Fun fact: Gabriel Sloyer, the actor for Javier, refused to aim his gun at Arthur and John because, in his words, he "didn't believe that Javier would do that to Arthur." That's commitment to the role.
Another fun fact, in a video the actor for Dutch stated that while mocapping the scene where he appears to call off the fight between Arthur and Micah, after leaving the scene he cried.
Little fact: at the part where Dutch walked away after the fight with Micah, his actor watched the rest of the scene get acted out just off shot and he was crying his eyes out. Technically, you could say even Dutch cried at Arthur's death.
damn that one i didn't knew..i knew about the one where arthur give his hat to john that rob was about to cry at that scene and the producers told him to try to keep up because john marston doesn't cry..and the whole cast was there clapping at the end..beautiful
On a lighter note.. the part with Mary visiting Arthur's Grave, Roger Clark had to stand in for Mary's actor lol I found that funny because he was like "The part where Mary is visiting Arthur's grave, well.. I was Mary" then laughed
obviously they didnt plan this but in the first game you can spare javier and just turn him in instead of kill him kind of a mutual respect thing i think.
@@joeydefalco4906 same here. I can't stop replaying it. This game is just a masterpiece and always will be. No matter how many times I play through I'll cry for Arthur
@@ardaerciyas1321 it's a masterpiece. Very few games make me cry like a baby this one did. Great story telling and just a massive game. Sometimes I just love to stand on a really high mountain in the game and just look out across to a relaxing view and appreciate Rockstar
That's the only part where I cried, i put so much love and time maxing out my steed MoonKnignt(the doc horse with the crescent moon) that I was truly devastated
Back then, with that type of life, your horse was blood bonded. Everyone came and went but your horse was the one good constant in your life, and that went for outlaws, gunslingers, drifters, rangers, etc. Losing your horse was like losing half your soul.
More often than not, I always try to get to that part with Buell. The horse that Hamish Sinclair gave us. That way, not only is Arthur thanking Buell, he’s also thanking Hamish.
My favorite part about this is the outfit and look of Arthur changing between each person, it shows who everyone wants Arthur to be and truly shows how this isn’t just a character, this is YOUR character.
Every game after RDR2 just wasn’t interesting and fun for me because it set the bar so high, it’s gonna be a real long time before I find a game on level with this
@@Epsa_ it’s just my opinion, but I feel that Both the games stand on the same level. It’s just Rdr2 hits more on emotional level & by far the most polished open world game ever.
I refuse to do anything but high honor specifically for that final shot. Arthur looking into the sunrise, almost as a showing of the redemption of his soul
The worst part of this game is you can never play it for the 1st time again. You also know Arthur is gonna die as soon as you find out he’s sick but how he died was a surprise.
I’ve replayed this game probably 7-8 times. Everytime, before the last couple missions, i always get Arthur a deluxe bath, a new suit, a shave and a slick haircut, because my boy deserves it. Also so I can clearly see the incredible motion capture acting from Roger Clark. Greatest protaganist in gaming history.
I’m on my second play through because I wanna explore as John and I’m having such a hard time with it. The part Arthur starts coughing in San Denis and collapses. I lost it. I couldn’t stop crying. Loaded an older save when things were good. I don’t think I can do it again.
The way Arthur said "Thankyou" to the horse was so touching for me because i only use 1 horse until it end (the American Standardbred bought at stable for the first time).
I had the morgan you buy at the start, it died in a gang ambush, after that i stole a ratty lookin tennessee walker and used that until i caught myself a mustang and rode it to the end
@@daxtro5492 i played it all over again about weeks ago. I got the golden horse from a stranger mission, Buell. I still used the Standarbred from the first stable, then tried Arabian (it's fast, but easy to fall), then i found Buell and used it until that scene. Damn, it still got me, even more with Buell.
@@daxtro5492 ok so i had the one at the start multiple tenesee walkers a 150 dollar one that died in chapter 6 another tenesee walker and i bought one after the epilogue that died (800 dollars gone) and stole 2 who died
When he is diagnosed with tuberculosis, you become much more attached to Arthur and begin to bathe him more frequently, feed him, dress him well, but at the same time you can't bear to see him pale, thin as a corpse. in the end you just want the story to end in a good way, this is so memorable and sad.
See, that is the scene that KILLED me. I KNEW Arthur was going to die- he wasn't in the first game. So I figured he'd go out in a crazy reckless, gunslinger death. Then, out of NOWHERE, you collapse and are on death's doorstep. There is NOTHING you can do- it's a terminal diagnosis. You just have to watch him die for the rest of the game with no hope. I was WRECKED when he collapsed from TB. I was not expecting the slow burn and feeling of helplessness :(
I don't mean to mention Cyberpunk like how a vegan would mention they're a vegan, but in Cyberpunk they gave the protagonist basically the same death sentence, but never really felt that you were in danger, nor did it change the protagonist in any meaningful way. With Arthur I never connected to a character as much as him. When he has been diagnosed I feel as though it is my life and I should be doing good like Arthur. I smoked a lot before too, and I took special care so he wouldn't even choke on dry food (yeah with dry foods he tends to cough like bread and biscuits), when most other players had him thin I made him overweight so he could at least keep his face not looking like a painted skull. Especially with the nun, you don't need to be religious to understand that death makes you learn things. Not many people get to take their lives in their own hands.
13:34 For the guys who complain about how the game ends after helping john if you have low honor or if you choose to return for the money, I can only tell you that you made your own decisions and at the end, the game taught you a lesson.
I used to like having massive shootouts in town, and get into fights with people who insulted my coyote scout jacket. In the actual story I did all the good choices, but hey I feel like Arthur getting shot is more realistic, no way would Micah have just left him there after all that. But still nothing can beat that sunrise.
Watched the VOD XqCoW was mad because his degenerate chat was still bickering about that he got the low honor ending and that he has no Morals and deserves to die So XQC got mad and in the clip at 13:32 he malds and tell chat that this is why he doesn't play story games
33 year old man, father and husband... the horse scene made me slam my controller and I cried my eyes out. I had to pause the game and walk off for a few minutes. This is why this game has my favorite story ever.
Not even kidding, I just finished the game and cried a little because I knew he was going to die. I tried to play as john and it just didn't feel right. Currently in my feels when I scroll down to the comments, see this and I just start bawling my eyes out. Arthur Morgan is such a good character.
I’m 38 father husband I screamed when I realized my horse was really dead and cried till Arthur died high honor, and I help John escape and as Dutch walked away I cried, like I hadn’t cried in years. This game was truly something magical.
Oh yes that had me crying too, this was the first time i cried from a game, even movies don't get me to that point that easy but this story is just a masterpiece and you really feel it. In my opinion the best story in a game i've ever played, there was really no game wich got me so hard.
@@marwan4358 haunting indeed. Haunting, upsetting, disturbing. Yet at the same time, liberating to know that he passes seeing the light. In a way, he’s okay now, and doing just fine. Even though he’s a fictional character.
This game brought me and my dad both to tears when we played it together for the first time. It’s the only time I’ve seen him cry like that, A+ to Rockstar for bringing a grown man to tears
Thats the Kind of stuff that melts the most men hearts. it has everything a man`s code should be! i just cried for two movies (green mile and lotr3 ending) no game ever could trigger tears but rdr2 managed it^^
Yeah, that was a decision on his actor's part. He didn't feel like Javier was 100% onboard with what was happening based on his character so far, so he just didn't raise the gun.
@@LazzyVamples Yeah, as selfish as it may sound, he probably thought going with Dutch/Micah was the best chance of survival. Which is what everybody in this game is trying to do.
What makes it sad is all the history Arthur and Dutch have, Dutch raised Arthur and for Dutch to just betray him like that for a guy he hasn't known more than 6 months.
I love john and arthur (especially arthur) but they betrayed dutch first. In a gang you can't disobey orders from the leader and do your own thing even if its morally not right. A combination of john having a kid (jack) and arthur getting TB made them both realize that being an outlaw is bad. If arthur never got TB i honestly believe he would have fought with dutch till the end and not help other people like the indians or john escape. There are many chapter 1 and 2 missions before TB where arthur is criticizing and angry at john for leaving the gang. This proves arthurs extreme loyalty to the gang and is why dutch loves him so much. Later in the story when arthur starts helping John escape (chapter 4,5,6) dutch turns to micah who was the only one (along with bill and javier) he could completely trust in the camp. To complete his 'plan' he needed more people on his side and thats why micah brought in his 2 rat friends (cleet and forgot the other guys name). Yes arthur and john were doing the right thing but dutch has every right to feel betrayed especially by john and thats why he gives him that look at 17:53. I believe he only shot micah because of his love for arthur not because he wanted to save john or sadie. Dutch has suspicions of johns mindset from as early as chapter 2 and dutch probably feels like john got into arthurs head and persuaded him to help him instead of the gang.
