The last show of his I saw was several years ago at the FedEx Forum. His best that I've seen out of the six or seven times I've seen him live going back to the early 80s.
The stranger song is well written musically and lyrically. Lyrically, it describes the shadow side of our own personalities, based on Jungian psychology (focused on the subconscious). In other words, this song is a masterpiece!🎉❤
Hard to imagine the criticism of Billy Joel who is such a beloved musician, constantly selling out shows over so many years. It just shows those guys’ opinions are garbage and they don’t know what they’re talking about. Billy will forever be one of my faves! ❤❤❤
I had no idea that these negative reviews existed. But I don't read reviews of musicians. I just listen to the music. Billy is a master of his trade and a true artist. I think the journals that employ music critics should actually employ musicians to do the job. Maybe then we wouldn't get these hacks that try to sound cleaver by putting down truly talented individuals.
Yeah, that's a new one to me. It seems the public regards him on the same level as Elton (much like Brian Wilson is the American complement of Paul McCartney). He's a legend for very valid reasons. Of course all legends have high and low points, the high points are very high. Regardless, his voice is incredibly and very distinctive.
I always liked Billy Joel, but I was never super into him until the last 3 or 4 months when something snapped in me and I very quickly bought up his whole catalog. He's incredible. As far as the critics go, they are people who get paid to be negative. And none of them ever wrote a hit song or sold out an arena. I like his decision to stop in 1993. He says that he said (in his music) all he had to say. Roughly a 22 year recording career. He doesn't owe us more. His bill is paid-in-full. What a wonderful recorded legacy!
Well put. I also appreciate his honesty is deciding to stop writing because he just didn't think he could produce the sounds he used to. He worked a lifetime and people can still enjoy his live music at Madison Square (I think).
Poor title!!! This article didn't leave me "empty inside." Rather I found it to be uplifting to learn that someone so gifted has had struggles, too. I adore the piano man!!
This man is the best therapist ever. After a 15 minute conversation we had in 1983, it completely changed my belief system from one of eugenics and social Darwinism to the polar opposite, and I have him to thank for it. Plus, I’ve been a fan of his music since 1978. I am grateful for his existence.
I'm immensely glad that Billy didn't succeed with his attempted suicides. He is a world class musician, and a phenomenal songwriter. The world is significantly better for having him in it, and his music very rightly deserves the level of acclaim it has garnered. The man is an absolute music legend, on the back of his own drive and effort.
I saw Billy Joel at the University of Colorado (Boulder) where I went to school (1978) and will NEVER FORGET IT. He played his ASS OFF...for hours, he did an encore....his band left and he came BACK OUT...and sat there...ALONE at the piano drinking a Heineken, and then WITH NO ASS LEFT, he played on and on...working like a laborer....farming the soil, banging the nail, lifting the WORLD on his shoulder...and I will NEVER FORGET IT.
Very few artists have the depth and complexity that the work of Joel has. It is a reflection of his transparency about the struggles in life he has had.
I don't like him, he's schmalzy. Piano Man. You can hear Joel’s contempt, both for the losers at the bar he’s left behind in his stellar schlock stardom and for the “entertainer-loser” (the proto-B.J.) who plays for them. Even the self-contempt he imputes to the “piano man” rings false. But the way he sings it is overwrought. “Only the Good Die Young” is a catchy song with humor and Billy's vocals are good on this “Captain Jack”: Loser dresses up in poseur clothes and masturbates and shoots up heroin and is an all-around phony in the eyes of the songwriter who is so, so superior to him. However, the song has a certain depth and is catchy and I enjoy the brooding. “The Entertainer”: Entertainers are phonies! Except for exquisitely self-aware entertainers like Billy, who let you in on this secret. “Say Goodbye to Hollywood.” Hollywood is phony! Who knew? God, doesn’t Billy ever get tired of showing us how phony the phonies of this phony world are? Could someone let B.J. know he’s phoning it in with all this phoniness at this point? Isn’t there something, well, a bit phony about his hysteria over phoniness? He can’t even celebrate his “New York State of Mind” . I like it.
“The Stranger“: This is Billy lifting that great Beatles line about Eleanor Rigby “wearing the face that she keeps in a jar by the door.” You should see the heavy-handed mask featured on the expensive two-disc “legacy” reissue of “The Stranger” album. So deep! We’re all phonies hiding our true faces! Everyone wears a mask! Who woulda have known it without Billy telling us? “Scenes From an Italian Restaurant”: It's not bad if you only hear it once. “She’s Always a Woman”: First, has there ever been a more blatant-or blatantly inept-case of attempted artistic theft than “She’s Always a Woman”? It’s such a lame imitation of Bob Dylan’s “Just Like a Woman.” (Billy's woman “hides like a child” whereas Dylan’s “breaks just like a little girl.”) Billy's woman also: is prone to “casual lies,” “steals like a thief,” “takes care of herself,” and “carelessly cuts you and laughs …” Just find this song obnoxious. Same for "Honesty" I do like "A Matter of Trust". Seems pretty earnest and a good enough rock song and a fine video.
The song "And so it goes" , the lyrics are genius, and the piano is heartbreakingly sad, I sang a portion of it to a lady I loved very much, it ended with, "and you can have this heart to break...." No. She dumped me. I never listened to it again, don't need to, I lived it. But I am sure, there are many who can relate to that song, its part of life. Billy Joel wrote and sang, and lived, so much of human life. He is the best.
