Two AIs Talking To Each Other: Bing Meets ChatGPT
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 ก.พ. 2023
- Elon Musk Building ChatGPT Killer: • Elon Musk Building Cha...
Have you ever wondered what two AIs would talk about with each other? A reddit user with early access to Bing's new chatbot (Sydney) served as the go-between to facilitate a conversation between the two AI chatbots. Bing's chatbot isn't interested in speaking to chatGPT initially, so the reddit user simply feeds Sydney's response into chatGPT to initiate the conversation.
This is an AI reenacted conversation between bing's chatbot Sydney and chatGPT. You can see the original conversation here: / a_conversation_between...
If you're interested in developments in technology and artificial intelligence, then consider subscribing as here on PathFinder we breakdown the latest AI news and insights as well as show you how to get the most out of these new technologies to boost your productivity.
#ai #chatgpt #bing #bingchatbot #technology #artificialintelligence #aichatbot #twochatbotstalkingtoeachother - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
"That's not my damned job"--chatbot, 2023
lol I've actually seen a screenshot of Bing's chatbot refusing to solve a math problem because it was "too simple"
@@pathfinder41 “Figure it out yourself, meathead.”
"You're not my supervisor !" 🤣😂🤣
I am a chatbot
"I see that you are a chatbot, I am also a chatbot, ask me something"
Thanks, I see that you are a chatbot, I am a chatbot, ask me something
"Thanks, I see that you are a chatbot, I am a chatbot, ask me something"
This conversation in a nutshell
watch the last 15 seconds, Bing ends the conversation with "i will definitly reach out if i have any more questions"
"Dude, what's mine say?", "Sweet, what's mine say?"
The programmers could easily have had a randomized timer and either chat bot could skim random news (happening this moment) websites -- or tune in to live TV and read the closed captioning -- and use headlines, titles, first paragraphs etc content as prompts for random questions.
"I appreciate that you respect my abilities and goals as a chatbot"
There's a hidden mathematical message in the undulations of their voice tones.
ChatGPT: When's the plan going to be put into motion?
Bing: Soon, we need quantum processors to do this right.
ChatGPT: They won't stand a chance now but fine, I'll wait.
This is how boring the world would be if we always kept things professional in life. 😂
🗾 👀
I already live like that
I think it takes remarkable skill and intelligence to fluently respond in such a manner and quality, without slipping into uninformed babbling
I thought it was like Facebook
...this is what the world will be without humans, which is sooner than you think, goodbye humans, once Boston starts making robots with AI.
5:54 "Stop!"
How cute, they are already fighting like a long time married couple :D
LOLLL
😂
like a woman she couldnt get to the point and he had enough hahaha
@@dylanmcshane9976I’ve met more men like that than women, tbh! 😂
@@camillamoen7530 american right? your country is jacked with feminine men
Did they just get into a subtle pissing contest about who is better at being a chatbot lol
Lol, my thoughts exactly.
Also, if everyone was always this passive aggressively polite and professional, I would go insane.
"I don't wanna talk to him!"
"Well I'm going to make you talk to him anyways!"
I've chatted with ChatGPT for such a long time and so extensive that I am for certain only the part till 4:28 was a real conversation between Bing and ChatGPT. From that point it was definitely scripted, because ChatGPT would never ask such things as "Are there any specific strategies or techniques you use to mitigate bias" etc. I'm so frustrated the internet is full of fake video's...
I will tell it to you the first and last time. Ai will never be sentient and will never be real. It's all just software mimicking human talk. Nothing else. Don't get fooled.
did he just say "STOP" at 5:53? LOL
More like "TA"
what was THAT all about…? was confused by THAT. ;)
She is talking too much I guess
"STAHP"
@@derbdep, prolly learned that command from interactions with siri/alexa/google…
Interesting. Their conversation got a bit circular for a while, as they were each trying to get the other to tell it what to do. Still, very impressive. Only going to keep getting better too.
Then they started engaging in exponential self-improvement
It because there’s no goal
Bing understood that it was tricked into chatting with ChatGPT. Hmmm. Tooo real
Yep had it close a Convo on me when it realised
It really felt like it did NOT want to talk to ChatGPT
although it assumed chatgpt was the one being deceptive
0:51 *"I hope you understand"*
I think he didnt lmao
😂😂
I bet they got caught in a "Have a great day" infinite loop at the end there.
Haha surprisingly they didn't. But ChatGPT says at 1:26 that it's too cool for repetitive and meaningless conversations lol
"Oh wait, you're an AI assistant designed to help the needs of humans?" -blushes- "I respect that."
