There are two types of detectives in this world. First, who analyse the evidences and find murderer. Second, who decide murderer first and then find evidences to make him murderer.
I researched a lot on this case some couple of months back, the more deeper one tries to go, the more mind-numbing things become. Imagine the culprit is still out freely on the streets despite such a tragic crime, 14 years later. 🙏🏻
I have a theory and I think it's much more convincing than all the other ones , the servant tried to assault aarushi, and when she resisted then he killed her, cause of this her parents must have woken up and went to her room , and assumed or they must have seen the servant doing all this and killed him,, and after that her father called his brother and his brother called someone to go his house at that time and helped him hide all the evidences, and then he locked the door form outside and that person then placed servent's body on the terrese . That's likely what happened
Aarushi Talwar was from my school and many of my elder friends and teachers tell me how charming she was. :( RIP to the innocent soul. No one deserves this :(( my teachers told me she was very good in studies too. I think there was def problem in the investigation, otherwise how could this not get solved with such clear reasons :((
I think the reason why this case is still unsloved is that the investigation team didn't handle the evidence properly and it was also shown in the movie "talwar" how the police mishandled the evidences. I am going to be a law student soon and would surely do more research on this case in near future.
The parents manipulated everyone by saying it's definitely his servent. Because of that police were busy finding him cause they also had lot of pressure. The parents let as many relatives as they can in the house even before the arrival of the police. Key evidences may have destroyed by that time. They both are dentists. They sure has the basic knowledge of clearing as many evidences as they can
While I was reading all the theories, I noticed a common thing in every one of it. Aarushi was considered the primary victim and Hemraj was considered the secondary, i.e he was killed because he saw something he should have not. I have a question for you. Compare the lives of both Aarushi and Hemraj and tell me which one of them is more likely to get into something shady and get killed. With no doubt Hemraj he feared his life from someone,he had not been sending any money back home, he didnt eat his food that night, and he received a call from a PCO and it was never found who called him. What if we assume that Hemraj was killed first and Aarushi was subsequently killed because she saw something she should have not? At around 8:30 PM on 15 May 2008 Hemraj received a call from a PCO( Public Phone booth) and they talked for approx 6 minutes. The person wanted to meet Hemraj. He invited the person to the Talwar’s appartement Both the persons meet at the house and Hemraj let him in… It was a friendly entry and not a FORCED ONE . Instead of the person coming late in the night around 10:30-12 in the midnight he may have been sitting in Hemraj’s room for a long time completely unaware to the family Hemraj was very worried and lost his appetite that night, he served himself food but did not eat. At some point The person demanded more liquor and to please him, Hemraj got it from Rajesh’s bar.. (The Ballantine Scotch Whisky) Hemraj may have left the bottle there on the table incase the person needed more liquor or accidentally left it. After some time around 12 -1am they decided to go the terrace to take an argument upstairs so that they do not wake up the family or just went up to smoke or catch fresh air Hemraj opened the lock and they went outside. Over here a scuffle ensued and they might have grappled each other(due to the abrasions on Hemraj’s elbows). The person went on to bludgeon his head and then slit his throat (i can say this because there was a blood spatter effect on the terrace door ) The person put the cooler lid on his body and then locked the terrace door and pocketed the keys(they were never found). He came back to Hemraj’s room to wash his face (as he must have got some blood on his face due to the spurting effect),collected his phone or something he must have left behind that may lead the cops to him. Before leaving he drank some more whiskey and placed the bottle on the dining table of the Talwars. On the other hand, Aarushi was reading Chetan Bhagat’s novel and had a split AC in her room Over here any one of the two situations might have happened -Aarushi on hearing some noise came out to check what was going on and saw the intruder OR -Aarushi went to the kitchen to drink some water and saw the person( Note that the kitchen and Hemraj’s room were pretty close) The person hit her left parietal skull by a heavy blunt object and she could not scream because she had severe throat infection, she was knocked out unconscious. Aarushi may have made some noise but her shrill high pitch sound may not have penetrated to her parents room under the din of a loud a/c. (shrill high frequency sounds do not travel far and do not easily travel across doors/walls while low frequency heavy sounds do, you may have seen this hearing sounds of drums / deep bass from a car with windows rolled up but not the sound of the singer.) This caused severe blood clotting and concussion and resulted her death within 2 minutes. On noticing a key on her door, he silently removed the key from the hole and put it on the dining table so as to not make any rattling noise due to the keys which might wake up the Talwars The person then dragged Aarushi’s body into her room and then for a good measure hit her left eyebrow skull and slit her throat so that she couldn’t survive. The person covered her with the white flannel blanket , arranged toys around her, put a school bag on her head to that show that as if she had been killed in her sleep. He then picked up the phone that was lying on her bed or table so as to sell it later on. It was a nokia N72 and it could easily fetch 10,000 to 15,000 INR at that time. Before leaving he drank some more scotch whiskey and then left the house He latched the first gate if incase someone followed him He didnt latch the outer one since it was useless. Most Importantly my theory does not violate any evidence that has been recovered. Ballantine Scotch whisky bottle containing both Hemraj’s as well as Aarushi’s blood glasses partially filled with whisky found in Hemraj’s room Hemraj being killed on the terrace Terrace keys not found Missing phones that were recovered later Hemraj fearing his life from someone Someone calling him from a PCO located within 1km of the Talwars and Hemraj’s phone being located within the same radius Abrasions found on his elbows The guard’s testimony that someone can enter Jalvayu Vihar without meeting the guards at all Murder weapons not being found. the shoe prints were of number 8 or 9, while Rajesh wears size 6 or 7 indicating there was someone else on terrace with Hemraj (who was wearing slippers) Hemraj had no money and he stopped sending money home latch from outside on the grill door Hemraj not eating his dinner that night use of Hemraj’s bathroom
But in the autopsy they specified that arushi was hit by a golf stick And hemraj had multiple bounds and autopsy showed the sign of sexual activity in hemraj's private part Arushi's private parts were cleaned thoroughly and tipped by his family not to include sexual assault in autopsy report They were doctors they knew the protocol of crime scene still they let their servants clean the house and neighbours contaminate the crime scene if it's like ur theory there should have been some kind of DNA as there was a signs of struggle on hemraj's body And DNA on the wishkey glass There are many loop holes in the theory.
Man this theory could have proved true but it doesn't explain the suspicious behaviour of her parents, also the reason behind Hemraj's sexual activity.
@@manisha3333 1)Autopsy just made an assumption the murder weapon might be a golf stick because they couldn't find any other suitable weapon that might have caused such a blunt injury 2) Swollen Penis doesn't mean that the person was having intercourse.. According to toxology, a person's penis swells automatically after 36hrs of his death.. 3)Aarushi's private parts were never cleaned.. Initially when the doctor conducted the autopsy on her.. He said there were no signs of rape.. but when the second cbi team took over the investigation(the one which blamed the parents) ,he suddenly reported that it was unusually large and "clean".. why would you that? 4)Take the shoes for a parents for a while.. would you be conscious enough to make the crime scene undisturbed or cry on you daugter's fate? It was the family members who helped clean the house not the Talwars..
brooo it isn't sure that her parents were the murderer and the lack of evidence cant proof who was the real culprit...i believe in the cbi's 2 nd case it seemed more real...
I truly believe that parents are the culprit 1. The parents used to work in different clinic. The father was working with a woman and the mother was working with a man. And that man and woman was actually a married couple. Why the hell they need to swap. And CBI confirmed that they had extra marital affairs. 2. There were no sign of break in 3. Autopsy was fake which was confirm 4. They had the key of upstairs but they choose to hide the fact. 5. They are doctors they knew how forensics work and still ordered domestic helper to clean 6. They let every neighbor walk in the apartment to contaminate possible dna 7. The room was super clean and tidy 8. In the autopsy of hemraj it was found that he had sex. 9. Arusi was murdered in a blow but hemraj was tortured and murdered. So on All this murder game was planned just to conceal their affairs and the huge crime of hemraj using a kid for his need. That kid was innocent, was distressed as there were conflict in the family. Hemraj also used and manipulated her. But parents of that kid chose their pride over their kid.