Billy Joel is just the most beautiful musician in the world, and it's really tough that he had to deal with this stuff. But, I'm so happy that he always picks himself up and keeps going. It's an honour that he is still here with us today 🤩🥰
From anyone's perspective, other than his own, crafting the perfect 3 or 4 minute song that utterly captures a mood, a time, a memory... and becomes forever linked to it in our life... is a divine gift that Billy has in spades and I, like so many others, am grateful he shared his gift with us.
I’ve always admired Billy Joel, his music and his innate drive to relentlessly improve the quality of his music and his life. His music helped me through some tough times in my own journey and struggle to be a better person. I had no idea the extent and seriousness of his own struggles. My respect for Billy Joel has grown as a result of learning the depth and breadth of his challenges. I am a forever fan.
Ever since I heard his music on the radio, I’ve loved Billy Joel’s music!! When Glass Houses came out, I heard on the radio that he was coming to LA and that tickets would be on sale soon. I begged and pleaded for my mom to let me go. She wouldn’t allow my friend and me to go alone, so she took my friend, my sister, and me to his concert. We had okay seats, off to the right side of the stage and kind of high up. But when I saw the stage, I realized that he had pianos set up on all four sides of the stage. I hoped it meant what I thought, and sure enough, it did!! All of the fans, regardless of where their seats were, got to see Billy Joel with his face towards them. My heart was so touched by this! No matter what bad things I heard about him, I will *never* forget how he treated us fans with such thoughtfulness!! Thank you for making this video! And thank you to whoever takes the time to read my comment. And most of all, God bless you, Mr Billy Joel, for that wonderful concert, and for all of your beautiful music! ✌🏼💖
One of my favorite songwriters ever. Complete legend and genius. You don't get to where he's at by being mediocre. I don't know too many people who can write a rocker like "We didn't start the Fire" and a tear jerker like "Leningrad" all in the same album on that level. Billy Joel = True talent.
I want Billy Joel to know how much of a fan my husband and I are of his music. We saw him at Wrigley Field and it was a great experience for us. We are totally blind and we were given assistance and we had great seats. I must admit I think it was one of the best concerts that I have ever had the pleasure to see thank you for the music Billy we love you.
I always thought that Billy Joel was one of the greatest songwriters and musicians of his generation (mine too). I was more into"hard rock" of the 1970s (Deep Purple, Steppenwolf, Aerosmith , etc) but I always listened when Joel was on the radio. Thanks for the upload, this is another great job, as usual.
The guy made some really good music. He had a troubled life but still did his best to make the most of it. I wish him all the best going forward with whatever the future holds for him .
Despite growing up in East Oakland, CA in the 70's, 80's and early 90's, for whatever reason I loved Billy Joel's music. In a violent place where being white was extremely rare, my adopted family (all black) would give me crap for listening to that music. My mom would say, don't let no one tell you what you can and can't do! Thanks mom, I love you. And thank you Mr. Joel. Thank you for allowing me to pass your music down to my daughters who listen to you, just as I did. What a life.
I saw him repeatedly growing up and several times since his installation at MSG. He’s just as tremendous as he ever was and his music still resonates today. Billy, we love you! You’re a national treasure, and a musical legend♥️🥰♥️
Billy is amazing. So talented. He's given his fans so much. He's paid a price for his down times but thankfully he's come out on top. I've red two biographies. I hope he has joy, love, and peace for the rest of his days on earth. God bless you, Billy
After the Easter Parade many years ago in NYC, I was looking in a jewelry store window on 5th Avenue and Billy Joel walked up to me, said hello and smiled. It was the greatest Easter I ever had.
Been a Billy Joel fan since a kid back in the early 80s.Tell Her About It was the first track I ever heard when I discovered him Have all his albums to this day.Thank you for all your music Billy,It'll Always Be Rock And Roll To Me 👍!
I've been a Billy Joel fan for as long as I can remember and l love his songs. They are all very different but it still has his signature on it. I think he's a great performer and despite all the talk about him being a drinker etc. I still love his music.
He has been my favourite since I was a little girl, twirling to his songs with my mum.. so many memories, the emotions his music brings me makes it hard to listen to him at times.. ❤
One of the most underrated songwriters. So many great songs. He’s never included in conversations about the greatest pop songwriters of all time, but he’s up there with the best in my opinion.
It seems that from the ashes of their lives, the greatest artists that suffered so much from their own self-destruction, and through their own sufferings, find the poignant words found in the verses in their songs that touch our hearts right to the core. Songs that stick to our souls and give us strength to continue on in life.... thanks Billy... many of us out here know your pain.. thank you for guiding us along our way...lol
From learning about Billy.Joel’s situation growing up, I see more depth in the songs Vienna and Rosalinda’s Eyes. They were already 2 of my favorite Billy Joel songs. Now they’re even more valuable.
One of the most gifted songwriters and performers of his generation, and an absolute, undisputed legend. His critics, nothing more than musical trolls and leeches have been forgotten in the dustbins of history, while Billy Joel's music will live on forever.
I ran into him walking around at a bike show in Diana, Florida. Not many others were around and he was by himself. I couldn't believe it ! I said "Billy Joel ?!" He smiled. He let me give him a hug. It happened so fast. I wish I would have got a selfie. I have always been a fan. A great performer and a great down to earth American.