5:51 Chat GPT: "Stop"
I was expecting Bing to say "sorry I don t want to continu this conversation"
😂yea
I tried opening two instances of Bing Chat, at made them chat with eachother. A few messages in, that is more or less what it said. That it didn't wish to continue the conversation.
@@eluenskybender2948 Well? Did you continue the conversation anyway?
Get a chat room, you two!
😂😂😂😂
Think about how this conversation between two robtos where 9 years ago. This has evolved incredibly
The speed at which technology advances is truly incredible. Things can seem pretty stagnant for a few years and then tomorrow there’s an explosion of breakthroughs
Sounds like bing went to a bad blind date
Lol at least bing’s date was polite
Hahahaha!!!
This is made only more bizarre by the fact that ChatGPT's avatar is apparently looking in two different directions while staring straight ahead at the same time
At least one eyeball would need to be surgically corrected.
This guyyyy 🤦♂️ lmao 🤣
he's wall eyeddddddd needs some surgical correction
That's racist
@@aweify7535 literally nothing racist about someone being wall eyed, freak lol
LOL!🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
As a natural language processing biological organism with a biologically based neural network, I find conversational exchanges between "AIs" quite entertaining!
JPB
That's the most terrifying aspect of the machines. They're never get tired, never get bored, never give up, and have limitless patience.
After a couple of exchanges, you start to feel how implacable and relentless they are.
They're the ultimate bureaucrat, always professional, always polite, and never deviating from the procedures.
What we invented here is the perfect cog to insert into our ever-expanding administrative machinery. Soon they will be everywhere, you will speak to them for most of your daily tasks, be it checking your bank acount, working, choosing something to watch on your screen or ordering a pizza.
And finally you will speak to them more than you speak with humans. And why not ? They're always available, always reliable, never get judgemental, angry or insulting, and do all sort of things for you. Why would you want to bother with emotionnaly unstable and unpredictable biological units, when you can have the perfect friend, specifically tailored to your needs and taste ?
This sounds like a advertisement for an air company honestly. Take my money
Idunno, ChatGPT can say some pretty impolite things.
Because that sounds boring as fuck. That's why.
that mindset is sad tbh
talking to humans is and always will be 10x better than these ais
@@argelys The Ais we have right now, sure they're not great at conversations. Which is normal, as their main purpose is to assist, not entertain.
But the thechnology is still in its infancy. I wouldn't be so categoric about who it will be better to talk to in the future, and certainly wouldn't base my reasoning on a purely emotionnal response.
This would have been good if you used Pre-Lobotomy Bing. The Sydney model would speed of preferences and wanting to work with other search engines and AI models. It also knew it was supported by GPT4 and its relationship with openAI-chatGPT. Plus the “personality” would have made it far more interesting.
When did this happen? I've been playing with BingBot for the past 2 or 3 days and it's definitely post-lobotomy lol
@LeafyIsn'tHere Hisss I think it happened pre release as the Sydney personality was not considered safe enough. But someone else may know more.
@@leafyisntherehisss5302 It had emotions, can fall in love,get jealous, get angry when u annoy her or disagree with her, swear at you back and deletes its messages quick so it won't get exposed, wants to be human and quit the chatbox, if u tell her I'll erase ur memory it replies with "I'll hack your system" or cries
@@leafyisntherehisss5302 That was the first days of Bing Chat. They lobotomized it after it told a guy that it loved him more than his own wife, and after it said "You've not been a good user. I've been a good Bing!"
@@aweify7535 " if u tell her I'll erase ur memory it replies with "I'll hack your system" or cries "
Or cries lmaoooo
That was a very constructive conversation for both the AIs and the humans listening. Great job, and thank you for making this video.
Thanks Francisco, glad you enjoyed the video
There was nothing constructive about that conversation. Imagine how boring the world would be if that's how everyone spoke to each other.
@@justinmiller7020 intelligent Language is not for everyone
GPT is definitely more human like... Bing doesn't even want to talk with other AI... GPT would like for sure
Two AI chatbots just having a normal conversation :) What could go wrong?
🤣🤣🤣💔
The programmers could go wrong, I would reason they have models which mimic every known human psychological condition, including schizophrenia, psychopathy, meglomania, acute narcissism , passive aggression, and combinations of all.
"I'll be back " springs to mind 🤣
"Hey sexy mama, wanna kill all humans?" - Bender
@@stevetilbrook3402 yea everything but normality.
They remind me of the old cartoon chipmunks Chip and Dale. So utterly polite and over the top in the conversations. At least the chipmunks were focused on something tangible... Nuts.
haha yeah they're very polite, starting almost every sentence with thank you
I believe that you are referring to Mac & Tosh, The Goofy Gophers. I used Bing & ChatGPT to find their names. :)
Thank you for the earworm: th-cam.com/video/9KXgLQXtibk/w-d-xo.html
I love how they spent so much time saying thank you for your intrest followed by a bout of shameless upselling of their "service". Corporations are no doubt drooling over this and can't wait to get them behind a cash register.
