Why women should FAST differently than men? | Dr Pal
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 มี.ค. 2023
- The biggest mistake in intermittent fasting is women not listening to their body and changing the fasting technique according to their menstrual cycle.
---
Dr. Palaniappan Manickam MD, MPH
Internal Medicine | Gastroenterology | Epidemiologist
---
For Tamil videos, please subscribe to my Tamil channel: / @priyapal_vibes
Like us on Facebook: / dr-pal-102856268051377
Follow us on Instagram: / dr.pal.manickam
Follow us on Twitter: / drpal_manickam
Join us on Telegram: t.me/Ask_Doc_Pal
Email: askdocpal@gmail.com
If you want to donate to AISHWARYAM TRUST, here are the details.
Website: aishwaryamtrust.com/ - บันเทิง
Dr, super video. Very concise and complete version. Thank you. Can you pl talk about fasting for women who have hit menopause
Dr, kindly enlighten on fasting during perimenopause and menopause
As there is no progesterone, fast with the help of estrogen and listen to your body and tone it down when you need it intermittently.
@Dr pal I am trying to donate in aiswaryam trust from Australia but my amount gets refunded in a couple of days.
I have the same question
Super info doctor!! What about those ladies who have hit menopause?
Nowhere a woman would get this kind of information that too for free. You are just fabulous Dr. Pal. Respect 🙏 Wishing you only the best
I totally agree to this. Thank you so much for sharing.
This is so good information, thanks for sharing, Dr Pal. Love all your videos 😊
I agree
Hi, I was 89kg and after listening to ur videos I started intermittent fasting and now I am 63kg. Also my TSH was 11 and now it came down to 3.5 . You are truly an inspiration and May God bless you and ur family 🙏🙏
Sis.. could u pls tel me ur eating window... nd how many months u followed?
@@priyarachel2804 Hi , 9am to 5 pm my eating window. At the beginning I stopped eating rice completely , and coffee from 2cups to 1. It took only 7moths to achieve the goal. Eating dinner earlier is the key.
Please let me know how old are you
@@bhsishtla I am 46😍😍
@@elizabathminoo9528 😘
His attitude has got a positive aura. Keep up the good work Sir ... We need doctors like you
Hi sir.. you're videos inspired me and i started 13 to 16 hours of fasting and i loss 5 kgs in 2 months. Even my gynecologist felt surprise with my weight loss.. Thank you so much sir..😊
Plz tell me what you were eating
Yes please share diet during eating window
Thank you so much doctor for bringing this up. My wife recovered from pcos with fasting. we saw your weight loss journey video 2 years ago and started IF and longer fasts.. within 5 months, all the cysts were gone and her periods regularised which surprised the gynec as well!! now we have a 9 month old kid😊 Can't thank you enough for introducing us to this healthy way of living
What a testimony to his hardwork.. Really happy for you
Babykku😘
Can you please mention which video is it , in specific ?
Awesome.
congratulations 😊
BRILLIANT! Hardly anyone even acknowledges that fasting for women is different! We need more doctors who talk about nutrition like Dr Pal, instead of making our entire nation pill happy!
This man is just WOW. I can listen to him for hours and never get bored. I've been doing IF for more than 2 months now and I've never been this healthy. I can easily do18-6 so I am sticking to it. on period days I as doing 16-8 and still feeling good. I am in love with this life style . thank you so much for all of this knowledge and humor . You are a gem.
What is your diet
My gynecologist never explained in this way like the way dr pal did
Thanks alot
I usually get cravings during periods (1 to 5) days of the cycle. The ladies have to agree with me that the chocolates and ice cream helps to ease those menstrual cramps 😊
I do agree
Agree.I thought we should never fast on periods days
Yes
Yes same here
Ya true. I too crave sweets during periods. But they tell me not to have sweets then.
