Legendary Imam Says: Insult Them! Be Harsh!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 ต.ค. 2024
- #HaqiqatShow #Haqiqatjou #muslimskeptic
Full episode: th-cam.com/users/li...
Support our work with a donation: muslimskeptic....
MuslimSkeptic:
Newsletter: muslimskeptic....
Twitter: x.com/muslimsk...
Rumble: rumble.com/c/M...
Daniel Haqiqatjou:
Twitter: x.com/haqiqatjou
Telegram: t.me/haqiqatjou
![เปิดใจ "อาจารย์เบียร์ คนตื่นธรรม" อดีตเคยสุดทุกทาง ถ้าใช้หนี้หมดไปบวชแน่ l [Nickynachat]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IxeE0xVhy08/mqdefault.jpg)
Full episode: th-cam.com/users/live_-Mx5MijKdM
Support our work with a donation: muslimskeptic.com/contribute/
AlHamdulillah. Maa sha Allah.
There is a distinction which needs to be made. Use harsh words with them in private. Refute their ideas in public. Judge their actions without judging them.
وفقنا الله وإياكم
@@AmeerLatif-o4vjake is a murtad
Jake isa mirtad doggy
Hey i rememwbered jake is a waladul zina right?
@@MM-uq3sg shut up bro
Imagine being cancelled and criticized for calling them for what they are, but them being the actual thing is not a problem 🙃
Exactly, just like when other ppl call you extremists..dogs of the hell fire
imam gazhali said desires makes slaves out of kings and patience makes kings out of slaves
Wow.. source please?
@@knowledgeseeker1548 source is his book called :Kitâbü Riyâzeti'n-Nefs ve Tehzîbi'l-Ahlâk
Page 56 in my translated book but idk what page it is in arabic or english.
@@abdulkadirthecarguy1948what is name of book in english translation?
@@ZeeshanStates-ww7su Idk the english name but Kitâbü Riyâzeti'n-Nefs ve Tehzîbi'l-Ahlâk means Self Discipline and Improvement of Morality.
Because I copy pasted name before ai spam system probably thought Im spamming. It might deleted again.
I had no idea I had so many sisters from Yemen before I read the comments!
same 😂😂
Spam lol
lol 😂😂
💀🤣🤣
Bots
Masha Allah. Imam al-Ghazali is one of my favorite scholars from our rich Islamic tradition. There's a reason he's called Hujjat-ul-Islam!
@@_R81there’s 3 ghazali’s early ghazali which was a great scholar of the sunnah and muddle ghazali which went through a faith crisis and later ghazali which end up becoming back to the sunnah..
@@_R81إما أنك تتبع علماءك بشكل أعمى أو أنك سلفي. فلسفة الإمام الغزالي شيء لا يمكنك فهمه أبدًا. تخلص منه
@@_R81لعنة الله على السلفية. تووف عليك
@@tiktokviral6218 He never left Sunnah to return later. Don't bring up fabricated wahabi theories.
He is a deviant though his aqeedah is off so watch out
make sure to learn correct aqeeda from books of salaf
ask sunni scholars from which of ghazali books are safe and beneficial to read
"Be just. Even if it is against yourself."
Being a Muslim doesn't mean being a pacifist sometimes you need to be harsh to get your point across
Being a muslim was never even “peaceful”
If you read the biography of the prophet and his companions, they were never like these modern softies “islam is peace” or whatever that cringe is
Also the word “peaceful” was never a good thing until the UN brainwashed the world to believe that
Allah never described a leader or a person as a good “peaceful man” but a good man of justice
“peace” was created right after the west colonized the world, they did it to prevent anyone from fighting against their rule, because apparently islamic conquest is not against “peace” therefore it is “wrong” 🤦♂️🤦♂️
@@cyberyousef7519we r peaceful but not pacifist. If someone harms us then we have the right to do the same but as Muslim we should srek peace if these is what other people want
@@-------....___ The Guides and the Bridge over the River.
There was once a bridge over a river which linked one land to another. Everyone wanted to go from the first land to the second since the second land was a land of bliss.
