LOL, esp the Kpop fan on the right. To be fair, Blooming does have a poppy vibe, esp the chorus, so anyone jaded on Kpop or generally allergic to pop may have an adverse reaction. These guys should have started with some straight hard rock/metal songs like Moratorium or Puzzle or From Now On - something to pull them out of their musical malaise.
I really hate it when Band-Maid fans seek approval from any mediocre "reactor"... after all you've seen the K Pop garbage these guys react to for a living... I don't know how many coffees they paid to these guys... but I hope it serves as a lesson to Band-Maid fans who decide to throw their pearls to the swine.👍😉
@COTTERO Well, I'm a music addict, so I love all types of music, and I like to tell others about it. If they like it great, if they don't, that's fine too. Everyone has their own musical tastes. As long as they have an open enough mind to give it a try, I'm happy.
I understand why you are frustrated but I don't mind people trying to get the word out about Band Maid, they probably, if sincere, are more let down that we are, if I had the money I would throw coffee at a 100 new reactors, if 95 loved them but 5 hated them, I would be ok with that, these guys don't know what they are talking about...
These guys are getting grift from faint praise to work from an artist with a huge passionate fanbase. Important to insult them at the level where we know they're really good. This increases "interaction". Really cynical grift.
Is normal for non or bad musicians to not appreciate good music. Is like a great joke that passes by to slow people. It happens, is not for everyone. From the start they already had a dismissing tone. Good thing Millions of people have better taste. Whata way to fumble 😂 There's really not coming back from this, at least with Band-Maid fans.
Drumming is not sampled, played live with lots of changes in almost every section of the song. If you can’t tell, oh well🤷♂️ not worth thinking about it 😮
Sigh… my opinion about your opinions is you don’t know what you’re talking about. Countless musicians have done reactions, and analysis, of this song and I’ve never heard any of your criticisms mentioned. I’ve listened to tons of rock and metal in my 58 years and, IMO, this song is a masterpiece. I don’t want, or expect, you to change your minds to appease anyone, though… we will just vehemently disagree on this.
Trying to understand how someone listens to this song and reaches these conclusions is breaking my brain. I suppose there are also people who think the Mona Lisa is trash, but... oh look, a pigeon, gotta run.
Hi from France: So, as soon as a group comes from Japan, their music is... ANIME!!! 😂😂😂😂 Ignorance is like jam... the less you have, the more you spread it... And, by the way, it's not K-pop, it's not Korean, but J-rock...
@@gillesmurat7362 I always piss off when even decent reactors mention anime. It’s a bit stupid in my eyes. Cliche I’d say, like ink dramas a boy always catches a girl. How the heck say Anemone or Unfair game are anime? So narrow minded.
i'm not gonna criticize your opinions.. everyone thinks whatever they want.. but in regard of the guitarrist (kanami) trying to show her skills during the solo that's wrong.. kanami could show off way more but in fact 99% the people are asking for her to do the solos longer.. she always gives her mates the room to shine
BAND AID heals your wounds ... BAND MAID heals your soul. The producers of the Netflix movie KATE thought enough of our MAIDs to include this and the song CHOOSE ME, along with a long cameo of the band, in the movie. No, it is not an anime ... lol.
@@FatTulip. life is unfair game. It’s better to put moratorium on such reactions. Let’s their play be only about us! No hate, no non fiction game, this reaction doesnt have much sense, no thrill. From no on only real existence and future domination.
I don't understand when people complain about guitar tones. Electric guitars can make a wide variety of sounds, and different sounds are used in different genres and by different individuals. It doesn't make sense to expect a hard rock song to sound like a pop rock song.
Band aid? You two are the ones who really need help and a single band-aid isn't enough to cure you. You can have your opinion and it can be negative, it doesn't matter... but the title is enough to know what two pieces of meat, with eyes, we are going to find. Please, react about flavours of chicken wings ...what two with a microphone! ( most of the song needs work ! ) Hahahaha
Well... in some years you will understand what an opportunity you missed... and sorry guys... "band aids" , really !? Keep listen to meaningless lalala stuff.
Reactors before the song: “We desperately don’t want to do this.” Reactors after the song: “What’s some word salad we can spew to dismiss this?” Me: “Go back to your lane of junk music while I return to admiring the greatest band of our time.”
We can see that you are clever by the Band-aids! thing. Well done Kazinho, at least for some recognition for this great band. Kanami (Lead Guitar) has just been honoured with a Signature PRS guitar- first female in the world. The interest in this band will show in the views.
These are very deep, introspective thoughts, you two must be like those guys what do you call them, oh yeah, idiot savants. Without the savant part of course
The lead guitar, Kanami Tono was just named as the first Japanese Signature PRS Guitar. The drummer, Akane Hirose has signature stix, the bass player, Misa has a signature SG, the rhythm guitar/back up vocals and founder of Band-Maid, Miku Kobato has a signature Zemaitis guitar and the lead singer, Saiki Atsumi is an amazing vocalist live. I have seen Band-Maid 3 times in the USA and can definettly recommend getting into more of their music to give them a more well rounded chance. They play multiple genre.
@@kschell286 This is a Hard Rock/Heavy Metal band, not a band that only knows 3 chords. Fans of Band-Maid and this type of music like to have multiple instruments that fill the space. We appreciate talented musicians that can give us mutiple soundscapes. Its not for everyone but for those of us who like, this is a very special band.
@BM4-Life Nah, they are good people. They are just brutally honest, and I respect them for it. Doesn't mean I agree all the time, but I respect them and their opinion.