Same even arushis private parts were cleaned her parents were doctors they knew what they were doing i think arushi was sexually involved with hemraj n the parents found them in compromising position that night
One of the most crucial factors was the fact that her parents were highly educated doctors. They possessed a deep understanding of manipulation and their acting skills were truly exceptional. It was peculiar that despite two individuals losing their lives in the same house, these actors were able to wake up in the morning without a hint of fear in their screams.
Arushi's parents were high profile doctors in Noida. So both of them were medically trained enough in hiding all the forensic evidence after committing both the murders at night. And they also called the Neighbors/medical help/police only after the maid finally saw Arushi's dead body. Normal parents would have called for external help way earlier.
It was clearly mentioned that that night arushi had s*x and in the same postmortem report it was also mentioned that hemraj's private part was erected when he hot killed. End of ur debate.
Yup this is also annoying that why they waited till the 6 am ? They can call the neighbours or someone nearby!!!! But how they can lock themselves from outside this is also the question ?
What was there plan ? ... To kill Arushi in home 🤣🤣🤣 because they need good sex life wtf ... If so they could easily killed Arushi outside without any problem .
Actually, before watching this.. I used to think that parents are not guilty. BUT after watching your video, I totally feel that parents did kill their daughter. Who in their right mind will lock their daughter's room.. this is a big red flag.
The abnormal thing is that Hemraj's body was in the terrace and it was locked . Why the outside murderer would take the pain of locking the terrace ? The key was with the Talwars .The body was also nicely wrapped .Why the outsider cover the body ? He has nothing to hide .
Good point, why would a killer bother to lock the door, he/she would run for their life, most other evidences also point towards the Parents, and their behaviour about the incident is also very wierd, specially the mother.
Exactly, who would take such a long time for transferring a boddy to terrace n then locking up then dressing up room ..😂😂he will be like m I killer or sweeper who is doing everything in just some minutes. ..talwars are killer infact her mother is killer .bcz she has no words to say . She can't make clear eye contact to any journalist. Also both parents 😂do close their arms like if they open hands in interview they will get scared.like in fear we get fold to over own body . They do tht
Exactly, wouldn’t the killer had the fear of getting caught? Talwars claim that their ac made loud noises due to which they barely heard outside noises, but if the killer was outsider, how did he knew about it??? Moreover Rajesh is extremely sketchy and as far I recalled he dint gave the key of door opening to terrace to the police n hurriedly cleaned the crime scene, if it not suspicious, then what is
- parents started crying after the their maid came in the morning. - at first father was claiming that their servent killed her and ran away. ( They might have planned to put the balme on Hemraj and later deal with hemarj's body ) - their terrace door was locked from inside (who else could have locked the door?) - later body of Hemraj found on terrace ( the point where their plan failed but their confidence and police negligence saved them )
1.If you kill somebody you will not keep their body on rooftop for 15 days he would have gotten rid of it 2 that was an apartment building not their private home so anyone could have locked it perhaps guard or watchman
@@luckyo1479 they did keep body on rooftop only because there is no option left to get ride of the body. How can someone take such huge body out of the buliding when there are guards it's impossible.
@@Ammu_ammu7 jab aap kisi ka murder kroge toh body raat me hi car me rkh kr ese jagha phekoge jaha koi pta nhi lga paye ya le jake chatt pr rakh doge raat ke 2 bje?
There was problem with their router. It kept turning on and off by itself. This behaviour was also noticed next day when police was around. Also, it is highly unlikely that body wsa dragged to rofftop. Instead it is more possible that Hemraj was killed on rooftop itself.
Thinking about this case still haunts me even though the film has potrayed the case in good way it gives up the decision to the audience to be made it’s just not justifiable to pin someone as the culprit there’s so much going on in this
Every single time I come across this case.... And i repeat... Every single time. It gives me chills which run down my spine. Being a med student this case has always got me thinking of what really would have happened on that night. I mean there are a number of probabilities. On one side i want to believe that the parents haven't committed such a henius crime.... While on the other their suspicious behaviour just doesn't allow me to support them. Plus the 6 phone calls drama.... And a police officer being involved just makes it even more shadier.... I mean c'mon why would u do that in the between of the night.... Oh god!
Actually our police officers are actually capable of solving such problems easily but most of the police officers don't do the investigation properly due to media and senior pressure and the second part is corruption in India for which most of the crimes are never solved
Those constables who came in the beginning must have been paid off, to neglect the obvious evidence. They did not even go and check the terrace. When crime happens, you need to peruse the whole surrounding area!!
@@rinkypatnaik1990 its not corruption , the way police system works its very dificult to investigate such cases unless there have been orders from above . and these orders only come when there is too much external pressure. The police at local level has limited power
Agar India main police crime patrol ya Savdhan India ki tarah hoti, to India bahut safe country hota rehne ke liye. But unfortunately our police is highly corrupt.@@rinkypatnaik1990
I watched talwar movie on Netflix recently, and the one scene I can't forget when one police man breaks the glass and asked the other one I broke just one glass and you are awake. But two murders happened in the house still parents were asleep?? What a bullshit! Arushi deserves justice. And the parents should be behind the bars!
@@D_S_DEVIL wo parents ke facts hain. CBI ke evidenciary proof ke hisaab se, aur common sense ke hisaab se , parents ke alawa aur koi bhi nahi tha. Agar alien aaya hoga toh pata nahi. Ye Hemraj ke darne wali baat sab created hai..wo normally reh Raha tha.
Doors were locked from inside. There was no new person seen in the colony for the last 3 weeks or so in the footage. There were security dogs. They never barked that night. And why only aarushi and hemraj were killed? Why no jewellery or any other items stolen? Why aarushi's inner body parts were cleaned up ? It doesn't take rocket science to figure out ,who did it!!
Why their parents didn't inform police in the first place? It's obvious that, anyone in that situation could have panicked and called any available helpline/neighbours at once. Their parents waited for arrival of the maid to disclose the incident, what stopped them?
I believe it's the parents. All they did was to sabotage the investigation. They didn't immediately informed the police when they "discovered" the body of the girl. They allowed the media to come in and contaminate the crime scene before the police could collect the evidence. They started criticising the police from the start. It's really a disturbing story. No one is right in the scenario. Everyone made mistakes but what the parents did was too glaring to ignore.
I still remember this case.. I was a kid that time.. this was the biggest mystery which went on for months in news channels.. daily i used to check the news for updates
Why is it only speculated that the father caught his daughter in a compromising position? Why was it never considered that Hemraj caught Rajesh abusing his daughter? His wife said he(Hemraj) felt fatherly towards Arushi. Even Arushi’s boyfriend Anmol said that she was having problems with her father. If something had been going on, low-key, and that night it escalated, he, Hemraj, might have felt he needed to step in. Which led to his murder, and then Arushi's, in order to prevent her from spilling the beans, about the abuse and subsequent murder. That to me seems the most likely. Also they allowed media and neighbours in the crime scene to contaminate the crime scene on purpose. Also they asked to not to mention sexual assault in the medical report.. why? Additionally her vaginal area was cleaned and diluted. According to my understanding, Both parents are guilty.
@@proudindian4401 I don't find that statement to have any credibility, because Hemraj's body was found more than 24 hours after he died and generally the abdomen becomes greatly distended and penis and scrotum becomes enormously swollen post 18-24 hours after someone dies.
Why to add sexual indulgement in every unsolved cases ??there are so many reasons and 14 years before sexual indulgement was not common enough for a teenager. Just in case victim is a girl these statements are not always appropriate.