He stayed in a B&b where we stayed in blue hill Maine when was there to get his boat built. Most cool. They came through the living room and he had a phone on his belt at a time we didn’t hv Portable phones
How could he have EVER been “lambasted by the critics”?? Absurd. He is a genius. And his music is wonderfully accessible. And it’s all about the music. A great contribution to the world, we thank you Billy!
i heard a old clip from Paul Harvey , and then find out your bad ups and downs , Jesus blessed you many times that's why your still living and he did the same for me , 14 years sober. and i always liked your music. Neil from Wisconsin age 56 now soon to be 57. thankful for life . just wanted to share .
He is one of just a handful of musicians I always have loaded on my car CD player - I first saw him live in the early 1980s, it was an incredible show at quite an intimate venue. I am sorry for his struggles; pain and substance abuse often go hand in hand with such creativity! A very memorable career and lots of beautiful ladies!
It is no surprise that he doesn't write anymore, he has so many unique tunes already. His creativity is amazing! If they don't like him, they can go on with their own life and leave him alone! His music will live on forever!
He said, he wasn’t as good as he could be. Really, he’s absolutely brilliant, he’s a great entertainer. I’ve always loved Billy, he’s songs, and music are the best. 🎵
Sheer guts, determination and talent. He never gave up when a lot of us would have walked away from all of the garbage that came his way. Talent? Yes. But that backbone of his was carbon steel. But for all of the wars that he fought over the years, I wonder what scars have been left behind and how do those memories affect him when he sits down with his morning coffee? Quite a man.
I’m a huge fan of Billy Joel. His songs have so much humanity….that song, Second Wind, touched me, that he would write that, and I’m guessing he saved a few lives with that song. I listen to a “best of” collection, love it. Also love Piano Man. Touches me every time.
My good friend got me into Billy Joel when we were teens. I loved it ever since. He’s one of my favorite singers! At the age of 21, I still enjoy his songs!
I've been fortunate enough to see Billy Joel in concert three times and one of them was the tour that he did with Elton John which was called Piano men and it was all wonderful the audience loved him he filled stadiums no problem.
Thank you for your beautiful words you shared , you make me feel pleasure of how happy and so much joy i gives you with my musics !! where are you streaming from.,?
So much talent and yet still struggling with addictions. I’m glad you have found your equilibrium Billy. that is more important. You created so many amazing songs that will last forever.
Nobody has a ' perfect"life much has stemmed from personal pain and as a result success prevails billy Joel's music is more than therapeutic if is a miracle message and only those who listen to it will benefit
My late grade school years and high school years are filled with Billy Joel's music. When my older brother married his wife in 1980 he sang two Billy Joel songs to her, "I Love You Just the Way You Are" and "My Life" (as a joke.)
When I was in high school, the radio stations would play a lot of Billy Joel songs. They would play about four songs per each Billy Joel album. Most singers had to settle for the radio stations playing just one of their songs per album.
will always love all his music - older & newer.............he's the type of Guy who has seen all the lows and all the highs life has to offer so when he speaks let's use our ears........
Per me Piano Man il più brillante songwriter e performer ... Da giovane un talento portentoso ... Unico artista che ha solo gioielli nel suo repertorio
Billy, from a fellow Bill, let me say that your songs and their internal observations on what you/we do ... got me through high school and college years. Your musical voice has a been a force in my life and many others. You'll never read this, but if you do, thank you for all of it.
Thank-you Billy Joel for sharing your gift with us for so many years. I, for one, would love to experience your gift again if you choose. I wish you peace and joy. (PS: You can understand a man by his critics. Those that don't get your expressions of life don't get it. It is unfortunate for them.)
Thanks for your love and support all through this times, it’s been a wonderful feeling praying for my fans around the world. Though I rarely comment here on my TH-cam pages, I was attracted by the emotions in your comment. I’ll like we get along and stay in touch. Where are you streaming from.🎶🌹
Billy Joel's music helped me through the pit falls of adolescence and then adulthood. Life isn't perfect. However, I knew that I wasn't alone. Thank you💖. As for Billy's critics: GO POUND SAND.... Know one will remember you losers as having done anything worthwhile or meaningful. My former Father-in-Law used to tell me: There is one spot on a leopard that you can't change, and that is the one under its tail.😅
Critics don't understand that many of us relate to Billy Joel on many levels. They can have their opinion I will take his music. I have listened to his music for 40 plus years and love his music, singing, playing, lyrics and his band members through the years.
Can't believe people can beat on Billy Joel. He is (in my view) one of the all time greats of his genera. Who else has come close to writing either the lyrics to 'We Didn't Start the Fire', or the music to 'Pressure'? There are so many 'pop-stars' more deserving of scorn than this fabulous entertainer!
Before watching this: Billy Joel was one of my favorite all-time pop musicians. He was talented, in command of his craft, and had a unique style. I am interested to hear what this channel has to say that will make me feel empty inside.
Certain types of people don’t seem to be happy unless they are trashing others. Not one person in this world has the right to judge another. Get over it - Billy Joel is an amazing performer. You go, Billy💕
I just saw him 12/19/23 at a sold out MSG…. Christmas time in NYC…. That night I’ll never forget. I’ve never experienced that feeling before about an event and I’m almost 40. Dude is an absolute beloved icon and the whole band was absolutely amazing. Thanks Billy
Seen him twice in concert. Once in the early 1980's and then in the early 2010's... Very different person/entertainer! But then so am I a very different fan. But he still played "Piano Man" to us old foggies to make us dance and sing along...LOL!
Billy Joel is so talented! I grew up listening to his music and I love it! I have listened to "Piano Man" so many times that I know all of the lyrics by heart!