They do it all. There's something for everyone. You haven't even scratched the surface. It all depends on what you like. It sounds like an anime theme song, and BAND-MAID have been commissioned to do theme songs for many anime. They even appear in anime themselves. But if you want something heavy they have loads of those as well. 'Rinne', Black Hole' Different', Shambles'. But to compare them to what you like and say they don't measure up is the height of amateurishness. Let's see your stuff and I'll cut it to ribbons compared to BAND-MAID.
9:50 The left guy said a lot of sht without saying anything. Repeating "needs a lot of work" "heard it a thousand times" without specifying. He might as well have been honest & said he didn't like it. An honest opinion is always appreciated. Instead he kept trying to rationalise his dislike & talking nonsense. Also, what exactly is "Anime" sounding. Most of the music used in Anime is no different from general music. People just tag anything with japanese vocals as Anime music. Its like saying any song that happened to play at a tv show or sports event as tv show music & sports music. I get it, it's mostly ignorance from people whose only contact with Japanese artists is Anime. But it never fails to bug the hell out of me. Probably cos I was like that too back in my early teens 😂
This is not a Band-Maid "feels" song, but the lead guitarist and main composer, Kanami, does not lack for emotional composition or lead solos. If that is your ilk, try Daydreaming or Alone. For compositional excellence, try Black Hole or Giovanni. But I suspect that Band-Maid is just too complex for you, and if that is the case, maybe try the artist Cluppo. Also, the cheesy thumbnail...👎
From Japan BAND-MAID has been together for 12 years, and the members have remained the same, with nearly 140 original songs. There is a diversity that cannot be evaluated by just one song. Japan is often associated with anime, but it is true that Japanese anime produces cool songs. Japanese anime has a cultural depth that is not found in the West, and has a world of different value. It is also necessary to enjoy more diversity. To get to know BAND-MAID, it is important to listen to a few songs, at least several times. I also recommend BAND-MAID's anime theme songs, Shambles, Different, and Protect You.
No guys, not everything Japanese sounds like anime, expand your knowledge and damn, study a little what you're watching, those girls are more than artists, they are one of the best bands in the world, if you want a solo that sounds like metal, listen to one of their metal songs, they have different types of solos.
Hey guys. Not an easy access song...they're very accomplished musicians at this point and this was actually an exercise where the composer/lead-guitarist asked all members to contribute ideas and she decided to use them all and make a very densely packed song (it's quite something when they serve this live TBH). I would honestly suggest two songs which I believe are top-drawer...accessible, beautifully arranged and individually distinctive: try the 'Bubble' MV and the 'Dice' MV. Even if you don't react to them, maybe give a listen to see if you then think they're unique or just part of the J-rock general noise for your tastes. It's the fact they go from acoustic ballads to borderline metal and, like bands I've enjoyed since the 70s, have progressive elements (a wicked lead bass player) and fit for me as a follow on from Deep Purple, Queen, Motorhead, Iron Maiden, Rush, Van Halen and more...they display all the techniques and variety and put each song before genre, image and ego. They've recently formed their own independent management company and proceed to be masters of their own art...outside of commercial expectations and pressures. Many big bands are all out of ideas after 11 years...the maids are well into their stride for 2025 onwards. Peace guys.
This is Band Maid’s pop/punk stuff from a particular album. They have done more classic tones in “DICE,” from the following album. After that, a metal instrumental “From Now On” as a lead single from their 7th studio album. I’m curious what you would think after a larger sample of what they do. I’m willing to give you a chance as you’re willing to give them one as well
Thanks for sharing such valuable information! I need some advice: I have a SafePal wallet with USDT, and I have the seed phrase. (alarm fetch churn bridge exercise tape speak race clerk couch crater letter). How should I go about transferring them to Binance?
You do need to check out more Band-Maid ... I understand if a song doesn't hit you, although I do disagree with almost every single criticism you made (but I've been listening to them since 2015 (I'm 68, grew up listening to some of the best rock bands ever, and Band-Maid is the best to every do it (not just the music, but the band itself is Beatles squared for entertainment value, and musically right up there with Zeppelin, The Who, Elton John, Beatles, Eagles, etc ... Queen is the only band that I know of that is as consistently good at creating songs that keep you interested throughout the whole song (you seemed to miss that while you may have 'heard it before', you were too busy looking for what might be wrong to notice that if you indeed had 'heard it before' you would have had to hear it in 4 or 5 different songs, since they never repeat a verse or chorus the same way ... and I don't mean some minor change, they actually arrange the instruments to make sure there are new 'counter-melodies' by different instruments every time around.) As someone pointed out,it's not often you hear your complaint about Kanami's guitar playing ... I understand the complaint, I am not much of a Metal fan for that reason, the guitar playing is just a bunch of scales with little to no adherence to the melody of the song ... Kanami never does that ... I think your criticism of the guitar sound as being shrill is a little bit justified, but her guitar sound changes a lot ... she is the main song writer & arranger, and the way I see her writing style is to write a melody first, then she arranges it as though she were writing a Rock Orchestra with a full orchestra to play with, then she gets together with the Basist and Drummer and they find ways to have their instruments play the part of whole 'section' (ie. so they never play over one another, they are always either doing lighter counter melodies underneath the main instrument, or taking the part of the 'lead' orchestra section. I think goven your 'complaints'. you really need to check out some of their live videos ... this will give you the evidence you need that these girls are the real deal, and it might help you understand that their music is just part of the Band-Maid experience ... yes, it's not going to have the 'tube sound' or whatever it is you might associate with your standard rock band, but these girls are not limited by their equipment ... they take inspiration from what their equipment can do and use it to provide a new sound to a great old sound that started losing its relevance Band-Maid is doing for Rock/Punk/POP what BABYMETAL did for Metal ... put a fresh face on it and pretty much gave it a new life ... some purists might not like it, but thre are certainly lots of Hard Rock and Metal musicians, some of the greats, that understand and appreciate both BABYMETAL and Band-Maid for what they can do and have done to revive Rock!
