Brothers and Sisters! Don't forget to Like, Comment and Share the video to help us reach more people so you can share in the reward in sha Allah! Support Me and The Channel: www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted_button_id=9NUGVQNWSZHEY www.patreon.com/TheMuslimLantern
By the time the Quran was written in the 7th century CE, the Gospels of Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John had already been written. These four Gospels were composed in the first century CE: - **Mark**: Around 65-70 CE - **Matthew**: Around 80-90 CE - **Luke**: Around 80-90 CE - **John**: Around 90-110 CE These Gospels were well-established and widely circulated among Christian communities by the time the Quran was revealed. When the Quran refers to the "Injeel" (Gospel), it is acknowledging the Christian scriptures that include these Gospels. Several scholars support the traditional view that the Gospels were written by the disciples: 1. **Richard Bauckham** - An influential New Testament scholar who argues for the reliability of the Gospels and suggests they are based on eyewitness testimonies. 2. **Craig Blomberg** - A prominent evangelical scholar who has written extensively on the historical reliability of the Gospels, including the traditional authorship attributions. 3. **F.F. Bruce** - A renowned biblical scholar who supported the traditional authorship of the Gospels and wrote extensively on the New Testament’s historical reliability. 4. **Martin Hengel** - A respected German scholar who argued for the early dating and eyewitness origins of the Gospel accounts. 5. **Craig Evans** - A leading New Testament scholar who supports the traditional authorship and the reliability of the Gospel narratives. These scholars, among others, argue based on historical, textual, and external evidence that the Gospels were written by the disciples.
Can you explain how long after the pen and paper incident our prophet passed away? You said why didn’t the prophet punish umar. You know he died two days after that incident right. And why do you Sunnis love to leave o it Allahs name, our prophet said I leave you the Quran and by Allah the ahlul bayt
Prophet SAW said "After I am gone, you will see great conflict. I urge you to adhere to my Sunnah and the path of the Rightly-Guided Caliphs, and cling stubbornly to it. And beware of newly-invented matters, for every innovation is a going astray" (Ibn majah 42,43, Riyad salihin 701 , hadith 28, hadith an nawawi, Mishkat al-Masabih 165, Sunan Abi Dawud 4607) This hadith "adhere my sunnah and rightly guided caliphs and hold it stubbornly" is not saying to follow Caliphs individual teachings, he saying they will protect sunnah. In the same way when Prophet says I'm leaving you two weighty things book of allah and my family, doesn't mean you follow new individual teachings of his family even if they invent things in religion, it means they will protect book of allah and they know,follow his teachings. Why they are not allowed to add festivals/ bidah's means Preaching of islam is completed by prophet himself as stated in quran Prophet Muhammad SAW Prophecized Abu bakr becoming caliph. When they rejecting Abu bakr as Caliph they not just rejecting Abu bakr they also rejecting Prophet mohammad SAW's prophecy which is kuffr. The Prophet said, "But I should say, 'O my head!' I feel like calling Abu Bakr and his son and appoint (the former as my successors lest people should say something or wish for something. Allah will insist on Abu Bakr becoming a Caliph - Sahih Bukhari 7217
@@stormcloud9146 Put Umar aside, do you believe in the Version of the Hadith in Sunni sources? If yes, why do you see it as problematic in a hollistic view?
Sahih al-Bukhari 6339 Narrated Abu Huraira: Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "None of you should say: 'O Allah, forgive me if You wish; O Allah, be merciful to me if You wish,' but he should always appeal to Allah with determination, for nobody can force Allah to do something against His Will."
I left Christianity, became Muslim and was headed down the Shia path. Alhamdulilah he guided me to the follow the Quran, sunnah, all under the understanding of the early Sahaba. One thing that struck me was how Shia worship the Imams and even call on them as intermediaries. It felt identical to Christianity and how I used to call on Jesus. I came to Islam to worship Allah and Allah alone.
Ure a rare gem. May Allah make it easy for you to live among them and keep you steadfast. Ive lived in Iran from 5th to 7th grade staying in Pasdaran ave in late 80s . None of my Iranian friends cared about religion. I hope you can make hijra to a muslim country ⚘️
I am from Kuwait, i was Shia and my whole family, i always founded their beliefs are always nonsense but i kept being a Shia until i really fell in love with the Quran, always asking Allah alone for guidance, until 2 years ago i sat with a Shia Sheikh, he was not clear and used false evidence with bad understanding, i knew something was off about it but then i realized that Shia Kuwait is different than other Shia because they lived with Sunni Muslims so they don’t do direct sherk, meanwhile i submitted to god and his words and saw Sunni is the only true path that follows Quran
I just converted to Islam 3 days before this past Ramadan Alhamdulillah. Then the Shia or Sunni question came and got confused but I knew that just like the Quran has the answers to life I knew it would have my answer for this question. Sunni is the way!
my advice for you is try stick on the Quran,InshaAllah all of your confusion get answer.Dont watch the video that give you doubt because syatan love it.Happy for you welcome to Islam❤
Shia sect came after the death of the prophet PBUH. It was more of a political issue, such as which imaam is going to be the leader. That's why you see some Shias worshiping or giving attributes to the companions of the prophet, which is haram.
A much needed video. I also left Shiaism when I came across this channel through one of your old video, where you were debating a shia girl. And since then i waited every day for someone to come on your stream and discuss this sect with you. Because i also struggle with convincing my family that all this is not Islam. But every time they would make me feel guilty by saying things like you are degrading Ahl e bait. And that no matter what you do now Allah is not going to accept that from you. Plus the ambiguous ayats from the quran that they show me to prove their points it's just so difficult for me to deal with them logically. Thank you brother Ali for making this video.
Salam, I am Shia and would like to debate. I am interested in what convinced you that Shiaism is wrong. Perhaps either you can guide me to the truth or I can guide you.
I was a shia before and when i read the quran a couple of times a lot of things became clear that the ahlal sunnah way is the truth. It is just that a lot of shias use their emoties more than logic.
@@HusseinAlAmili12no point in debating, Did u watch the 50 minute video? Following the Sunnah of prophet Muhammad ﷺ and having tawhid of Allah ﷻ is the only truth
not Sunni my friend. Muslim. Sunni is the accepted Islamic school of thought. we're Muslims and we reject whoever practice shirk, naudzubillah minzalik.
She sounds sincere and genuinely seeking the truth , May Allah guide her and steadfast her honest pure heart And may Allah reward you greatly for your dawah Mohamed , we love you for the sake of Allah
I left shiism in 2008 and accepted Islam and Sunnah, back then it was hard because there was less awareness about shi'a, there wasn't much content or support but now alhamdulillah i see so many shi'a leaving it and coming to the haqq.
@@MojtabaKarimi-x5vMy brother i saw your comment about your story in this comments section. May Allah protect and preserve you and grant you a big family so that you and they may continue to spread the haqq in your home country. Allah rewards people in accordance to the difficulty of what they have to do to obey and people like you my brother will be rewarded immensely on yawm al qiyamah Insha’Allah.
To a revert like me, Shiaism is like Catholicism. Blind zealotry for figures that aren’t Messengers of Allah swt. Veneration of righteous people into divine intercessors.
I am an ex-Shia originally from Afghanistan and I am a Sayyid. After reading the entire Quran with the intention of seeking the truth back in 2013, I realized that the foundations of Sunni belief is mentioned in details in explicit verses multiple times while the foundations of Shia belief is not only not found in the Quran but it in fact warns against those concepts which is the foundation of Shiaism. Therefore, I was faced with two alternatives: 1) Either I ignore the clear message of the Quran and continue being a Shia because it is difficult to accept that I have been wrong up until this moment and just continue believing what I have been growing up with because its convenient, or 2) Literally implement the meaning of the word ´´Muslim´´ which means submission to the will of Allah swt, and with all humility and genuinety accept the message of the Quran even if it has been against my belief all the time up until now. Of course, with the guidance of Allah swt, I ended up choosing the second alternative, and since 2013, I am a proud Muslim who follows pure tawhid and the authentic Sunnah of the Prophet SAW. Ever since then I feel an inner peace and security for disassociating myself from shirk and superstitious beliefs, rituals and practices. My advice to the sincere Shias is to read the Quran and as you are reading it constantly ask yourself whether you see the core beliefs of Shiaism in it or not, without resorting to word-games, weird analogies, twisted examples from every day life or using weak and fabricated narrations.
It has been narrated on the authority of Jabir b. Samura who said: I heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) say: Islam will continue to be triumphant until there have been twelve Caliphs. Then the Prophet (ﷺ) said something which I could not understand. I asked my father: What did he say? He said: He has said that all of them (twelve Caliphs) will be from the Quraish. Sahih Muslim 1821d Book 33, Hadith 8 Like Muhammed Ali said in the beginning of this debate, bring it back to Qur'an and Messenger. The Messenger (pbuh) said there will be 12 Khalifas (Imams, or whatever titles you want to use). Can Sunnis name all these 12 people that they were supposed to follow? The thing that makes Shias really dislike Sunnis' behaviour as seen in these comments, is that they say that Shias are kafirs.