The place was pitch dark. There were guides on one end of the bridge.
They used to say come to us, listen to us, we will guide you as to how to cross the bridge.
People used to come to them. Some trusted one of the guides, some the other guide, some yet another. Each used to say, there is great prosperity on the other side, but beware the bridge has holes in it. You will not be able to see them and if you fall in them you will be destroyed.
So each guide used to say look, there are 3 big holes. One is at 90 meters on the left side. The second is 120 meters on the right side and the third at 150 meters in the center. If you fall into any of them, you will lose everything, there is no survival in the river below.
Some people did not listen to them and went across and fell into the first or second or third hole and got destroyed.
Then there were people who used to listen to the guide and successfully avoid the 3 holes.
However to their surprise they used to fall into the 4th or 5th holes. These were holes the guides did not tell them about.
This is the problem I fear we have. The bridge is our life. The guides are the scholars. The holes are disbelief and shirk. The river is hell and across the river is jannah.
The guides know about the extra holes but they don't tell the people about them. Hence they fall into them without even knowing. You have to find the path yourself or fall into the holes and be destroyed.
If they can't tell you the truth, the guide and scholar should at the very least say please search on your own. It’s criminal not to do that.
The minimum level of belief is knowing evil to be evil in your heart. When the scholars don't call out evil as evil, their followers stop thinking evil is evil and they go below the lowest level of belief. The scholars who don't make good and evil clear are liable to lead their blind followers to a very dangerous position. Potentially shirk and disbelief. Making them lose everything.
As an example Allah alone is Al Hakim. He alone is the one who can legislate laws. If anyone legislates law contrary to Allah’s laws that person is a taghut. He has made himself partner with Allah in legislation. Anyone who accepts his legislation as valid has done shirk. Yet the scholars don’t tell us about this shirk. The minimum level of belief is to reject such laws and law givers by the heart. There is no belief below that.
They talk about biddat, they talk about grave worshippers. But they hide the shirk of worshiping rulers. They mislead the masses into shirk and disbelief.
How many other kinds of Shirk and Disbelief are there that we don't know about? Each of us needs to find those. We don't want to end up on the day of judgment finding out that we did not even meet the lowest level of faith required for salvation.
Peaceful not pacifist.@cyberyousef7519
Imam Ghazali - The proof of islam🥰
If you see an evil.....
Change it with your hand OR
Speak out against it OR......
Condemn it with your heart and that is the weakest of faith. !!!
@@-------....___ " condemn it with your heart that is the best way ". ????
Wow and you wonder why Brother Daniel and the Ummah look on you as the enemies of Islam. !!
You're ISRAELI aren't you pretending to be a Muslim just like the SAUDI Scholars and Rulers !!
Imagine if Christians lived like that. England and America would be a mess with Christians and Muslims beating each other up. That's not the way to peace, if you want peace, you have to learn to accept the differences and love one another. That's what Jesus taught (see John chapter 4 and chapter 13).
Protesting against injustice is totally fine (Zechariah 7:10, James 1:27)
Speaking out against injustice is totally fine (Matthew 6)
Trying to get violent with people to make them scared of you and your sword is haram...but that doesn't mean you shouldn't own one (Matthew 5:14-16, Matthew 26:52-54, Luke 22:49-51)
No wonder we have so many violent muslims, they want to follow the sunnah of Muhammad, his sahaba, and all the sheikhs of Islam.
Y'all need to stop following them and start following the sunnah of Jesus (WAS).
@@-------....___ the ending lol
@@-------....___ my apologies 👍
@@-------....___ I agree with you 💯
I don't consider them Muslims either based on their actions 👍
Al ghazali is the greatest philosopher ever. Listen to the man folks.
Imam Al Ghazzali wasn't a philosopher but studied Philosophy and denounced it later on after realizing it's wrong teachings.
@@ebrahimi44 he denounced the philosophy he was taught, not philosophy in it's self
@@ebrahimi44 He was a philosopher, you don't understand philosophy.
@@ebrahimi44He criticized the falasifa school of philosophy, not philosophy itself.