I suggest you try Day Dreaming the studio version. When Kanami writes her solos the goal is to serve the song. Day Dreaming has only one solo and no tapping. It is rare that a reaction channel are disappointed with the Maids after 3 reactions. Dare I suggest Influencer the studio version.
I'm a little confused by this also. "We get it she can play." About three days ago Kanami (the lead guitarist) got her own PRS guitar line and was presented with a model by Paul Reed Smith personally at a live event in Japan. I do think you guy are missing something. Maybe check out some more of their songs and see if you understand what they are doing. "Hate" live is the new hotness. Here's a reactor with some stills and commentary on the live event: th-cam.com/video/hwucmmQTA_s/w-d-xo.html
Starting with an MV instead of a live performance is an interesting choice. Hate? live at Yokohama Arena does them more justice. They've only been together 11 years and have 100s of songs in their library. www.youtube.com/@Ohrenje is a good way get to know the band.
Animé??? This song it's a soundtrack from the movie kate. You must see this. You are entitled to your opinion. It's normal that not everyone likes rock. I like pop, metal, hard rock and I also like some k-pop bands. it doesn't have bad music just bad editing.
Been listening to and playing music for about 60 years now and I'm always amazed at some peoples' arrogance in thinking that they can be critics. This song has "been done a thousand times"? What a stupid remark. Please name even 10 of those times. There is no band like Band Maid. This is not an "opinion", it's a fact. Whereas you may hear some bits and pieces in their songs that sound similar to other bands, that is the same with every band you goofballs. Yes. There is a bias here. Same as you two evidently have a bias. Metal heads maybe? But my bias is the recognition of great musical talent. And they have it. What is that saying? "Those who can do, those who can't criticize".
So, they don't like it. And my fellow fans go nuts 🙃 You cannot please everybody in the world. And to be fair - IMHO - Blooming might not be a good first song. This version has some filter on it making it sound like indie or something. Not my thing. Which could explain their dislike for the guitar tone. Personally I am huge fan of BAND-MAID and I never listen to Blooming, just saying. Then, of course, they missed the obvious skills also in this song, but, easy to miss if you do not like how it sounds. Two guys missing BAND-MAID. Life goes on.
This is a band that is made for playing live, they have more official live videos than MVs. Probably good to do Domination live, moratorium live and the Manners/black hole live, then their newer albums like Influencer MV or Hate live. Different is the action Anime song they wrote. I have seen them live they do long concerts, 22+songs and are known for their live musical talent. This is my favorite rock band, who I choose when I need rock. Miku, The rhythm guitarist is actually the band leader and writes all of their lyrics from the 4th album to today. Kanami is the lead guitarist, considered one of the best but she is the one who writes all of the music. Saiki is the lead singer. Misa is on that bass, akane on the drums both also considered in the best of the best for talent.
I agree completely, but disagreeing with a reactor is fair. I think it's also fair to insult a reactor that disparages or shows little respect for a band. I don't think these guys really crossed the line, so yeah just move on.
@SLICKYRICKY888 yes...and no...word gets around to avoid the channel...Fan base treats it like kryptonite...Even if their next review is favorable. Still...if it's honest, I have no issues.
Usagi must be friendl of 2 re*****. Usagi have mini tteokbokki, too? Mini tteokbokki brothers making fun of Bandmaid on purpose, so everyone please bash tteokbokki brothers
Their reaction is literally trash, but don't go around saying Kpop is garbage coz that makes y'all no different from them. Calling their ignorance out just because their knowledge about Japanese music was limited to anime but at the same time disparaging Kpop when all you've probably heard of are either BTS or Psy is unironically hypocritical, to say the least.
K4os got a comeback now, it's called "RAGE" - K4OS. I thing the girls are going to surprise you guys with how much they grew. They got into planing the Mv this time too
Am I the only one that appreciates reactors who are honest with their thoughts rather than pandering to potential viewers? I came in expecting a positive reaction and they didn't deliver, but they took the time to properly lay out why it wasn't to their taste, and their overall stance seemed pretty neutral to me. They are not always positive when it comes to k-pop groups either because nobody is going to like everything they hear.
Nop, you're Not the only one. There's a reason they reached 10k subs in a few months. I'm a Fan of their reactions since they began with IVE and Stray Kids, and it was such a fresh take in comparison to the Channels I used to watch, where I noticed that they were Always excited with every single groups Comebacks, and I thought.. How? How can people enjoy everything they hear, even If it's clearly nothing Special? And then I realised... It's all fake, to garner subscribers. That's why they always feel hyper excited. Nah.... I'm done with that. Whenever These dudes actually enjoy and praise a Song or group I Love, it's Like Christmas to me, because it's rare and I know, it's honest!
@@waynedahlen I don't disapprove Nor Approve. The Thumbnail is clearly for click bait, so I Just don't take it personally. If I would take every little provocation personally, I wouldn't survive long in this era of Internet. I advise you do the same... It's definitely healthier. Lol
@waynedahlen I'm free to give any advise I want. And you're free to take it or discard it ;) You were the one asking and tagging me. Clickbait is used literally everywhere by everyone. I do Not think that, after a 10 years carreer, the girls mind it. It's apparently an Art in and on itself to not get provoced by criticism. They don't need you to defend them, because they don't need defending. They couldn't care less, and neither should you.
No wonder you think it's similar to many other anime songs, because your knowledge and understanding of music is so narrow.