@@lexdemerindol320 Good theory but nobody "directly" betrayed the gang, Dutch was going crazy and killing that BW girl didn't help much, I'm not saying it's his fault but something clicked in him. Arthur and other members couldn't help but notice that the Law is gonna catch up and they will die and they didn't all want to die for a madman. Imo the ONLY reason Bill and Javier stayed is because they literally know nothing else but fighting for Dutch but right after the main campaign they ditched and took their chances in Mexico One of the western themes of the game IMO is the dangerous game of cat and mouse but in this game the cat will always win. Redemption is a long road that goes less traveled, but once you start the path it never ends until the final standoff
@@lexdemerindol320 Jesus never thought of it like that, it makes sense but is still fucked, but what else could you expect from a group of morally confused people falling apart at the seams
I prefer the bad honor go for the money ending with this, because after 20+ years of loyalty Arthur doesn’t care anymore. ‘Dutch, Micah, come get me you bastards’
Im jealous that in your case its ONLY ONE month. In my case I feel depressed to this day but its now a bit better than at the first, second,third and fourth playthrough
I’m not ashamed to say this game is the only game that had made me cry. When my horse died, I lost all hope that Arthur was gonna live. Seeing my horse cry in pain in his last dying breaths just broke me. Seeing Arthur die under a great sunrise broke me. This game has an amazing story
i started cryiing when he said goodbye to tilly and cut her off saying she will miss him and didnt stop till about 5 mins after Arthur died im so glad i decided to start being high honor just before arthur got tb literally finished this game 2 hours ago for the first time lol
The high honour ending is sooo good. I always get so emotional as I've spent time reforming Arthur and then u have to see him die. A good man doesnt deserve to die because of micha
Ehhhh arthur isn't really a good man. He did SOME good, doesn't absolve how shitty of a human he was to other people tho. If hell existed, he's definitely going there
@@PotatoMaGobinus I think the moral of rdr2 is second chances. Arthur realised too late he needed to change and didn't have time for a full second chance, that's why he saves John, Abigail and Jack, to give them his second chance. John avenged Arthur by killing micha and then led a calm life (from what I know) until rdr. After his death jack takes over. Sorry for explaining the plot that u probably know. But the reason we love Arthur is because he isn't all bad. He tried to make amends but dies too early. Even before his diagnosis he tries to help out everywhere he can, only robbing and murdering when necessary.
@@ibrahim-bm6rw while that may have helped them find john it‘s not like it was a mystery to find john anyway he literally bought land on his own name and not just in the middle of nowhere right next to blackwater they would have found john anyway no matter if he killed micah or not they have more than enough things to go and find john
The fact that Arthur refused to abandon his horse when dying says everything about Arthur. He would not abandon his best friend, no matter what. That made me cry soooo bad
@@Christ42yeah I know! That’s why it’s so beautiful because despite it just being a video game it has the same emotional impact as a movie. It makes you feel things, it hits you right in the heart strings, because you learn to love these characters. After all games are just another form of storytelling, at least games like these with a plotline and stuff not like fall guys or among us, though those games are still cool.
Javier not pointing his gun at John and Arthur during the stand-off is a really good catch. Apparently his actor, Gabriel Sloyer, fought the directors to add that detail to the scene because he felt Javier wouldn't actually want to kill his 'brothers' even at the end.
Actually I noticed something also when Bill was on the other side I also noticed that his gun was away from Arthur as well so he was also shaking a bit.
they still really like Arthur but when dutch made them choose between him and arthur rather then arthur vs Micah they would choose dutch, but i’m glad they put that in
I'm 53 yrs old, been gaming since 1990 or so. This was the best game I ever played, and it's great to see that it touched these gamers like it touched me. I took my time with RDR2 and played it over about 6 months; a most enjoyable half year of my gaming life! Great video, thanks for creating!
I'm 55 started with gaming in the 90s too and yes ... this game is by far the best I ever played. First time cried my eyes out over a game. Heartbraking stories everywhere - told just through letters or remains in cabins. A world that feels real and alive. So many things to explore and to do. After 4 years I started another round a few weeks ago and already I found so many things I missed when I played the first time. This is not just a game - it's more like a mix between game, movie, novel and history lesson. I hope I am going to live long enough to see another game that is able to impress me so deeply.
Good for you man I’m 45 and just love it more then ever this game was just everything to me love the whole package of it,I was bawling at end of this game the wife and kids looking at me thinking I’m losing my mind 😊😊gaming since 80s grew up in arcades never lost the love of gaming stayed with me all way through life 👌👍we could be at a lot worse things in life 👏👏
They most likely just did wgat i found fun. Massive shootouts in town. Just kill someonr and see how long you survive. Big problem is it gets you all the way down to bottom honor very fast.
What we didn't see was anyone who got high Honor but went back for the money. Going back for the money does put a big hit on the Honor, but if it was high enough at the point of deciding it still plays out much like "high Honor, help John"...He fights Micah, Dutch appears, Micah & Dutch leave (separately), Arthur still gets to see one last sunset before he dies (& his totem animal is still the buck). Yes, it's possible for *both* choices to end with high Honor or low Honor, which makes *four* different endings.
I can’t lie the night I beat this game I cried for hours… I never connected with characters as much, but Arthur had such great character development. The buildup was just wow, this definitely deserved game of the year.
@@FeynAnimate dude once you get to a certain point near the end, they did good at making it suck you in, so you didn’t experience it in pieces,it makes wanna play more and more and you end up experiencing it whole. Best game I’ve ever played.
If there was a person I hated more in this game, that was that soab Micah, then Dutch. At the beginning I didn't like Arthur but later I started getting a bond with his character. Only in few games I had this emotional feeling.
Definitely, I played the game for the first time back in beginning of 2022 and I liked Dutch. But as story goes on I started to hate Dutch. Micah was hated the moment I saw him lol felt something bad
I liked Dutch even at the end of the game. But what I never understood is why it took him so long to realize he was wrong. I mean, by the time there was only a handful of his old "family" left, he should have known. Pretty stupid for an otherwise smart guy.
@@Hexenmeister999 I am really wondering the same thing, How in the hell did he just leave Arthur too die like that after all these years. I think it’s combination of Micah and Dutch real personality coming out and showing who he really is
@@00mints Yeah I can't understand how someone could reach the end with low honor. I love going full psycho in most games but I couldn't bring myself to do it here. It didn't feel right
I mean bad ending and good ending exist long before RDR2 and RDR2 Cleary show that it has good and bad ending before you end it so i'm really confused why is he mad seens it was obvios from the start that he would get the bad ending
In one of the cutscenes Arthur says: face my grave to the sunset so i can watch it and remember all the good times with my friends.... he died watching the sun set
So many moments in this game that give you an emotional punch in the guts. The deaths of Sean, Lenny, Hosea and Keiren. The Tuberculosis diagnosis. The characters in this game are just incredible. Kudos to the writers who gave us so many friends in the game. I've played good games twice before, but it's probably up to 7 playthroughs of RDR2 now.
One scene that almost equals in the "God damn this is a hard one..." department, is if you have high honor and helped the Priest and the Sister out during Chapter 4, later in the game after a mission with Charles and some army dude (I forgot the exact mission and details) gets on a train, you'll have a talk to the Sister of the church, and Arthur legitimately admits he's dying of TB and he's afraid, he goes from a goofy, blow it off demeanor to a completely broken man by the end of the scene. You see his guard fall for the first time for real in the game, and they executed the timing great.
@@Wildlink123 That's actually the very first time you see Arthur vulnerable, as well as admitting it. I took notice of that scene myself, he even actually said he's scared. I don't think he was scared of dying, he's just scared of how he'll be remembered, and what will happen to those he loves he'll have to leave behind. John, little Jack, Sadie That's why he told John to run, and asked Sadie to make sure they all run. He's lost respect for Dutch, Dutch is just a loose cannon at this point
The last ride made me cry like a baby because I had Arthur’s death spoiled for me so I prepared for that the entire run but I wasn’t expecting his last ride to hit so hard and it threw me off
same, someone spoiled it for me and so as soon as I went into the cinematic and that song started playing I cried for the WHOLE last ride, which is the whole song, ffs
Same thing happened with me. I don't understand why people feel the need to spoil video games endings. I was just rushing to get it over with because I was mad that I knew ultimately what would happen, and then that last ride hit me. Took my breath away. 😭
This made me cry because we did so much with Arthur. Arthur had such a legacy, we bonded with him, the more we played the more attached to him as a character we were. It felt as if Arthur was more than a person, just a soul looking for redemption. Having him die watching the sunset means he didn’t want to spend his last seconds with his eyes closed accepting his fate, and he made the best if those last seconds, using all the strength his body had left to watch the sunrise. RIP Arthur.
I love this comment, here's some interesting lore for you: Early in the game, Arthur was asked how he wanted to be buried. He said to face him west so he could watch the sunset. If you get this ending, he dies facing East watching a sunrise, indicating he had achieved true redemption from his old ideas.
Losing Arthur felt more personal than any other game. We fed him, clothed him, did his chores, and even fucking BATHED him. lol We WERE him... I believe this game straight up helped raise an entire generation of gamers. Most of us were not the same by the end of this game.
I’ve never cried over a game or a movie Until Red Dead 2. I’ve never been so emotionally invested in a game or movie or tv series until RDR2. Arthur kind of reminded me of my dad. Rough and tough on the outside but always showed his love when it was needed.
It's the best game I ever played but it's not perfect. Guns not being equipped after you get off ur horse is particularly annoying. Definitely a masterpiece tho
Shot out to xQc for showing me the worst ending imaginable. Had no idea this one existed. He must've really done some F'd up Sh*t in the whole game to get this result😂🤷♂
Either way, Arthur dies horribly on low honor. A knife in the back or a shot in the head. But yes, going for money on low honor must be the worst ending.
@@izmi2938 no theres another one if you still have high honor after chosing to save the money. Micah will just walk away and arthur dies "peacefully", without getting stabbed
Never been ashamed about crying during video games, but holy hell no other game made me cry this many times. RDR2 is more than just a game, it is truly an art that needs to be treasured.
Yes I was thinking same. Watching people play the ending gave me goosebumps. Epic games qish I could play it again for the first time. I rushed it, gutted lol
@@Gliding-Admiral that's the point. If you have low honor, you did bad things. It's abrupt and violent and micah ends arthur in such a bloody way, obliterating arthur as a person. Low honor Arthur is a bad, bad, BAD person, and he gets no last words, no final quips. Birds and wolves feast on his corpse and he is forever forgotten except by those he terrorized
And the most incredible thing is that in a conversation at the camp, Arthur is asked how he wanted to die and he replies: I want to die watching the sunset. Thanks for the great work Rockstar.