@@stormcloud9146 When you answer a question with a question, it shows that you don't want to answer the question. Most of the time, it's because the answer would be an admission. When you don't want to admit, you deflect with a counterquestion. I'll ask again, who are the 12 Khalifas that The Prophet (pbuh) said we should follow? Do Sunnis follow them? Do they even subscribe to a 12 Khalifa narrative at all, or do they pretend that there's no such thing as 12 to be followed after The Prophet (pbuh)?
@@WahidShirin when are you debating, non-Muslims rather than talking 24x7 about ahlussunnah When are you actually going to talk about Islam and preaching Islam to non-Muslims and refuting their allegations? Where is your most known shia hiding
Has nothing to do with them and absolutely wouldn't stand for this mockery just like Isa AS wouldn't stand to be elevated to divine status. It's just plain wrong.
The shia is actually quite similar to christianity,the Shia have a picture of Ali (Ra) same as the Christian..the Christian has a lenten penitential sacrifice and the shia has rituals take place during the first ten days of Muharram
Yea, you know Imam Ali and the Prophet's daughter Fatima really loved Abu Bakr and Umar... You know, those that you base your religion on aswell as Muawiya and Yazid.
These educational experiences are truly some of the best gems on TH-cam in general. Thank you for this clip. May Allah elevate and forgive the believers of this ummah in this life and the next.
most of the disbelievers have some common practices; Christianity, shia, Hinduism...etc they worship men and creations of almighty Allah swt. They are uplifting normal men to be close to prophets and they use their names to get closer to their god. Satan has been using the same thing since the beginning and humans still fall in the same trick
I was brought up as a shia from Iran as well, Alhamdulillah Allah guided me to the true Islam. Sadly, majority of Iranians have become Islamophobes due to the corrupt version of the shias, thinking that is the real Islam.
Reading into Shiaism. It's more of a political issue about who's going to be the next leader. From there, you can see why Shias believe what they believe, like giving Allah's attributes to companions of the prophet. It is always about politics. Alhamdulliah for Quran, it gives us the foundations for Islam. Alhamdulliah! May Allah guide us all towards the straight path. Ameen
Which Shia era? The Shi'at-'Ali during his life existed with the known reputation of being Shi'at Ali. So the original Shia, you honor as being on Haqq, correct?
Amazing discussion subhaaaanallah 🥹🥹 May Allah guide her family and friends to the right path as well and protect all of us from trials in our deen and keep us all steadfast 🤍🤍
I'm proud of you sister. You're doing some amazing critical thinking for the sake of truth. Sometimes our own family can be our tests. Stick with The Quran and one cant go wrong. I loved seeing your honesty & sincerity. May Allah guide you to the truth, to His closeness and be pleased with you Allahumma ameen. I appreciate the shias but one thing I find interesting is that shias make the whole religion about ahle-bait (I believe Allah is pleased with them but they wont be happy with us if we tweek their effort for Islam). Islam is so much more like Surah Ikhlas, tawheed❤ & all about Allah's deen.
"And who is more astray than he who invokes besides Allāh those who will not respond to him until the Day of Resurrection, and they, of their invocation, are unaware. And when the people are gathered [that Day], they will be enemies to them, and they will be deniers of their worship." Surah Al-Ahqaf 5-6
“Quran4:59 - O you who believe, obey God, and obey the Messenger and the holders of authority amongst you”) and Surah Yasīn (Quran36:12 - “And We have encompassed all things in the Manifest Imām”)
@@j86485 First subscribe and put notifications on for the channel so you’re told when brother M.A goes live. There is no set schedule but this is usually Sat/Sun evening UK time.
@@ShiaSunniSeries It is because 33:32 starts with "O wives of the Prophet" - giving the context for verse 33. The hadith you quoted mentions the context of the last part of verse 33 where it says "O members of the family".
The majority of the Persian peoples were Sunnis, but Ismail al-Safavi forced them to embrace Shiite thought and distanced them from true Islam. I hope that we will unite again on one religion, as was the case with the first generation of Muslims
@rajababy2009 none of this matters, ultimately Sunni and Shia majority was NOT the result of freedom of thought and choice. From Bani Umayya to Abbasid to Mongol invasion and then ottoman era etc they were all imposed school of thought, chosen by the ruler for political reasons
i like how professional brother muhammed did the discussion. He didnt just simply answered the questions of her about the little details etc. but started at the root and base of her believe and step by step cleared the fog she had in front of her eyes.
@@ShiaSunniSeries what exactly do you not understand about the principle of using the Qur'an without anything external, that was established and agreed by both parties? This particular discussion is only about which beliefs is Qur'an aligned with, whose foundations are found in the Qur'an by looking at it alone. Since we disagree on the other sources what is the point of the opposing side cherry picking from it what they think suits their position, it leads nowhere since they are not using the source as a whole or accepting it in the first place. Do we accept this hadith, yes but we also accept all the other ahadith that are reliable and give information on the topic, and conclusion is based on looking at the revelation altogether regarding it. But as the brother said even if he were to be charitable and accept this idea that the shia bring without the support of the Qur'an itself, where does it in the verse say that you should follow them? It doesn't, and purification is mentioned in other places for all the companions, so now what? With all due respect shi'as in this comment section who've written their objections only show that they are one of 2 things. They are either insincere and choose to ignore what was clearly demonstrated using purely the Qur'an, or they didn't listen and comprehend the points being made correctly so they basically didn't grasp the conversation. If you want to say the brother is misrepresenting something either from our position or yours or denying it, the live streams are open for you, come and say it bravely to his face and demonstrate it with evidence instead of accusing him of lying and deception while sitting behind your keyboard.
We follow Prophet Muhammad pbuh and his companions including Imam Ali R.A but we dont pray to them like shia does We don't curse his woves like Shia does.
I’m very confused. Why are they following 12 imams when the Quran clearly states Prophet Muhammad (SAW) is the last and final messenger. Meaning there are no teachings of Allah(SWT) to follow after him as the final messenger. And they praise Ali more than any Prophet including Prophet Muhammad (SWT). Why are they praising humans and not focussing only on Allah(SWT). Allah(SWT) commanded to follow His teachings in Quran and from the final messenger Prophet Muhammed(SAW). Not human lineage, families, culture, history.
Imam Abu Bakr, Imam Umar, Imam Uthman, and Imam Ali. Why you make Ali is the only Imam? We recognize 4 Imam (leaders) after prophet Muhammad (pbuh) died.
Brother Ali is dismantling their wrong beliefs on Ali RA. SubhanAllah May Allah bless Br. Mohammed Ali more and increase him and the ummah in every way.
@@ShiaSunniSeries He talks about the verse of the quran not hadith Quran 33:33 as mentioned to wives of the prophets as what they must do and they are also mentioned as ah lul bait The hadith also was clarified as no issues they were purified no where does it mentioned follow them I guess you were listening to him but not understanding the words coming out of his mouth.
Dang! MashAllah Muhammad Ali has 400,000 followers now lol I was following him when he had like 10k followers or less! I kept seeing it grow but I already knew his channel might take longer than other Muslim channels due to his detailed explanations and ZERO CLOUT edits. Muhammad if you read this never change the method of Quran and Sunnah. I’m a revert Latina Muslimah. Alhamdulillah I learned so much from your videos and it encouraged me to enroll in Islamic university because of how detailed and encouraging you were. May Allah continue to bless you. Ameen
May Allah preserve and protect you akhi Muhammad. You are doing a great work and we need more of you who deeply understand and eloquent in passing the clear Islam to others in need. جزاك الله خير الجزاء
The Prophet ﷺ said: ❰ By Him in Whose Hands my life is, none of you will have faith till he loves me more than his father and his children. ❱ Sahih al-Bukhari 14
This video can serve as a benchmark for anyone having the question or confusion in the mind. The foundation is very clear and strong and clears all the conflicts elegantly. That's the beauty of Islam, the principles are so clear that unless you want to go astray, you won't!
She came live before 10th Muharram but MA didn't upload this clip as he might have thought people would think he deliberately uploaded this video on occasion that is sacred to Shias to hurt their feelings. My bro's so clever he care for the timing as well.
We should stop linking the blessed day of Ashoura to them and go back to linking it to its original context, Prophet Muhammad pbuh told us to celebrate the day that Allah saved Musa pbuh and his companions and destroyed pharaoh and his army. And we do so by fasting it and all kinds of worship and knowledge-seeking.
@@MariaBKBKThat's the invented Bani Umayya mythology. Look into debates on the topic with evidence from Yahud history and religious holidays and calendars. Whoever invented the myth of Ashura being a Jewish celebration really did a poor job. It's a cover story to forget the crimes of Bani Umayya in Karbala
She just wanted to ask her question about open and closed handed prayer and M.A ignores that and dismantled the whole shia believe lol appreciate the video still its a eye opener to see what shia believe about us
Yah that 12 imam business is totally mind blowing. They apparently have an Imam Pope always around. I am in shock. How can anyone believe such blatant deviation. May we be protected from ignorance and be guided.