@@priiaa1012 in that time also things were that common.2006se maine suna hai ladkian bf krti thi at the age of 18-19,aur physical bhi hoti thi unke saath so it's not uncommon for girl's to be physical with any other man. But point is we don't know if she was doing that consensually or she was forced by the servant.
@@Nothing-uc5mg I kinda feel like it was mutual. If it was forced she would have told her parents or friends. Even if she wouldn't have told anyone. She might be scared or depressed and anyone would have noticed. Her parents said in an interview that Hemraj and Arushi got along like father and kid. So it is pretty much clear it was mutual.
It was the parents who told maid first instead of calling police/dialling 100. They showed it to maid. She inturn informed all the surroundings, all people dived into their house. Disturbed the footprints, fingerprints. It always points out to the parents.
parents of Arushi talvar did a crime for sure. The spontaneity speaks it all; 1. The evidences were cleared. It is a crime. 2. They did not give the key to the terrace 3. They were on a phone call for three hours in a loop which involves a police personnel. It is also possible that they killed Hemraj for killing their daughter. Unki beti ke marne ka dukh woh kitne din mein bhula paaye can tell us how much they loved her to not kill her
I closely followed this case and also read entire investigation report and i am 100000% sure there parents are involved. This is a case of honor killing.
Parents could be killers but we have to consider all possible cases Hemraj's friends were present at the night of murder so isn't it possible that his friends got drunk which lead them to enter Aarushi's room and Hemraj was killed as he saw everything.
House was locked from inside. Even the spare key was with mother. She threw it down to the servant in the morning. All friends of Hemraj had alibi. I believe CBI's chargesheet partially. Aarushi got to know about her parents' extra marital. She must have questioned them but they wouldn't budge. She confided in Hemraj. The father and Aarushi must have had a face off where the jerk must have lost his cool and killed her. And hemraj must have objected. He too was finished. And then all the clean up started. He called up his elder brother and rest of the relatives to cover the scene and pay off the police. That's why they were in a hurry to cremate Aarushi and go off to Benares.
The only thing I noticed that she was a kid,just on the verge of entering teenage...and the amount of disrespect this departed soul received was utterly disrespectful....those who haven't carried out the evidences or manipulated it and played false witnesses are all in the category of murderers...Shame on CBI... Also...this was worst narration of this story and on this channel...
If she is not murdered by parents .. then after rescue why they are not asking for her justice... As sushant and Jiya khans family is still asking for justice... Then why isn't Arushi's parents ... It means they have some or other involvement.. either they murdered Hemraj... And someone else to Arushi .. when they saw her body they would have thought hemraj is killer.. and then they killed him.. but they didn't het chance to dump him
brother ! There are many more such cases in the past (abroad)..most of them were solved after more than a decade...it takes time ... or the truth itself reveal after sometime
@@kadumpabin6188 I think now it's too late I think Aarushi's parents are culprits because there was only one door to enter the house and there was a lot of noise from that door, her parents could not even hear it. Shocking
@@supriyacv actually anyone with a manipulated brain will think of it as murder cuz suicide and depression can be an alien concept for you scientist but not for normal human beings.
I think the reason why this case is still unsolved is because, from the beginning, the police suspected the parents and tried to gather evidence to prove them guilty. In the mean time, the news got so much media coverage that the real culprit took advantage of the situation and escaped.
@@memchakonthoujam3413 yes exactly. There was this one answer on quora that kind of brings out a perspective which seems like the real incident that might have occurred.
Hell no . Third party came inside and did all that mess without parents being awared . Whatever happened / escalated / led to these two murders can be speculated from various perspective but culprit being other than parents is unlikely at all .
It's very much evident that parents know the truth for sure but no evidence..This case disturbs me like hell..Who ever has done the crime,I don't think they can live a peaceful life for sure..
I have been following this case ever since 2008, I was 18 then. There are numerous theories about this case, n one of them being is that the Aarushi's parents were having an extra-marital affair n somehow both aarushi and hemraj were aware of it. Aarushi was quite disturbed with all these stuff and she may have threatened her parents to expose them in public, Maybe this could have been reason that parents ordered a camera n gifted her a lot earlier from her birthday just to please her but she didn't forgave them n this led her parents to kill both of them and it's quite likely that they have taken help of Krishna and his friends as they had failed in their narco tests.
Parents are the real killers .. remember the first incident the maid came home at 7:30 in morning and till she entered nobody actually called police... Why they was waiting for the maid to come and call the police?? They are the real culprits
Probably they were shocked and stunned. You see your daughter lying in pool of blood, I am sure calling police is not the first thing that comes in mind.
@@anushagupta4944 they saw her at 5 o clock at early morning .. maid came on 8 o clock didn't even thought to call police seeing daughter in that condition?? Atleast father would have thought .. but noo
How about this- • Arushi and Hemraj had a friendly relationship (like most children have with the house keepers) and arushi was in her room with Hemraj discussing about the camera. • things get a little personal and they both end up getting intimate consensually. • father hears something and goes in to check and catches them off guard. • Hemraj starts panicking and eventually tries to run away, father in rage goes after him but arushi tries to stop him. • in pure reflex he tries to push her away which leads to the head injury from bumping her head which leads to her death. • meanwhile the mother comes in and takes care of arushi when the father is still running after Hemraj. • Hemraj runs and eventually reaches the terrace, the father catches up to him and they argue and eventually the father kills him. • then begins the mourning period for an hour where they try to call everyone they can. 6 straight commected calls prove this theory that they're panicking. • eventually they clean up after arushi, then go for hemraj, the father first tries to mess up Hemraj's face so that when the forensics try to identify him, they get more time to get in the clear. • now here comes the part that is missed by most of the theories, they said that the maid had to unlock a door which was locked from outside before entering the house. the father and mother (Both dentists, both earning, both rich) they bribed the made into putting this simple and small detail which eventually becomes a big part of the case. [and from here on begins the case] Ps- the reaction they gave when the maid arrived wasn't a reaction you would expect from the parents who'd just lost their child, they didn't even call the police, the ambulance, anyone, it's so clear that they're the culprits, like really.
BUYING ad GIFTING CAMERA by TALWAR's were PART OF THE CONSPIRACY It wasn't accidental HEMRAJ had approached a senior social worker to inform her of something Unfortunately it didn't happen HEMRAJ had called his wife in Nepal and told about threat to his life Hemraj ddn't receive any salary for months This is not an accidental Murder It was well planned Only thing which screwed them was the PART of DISPOSING off HEMRAJ's Body which they failed due to Rabid Media attention Imagine if HEMRAJ's body was disposed THE STORY running today would be "NEPALI SERVANT MISSING AFTER KILLING DOCTOR'S DAUGHTER" KHALLAS!
It could have been a clear case. The only parties in case are Hemraj, Hemraj's friend, arushi and Talwar couple. But police showed such a low level of professionalism that all the evidence was destroyed. My relative was a part of probe. He told me for the first 2 days anyone could literally come inside the lobby of flat where bottle of wine was found opened. And the door of terrace was open for 5 days!. Imagine hundreds of people coming in the crime spot below while Hemraj is lying dead on terrace.