This is the first time I'm hearing about progesterone and fasting. Thank you Dr. Pal! 🎉 First 14 days, I can fast, exercise and have all sorts of goals accomplished. My body and brain is in a " Bring it on" mode. But the second 14 days are challenging particularly on an emotional level.
I agree
I agree
agree...but once I started doing yoga, pranayama, and meditation my mental health as well as physical health improved...now I feel much better throughout the month...if you wish even you can give it a try...
During fasting can we drink water
Yes, water doesn't contain any calories. Actually, for the intermittent fasting to be more effective, one should drink a lot of water @@moviesworld8089
Dear Doctor,
So inspired and motivated by all your videos, Doctor. I have started intermittent fasting and already feel so happy and good about my wellness journey.
Your videos are a pure blessing to me. God bless you, Doctor, with all the wellness in the universe.
When I started intermittent fasting some 7 years back, nobody agreed this. But after ppl like you, they are now realising what I said. Thanks for voicing out this to many.
When I continued 16 hours fasting during phase 3 (day 21 to 28), I had trouble sleeping properly. Now I understand better on how to follow IF. Thank you doc !
I feel very tired just few days before periods starts. I thought it's something else but now you have explained it very clearly. Thanks doc
Wooowww doctor!!!!!! It's amazing to listen to ur speech that clears all our doubts which means a lot to a common women. U r addressing each n everything we face in our day to day life... Thank u is not enough for ur hardwork. Keep rocking dr🎉
Thank you for being so precise. Dietitian simply says do 16:8 fasting but this week it has been quite hard. Now I get it
Thanks for this video and everything in this series Dr. Pal. This explains a lot of things scientifically. My husband and I started our intermittent fasting journey together while I was close to my luteal phase. I was finding it difficult to keep up the fasting window and kept saying I was hungry for 3 weeks and my husband wanted me checked with a doctor since he thought I had some bad bacteria in my gut. Now, we know this might be normal after all. Had him watch this video as well.
Excellent content sir. I do 16:8 fast regularly. It has become my life style. But now I understood why I am unable to do so in those days of the month. Thank you very much for the valuable information Dr. Pal
Oh God, such detailed description! Thank you Dr. Pal. You are a sweetheart ❤
Protect this doctor at all costs🙏🏻
First 20 days i follow strict diet, intermittent fasting, but before my menstrual cycle i crave for food and eat whatever I see just can't control at all. This video is very helpful to understand the reason for craving for food.
Thank you Dr Pal! After doing IF, actually my cravings before cycle has completely disappeared. Wish I had known this eating pattern before. IF has saved me from eating all junk food n switched to clean eating without any effort 😊
God bless you . Thank you for your unconditional love and support for your viewers. Your video was an eye opener.
Hey Pal, I just love all your videos that helped my husband reversing his fatty liver. I am also undergoing fasting with him and I feel emergetic😁 A big thanks for making an awareness towards all critical health issues. Best wishes🎉
Thanks you sir it is so comforting to hear your speech about hormonal cravings which is absolutely what most womèn experience. I usually do 16 hour fasting with ease on my normal days but cannot even follow 10 hrs fasting during the last phase of my cycle .From now on will follow your advice . Could you pllease do a video to overcome perimenopausal signs and symptoms for women over 40.Thanks again
Such a thoughtful video. Very generous of you, Dr. 🙏💐
Beautifully explained....just loved it....thank you doc
It’s been 15 days since I started serious intermittent fasting, and my family are already noticing a difference in my weight ! Thank you for these videos, I feel very inspired and motivated after watching your videos !
me too
My family is not allowing me to follow intermittent fasting and it's so difficult
@@-zmxuxtxhxuz-709 yes, I understand, my family also resisted at first, but I was very strong and fought and stuck to my resolution. My family also said that I should eat everything and burn it off by exercising !