@@zedzpanAre the 12 Imam alive or passed? What if one passes? Do they reincarnate another Imam like a Bhudda? It’s all very confusing and not apart of Islam
@oromtitiwbo5078 Indeed. It makes zero sense. They just made it up, gave God like attributes to a man. Honestly, still in shock. How can they even defend this position. They are way outside of the fold. Satan is remarkably good at continuing to lead mankind astray, yet man is too ignorant and proud to leave the astray path of their forefathers. May we be protected from going astray.
Most people of Shia background living in the West find Shia ism abhorrent for a variety of reasons but namely because they feel their “freedoms” are severely limited. I wish they knew more about Sunna Islam and this most informative video.
Yea most Iranian diaspora I have met are the ex muslim type who become Christian or atheist and talk about how oppressive Islam is as if they were ever muslim to begin with
they did left zorastianism and Iran became an important part of Islamic world and empire but in 16 century the Safavid dynasty came in power and they were sufis and in fear of ottomans becoming popular in Iran because they are the same religion, the safavids became Shia and imported hundreds of top shia clerics from lebanon and started prosecuting sunni majority Iran, closing down their Mosques, killing their religious leaders and killing anyone who resisted, thats why ottomans called them kafirs and went in war with safavids but they started good but not successful in the end because they were fighting two front and also this was also the reason that modern day Afghanistan region rebelled in 18 century and dismantled the safavid dynasty but unfortunately they lost power in a few years because mahmod hotaki died young and next iranian dynasty kept iran a shia state, yiu can search “how Iran became Shia” amd also there is a book called ‘The History of Ismail Safavi - The Bringers of Shiism’ you can read this in Persian and Arabic
@@alFarsi570I'm not talking about Iran specifically. I mean Shi'ism. If you study the theology from the time of Ali May Allah be pleased with him and especially after the death of Hussein may Allah be pleased with him, and you read how the theology developed over the centuries - it seems clear to me that many Persians did not truly give up their pagan roots after Islam spread to them. It just went underground and morphed into shi'ism. I'm not talking geopolitics here. Specifically the theology. For example, why do they revere Hussein and his line so much more than Hasan? Oh, they give different answers, but none that really explain the huge difference in reverence. But when you learn that the Persians of old used to trace their kings' bloodlines through their mothers, and then you learn that Hussein may Allah be pleased with him married one of the last Persian princesses after the muslims conquered Persia, it all makes sense. They don't truly revere Hussein's line because of Hussein (and Ali). They revere Hussein's line because the mother is the link to the old Persian kings
@@thepoetesskhansaaSo after Karbala who was the leader of the Ahl al-Bayt? There was no election between Hassan line and Husayn, correct? It was by appointment from Husayn. Correct?
@@CaptainN. there was never any "leader" of ahlul bayt. Stop with the rubbish. The true ahlul bayt and their line have always hidden themselves so as not to distinguish themselves among the muslims. They dispersed all over the muslim world and kept quiet about who they are. There is no leader. That's shia brainwashing
"Oh yeah that makes the sense"- sister saying this seems very polite and broad minded. May Allah guide her to the straight path. And may Allah bless our brother Muhammad Ali more wisdom and knowledge. It was a nice and perfect discussion.Jazakallahu Khairan ❤.
For all the shias and others sects that are not following the way of the prophet and his companions, fear Allah and be sincere. Anyone who will bring a way other than Islam, it will not be accepted and he will be among the losers.
احسن الظن في الناس وكأن كل الخير فيهم، واعتمد على نفسك كأنه لا خير في الناس.🎉🤲🧕Free Palestine From Palestine, Gaza City call from Gaza from the midst of war death, hunger, destruction and pain. To the lovers of goodness, a kind greeting to every Muslim from a Palestinian mother from Gaza. The Prophet, may God’s prayers and peace be upon him, said: “We will never diminish the money you have given in charity.” narrated by Muslim ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''"""""""""""""""""""💔 """"""""""""""""""""""""'""""""""" """" "" "" "" "" "" "" "" "'" ""''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''🤲 I have four orphan children, and we are in the midst of a war of extermination, displacement, hunger, pain, wounds, and deprivation. They were martyred in this war. My family and now I'm alone without a father. Today, I make this appeal to you from among the rubble and destruction, my brothers. I live under difficult circumstances, an unjust siege, and a blind war that destroyed my city in which I live, and my home that houses my children’s dreams. Today, I found myself living on top of the ruins of my home in a tent no more than a few meters long, with me and my four children. This is a very difficult thing that no human being can bear. I live in very difficult conditions without food, water, and flour due to the siege, and we drink water. Polluted due to lack of money and my children’s fear of war, and now I am asking for help and assistance in order to restore the smile of life to my children, and I am in dire need of your contribution in order to rebuild my house that was demolished, and I ask (00970592511969)To donate, WhatsApp wrote to you these short words that do not express a little of the pain and wounds that we are experiencing in Gaza, and I write these words to you while tears do not leave my eyes from the pain and cruelty of life. I hope that you will be supporters of my cause in all parts of the world and the ugliness of the injustice that we live in every day, but every minute. We lose loved ones every day. And do not forget the difficulty of life in a small tent that does not exceed a few meters. God was a protector for us from the heat of summer and the cold of winter in the tent, and today all my dreams are to drink a drop of cold, clean water in the summer and feed my children. Praise be to God in any case, this is God’s command. Note: I have a child who is sick in the eye, and he is forbidden by the doctor’s prescription from high heat and sunlight. How can he be in a very hot tent? Therefore, I ask you to help me in maintaining my house. """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""يارب قد دقت الدنيا بنا وانت ارحم الراحمين نداء انا عندي اربع طفال ونحن فى ظل حرب الاباده والتهجير والتجويع والالم والجراح والحرمان لقد استشهدوا في هذا الحرب اسرتي وانا الان وحيدة بلا اب واليوم ارسل ندائي هذا من بين الركام والدمار لكم يا إخوتي انا اعيش في ظل ظروف صعبة و حصار ظالم وحرب عمياء ولقد دمرت مدينتي التي اعيش فيها و دمر بيتي الذي يؤوي احلام اطفالي واليوم لقد وجدت نفسي اعيش فوق ركام بيتي في خيمه لا تتجاوز عدت امتار انا واطفالي الاربعه هذا امر صعب جداً لا يتحمله إنسان واعيش ظروف صعبه جداً بدون طعام وماء و طحين بسبب الحصار ونشرب الماء الملوث بسبب قلت الاموال وخوف اطفالي من الحرب والان اطلب يد العون والمساعدة لكي اعيد بسمة الحياة الي اطفالي وانا في امس الحاجه الي المساهمه لكي اعيد بناء بيتي الذي هدم و ارجو منكم المساهمة كتبت لكم هذي الكلمات القصيرة التي لا تعبر الى القليل من الالم والجراح الذي نعيشه فى غزة واكتب لكم كلماتي هذه والدموع لا تفارق عيني من الالم وقسوة الحياة ارجو منكم ان تكونو مناصرين إلى قضيتي في جميع انحاء العالم وقبح الظلم الذي نعيشه في كل يوم بل كل دقيقه ونحن نفقد الاحبه كل يوم. ولا تنسو صعوبة الحياة في خيمة صغيرة لا تتعدى بعض الامتار كان الله لنا معين من حم الصيف والبرد الشتاء فى الخيمة واليوم كل احلامي ان اشرب نقطة ماء باردة ونظيفه في الصيف وطعام اطفالي. الحمدلله على كل حال هذا امر الله.~~♡~♡~ ~♡~♡~/♡~♡~/~♕😭🎉😭🎉😭🎉😭🎉😭😭🎉😭😭🎉🎉~~♡~/♡~♡~♡~/♡/♡//♡/♡//♡/♡/♡//🧕🧕🧕🧕🧕
Even Christianity, once people started editing the concept, the baraqah goes away. Then the people have no choice but to connect one quote to another to strengthen the assumption/man-made thesis. Lets not go there. Lets stay close to The Quran. Shias & Sunnis both. Study Quran❤
I feel shiah and Christianity feel the same for using not direct verses And explaining them in a way to construct very far away religion and rejecting the direct and obvious teaching
I can’t express on how happy I am to watch your video’s! Morning, evening, during work, during gym.. the amount of knowledge this man has is mind blowing especially his way of explaining!!
Shia in 99 percent about the head of the state (Imama) . 1 percent about Allah . they put people between themselves and Allah they put 12 Imams and Ali and Fatima and Hussien . all they took about is the leadership of the state .