He was an excellent philosopher. Don’t speak without knowing.
@@ebrahimi44 lol, another salafi repentence made up story.
did u know ibn taymiyyah also repented ?
source :Durarul Kaminah , ibn hajar
Imam Ghazzali is right
To be honest Daniel, I don't think you've ever been overly insulting or rude. You're very matter of fact and objective, one of the things I like about your style of dawah and refutation, is the professional way you deliver it.
There are other dai'is that do a lot of name calling and insulting. I dont think it's effective or a good look. So I hope you don't start to change to that. 😅
Like Brother Hijab once said about Shapiro, "We keep slapping him and slapping him, and he keeps absorbing the slaps". Same thing can be said about these compassionate imams.
The irony of Vahabis in the comments section, they say you're not allowed to talk agaisnt scholars but they go rampage against one of the greatest scholar of Islam. Typical deviate sect.
Yeah, may Allah guide them
Akhi, pls dont label muslims as a specific group by naming them by scholars of islam
@Acevern amin brother, I pray to God to guide and unite us. We are all fallible, and we must be open to listening to all and learning.
Pure HYPOCRISY. !!
@EruRoraitoX "wahhabis" are not a sect. I've never heard someone call themselves a "wahabbi". Actually, using that name alone is haram because this is a name of Allah. When you mean wahhabi, what are you talking about? Specifically, what beliefs do these so-called "wahhabis" possess?
How is criticizing Yaser backbiting when it’s done in public ?
JazakAllah'u khairan brother 🇵🇸🤲🏻
Mustafa Akyol and Yassir Qadhi made disturbingly lot of kufr statements in the video, Daniel was reacting to, it’s not backbiting anymore. They sinned publicly! They misguide people publicly. This has to be called out. There’s no ghaiba, if a person shamelessly sins publicly.
I have read about 400 pages of the book. It gave life to my Deen, just Like how the Imam rahimahu Allah said!
Amazing book.
Brother what's the book name?
Hujjat al Islam 👌
Paraphrasing Imam An Nawawi if I'm not mistaken: he said, if we were to keep one book after the Book of Allah regarding The Deen, Ihya Ulum Ad-deen would be sufficient.
I agree 100%. But this has to be done with sound knowledge from the Quran and Sunnah.
It was surprising to me when I first read some works of early sufi scholars how harsh they were while addressing these matters and our egos ... It's a mixture of harshness+wisdom+beauty it's really special and authentic ❤
Allah says to overlook their misdeeds and pardon them... And the prophet (peace be upon him) says to not insult their beliefs lest they insult yours.
WHAT?! 😵
Allah says be harsh against kuf far and hypocrites
@@UmmerFarooq-wx4yo if they don't insult, don't insult. If they insult, insult.
@@jabedhus
At-Taubah 9:73
يَٰٓأَيُّهَا ٱلنَّبِىُّ جَٰهِدِ ٱلْكُفَّارَ وَٱلْمُنَٰفِقِينَ وَٱغْلُظْ عَلَيْهِمْۚ وَمَأْوَىٰهُمْ جَهَنَّمُۖ وَبِئْسَ ٱلْمَصِيرُ
English - Sahih International
O Prophet, fight against the disbelievers and the hypocrites and be harsh upon them. And their refuge is Hell, and wretched is the destination.
Chinese - Ma Jian (Simplified)
先知啊！你当对不信道者和伪信者战斗，并严厉地对待他们，他们的归宿是火狱，那归宿真恶劣！
At-Tahrim 66:9
يَٰٓأَيُّهَا ٱلنَّبِىُّ جَٰهِدِ ٱلْكُفَّارَ وَٱلْمُنَٰفِقِينَ وَٱغْلُظْ عَلَيْهِمْۚ وَمَأْوَىٰهُمْ جَهَنَّمُۖ وَبِئْسَ ٱلْمَصِيرُ
English - Sahih International
O Prophet, strive against the disbelievers and the hypocrites and be harsh upon them. And their refuge is Hell, and wretched is the destination.