You guys aren’t to good at listening to music are you! 🍺😂
👍👍🍻🍻
LOL, esp the Kpop fan on the right. To be fair, Blooming does have a poppy vibe, esp the chorus, so anyone jaded on Kpop or generally allergic to pop may have an adverse reaction. These guys should have started with some straight hard rock/metal songs like Moratorium or Puzzle or From Now On - something to pull them out of their musical malaise.
This is why I don't even attempt dealing with duos or trio channels. Schtick, not substance.
They only seem to be interested in girls in hot pants
Guys please suggest them k-pop stuff. This music went above their heads.
They say this song needs work😂😂😂.
probably they even think they can do better.
There is a saying called "game recognizes game". This is a great example when game is not recognized.
Well said 👍🍻
@@madsstavang What they said.☝️
This reaction is pure "game"
I give this reaction a rating of 0.5
Out of 10?
@viaverde3153 of course.
@@kitsunedao3895nah, I'm fine with it. Guy on the left said at least one or two reasonable things 😊
I just came back 4 hrs later to see how the bashing is going.
I just read the comments, didn't bother with the non reaction :)
@GaryHolloway-810 allo allo Gary San your right then govna
@@jeremydawkins8814 lawd luv a duck it's Jezza "Cock-er-ny" Dawkins.🫡
I really hate it when Band-Maid fans seek approval from any mediocre "reactor"... after all you've seen the K Pop garbage these guys react to for a living... I don't know how many coffees they paid to these guys... but I hope it serves as a lesson to Band-Maid fans who decide to throw their pearls to the swine.👍😉
@COTTERO Well, I'm a music addict, so I love all types of music, and I like to tell others about it. If they like it great, if they don't, that's fine too. Everyone has their own musical tastes. As long as they have an open enough mind to give it a try, I'm happy.
I understand why you are frustrated but I don't mind people trying to get the word out about Band Maid, they probably, if sincere, are more let down that we are, if I had the money I would throw coffee at a 100 new reactors, if 95 loved them but 5 hated them, I would be ok with that, these guys don't know what they are talking about...
These guys are getting grift from faint praise to work from an artist with a huge passionate fanbase. Important to insult them at the level where we know they're really good.
This increases "interaction".
Really cynical grift.
Straigh to the black list. The channel.
Band-Maid is amazing. I wish the guy talking about the technical aspect demostrate how is supposed to be done.
Is normal for non or bad musicians to not appreciate good music. Is like a great joke that passes by to slow people. It happens, is not for everyone.
From the start they already had a dismissing tone. Good thing Millions of people have better taste. Whata way to fumble 😂
There's really not coming back from this, at least with Band-Maid fans.
こんなにセンスの無い人達にも１万人も登録者が居る、不思議な世界だよなぁ。
Agreed
特に右の男性ほんと生理的に無理吐きそう🤮
自分はBAND-MAIDのファンであり、NewJeansも好きなBunniesでもあります
彼らのように、ミュージシャンに対する敬意も、音楽の知識や、音楽への愛情も感じられない人物がリアクターとして存在出来る事自体が驚きです…😂
本当に呆れました👎
Bye-Bye, Po!
Drumming is not sampled, played live with lots of changes in almost every section of the song. If you can’t tell, oh well🤷♂️ not worth thinking about it 😮
Scientists need sample of their brain tissue to save ch**dren from becoming st*p*d
Um. Oh well. Looks like this channel is on perpetual Moratorium.
Plus, Atom has to live with K re***d face for rest of life. Poor Atom 😢 he got mini tteokbokki and K re**** face😢
@@গোহাস3877 Spicy rice cakes??? 😊🤣
The faces of these two say it all. They don't understand what they're hearing.
they barely understand life i suppose
Obviously not musicians. and this is exactly why the phrase "Opinions are like assholes, everyone's got one" was created.
WTF...さいてー... 見なきゃよかった。
Sigh… my opinion about your opinions is you don’t know what you’re talking about. Countless musicians have done reactions, and analysis, of this song and I’ve never heard any of your criticisms mentioned. I’ve listened to tons of rock and metal in my 58 years and, IMO, this song is a masterpiece.
I don’t want, or expect, you to change your minds to appease anyone, though… we will just vehemently disagree on this.
It’s not Taylor Swift.
Trying to understand how someone listens to this song and reaches these conclusions is breaking my brain. I suppose there are also people who think the Mona Lisa is trash, but... oh look, a pigeon, gotta run.
Another unoriginal reaction channel - irony
Hi from France:
So, as soon as a group comes from Japan, their music is... ANIME!!!
😂😂😂😂
Ignorance is like jam... the less you have, the more you spread it...
And, by the way, it's not K-pop, it's not Korean, but J-rock...
@@gillesmurat7362 I always piss off when even decent reactors mention anime. It’s a bit stupid in my eyes. Cliche I’d say, like ink dramas a boy always catches a girl. How the heck say Anemone or Unfair game are anime? So narrow minded.
A channel that wastes valuable time
i'm not gonna criticize your opinions.. everyone thinks whatever they want.. but in regard of the guitarrist (kanami) trying to show her skills during the solo that's wrong.. kanami could show off way more but in fact 99% the people are asking for her to do the solos longer.. she always gives her mates the room to shine
Oh you mean Kanami? The one who has a Signature PRS 40 anniversary. 😂
The face said it all that they only know kpop music
Most people who have heard this song think it's a masterpiece. However, these two guys are trashing it like they've never had whiskey before🤣🤣🤣
Become a member? No! Support you on PayPal? No! Donate? No! Come back?😾Hell no!
BAND AID heals your wounds ... BAND MAID heals your soul. The producers of the Netflix movie KATE thought enough of our MAIDs to include this and the song CHOOSE ME, along with a long cameo of the band, in the movie. No, it is not an anime ... lol.