Muhammed Ali has just nailed the conversation. I never expected that she would convince. But at the end she said when the shias foundation itself dismantled i don't have anything to ask. May Allah swt guide her and entire shia community
@@ShiaSunniSeries OKAY LETS TAKE UR STATEMENT FOR THE SAKE OF ARGUMENT OF AHLE-BAIT IT WAS WHOM RASOOL-ALLAH IS TALKING AND WHAT MENTIONED IN QURAN BUT STILL THE QUESTION REMAINS WHERE DOES IT SAY IN THE QURAN FOLLOW THEM ??? YOU GUYS CANT PROVE A THING FROM QURAN THAT SUPPORTS YOUR BELIEF 😄
We love ahlu bait but we don’t make our religion revolve around them. We follow the prophet and the Quran. Ahlu Sunnah ❤ May Allah guide our Shia Muslim brothers and sisters
Alhamdulillah, new knowledge I learned. Every video Brother Muhammad Ali posted always contains something new for me to learn. May Allah reward you with baraka and good rizq, brother.
Barak Allah Feek, going straight to the foundations of the belief so she can understand what is the correct belief rather than just answering the smaller questions she has. May Allah guide her and all the shia to the correct belief and way of Islam
Very beneficial video brother I loved it so much, you really explain everything from The Qur’an, I always loved your explanation because its not biased or from emotional perspective, may Allah ﷻ preserve you brother and may Allah ﷻ guide her and her family and guide us too
Wow, wow, MaashaaAllaah. Brother Mohammad Ali may Allaah bless you and forgive you and your family. May Allaah protect you from evil and harm as you work hard day and night for His religion of Islam and aid you in dispelling falsehood. Aamiin. Take care and be well.
@@m0o0ntecrist08no bro you should read what the scholars of Islam said if you know Arabic language you should separate yourself from ahlu albid'a .but I'm Muslim when I took with my brothers from ahlu Sona or kufar but between tha people of bid'a I'm salafi Suni .
There is a problem in some Indian muslims and pakistani muslims they said that they are Sunni Muslims but because of half knowledge of islam and weak imaan they do follow some shia concepts also and they messed up there faith.....😢and the thing is I'm living around them....pray for them that Allah guide them
Sincerity just lightens up the video and makes it peaceful and beneficial.. I hope that everyone who comes to the stream would be as sincere as her and just seeking the truth ❤❤
Brothers and Sisters! Don't forget to Like, Comment and Share the video to help us reach more people so you can share in the reward in sha Allah!
Support Me and The Channel:
www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted_button_id=9NUGVQNWSZHEY
www.patreon.com/TheMuslimLantern
By the time the Quran was written in the 7th century CE, the Gospels of Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John had already been written. These four Gospels were composed in the first century CE:
- **Mark**: Around 65-70 CE
- **Matthew**: Around 80-90 CE
- **Luke**: Around 80-90 CE
- **John**: Around 90-110 CE
These Gospels were well-established and widely circulated among Christian communities by the time the Quran was revealed. When the Quran refers to the "Injeel" (Gospel), it is acknowledging the Christian scriptures that include these Gospels.
Several scholars support the traditional view that the Gospels were written by the disciples:
1. **Richard Bauckham** - An influential New Testament scholar who argues for the reliability of the Gospels and suggests they are based on eyewitness testimonies.
2. **Craig Blomberg** - A prominent evangelical scholar who has written extensively on the historical reliability of the Gospels, including the traditional authorship attributions.
3. **F.F. Bruce** - A renowned biblical scholar who supported the traditional authorship of the Gospels and wrote extensively on the New Testament’s historical reliability.
4. **Martin Hengel** - A respected German scholar who argued for the early dating and eyewitness origins of the Gospel accounts.
5. **Craig Evans** - A leading New Testament scholar who supports the traditional authorship and the reliability of the Gospel narratives.
These scholars, among others, argue based on historical, textual, and external evidence that the Gospels were written by the disciples.
Can you explain how long after the pen and paper incident our prophet passed away? You said why didn’t the prophet punish umar. You know he died two days after that incident right. And why do you Sunnis love to leave o it Allahs name, our prophet said I leave you the Quran and by Allah the ahlul bayt
Prophet SAW said "After I am gone, you will see great conflict. I urge you to adhere to my Sunnah and the path of the Rightly-Guided Caliphs, and cling stubbornly to it. And beware of newly-invented matters, for every innovation is a going astray" (Ibn majah 42,43, Riyad salihin 701 , hadith 28, hadith an nawawi, Mishkat al-Masabih 165, Sunan Abi Dawud 4607)
This hadith "adhere my sunnah and rightly guided caliphs and hold it stubbornly" is not saying to follow Caliphs individual teachings, he saying they will protect sunnah. In the same way when Prophet says I'm leaving you two weighty things book of allah and my family, doesn't mean you follow new individual teachings of his family even if they invent things in religion, it means they will protect book of allah and they know,follow his teachings. Why they are not allowed to add festivals/ bidah's means Preaching of islam is completed by prophet himself as stated in quran
Prophet Muhammad SAW Prophecized Abu bakr becoming caliph. When they rejecting Abu bakr as Caliph they not just rejecting Abu bakr they also rejecting Prophet mohammad SAW's prophecy which is kuffr.
The Prophet said, "But I should say, 'O my head!' I feel like calling Abu Bakr and his son and appoint (the former as my successors lest people should say something or wish for something. Allah will insist on Abu Bakr becoming a Caliph - Sahih Bukhari 7217
@@stormcloud9146 Put Umar aside, do you believe in the Version of the Hadith in Sunni sources?
If yes, why do you see it as problematic in a hollistic view?
Sahih al-Bukhari 6339
Narrated Abu Huraira:
Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "None of you should say: 'O Allah, forgive me if You wish; O Allah, be merciful to me if You wish,' but he should always appeal to Allah with determination, for nobody can force Allah to do something against His Will."
I left Christianity, became Muslim and was headed down the Shia path. Alhamdulilah he guided me to the follow the Quran, sunnah, all under the understanding of the early Sahaba. One thing that struck me was how Shia worship the Imams and even call on them as intermediaries. It felt identical to Christianity and how I used to call on Jesus. I came to Islam to worship Allah and Allah alone.
Yeah. Me too. I feel Shia is just like Christianity concept. Sounds like they idolized human/Imam as God. Scary.
@@Uda007 god, what have they told you about us 🤦🏻
@@lookingup3390 out of all the things that didn’t happen 😂😂😂👍🏼
@@Uda007that's bcz yahood played the same game with both of these
U did the right thing brother welcome to the real islam
May Allah SWT reward you in the dunya and the akhirah.
mashallah brother.. may Allah accept it from you. and may Allah make me as one who can give like you . ameen
Masyallah brother. Do u have a business or smth?
I am Iranian Sunni Muslim and I have proud for quran and Sunnah alhamdulillah
May Allah keep you steadfast and make it easy for you to practice Islam in Iran.
The best Muslims are the iranians sunnis, humble and honorable and extremely wise. Just like the first ones
@@MobinYazdani-xh7er اهل کجایی برادر؟
@@rimacalid6557 back when iran followed sunnah
Good job not just following blindly
Bless her. She is sincere in her search to understand. May Allah guide her and keep her on the true path.
@@yelbuck may Allah guide her to the truth
Ameen
ameen
The name tag of the girl showing 'Confused Shia' is too funny 😂
ALI ibn abi Talib(R.A) named his sons Uthman, Umar and Abu Bakr. May Allah be pleased with them all.
Ameen
You Mean Muhammad Ali ? He has 3 Kids 😮 Ma Sha Allah
@@AkZain21 no he meant Ali ibn Abi Talib radi'allahu anhu…
@@AkZain21no, not Mohammad ali, Ali R.A.
Mic drop
It's never to late to be Muslim.
Alhamdulillah, I'm not shia.
Love from iran
May Allah protect you. Were you born into a Shia family or are you one of the Sunni minority groups around the outskirts of Iran?
@@InfiniteMotivation23 I live in Tehran.
My family is irreligious. Been so for decades, even my great grandfather was.
Ure a rare gem. May Allah make it easy for you to live among them and keep you steadfast. Ive lived in Iran from 5th to 7th grade staying in Pasdaran ave in late 80s . None of my Iranian friends cared about religion. I hope you can make hijra to a muslim country ⚘️
Do you pray the 5 dailies or the Jumuah in congregation? @MojtabaKarimi-x5v
@@Cyrus-Idris I do not go to mosques, non I know follow sunnah.
I am from Kuwait, i was Shia and my whole family, i always founded their beliefs are always nonsense but i kept being a Shia until i really fell in love with the Quran, always asking Allah alone for guidance, until 2 years ago i sat with a Shia Sheikh, he was not clear and used false evidence with bad understanding, i knew something was off about it but then i realized that Shia Kuwait is different than other Shia because they lived with Sunni Muslims so they don’t do direct sherk, meanwhile i submitted to god and his words and saw Sunni is the only true path that follows Quran
Masha Allah brother welcome to Islam . May Allah protect you
Alhamdullilah you have sheikh uthman al khamees in ur country look at what his debates with the shia! May Allah keep you firm ameen
Allah*
@@saloomyaseen9526 but yasir al habib is from kuwait and he's the worst shi'i on earth.