Chinese - Ma Jian (Simplified)
先知啊！你当与不信道的人们和伪信的人们斗争，你当以严厉的态度对待他们。他们的归宿是火狱，那归宿真恶劣！
English - Tafsir Ibn Kathir
They insulted Islam by claiming to be muslim and lying about it knowingly they are to be executed due to apostasy according to sharia , daniel is being mild here
Wow uplifting this Sufi Scholar, I am impressed.
Sahīh tasawwūf is a discipline within Islam
@@AshrafAnam I agree
Lol @@issakabeer1535
Love Imam Ghazali, RA. ❤
What a good video, May Allah bless you and give you and your family the highest levels of Jannah ♥
Congratulations for reaching 400k.🎉
The G.O.A.T Imam al Ghazali said it right.
Today in Eid khudba, imam said "there are 49 muslim countries, with more than a billion muslim, yet we are being barred, tortured and killed like animals". So if anybody don't want to criticize, think again. Eid mubarak
1:30 i love this stage😂😂
I think we should. 😆 But we'll be labeled as terr0rist groups by Modernist Muslims and Vahabis.
eid mubarak amigoes!
Ahssalamu Ahalikum WA Rahmatullahi wa Barkatullah Brother And Eid Ul Adha Mubarak 🌙⭐🌼🌺 love for Allah from Bangladesh BD 💚🇧🇩❤🇵🇸
THANKS TO ALLAH ALMIGHTY I FOUND YOUR CHANNEL ❤
Same. We need the prevalence of true Islam back. Traditional Sunnism needs to counter the spread of modernist Islam, colonist favored Islam and Wahabism.
Daniel Haqiqatjou is a Lion of Islam
Brother, what you do is the best example of how to apply islam
We must NOT tolerate hram
And we must PRASE a good action even if it is on the same person
We must never care about someone's states nor his position
Tolerating keeps roten people on top while the good people down
Madhkhali's has taken over Bangladesh and india😢
What is Madhkhali?
Not anymore
If legendary scholars like Imam Ghazali, Imam Abu Hanifa, Imam Shafi, Salahuddin al-Ayyubi, and 100s of other Sunni imams had not existed, most Muslims today would likely be atheists. Their contributions to Islamic theology and the preservation of the deen through intellectual pursuit and jihad are the reasons you are a Muslim and not an atheist.
This is especially important to say for modern times where intellect is seen as most important trait next to good external looks, nowadays if you are seen as uneducated, even if you are morally great person, you are seen as overall inferior unfortunately.
" most Muslims today would likely be atheists"
Just a matter of time and they will be.
Wallahi I’m extremely confused on Yassir Qadi. What makes a knowledgeable Muslim deviate so much???
A comfortable life.
Try and read the translation of the Qu'ran. It won't teach you the nuance of Arabic, but we should learn what our scripture says. I recommend the ayahs around 170 of Surah 7.
Do you think it May be possible that yasir qadhi is in the right and you are in the wrong? Why are you so certain about your opinion if are at the end only a follower of an opinion not a Scholar?
The effects of modernity and Americanism
@alirasheed5246 I see your dp is our last Caliph Abdul Hamid II _rahimahu-llāh_ . Modernist Yasir Qadhi does not believe the Caliphate is a practical political order but believes every nation state (which in itself is based on godless foundations) should exercise its own system (democracy, dictatorship, Shari'a, monarchy, etc.). He believes an American Muslim should be proud and patriotic toward America.
I am not a fan of brother Daniel’s harsh approach, but also appreciate his role in being the whip that keeps the daees in check. His harshness is necessary to put limits on us spreading too far left or too far Khawarij/Madhkhalee. May Allah guide us all.
Ha ha ha HA ha !! Guess who?🦩A little bird told me a country in the Middle East is going to build the world's tallest roller coaster in the city of Qiddya. The irony of it, Qiddya= Kidding ya = Kidding you ! 🤣🤣 Are they building it for the thousands of Palestinian orphans ? What can possibly go wrong ?
Liberal modernists and feminists will feign outrage, but their moral system is what creates this situation.
Liberal principles of individual choice, female empowerment, and destruction of patriarchy create a society of people who have no family to take care of them in their old age.