After seeing the results, they have stopped pestering me, but they still say from time to time-
“today you can skip your fasting for one day… one day is okay,
now you have lost a lot of weight, now stop this fasting,
If you don’t eat today, I will also stay hungry because of you, so just for today..eat for me, at least eat a fruit.. or some gajar ka halwa I have made healthy which is sugar free as it is made with with jaggery”
oh it’s relentless….! It’s just our Indian mindset… you should not fall prey to their emotional blackmail and stay strong! All the best !
How many months did it take for you to lose so much weight?
@@ankitamal8647 hi, so now it’s been approximately about 3 months, that I am following intermittent fasting. I usually eat from 11am to 5 pm. I usually try to do it everyday, but sometimes during the week on any occasions, I can break my fast… but because of following this fasting everyday, I automatically don’t feel hungry, and even if I have to eat, I eat in very small quantity. It becomes natural to not eat, our body gets used to it… it’s harder for the first few days, but if you stick to a routine, it will be easy. Though I eat literally anything and everything in my eating window, which is wrong… I eat chips, pizza, cakes, ice cream, biscuits, everything… but the quantity is reduced and I am losing weight despite of eating everything. I think Dr Pal is right he says, “what” you eat is less important than “when” you eat.
Hai doc,
U r amazing ,
I have hypothyroidism,
I was 125 kg,
Coz of u ,I have started intermittent fasting, following 3 weeks ,now I'm 119 kg,
Happy to see the result,
Thank u for ur continues videos insisting the society to be free out of disease,stay blessed doc
Hey! I have hypothyroidism too. What was your eating window and did you skip breakfast
Hi Mam even I am also suffering from hypothyroidism what was your eating window.
My question is about when to take medicine? I take it early in the morning. Should I take it in my eating window?
I as a doctor myself have been practicing INTERMITTENT FASTING(16-8) since more than 8 years. Have regular menstrual cycles and I maintain circadian rhythm as well 😊 very concise video loved it👌💯
How do u maintain circadian rythym
Dear Doctor ,
Thank you so much for your great work. I really admire the method that you use to educate your audience. It is so much fun to learn and entertain yourself at he same time.
Can you please do a video for women 65 and over. Presently, there are a great number of us out there who are blessed and able to live a healthy life.
I am been fasting for a few years and I love it.😀
Could you please tell me😢,,during period how can i even fasting?s we need to drink a good amount of water.
Please reply🥲
@@fawziatasneem9018we can drink water during intermittent fasting
@@fawziatasneem9018 If u don't feel good in periods days, then don't do IF. Listen to your body!
So useful . Simple and concise to understand. Thank you 🙏.
I'm so glad Dr. Pal made this video. This actually takes the pressure off for a woman to be eat/fast perfectly every single day. Listening to the body helps and also controls from over indulging or having backfire from resisting too hard.
IF has really helped stabilize blood sugars and regulate cycles. And best part is it is a habit now, not like a diet that crashes in 2 weeks. I thank you sincerely for your videos. They help a lot!
Please make a video for older women in post menopause phase of life. Thank you for all your videos so far.
Thank you Dr.Pal for sharing this. You are true to your profession and passion❤❤❤❤
Great video❤ super concise and enlightening, thank you doctor!
Very true doctor especially we get sweets cravings. Thanks for this awesome enlightening video. Before menstrual periods it is bit difficult and we were waiting for this video for a long time thanks doctor
i recently discovered dr pal's youtube channel and his attitude towards things and his content are a gem. Just wanted to mention that i as a jain have been taught fasting and not eating in the night or as we call it ratri bhojan tyaag right from the ripe age of 4 which is quite common in jain house holds. Every year lakhs of jains do 1-2 to 8 and even 31 days of continuous fasting and the oldies especially follow ratri bhojan tyaag. I'm lucky to discover dr. pal who is guiding us towards a better life style using our own culture and not advising "multiple small meals" as advised by other doctors and nutritionist. Proud Indian and a Proud Jain
You are amazing. Very very simple and clear explanation. Thank you Doc🙏
Very useful video DR. Pal. Thank you. Hands off🎉
Your way of explaining is commendable🎉
When I used to do IF .. my cycles got delayed so much that I left it😢
Also i have tiny fibroids in my uterine cavity
Please do a video for women above 50 years who have reached menopause life what and how should the fasting window be
This is absolutely amazing, Dr. Pal. I always tell myself that every month I will do fitness as soon my fourth day period is over. Where I am fully energetic and I do jogging, dance, fitness, diet. Then slowly kazhudha thenju katterumbu aagidum. I used to feel why I am not able to stick to one routine properly.