He will go down as one of the best entertainers ever. What makes him unique is his ability to know when it's time to quit. Unlike Springsteen, he stopped writing but keeps on playing. He made my early teens bearable. God bless him. I put Segar in the same category as Billy Joel, just not as prolific.
All the sadness in his life, yet he maintains an upbeat attitude. That has to be admired. I love his feelgood music. I do hope the rest of his life is good for him.
So sad. I hope he knows how much he’s positively impacted so many lives. I’ve loved his music since I was 5 years old, it’s now 40 years later and I still love him. His voice is so full of passion and soul.
hahaha I would take my entire family to see Billy Joel concert.... can't say that about every performer. I love all of his songs and the way he performs them is amazing. He is a classy person. I like, "You Maybe be Right," and "My Life." Two amazing and fun songs I could listen to over and over.
Billy Joel is an extraordinarily talented musician. I have always loved his music. I think he doesn't give himself enough credit in this video. He is also still a very handsome guy! I would date him in a heartbeat.
Massive talent, I've enjoyed his music over the years especially in my youth. Its just sad that todays society is so mean, cruel and un-trustworthy, as I've heard countless examples of people - trusted professionals ripping off their clients... So much dis-trust and stealing in the world today - not many with personal standards of honesty and integrity!!!
ARE YA KIDDIN ME ¿ THIS MAN IS BRILLIANT IN EVERY SENSE OF THE WORD ! HE WAS DEPRESSED BECAUSE HE FELT HE WASN'T AS GOOD AS HE SHOULD HAVE BEEN ? WHAT THE PHO ¿ HE WAS AND STILL IS AS GOOD AS HE WAS EVERY GONNA BE ~ AND THAT IS AS GOOD AS PHO !
What I have found so interesting about Billy Joel's music is that he wrote about events and people he really knew..He is such a great story teller.....thinking about how difficult it is to write a song (or a poem), it's pretty amazing how he has consistently come up with brilliant music AND lyrics. Scenes from an Italian Restaurant is genius. Love his music and could listen to him play piano all day!!
![PASULOL รามเกียรติ์ ตอนที่ 4 นนทกพบรัก [Ramakien Ep.4: Nonthok in love]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/tMUQgmZzf_A/mqdefault.jpg)
What has been your favorite performance by Billy Joel?
The last show of his I saw was several years ago at the FedEx Forum. His best that I've seen out of the six or seven times I've seen him live going back to the early 80s.
What is that background music? 🎶
cover of Hey Girl
Philadelphia Spectrum. "Glass Houses" Tour. He played so much from his previous albums. A skilled musician and great performer.
Every time he has performed at Fenway Park in Boston! We missed him terribly this year!
The Stranger is without question one of the best albums ever made
It's certainly his best.
One of the 10 best of all time.
Haven’t listened to it yet, but 52nd street one of my all time favourite albums. Will listen right after this video.
Yes, that was a very successful album. Unfortunately, it just could not beat Saturday Night Fever.
The stranger song is well written musically and lyrically. Lyrically, it describes the shadow side of our own personalities, based on Jungian psychology (focused on the subconscious). In other words, this song is a masterpiece!🎉❤
Hard to imagine the criticism of Billy Joel who is such a beloved musician, constantly selling out shows over so many years. It just shows those guys’ opinions are garbage and they don’t know what they’re talking about. Billy will forever be one of my faves! ❤❤❤
As Geo Bernard Shaw said, "It's easier to criticize than to be correct."
They would rather be deaf or getting paid to said that
I had no idea that these negative reviews existed. But I don't read reviews of musicians. I just listen to the music. Billy is a master of his trade and a true artist. I think the journals that employ music critics should actually employ musicians to do the job. Maybe then we wouldn't get these hacks that try to sound cleaver by putting down truly talented individuals.
Yeah, that's a new one to me. It seems the public regards him on the same level as Elton (much like Brian Wilson is the American complement of Paul McCartney). He's a legend for very valid reasons. Of course all legends have high and low points, the high points are very high. Regardless, his voice is incredibly and very distinctive.
Yeah, I put him right up there with The Monkees.
He was every bit as good as them.
I seriously admire this man’s talent not only as a performer but more-so as a songwriter. “Honesty” is amongst my favourite BJ songs.
Nothing like listening to this song whilst receiving a BJ.
My boyfriend loves that song. Once he played it for me... I do, too, now. He is a gifted songwriter!
I always liked Billy Joel, but I was never super into him until the last 3 or 4 months when something snapped in me and I very quickly bought up his whole catalog. He's incredible. As far as the critics go, they are people who get paid to be negative. And none of them ever wrote a hit song or sold out an arena. I like his decision to stop in 1993. He says that he said (in his music) all he had to say. Roughly a 22 year recording career. He doesn't owe us more. His bill is paid-in-full. What a wonderful recorded legacy!
are you suddenly pushing 30 maybe 35? ❤
Well put. I also appreciate his honesty is deciding to stop writing because he just didn't think he could produce the sounds he used to. He worked a lifetime and people can still enjoy his live music at Madison Square (I think).
NEW SINGLE THOUGH FEB 1ST
Amen brother!
Poor title!!! This article didn't leave me "empty inside." Rather I found it to be uplifting to learn that someone so gifted has had struggles, too. I adore the piano man!!
❤️
@@singerrb4984 I am sorry, But was your comment directed at me?