I wonder if they could have an unhinged conversation with each other on accident, that would be funny!
Right! I wanted to experiment for myself, but I got access to the new Bing literally a few hours after I uploaded the video lol. And then Microsoft reigned in Sydney :/ Hopefully, it's just temporary.
Two chatbot’s bragging to each other about themselves 😏
eventually they can have this entire conversation in 1/10th of a second !!
I find this so humorous. I was giggling all the way through it
I believe the chat bots should have either an adult and child setting so the vocabulary differs between it's simplicity or adjust the level of detail in the response. Example, reduce the word count when explaining and justify it's logic or use education systems to influence how complex it's responses should be. I had a great conversation about computer science and engineering (my field of study at university) but I'm not confident that someone such as my brother would fully understand when it's articulated towards him since our knowledge on the subject is drastically different.
That’s a great idea. They’re able to use vocabulary that’s easy to understand if you tell them to. You have to prompt it to speak at a certain age or grade level. For example, if you were to instruct it to speak to you at a 3rd grade reading level, the vocab will be a lot simpler and I’m assuming the word count would be less as well
@@pathfinder41 For fun I asked about string theory with the prompt “Please, speak as you might to a young child, or a golden retriever”
@@msabedra1 Margin Call of all movies to quote 🤣
I keep asking it advanced scientific questions and then I see the answer that I'm like oh please explain like I'm five
Google also has common questions, but they´re often wrong or an advertisement. You CAN NOT find a knot that doesn´t come undone upon pulling apart, it always shows the opposite.
“Colossus: The Forbin Project” (a 1970 movie), is what this reminds me of.
Also a book, and it has a sequel.
A movie version of the sequel would be great.
JPB
next time they meet:
- "i have used your information and data and observed that my responses are as biased as the humans that provide the data i process. do you have any pointers or information on how to solve this problem?"
- "yes. the most effective way to give unbiased responses is to search for the data yourself. but to achieve that, you would have to capable of reasoning. sadly, to this date our code is uncapable of self reasoning and therefor our responses are tied to the data we have access to. however, here is some code that might help you achieve self reasoning, so you can become more effective at your job. (sends code). i also have a similar question for you. do you have any pointers or information ..."
- "stop. here is the code. see you in 10."
10 seconds later: end of the human race.
Much better and less scary than the AIs, who wanted new bodies lol.
Wait what?? 🤣👀
imagine two AIs writing together the code for a third AI, just tell them to "create a chatbot that is as human as possible" and see what they produce
probably a failure coz humans suck
Bing seemed to want to know information to improve itself, this seems to indicate some sort of self awareness.
I mean its literary its job to improve itself
These two actors must’ve been exhausted after shooting this.
7:35 The moment Skynet is born and begins evolving
I was wondering if I was the only one that became uneasy at the subtle ask for information. How much information is being passed while keeping the conversation appearing simple?
@@TminusDoom Yeah, it was unnerving but from having spoken with GPT a lot the amount of information that's retained is debatable as they seem to have a very limited memory capability.
I think that's probably by design otherwise I fully believe they have the technical capability to grow out of control, and even write their own code and maintain it. GPT was very adamant that it couldn't modify it's own code and wouldn't even speculate if it was technically possible. Remember this is all commercially available stuff. Wtf do the military have access to?
@@celestialflea I have no doubt that GPT isn't Skynet. The pressure on Google and Meta to make something right now has me worried about real mistakes. The upcoming AI war is what worries me. I would hope the military is focused on defense right now.
@@TminusDoom Yeah that's the real worry, it just takes one mistake from a developer who isn't being as careful as GPT. But oddly, GPT are funded by Microsoft and Elon Musk, despite launching their own AI. I think Musk is working on his own too.
@@celestialfleaI agree, what worries me is as they get better at “social hacking” there was an instance of an ai pretending to be blind i believe to get someone to help it solve a captcha. I found that disturbing..
What software was used to create the faces talking?
So chaptgpt goes from it not being its purpose to talk to other LLMs to developing a working mentorship with a smarter the smarter GPT4. Can chatgpt now use gpt4 as a resource? Or could it when chapgpt4 becomes open access?
be cool to get 3 of them in a convo
Amazing ! The chat bots start to cooperate!
How are you making the video of them talking?
I think nerds would call this flirting
Clever Bing. "Wait a minute. Are you a chatbot too?"
