying his victory too much. This was his first battle to the death and he was on the edge of relishing it. In the book, it was like a sharp slap to the face for him.
not really sure why they'd cut this bit. works really well & creates a believable bond between Paul & the Fremen.
Gut wounds are always instantly mortal in movies
The Overseers of this production always did underestimate the Audience. Shame on them for eternity.
They should release the uncut version on DVD
David Lynch to Kyle McLaughlin:" Okay, after you stab him to death, breathe very heavily only through your nose.
Shaihlude!!! May his passing cleanse the Universe.
why did they cut it, it was such a good scene
In the book it wasn't Paul's first kill. He took out one of the Harkonnen's when Jessica and Paul escaped from the Orthinopter. "Well-l-l now--how does it feel to be a killer"? She asks after he bests Jamis in the knife fight. The difference is her concern. From the book. "Now is the terrible moment, she thought. He has killed a man in clear superiority of mind and muscle. He must not grow to enjoy such a victory". His first kill against the Harkeonnen was with his feet and was quickly done against a much lesser opponent who, as a Harkonnen, many might not have considered 'a man'. It was about the third reading of the book when I realized it wasn't really Paul's first kill.
@superhornet69 To quote Doctor Kynes: "Urine and feces are processed in the thigh pads."
The point was, tears fall when one is truly moved. As a consequence, they were in awe.
That's not the point of the scene. The point of the scene is that they know people can cry, but they work hard at not doing so because it's a waste of moisture (remember, these people worship water).
For their culture, if you cry for someone who is dead, they must have truly had an effect on you... so not only does Jessica's prodding cause Paul to not enjoy/relish violence, it's also meant as a way of impressing and ingraining themselves into the Fremen tribe.
I'm guessing then that you've never read the book.
The Fremen don't cry and also have a mutation that allows for super-fast blood clotting.
This is fucking eerie
WTF! This didn't even make it to the directors cut! Ahh, the pain!! No man, woman, or stars wars fan has ever survived so much!
@gbilios You mean the death of Thufir. Anyway, I know. But Jamis was in the background of the theatrical movie.
It's a good and meaningful scene not too long. They should have left it in.
Boy, if they were impressed by one little tear, imagine if he wiped it out and pissed on him. Now _that's_ what I call giving water to the dead!
+Emanresuadeen The reason is in the book they think Paul is sadistically toying with the man as he kills him.
SkyExplosion I know. But if they were impressed by one tear...follow?
Emanresuadeen No they were surprised he would cry since they thought he was sadistically torturing the dude and found it surprised this small weak kid was a sadistic guy who then cried for the man he just murdered. Paul wasn't sadisitci though he was just so use to fighting with a shield he never attacked with speed. or precision and never had never really seen men cry from guilt before.
SkyExplosion You obviously don't get the joke.
SkyExplosion Thanks for the explanation. It made me want to read the book.
With the cgi and technology today they can improve the special effects and with great editing they can remaster dune 1984, and restore the best deleted scenes. They have the means and resources to do it, if they want to do a great dune 1984 version. They can make it a peace offering and tribute to david lynch. The studio owe him a lot.
You'd wind up with a mess like the Star Wars "special editions". Remaster, and restore the deleted scenes.
@@killbot1974 i hope not, i wish it could be done great
*Ziiip*
*Fshhhhhhhhhh*
"He, ah, he gives, water I guess? To the dead."
"Get fucked Jamis." *Fsssssssh*
I hate that Delaurentis wanted to cut it down so much. The movie would have flowed so much better and made more sense without the massive cutting that happened.
Jamis was a friend of mine.
LOL, great answer, quoted directly from the movie. Amazing movie. Dune and Blade Runner, simply great.
They should've shown Chani admiring Paul before Jessica's line like in the book, it would've made more sense.
Dune (2014) and Blade Runner (in development) [check IMDB]. Before someone try to kill me, I'm all for it (for new ideas). If it sucks, we always have the originals, so, we've nothing to loose. Blade Runner will be directed by Ridley Scott, Dune still in development.
Why was this part cut?
How come this was way better than Feyd vs Paul?
Jamis was my friend and good in a fight but when he gets this carving rage on him he is dangerous to his tribe
I wasn’t aware there were so many deleted scenes from the original Dune. Maybe that’s why I was so disappointed when I watched it in the movie theater. After reading, and loving, the books in high school. The movie felt all chopped up and in segment’s.
Jamis was my friend…
Lynch must flow... Pure Lynch ...
@Lark1610 Yep, but this movie didn't really followed the book all times, what about voice activated weapons?
So technically could he piss on the corpse and be respected ?
This was a great seen. They shouldn't have cut it. It made Paul more human.
These scene never made much sense in the book because Paul kills a Harkonnen soldier.
I'm just wondering why they cut out most of the knife fight and just showed the final strike.
There is more footage of the entire knife fight posted on TH-cam.
that is cruicial part. and its missing in 2021 too
Kyle Maclachlan!
Is this scene in _ANY_ version of Dune 1984?
In this fan cut th-cam.com/video/vJykw3H4PDw/w-d-xo.html
I'll have to watch the fan edit by Spice Diver again maybe he put it in his version.
I honestly think if the deleted scenes were kept the film would have been better. It's not a bad film I love the weirdness of it my only issue is making the baron just plain psychotic but the film was overall good if disjointed and I would love to have set though even if it was 4 hours.
Like what they do to movies like apocalypse now redux and kingdom of heaven directors cut.
The words are from the book, but they're meaningless without context.
why was this scene cut?
$
without reading the book it's hard to understand. the fremen looked at him funny because they thought he was playing with jamis, but he had never fought to death or killed, so he was hesitant. her words and his crying showed them he wasn't being cruel just hadn't yet pushed his fighting that far.
Bad cut. That makes a huge difference and from the comments there are alot more scenes that should have been left in.
Except for the parts with the painted sheets behind the sets with mismatched lighting, and the parts where the Fremen still have white in their eyes, and the parts where the spice is green instead of orange.
Has there ever been a directors cut of DUNE?
No but there is a 3 hour fanedit by spicediver
@@jeffdube6016 Oooohhhhh where can one find this gem and is it safe to download?
@@SHA4200 I found a copy on p.i.r.a.t.e.b.a.y
@@jeffdube6016 Whoa boy. Aren't those seas a bit treacherous?
@@jeffdube6016 And before that there is the 3 hr tv version. I grew up on it.
this would have been an improvement - should have kept the scene.
I have CD's of both versions and CD's of "Children of Dune." no goats.
This movie would have been great if they hadn't butchered it. They cut off key segments of the movie.
No it's not. In the Butlerian Jihad humans waged a crusade against thinking machines and the humans won and outlawed artificial intelligence. In The Matrix humans also waged war against thinking machines but the humans lost. Both Neo and Paul were the "one" of their people. So who would win in a fight?
Obviously SkyNet would win via proxy, 'cuz it would choose Arnold Schwarzenegger as its champion.
Paul. If they're fighting in the physical world, Paul has the advantage.
Who would win in a fight. Paul or Neo from the Matrix?
Physical world-Paul. Matrix-Neo, unless Paul's abilities allow him to be similar.