I just converted to Islam 3 days before this past Ramadan Alhamdulillah. Then the Shia or Sunni question came and got confused but I knew that just like the Quran has the answers to life I knew it would have my answer for this question. Sunni is the way!
May Allah keep you steadfast ❤
Islam ☪️ Agree bro Islam is follow the sunnah of the prophet and the book of Allah. Anything else is innovation by Satan
my advice for you is try stick on the Quran,InshaAllah all of your confusion get answer.Dont watch the video that give you doubt because syatan love it.Happy for you welcome to Islam❤
Shia sect came after the death of the prophet PBUH. It was more of a political issue, such as which imaam is going to be the leader. That's why you see some Shias worshiping or giving attributes to the companions of the prophet, which is haram.
@@JAAD0408 ok reference the parts that convinced you in the Quran that Sunni is the way.. you never read the Quran
A much needed video. I also left Shiaism when I came across this channel through one of your old video, where you were debating a shia girl. And since then i waited every day for someone to come on your stream and discuss this sect with you. Because i also struggle with convincing my family that all this is not Islam. But every time they would make me feel guilty by saying things like you are degrading Ahl e bait. And that no matter what you do now Allah is not going to accept that from you. Plus the ambiguous ayats from the quran that they show me to prove their points it's just so difficult for me to deal with them logically. Thank you brother Ali for making this video.
May Allah guide your family too, aamiin
Salam, I am Shia and would like to debate. I am interested in what convinced you that Shiaism is wrong. Perhaps either you can guide me to the truth or I can guide you.
Marhaba ..
My god bless you
@@HusseinAlAmili12there is 1 or 2 more videos about shiism on this channel, watch them insallah
I was a shia before and when i read the quran a couple of times a lot of things became clear that the ahlal sunnah way is the truth. It is just that a lot of shias use their emoties more than logic.
Care to debate me then? Let's keep it respectful, and inshallah, either you guide me to the truth or I guide you.
@@HusseinAlAmili12 Why don't you go to Muhammad Ali's stream to debate?
@@HusseinAlAmili12Only Allah can guide someone to Truth. So say "may Allah guide u and me to Truth"
@@HusseinAlAmili12no point in debating, Did u watch the 50 minute video? Following the Sunnah of prophet Muhammad ﷺ and having tawhid of Allah ﷻ is the only truth
@@HusseinAlAmili12your on discord?
I am living in a Shia household, but personally I think sunni Islam makes more sense.
Talk to your local sheikhs first brother don’t make any irrational decisions
not Sunni my friend. Muslim. Sunni is the accepted Islamic school of thought. we're Muslims and we reject whoever practice shirk, naudzubillah minzalik.
@@EZ_Abidin so you’re saying shias are polytheists
She sounds sincere and genuinely seeking the truth , May Allah guide her and steadfast her honest pure heart
And may Allah reward you greatly for your dawah Mohamed , we love you for the sake of Allah
Ameen
I’m born Shia but have always had doubts about Shia doctrine. I liked this conversations and open mindedness and respect shown by both individuals.
I left shiism in 2008 and accepted Islam and Sunnah, back then it was hard because there was less awareness about shi'a, there wasn't much content or support but now alhamdulillah i see so many shi'a leaving it and coming to the haqq.
@@ath_thabaat where you from friend?
Allhamdulillah ❤
Did you say the shahada? Were your sins forgiven?
@@MojtabaKarimi-x5vMy brother i saw your comment about your story in this comments section. May Allah protect and preserve you and grant you a big family so that you and they may continue to spread the haqq in your home country. Allah rewards people in accordance to the difficulty of what they have to do to obey and people like you my brother will be rewarded immensely on yawm al qiyamah Insha’Allah.
I left Sunnism in 2009 and reverted to real Islam which is Shiaism.
To a revert like me, Shiaism is like Catholicism. Blind zealotry for figures that aren’t Messengers of Allah swt. Veneration of righteous people into divine intercessors.
I am an ex-Shia originally from Afghanistan and I am a Sayyid. After reading the entire Quran with the intention of seeking the truth back in 2013, I realized that the foundations of Sunni belief is mentioned in details in explicit verses multiple times while the foundations of Shia belief is not only not found in the Quran but it in fact warns against those concepts which is the foundation of Shiaism. Therefore, I was faced with two alternatives:
1) Either I ignore the clear message of the Quran and continue being a Shia because it is difficult to accept that I have been wrong up until this moment and just continue believing what I have been growing up with because its convenient, or
2) Literally implement the meaning of the word ´´Muslim´´ which means submission to the will of Allah swt, and with all humility and genuinety accept the message of the Quran even if it has been against my belief all the time up until now.
Of course, with the guidance of Allah swt, I ended up choosing the second alternative, and since 2013, I am a proud Muslim who follows pure tawhid and the authentic Sunnah of the Prophet SAW. Ever since then I feel an inner peace and security for disassociating myself from shirk and superstitious beliefs, rituals and practices.
My advice to the sincere Shias is to read the Quran and as you are reading it constantly ask yourself whether you see the core beliefs of Shiaism in it or not, without resorting to word-games, weird analogies, twisted examples from every day life or using weak and fabricated narrations.
@@Qandebachaa 😂😂😂😂😂
@@NAStheNomad What is the use of your comment?
@@Lynn.-_-. even no point is better than blatant lies.
@@NAStheNomad What lies did they write?
@@Lynn.-_-. everything
The Truth always defeats Falsehood, the greatest gift to a human is guidance.
It has been narrated on the authority of Jabir b. Samura who said:
I heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) say: Islam will continue to be triumphant until there have been twelve Caliphs. Then the Prophet (ﷺ) said something which I could not understand. I asked my father: What did he say? He said: He has said that all of them (twelve Caliphs) will be from the Quraish.
Sahih Muslim 1821d
Book 33, Hadith 8
Like Muhammed Ali said in the beginning of this debate, bring it back to Qur'an and Messenger. The Messenger (pbuh) said there will be 12 Khalifas (Imams, or whatever titles you want to use). Can Sunnis name all these 12 people that they were supposed to follow?
The thing that makes Shias really dislike Sunnis' behaviour as seen in these comments, is that they say that Shias are kafirs.
@@stormcloud9146 When you answer a question with a question, it shows that you don't want to answer the question. Most of the time, it's because the answer would be an admission. When you don't want to admit, you deflect with a counterquestion.
I'll ask again, who are the 12 Khalifas that The Prophet (pbuh) said we should follow? Do Sunnis follow them? Do they even subscribe to a 12 Khalifa narrative at all, or do they pretend that there's no such thing as 12 to be followed after The Prophet (pbuh)?
@@WahidShirin bro I think we both misunderstood each other I read your text wrong lol I’m ahlul bayt team bro
a little life-conflict in Guidance of God 🙂
@@WahidShirin when are you debating, non-Muslims rather than talking 24x7 about ahlussunnah
When are you actually going to talk about Islam and preaching Islam to non-Muslims and refuting their allegations? Where is your most known shia hiding
Wallahi I pray to Allah to see Iran become a muslim country again like the golden ages of Islam...
Bruh
@@Cyrus-Idris same
@@Cyrus-Idris why so they can support Israel like the Sunnis?
@stormcloud9146 I'm refering to the people and the sharia, not necessarily the government. Also Israel didn't exist at the golden age of Islam.
@@Cyrus-Idris is this comment for me?
Just Like Prophet Isa (Jesus) a.s, Have Nothing to do with Christianity,
Same way, Imam Ali r.a have nothing to do with Shias!
*May Allah Guide them all, Ameen
Has nothing to do with them and absolutely wouldn't stand for this mockery just like Isa AS wouldn't stand to be elevated to divine status.
It's just plain wrong.
The shia is actually quite similar to christianity,the Shia have a picture of Ali (Ra) same as the Christian..the Christian has a lenten penitential sacrifice and the shia has rituals take place during the first ten days of Muharram
@@ThSF-Vthe level of ignorance goes crazyyy
Yea, you know Imam Ali and the Prophet's daughter Fatima really loved Abu Bakr and Umar... You know, those that you base your religion on aswell as Muawiya and Yazid.
These educational experiences are truly some of the best gems on TH-cam in general. Thank you for this clip. May Allah elevate and forgive the believers of this ummah in this life and the next.
💯
Amiin 🤲🏾
most of the disbelievers have some common practices; Christianity, shia, Hinduism...etc they worship men and creations of almighty Allah swt. They are uplifting normal men to be close to prophets and they use their names to get closer to their god. Satan has been using the same thing since the beginning and humans still fall in the same trick
I was brought up as a shia from Iran as well, Alhamdulillah Allah guided me to the true Islam. Sadly, majority of Iranians have become Islamophobes due to the corrupt version of the shias, thinking that is the real Islam.
Reading into Shiaism. It's more of a political issue about who's going to be the next leader. From there, you can see why Shias believe what they believe, like giving Allah's attributes to companions of the prophet. It is always about politics. Alhamdulliah for Quran, it gives us the foundations for Islam. Alhamdulliah! May Allah guide us all towards the straight path. Ameen
@@Soroush.73 راست میگی برادر
I'm from Iran too, as a brought up shai I'm finding for the truth. May Allah bless us.