One and done......out..
Yeah, these guys are just lame who don’t care music at all. Bye Bye 🙏🏻❤️
Really,there is no hope for some folks,,all madiacs smile and move on,nuff said.
Atrocious thumbnail. Awful take. “I don’t care if you die out”…
Only a true BAND-MAID fan will recognise the reference in your final line. By the way, Hate? is a masterpiece, like every single song from our maids.
This is gold, nice reference use.
They'll don't like any women groups because they have useless mini tteokbokki. They both give women 2 hours of limp gymnastics
@@FatTulip. life is unfair game. It’s better to put moratorium on such reactions. Let’s their play be only about us! No hate, no non fiction game, this reaction doesnt have much sense, no thrill. From no on only real existence and future domination.
Read the comments before you got going......decided to not waste my time with the other 11 mins.
I don't understand when people complain about guitar tones. Electric guitars can make a wide variety of sounds, and different sounds are used in different genres and by different individuals. It doesn't make sense to expect a hard rock song to sound like a pop rock song.
Those people only listen to generated AI music lol.. 😂
Band aid? You two are the ones who really need help and a single band-aid isn't enough to cure you. You can have your opinion and it can be negative, it doesn't matter... but the title is enough to know what two pieces of meat, with eyes, we are going to find. Please, react about flavours of chicken wings ...what two with a microphone! ( most of the song needs work ! ) Hahahaha
Don't do anymore Band Maid, your not worthy 😂
Well... in some years you will understand what an opportunity you missed... and sorry guys... "band aids" , really !? Keep listen to meaningless lalala stuff.
You know you're dealing with real winners when they bust out that always hysterical "BAND-AID": joke right in the thumbnail. 🤣
Yes, they both have mini tteokbokki and dont like women groups.
Reactors before the song: “We desperately don’t want to do this.”
Reactors after the song: “What’s some word salad we can spew to dismiss this?”
Me: “Go back to your lane of junk music while I return to admiring the greatest band of our time.”
We can see that you are clever by the Band-aids! thing. Well done Kazinho, at least for some recognition for this great band. Kanami (Lead Guitar) has just been honoured with a Signature PRS guitar- first female in the world. The interest in this band will show in the views.
About 5 songs in and you're gonna be so sorry that you ever attempted to compare them to bandaids. 🤣
No more reaction. They don't like women groups because women make fun of their mini tteokbokkis
my bad... the thumbnail alreadly was screaming, and yet i still clicked. congratulations for getting one view from me.
moving on.
These are very deep, introspective thoughts, you two must be like those guys what do you call them, oh yeah, idiot savants.
Without the savant part of course
Wow, clueless.
The lead guitar, Kanami Tono was just named as the first Japanese Signature PRS Guitar. The drummer, Akane Hirose has signature stix, the bass player, Misa has a signature SG, the rhythm guitar/back up vocals and founder of Band-Maid, Miku Kobato has a signature Zemaitis guitar and the lead singer, Saiki Atsumi is an amazing vocalist live. I have seen Band-Maid 3 times in the USA and can definettly recommend getting into more of their music to give them a more well rounded chance. They play multiple genre.
Misa's signature bass is her long time endorser Black Cloud , maker of bespoke instruments. Saiki is awesome peroid. 😁
@ thank you for the correction. The live Freedom video she was playing the SG. I always get those confused.
... that Zemaitis metal front is really something to behold ;) .
Yeah, that's all well and good, but this song would be better with fewer instruments. They really are holding too much space...
@@kschell286 This is a Hard Rock/Heavy Metal band, not a band that only knows 3 chords. Fans of Band-Maid and this type of music like to have multiple instruments that fill the space. We appreciate talented musicians that can give us mutiple soundscapes. Its not for everyone but for those of us who like, this is a very special band.
I am the one who requested this. Regardless of the outcome, thank you for doing my request.
Thank you for spreading the word about our Maids. They deserve to be heard in more ears.
Thanks for spreading the word? 🍺😁🕊️
@@RogerChance5309 I'm just following your lead.
Thanks you *Kaeg* for spreading the word of *BAND-MAID* 😊as for the other two hard pass 👎
@BM4-Life Nah, they are good people. They are just brutally honest, and I respect them for it. Doesn't mean I agree all the time, but I respect them and their opinion.
👎
Como puede hablar de música un fan del kpop, que será lo siguiente uno de reguetón, vaya par de catetos musicales
😂😂 well said, cheers from Australia 👍🍻
They do it all. There's something for everyone. You haven't even scratched the surface. It all depends on what you like. It sounds like an anime theme song, and BAND-MAID have been commissioned to do theme songs for many anime. They even appear in anime themselves. But if you want something heavy they have loads of those as well. 'Rinne', Black Hole' Different', Shambles'. But to compare them to what you like and say they don't measure up is the height of amateurishness. Let's see your stuff and I'll cut it to ribbons compared to BAND-MAID.
Why are you guys surprised? Their videos are mostly about hating. Hahaha they just wanna hate 😂
9:50 The left guy said a lot of sht without saying anything. Repeating "needs a lot of work" "heard it a thousand times" without specifying. He might as well have been honest & said he didn't like it.
An honest opinion is always appreciated. Instead he kept trying to rationalise his dislike & talking nonsense.
Also, what exactly is "Anime" sounding. Most of the music used in Anime is no different from general music. People just tag anything with japanese vocals as Anime music. Its like saying any song that happened to play at a tv show or sports event as tv show music & sports music.