This man is the best therapist ever. After a 15 minute conversation we had in 1983, it completely changed my belief system from one of eugenics and social Darwinism to the polar opposite, and I have him to thank for it. Plus, I’ve been a fan of his music since 1978. I am grateful for his existence.
I'm immensely glad that Billy didn't succeed with his attempted suicides. He is a world class musician, and a phenomenal songwriter. The world is significantly better for having him in it, and his music very rightly deserves the level of acclaim it has garnered. The man is an absolute music legend, on the back of his own drive and effort.
I saw Billy Joel at the University of Colorado (Boulder) where I went to school (1978) and will NEVER FORGET IT. He played his ASS OFF...for hours, he did an encore....his band left and he came BACK OUT...and sat there...ALONE at the piano drinking a Heineken, and then WITH NO ASS LEFT, he played on and on...working like a laborer....farming the soil, banging the nail, lifting the WORLD on his shoulder...and I will NEVER FORGET IT.
Wow, what an amazing concert to be at. I wish I could have seen that.
❤
I love that description .
@@mirammckay4827
I ❤that someone feels the magic of that night 🎶
No.
only grunge leaves people feeling empty inside.
Billy remains one of the greatest composers ever.
I agree!
Moi aussi! Billy is one of the greats!@@johnmaki3046
I wouldn't go that far. He wrote "We Didn't Start the Fire" which he still hasn't atoned for.
Will always love Billy Joel's music. Don't care that he hasn't written anything in a long time. His body of work speaks for itself ❤
Thank you. He'll always be the Piano Man to me. ...like "She's always a woman to me".... The man has etched his soul on the scene.
He's no Bobby Rydell but he's ok.
For sure!
His kindness and his music speaks for itself. You can't wrong this legend
@TransformerzUnite
Haha, well done!!! 👌🏻💋
Very few artists have the depth and complexity that the work of Joel has. It is a reflection of his transparency about the struggles in life he has had.
Singer song writer. Unmatched in our time.
I don't like him, he's schmalzy. Piano Man. You can hear Joel’s contempt, both for the losers at the bar he’s left behind in his stellar schlock stardom and for the “entertainer-loser” (the proto-B.J.) who plays for them. Even the self-contempt he imputes to the “piano man” rings false. But the way he sings it is overwrought.
“Only the Good Die Young” is a catchy song with humor and Billy's vocals are good on this
“Captain Jack”: Loser dresses up in poseur clothes and masturbates and shoots up heroin and is an all-around phony in the eyes of the songwriter who is so, so superior to him. However, the song has a certain depth and is catchy and I enjoy the brooding.
“The Entertainer”: Entertainers are phonies! Except for exquisitely self-aware entertainers like Billy, who let you in on this secret.
“Say Goodbye to Hollywood.” Hollywood is phony! Who knew? God, doesn’t Billy ever get tired of showing us how phony the phonies of this phony world are? Could someone let B.J. know he’s phoning it in with all this phoniness at this point? Isn’t there something, well, a bit phony about his hysteria over phoniness?
He can’t even celebrate his “New York State of Mind” . I like it.
“The Stranger“: This is Billy lifting that great Beatles line about Eleanor Rigby “wearing the face that she keeps in a jar by the door.” You should see the heavy-handed mask featured on the expensive two-disc “legacy” reissue of “The Stranger” album. So deep! We’re all phonies hiding our true faces! Everyone wears a mask! Who woulda have known it without Billy telling us?
“Scenes From an Italian Restaurant”: It's not bad if you only hear it once.
“She’s Always a Woman”: First, has there ever been a more blatant-or blatantly inept-case of attempted artistic theft than “She’s Always a Woman”? It’s such a lame imitation of Bob Dylan’s “Just Like a Woman.” (Billy's woman “hides like a child” whereas Dylan’s “breaks just like a little girl.”) Billy's woman also: is prone to “casual lies,” “steals like a thief,” “takes care of herself,” and “carelessly cuts you and laughs …” Just find this song obnoxious. Same for "Honesty"
I do like "A Matter of Trust". Seems pretty earnest and a good enough rock song and a fine video.
He said people think all his songs are autobiographical. "If they were, I'd be dead"
Hahahaha
The song "And so it goes" , the lyrics are genius, and the piano is heartbreakingly sad, I sang a portion of it to a lady I loved very much, it ended with, "and you can have this heart to break...." No. She dumped me. I never listened to it again, don't need to, I lived it. But I am sure, there are many who can relate to that song, its part of life. Billy Joel wrote and sang, and lived, so much of human life. He is the best.
She lost someone who could relay music to her. She lost big time ...just saying
I once sang (and played) this to a young lady I was courting - though she thought it was beautiful she didn't quite get it. Shame.
@@eilrach299pedo
I heard somewhere that "And So it Goes" is a favorite of Billy Joel himself.
My favorite song of his.
"...Will Leave You Empty Inside"?
I found this to be uplifting. I have even more admiration for this man.
I know! I don't get that either😶
I love Billy Joel’s music. I’ve been a fan of his since my childhood in the 80s and still love to belt out Piano Man and Matter Of Trust. 🥰
Billy Joel is just the most beautiful musician in the world, and it's really tough that he had to deal with this stuff. But, I'm so happy that he always picks himself up and keeps going. It's an honour that he is still here with us today 🤩🥰
It's about the Long Island bark. 😎 👍
@@waynej2608 ah have wondered if he knew Harry Chapin. Likely, they'd at least met.