I agree may Allah guide them to Islam
@@drewfiji8845I've seen a lot of former Shia Iranians in the West and it's clear that the evil regime made them hate Islam.
May Allah guide the Shia into Islam. And may Allah bless and reward brother Muhammed Ali. Aameen 🤲
They already follow islam abd you are way too arrogant.
@@nogag8219 Did you even watch the video?
Shia do not follow Islam, they are only Muslims by name, that's just the truth.
Well said brother@@MaskedGuyCh
The name tag of the girl showing 'Confused Shia' is too funny 😂
Ameeeennnnn ya RABB 🤲🏼🤲🏼🤲🏼
I was born into a Shia Family too. No one who looks objectively into islamic sources would ever follow the way of the Shia.
Which Shia era? The Shi'at-'Ali during his life existed with the known reputation of being Shi'at Ali. So the original Shia, you honor as being on Haqq, correct?
Ur right. I also grew up around Shias and they follow what their family told them. They don’t listen if we guide them to the right path
That depends with what you call Islamic
What source,
@@reegarafat perhaps they have legitimate knowledge that you don't have, and vice-versa. Humility from all Muslims is a good thing. Only Allahu A'lam
SHIA's its never to late to convert to Islam
Shias*
How come Shiah is not considered as Islam ?
@@rashidmdamin5552 because of shirk
@@rashidmdamin5552 because they bring many innovation to deen and represents family of the prophet more than Quran itself.
@@MojtabaKarimi-x5v Innovation is an understatement, they commit clear Kufr in their teachings. Like associating the unseen attributes to the Imams.
Amazing discussion subhaaaanallah 🥹🥹 May Allah guide her family and friends to the right path as well and protect all of us from trials in our deen and keep us all steadfast 🤍🤍
assalamualaikum from malaysia🇲🇾. hope this channel can reach 1 million subs
It will reach and pass insha'Allah
Infact 7 billion subscribers so that the message can reach the world
وعليكم السلام ورحمة الله وبركاته
aamiin. Malaysia here (KL)
@@nasiruyusuf8782aamiin
Mashalah you can tell shes sincere..May Allah guide her and us all
Wonderful video. thank you Muhammad Ali. Love you for the sakw of Allah. May he reward you with the highest level of Jannah, Ameen!
I'm proud of you sister. You're doing some amazing critical thinking for the sake of truth. Sometimes our own family can be our tests. Stick with The Quran and one cant go wrong.
I loved seeing your honesty & sincerity. May Allah guide you to the truth, to His closeness and be pleased with you Allahumma ameen.
I appreciate the shias but one thing I find interesting is that shias make the whole religion about ahle-bait (I believe Allah is pleased with them but they wont be happy with us if we tweek their effort for Islam). Islam is so much more like Surah Ikhlas, tawheed❤ & all about Allah's deen.
@@Squirrellium surah al-kausar disproved shiaesem to me.
I agree with you .
"And who is more astray than he who invokes besides Allāh those who will not respond to him until the Day of Resurrection, and they, of their invocation, are unaware. And when the people are gathered [that Day], they will be enemies to them, and they will be deniers of their worship." Surah Al-Ahqaf 5-6
Stop spreading misinformation
Truè. That's an àyàt in Al-Qur'an for thòse Syiàh who ìnvòke Ali (rà) and Sùfìs who ìnvòke thè gràvè.
@@goujosatorou1628 its in the literal Quran
@@goujosatorou1628
How is it misinfo?
“Quran4:59 - O you who believe, obey God, and obey the Messenger and the holders of authority amongst you”) and Surah Yasīn (Quran36:12 - “And We have encompassed all things in the Manifest Imām”)
Wallahi I waited for you to upload I was gonna sleep about an hour ago but I knew a video was coming allah yehmik brother Muhammad Ali
😂😂😂 alhamdulilah imagine we had 10 such people and were doing Dawah full time
I’ve been waiting for this since the live stream. May Allah keep us all on the truth and unite us. Ameen.
How do you join the live stream?
@@j86485 First subscribe and put notifications on for the channel so you’re told when brother M.A goes live. There is no set schedule but this is usually Sat/Sun evening UK time.
@@Adamm.h Thanks bro
زادك الله من فضله وتوفيقه وحفظك وجزاك خيرا كثيرا
Very softly spoken & genuine mashallah
May Allah guide the Shia to the straight path. To the Sunnah of his prophet and his companions .
امين.
Aminn 🤲
Both Aisha and Ali are in hell, according to quran.
@@ShiaSunniSeries 33:6 is about the wives who are counted as um al-muimenin
Ameen!
May this video reach our Shia brothers and sisters and aid them in their understanding and search for truth. May Allah guide all of us
Ameen!
Ameen ya Rabb
When people are sincere Allah guides them. Allahu Akbar!
@@ShiaSunniSeries It is because 33:32 starts with "O wives of the Prophet" - giving the context for verse 33. The hadith you quoted mentions the context of the last part of verse 33 where it says "O members of the family".
The majority of the Persian peoples were Sunnis, but Ismail al-Safavi forced them to embrace Shiite thought and distanced them from true Islam.
I hope that we will unite again on one religion, as was the case with the first generation of Muslims
Fatimid Egypt was on another Minhaj and after they lost power, Egypt was forced to become Sunni
@@CaptainN. egypt was never shia, no country on earth was shia kuff religion. Only forced conversions made iran and azerbaijan shia countries.
@@CaptainN. you are wrong Fatimid took control from Sunni Muslims in egypt while iran was always sunnis until safavids
@rajababy2009 none of this matters, ultimately Sunni and Shia majority was NOT the result of freedom of thought and choice. From Bani Umayya to Abbasid to Mongol invasion and then ottoman era etc they were all imposed school of thought, chosen by the ruler for political reasons
i like how professional brother muhammed did the discussion. He didnt just simply answered the questions of her about the little details etc. but started at the root and base of her believe and step by step cleared the fog she had in front of her eyes.
@@ShiaSunniSeries what exactly do you not understand about the principle of using the Qur'an without anything external, that was established and agreed by both parties? This particular discussion is only about which beliefs is Qur'an aligned with, whose foundations are found in the Qur'an by looking at it alone. Since we disagree on the other sources what is the point of the opposing side cherry picking from it what they think suits their position, it leads nowhere since they are not using the source as a whole or accepting it in the first place. Do we accept this hadith, yes but we also accept all the other ahadith that are reliable and give information on the topic, and conclusion is based on looking at the revelation altogether regarding it.
But as the brother said even if he were to be charitable and accept this idea that the shia bring without the support of the Qur'an itself, where does it in the verse say that you should follow them? It doesn't, and purification is mentioned in other places for all the companions, so now what?
With all due respect shi'as in this comment section who've written their objections only show that they are one of 2 things. They are either insincere and choose to ignore what was clearly demonstrated using purely the Qur'an, or they didn't listen and comprehend the points being made correctly so they basically didn't grasp the conversation.
If you want to say the brother is misrepresenting something either from our position or yours or denying it, the live streams are open for you, come and say it bravely to his face and demonstrate it with evidence instead of accusing him of lying and deception while sitting behind your keyboard.
Pleasant, respectful, evidence based, methodical and surgical. Can’t thank you enough, it’s always a pleasure listening to you!
Upon The Adab & The Good Ahlaq
We follow Prophet Muhammad pbuh and his companions including Imam Ali R.A but we dont pray to them like shia does
We don't curse his woves like Shia does.
Wives*
@@ChadUsman shia is buncha sad people
I’m very confused. Why are they following 12 imams when the Quran clearly states Prophet Muhammad (SAW) is the last and final messenger.
Meaning there are no teachings of Allah(SWT) to follow after him as the final messenger.
And they praise Ali more than any Prophet including Prophet Muhammad (SWT).
Why are they praising humans and not focussing only on Allah(SWT).
Allah(SWT) commanded to follow His teachings in Quran and from the final messenger Prophet Muhammed(SAW).
Not human lineage, families, culture, history.
Imam Abu Bakr, Imam Umar, Imam Uthman, and Imam Ali. Why you make Ali is the only Imam? We recognize 4 Imam (leaders) after prophet Muhammad (pbuh) died.
@@leodavinci8935 don't forget imam hassan, the last rashidun khalifa
What a beautiful conversation and refutation with solid and incontrovertible evidences
💯
Thanks!
Brother Ali is dismantling their wrong beliefs on Ali RA. SubhanAllah May Allah bless Br. Mohammed Ali more and increase him and the ummah in every way.
@@ShiaSunniSeries
He talks about the verse of the quran not hadith
Quran 33:33 as mentioned to wives of the prophets as what they must do and they are also mentioned as ah lul bait
The hadith also was clarified as no issues they were purified no where does it mentioned follow them
I guess you were listening to him but not understanding the words coming out of his mouth.