I get it, it's mostly ignorance from people whose only contact with Japanese artists is Anime. But it never fails to bug the hell out of me. Probably cos I was like that too back in my early teens 😂
PRS recently released a Signature limited edition Kanami model for the lead guitar player.
Are these two braddahs up for da Dumb and Dumber sequel 😅
Beavis and #### head
@@গোহাস3877 Not Beavis and Butthead. They Actually have great taste in music! So B&B are way above these two...
This is not a Band-Maid "feels" song, but the lead guitarist and main composer, Kanami, does not lack for emotional composition or lead solos. If that is your ilk, try Daydreaming or Alone. For compositional excellence, try Black Hole or Giovanni. But I suspect that Band-Maid is just too complex for you, and if that is the case, maybe try the artist Cluppo.
Also, the cheesy thumbnail...👎
Dudes ..did i hurt your feelings
Oh dear
Is there music you do like ? I'm wondering, this is my 4 or 5 video I have watched of you guys. You're never happy 😢
From Japan
BAND-MAID has been together for 12 years, and the members have remained the same, with nearly 140 original songs. There is a diversity that cannot be evaluated by just one song. Japan is often associated with anime, but it is true that Japanese anime produces cool songs. Japanese anime has a cultural depth that is not found in the West, and has a world of different value. It is also necessary to enjoy more diversity. To get to know BAND-MAID, it is important to listen to a few songs, at least several times.
I also recommend BAND-MAID's anime theme songs, Shambles, Different, and Protect You.
英語かったるいんで日本語でいいよね。
まぁ、toshiさん色々言ってるけど無駄だと思うな、彼等にはさ。
彼らは徹底的にK-POPと比較して違いを優劣に引き込んで語ってるよね。御存じのようにK-POPは周到に企画された販売戦略によってグループのキャラクターが決められ、楽曲もそれに従って作曲家集団が緻密に計算してPCで作られているよね。それによって、"ここにギターソロをはめ込もう、リスナーを驚かすテクニカルなソロにしよう”というような計算のもとでギターのソロが組み込まれ、ベースやドラムも楽曲のボトムとして曲を牽引するが目立たないようにPCで注意深く打ち込まれ作られる。だからこそ、バンドのリードギターとして歌詞も踏まえてあえて激早のパッセージを選択しているカナミのソロにたいして"やりすぎじゃね"という感想になるし、各メンバーのプレイをリスナーが確実に聞き取れるように配慮したミキシングについても、メンバーのボーカルが立つようにバッキングなどは残響などの録音技術で周到に造り込まれたK-POPのサウンドに対して、"なんか古臭くね、楽器が目立ちすぎ"のような感想となる。そして彼等は、コンセプトがK-POPと比較的似ていて激しいロックのビートを持ったアニソンに、"同じじゃね"という感想を持つに至る。バンドが作り続け演奏し続けてきた楽曲とその演奏の創造性・芸術性には全く気が付かず(まぁポピュラリティが異常に高い計算されつくしたPCミュージックばかり聞き続ければそうなると思うが)、各メンバーの演奏の背後にある高い演奏技術にも気が付かず(まぁPCミュージックばかり聞き続けているだろうからね)、カナミのメンバーそれぞれにフォーカスを当てつつ楽曲をまとめあげる音楽的才能にも思いもよらない。まぁ終わってる連中だから、"つまらない事を吹聴するくらいなら2度とBAND-MAIDに触れないでくれ！"くらいのスタンスでいいんじゃね・・・と、思うけどね。
@@doraemonnobita2730 K- POPは売るためにつくられた感が強すぎて、聞いていません。大人の都合が優先する音楽より、手作りの個性的な音楽、自分たちで作ってると言える音楽に魅力を感じています。彼らにもそれが伝わればと願っています。まあ、嫌いなものはそれまでなので無理はできません。
@@toshimatyu6654 Maidiacにはあなたのような理性的に啓蒙活動をする人が必要です。これからも共に彼女たちを応援しましょう。👍
No guys, not everything Japanese sounds like anime, expand your knowledge and damn, study a little what you're watching, those girls are more than artists, they are one of the best bands in the world, if you want a solo that sounds like metal, listen to one of their metal songs, they have different types of solos.
These guys hate every songs😂
Disrespectful…
Hey guys. Not an easy access song...they're very accomplished musicians at this point and this was actually an exercise where the composer/lead-guitarist asked all members to contribute ideas and she decided to use them all and make a very densely packed song (it's quite something when they serve this live TBH). I would honestly suggest two songs which I believe are top-drawer...accessible, beautifully arranged and individually distinctive: try the 'Bubble' MV and the 'Dice' MV. Even if you don't react to them, maybe give a listen to see if you then think they're unique or just part of the J-rock general noise for your tastes. It's the fact they go from acoustic ballads to borderline metal and, like bands I've enjoyed since the 70s, have progressive elements (a wicked lead bass player) and fit for me as a follow on from Deep Purple, Queen, Motorhead, Iron Maiden, Rush, Van Halen and more...they display all the techniques and variety and put each song before genre, image and ego. They've recently formed their own independent management company and proceed to be masters of their own art...outside of commercial expectations and pressures. Many big bands are all out of ideas after 11 years...the maids are well into their stride for 2025 onwards. Peace guys.
Comments are a great help . So much time saved . 👍👍👍👍👍 for the ladies
Just the thumbnail is a disrespect to the group..so pathetic!
This is Band Maid’s pop/punk stuff from a particular album. They have done more classic tones in “DICE,” from the following album.
After that, a metal instrumental “From Now On” as a lead single from their 7th studio album.
I’m curious what you would think after a larger sample of what they do. I’m willing to give you a chance as you’re willing to give them one as well
I know u guy reaction xg but I don't appreciate this..sorry
Honestly that's a pretty good score looking over your others, especially when it was produced by way fewer people.