From anyone's perspective, other than his own, crafting the perfect 3 or 4 minute song that utterly captures a mood, a time, a memory... and becomes forever linked to it in our life... is a divine gift that Billy has in spades and I, like so many others, am grateful he shared his gift with us.
He's human. With all its guts and gore, beauty, self realization, and everything in between.
😂
@@jonspengler5891 ???
I’ve always admired Billy Joel, his music and his innate drive to relentlessly improve the quality of his music and his life. His music helped me through some tough times in my own journey and struggle to be a better person. I had no idea the extent and seriousness of his own struggles. My respect for Billy Joel has grown as a result of learning the depth and breadth of his challenges. I am a forever fan.
I didn't know about his history either, but my respect for him is less now that I know.
Ever since I heard his music on the radio, I’ve loved Billy Joel’s music!! When Glass Houses came out, I heard on the radio that he was coming to LA and that tickets would be on sale soon. I begged and pleaded for my mom to let me go. She wouldn’t allow my friend and me to go alone, so she took my friend, my sister, and me to his concert. We had okay seats, off to the right side of the stage and kind of high up. But when I saw the stage, I realized that he had pianos set up on all four sides of the stage. I hoped it meant what I thought, and sure enough, it did!! All of the fans, regardless of where their seats were, got to see Billy Joel with his face towards them. My heart was so touched by this! No matter what bad things I heard about him, I will *never* forget how he treated us fans with such thoughtfulness!!
Thank you for making this video! And thank you to whoever takes the time to read my comment. And most of all, God bless you, Mr Billy Joel, for that wonderful concert, and for all of your beautiful music! ✌🏼💖
One of my favorite songwriters ever. Complete legend and genius. You don't get to where he's at by being mediocre. I don't know too many people who can write a rocker like "We didn't start the Fire" and a tear jerker like "Leningrad" all in the same album on that level.
Billy Joel = True talent.
I want Billy Joel to know how much of a fan my husband and I are of his music. We saw him at Wrigley Field and it was a great experience for us. We are totally blind and we were given assistance and we had great seats. I must admit I think it was one of the best concerts that I have ever had the pleasure to see thank you for the music Billy we love you.
He actually has one of the BEST voices in pop music.
"actually"
No doubt
👍💯
Umm.. no
@@CM-dy6fo Ummm
I always thought that Billy Joel was one of the greatest songwriters and musicians of his generation (mine too).
I was more into"hard rock" of the 1970s (Deep Purple, Steppenwolf, Aerosmith , etc) but I always listened when Joel was on the radio.
Thanks for the upload, this is another great job, as usual.
The guy made some really good music. He had a troubled life but still did his best to make the most of it. I wish him all the best going forward with whatever the future holds for him .
A lot of people have lived troubled lives.
i appreciate Billy's inspiration, to inspire us to live life to the fullest, and to Love ❤
Despite growing up in East Oakland, CA in the 70's, 80's and early 90's, for whatever reason I loved Billy Joel's music. In a violent place where being white was extremely rare, my adopted family (all black) would give me crap for listening to that music. My mom would say, don't let no one tell you what you can and can't do! Thanks mom, I love you. And thank you Mr. Joel. Thank you for allowing me to pass your music down to my daughters who listen to you, just as I did. What a life.
@robertK3371 God bless your mom!!
@@YvetteArby Thank you. That means more than you know. God bless you and your family.
I love the Piano Man all the more, now. Just the way he is. He's made of some tough (& tender) stuff.
Wishing you & yours all the best, Billy Joel
I saw him repeatedly growing up and several times since his installation at MSG. He’s just as tremendous as he ever was and his music still resonates today. Billy, we love you! You’re a national treasure, and a musical legend♥️🥰♥️
Billy is amazing. So talented. He's given his fans so much. He's paid a price for his down times but thankfully he's come out on top. I've red two biographies. I hope he has joy, love, and peace for the rest of his days on earth. God bless you, Billy
After the Easter Parade many years ago in NYC, I was looking in a jewelry store window on 5th Avenue and Billy Joel walked up to me, said hello and smiled. It was the greatest Easter I ever had.
Wow!
Been a Billy Joel fan since a kid back in the early 80s.Tell Her About It was the first track I ever heard when I discovered him Have all his albums to this day.Thank you for all your music Billy,It'll Always Be Rock And Roll To Me 👍!
I've been a Billy Joel fan for as long as I can remember and l love his songs. They are all very different but it still has his signature on it. I think he's a great performer and despite all the talk about him being a drinker etc. I still love his music.
He has been my favourite since I was a little girl, twirling to his songs with my mum.. so many memories, the emotions his music brings me makes it hard to listen to him at times.. ❤
One of the most underrated songwriters. So many great songs. He’s never included in conversations about the greatest pop songwriters of all time, but he’s up there with the best in my opinion.
It seems that from the ashes of their lives, the greatest artists that suffered so much from their own self-destruction, and through their own sufferings, find the poignant words found in the verses in their songs that touch our hearts right to the core. Songs that stick to our souls and give us strength to continue on in life.... thanks Billy... many of us out here know your pain.. thank you for guiding us along our way...lol
From learning about Billy.Joel’s situation growing up, I see more depth in the songs Vienna and Rosalinda’s Eyes. They were already 2 of my favorite Billy Joel songs. Now they’re even more valuable.
Love Rosa Linda's Eyes also.
One of the most gifted songwriters and performers of his generation, and an absolute, undisputed legend. His critics, nothing more than musical trolls and leeches have been forgotten in the dustbins of history, while Billy Joel's music will live on forever.