@@henriquediniz9240 it is poetic though. His whole life, he thought he isn't worthy of anything and sunset means the day is over. Yet when he died, he watched sunrise, a new beginning, not for himself, but for John, hopefully.
Watching this is bringing back how much this game upset me at the time, i was going through a break up and playing this just after i broke up with my ex, this was released and it was my own way of getting over my ex, this game hurt me more than she did the way arthur was treated. Cant believe how much this story still gets to me.
Even though i finished RDR2 a while ago, watching this brought all the feels back. The story and dialogue in the game was the best ive played, for me it was all about the real detail spots. Some might disagree but i think the game is a work of art. It was worth waiting for, and worth every minute i put into playing it.
This video game had better dialogue writing than a considerable amount of movies. This was like playing a movie, to every little detail. Whoever directed this games cinematography and writing deserves an award.
I love XQC's logic that Arthur didn't have any family or friends to make helping John worth it, so his best logical conclusion is to spend an absurd amount of money that he won't even live long enough to even hold or make a life worth living, seemingly forgetting the game made it ultra clear that Arthur was going to die soon no matter what happened. Not only that, but he gets ENRAGED that he died after choosing the most logically stupid option at that moment. His mind genuinely is an enigma.
Indeed XQC was absolutely funny to think as if Arthur would still live longer if he goes after the money (knowing that, back then, TB was incurable and antibiotics doesn't exist yet.)
he wasn't angry that arthur died if you were there for the stream he was angry the he was getting death threats and was getting told to kill himself because of the ending he got
@@I_hate_you_8--D I don’t think anyone condones that kinda crap when we’re talking about games here. It’s hostile and obviously XQC doesn’t deserve that. That being said, it would take an (in my opinion) unreasonable amount of detachment from the text to just shrug and really think nothing of a choice like that. The only way I would concede that someone doing that ending would be believable within the context of the story, is if the player believes Arthur to actually be that kind of man. And that’d be valid! That’s why the option is there. The valid criticism I empathize with, at the root of that unnecessary hostility, is that of XQC (and some other low honor players’) unthinking detachment from the game. When the literal entirety of the game has been about Arthur finding himself able to be redeemed *despite* his past actions, denying him that redemption is kinda going against the name of the game, no? Also, if I may, I find it a little ironic that we’re talking about how people shouldn’t tell others to “Roblox” themselves, when you have *that* as your profile picture.
@@TerranPersoid725 on this account I usually go to pedo accounts or videos of animal abuse and tell people to Roblox them selves but I sometimes comment on other videos too
And that's how they find John and the sad part is John and Abigail only got three years of actually being married and settled down before he was killed
it's cool how the game goes from you thinking "oh just a stupid cowboy game" to the best story in all of video game history Edit: that was at least what i was thinking when i first played it because i'd never seen anything about the game
Hits me now still and on every single playthrough. Only played through at least 20 times. My first ever playthrough: I held out hope until right up the buck walked away. Then I knew it was over. Death/spirit animal retrieved his soul and went home. Having not played RDR I didn't know how the endings worked, so when it said "A few years later" I was like "Really?!? Did Rains Fall...?" Then John spoke. I was in a bad evil mood as John for a while. John didn't care. Until I got more into playing John then I finally calmed down IRL. I wanted Micah though... AND Dutch. I though Arthur was like a son to him. And he said Arthur was the type to be a traitor. HA! Says the narcissist.
I just finished my first playthrough of RDR2 right now and cried when my horse died and when Arthur died. I knew the ending of this way before and I still cried, absolutely legendary game.(I am 12)
This is my FAVORITE, FAVORITE game of all time!! Just like the gamers in the video, I cried so hard when he passed away at the mountain when I played, and I cried just as much watching this video. Maybe its a game, but the connection you get to Arthur doing the gameplay, is insane, which makes his death even more sad. I really felt like I lost a dear friend. Rockstar did such an indescribable good job with RDR2. In my opinion, no game will ever compare with this one. Truly blessing! How I wished he would't have died.. Imagine the story we would've gotten, when it was all over, if he survived
This part honestly wasn’t as heartbreaking as the part where Arthur meets the Sister one last time before she heads to Mexico. When Arthur looked dead at her and said “I’m afraid” with a shaky voice and bloodshot eyes like if he was holding back from crying really had me bawling.
That part made me realize that I was not ready for the rollercoaster of emotions coming my way in the ending of the game. I had to take a break for a few hours before finish it, still crying like a baby when that song hit after the rescue of Abigail.
The fact Dutch and Arthur had been together for almost 20 years or so. Having Arthur as his sort of second hand man to then just be betrayed like that really hits hard 😔
Me too!! That one broke the Levee for sure! And I'm typically not a crier, but that hit hard after all the days and nights I spent getting to know Arthur and the rest of the gang. What an amazing experience this game was.
I'm a COD gamer through and through. Since trying RDR2 last month I haven't been able to stop playing RDR2. This game has changed me so much. Even I had a tear in my eye when Arthur horse was hurt and don't get me started when Arthur looked out to the horizon. Absolutely epic story and game play ❤❤
I went for the money because I was low honor my entire playthrough and then in chapter 6 got up to high honor and when faced with that decision, I remember audibly saying "nah, outlaw for life". Also I played the original so I knew John survived whether I went with him or not. I didn't mind the ending but high honor, help John is definitely the better ending. The knife fight with Micah is cooler than the fist fight though
The whole Journey of arthur was truly artwork From beginning to end we really get more attached to this fictional character So much so that the idea of him slowly dying was unacceptable And then theres markiplier who constantly gives arthur and Schwoomple multiple concussions
Markiplier is a manchild tbh. His RDR2 playthrough sucks. He didnt even finish the game because he got spoiled about the ending. Just leave him with his 10 y/o audiences whoe enjoy watching him screams all the time
@@kingf6766 you sure hate a lot on somebody with 29.7 million subscribers, and I'm pretty sure he has a wide spread of an audience. He does videos in term of if people enjoy it or not and he determines that in views and likes. If his audience didn't like it, he does something else.
@@kingf6766 Also, so what if he is a manchild, he is not ashamed to show it and he has fun doing what he does which is difficult for many content creators
@@despacitodaniel801 Maybe, maybe not, but the fact is it’s a great scene, and some movies miss the attachment you have when playing the game like it’s your own movie.
This was fun to watch. I used to be a gamer, but I had to stop for personal reasons. Like being so hooked up in a game, that sometimes I called in sick for work. RDR2 is one of the first games I have played in many years. I was pretty late. Bought it for one year ago. Really great game, the story, the graphics and also everything you can discover in the game. I'm still playing it. I tried playing it online, but it felt so empty. Anyways, I have seen so many people cry at the end of this game. Teenagers to older people, like 70yr old.
The relationship arc between john and Arthur is beautiful. At the beginning of the game Arthurs blasts John for leaving the gang and by the end of the story all Arthur wants is for John to get away 😭😭😭
It’s weird to describe my reaction to Arthur’s death. I wasn’t sad, deep down maybe i was. But the only feelings i felt was hate, and dissatisfaction with not being able to kill Micah. So for the entire prologue of the game, that anger never went away. Even after killing Micah, it felt too easy to let him die so quickly. I was filled with anger and rage and it wasn’t until i sat down as John and red all of Arthur’s journals that i finally broke down into tears. I finally got to grief for a fictional characters death. I finally was able to feel at ease over his death. I guess, at the end, my blind rage and hatred still ended up costing John’s family and potential future they may have had. Making feel even worse knowing I was more then happy to go after Micah knowing the outcome of the first game.
I was so mad Arthur dont kill Micah. I like the epilogue but I would prefer killing Micah as Arthur, even if Dutch had killed him would be better for me but I understand that they had to save him for the epilogue, I got the shotgun to shoot him in the face but sadly the cut scenes didn't let me
@@phil393 lmao i mean we go around killing O’Driscoll‘s by the thousands, hundreds if not thousands of law man, and hundred of thousands of innocent NPC’s by the time we beat the game lmao 💀 Like i’m sure Rockstar intended for the game to feel more realistic, but killing is what u do from start to finish lmao
Arthur is the ONLY video game character I've ever teared up for. That alone tells you how incredible this story line really is. Greatest game ever, and it's not even close!!!!
Lol know the difference between greatest and best. Rdr2 isn't even close to being greatest game of all time. Some of the greatest games of all time are gta v, Minecraft, last of us, witcher 3, legend of Zelda ocarina of time, etc
@@yazeed_joestar I've played them all except Minecraft and 3 of the ones you mentioned are in my all time top 5, but none of them come even close to rdr2, it's embarrassing that you think they're better. The fact you have Minecraft on here means you just shot your credibility right in the foot. Rdr2 It is the best, the greatest ever, it's whatever you want to call it, it's no.1, it's irreplaceable.
@@atourdeforce I literally said know the difference between greatest and best. I never said those are "better" than rdr2 lmao. I just said they're "greater". Rdr2 is also the best game I've ever played. But that doesn't make it the greatest game of all time. U or me cannot decide which game is greater than the other one. Its not subjective
@@yazeed_joestar You're talking like greater cannot be subjective there is literally zero difference between best or greatest. It's word choice, so I literally have zero clue why you seem so hung up on a definition that means the exact same thing either way. It is the greatest game ever, it is the best game ever, there is zero difference in either meaning except someone might chose to use one instead of the other. If someone thinks it's the greatest game ever that is absolutely no different to someone thinking its the best game ever.
@@atourdeforce valid, I just finished the game man and this is a game that cannot be replicated, the story, the interaction, wild life like its just a collection of diamonds that cannot be done again at least in my eyes. My experience with this game, I will never feel it with another one. On my second playthrough rn
bro i gotta give you props, you do amazing transitions between gameplay with other people’s reactions. most reaction channels will show one persons full reaction and then the next one repeating the same scene, but you show ALL OF THEM through these super smooth transitions. really making me feel the feels with these guys. nice job man.