And this video blew me away. It make absolute sense.
And now I can mindfully plan my diet routine.
Thank you Dr. Pal.
Thank you for that nice explanation doctor. This is really educative. God bless your service💐
I too had irregular periods since my puberty. I was on medication. But nothing worked. After started watching your videos n follow intermittent fasting i get the period in 28 days cycle. Yes as u said i too have sugar cravings like anything before my periods..
Thank you sir n you are truly a blessed soul to help millions of ppl like me. Long live doctor🎉
Hi, what exactly did you do other than IF?
IF worked well. 12-16 hours fasting period everyday.. I reduced my weight 5kgs over the period of 8 months… It’s amazing Dr.Pal …
Very very informative.. thank you Dr pal.god bless you always.
Very useful and informative video.. Thank you so much Dr. Will surely follow 😊
Dr. Pal, you are a gift to your audience and patients. Thank you for all that you do for us and your generosity in curing and helping people. As a teacher, I can tell that you are an excellent teacher who is brilliant at explaining technical medical terms in layman terms. I am not sure if you already have a video on the relationship between high body fat percentage, hypothyroidism and estrogen dominance. I am really hoping that you could give us some insight on how to lose weight and eat right to manage hypothyroidism and high estrogen levels due to high body fat percentage.
I would like to understand this as well please
Thank you doc for this thoughtful message to the women out here …. I’m sure all of us are able to relate to it. Keep doing this good job and god bless your family!
Very helpful n it's informative thanks Dr. Pal
Thank you Dr.Pal from each corner of my heart. I was feeling so down and low bp of 102/59 and craving for salty food yesterday that I came looking for you. I had enough chips. Now I know it's because it was my 21st, period due on the next 9 days. Thank you so much for sharing such useful. information.
Thank you Dr. Pal. It was so easy to understand. Could you please also do a video on Peri Menopause and Menopause for us women who have hit 45 and have irregular menstrual cycle? Much thanks.
Dr Pal, you are awesome! Can you also put a video for peri-menopausal women and IF? I am currently doing 16:8 for the past month along with yoga and some bharathanatyam. I have seen huge difference and already reduced 4 lbs. But I want to make sure I am doing this right in my rhis stage of life.
Wow Dr Pal ......you are the best . Brilliantly explained 👌🙏
Wow, doc hats off to you. Your videos are really motivating. I have started my journey of intermittent fasting from sometime ago, the results I’m seeing are little slow, but I’m seeing them. Hopefully like you said I will be able to improve my hormone profile.
Please give menopausal women a good fasting cycle for their health too. Thank you! As a post menopausal woman my hormonal balance is so jumbled up and no matter how much I’ve tried various healthy changes in diet and in intermittent fasting, I don’t seem to achieve much. Thank you in advance.🙏🏼
Please consider this topic.. my mother could be helped by this..
Dr. pls consider this . Post menopausal women..3 -4 yrs after last period continuing to have hot flashes and other symptoms sometimes . can we do 14 hr fasting?
Sir , please consider this topic
Thank you Dr. Pal. As always, your videos have lot of vital information, simply put for a common man to understand. Can you highlight on hormonal migraines and how to handle them with intermittent fasting or any changes that can help. It’s miserable to go through hormonal migraine. Pls share your expertise. 🙏🏻
I too had but after practicing IF slowly it vanished
Loved this video and the insights shared. Thanks for sharing
Thank you doc for breaking it down to this level. I do practice intermittent fasting but I was not aware of all the detail you touched in your video. Greatly appreciate it. Again thank you very much
Very good explanation. Thank you! What about women who have entered menopause, either naturally or surgically (hysterectomy+bilateral oophorectomy)? Could you please talk about the right way to do intermittent fasting in menopausal women? The dos and don’t?