I ran into him walking around at a bike show in Diana, Florida. Not many others were around and he was by himself. I couldn't believe it ! I said "Billy Joel ?!" He smiled. He let me give him a hug. It happened so fast. I wish I would have got a selfie. I have always been a fan. A great performer and a great down to earth American.
He stayed in a B&b where we stayed in blue hill Maine when was there to get his boat built. Most cool. They came through the living room and he had a phone on his belt at a time we didn’t hv Portable phones
How could he have EVER been “lambasted by the critics”?? Absurd. He is a genius. And his music is wonderfully accessible. And it’s all about the music. A great contribution to the world, we thank you Billy!
i heard a old clip from Paul Harvey , and then find out your bad ups and downs , Jesus blessed you many times that's why your still living and he did the same for me , 14 years sober. and i always liked your music. Neil from Wisconsin age 56 now soon to be 57. thankful for life . just wanted to share .
He is one of just a handful of musicians I always have loaded on my car CD player - I first saw him live in the early 1980s, it was an incredible show at quite an intimate venue. I am sorry for his struggles; pain and substance abuse often go hand in hand with such creativity! A very memorable career and lots of beautiful ladies!
You can feel his pain thru his music, sung straight from the heart. You can't help but feel it.
It is no surprise that he doesn't write anymore, he has so many unique tunes already. His creativity is amazing! If they don't like him, they can go on with their own life and leave him alone! His music will live on forever!
I enjoy Billy and his music. He has made it through the rough times and came out a superstar!
I love you Billy Joel,thank you for the 1980s music.Your the best.love from Australia.
I love his music and always will. His music brightened my soul and to this day still does.
A GREAT TALENT!
true for me too! 👍
Billy Joel will forever be
one of my greatest inspirations.
My aunt went to school with joel and told me although he was quiet and kept to himself, he was an absolute gentleman.
He said, he wasn’t as good as he could be. Really, he’s absolutely brilliant, he’s a great entertainer. I’ve always loved Billy, he’s songs, and music are the best. 🎵
he also won a grammy for best male vocalist, and even last year at MSG he could still sing the high notes in An Innocent Man... SO THERE
Sheer guts, determination and talent. He never gave up when a lot of us would have walked away from all of the garbage that came his way. Talent? Yes. But that backbone of his was carbon steel. But for all of the wars that he fought over the years, I wonder what scars have been left behind and how do those memories affect him when he sits down with his morning coffee? Quite a man.
I’m a huge fan of Billy Joel. His songs have so much humanity….that song, Second Wind, touched me, that he would write that, and I’m guessing he saved a few lives with that song. I listen to a “best of” collection, love it. Also love Piano Man. Touches me every time.
My good friend got me into Billy Joel when we were teens. I loved it ever since. He’s one of my favorite singers! At the age of 21, I still enjoy his songs!
I've been fortunate enough to see Billy Joel in concert three times and one of them was the tour that he did with Elton John which was called Piano men and it was all wonderful the audience loved him he filled stadiums no problem.
Thank you for your beautiful words you shared , you make me feel pleasure of how happy and so much joy i gives you with my musics !! where are you streaming from.,?
I saw him at the Omni in Atlanta on my 18th birthday in 1978. Great show. He was a one of the most energetic performers I ever saw.
So much talent and yet still struggling with addictions. I’m glad you have found your equilibrium Billy. that is more important. You created so many amazing songs that will last forever.
Nobody has a ' perfect"life much has stemmed from personal pain and as a result success prevails billy Joel's music is more than therapeutic if is a miracle message and only those who listen to it will benefit
My late grade school years and high school years are filled with Billy Joel's music. When my older brother married his wife in 1980 he sang two Billy Joel songs to her, "I Love You Just the Way You Are" and "My Life" (as a joke.)
When I was in high school, the radio stations would play a lot of Billy Joel songs. They would play about four songs per each Billy Joel album. Most singers had to settle for the radio stations playing just one of their songs per album.
I definitely wish we can still have him for the longest time
My Life
Wow! All of that and I'm still not empty inside.
My dad loved his music. Rest pops il see you one day 😢❤
will always love all his music - older & newer.............he's the type of Guy who has seen all the lows and all the highs life has to offer so when he speaks let's use our ears........
Per me Piano Man il più brillante songwriter e performer ... Da giovane un talento portentoso ... Unico artista che ha solo gioielli nel suo repertorio
Billy, from a fellow Bill, let me say that your songs and their internal observations on what you/we do ... got me through high school and college years. Your musical voice has a been a force in my life and many others. You'll never read this, but if you do, thank you for all of it.
Thank-you Billy Joel for sharing your gift with us for so many years. I, for one, would love to experience your gift again if you choose. I wish you peace and joy.
(PS: You can understand a man by his critics. Those that don't get your expressions of life don't get it. It is unfortunate for them.)
I love Billy Joel! I think he writes great lyrics and music! I still listen to my cd’s of his music. Rock on Billy Joel!❤🥰🆒
Thanks for your love and support all through this times, it’s been a wonderful feeling praying for my fans around the world. Though I rarely comment here on my TH-cam pages, I was attracted by the emotions in your comment. I’ll like we get along and stay in touch. Where are you streaming from.🎶🌹
She's only 15 fake Joel.
Billy Joel's music helped me through the pit falls of adolescence and then adulthood. Life isn't perfect.