Not gonna lie when the Pinkertons arrived and he yelled “this is agent Ross with the Pinkerton detective agency, put your guns down!” i legit got goosebumps because for the first time it really felt like it was all over for them.
I will always look up to Arthur. He’s a real man and does what needs to be done when no one else would❤️ never been more attached to a video game character but shit, LONG LIVE ARTHUR
And friends i have dont understand how you can get so emotionally invested "its only a game" , arthur is hands down one of the best characters i have played as, that ride he takes back to camp after saying goodbye to abigail and sadie one last time always gets me
![[#2024MAMA] BIGBANG (빅뱅) - 뱅뱅뱅 (BANG BANG BANG) + FANTASTIC BABY | Mnet 241123 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EQsYfiPR9uM/mqdefault.jpg)
Never cried during a movie in my life...
But arthurs death broke me, man.
Same here man. And my horse
Same exept I was mad they killed my 5th horse
I thought after John's death I couldn't cry again for a characters death in a videogame... And then came Arthur's and made me cry again
Same bro...
Need to watch better movies, man.
Fun fact: Gabriel Sloyer, the actor for Javier, refused to aim his gun at Arthur and John because, in his words, he "didn't believe that Javier would do that to Arthur." That's commitment to the role.
And my respect to Rockstar for allowing this to be happening in the final game.
Makes the first game far darker cause you kill him your self or have the state hang him
Another fun fact, in a video the actor for Dutch stated that while mocapping the scene where he appears to call off the fight between Arthur and Micah, after leaving the scene he cried.
@@JustAreru which is now officially cannon in the story
@@X4ZYLE yep, because the one who was crying was the actor not dutch
Little fact: at the part where Dutch walked away after the fight with Micah, his actor watched the rest of the scene get acted out just off shot and he was crying his eyes out. Technically, you could say even Dutch cried at Arthur's death.
damn that one i didn't knew..i knew about the one where arthur give his hat to john that rob was about to cry at that scene and the producers told him to try to keep up because john marston doesn't cry..and the whole cast was there clapping at the end..beautiful
If look closely at ductes eye you can see his tearing up as he walks away
also Micah's actor apparently cried because of that mission too due to how evil he had to be.
On a lighter note.. the part with Mary visiting Arthur's Grave, Roger Clark had to stand in for Mary's actor lol I found that funny because he was like "The part where Mary is visiting Arthur's grave, well.. I was Mary" then laughed
How do you all know?
“You’re my brother” = I love you
“I know, I know” = I love you too
Facts
"You're my brother" is basically the manliest way of saying "I love you" in a non-romantic way
@@Asylumturtle05 that bromantic
Said every man to another man, without saying it. Genuine.
Dutch was just mad cause I never upgraded his tent
First things first. Dutch wants something comfier
@@45jmo screw ducth.
@@moodyowlproductions4287 first things first. Dutch WANTS something comfier
@@moodyowlproductions4287 I got a Plan plannin to Rob your train
@@45jmo what about you uncle, 'cause you still got that LUMBAGO
I'll always appreciate that Javier does *not* point his gun at Arthur.
Which makes sense with his characterization throughout the game.
He’s on Dutch’s side all the way but he knows Arthur ain’t a rat.
The actor for Javier had to fight for that part. Does that mean Rockstar initially wanted Javier to point his gun at Arthur & John?
obviously they didnt plan this but in the first game you can spare javier and just turn him in instead of kill him kind of a mutual respect thing i think.
@@tylerfreal6472 yes and then he gets hanged
He also doesn’t just run past lenney in the bank mission
John: “You’re my brother….”
Arthur: “I know…”
Makes me cry every time
I played it 7 times and I cried so for 2 years the game touched my heart
@@joeydefalco4906 same here. I can't stop replaying it. This game is just a masterpiece and always will be. No matter how many times I play through I'll cry for Arthur
I didn't cried only on the inside
Me too dont wory
@@ardaerciyas1321 it's a masterpiece. Very few games make me cry like a baby this one did. Great story telling and just a massive game. Sometimes I just love to stand on a really high mountain in the game and just look out across to a relaxing view and appreciate Rockstar
Fun fact: The voice of Dutch cried after filming the scene we’re Dutch left Aurthur to die
Arthur saying ‘Thank you’ to his horse is one of the noblest things I’ve ever seen.
That's the only part where I cried, i put so much love and time maxing out my steed MoonKnignt(the doc horse with the crescent moon) that I was truly devastated
That only happens if its a horse that you have level 4 bonding with
Back then, with that type of life, your horse was blood bonded. Everyone came and went but your horse was the one good constant in your life, and that went for outlaws, gunslingers, drifters, rangers, etc. Losing your horse was like losing half your soul.
Arthur was a honorable and noble man. One of a kind
More often than not, I always try to get to that part with Buell. The horse that Hamish Sinclair gave us. That way, not only is Arthur thanking Buell, he’s also thanking Hamish.
First mission started with Arthur Dutch and Micah
Ended with Arthur Dutch and Micah
John
@@unoriginalcontent237 Jack
@@rang_ongaming231 wow I forgot about Jack
*last mission ended as Arthur with Dutch and Micah
Oh wow you’re right and then the last last mission ends with John dutch and Micah
Well actually technically just John and Dutch
"Can't even kill a dying man..." is the ultimate insult
Fr tho. If he won’t dying he could have killed Micah with ease
@@tylerjohnson4311 he would’ve killed Micah if not for Dutch
@@tylerjohnson4311 if he wasnt sick, he would easily beat Micah
@@tylerjohnson4311 I mean in the epilogue he can barley get a hold of Sadie and she was injured
CAN ANYONE EXPLAIN WHY THE HELL DUTCH DIDNT SAVE ARTHUR IN MOUNTAINS AND KILL MICAH
My favorite part about this is the outfit and look of Arthur changing between each person, it shows who everyone wants Arthur to be and truly shows how this isn’t just a character, this is YOUR character.
👏🏼
Ugh this game. One of Rockstar’s best, if not their best story ever.
Definitely their best story of all time and one of the best stories of all time
Every game after RDR2 just wasn’t interesting and fun for me because it set the bar so high, it’s gonna be a real long time before I find a game on level with this
@@Epsa_ play the witcher 3
@@xaosils1083 played it back on release, still doesn’t amount to RDR2
@@Epsa_ it’s just my opinion, but I feel that Both the games stand on the same level. It’s just Rdr2 hits more on emotional level & by far the most polished open world game ever.
I refuse to do anything but high honor specifically for that final shot. Arthur looking into the sunrise, almost as a showing of the redemption of his soul
I tried to replay with low honor and just couldn't do it.
bro I thought the same, it's like I can't be low honor @@Outlaw2-5
low honour also just generally makes the game a little harder and you make less money.
High honor, last bad decision is my favorite ending
i think the game is supposed to be played:
early chapers - low honor
late chapters - high honor
thats the point of redemption
Where Girls Cried: RDR2 Good Ending
Where Boys Cried: RDR2 Good Ending
Where Legends Cried: RDR2 Good Ending
We all could agree on this
where a xqc got mad: RDR2 Bad Ending
@@Cyrex64 LMAO
Where giga chad cries: RDR2 Good ending
The worst part of this game is you can never play it for the 1st time again. You also know Arthur is gonna die as soon as you find out he’s sick but how he died was a surprise.
I’ve replayed this game probably 7-8 times. Everytime, before the last couple missions, i always get Arthur a deluxe bath, a new suit, a shave and a slick haircut, because my boy deserves it. Also so I can clearly see the incredible motion capture acting from Roger Clark.
Greatest protaganist in gaming history.
Did the same thing at the second time I played the ending. Arthur really deserved it 🤘🏻
Not the greatest definitely, but amongst the GOATs no less
greatest he is@@yasininn76
@@yasininn76if not him then who else.
I’m on my second play through because I wanna explore as John and I’m having such a hard time with it. The part Arthur starts coughing in San Denis and collapses. I lost it. I couldn’t stop crying. Loaded an older save when things were good. I don’t think I can do it again.
The way Arthur said "Thankyou" to the horse was so touching for me because i only use 1 horse until it end (the American Standardbred bought at stable for the first time).
I used about 8 horses cuz these bitches kept falling off of cliffs
I had the morgan you buy at the start, it died in a gang ambush, after that i stole a ratty lookin tennessee walker and used that until i caught myself a mustang and rode it to the end
@@daxtro5492 i played it all over again about weeks ago. I got the golden horse from a stranger mission, Buell. I still used the Standarbred from the first stable, then tried Arabian (it's fast, but easy to fall), then i found Buell and used it until that scene. Damn, it still got me, even more with Buell.
@@daxtro5492 ok so i had the one at the start multiple tenesee walkers a 150 dollar one that died in chapter 6 another tenesee walker and i bought one after the epilogue that died (800 dollars gone) and stole 2 who died
omg too! I cried a lot with that part because it really broke my heart to see my only horse die that I used for the entire game ;(
When he is diagnosed with tuberculosis, you become much more attached to Arthur and begin to bathe him more frequently, feed him, dress him well, but at the same time you can't bear to see him pale, thin as a corpse. in the end you just want the story to end in a good way, this is so memorable and sad.
See, that is the scene that KILLED me. I KNEW Arthur was going to die- he wasn't in the first game. So I figured he'd go out in a crazy reckless, gunslinger death. Then, out of NOWHERE, you collapse and are on death's doorstep. There is NOTHING you can do- it's a terminal diagnosis. You just have to watch him die for the rest of the game with no hope. I was WRECKED when he collapsed from TB. I was not expecting the slow burn and feeling of helplessness :(
Ya
bro when you close up on his eyes and they are always red af. sad
I DID EXACTLY THE SAME THING! I was feeling so bad for Arthur and because I liked him from the beginning! Seeing him go pale and weak crushed me...