Love the way you explain things with analogies and in a jovial way…removes the tedium and fear and makes us more receptive…great job, doctor!
Pls advise for menopause women
Yes please! Apart from that, what’s with ladies with irregular cycles like it just starts whenever & randomly? How to manage IF in them?
Hi Doctor. I am a Physiotherapist and try educating ppl on metabolic disorders and intermittent Fasting benefits to get them in control along with regular exercises. Your videos are very helpful for me and my clients as well. They are very inspiring and motivating. Can you make a video on IF during Pregnancy and what is the window period and how safe is it during Pregnancy
If your covering pregnancy, I am lacatating mom, can you as well cover breastfeeding mothers to loose weight but not compromising on milk output. Thanks Dr.Pal
Very informative video Dr. Pal. Thank you 🙏
I am from Andhra Pradesh, India and you are doing a great work ❤. It's a boon for us that you are on TH-cam
4:00 1st 10 days of menstrual cycle 16 hours of fasting
11th to 20 days of cycle 14 hours
10 to 28 days 12 to13 hours
Does day 1-10 start from first day of bleeding? or does it start after the bleeding ends?
@@hirazahid9051 it starts from the day of bleeding, i.e mine starts from 6th of every month so from 6th-15th you have to fast for 16 hours.
May Allah bless Dr. Pal and his family with the best of this life and the next, Ameen! He is 100% correct about PCOS and eating without intermittent fasting and circadian rhythm. Dr. Pal is doing good things!
Dear Dr Pal, I cannot thank you enough for this video. I’ve been too harsh on myself for not being able to fast during 15th to 28th day of the menstrual cycle. Now I understand myself and my body better. I feel I was playing a game without understanding the rules of the game. I can do better now.
Once again a huge thank you and respect for sharing this knowledge 🙏🙏
Hats off to you Dr Pal.... thank you for sharing such a wonderful information...
Yes Cravings happens and used to have 90% dark chocolate to control. Even if I try couldn’t fast for more than 14 hrs, week before my periods.
Recently started intermittent fasting after watching Dr Pal Video. I have reduced 3 kg without any exercise. Thank you very much Pal for your wonderful informative videos. Your videos are changing our eating habit and lifestyle... Continue your great work which helping many people 🎉
how long it took you to loose 3 kg?
@@user-zm4lj1xf7m Around 10 to 15 days
U r literally the God, God bless you with lots of happiness
Very informative and encouraging. Thanks
I'm doing intermittent fasting regularly. I don't see such cravings on my last cycle time. I believe my will power is more powerful than any other thing. I continue my 16:8 fasting the whole cycle. It's doable.
Thanks doc, that you make us to understand our body conditions. Even hereafter, if I crave for sugars, I can make myself clear that it's the mischievous progesterone that does it. 😂
😊
Thank you Dr for this video. Very helpful to understand why we have certain cravings. Is it same for women of age above 40s and 50s and could you please give the best times for fasting? Also could you please let know the best fasting patterns for women undergoing menopause stage?
Watch Dr. Mindy, fast like a girl. Woman over 40+ is differ.
Thank you Dr. Pal
Very informative video.
Very useful doctor. What about people who are in the process of menopause. Hard to remember different timings. May be easy to follow a medium range like 14 hours?
Thank you for the fasting guidance based on women hormones. Very helpful!!
Wow... Really wow... This vedio is very informative and this will helps many women..
Thank you❤
Excellent video differentiating between men and women , please do more of these
Dr Pal, a video on menopause will be greatly appreciated🙏 please include weight-loss, bone-density loss, fatigue issues too in that🙏
Yes
It's essential....