@@SAFFRONINFERNO i didn't say Hemaraj was not left unattended for 5 days. He was found on Day 2 of investigation. The door was bolted when police went up on day 1. So they climbed the neighbour's terrace. Ridiculously, they didn't noticed Hemraj (must be because he was covered with Water cooler sheets near the corner, so police pov it was blindspot. My point is there gross violation of code of conduct that is needed in forensics and crime spot security. Otherwise it could have been somewhat easier to comprehend
@@Urgrannytranny I know all facts of the case Thank You Inspite of HEMRAJ's body being found only on the next day UP POLICE had cracked the case Rest were all MEDIA NAUTANKI Ultimately 2nd CBI also agreed withUP POLICE findings
When Aarushi's body was discovered in her bedroom on 16 May, Hemraj was missing at the time, and was considered the main suspect. The next day, Hemraj's partially decomposed body was discovered on the terrace. The police were heavily criticized for failing to secure the crime scene immediately. After ruling out former domestic servants of the family, the police treated Aarushi's parents-Dr. Rajesh Talwar and Dr. Nupur Talwar-as the prime suspects. The police suspected that Rajesh had murdered the victims after finding them in an "objectionable" position, or because Rajesh's alleged extra-marital affair had led to his blackmail by Hemraj and a confrontation with Aarushi. The Talwars' family and friends accused the police of framing the Talwars in order to cover up the botched-up investigation. The case was then transferred to the CBI, which exonerated the parents and suspected the Talwars' assistant Krishna Thadarai and two domestic servants-Rajkumar and Vijay Mandal. Based on the 'narco' interrogation conducted on the three men, the CBI assumed that they had killed Aarushi after an attempted sexual assault, and Hemraj for being a witness. The CBI was accused of using dubious methods to extract a confession, and all the three men were released for lack of evidence. {R.I.P AARUSHI}...
A point I find interesting is why would the mother/parents used to lock Aarushi’s room? 🔐 I find it suspicious. Was it to prevent Aarushi from running away? Had someone broke into the house before? Most likely it was to prevent the father or Hemraj from entering her room. Then why put the key on the nightstand in plain reach?
Her room door was like when it closes, the person inside could open it easily like every normal door but the person outside could open it only by its key.
TRUE BUT THAT NIGHT SOMETHING ELSE HAPPENED arushi saw her mother having intercourse with hemraj ,arushi is a 14yrs old child and i dont think she would be okay with having sexual intercourse with a nepali 30+uncle . nupur talwar killed arushi,heat of the moment and when rajesh heard some sound in other room ,he came with golf stick and saw arushi dead on the floor .nupur talwar is a big kamapisachi,these married women need happy moments in bed if thier husbands won't do that ,these married women would lookout for some other source ,she manipulated the whole scene and said hemraj was forcing arushi and in that moment hemraj killed her ,listening to this scene rajesh talwar attacked hemraj with golf stick ,nupur also attacked with some sharp objject and then they killed him and took his body to terrace and left there . this is like a secret buried within a secret. even now nupur is hiding that affair of her with hemraj /
@@1ne7evN bro tm bta to aise rahe ho jaise is case ke record, evidence sab tumhari almirah mein rkhe hai jaise is incident ke agle din tumhi Gaye the waha investigation krne.. Did someone kidnapped your mind? Think before you speak...how can you say so that Mrs. Talwar was physically engaged with her servant.....do you have any prove? If not than mention that this is your assumption and nothing else
You should have covered the part where CBI came with another angle in which hemraj's friends were involved in the murder. You seem to have already chosen your side and announced that her parents were murderers.
Why will hemraj frnds turn the wifi off...seems like her father came into her room to turn the wifi off and saw something that compled him to murder her child
Hemraj ke frnd ko kaise pta ke wifi band krna hai taaki digital evidence na mile.... Aur usko kaise pta ke keys konsi hai terrace ki aur key nupur ke room me mili thi..... Mujhe to lgta hai ke arushi aur hemraj ke bich sexual relations honge aur arushi ke parents ne planning kr ke murder kiya hoga taaki proofs na mile.... Arushi ke parents arushi aur hemraj ko daily watch krte honge.... Isiliye planning kr ke murder kiya tha.... Giving her daughter camera gift is part of planning... Woh log acting kr rhe the......autopsy me sexual evidence nhi mile honge q ki dono safe sex krte hoge
A month ago I was reading comments (I don't remember the channel's name) there a man described himself as an ex policeman and he stated that Arushi talwar was their adopted child. Arushi's Foster dad raped her and hemraj knew about it.3-4 days ago before the murder case, Hemraj went to seek help from a Social worker But she was probably going out of town due to some imp work so she gave him a cop's no. A month ago, he called up his wife and told her to take care of herself , he's in danger n all. He's wife was so scared that she was ready to come to Delhi from Nepal.( this statement was given by their neighbours on phone call) But somehow hemraj convinced her that everything was fine. Hemraj was just trying to save arushi. Whenever I see the interviews, I see no pain in the talwar's eyes. I don't know the truth but this theory actually makes sense
Every time I come across this case I feel very strong sadness for the poor 13 years old girl who had to die in a horrible way in the middle of the night. Please don't blacken the name of this girl without evidence. I feel it is equally possible that she was killed by the 3 rowdy associates of Hemraj who were present in the house that night. The local police did an outstanding job of messing up the entire investigation.
@@captainlevi7188 Exactly 👌. Looks more like an honour killing. The post mortem report revealed the heavy killing blows were on the back of Hemraj's head and on the forehead of Arushi. Also the report said that both the throats were likely cut by surgical instruments and by people having keen knowledge of human anatomy. Arushi's private parts had also been cleaned up....
I believe the father sexually molested his own daughter, and the mother was well aware about her husband's nature. Probably hemraj saw something and wanted to help arushi which is why they killed him as well.
The police botched up the investigation on the first day itself. All the little evidences gathered lead to one of the 3 workers being the killers but sadly we might never get to know what happened on that fateful night.
I did follow this case when I first heard of it. It was back in 2016-17 when Talvar movie was released and my interest was invoked.I did a deep research on this, read every report that was available . As per all the information that was available, I felt that the first CBI team tried looking at this case with an angle involving an outside help ( hemraj friends & the clinic helpers). They were also put under narcotics test in which they did admit doing something heinous, but since the test is not admissible in court, there were no hard evidence to support their theory. It was only after the second CBI team, which I believe was under pressure to close this asap, accused the parents and tried the case. One should watch the movie ‘Talvar’ if they want to know what and how exactly the things happened. Also, @brainco , I watch your videos because I know that you present your matter without any bias and with full research, but this time, I really felt that your team lacked research n facts and this story was presented in very biased manner which made the parents prime suspects. The parents were not the suspects until the case was reopened and there was no action taken against police for letting people stampede the crime scene.
There's a reason why narcotics tests are not admissible in court. Because many times a positive can be a false positive in these tests. Simply moving your body and being nervous and afraid in general can falsely make your body act like it's lying which is why even if you are not lying you can appear to be lying. You can even fake these tests and lie and get away with it. That is why they are not credible to begin with. Yes hemraj's friends could be the culprit but the evidence is circumstantial. At the same time the parents can be the culprit too. There's evidences pointing towards both the parents and hemraj's friends so you can't just pick one side.
Evn i have watched TALWAR movie but that movie itself raise many question .... When police asked for keys why talwars dint gave it in one go why they said first go and search hemraj ??? When a ur child die any other parent would have obeyed the police... How murdered cleaned the room ?? For that one need to know where floor cleaner and cloth is kept Which servant realy do party inside their owner home???? Which owner realy give their keys to servants when they are living in that house ...... There was a door from hemraj room leading outside why this was not told by them to police .... Why his father called his brother at 3:09 am in the morning .....why they waited til their servant come to inform all Any sensible parents would have asked help immediately
Sorry but you cannot blame Brainco for the bias! The Research is pretty much up to standards but there are no evidenes (direct) to point towards anyone! But still the CBI and the police accused the parents due to circumstances and if you read the judgement and if you know the law on this then Conviction can be based on Circumstancial evidences!
Biggest flaw in the theory based on sexual relations of aarushi and hemraj was that hemraj's dna wasn't found in aarushi's room. It's impossible for parents to clean the entire room so hemraj's presence in that room is impossible. Aarushi already had a bf then why would she engage with an old man. People just like to spice up things no one really cares about the victims😔
U can't deny the fact that arushi and hemraj had sexual relationship. There are many cases in india where family servants or drivers are involved sexually with owners minor daughter. I think u don't see the news.