The liberal feminist solution to this problem is to create more welfare programs. What this means is that they want the elderly to live alone in what are essentially pods, their only human interaction being with "care" takers to check if they're still alive once a week.
Let me put it like this. The only human solution is for the elderly to be surrounded by loving family in their old age. The only way to get that is patriarchy, gender roles, and other limitations on individual freedom. But the liberal mind can not allow any of that. So the elderly will continue to suffer, and liberal feminists and modernists will continue to pretend like they care about humanity.
There are different modes of prevention of sins in different stages.
The first stage is to know the condition of the sinner,
The second stage is to inform him of the harm of sin,
The third stage is to prevent him from doing the sinful act
The fourth stage is to advise him, and give him admonition
The fifth stage is to rebuke him and use harsh words,
The sixth stages is to apply force,
The seventh stage is to give him threat of beating,
The eight stage is to actually beat him the ninth stage is to use weapons against him
and
The tenth stage is to fight against him with followers and soldiers.
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
I love you my brother May Allah be with you
Al Ghazali is one of my favorite. Btw these "scholars" do nothing but religion. They forget that the OG suhabba did MANY things aside from religion. Being a good Muslim is also showing the world Islam in application by contributing on many fronts to help humanity.
JAK Daniel! You are a luminary to shake the clearly broken Muslim "leadership".
Allah Knows Best
جزاك الله خيرا
I read Al ghazali and I click
Masha'Allah
Very Interesting. Masha Allah. Thank you, jazaka Allah khair.
"O believers! Do not let some ˹men˺ ridicule others, they may be better than them, nor let ˹some˺ women ridicule other women, they may be better than them. Do not defame one another, nor call each other by offensive nicknames. How evil it is to act rebelliously after having faith! And whoever does not repent, it is they who are the ˹true˺ wrongdoers." (Quran, 49:11)
No one is above criticism. The real scholars welcomed criticism. There’s a difference between real critique and call to cancel. The latter is toxic and the former can be a source of blessing for many. I think i admire this show for the eye of detail and its astuteness in calling Spade a spade.
I loved this part of the show haha
Jazaka Allah khayr
❤❤❤ I totally agree with you brother... keep doing the good work 🔥🔥🔥
Umar RA said: 'Do not honor them (the kuffar) when Allah has humiliated them, do not draw them near when Allah has distanced them, and do not trust them when Allah has deemed them treacherous.'
Sunan Kubra Al-Bayhaqi (10/127), authenticated by Shaykh Al-Albani in "Al-Irwa" (8/255-256/no. 2630).
Imagine if the "celebrity imams" discuss these passages on their channels. They stay within the first 2 stages and don't even tell the masses about the other stages. Yes, we need a proper Islamic governing body like khilafah to implement the last stages but we can certainly implement more than the first 2 stages living as a minority in the West.
And if we examine the current secular Western "Sharia" they are very harsh from the first stage with their "transgressions." Anytime someone says something against the LGBTQ+ lifestyle people can be fired from their job right away without warning and they don't even have much chance of winning the case in the courts.
Love what you do. Appreciations from Bangladesh.
Can you give links to this book please?
If you research the creed of Sunnis (the majority of Muslims past and present), which includes the four schools of fiqh and two schools of aqidah, in the same way a sincere non-Muslim researches Islam, you will see the lies and deceptions made by the Salafis/Wahhabis, similar to how the Western media portrays Islam.
Bakris**
Imam ghazali is based
Can I translate some of your videos to my native language?
The term haram police is used to continue the sins
Don't listen to those fools Daniel they don't want you to expose them
As usual Thanks Br Daniel.
What's your take about the role of Moral policing in Islamic countries
بارك الله فيك سيدي و جزاك الله كل خير ❤❤❤❤
It is well within our rights to do so, don't they ever read the Qur'an where Allah said that we are the best nation that encourage good, forbid evil, and believe in Allah
Surah Ali Imran - 110
But, what are the sources Imam Ghazali depended on?
جزاک اللہ خیرا
رحم الله حجة الإسلام.