I don't mean to mention Cyberpunk like how a vegan would mention they're a vegan, but in Cyberpunk they gave the protagonist basically the same death sentence, but never really felt that you were in danger, nor did it change the protagonist in any meaningful way.
With Arthur I never connected to a character as much as him. When he has been diagnosed I feel as though it is my life and I should be doing good like Arthur. I smoked a lot before too, and I took special care so he wouldn't even choke on dry food (yeah with dry foods he tends to cough like bread and biscuits), when most other players had him thin I made him overweight so he could at least keep his face not looking like a painted skull.
Especially with the nun, you don't need to be religious to understand that death makes you learn things. Not many people get to take their lives in their own hands.
0:02 'Face me to the West, so i can watch the setting sun and remember all the fine times we had that way' -Arthur Morgan.
13:34 For the guys who complain about how the game ends after helping john if you have low honor or if you choose to return for the money, I can only tell you that you made your own decisions and at the end, the game taught you a lesson.
I think xQcOW was pissed off cause someone in his chat was mad about his gameplay choice and told him to kys
I used to like having massive shootouts in town, and get into fights with people who insulted my coyote scout jacket. In the actual story I did all the good choices, but hey I feel like Arthur getting shot is more realistic, no way would Micah have just left him there after all that. But still nothing can beat that sunrise.
Watched the VOD
XqCoW was mad because his degenerate chat was still bickering about that he got the low honor ending and that he has no Morals and deserves to die
So XQC got mad and in the clip at 13:32 he malds and tell chat that this is why he doesn't play story games
@@karolkos5915 its still funny how mad he got
@@DustySiren True
“People don’t forget, and nothings forgiven.”- John Marston
“You don’t get to live a bad life, and have good things happen to you.”- Arthur Morgan
"Im Real sick John, Lumbago, It's a slow and painful death, my brother." -One shot kid/Arthur Third favourite parasite/Red harlow/Uncle
"Have you seen my friend Gavin? An english man" - Niko Bellic
Arthur:*donates thousands of dollars for everyone to get to tahiti*
Dutch: WHO IS WITH ME AND WHO IS AGAINST ME!!?!
Money
Correction. *Moneh
@@damagicalrhino7951 thanks son I forgot
@@Mineway_Offical I gave you $5000 dollars and Still could not get to Taihiti.
@@supremealgo1 you know how I had silver guns but then they were golden at the end?
Ever noticed when you confront Micah in the mountains,a rat runs arounds
33 year old man, father and husband... the horse scene made me slam my controller and I cried my eyes out. I had to pause the game and walk off for a few minutes. This is why this game has my favorite story ever.
I’m 56 mate,, totally gutted when I lost Rachel my horse, had her from the outset of the game.
Not even kidding, I just finished the game and cried a little because I knew he was going to die. I tried to play as john and it just didn't feel right. Currently in my feels when I scroll down to the comments, see this and I just start bawling my eyes out. Arthur Morgan is such a good character.
I’m 38 father husband I screamed when I realized my horse was really dead and cried till Arthur died high honor, and I help John escape and as Dutch walked away I cried, like I hadn’t cried in years. This game was truly something magical.
Same
Oh yes that had me crying too, this was the first time i cried from a game, even movies don't get me to that point that easy but this story is just a masterpiece and you really feel it. In my opinion the best story in a game i've ever played, there was really no game wich got me so hard.
The pain in his voice when he said “ I tried, I did… in the end I did” 😭😭
It's still haunts me, even after all those years.
@@marwan4358 it really does…..
Literally the best ending of any game in my fuckin 30 years alive. It was so much like a book
@@thyunholysinner5389 No, it was like a real life experience
@@marwan4358 haunting indeed. Haunting, upsetting, disturbing. Yet at the same time, liberating to know that he passes seeing the light. In a way, he’s okay now, and doing just fine. Even though he’s a fictional character.
This game brought me and my dad both to tears when we played it together for the first time. It’s the only time I’ve seen him cry like that, A+ to Rockstar for bringing a grown man to tears
That when you know rdr2 is a master piece
Thats the Kind of stuff that melts the most men hearts. it has everything a man`s code should be! i just cried for two movies (green mile and lotr3 ending) no game ever could trigger tears but rdr2 managed it^^
I bet that you'll cry again if you play again. This is clearly a masterpiece
Micah: *Shoots Grimshaw*
Dutch: WHO TF IS BETRAYING ME ?
she did side with arthur ig
This was the most illogical point in the ending scene
Didn’t realize javaire doesn’t point his gun until the girl pointed it out.
The actor insisted on javier doing that
Yeah, that was a decision on his actor's part. He didn't feel like Javier was 100% onboard with what was happening based on his character so far, so he just didn't raise the gun.
@@LazzyVamples oh that’s cool.
@@LazzyVamples Yeah, as selfish as it may sound, he probably thought going with Dutch/Micah was the best chance of survival. Which is what everybody in this game is trying to do.
you can also see bills hands were shaking while pointing at arthur
What makes it sad is all the history Arthur and Dutch have, Dutch raised Arthur and for Dutch to just betray him like that for a guy he hasn't known more than 6 months.
At the end of the day Dutch is a narcissist, and Micah does nothing but feed into his god complex with his constant ass kissing
I love john and arthur (especially arthur) but they betrayed dutch first. In a gang you can't disobey orders from the leader and do your own thing even if its morally not right.
A combination of john having a kid (jack) and arthur getting TB made them both realize that being an outlaw is bad. If arthur never got TB i honestly believe he would have fought with dutch till the end and not help other people like the indians or john escape.
There are many chapter 1 and 2 missions before TB where arthur is criticizing and angry at john for leaving the gang. This proves arthurs extreme loyalty to the gang and is why dutch loves him so much.
Later in the story when arthur starts helping John escape (chapter 4,5,6) dutch turns to micah who was the only one (along with bill and javier) he could completely trust in the camp. To complete his 'plan' he needed more people on his side and thats why micah brought in his 2 rat friends (cleet and forgot the other guys name).
Yes arthur and john were doing the right thing but dutch has every right to feel betrayed especially by john and thats why he gives him that look at 17:53. I believe he only shot micah because of his love for arthur not because he wanted to save john or sadie.
Dutch has suspicions of johns mindset from as early as chapter 2 and dutch probably feels like john got into arthurs head and persuaded him to help him instead of the gang.
@@lexdemerindol320 Good theory but nobody "directly" betrayed the gang, Dutch was going crazy and killing that BW girl didn't help much, I'm not saying it's his fault but something clicked in him.
Arthur and other members couldn't help but notice that the Law is gonna catch up and they will die and they didn't all want to die for a madman. Imo the ONLY reason Bill and Javier stayed is because they literally know nothing else but fighting for Dutch but right after the main campaign they ditched and took their chances in Mexico
One of the western themes of the game IMO is the dangerous game of cat and mouse but in this game the cat will always win. Redemption is a long road that goes less traveled, but once you start the path it never ends until the final standoff
@@lexdemerindol320 Jesus never thought of it like that, it makes sense but is still fucked, but what else could you expect from a group of morally confused people falling apart at the seams
I prefer the bad honor go for the money ending with this, because after 20+ years of loyalty Arthur doesn’t care anymore. ‘Dutch, Micah, come get me you bastards’
Now, years later. Watching this. It makes me cry. Hell, this was the most emotional ending in all my game history.
For me it was Amazing Grace at the end of Yakuza 1 back when there was only a Yakuza 1 now it is the ending of Yakuza 6
Brok's funeral at the end of God of War Ragnarok comes close as well
@@jamalnasir5648 💀
Ditto. Something about watching them go through this for the first time
how much is the $40,000 at now?
The editing with this video is/was very superb. Just the way that everyone's playthrough seamlessly switched to each other was well done.
Some random guy: "it's just a game"
Me after beating Red Dead 2 feeling depressed for the next month.
Im jealous that in your case its ONLY ONE month. In my case I feel depressed to this day but its now a bit better than at the first, second,third and fourth playthrough
Me after beating Life is Strange feeling depressed for years.
CAN ANYONE EXPLAIN WHY THE HELL DUTCH DIDNT SAVE ARTHUR IN MOUNTAINS AND KILL MICAH
@@shanewhitewolf9393 Probably his ego. He couldn't even apologise.
That one guy who went back for the money is SUCH A "WHOLE ASS"
“My horse just died”
Me after accidentally running my horses off cliffs like 300 times: yea first time?
I know right that girls fucking dying 🤣
@@mackward57 i laughed so hard when they tried to talk afterwards but were still crying
even my arabian had died multiple times but this death scene hits hard
My horse died while I was in a cut scene with the guy who collects cigarette cards. Hit by the train. I was so mad!
When the a.I permanently die
I’m not ashamed to say this game is the only game that had made me cry. When my horse died, I lost all hope that Arthur was gonna live. Seeing my horse cry in pain in his last dying breaths just broke me. Seeing Arthur die under a great sunrise broke me. This game has an amazing story
@@Denzo116my cousin played this game and was killing everyone and everything that moved! He played it again after seeing Arthur die
i started cryiing when he said goodbye to tilly and cut her off saying she will miss him and didnt stop till about 5 mins after Arthur died im so glad i decided to start being high honor just before arthur got tb literally finished this game 2 hours ago for the first time lol
Unmerited gigachad profile photo perhaps a picture of Chanel or nail polish will fancy your bussy
Miller's death in Metro Exodus had me fighting tears
I loaded my mainsave from 2 missions ago to get my horse kevin back after I ridoe him off a cliff while checked my phone.