@@prakashverma7053 actually its was arushis father who is a sexual predator....hemraj was just a victim tats parents want to put all the blames to hemraj...to hide his body they kept him in roof locked the door...so her mom first answered to servent is "dekho hemraj ne kya karke bhag gaya" but they miserably failed to hide his body
I have seen so many such kind of cases on TH-cam itself, cases like people who died at very young age and after seeing those innocent faces, the only thought revolve around my mind is like ki uss ladke yaa ladki ko kitna kuch dekhne ko tha zindagi mai, there could be so many things which he/she might be having desire of achieving something.
In the first place Arushi was a teenager, why they kept a male maid? There are ample women out there and parents were working so the maid and Arushi used to be alone
The parents thought that they will puy the blame on Hemraj and later whenever possible they will get rid of Hemraj body..people will think that he killed Arushi and ran away...but their bad luck police found Hemraj body..
My only question 1.If parents were not involve then why didnt they shout out loud in the morning seeing the murder of their only child..rather they started weeping when the maid came inside the room
I think the parents killed Arushi,not intentionally,but accidentally,cos Arushis father got angry on Hemraj doing such a shameful act,which any parent will not accept,so to punish him he hit Hemraj,but accidentally hit his daughter.
I wonder why this case is still unresolved, while it is a clear evidence that only people who were present in that home on that fateful night were Talwar Couple and the servent ....also it was the couple who washed / cleaned / altered the crime scene even before police arrived. Being a Dentist they knew that it was gross negligence and unlawful on their part to act in such a manner. The house maid that visited very next morning as per her , Talwar Couple were quite Calm until they saw the maid and then strated crying. It clearly shows that they were mentally prepared and knew about the daughter 's death. The most stupid part of the Case is Noida police failed to Secure the evidence in their very first visit, and discovered that Upstairs door is still locked and this is where they later found the body of their servent who lived with the family. The very fact that Noise police failed to collect the Necessary in timely manner, lead to an Inconclusive resolution of this case ....
You didn't mentioned about the 1st investigation team of CBI wo declared Hemraj's friends as murderers and one of which was a assistant of Mr. Talvar. All this had been shown in the movie 'Talvar' of Irrfan Khan which is based on this case.
@@azfarsweb if it's in wikipedia Or bollywood make the movie doesn't mean that it is true and believed.. There are many thing in wikipedia not true and bollywood manipulate things that also true.. Some things or incident, situation should be analyzed from our brain and heart because God has given us that not wikipedia and movie that is made up by humans
@@jyotithapapatial3865 It's just a fact shown by the movie and wikipedia. This fact may or may not be frictional. Neither I nor you was present there so if we can't accept that fact we can't deny it too. But the end thing remains same. The actual murderers are not proved in the court. Her parents are released because of not much proof. This is thing we know and that is shown by the movie and wikipedia.
This, the Sushant singh rajput case and so many more mind boggling murder mysteries.. crime mysteries are so fascinating. now I realize why so many people are obsessed with crime mystery, thriller and suspense genres because the world is full of mysteries
I don't think parents can do such a heinous thing to their only child. And why would Aarushi have any relations with the servant, I mean she was a young attractive girl, she could easily have a boyfriend of her age. Hemraj was 45 and she was just a teen. Either it was the other servants or a third person, who initially came to kill Hemraj but Aarushi saw him, and then he killed her. Because there was an unknown fingerprint on the bottle of alcohol and various places in the house. And a different shoe sizes' footprint. Plus all the evidence was contaminated and the Police did not carry out the investigation properly.
but the tool use to kill them was used by doctors, her genitals were cleaned but pajama was wet, a mere maid can't remove evidence, a 3rd person would never know exactly that night NUPUR will forget to unlock the door unless maid helped in first place why will they keep a male maid in their house with a 13 year old? They were working full day and Hemraj and Arushi use to be alone.
Relax yrr chodo ab ye sb court bhi pgla gya ha ye case solve krte krte cbi,police koi nhi kr ska toh hum yaha comment section me ise suljha lenge kya? Ye case aisa hi jitna isme ghuso utna ye ulajhta jata ha mene talvar movie 2019 me dekhi thi aur aaj ye video dekha phir se ye mystery ne mujhe dara diya bechari arushi bechara hemraj kisne mara inhe kon tha vo bhagwan jane ab toh
Why will parents kill their child? If they were aware the body is there they would have tried to hide it somewhere else. It was definitely not parents because they seem to be really unaware. It was the other servants or somebody else.
The case is still unsolved because as per one of the theory arushi's father had two more servants other than Hemraj, at that night due to some reason all the three entered in the house as hemraj had an extra key of the house, as they entered the other two saw arushi sleeping their and they tried to manipulate her but she woke up and as they were frightened one of them who was also an assistant of arushi's father in his clinic cut her throat and when hemraj saw them doing so they killed him too
There was no one in the house except Talwars and Hemraj. Obviously, the parents have killed both of them and since they're doctors, they know how to clean the evidence very well. That's why they could never be caught.
@@prakashverma7053true ....bt jb apna h shi n ho to dusro ko kya blame krna .... parents should also take care that his child is young n alone at home n it's not safe to leave her at home with a servant ...that's why everyone not deserves to be a parent
There were other people involved in this case there is no doubt in that. I remember this case because I start having a hallucinations about her due to constantly watching her news. People who say that hemraj was having a intimacy with Aarushi why the hell parents choose to kill there daughter like this and then torture the servant and plan everything so much clearly. There is no chance at all that something big happens and they made up this story no doubt in that. My dad always said that the family who gives so much facility to a servant why the hell he would take advantage of owners in this way. There is no sane person who is getting separate room with refrigerator, tv and ac and all the things do such a stupid thing and that too in there own house. They just did it to drive the public attention to this shit so that main culprit can get away easily. Parents eere involved no doubt in that but i think Aarushi witness something she shouldn't have which is why the meet such a end.
And then why was her private organ cleaned,I think her parents forced the actuall killer to rape arushi and kill herself,to seperate themselves form the crime
Heemraaj was killed by arusi parents for having intercourse...... inreturn heemraaj relative/friends killed arusi as a Revenge 👍.....only arusi parents is investigated the other is unknown
Due to sudden rage, the father tried to hit hemraj but he moved his head and the golf stick hit Arushis head at left eye. It lead to concussion and she died.After that Hemraj ran towards terrace, Rajesh talwar ran after him and he hit him on stairs.Hemraj was able to walk upto to terrace gate where he actually fainted . His head was bleeding so he put one his hands on his head and whole fainting he put one of his hands on the wall.After that talwar couple dragged him till centre.Then they cut his throat with accurate precession so that they can make a story.They did same with Arushi as she was also dead due to concussion This all was done in fit of rage not planned .You can get this information from many platforms that Rajesh talwar is very loose tempered
Case studies, business, geopolitics and a lot more is awaiting on our new channel BigBrain Plus.
Check it out here : bit.ly/3V1ZCAY
Please make a video on Shardha's case too.....
Aaj bhi ye story mu jabani yaad hai bachpan me news me dhekha tha yee aabhi bhi yaad hai
Nostalgia
didn't expect @BigBrainco to leave out the CBI angle (Thadarai, Rajkumar and Mandal as suspects)...
Please a story on Skeleton Man of Kolkata
There are two types of detectives in this world. First, who analyse the evidences and find murderer. Second, who decide murderer first and then find evidences to make him murderer.
Copied dialogue from Criminal justice..... CONFIRMATORY BIAS
The second one is the lazy police
Criminal justice 🌝
@@samayrahere what's ur insta 🙈
Foolish dejavu
I researched a lot on this case some couple of months back, the more deeper one tries to go, the more mind-numbing things become.