Dang! MashAllah Muhammad Ali has 400,000 followers now lol I was following him when he had like 10k followers or less! I kept seeing it grow but I already knew his channel might take longer than other Muslim channels due to his detailed explanations and ZERO CLOUT edits. Muhammad if you read this never change the method of Quran and Sunnah. I’m a revert Latina Muslimah. Alhamdulillah I learned so much from your videos and it encouraged me to enroll in Islamic university because of how detailed and encouraging you were. May Allah continue to bless you. Ameen
I personally like his way of dawah. He doesn’t go the route of trying to “one up” or get “gotcha” moments alot of the TH-camr da’is tend to do.
The second the Muslim Lantern postes.... I watch.
me too
Same 😂
I think she knows who is right and who is wrong, but she wants to be sure ❤ May Allah The Almighty guide us all to his path ❤
Thanks
May Allah preserve and protect you akhi Muhammad.
You are doing a great work and we need more of you who deeply understand and eloquent in passing the clear Islam to others in need.
جزاك الله خير الجزاء
The Prophet ﷺ said: ❰ By Him in Whose Hands my life is, none of you will have faith till he loves me more than his father and his children. ❱ Sahih al-Bukhari 14
JazakAllah khair Brother Muhammad Ali for your time and knowledge in matters of religion! May Allah bless you with Jannah! 🇵🇰❤️🇵🇰❤️
This video can serve as a benchmark for anyone having the question or confusion in the mind. The foundation is very clear and strong and clears all the conflicts elegantly. That's the beauty of Islam, the principles are so clear that unless you want to go astray, you won't!
She came live before 10th Muharram but MA didn't upload this clip as he might have thought people would think he deliberately uploaded this video on occasion that is sacred to Shias to hurt their feelings. My bro's so clever he care for the timing as well.
Masya Allah
May Allah rewards him abundantly for that..and may Allah always guides us all in His path
We should stop linking the blessed day of Ashoura to them and go back to linking it to its original context, Prophet Muhammad pbuh told us to celebrate the day that Allah saved Musa pbuh and his companions and destroyed pharaoh and his army. And we do so by fasting it and all kinds of worship and knowledge-seeking.
@@MariaBKBKThat's the invented Bani Umayya mythology. Look into debates on the topic with evidence from Yahud history and religious holidays and calendars. Whoever invented the myth of Ashura being a Jewish celebration really did a poor job. It's a cover story to forget the crimes of Bani Umayya in Karbala
@@CaptainN. Wow you're really lost in the sauce, may Allah guide you
@@CaptainN.
She just wanted to ask her question about open and closed handed prayer and M.A ignores that and dismantled the whole shia believe lol appreciate the video still its a eye opener to see what shia believe about us
Yah that 12 imam business is totally mind blowing. They apparently have an Imam Pope always around. I am in shock. How can anyone believe such blatant deviation. May we be protected from ignorance and be guided.
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
@@zedzpanAre the 12 Imam alive or passed? What if one passes? Do they reincarnate another Imam like a Bhudda?
It’s all very confusing and not apart of Islam
@oromtitiwbo5078 Indeed. It makes zero sense. They just made it up, gave God like attributes to a man. Honestly, still in shock. How can they even defend this position. They are way outside of the fold. Satan is remarkably good at continuing to lead mankind astray, yet man is too ignorant and proud to leave the astray path of their forefathers. May we be protected from going astray.
Did you watch the whole video? He answered that question in the end. Muslims pray the way the prophet prayed according to the companions.
Most people of Shia background living in the West find Shia ism abhorrent for a variety of reasons but namely because they feel their “freedoms” are severely limited. I wish they knew more about Sunna Islam and this most informative video.
Yea most Iranian diaspora I have met are the ex muslim type who become Christian or atheist and talk about how oppressive Islam is as if they were ever muslim to begin with
You are in the right place my dear sister. May Allah guide you and all of us.
When you look at shia beliefs it's clear that they never left zoroastrianism, they just dressed it in Islamic clothing
they did left zorastianism and Iran became an important part of Islamic world and empire but in 16 century the Safavid dynasty came in power and they were sufis and in fear of ottomans becoming popular in Iran because they are the same religion, the safavids became Shia and imported hundreds of top shia clerics from lebanon and started prosecuting sunni majority Iran, closing down their Mosques, killing their religious leaders and killing anyone who resisted, thats why ottomans called them kafirs and went in war with safavids but they started good but not successful in the end because they were fighting two front and also this was also the reason that modern day Afghanistan region rebelled in 18 century and dismantled the safavid dynasty but unfortunately they lost power in a few years because mahmod hotaki died young and next iranian dynasty kept iran a shia state, yiu can search “how Iran became Shia” amd also there is a book called ‘The History of Ismail Safavi - The Bringers of Shiism’ you can read this in Persian and Arabic
@@alFarsi570I'm not talking about Iran specifically. I mean Shi'ism. If you study the theology from the time of Ali May Allah be pleased with him and especially after the death of Hussein may Allah be pleased with him, and you read how the theology developed over the centuries - it seems clear to me that many Persians did not truly give up their pagan roots after Islam spread to them. It just went underground and morphed into shi'ism. I'm not talking geopolitics here. Specifically the theology.
For example, why do they revere Hussein and his line so much more than Hasan? Oh, they give different answers, but none that really explain the huge difference in reverence.
But when you learn that the Persians of old used to trace their kings' bloodlines through their mothers, and then you learn that Hussein may Allah be pleased with him married one of the last Persian princesses after the muslims conquered Persia, it all makes sense. They don't truly revere Hussein's line because of Hussein (and Ali). They revere Hussein's line because the mother is the link to the old Persian kings
@@thepoetesskhansaainteresting!
@@thepoetesskhansaaSo after Karbala who was the leader of the Ahl al-Bayt? There was no election between Hassan line and Husayn, correct? It was by appointment from Husayn. Correct?
@@CaptainN. there was never any "leader" of ahlul bayt. Stop with the rubbish. The true ahlul bayt and their line have always hidden themselves so as not to distinguish themselves among the muslims. They dispersed all over the muslim world and kept quiet about who they are. There is no leader. That's shia brainwashing
"Oh yeah that makes the sense"- sister saying this seems very polite and broad minded. May Allah guide her to the straight path. And may Allah bless our brother Muhammad Ali more wisdom and knowledge. It was a nice and perfect discussion.Jazakallahu Khairan ❤.
For all the shias and others sects that are not following the way of the prophet and his companions, fear Allah and be sincere. Anyone who will bring a way other than Islam, it will not be accepted and he will be among the losers.
sahabas are replaceable ahlulbait are not
@@seanshui5909 then why do you follow selected members of the family?
Not entirely?
Which sahaaba?
@@jaferessop4412 Abu Bakr, Umar, Usman, Muawiya May God curse him for the eternity is not even considered to be sahaba
@@MojtabaKarimi-x5v Aisha waged war against Imam Ali and she disrespected lady Khadija
Pray for Muslims around world 🇵🇸
احسن الظن في الناس وكأن كل الخير فيهم، واعتمد على نفسك كأنه لا خير في الناس.🎉🤲🧕Free Palestine
From Palestine, Gaza City
call from Gaza from the midst of war death, hunger, destruction and pain. To the lovers of goodness, a kind greeting to every Muslim from a Palestinian mother from Gaza. The Prophet, may God’s prayers and peace be upon him, said: “We will never diminish the money you have given in charity.” narrated by Muslim
''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''"""""""""""""""""""💔
""""""""""""""""""""""""'"""""""""
"""" "" "" "" "" "" "" "" "'" ""''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''🤲
I have four orphan children, and we are in the midst of a war of extermination, displacement, hunger, pain, wounds, and deprivation. They were martyred in this war. My family and now I'm alone without a father. Today, I make this appeal to you from among the rubble and destruction, my brothers. I live under difficult circumstances, an unjust siege, and a blind war that destroyed my city in which I live, and my home that houses my children’s dreams. Today, I found myself living on top of the ruins of my home in a tent no more than a few meters long, with me and my four children. This is a very difficult thing that no human being can bear. I live in very difficult conditions without food, water, and flour due to the siege, and we drink water. Polluted due to lack of money and my children’s fear of war, and now I am asking for help and assistance in order to restore the smile of life to my children, and I am in dire need of your contribution in order to rebuild my house that was demolished, and I ask (00970592511969)To donate, WhatsApp wrote to you these short words that do not express a little of the pain and wounds that we are experiencing in Gaza, and I write these words to you while tears do not leave my eyes from the pain and cruelty of life. I hope that you will be supporters of my cause in all parts of the world and the ugliness of the injustice that we live in every day, but every minute. We lose loved ones every day. And do not forget the difficulty of life in a small tent that does not exceed a few meters. God was a protector for us from the heat of summer and the cold of winter in the tent, and today all my dreams are to drink a drop of cold, clean water in the summer and feed my children. Praise be to God in any case, this is God’s command. Note: I have a child who is sick in the eye, and he is forbidden by the doctor’s prescription from high heat and sunlight. How can he be in a very hot tent? Therefore, I ask you to help me in maintaining my house.