XqC raging after making a lobotomite decision and paying for it is my favorite reoccuring gag
The high honour ending is sooo good. I always get so emotional as I've spent time reforming Arthur and then u have to see him die. A good man doesnt deserve to die because of micha
Your lucky some smartass hasnt corrected you misspelling micah, but good comment
even michas death is the cause for johns tragedy in rdr1. the pinkertons tracked john from michas little hideout
Ehhhh arthur isn't really a good man. He did SOME good, doesn't absolve how shitty of a human he was to other people tho. If hell existed, he's definitely going there
@@PotatoMaGobinus I think the moral of rdr2 is second chances. Arthur realised too late he needed to change and didn't have time for a full second chance, that's why he saves John, Abigail and Jack, to give them his second chance. John avenged Arthur by killing micha and then led a calm life (from what I know) until rdr. After his death jack takes over. Sorry for explaining the plot that u probably know. But the reason we love Arthur is because he isn't all bad. He tried to make amends but dies too early. Even before his diagnosis he tries to help out everywhere he can, only robbing and murdering when necessary.
@@ibrahim-bm6rw while that may have helped them find john it‘s not like it was a mystery to find john anyway he literally bought land on his own name and not just in the middle of nowhere right next to blackwater they would have found john anyway no matter if he killed micah or not they have more than enough things to go and find john
Hard to believe it's been over 2 years already. WHAT A MASTERPIECE OF A GAME 😢
Can you play dying light??
@@e0766 never say never.
Hate to be that guy but it hasnt. It came out in october
3*
2018 was a good year
The fact that Arthur refused to abandon his horse when dying says everything about Arthur. He would not abandon his best friend, no matter what.
That made me cry soooo bad
If anything it seemed a relief to Arthur to not have to worry about what would happen to his steed when he kicked the bucket.
Brother. He was truly family at the end. You don't sacrifice yourself for a friend*
Why not? @@FK-xi4tk
Video game it’s a video game
@@Christ42yeah I know! That’s why it’s so beautiful because despite it just being a video game it has the same emotional impact as a movie. It makes you feel things, it hits you right in the heart strings, because you learn to love these characters. After all games are just another form of storytelling, at least games like these with a plotline and stuff not like fall guys or among us, though those games are still cool.
“Thank you.” Arguably the most heart-wrenching moment in video game history
Javier not pointing his gun at John and Arthur during the stand-off is a really good catch. Apparently his actor, Gabriel Sloyer, fought the directors to add that detail to the scene because he felt Javier wouldn't actually want to kill his 'brothers' even at the end.
Actually I noticed something also when Bill was on the other side I also noticed that his gun was away from Arthur as well so he was also shaking a bit.
they still really like Arthur but when dutch made them choose between him and arthur rather then arthur vs Micah they would choose dutch, but i’m glad they put that in
Bruh when the horse died why the female streamers weep over a horse who is just in a game.
@@Ikkamina because the game has a horse bonding system so you only get that scene with the horse if you’ve bonded with it
@@Gentleman534 i had bonding on max but i still didnt cry over a fictional horse
I'm 53 yrs old, been gaming since 1990 or so. This was the best game I ever played, and it's great to see that it touched these gamers like it touched me. I took my time with RDR2 and played it over about 6 months; a most enjoyable half year of my gaming life! Great video, thanks for creating!
I am 55 and can say the same.
I'm 55 started with gaming in the 90s too and yes ... this game is by far the best I ever played. First time cried my eyes out over a game. Heartbraking stories everywhere - told just through letters or remains in cabins. A world that feels real and alive. So many things to explore and to do. After 4 years I started another round a few weeks ago and already I found so many things I missed when I played the first time. This is not just a game - it's more like a mix between game, movie, novel and history lesson. I hope I am going to live long enough to see another game that is able to impress me so deeply.
@@chrissiesbuchcocktaili hope you do allah bless you ❤
I'm 49.. I refuse to finish my story missions.. My Arthur Morgan is alive, with a bit of a cough.
Good for you man I’m 45 and just love it more then ever this game was just everything to me love the whole package of it,I was bawling at end of this game the wife and kids looking at me thinking I’m losing my mind 😊😊gaming since 80s grew up in arcades never lost the love of gaming stayed with me all way through life 👌👍we could be at a lot worse things in life 👏👏
Women Didn’t cry at this
Men Didn’t cry at this
Legends didn’t cry at this
Everyone cried at this
Wait, so if women and men failed to cry at this? Then who is everyone? 🧐
@@shmallkine PLEASE STOP THE CAR I DON'T WANT TO GO TO BRAZIL
@@murdermilitiarecords no
Why does everyone cry for a horse
Lol
@@I.Am.Shadow4o0 mate, I didn’t cry at that part, but if you’re being serious, ur just idiotic
music still gives me chills to this day. This game forever holds a special place in my heart
Love how ONE person got “low honor, help John”
They most likely just did wgat i found fun. Massive shootouts in town. Just kill someonr and see how long you survive. Big problem is it gets you all the way down to bottom honor very fast.
@@ohnoimatrap856 My problem on my first play through I would always get pissed at people who wouldnt say hi to me back 😂
@@brettg744 I got the bear hunter outfit very early and shot anyonr who insulted it.
What we didn't see was anyone who got high Honor but went back for the money. Going back for the money does put a big hit on the Honor, but if it was high enough at the point of deciding it still plays out much like "high Honor, help John"...He fights Micah, Dutch appears, Micah & Dutch leave (separately), Arthur still gets to see one last sunset before he dies (& his totem animal is still the buck).
Yes, it's possible for *both* choices to end with high Honor or low Honor, which makes *four* different endings.
@@MidnightDStroyer I wanted to do it by replaying to mission but when i did my honor had slipped down too much so i got the low honor ending.
I love the fact that XQC thought Arthur would have lived long enough to even spend the money.
Sometimes he could be retarded
Xqc is braindead lol
yeah he's pretty dumb
xqc being stupid? Who would've thought??
I mean, this is the man who said "Is jellyfish, a herb?"
I can’t lie the night I beat this game I cried for hours… I never connected with characters as much, but Arthur had such great character development. The buildup was just wow, this definitely deserved game of the year.
Same...I didn't even intend to finish the story that night, but I just couldn't stop. I finished the last mission at 1 am and cried till 2 😭😭
@@FeynAnimate dude once you get to a certain point near the end, they did good at making it suck you in, so you didn’t experience it in pieces,it makes wanna play more and more and you end up experiencing it whole. Best game I’ve ever played.
Same as me I don't want to beat the game
Yeah it makes u rethink your own life.... This game is just something else ❤
@Feyn, when i had the choice to go back for the money, I took it as a chance to make a future with the money
When he said thank you I cried because I kept the same horse from the beginning 😢
If there was a person I hated more in this game, that was that soab Micah, then Dutch. At the beginning I didn't like Arthur but later I started getting a bond with his character. Only in few games I had this emotional feeling.
Definitely, I played the game for the first time back in beginning of 2022 and I liked Dutch. But as story goes on I started to hate Dutch. Micah was hated the moment I saw him lol felt something bad
Everyone had a sense of relief when they used deadeye and smoked that sorry fuck.
Just curious but what games were those?
I liked Dutch even at the end of the game. But what I never understood is why it took him so long to realize he was wrong. I mean, by the time there was only a handful of his old "family" left, he should have known. Pretty stupid for an otherwise smart guy.
@@Hexenmeister999 I am really wondering the same thing, How in the hell did he just leave Arthur too die like that after all these years. I think it’s combination of Micah and Dutch real personality coming out and showing who he really is
This game's story is DEFINITELY one of if not the best story of all games
and arthur morgan the best maincharacter in the video games
the last time a story got me hooked like this and brought me to cry like a baby was Last of Us, this was quite a few years ago
@@MrRight-xs7xc same, my friend. Same.
No doubt about it. One of the best games I’ve ever played.
@@MegaStevie1990 any other good story games ? After playing the last of us and red dead , no other game has been the same for me
Dude that one guy with low honor was so confused.
i dont think he got the point of the game
@@00mints Yeah I can't understand how someone could reach the end with low honor. I love going full psycho in most games but I couldn't bring myself to do it here. It didn't feel right
@@00mints
He thought he was playing GTA and killing NPCs meant nothing.
I mean bad ending and good ending exist long before RDR2 and RDR2 Cleary show that it has good and bad ending before you end it so i'm really confused why is he mad seens it was obvios from the start that he would get the bad ending
Yeah, XQC’s personality is very straightforward. He did nothing but rob, kill, and do main missions, picking each and every least honorable option.
In one of the cutscenes Arthur says: face my grave to the sunset so i can watch it and remember all the good times with my friends.... he died watching the sun set
So many moments in this game that give you an emotional punch in the guts. The deaths of Sean, Lenny, Hosea and Keiren. The Tuberculosis diagnosis. The characters in this game are just incredible. Kudos to the writers who gave us so many friends in the game.
I've played good games twice before, but it's probably up to 7 playthroughs of RDR2 now.
One scene that almost equals in the "God damn this is a hard one..." department, is if you have high honor and helped the Priest and the Sister out during Chapter 4, later in the game after a mission with Charles and some army dude (I forgot the exact mission and details) gets on a train, you'll have a talk to the Sister of the church, and Arthur legitimately admits he's dying of TB and he's afraid, he goes from a goofy, blow it off demeanor to a completely broken man by the end of the scene. You see his guard fall for the first time for real in the game, and they executed the timing great.
I'm on my 4th Arthur won't even get sick this time around
@@Blueridgebully good thing he doesn’t actually get sick until Chapter 6
@@Wildlink123 That's actually the very first time you see Arthur vulnerable, as well as admitting it.
I took notice of that scene myself, he even actually said he's scared.
I don't think he was scared of dying, he's just scared of how he'll be remembered, and what will happen to those he loves he'll have to leave behind.