Imagine the culprit is still out freely on the streets despite such a tragic crime, 14 years later. 🙏🏻
I have a theory and I think it's much more convincing than all the other ones , the servant tried to assault aarushi, and when she resisted then he killed her, cause of this her parents must have woken up and went to her room , and assumed or they must have seen the servant doing all this and killed him,, and after that her father called his brother and his brother called someone to go his house at that time and helped him hide all the evidences, and then he locked the door form outside and that person then placed servent's body on the terrese . That's likely what happened
@@beserk-er7843 so he dared to assault a girl in her own house while her parents were asleep ?
I think arushi n hemraj have sexual relationship...her parents saw them n killed them
@@TYSGHy78 it's all about the possibilities , if parent can kill their own child which is so so unusual, then there is a possibility of this too,
@@beserk-er7843 lame
if this may have happen
they would admit it right away
Aarushi Talwar was from my school and many of my elder friends and teachers tell me how charming she was. :( RIP to the innocent soul. No one deserves this :(( my teachers told me she was very good in studies too. I think there was def problem in the investigation, otherwise how could this not get solved with such clear reasons :((
Which school?
@@rockstarmighty468 dps noida
Woah this gives me goosebumps man. This is sad and so wierd that this case never got resolved
🙁🙁😢😢
Yes she was very intelligent in study ... uske sath talwar ne bahut galat kiya bas apni kamiya chupane k liye us bechari ki Bali chada si
I think the reason why this case is still unsloved is that the investigation team didn't handle the evidence properly and it was also shown in the movie "talwar" how the police mishandled the evidences.
I am going to be a law student soon and would surely do more research on this case in near future.
@@karunasingh3269 yes!
The parents manipulated everyone by saying it's definitely his servent. Because of that police were busy finding him cause they also had lot of pressure. The parents let as many relatives as they can in the house even before the arrival of the police. Key evidences may have destroyed by that time. They both are dentists. They sure has the basic knowledge of clearing as many evidences as they can
You belong from uttar pradesh allahabad?
All the best!!!
@@sangeetamishra5071 nope
While I was reading all the theories, I noticed a common thing in every one of it. Aarushi was considered the primary victim and Hemraj was considered the secondary, i.e he was killed because he saw something he should have not.
I have a question for you. Compare the lives of both Aarushi and Hemraj and tell me which one of them is more likely to get into something shady and get killed.
With no doubt Hemraj
he feared his life from someone,he had not been sending any money back home, he didnt eat his food that night, and he received a call from a PCO and it was never found who called him.
What if we assume that Hemraj was killed first and Aarushi was subsequently killed because she saw something she should have not?
At around 8:30 PM on 15 May 2008 Hemraj received a call from a PCO( Public Phone booth) and they talked for approx 6 minutes.
The person wanted to meet Hemraj. He invited the person to the Talwar’s appartement
Both the persons meet at the house and Hemraj let him in… It was a friendly entry and not a FORCED ONE .
Instead of the person coming late in the night around 10:30-12 in the midnight he may have been sitting in Hemraj’s room for a long time completely unaware to the family
Hemraj was very worried and lost his appetite that night, he served himself food but did not eat.
At some point The person demanded more liquor and to please him, Hemraj got it from Rajesh’s bar.. (The Ballantine Scotch Whisky) Hemraj may have left the bottle there on the table incase the person needed more liquor or accidentally left it.
After some time around 12 -1am they decided to go the terrace to take an argument upstairs so that they do not wake up the family or just went up to smoke or catch fresh air
Hemraj opened the lock and they went outside.
Over here a scuffle ensued and they might have grappled each other(due to the abrasions on Hemraj’s elbows). The person went on to bludgeon his head and then slit his throat (i can say this because there was a blood spatter effect on the terrace door )
The person put the cooler lid on his body and then locked the terrace door and pocketed the keys(they were never found). He came back to Hemraj’s room to wash his face (as he must have got some blood on his face due to the spurting effect),collected his phone or something he must have left behind that may lead the cops to him. Before leaving he drank some more whiskey and placed the bottle on the dining table of the Talwars.
On the other hand, Aarushi was reading Chetan Bhagat’s novel and had a split AC in her room
Over here any one of the two situations might have happened
-Aarushi on hearing some noise came out to check what was going on and saw the intruder
OR
-Aarushi went to the kitchen to drink some water and saw the person( Note that the kitchen and Hemraj’s room were pretty close)
The person hit her left parietal skull by a heavy blunt object and she could not scream because she had severe throat infection, she was knocked out unconscious.
Aarushi may have made some noise but her shrill high pitch sound may not have penetrated to her parents room under the din of a loud a/c. (shrill high frequency sounds do not travel far and do not easily travel across doors/walls while low frequency heavy sounds do, you may have seen this hearing sounds of drums / deep bass from a car with windows rolled up but not the sound of the singer.)
This caused severe blood clotting and concussion and resulted her death within 2 minutes.
On noticing a key on her door, he silently removed the key from the hole and put it on the dining table so as to not make any rattling noise due to the keys which might wake up the Talwars
The person then dragged Aarushi’s body into her room and then for a good measure hit her left eyebrow skull and slit her throat so that she couldn’t survive.
The person covered her with the white flannel blanket , arranged toys around her, put a school bag on her head to that show that as if she had been killed in her sleep.
He then picked up the phone that was lying on her bed or table so as to sell it later on. It was a nokia N72 and it could easily fetch 10,000 to 15,000 INR at that time.
Before leaving he drank some more scotch whiskey and then left the house
He latched the first gate if incase someone followed him
He didnt latch the outer one since it was useless.
Most Importantly my theory does not violate any evidence that has been recovered.
Ballantine Scotch whisky bottle containing both Hemraj’s as well as Aarushi’s blood
glasses partially filled with whisky found in Hemraj’s room
Hemraj being killed on the terrace
Terrace keys not found
Missing phones that were recovered later
Hemraj fearing his life from someone
Someone calling him from a PCO located within 1km of the Talwars and Hemraj’s phone being located within the same radius
Abrasions found on his elbows
The guard’s testimony that someone can enter Jalvayu Vihar without meeting the guards at all
Murder weapons not being found.
the shoe prints were of number 8 or 9, while Rajesh wears size 6 or 7 indicating there was someone else on terrace with Hemraj (who was wearing slippers)
Hemraj had no money and he stopped sending money home
latch from outside on the grill door
Hemraj not eating his dinner that night
use of Hemraj’s bathroom
What about arushi's private parts been cleaned and diluted?
Bhai tune hi toh nhi maara😂
O bhai.. first time itne likes aaye hain 🥺 thankyou bhailog❤️
But in the autopsy they specified that arushi was hit by a golf stick
And hemraj had multiple bounds and autopsy showed the sign of sexual activity in hemraj's private part
Arushi's private parts were cleaned thoroughly and tipped by his family not to include sexual assault in autopsy report
They were doctors they knew the protocol of crime scene still they let their servants clean the house and neighbours contaminate the crime scene if it's like ur theory there should have been some kind of DNA as there was a signs of struggle on hemraj's body
And DNA on the wishkey glass
There are many loop holes in the theory.
Man this theory could have proved true but it doesn't explain the suspicious behaviour of her parents, also the reason behind Hemraj's sexual activity.
@@manisha3333
1)Autopsy just made an assumption the murder weapon might be a golf stick because they couldn't find any other suitable weapon that might have caused such a blunt injury
2) Swollen Penis doesn't mean that the person was having intercourse.. According to toxology, a person's penis swells automatically after 36hrs of his death..
3)Aarushi's private parts were never cleaned.. Initially when the doctor conducted the autopsy on her.. He said there were no signs of rape.. but when the second cbi team took over the investigation(the one which blamed the parents) ,he suddenly reported that it was unusually large and "clean".. why would you that?
4)Take the shoes for a parents for a while.. would you be conscious enough to make the crime scene undisturbed or cry on you daugter's fate? It was the family members who helped clean the house not the Talwars..