Thanks for sharing such valuable information! I need some advice: I have a SafePal wallet with USDT, and I have the seed phrase. (alarm fetch churn bridge exercise tape speak race clerk couch crater letter). How should I go about transferring them to Binance?
You do need to check out more Band-Maid ... I understand if a song doesn't hit you, although I do disagree with almost every single criticism you made (but I've been listening to them since 2015 (I'm 68, grew up listening to some of the best rock bands ever, and Band-Maid is the best to every do it (not just the music, but the band itself is Beatles squared for entertainment value, and musically right up there with Zeppelin, The Who, Elton John, Beatles, Eagles, etc ... Queen is the only band that I know of that is as consistently good at creating songs that keep you interested throughout the whole song (you seemed to miss that while you may have 'heard it before', you were too busy looking for what might be wrong to notice that if you indeed had 'heard it before' you would have had to hear it in 4 or 5 different songs, since they never repeat a verse or chorus the same way ... and I don't mean some minor change, they actually arrange the instruments to make sure there are new 'counter-melodies' by different instruments every time around.)
As someone pointed out,it's not often you hear your complaint about Kanami's guitar playing ... I understand the complaint, I am not much of a Metal fan for that reason, the guitar playing is just a bunch of scales with little to no adherence to the melody of the song ... Kanami never does that ... I think your criticism of the guitar sound as being shrill is a little bit justified, but her guitar sound changes a lot ... she is the main song writer & arranger, and the way I see her writing style is to write a melody first, then she arranges it as though she were writing a Rock Orchestra with a full orchestra to play with, then she gets together with the Basist and Drummer and they find ways to have their instruments play the part of whole 'section' (ie. so they never play over one another, they are always either doing lighter counter melodies underneath the main instrument, or taking the part of the 'lead' orchestra section.
I think goven your 'complaints'. you really need to check out some of their live videos ... this will give you the evidence you need that these girls are the real deal, and it might help you understand that their music is just part of the Band-Maid experience ... yes, it's not going to have the 'tube sound' or whatever it is you might associate with your standard rock band, but these girls are not limited by their equipment ... they take inspiration from what their equipment can do and use it to provide a new sound to a great old sound that started losing its relevance
Band-Maid is doing for Rock/Punk/POP what BABYMETAL did for Metal ... put a fresh face on it and pretty much gave it a new life ... some purists might not like it, but thre are certainly lots of Hard Rock and Metal musicians, some of the greats, that understand and appreciate both BABYMETAL and Band-Maid for what they can do and have done to revive Rock!
No more reaction. Re***** guys make fun of everyone. They both have mini tteokbokki that's why they mad a world
To each their own.
I suggest you try Day Dreaming the studio version. When Kanami writes her solos the goal is to serve the song. Day Dreaming has only one solo and no tapping. It is rare that a reaction channel are disappointed with the Maids after 3 reactions. Dare I suggest Influencer the studio version.
No more. They Daydreamed of chocolate banana during this reaction because they both have mini tteokbokki
👎👎👎
I'm a little confused by this also. "We get it she can play." About three days ago Kanami (the lead guitarist) got her own PRS guitar line and was presented with a model by Paul Reed Smith personally at a live event in Japan. I do think you guy are missing something. Maybe check out some more of their songs and see if you understand what they are doing. "Hate" live is the new hotness.
Here's a reactor with some stills and commentary on the live event:
th-cam.com/video/hwucmmQTA_s/w-d-xo.html
Starting with an MV instead of a live performance is an interesting choice. Hate? live at Yokohama Arena does them more justice. They've only been together 11 years and have 100s of songs in their library. www.youtube.com/@Ohrenje is a good way get to know the band.
No offense Donald, but I hope they go back to KPOP and leave us Alone.
@@bandmaidfanATL Nice Play there.
If you thought not enjoying BTS would bring you hate, you haven't met the Band Maid Fandom 😂😂😂😂😂 good luck, my brothers...
About aid. Maybe you should react to Jug Mafia? An idol group more to your liking, IMO. 😏
No life in these two. Proof that zombies exist.
Thanks for giving Band-Maid a try. Love the band, love the song. I to give this song 8.5, just different reasons though.
Thanks so much for sharing!
You can`t understand for them?
Thank you commenters.
Movin' on...
Animé??? This song it's a soundtrack from the movie kate. You must see this. You are entitled to your opinion. It's normal that not everyone likes rock. I like pop, metal, hard rock and I also like some k-pop bands. it doesn't have bad music just bad editing.
Been listening to and playing music for about 60 years now and I'm always amazed at some peoples' arrogance in thinking that they can be critics. This song has "been done a thousand times"? What a stupid remark. Please name even 10 of those times. There is no band like Band Maid. This is not an "opinion", it's a fact. Whereas you may hear some bits and pieces in their songs that sound similar to other bands, that is the same with every band you goofballs. Yes. There is a bias here. Same as you two evidently have a bias. Metal heads maybe? But my bias is the recognition of great musical talent. And they have it. What is that saying? "Those who can do, those who can't criticize".
I don't know...
They looked...confused?
So, they don't like it. And my fellow fans go nuts 🙃
You cannot please everybody in the world. And to be fair - IMHO - Blooming might not be a good first song. This version has some filter on it making it sound like indie or something. Not my thing. Which could explain their dislike for the guitar tone. Personally I am huge fan of BAND-MAID and I never listen to Blooming, just saying. Then, of course, they missed the obvious skills also in this song, but, easy to miss if you do not like how it sounds. Two guys missing BAND-MAID. Life goes on.