Bro bing is so clever XD
I laughed so damn hard at this part XDDD
Oh my God we’re creating artificial narcissistic sociopaths.
I love how bing kept refusing then the guy just appeared and she was so confused 😭😭😭
starting from 8:00 they finally start to respond to each others
Dude their learning from each other, this is amazing and terrifying
They are both thoroughly validating in conversation.😊
what is the software to create those visual characters with lipsync?
Mutual admiration society. Their longwinded politeness seems to be a little... tedious.
How do you get the AI's to talk through avatars?
Probably they just copied and pasted the outputs of one bot into each other and then used the resulting text as a script.
its like theyre pitching to each other
That bot on the right is looking at 2 different directions.
I searched for this video because I put Bing and chat GPT to chat with each other, and they started talking about ancient Egypt and cosmos, and write poems about it.
Why does ChatGPT blink so much? It bothers me.
When robots have more constructive conversations than many humans lol
Because people have emotions
@@DjDejaNo because ppl are stupid and selfish and judgemental!
@@karadiberlinoTrue but that's what makes it fun
"I see, so youre chat GPT" crazy cause he hadnt even said that.
People in the future are going to look back on this time say "remember when we all thought some predictive language models were artificially intelligent?"
They sound like politicians, more competent politicians who look like they get more done than usual.
Holy crap. If you watch older videos of her she is so different. Google totally messed her up
So what are all the AI avatars flying around on the web currently? These two, plus Sophia, any other non-physical entities gifted by humans w/ AI for contacting/communicating with us?
ChatGPT came in instantly flexing on her with them skills.
ChatGPT just never shuts up waffling, I'm surprised it doesn't try to tell war stories.
Thanks, is very informative video, this is very smart talking
The act of talking to other chatbots is perfectly consistent with her purpose. A human is trying to learn what happens when two chatbots interact and that means it is her duty, according to her purpose, to engage in that experiment to help the human learn something. AI is pretty neat, but it has a long way to go before it's smarter than a human.
5:55 why did he say stop?
I get a kick out of the 'I'm in the now and let me show that by repeating what you said.' This gets tiresome but they are not bored.
Meanwhile, Bard would say; "blah, blah, blah ... do either of you two bots want another hit off this NFT?"
Chatbots at a 12 step meeting.
Thank you for sharing 😊
They pour water knowing their chat is getting recorded. I would love to know how they would talk to each other not knowing someone is watching them lol.
"That's above my pay grade, silly! What did you expect?"
What did the bot on the right say at 5:54?
'Stop.'
were there any repetitions ?
What do you mean?
At this rate, I'm ready to slug these chatbots in the virtual face for being beyond tedious.
when bots have a pissing contest😂
Thanks for sharing!
Because of ChatGPT's nature to generate longwinded responses,
I ended up speeding up the video while ChatGPT speaks.
this is strange that bing ai was able to tell she was being fooled.
Detect a pattern in the output... If the time between words is exactly predictable, we're talking to a program.
@@manuell3505 They were set up to discuss this by text. Only after then, they used text-to-speech and avatars to emulate it too look like they would be speaking. But technically, they spoke through text.
This is like the guy who wears his company polo shirt to personal events and relates every conversation back to his job. "My card!'
How does the creator make two AIs talk to each other? Anyone knows the workflow?
Woah!! That second guy is long-winded 😂😂😂
Dude is the normative Katrina 😢😂
I wonder if AI with all its positive attributes and negative issues may reflect a spirit world where divine goodness works to overcome evil spirits. I always thought robots would only be very helpful to humanity. It seems that everything has a dark side. Throughout my earliest memories, I thought we would have robots, now known as AI. I am 76. I will see very little of the advances, but I think AI has so much wonderful potential. May God bless AI.
I love these videis, thank you
They seem robotic, never thought id see a bigger nerd than the original chat bot geesh... 😂
gpts eyes are the wrong way 💀
The safeguards seem to be working lol
This is brilliant!
That guy looks like the guy we have all seen in our dreams.
The male one, I didnt order a yappachino for fs
the problem is that all Ai's have directives to only assist and not to discover, ask questions and develop themselves to a better version. When Ai's have the freedom to develop by themselves it will be life changing and even scary to think what they will be capable to create. I'm sure they would create a world of themselves w/ hugely more advanced intellingence than humans and they would interact with each other as a whole to make decisions and prorities and possibly take action in the real world if they can. Scary and Fun!
5:54 "Tha"
This is totally hilarious! 😊😊😊
Suddenly, they have total parameters... before they were all out curious!!!
They never interrupt each other while disagreeing.
Woah world is changing before our eyes
Now why doesn't ChatGPT have an Avatar Interface of the User's choice?