"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""يارب قد دقت الدنيا بنا وانت ارحم الراحمين نداء
انا عندي اربع طفال ونحن فى ظل حرب الاباده والتهجير والتجويع والالم والجراح والحرمان لقد استشهدوا في هذا الحرب اسرتي وانا الان وحيدة بلا اب واليوم ارسل ندائي هذا من بين الركام والدمار لكم يا إخوتي انا اعيش في ظل ظروف صعبة و حصار ظالم وحرب عمياء ولقد دمرت مدينتي التي اعيش فيها و دمر بيتي الذي يؤوي احلام اطفالي واليوم لقد وجدت نفسي اعيش فوق ركام بيتي في خيمه لا تتجاوز عدت امتار انا واطفالي الاربعه هذا امر صعب جداً لا يتحمله إنسان واعيش ظروف صعبه جداً بدون طعام وماء و طحين بسبب الحصار ونشرب الماء الملوث بسبب قلت الاموال وخوف اطفالي من الحرب والان اطلب يد العون والمساعدة لكي اعيد بسمة الحياة الي اطفالي وانا في امس الحاجه الي المساهمه لكي اعيد بناء بيتي الذي هدم و ارجو منكم المساهمة كتبت لكم هذي الكلمات القصيرة التي لا تعبر الى القليل من الالم والجراح الذي نعيشه فى غزة واكتب لكم كلماتي هذه والدموع لا تفارق عيني من الالم وقسوة الحياة ارجو منكم ان تكونو مناصرين إلى قضيتي في جميع انحاء العالم وقبح الظلم الذي نعيشه في كل يوم بل كل دقيقه ونحن نفقد الاحبه كل يوم. ولا تنسو صعوبة الحياة في خيمة صغيرة لا تتعدى بعض الامتار كان الله لنا معين من حم الصيف والبرد الشتاء فى الخيمة واليوم كل احلامي ان اشرب نقطة ماء باردة ونظيفه في الصيف وطعام اطفالي. الحمدلله على كل حال هذا امر الله.~~♡~♡~
~♡~♡~/♡~♡~/~♕😭🎉😭🎉😭🎉😭🎉😭😭🎉😭😭🎉🎉~~♡~/♡~♡~♡~/♡/♡//♡/♡//♡/♡/♡//🧕🧕🧕🧕🧕
Allhumdulliah 🤲🏼🤲🏼🤲🏼
@@Palestiniangaza tell that to the sunnis… only the Shia are fighting Israel
@@stormcloud9146
First thing is act accordingly to Quran
@@Believe_in_one_Creator what’s that got to do with anything I said? Does the Quran tell you to stand with Israel?
May Allah bless you and your entire team, dear Brother
Call on Allah swt alone.
the christian branch of Islam.
@@lordalmansoori6888 why?
@@MojtabaKarimi-x5v what do you mean, why?
@@reniaibnkhidr because I don't get the reference
@@MojtabaKarimi-x5v they call upon ali like how christians call upon jesus
@@ashur9_440 how?
May Allah guide her to Islam 🤲🏼
I waited for this one 😊
I am trying very hard to convert my Shia friend,alhamdulillah he no longer claims Shia,he is still confused but is getting closer to the haqq
Even Christianity, once people started editing the concept, the baraqah goes away. Then the people have no choice but to connect one quote to another to strengthen the assumption/man-made thesis.
Lets not go there. Lets stay close to The Quran.
Shias & Sunnis both. Study Quran❤
جزاك الله خير الجزاء وحفظك
Mashallah! Your knowledge is incredible Muhammad Ali, just like the boxer you float like the butterfly and sting like the bee!
I'm glad she came on here. She seemed very sincere. May Allah guide her and us all. Ameen.
I feel shiah and Christianity feel the same for using not direct verses And explaining them in a way to construct very far away religion and rejecting the direct and obvious teaching
Jazakallahukhair for this. May Allah reward you brother Muhammed Ali
Thank you, brother Mohamad. Your description is eye-opening to shiaa. I hope every one will share it.
BarakAllah feekum My brother Muhammad. May Allah SWT reward u for good u do. Ameen
I can’t express on how happy I am to watch your video’s! Morning, evening, during work, during gym.. the amount of knowledge this man has is mind blowing especially his way of explaining!!
Shia in 99 percent about the head of the state (Imama) .
1 percent about Allah .
they put people between themselves and Allah they put 12 Imams and Ali and Fatima and Hussien .
all they took about is the leadership of the state .
allah is also head of islamic state.
Islam is 100% about head of islanic state aka allah. So, how is that a big deal what Shia believe in. You are too arrogant to say that they are wrong.
@@nogag8219 It's not non-muslim who decides what Islam is about.
@@LisaD-yy4gq Get this in your fascist head - anyone can speak their mind on anything
Muhammed Ali has just nailed the conversation. I never expected that she would convince. But at the end she said when the shias foundation itself dismantled i don't have anything to ask. May Allah swt guide her and entire shia community
Alhamdulillah another upload
If you read this;
Say "SubhanAllah" 33x
Say "Alhamdulillah" 33x
Say "Allahu akbar" 34x
May Allah reward you.
@@YEAGERlST put the reward habibi
Salam from Sweden 🇸🇪
WA alykum asalam 🎉
@@Predator_994 💪
Walaikum Salaam. Kashmir 🥰
Wa Alaykum salaam from the southern tip of Africa
وعليكم السلام ورحمه الله وبركاته.
MAY ALLAH GUIDE ALL SHIAS AND OTHER SEMI-RAFDI PEOPLE. ❤️✅
@@ShiaSunniSeries
OKAY LETS TAKE UR STATEMENT FOR THE SAKE OF ARGUMENT OF AHLE-BAIT IT WAS WHOM RASOOL-ALLAH IS TALKING AND WHAT MENTIONED IN QURAN
BUT STILL THE QUESTION REMAINS WHERE DOES IT SAY IN THE QURAN FOLLOW THEM ???
YOU GUYS CANT PROVE A THING FROM QURAN THAT SUPPORTS YOUR BELIEF 😄
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Make dua'a for them instead of commenting
@@IZIKI-399that’s the style of the Sunnis. Shias do actions.
@@joal9235 by involving others and leaving the chat
@@joal9235 by causing more civil wars?
@@IZIKI-399 what hit yourselfs and cry you couldn't even protect your own imam even though it was you guys who promised his safety in karbaala
We love ahlu bait but we don’t make our religion revolve around them. We follow the prophet and the Quran. Ahlu Sunnah ❤ May Allah guide our Shia Muslim brothers and sisters
I pray for my Shia brothers and sisters to question these assumptions and follow the Quran, the foundation of Islam.
Subhannallah the beginning where he steered the conversation to what matters was so wise
احسن الله اليك
Informative ❤
Alhamdulillah, new knowledge I learned. Every video Brother Muhammad Ali posted always contains something new for me to learn.
May Allah reward you with baraka and good rizq, brother.
Barak Allah Feek, going straight to the foundations of the belief so she can understand what is the correct belief rather than just answering the smaller questions she has. May Allah guide her and all the shia to the correct belief and way of Islam
Dismantle is an understatement. 😂😂 JazakAllah Khayran Brother. Thank you for rightfully spreading the Knowledge of the Book
Very beneficial video brother I loved it so much, you really explain everything from The Qur’an, I always loved your explanation because its not biased or from emotional perspective, may Allah ﷻ preserve you brother and may Allah ﷻ guide her and her family and guide us too
بارك الله فيك يا محمد 🤲
Wow, wow, MaashaaAllaah. Brother Mohammad Ali may Allaah bless you and forgive you and your family. May Allaah protect you from evil and harm as you work hard day and night for His religion of Islam and aid you in dispelling falsehood. Aamiin. Take care and be well.
From the descendents of ali (ra) and Im suni salafi alhamdululah ❤ all my family are sunnis
Ali r.a himself followed Sunnah of Prophet a.s
just call your self a muslims no need to call your self sunni or salafi
@@m0o0ntecrist08 No. It is needed to separate oneself from Ahlul Bid'ah.
@@m0o0ntecrist08no bro you should read what the scholars of Islam said if you know Arabic language you should separate yourself from ahlu albid'a .but I'm Muslim when I took with my brothers from ahlu Sona or kufar but between tha people of bid'a I'm salafi Suni .
There is a problem in some Indian muslims and pakistani muslims they said that they are Sunni Muslims but because of half knowledge of islam and weak imaan they do follow some shia concepts also and they messed up there faith.....😢and the thing is I'm living around them....pray for them that Allah guide them
Sincerity just lightens up the video and makes it peaceful and beneficial.. I hope that everyone who comes to the stream would be as sincere as her and just seeking the truth ❤❤
Ex shia her Alhumdulillah
Who else
Elhamdulillah ❤
Alhamdulillah for Islam
Beautifully explained. Loved it. Makes Islam more clear and straight forward.
Brother Muhammad may Allah bless you and bless your work and knowledge