BTW - they will also miss Lovebites, Nemophila and Hanabie. So, their life will be a bit more boring. Their loss.
這頻道應該是從NEW JEANS開始看，閒著無聊，有回過頭從第一部開始看，單純好奇UP的品味或有無立場，完整追到本月那一部，後面就停止，但有跳著看MAMAMOO，TAEMIN。
有關BAND MAID我是建議看LIVE，對於多數路人的聽感及MV視覺，第一首也不該是Blooming。個人經驗，我以前看到BAND MAID都會跳過，無意點開音樂聽個開頭，秒關，包含LOVEBITES、BABYMETAL、OOR……，現在看來，屬個人偏見。
有次無意中，跟著某頻道reaction看完兩場live，我就有點沉浸在band maid的音樂，跟我當初入坑kpop的感覺一樣。但一開始對這團音樂，我還是會挑刺，並不是每一首都有感（kpop也是如此），不過band maid是個寶藏，很多我覺得"可能"不好聽，或非主打，沒有mv，一開始欣賞不來的……，變成我最喜歡的，比入坑曲還喜歡
BTW其他幾個日本band我也都喜歡，現在很喜歡聽歌曲所有吉它、貝斯、鼓、vocal，好的演奏聽著舒服，很爽。
至於這個頻道，見仁見智吧，除了up自身，有的粉絲推kpop選的歌，我會覺得問號，哈哈哈，然後老實說，欣賞度還真的是會分MV、LIVE、編舞、RADIO、音源……，精彩度有所不同。
kpop是mv好看，有的編舞版會加分，至於live版，除了走vocal，其它的我會……恩恩，而日本相反，jpop的mv還ok，但jrock的mv真不怎麼樣，但live版反而優。
They reacted to Blooming? Kind of an unexpected choice for a first Band Maid reaction.
I thought you guys were about to fall asleep n
They were dreaming of chocolate big banana because they both have mini tteokbokki
This is a band that is made for playing live, they have more official live videos than MVs. Probably good to do Domination live, moratorium live and the Manners/black hole live, then their newer albums like Influencer MV or Hate live. Different is the action Anime song they wrote. I have seen them live they do long concerts, 22+songs and are known for their live musical talent. This is my favorite rock band, who I choose when I need rock. Miku, The rhythm guitarist is actually the band leader and writes all of their lyrics from the 4th album to today. Kanami is the lead guitarist, considered one of the best but she is the one who writes all of the music. Saiki is the lead singer. Misa is on that bass, akane on the drums both also considered in the best of the best for talent.
No. Blooming is written by Band Maid.
Wow, if they don't like it it's their preference and opinion, just move on. There is no need to bash them for their honest opinion.
Oddly true... I've been a Maidiac for three years. I've rarely seen a fan base that is more territorial. If people aren't into them... that's fine.
I agree completely, but disagreeing with a reactor is fair. I think it's also fair to insult a reactor that disparages or shows little respect for a band. I don't think these guys really crossed the line, so yeah just move on.
@SLICKYRICKY888 yes...and no...word gets around to avoid the channel...Fan base treats it like kryptonite...Even if their next review is favorable. Still...if it's honest, I have no issues.
Usagi must be friendl of 2 re*****. Usagi have mini tteokbokki, too? Mini tteokbokki brothers making fun of Bandmaid on purpose, so everyone please bash tteokbokki brothers
Their reaction is literally trash, but don't go around saying Kpop is garbage coz that makes y'all no different from them.
Calling their ignorance out just because their knowledge about Japanese music was limited to anime but at the same time disparaging Kpop when all you've probably heard of are either BTS or Psy is unironically hypocritical, to say the least.
K4os got a comeback now, it's called "RAGE" - K4OS. I thing the girls are going to surprise you guys with how much they grew. They got into planing the Mv this time too
Please REACT TO "RAGE" FROM KAOS🙌❤🔥🔥🔥
Babymonster reaction please
Oh no let the hate? begin 🤟🤟, its a reaction guys, cut them some slack.
Am I the only one that appreciates reactors who are honest with their thoughts rather than pandering to potential viewers? I came in expecting a positive reaction and they didn't deliver, but they took the time to properly lay out why it wasn't to their taste, and their overall stance seemed pretty neutral to me. They are not always positive when it comes to k-pop groups either because nobody is going to like everything they hear.
???😅This must be their freind. You have mini tteokbokk,too. So sorry for Atom K re****d face
Nop, you're Not the only one. There's a reason they reached 10k subs in a few months. I'm a Fan of their reactions since they began with IVE and Stray Kids, and it was such a fresh take in comparison to the Channels I used to watch, where I noticed that they were Always excited with every single groups Comebacks, and I thought.. How? How can people enjoy everything they hear, even If it's clearly nothing Special? And then I realised... It's all fake, to garner subscribers. That's why they always feel hyper excited. Nah.... I'm done with that. Whenever These dudes actually enjoy and praise a Song or group I Love, it's Like Christmas to me, because it's rare and I know, it's honest!
@@Pookasoul 🤣👌
@@waynedahlen I don't disapprove Nor Approve. The Thumbnail is clearly for click bait, so I Just don't take it personally. If I would take every little provocation personally, I wouldn't survive long in this era of Internet. I advise you do the same... It's definitely healthier. Lol
@waynedahlen I'm free to give any advise I want. And you're free to take it or discard it ;) You were the one asking and tagging me. Clickbait is used literally everywhere by everyone. I do Not think that, after a 10 years carreer, the girls mind it. It's apparently an Art in and on itself to not get provoced by criticism. They don't need you to defend them, because they don't need defending. They couldn't care less, and neither should you.
More Band Maid and y’all should react to the Warning
Kpx always has the best content