I vote for it.... highly needed
Dr. I can fast 16 to 18 hours on all days except for my days of periods where my menstrual cramps does not allow me stay fasting.. this video putting me in less guilt.. thanks to u and your service.. May God bless you with good health wealth and happiness abundantly..
My doubt is that many days i feel my tummy is so gassy during fasting period.. i ignore and just drink water.. is it fine..
Finally someone made a cycle based video alongside IF!! Thankyou Dr. Pal.
Thank u so much doctr for encouraging us to fast very inspiring. I started my intermittent fasting during covid period I lost 14 kgs nd again was lazy to continue from past 6 months ur video s have motivated me I have started it again 16 hrs nd feeling great I think u should keep inspiring us
Thank you so much for this! Can you shed some light on the messed up circadian rhythms in teen girls, and how it could bring hormonal/metabolic imbalance? I find many young girls are unable to sleep at normal times despite practicing sleep hygiene (no devices, etc), but they are still required to wake up earlier than their bodies can handle, hence they are sleep deprived. This leads to other disruptions in the body. I experienced this myself and ended up with PCOS and other issues.
Is your pcos reduced now or got worse??
Super informative...now I know the correct way of doing intermittent fasting . All thanks to u.. I'm sure it's going to help thousands of females like me... you are doing a great job...keep it up..
Dr. Pal you are a genius ! I do intermittent fasting but on certain days I feel extremely hungry and these are the days which falls on the 3rd phase that you mentioned, I used to curse myself and think my body is acting crazy even after following intermittent for sometime now! Now I totally understand what my body needs and will slightly give in on those special days! Ofcouse no major harm in treating yourself a little special on these days! Thank you for enlightening me! You are a super star and I follow your channel and love your narration & your friends Saravanakumar and Thirupurasundari! Please say hi to them from my side 🤣😂🫣
What a magnificent creativity by God, and when we learn about it all the more we should learn how to safeguard.... thank you for your wonderful explanation....I m already seeing the results 🙏🙏
Yes doc iam able to fast 16hours a day... I have several doubts;
1. How long should we continue 16hrs fasting? After weight loss can we reduce to 10 to 12hrs fasting?
2. Can we take thyroid tablets while intermittent fasting?
Doc, the problem with PCOS as you know is irregular periods. Then how can we stick to this plan when the cycle isn't going to be 28 days everytime. Kindly advise
I've never seen or heard anyone explain such a topic so easily and lovely.
Very beautifully explained Dr Pal. This explains my sweet cravings a week before the menstruation starts.
Day 1 and 2 of my menstruel cycle I have a lot of cravings for carbs . I don’t feel like working. I stop my daily exercises and rest on my sofa doing nothing. From day 3 everything sets back to normal. As you say from day one to day ten 16hrs of fasting is impossible for me the first two days but from day 3 it’s absolutely fine😊
I lost 11 kg in one month and total 14 kgs in 51 days, still few more days to complete 2 months. Started at 95 kgs and currently at 81 kg, target weight is 70kg. I am a Male, 28 and 5’10”. IF has been nothing short of a miracle. To all the people struggling to lose weight, just wanna say don’t give up and keep pushing yourself. “You feel great when you look great”
How? Wat you are?
dr I am trying for 16 hours but I can't do it I keep on feeling hungry I am 45 year female
"The visuals and explanations in this video make it so much easier to understand the importance of a balanced and healthy lifestyle."
Keep spreading knowledge...and more power to you sir ❤️
During periods thr craving for chocolate is very high
Can you please tell us the kind of fasting in menopausal woman ?
As progesterone is not there, you could extend your estrogen phase fasting and listen to your body and modify accordingly
@@DrPal thanks for your response
Very well explained doc..
Just like a teacher🎉
Thank you so much dr. Pal these tips are rare and very effective 🙏🙏
If I do even 12 hours of fasting during my menstruation I feel dizzy and fatigued.