John, little Jack, Sadie
That's why he told John to run, and asked Sadie to make sure they all run.
He's lost respect for Dutch, Dutch is just a loose cannon at this point
I have completed the game once. Now i'm aiming for my version of a perfect play through. Restarted about 5 times now.
The last ride made me cry like a baby because I had Arthur’s death spoiled for me so I prepared for that the entire run but I wasn’t expecting his last ride to hit so hard and it threw me off
same, someone spoiled it for me and so as soon as I went into the cinematic and that song started playing I cried for the WHOLE last ride, which is the whole song, ffs
@@My.Darkling lol same here man, you got high honor too?
@@braedentrebell3718 yep, I made sure to say howdy to everyone every time I visited Saint Denis just in case, haha
@@My.Darkling lmao I was doing at ever since I got his diagnosis, even though chapter 6 is designed to boost honor as long as you aren’t an asshole
Same thing happened with me. I don't understand why people feel the need to spoil video games endings. I was just rushing to get it over with because I was mad that I knew ultimately what would happen, and then that last ride hit me. Took my breath away. 😭
This made me cry because we did so much with Arthur. Arthur had such a legacy, we bonded with him, the more we played the more attached to him as a character we were. It felt as if Arthur was more than a person, just a soul looking for redemption. Having him die watching the sunset means he didn’t want to spend his last seconds with his eyes closed accepting his fate, and he made the best if those last seconds, using all the strength his body had left to watch the sunrise. RIP Arthur.
Im crying just thinking about this
I love this comment, here's some interesting lore for you: Early in the game, Arthur was asked how he wanted to be buried. He said to face him west so he could watch the sunset. If you get this ending, he dies facing East watching a sunrise, indicating he had achieved true redemption from his old ideas.
Losing Arthur felt more personal than any other game. We fed him, clothed him, did his chores, and even fucking BATHED him. lol We WERE him... I believe this game straight up helped raise an entire generation of gamers. Most of us were not the same by the end of this game.
I’ve never cried over a game or a movie
Until Red Dead 2. I’ve never been so emotionally invested in a game or movie or tv series until RDR2.
Arthur kind of reminded me of my dad. Rough and tough on the outside but always showed his love when it was needed.
Arthur's death was the only time a game character that made me cry
What about Joel?
@@indieoconnell4616 I honestly didn't care that much because I didn't play last of us 1
It was Dom from Gears of War 3 for me
@@indieoconnell4616 TLOU2 was dogshit
@@Taschip hey it's his opinion
I pray that I could play this ending for the first time again.
So powerful, so outstanding. This game is perfect
It's the best game I ever played but it's not perfect. Guns not being equipped after you get off ur horse is particularly annoying. Definitely a masterpiece tho
Shot out to xQc for showing me the worst ending imaginable. Had no idea this one existed. He must've really done some F'd up Sh*t in the whole game to get this result😂🤷♂
Either way, Arthur dies horribly on low honor. A knife in the back or a shot in the head. But yes, going for money on low honor must be the worst ending.
shot out? uhh you gonna shoot him or uhh
@@littlejohnnymarston too much mayo in your comment son
He just making the worst decision even you did have high honor and choose for the money I think the ending is still the same as xqc had
@@izmi2938 no theres another one if you still have high honor after chosing to save the money. Micah will just walk away and arthur dies "peacefully", without getting stabbed
Never been ashamed about crying during video games, but holy hell no other game made me cry this many times. RDR2 is more than just a game, it is truly an art that needs to be treasured.
Man, as many times as I’ve played through this and seen the endings, it still makes me well up. This game is an absolute masterpiece.
It most certainly is!
Yes I was thinking same. Watching people play the ending gave me goosebumps. Epic games qish I could play it again for the first time. I rushed it, gutted lol
Seeing arthur getting shot by micah and Micah laughing after is even more painful than seeing arthur drew his last breath
That felt insulting, maybe that's why It's low honour version. And going back for the money is even worse.
@@Gliding-Admiral whoever chooses the money over saving john
Have no souls
@@Gliding-Admiral that's the point. If you have low honor, you did bad things. It's abrupt and violent and micah ends arthur in such a bloody way, obliterating arthur as a person. Low honor Arthur is a bad, bad, BAD person, and he gets no last words, no final quips. Birds and wolves feast on his corpse and he is forever forgotten except by those he terrorized
@Nyanderthal what ending did you get
@Nyanderthal ok
And the most incredible thing is that in a conversation at the camp, Arthur is asked how he wanted to die and he replies: I want to die watching the sunset.
Thanks for the great work Rockstar.
@@henriquediniz9240 it is poetic though. His whole life, he thought he isn't worthy of anything and sunset means the day is over. Yet when he died, he watched sunrise, a new beginning, not for himself, but for John, hopefully.
Watching this is bringing back how much this game upset me at the time, i was going through a break up and playing this just after i broke up with my ex, this was released and it was my own way of getting over my ex, this game hurt me more than she did the way arthur was treated. Cant believe how much this story still gets to me.
To this day I always make sure to visit Arthur's grave if I'm in the area. Charles buried him in such a nice spot you can stay there for ages
It was charles who buried him btw
@@blopplop1568 and it was Arthur doing the mocap for Mary XD
Edit: in that scene
I can never find it
@@jakestan1185 find what
@@jakestan1185 it's by the weird house that looks like a hobbit house. It's just above it on the cliff
Even though i finished RDR2 a while ago, watching this brought all the feels back. The story and dialogue in the game was the best ive played, for me it was all about the real detail spots. Some might disagree but i think the game is a work of art. It was worth waiting for, and worth every minute i put into playing it.
Fax after watching this I decided to replay the game
Totally agree its beautiful game
I dont see how ANYONE would disagree with that statement, this game it's something else man, true masterpiece
This video game had better dialogue writing than a considerable amount of movies. This was like playing a movie, to every little detail. Whoever directed this games cinematography and writing deserves an award.
I love XQC's logic that Arthur didn't have any family or friends to make helping John worth it, so his best logical conclusion is to spend an absurd amount of money that he won't even live long enough to even hold or make a life worth living, seemingly forgetting the game made it ultra clear that Arthur was going to die soon no matter what happened. Not only that, but he gets ENRAGED that he died after choosing the most logically stupid option at that moment. His mind genuinely is an enigma.
Indeed XQC was absolutely funny to think as if Arthur would still live longer if he goes after the money (knowing that, back then, TB was incurable and antibiotics doesn't exist yet.)
I don't even if that dude is faking anymore or is it real
he wasn't angry that arthur died if you were there for the stream he was angry the he was getting death threats and was getting told to kill himself because of the ending he got
@@I_hate_you_8--D I don’t think anyone condones that kinda crap when we’re talking about games here. It’s hostile and obviously XQC doesn’t deserve that.
That being said, it would take an (in my opinion) unreasonable amount of detachment from the text to just shrug and really think nothing of a choice like that. The only way I would concede that someone doing that ending would be believable within the context of the story, is if the player believes Arthur to actually be that kind of man. And that’d be valid! That’s why the option is there.
The valid criticism I empathize with, at the root of that unnecessary hostility, is that of XQC (and some other low honor players’) unthinking detachment from the game. When the literal entirety of the game has been about Arthur finding himself able to be redeemed *despite* his past actions, denying him that redemption is kinda going against the name of the game, no?
Also, if I may, I find it a little ironic that we’re talking about how people shouldn’t tell others to “Roblox” themselves, when you have *that* as your profile picture.
@@TerranPersoid725 on this account I usually go to pedo accounts or videos of animal abuse and tell people to Roblox them selves but I sometimes comment on other videos too
And that's how they find John and the sad part is John and Abigail only got three years of actually being married and settled down before he was killed
Cried in the playthrough and came here to cry again...
I sobbed even more this time…Arthur truly was a good man.
Me too
@@ariyaturner3374 same. Take care fellow player
Same same same 😭😭😭😭
Brought back so many great memories
it's cool how the game goes from you thinking "oh just a stupid cowboy game" to the best story in all of video game history
Edit: that was at least what i was thinking when i first played it because i'd never seen anything about the game
SO DAMN TRUE!!
not stupid
I started the game not wanting to play Arthur, or really liking him that much, man, what a game
Literally nobody thought that, not even when it was released bruh
We're talking about a Red Dead entry not "Call of Overwatch: Infinite Creed 7" here.
@@taco8077 .... i did..... i knew NOTHING of read dear redemption 1 ok?!?!
I think we can all agree that in every series, the ending is ALWAYS the worst part.
Ikr
I didn’t finish the game because the disc got corrupted and when I saw the ending on TH-cam I was for real crying
No I dont agree because mk 11 in the middle of the story Scorpion gets killed by D'vorah
Gta 5 ended pretty well
Yeah it's boring as fuck.
Hits me now still and on every single playthrough. Only played through at least 20 times.
My first ever playthrough: I held out hope until right up the buck walked away. Then I knew it was over. Death/spirit animal retrieved his soul and went home.
Having not played RDR I didn't know how the endings worked, so when it said "A few years later" I was like "Really?!? Did Rains Fall...?" Then John spoke. I was in a bad evil mood as John for a while. John didn't care. Until I got more into playing John then I finally calmed down IRL. I wanted Micah though... AND Dutch. I though Arthur was like a son to him. And he said Arthur was the type to be a traitor. HA! Says the narcissist.
The way everyone lit up Micah with them x’s shows just how good of a job Rockstar did at making us hate him.
even the voice actor for Micah didn't like Micah
@@kitieriwhite7758 this is so weird for me cause my name is Micah.
I don’t trust people named Micah after playing rdr2
@@donkeykong2699 but my name is Micah.
Facts
Never cried at the end of a game as much as I did at the end of this one..... MASTERPIECE...