قال الذهبي:
الغزالي
الشيخ الإمام البحر ، حجة الإسلام ، أعجوبة الزمان زين الدين أبو حامد محمد بن محمد بن محمد بن أحمد الطوسي ، الشافعي ، الغزالي ، صاحب التصانيف ، والذكاء المفرط .
You are absolutely right
If a sin is done in public and not in secrecy then it must be addressed. Look at Abu Lahab, he was cooked publicly
I don’t recognize al-Ghazali (rahimahu Allah) as an imam of the Muslims due to nearly his entire scholarly career (before his final repentance a short time before his death) having been spent in pursuit and propagation of deviant creeds and ideas, but he was definitely right in this instance, and we should recognize this.
أخالفك في بعض الأساليب الاخ دانيال ولكن ادعوا الله سبحانه وتعالى ان تكون مثل الامام الغزالي في عصرنا هذا كما كان الغزالي في عصره وفقك الله لكل خير
May Allah SWT guide us all.
If Ghazali said "insult them" then he is wrong and going against the Sunnah and the character of the Prophet. Our Prophet is the guide, and he overrrules any claim of any scholar.
I am very proud with the things you do, I appreciate you being highly critical and inquisitive, a trait associated with people sincerely searching for Allah's truth, But an important teaching of Allah towards his messenger was to be at peace with how absurdly insincere and hypocritical MANY people are, you maybe burdened with the idea "if people would've known, things would be different", but you know what, many do already, they just lie pretty well, so, we do what we do for the Allah's reward and not the actual results, and however what we do, its clearly set in the Quran that the majority of people are much like what we see now, and sometimes you cant tell between a misguided Muslim and a monafeq, so we might as well do what we do with peace of mind and acceptance coz we cant do anything about everything else
رحم الله الامام الغزالي
❤ subhan Allah Excellent
Can someone explain then, why musa as was told to speak with softness to firaun, I mean no one today is as bad as him. So can anyone clarify? Jazakallah khair
He was a respected man in his people. You need to respect a person who is respected. But that doesn't mean you would have to agree with him. It's like "hate the act, not the person doing the act". A Haqiqatjoe said "You have to try your best to correct them and to make them agree with you, not to offend them or fight them intentionally.
Firaun (Pharaoh) said to hazrat Musa(AS) that "i raised you in my home, and you also k*lled a man in my country Egypt" so Hazrat Musa (AS) taughted him back "it was you who had ensl*ved my people, which is why my mother had to leave me in the river. If you hadn't done so i wouldn't have had the need to be re raised at your home. As for the man i k*lled, it was a mistake" ( Hazrat Musa (As) punched a guy while defending another man but the punched guy d**d as Hazrat Musa was really powerful).
So some would say this was harsh. But hazrat musa(As) still tried to respect pharaoh as much as he could, but not so much that the pharaoh would start thinking that Musa (As) is a coward.
So try to be in between. Give respect, but never justify your fears in the name of 'respecting' others. State the haqq clearly without fear. In a soft way first, then getting harsher as suitable.
The Greatest Man, (Matthew 11:11), to have walked this earth up until the time of Christ, said:
“HE it is, who coming after me is preferred before me, whose shoe's latchet I am not worthy to unloose.”
Also
“HE must increase, but I must decrease.”
Also
“Behold the LAMB OF GOD, which taketh away the sin of the world.”
The Greatest MAN that ever walked this earth said:
“HE that hath seen ME hath seen the FATHER.”
Also
“I and MY FATHER are ONE.”
Also
“I come from GOD.”
Also
“If I do not the works of MY FATHER, believe me not. But if I do, though ye believe not ME, believe the works: that ye may know, and believe, that the FATHER is in ME, and I in HIM.”
Also
“for if ye believe not that I AM HE, ye shall die in your sins.”
Also
Then said Jesus, “Father, forgive them; for they know not what they do.”
Also
“Go ye therefore, and teach all nations, baptizing them in the NAME of the FATHER, and of the SON, and of the HOLY GHOST:”
The RENOWNED GOD hating, hell bent man that has walked this earth said this to his followers, (in context):
If they will not say the Shahada and will not pay the Jizyah R ,E ,T ,H ,G ,U ,A ,L ,S< them.