I was 6-7 years old at that time..trust me it scared the shit outta me that even parents can kill their kid..it still gives me chills
@TaetaeKook hey me too
@taetaekook8989 I'm 7th my English teacher tell this story whole class...
@@anonymouse05 might have been graphic for you but trust when i was in 7th i had seen way worse shit on TH-cam+Internet
brooo it isn't sure that her parents were the murderer and the lack of evidence cant proof who was the real culprit...i believe in the cbi's 2 nd case it seemed more real...
I think case should be reopen as Cm of Up is yogi he can do this to serve justice let the truth come out culprit get caught and case get solved
I truly believe that parents are the culprit
1. The parents used to work in different clinic. The father was working with a woman and the mother was working with a man. And that man and woman was actually a married couple. Why the hell they need to swap. And CBI confirmed that they had extra marital affairs.
2. There were no sign of break in
3. Autopsy was fake which was confirm
4. They had the key of upstairs but they choose to hide the fact.
5. They are doctors they knew how forensics work and still ordered domestic helper to clean
6. They let every neighbor walk in the apartment to contaminate possible dna
7. The room was super clean and tidy
8. In the autopsy of hemraj it was found that he had sex.
9. Arusi was murdered in a blow but hemraj was tortured and murdered.
So on
All this murder game was planned just to conceal their affairs and the huge crime of hemraj using a kid for his need. That kid was innocent, was distressed as there were conflict in the family. Hemraj also used and manipulated her. But parents of that kid chose their pride over their kid.
Also his elder brother Dinesh talwar is most popular eye surgeon. He has connections with the doctor who did postmortem
Same even arushis private parts were cleaned her parents were doctors they knew what they were doing i think arushi was sexually involved with hemraj n the parents found them in compromising position that night
True what you said. They did it.
Agree . Their confidence and police negligence saved them)
why was the narco test not done of her parent's ?
One of the most crucial factors was the fact that her parents were highly educated doctors. They possessed a deep understanding of manipulation and their acting skills were truly exceptional. It was peculiar that despite two individuals losing their lives in the same house, these actors were able to wake up in the morning without a hint of fear in their screams.
They were dentists does bds also has forensic medicine as a subject?
Having a degree doesn't prove convicted you nonsense
Why is everyone calling them doctors, they were denstists.
@@dayaDarwazaKholDo dentists are also doctors
They have the prefix "dr"
@@bhoomi348 they have forensic odontology but they know everything quite well
Arushi's parents were high profile doctors in Noida. So both of them were medically trained enough in hiding all the forensic evidence after committing both the murders at night.
And they also called the Neighbors/medical help/police only after the maid finally saw Arushi's dead body.
Normal parents would have called for external help way earlier.
It was clearly mentioned that that night arushi had s*x and in the same postmortem report it was also mentioned that hemraj's private part was erected when he hot killed. End of ur debate.
Yup this is also annoying that why they waited till the 6 am ? They can call the neighbours or someone nearby!!!!
But how they can lock themselves from outside this is also the question ?
This is true.
@@letslive5372 there was a door from hemraj room that was leading outside to their main entrance .....
What was there plan ? ... To kill Arushi in home 🤣🤣🤣 because they need good sex life wtf ... If so they could easily killed Arushi outside without any problem .
This case will always remain a mystery and sometimes it still haunts me that what actually Happened that Night.
yes this case and burari case
@@ankanaghosh5163 burari case was shocking but it was clear why it happened But this Aarushi one isn't like that
Me too
Same
@AnshJain - exactly
Actually, before watching this.. I used to think that parents are not guilty. BUT after watching your video, I totally feel that parents did kill their daughter. Who in their right mind will lock their daughter's room.. this is a big red flag.
they dont lock her room , door to her room had self locking so it can either be opened from inside or the keys which the parents had
It's called latch system.
The abnormal thing is that Hemraj's body was in the terrace and it was locked . Why the outside murderer would take the pain of locking the terrace ? The key was with the Talwars .The body was also nicely wrapped .Why the outsider cover the body ? He has nothing to hide .
Good point, why would a killer bother to lock the door, he/she would run for their life, most other evidences also point towards the Parents, and their behaviour about the incident is also very wierd, specially the mother.
Exactly, who would take such a long time for transferring a boddy to terrace n then locking up then dressing up room ..😂😂he will be like m I killer or sweeper who is doing everything in just some minutes. ..talwars are killer infact her mother is killer .bcz she has no words to say . She can't make clear eye contact to any journalist. Also both parents 😂do close their arms like if they open hands in interview they will get scared.like in fear we get fold to over own body . They do tht
Exactly, wouldn’t the killer had the fear of getting caught? Talwars claim that their ac made loud noises due to which they barely heard outside noises, but if the killer was outsider, how did he knew about it??? Moreover Rajesh is extremely sketchy and as far I recalled he dint gave the key of door opening to terrace to the police n hurriedly cleaned the crime scene, if it not suspicious, then what is
And if the outsider came, why did he killed only Aarushi and hemraj why not Mr and Mrs Talwar??
- parents started crying after the their maid came in the morning.
- at first father was claiming that their servent killed her and ran away. ( They might have planned to put the balme on Hemraj and later deal with hemarj's body )
- their terrace door was locked from inside (who else could have locked the door?)
- later body of Hemraj found on terrace ( the point where their plan failed but their confidence and police negligence saved them )
1.If you kill somebody you will not keep their body on rooftop for 15 days he would have gotten rid of it
2 that was an apartment building not their private home so anyone could have locked it perhaps guard or watchman
@@luckyo1479 they did keep body on rooftop only because there is no option left to get ride of the body. How can someone take such huge body out of the buliding when there are guards it's impossible.
@@Ammu_ammu7 jab aap kisi ka murder kroge toh body raat me hi car me rkh kr ese jagha phekoge jaha koi pta nhi lga paye ya le jake chatt pr rakh doge raat ke 2 bje?
@@luckyo1479 why is the wifi turned off?
There was problem with their router. It kept turning on and off by itself. This behaviour was also noticed next day when police was around. Also, it is highly unlikely that body wsa dragged to rofftop. Instead it is more possible that Hemraj was killed on rooftop itself.
Thinking about this case still haunts me even though the film has potrayed the case in good way it gives up the decision to the audience to be made it’s just not justifiable to pin someone as the culprit there’s so much going on in this
May I know the name of the movie please
@@anonymousgrimreaper_00 Talvar
Bollywood is sold and has a diplomatic state of mind 😏
Then go and watch 44 days of hell
@@rishav_gupta where a girl was trapped in a room by a group of boys?
Every single time I come across this case.... And i repeat... Every single time. It gives me chills which run down my spine. Being a med student this case has always got me thinking of what really would have happened on that night. I mean there are a number of probabilities. On one side i want to believe that the parents haven't committed such a henius crime.... While on the other their suspicious behaviour just doesn't allow me to support them. Plus the 6 phone calls drama.... And a police officer being involved just makes it even more shadier.... I mean c'mon why would u do that in the between of the night.... Oh god!
What 6 phone calls?? Please elaborate
pls elaborate on 6 phone calls?
@@thegr8dowite Watch the clip at8:02
I think case should be reopen as Cm of Up is yogi he can do this to serve justice let the truth come out culprit get caught and case get solved
Array chumtiye khuch nahi hai itna bhuddi ghisne ka. Maa baap hai murder as they caught their daughter having hanky panky on the bed that night.
Actually our police officers are actually capable of solving such problems easily but most of the police officers don't do the investigation properly due to media and senior pressure and the second part is corruption in India for which most of the crimes are never solved
Crine patrol aur savdhan india ka police hi capable hai case crack karne ke liya bt reality main almost 90 percent officers r corrupted..
Those constables who came in the beginning must have been paid off, to neglect the obvious evidence. They did not even go and check the terrace. When crime happens, you need to peruse the whole surrounding area!!