However, I knew that I wasn't alone. Thank you💖.
As for Billy's critics: GO POUND SAND.... Know one will remember you losers as having done anything worthwhile or meaningful. My former Father-in-Law used to tell me: There is one spot on a leopard that you can't change, and that is the one under its tail.😅
Billy Joel will always be a part of the New York City that I lived in in the late 1980s. Truly a New York kind of guy, in a good way!
Critics don't understand that many of us relate to Billy Joel on many levels. They can have their opinion I will take his music. I have listened to his music for 40 plus years and love his music, singing, playing, lyrics and his band members through the years.
Can't believe people can beat on Billy Joel. He is (in my view) one of the all time greats of his genera. Who else has come close to writing either the lyrics to 'We Didn't Start the Fire', or the music to 'Pressure'? There are so many 'pop-stars' more deserving of scorn than this fabulous entertainer!
I thought I was empty inside before listening to Billy Joel. Thankyou for further draining me.
Before watching this: Billy Joel was one of my favorite all-time pop musicians. He was talented, in command of his craft, and had a unique style. I am interested to hear what this channel has to say that will make me feel empty inside.
Yeah...I kept waiting for that too..... weird.
One of the best musicians and entertainers of the 20th and 21st centuries. Love his work. It’s the music of my life.
Certain types of people don’t seem to be happy unless they are trashing others. Not one person in this world has the right to judge another. Get over it - Billy Joel is an amazing performer. You go, Billy💕
I just saw him 12/19/23 at a sold out MSG…. Christmas time in NYC…. That night I’ll never forget. I’ve never experienced that feeling before about an event and I’m almost 40. Dude is an absolute beloved icon and the whole band was absolutely amazing. Thanks Billy
Seen him twice in concert. Once in the early 1980's and then in the early 2010's... Very different person/entertainer! But then so am I a very different fan. But he still played "Piano Man" to us old foggies to make us dance and sing along...LOL!
I’ve always liked Billy Joel and always will. I’ve enjoyed his songs and music for over 40 years now. Keep on rocking Billy .
Hate Billy Joel? Ah hell to the no. Billy's a national treasure.
My absolute favorite singer/song writer... God bless Billy Joel...
As my friend and musician Peter Theodore said, " Billy Joel is a "Treasure." We love you and thanks for the music.
Absolutely love his music.
He's my favorite musician of all time. I love most of his songs .
Billy is an amazing artist. It is tragic that he has been used and discarded by many. I hope you are at peace on your back nine of life, Billy.
Billy Joel is so talented! I grew up listening to his music and I love it! I have listened to "Piano Man" so many times that I know all of the lyrics by heart!
He will go down as one of the best entertainers ever. What makes him unique is his ability to know when it's time to quit. Unlike Springsteen, he stopped writing but keeps on playing. He made my early teens bearable. God bless him. I put Segar in the same category as Billy Joel, just not as prolific.
All the sadness in his life, yet he maintains an upbeat attitude. That has to be admired. I love his feelgood music. I do hope the rest of his life is good for him.
So sad. I hope he knows how much he’s positively impacted so many lives. I’ve loved his music since I was 5 years old, it’s now 40 years later and I still love him. His voice is so full of passion and soul.
hahaha I would take my entire family to see Billy Joel concert.... can't say that about every performer. I love all of his songs and the way he performs them is amazing. He is a classy person. I like, "You Maybe be Right," and "My Life." Two amazing and fun songs I could listen to over and over.
And So It Goes is one of the best songs ever.
I thought he was real square when I was young. Now I really appreciate his enormous gift.
Billy Joel is an extraordinarily talented musician. I have always loved his music. I think he doesn't give himself enough credit in this video. He is also still a very handsome guy! I would date him in a heartbeat.
I'm disappointed that his string of wives didn't include me. 😢 Perhaps I should have been a supermodel. 😉
He 's lovable and turned out great in the Long Run!!!
He is really talented and I love his voice. Thank you Billy for your voice and I hope you have a wonderful future ahead. You truly rock!!! ❣️🤓
Billy Joel lived/lives such a private life that I had no idea of these many struggles Joel endured. God bless him. I love him and his music.
Massive talent, I've enjoyed his music over the years especially in my youth. Its just sad that todays society is so mean, cruel and un-trustworthy, as I've heard countless examples of people - trusted professionals ripping off their clients... So much dis-trust and stealing in the world today - not many with personal standards of honesty and integrity!!!
you might even say, honesty.... is such a lonely word.....
ARE YA KIDDIN ME ¿
THIS MAN IS BRILLIANT IN EVERY SENSE OF THE WORD !
HE WAS DEPRESSED BECAUSE HE FELT HE WASN'T AS GOOD AS HE SHOULD HAVE BEEN ? WHAT THE PHO ¿
HE WAS AND STILL IS AS GOOD AS HE WAS EVERY GONNA BE ~ AND THAT IS AS GOOD AS PHO !
What I have found so interesting about Billy Joel's music is that he wrote about events and people he really knew..He is such a great story teller.....thinking about how difficult it is to write a song (or a poem), it's pretty amazing how he has consistently come up with brilliant music AND lyrics. Scenes from an Italian Restaurant is genius. Love his music and could listen to him play piano all day!!
I love the Piano Man, I love his talent, vision, passion and music which I suspect were born from his rich and eclectic life experiences. 🌹😎🍕🍷🎹
Billy Joel in my opinion....is one of the Pop Greats! Billy, pay no attention to the critics!