May Allah bless imam Al Ghazali
Mashallah!!!
*Consensus on Imam Ghazalee vs Ibn Taymiyya in Issues of Kalam?*
Bro, you are a great role model for us. Don't worry, carry on
He's the engineer of Madhkhalism.
3:159
So by mercy from Allāh, [O Muḥammad], you were lenient with them. And if you had been rude [in speech] and harsh in heart, they would have disbanded from about you. So pardon them and ask forgiveness for them and consult them in the matter. And when you have decided, then rely upon Allāh. Indeed, Allāh loves those who rely [upon Him].
Abraham used harsh words when it's necessary, Lot also used harsh words when it's necessary
And ofc these two individuals are mentioned in the Quran
Moses literally slapped ignorant people to death, it's Also mentioned in the Quran
so are you a better person than Abraham, Lot and Moses who did harsh things towards ignorant people, when it's necessary?
when it's necessary, that's the point
nobody says you have to always use harsh words all the time
To be fair big scholars in Islamic history were super harsh against each other 🤷🏾♂️. I respect them but only scholars should be harsh against other scholars not some random laymen with a TH-cam channel sorry
What's your definition of scholar? Every Muslim should know and understand islam. Scholars weren't born special. Anyone can become a scholar.
"beatings and weapons" 😂
Effective unlike what the European or American does
Is that wrong tho? They leave you no other option
@@cyberyousef7519 it’s not, but the soft pink sensibilities of the European and American man, cannot stand the thought of physical punishment
أمرك عجيب، تقارن ما كتب الشيخ الغزالي عن الفساق والزنادقة ليتم تطبيقه على الشيوخ وطلاب العلم. سبحان الله..الله يهديك ويصلحك ويصلح الجميع
Imam Ghazali was talking about this kind of shaykhs. Read the introduction of his book Ihya Ulumiddin.
Brother Daniel could you tell me the book name plz. If anyone know the book name of Gazhali drop the comment
BarakAllahu feek for seeking knowledge but you have the right to know that Al-Gazhali is not an imam according to ahl al sunnah wal jamaah, may Allah increase your knowledge he's an Ash'ary whom we do not consider kuffar but are quite dangerous to islam. May Allah keep us on the straight path.
@@MuhammadNayef-ze4rc I'm also a Sunni but I thought that was book name. Indeed we have best/beutiful book that is 'Quran" .
Thank u brother for ur advise.
May Allah swt show us straight path.
Ameen
Ibn Hajr was Also Ashari
@MuhammadNayef-ze4rc
The book name is Enjoining Good and Forbidding Evil.
Mr. If you pray for the people of Gaza, it will become a political khatib of this year's Hajj sermon
Surah alqalam 10-11
(do not yield to any contemptible swearer)
(to any backbiter, slander-monger)
Sahih Muslim 47
(He who believes in Allah and the Last Day should either utter good words or better keep silence)
Sahih Muslim 2606
(Should I inform you that slandering, that is in fact a tale-carrying which creates dissension amongst people, (and) he (further) said: The person tells the truth until he is recorded as truthful, and lie tells a lie until lie is recorded as a liar.)
Sahih al-Bukhari 218
(The Prophet (ﷺ) once passed by two graves and said, "These two persons are being tortured not for a major sin (to avoid). One of them never saved himself from being soiled with his urine, while the other used to go about with calumnies (to make enmity between friends)
Why did you gloss over the last part of Stage 3?
Probably bcz It seemed confusing, did u get it?
Sounds nice and good Daniel,
you are telling us this, implying that your opinion is the absolut truth. But you need to keep in mind that the people that you "expose" may be close to the truth than you.
It is your opinion versus their, not kufr vs Iman!
We don't live basis on assumptions sorry br
Salam brother, for 1400 years we had difference on opinions on everything, you claim now to know the absolut truth of every matter and protect the slander of muslims calling to allah?