“In the end Micah…. Despite my best efforts to the contrary… it turns out I’ve won”
Best ending to a story in gaming. Hands down.
But he died
I just finished my first playthrough of RDR2 right now and cried when my horse died and when Arthur died. I knew the ending of this way before and I still cried, absolutely legendary game.(I am 12)
It's funny seeing all the different looking Arthurs via cuts.
LMAO right?
Well, it’s the end of Arthurs story’s, not the whole one. We ain’t finished yet Bois 😔.
You mean, BOAHS?
@@_so1ius yes 😔
'Just you left is it?'
'Yeah...Just me.'
@@BlueSpeedy69 epic
Can’t wait to cry in RDR3 lol
"You don't get to live a bad life and have good things happen to you."
This is my FAVORITE, FAVORITE game of all time!! Just like the gamers in the video, I cried so hard when he passed away at the mountain when I played, and I cried just as much watching this video. Maybe its a game, but the connection you get to Arthur doing the gameplay, is insane, which makes his death even more sad. I really felt like I lost a dear friend. Rockstar did such an indescribable good job with RDR2. In my opinion, no game will ever compare with this one. Truly blessing! How I wished he would't have died.. Imagine the story we would've gotten, when it was all over, if he survived
This part honestly wasn’t as heartbreaking as the part where Arthur meets the Sister one last time before she heads to Mexico. When Arthur looked dead at her and said “I’m afraid” with a shaky voice and bloodshot eyes like if he was holding back from crying really had me bawling.
Wait how can i meet the sister? I didn't come across her in my playthrough
@@caocao7925 I think she was at the train station
@@caocao7925 you meet the sister in a high honor and meet reverend swanson in low honor
@@caocao7925 you have to do several side missions in saint denis about the sister and church and stuff or Swanson will be there
That part made me realize that I was not ready for the rollercoaster of emotions coming my way in the ending of the game. I had to take a break for a few hours before finish it, still crying like a baby when that song hit after the rescue of Abigail.
The fact Dutch and Arthur had been together for almost 20 years or so. Having Arthur as his sort of second hand man to then just be betrayed like that really hits hard 😔
Sides with someone who's been with them for only months.
This game telling us really friend doesn't metter how long friend us could be 20 years could be 1 year duch show his barstad
We have done anything for him
Dutch and Micah are rats
"I gave you all I had"
That line broke me
it broke me
Tears in my eyes when he said that. Dutch was like his father or something...
Me too!! That one broke the Levee for sure! And I'm typically not a crier, but that hit hard after all the days and nights I spent getting to know Arthur and the rest of the gang. What an amazing experience this game was.
I'm a COD gamer through and through.
Since trying RDR2 last month I haven't been able to stop playing RDR2.
This game has changed me so much. Even I had a tear in my eye when Arthur horse was hurt and don't get me started when Arthur looked out to the horizon.
Absolutely epic story and game play ❤❤
99.9999999% chose to follow their heart and help John.
00.0000001% chose the money and only did it to see what happens.
I went for the money because I was low honor my entire playthrough and then in chapter 6 got up to high honor and when faced with that decision, I remember audibly saying "nah, outlaw for life". Also I played the original so I knew John survived whether I went with him or not. I didn't mind the ending but high honor, help John is definitely the better ending. The knife fight with Micah is cooler than the fist fight though
@Nyanderthal yeah I had that confusion too
I went for the money just because I didn’t want Micah to get it
Dude ive started the game again like 4 times and i cant bring myself to go for the money
@Nyanderthal same here
The whole Journey of arthur was truly artwork
From beginning to end we really get more attached to this fictional character
So much so that the idea of him slowly dying was unacceptable
And then theres markiplier who constantly gives arthur and Schwoomple multiple concussions
Markiplier is a manchild tbh. His RDR2 playthrough sucks. He didnt even finish the game because he got spoiled about the ending. Just leave him with his 10 y/o audiences whoe enjoy watching him screams all the time
@@kingf6766 umm I take it you don't like markiplier?
@@kingf6766 you sure hate a lot on somebody with 29.7 million subscribers, and I'm pretty sure he has a wide spread of an audience. He does videos in term of if people enjoy it or not and he determines that in views and likes. If his audience didn't like it, he does something else.
@@kingf6766 Also, so what if he is a manchild, he is not ashamed to show it and he has fun doing what he does which is difficult for many content creators
The masses have been proven to be dangerously incompetent time and time again for thousands of years.
When people say "It's just a game", you can show this part of this game. Better than any movie.
It really was like I lost a member of my family.
Same, i felt lost after the epilogue
It's just a game.
@@stopmotionless262 watch the video or play the game then! 😂
Bruh you haven't seen a lot of movies
@@despacitodaniel801 Maybe, maybe not, but the fact is it’s a great scene, and some movies miss the attachment you have when playing the game like it’s your own movie.
This was fun to watch. I used to be a gamer, but I had to stop for personal reasons. Like being so hooked up in a game, that sometimes I called in sick for work. RDR2 is one of the first games I have played in many years. I was pretty late. Bought it for one year ago. Really great game, the story, the graphics and also everything you can discover in the game. I'm still playing it. I tried playing it online, but it felt so empty. Anyways, I have seen so many people cry at the end of this game. Teenagers to older people, like 70yr old.
The relationship arc between john and Arthur is beautiful. At the beginning of the game Arthurs blasts John for leaving the gang and by the end of the story all Arthur wants is for John to get away 😭😭😭
Bro I didn't know they were cutting onions right next to me 😭😭😭😭 as if I couldn't love Arthur more
It’s weird to describe my reaction to Arthur’s death. I wasn’t sad, deep down maybe i was. But the only feelings i felt was hate, and dissatisfaction with not being able to kill Micah. So for the entire prologue of the game, that anger never went away. Even after killing Micah, it felt too easy to let him die so quickly. I was filled with anger and rage and it wasn’t until i sat down as John and red all of Arthur’s journals that i finally broke down into tears. I finally got to grief for a fictional characters death. I finally was able to feel at ease over his death. I guess, at the end, my blind rage and hatred still ended up costing John’s family and potential future they may have had. Making feel even worse knowing I was more then happy to go after Micah knowing the outcome of the first game.
Happened the exact same thing to me I was SO MAD during the final mission that I could only think abt killing Micah
Yeah same here,,
I was so mad Arthur dont kill Micah. I like the epilogue but I would prefer killing Micah as Arthur, even if Dutch had killed him would be better for me but I understand that they had to save him for the epilogue, I got the shotgun to shoot him in the face but sadly the cut scenes didn't let me
@@g23g psychopath 😂😂😂😂
@@phil393 lmao i mean we go around killing O’Driscoll‘s by the thousands, hundreds if not thousands of law man, and hundred of thousands of innocent NPC’s by the time we beat the game lmao 💀 Like i’m sure Rockstar intended for the game to feel more realistic, but killing is what u do from start to finish lmao
Arthur is the ONLY video game character I've ever teared up for. That alone tells you how incredible this story line really is.
Greatest game ever, and it's not even close!!!!
Lol know the difference between greatest and best. Rdr2 isn't even close to being greatest game of all time. Some of the greatest games of all time are gta v, Minecraft, last of us, witcher 3, legend of Zelda ocarina of time, etc
@@yazeed_joestar I've played them all except Minecraft and 3 of the ones you mentioned are in my all time top 5, but none of them come even close to rdr2, it's embarrassing that you think they're better. The fact you have Minecraft on here means you just shot your credibility right in the foot.
Rdr2 It is the best, the greatest ever, it's whatever you want to call it, it's no.1, it's irreplaceable.
@@atourdeforce I literally said know the difference between greatest and best. I never said those are "better" than rdr2 lmao. I just said they're "greater". Rdr2 is also the best game I've ever played. But that doesn't make it the greatest game of all time. U or me cannot decide which game is greater than the other one. Its not subjective
@@yazeed_joestar You're talking like greater cannot be subjective there is literally zero difference between best or greatest. It's word choice, so I literally have zero clue why you seem so hung up on a definition that means the exact same thing either way. It is the greatest game ever, it is the best game ever, there is zero difference in either meaning except someone might chose to use one instead of the other.
If someone thinks it's the greatest game ever that is absolutely no different to someone thinking its the best game ever.
@@atourdeforce valid, I just finished the game man and this is a game that cannot be replicated, the story, the interaction, wild life like its just a collection of diamonds that cannot be done again at least in my eyes. My experience with this game, I will never feel it with another one. On my second playthrough rn
The part that got to me was when Arthur was riding back to camp for the last time with that yellow film and conversations in the background
bro i gotta give you props, you do amazing transitions between gameplay with other people’s reactions. most reaction channels will show one persons full reaction and then the next one repeating the same scene, but you show ALL OF THEM through these super smooth transitions. really making me feel the feels with these guys. nice job man.
Not gonna lie when the Pinkertons arrived and he yelled “this is agent Ross with the Pinkerton detective agency, put your guns down!” i legit got goosebumps because for the first time it really felt like it was all over for them.
for those who don't know,in the high honor ending aurtur sees "stag" which is a symbol for honor
I will always look up to Arthur. He’s a real man and does what needs to be done when no one else would❤️ never been more attached to a video game character but shit, LONG LIVE ARTHUR
And friends i have dont understand how you can get so emotionally invested "its only a game" , arthur is hands down one of the best characters i have played as, that ride he takes back to camp after saying goodbye to abigail and sadie one last time always gets me
“Wow! A good ending”
Edgar Ross: “Hello There!”
jack marston:let me introduce myself
@@daddowastaken7543 true lol 😂
is this a red dead reference? I didnt playb the first game
@@zen2608 yep
You can always blame Sadie for gettinf John killed
The best story I have ever played. “And in the end, I tried, I did.” Still gets me every time I replay it
The Rock Of Defiance where you are put to the test and tears roll down your face.