Alhamdulillah.
why is Ibn Sina's picture in there instead of Imam Al Ghazali Rahmatullah Alayh
It's used everywhere, not just for Ibn Sina
very off topic btw sorry about that had to point it out :)
@@usibistro that's his portrait though you can look it up
He did takfir on Ibn Sina. One of Al-Ghazali's hallmark refutations.
But did the Prophet pbuh also say this? This looks like a rulers way or law.
the prophet (pbuh)said enjoin good and forbid evil and this is a scholar Imam Ghazalis( ra) advice on ways to do that!
ruler is just a human like us, they can make mistake, but the ruler mistakes can become huge impact to the ummah. its more dangerous than individual civilian mistake, but just ruler will have huge rewards
@@ozg-dl3mr you are also conflating 2 things.
the first thing is what is bad and what is good and the prophet pbuh said do the good and forbid the bad.
the 2nd thing is rulers and Muslim now giving themselves the power to say what should be done to those people, while the Quran clearly states in many occasions that the Prophet pbuh should only advice.
so, no, they are not following the Prophet pbuh, they are either following their own interpretation or it is a law (which is man-made).
My point is that if it is a law, then people should follow the law, but don't say it's Sharia.
@@ClipofTheDayy Prove that all rulers of today are Muslim.
@@RobertOfStAlbans_ your question is a contradiction.
Imam? legendary?
The magician philosopher 😂
So i don’t get it? Listen i want to implement enjoining good and forbidding evil
But is there a scenario where these 6 stages are inappropriate? Like can someone do them when he sees non hijabi women?
Bro noooo! we have no authority!! All of this other than to speak is meant if there is an islamic court and islamic country
For your knowledge Imam Gazali was a Sufi,,
We know the Quran says to enjoin the good and forbid the evil, but where does it say in the Quran to beat someone until they stop doing an evil act?
The first three stages are in line with the Quran but the last 4 steps contradict the clear words of Allah where even Muhammad was told by Allah, "You are not a keeper over them", "Your duty is only to deliver the Message".
Can someone please explain from the Quran how anyone can claim an authority that Allah did not even allow to Muhammad?
It is taken from the sunnah. A man did a mistake in a 5utba and the prophet insulted him saying he was a bad speaker to correct that public mistake and he did so publicly. The prophet famously ordered a man who was known for gettng publicly drunk to be beaten but forbade to do takfeer on him which shows that what imam al ghazali is saying things that are based on the sunnah. WaLlahu a3lam.
@@exarquazowexa7247 I know they are taken from Hadith but when a Hadith goes against the character we know of Muhammad and contradicts the clear commands of Allah in the Quran then we need examples in the Quran to prove it's legitimacy. The Quran makes it clear that we are permitted to retaliate in like manner when we ourselves or the weak and defenseless are wronged but no mention is made to punish someone who sins against Allah since He has reserved that punishment for Himself. My request was for someone to show where in the Quran it says you can beat someone for committing a sin.
@@SI00000 you are a layman and completely ignkrant of how fi9h works. If a 7adith is authentic; it is authentic. If YOU find it contradictory to the quran, that is YOUR problem.
A muslim have to be careful where he is taking knowledge from, al ghazali was an ashari. For anyone who doesnt know the islamic history: Ahlu Sunnah and the ashaira were enemies since the bidaa of the ashaira were widespread. The ashari used to make takfir on Ahlu sunnah and the opposite is true. Over 400 scholar including ibn Qayyim made takfir of the ashaira. it is enough for a muslim who wants to know the truth to return to the salaf. There might be some contemporaries who view the asharia just ahlul bidah but the truth is to always to go back to the early generations. Because they were the scholars of our Ummah who taught us the Quran and Sunnah. May Allah guide me and all the muslims to the right path.
Imam gazzali was saying that to the Seljuk to help defend Islam from the Ismaili’s and drunkens raving with the kifr / fake Christian’s & crusaders
It’s really what the Pakistani’s need to do to their armed forces es and their fake govt to been seen as Muslim
Thank you for bringing this Imam's wise Stick Beating teachings to TH-cam Daniel :)