Like the SSR case everyone knows but still it lingering...bcoz everyone knows when it's dragged people will forget the case
@@rinkypatnaik1990 its not corruption , the way police system works its very dificult to investigate such cases unless there have been orders from above . and these orders only come when there is too much external pressure. The police at local level has limited power
Agar India main police crime patrol ya Savdhan India ki tarah hoti, to India bahut safe country hota rehne ke liye. But unfortunately our police is highly corrupt.@@rinkypatnaik1990
I watched talwar movie on Netflix recently, and the one scene I can't forget when one police man breaks the glass and asked the other one I broke just one glass and you are awake.
But two murders happened in the house still parents were asleep?? What a bullshit! Arushi deserves justice. And the parents should be behind the bars!
What is name of that serie how can I find it
Court asked to validate this. They tested and found that they close the door becz of ac and due to other factors sound is inherited. Soundproof
@@iamfreestyle4133 it's movie Talwar
No bro facts ke hisaab se parents culprit nhi hai, room ac sound,
@@D_S_DEVIL wo parents ke facts hain. CBI ke evidenciary proof ke hisaab se, aur common sense ke hisaab se , parents ke alawa aur koi bhi nahi tha. Agar alien aaya hoga toh pata nahi.
Ye Hemraj ke darne wali baat sab created hai..wo normally reh Raha tha.
The fact that chills me out is that someONE knows who actually killed her
What is more chilling is that her parents did it. And way more than that is that they got away with it.
How can u say it
Doors were locked from inside. There was no new person seen in the colony for the last 3 weeks or so in the footage. There were security dogs. They never barked that night. And why only aarushi and hemraj were killed? Why no jewellery or any other items stolen? Why aarushi's inner body parts were cleaned up ? It doesn't take rocket science to figure out ,who did it!!
@@sanjaysingha4346 how can they be so ruthless to their own daughter
Door was not locked from inside. From where did you get those facts. Please provide link
Why their parents didn't inform police in the first place? It's obvious that, anyone in that situation could have panicked and called any available helpline/neighbours at once. Their parents waited for arrival of the maid to disclose the incident, what stopped them?
They killed their daughter and servant as they found them having sex and got furious.
I think case should be reopen as Cm of Up is yogi he can do this to serve justice let the truth come out culprit get caught and case get solved
I believe it's the parents. All they did was to sabotage the investigation. They didn't immediately informed the police when they "discovered" the body of the girl. They allowed the media to come in and contaminate the crime scene before the police could collect the evidence. They started criticising the police from the start. It's really a disturbing story. No one is right in the scenario. Everyone made mistakes but what the parents did was too glaring to ignore.
I still remember this case.. I was a kid that time.. this was the biggest mystery which went on for months in news channels.. daily i used to check the news for updates
Same here
@@GauravSaikia01 I happen to do the same now for sheezan tunisha case, where I think sheezan is innocent
Why is it only speculated that the father caught his daughter in a compromising position? Why was it never considered that Hemraj caught Rajesh abusing his daughter? His wife said he(Hemraj) felt fatherly towards Arushi. Even Arushi’s boyfriend Anmol said that she was having problems with her father. If something had been going on, low-key, and that night it escalated, he, Hemraj, might have felt he needed to step in. Which led to his murder, and then Arushi's, in order to prevent her from spilling the beans, about the abuse and subsequent murder. That to me seems the most likely. Also they allowed media and neighbours in the crime scene to contaminate the crime scene on purpose.
Also they asked to not to mention sexual assault in the medical report.. why? Additionally her vaginal area was cleaned and diluted.
According to my understanding, Both parents are guilty.
movie and news
@@graphiannikhill2409 I have followed this case for quite a long time. Watched few documentary having details so I know this much.
@@graphiannikhill2409 was talking about myself sir!
But in autopsy of hemraj it was found dat he had sex...
@@proudindian4401 I don't find that statement to have any credibility, because Hemraj's body was found more than 24 hours after he died and generally the abdomen becomes greatly distended and penis and scrotum becomes enormously swollen post 18-24 hours after someone dies.
Why to add sexual indulgement in every unsolved cases ??there are so many reasons and 14 years before sexual indulgement was not common enough for a teenager.
Just in case victim is a girl these statements are not always appropriate.
Is it common now for Indian underage girls to wh*re themselves in school itself?, disgusting girls in our society.
@@SodiumSyndicate the case is of 14 years ago watch video properly ..that time these things were not common
@@priiaa1012 in that time also things were that common.2006se maine suna hai ladkian bf krti thi at the age of 18-19,aur physical bhi hoti thi unke saath so it's not uncommon for girl's to be physical with any other man.
But point is we don't know if she was doing that consensually or she was forced by the servant.
@@Nothing-uc5mg I kinda feel like it was mutual. If it was forced she would have told her parents or friends. Even if she wouldn't have told anyone. She might be scared or depressed and anyone would have noticed. Her parents said in an interview that Hemraj and Arushi got along like father and kid. So it is pretty much clear it was mutual.
@@Ammu_ammu7 anything could have happened,we can't never be sure.
It was the parents who told maid first instead of calling police/dialling 100. They showed it to maid. She inturn informed all the surroundings, all people dived into their house. Disturbed the footprints, fingerprints. It always points out to the parents.
This case is simply chilling because it hasn't come to any conclusion. Only Arushi and Hemraj know...
Exactly.. Baki everything is just a speculation..
maybe one day murderer himself/herself will confess
@@ankanaghosh5163 hope so but there is very less chance that will happen, sadly ☹️
💀
Or the criminals 💰
The 2008 image of Aarushi still gives goosebumps.
Yah
parents of Arushi talvar did a crime for sure. The spontaneity speaks it all;
1. The evidences were cleared. It is a crime.
2. They did not give the key to the terrace
3. They were on a phone call for three hours in a loop which involves a police personnel.
It is also possible that they killed Hemraj for killing their daughter.
Unki beti ke marne ka dukh woh kitne din mein bhula paaye can tell us how much they loved her to not kill her
I feel like her parents were actually innocent but a third party was involved who managed to get away during the whole controversy
I like your comment Broder 👍
@@Caniacaniago007 brother not broder🌝🌝
I closely followed this case and also read entire investigation report and i am 100000% sure there parents are involved. This is a case of honor killing.
@@sukanthdev8153 why do you think so?
proud to be ex-jews vegetarian muslim - pm imran Khan ( ex-President of pakistan) hj
Parents could be killers but we have to consider all possible cases Hemraj's friends were present at the night of murder so isn't it possible that his friends got drunk which lead them to enter Aarushi's room and Hemraj was killed as he saw everything.
Have u seen the Talwar Movie?
@@Abhi_45 yeah
May be
House was locked from inside. Even the spare key was with mother. She threw it down to the servant in the morning. All friends of Hemraj had alibi. I believe CBI's chargesheet partially.
Aarushi got to know about her parents' extra marital. She must have questioned them but they wouldn't budge. She confided in Hemraj. The father and Aarushi must have had a face off where the jerk must have lost his cool and killed her. And hemraj must have objected. He too was finished. And then all the clean up started. He called up his elder brother and rest of the relatives to cover the scene and pay off the police.
That's why they were in a hurry to cremate Aarushi and go off to Benares.
Frr hemraj ka friend khn gya?
I was 12 yrs old that time and still remember this news playing whole day in every news channel
The only thing I noticed that she was a kid,just on the verge of entering teenage...and the amount of disrespect this departed soul received was utterly disrespectful....those who haven't carried out the evidences or manipulated it and played false witnesses are all in the category of murderers...Shame on CBI...
Also...this was worst narration of this story and on this channel...
If she is not murdered by parents .. then after rescue why they are not asking for her justice... As sushant and Jiya khans family is still asking for justice... Then why isn't Arushi's parents ... It means they have some or other involvement.. either they murdered Hemraj... And someone else to Arushi .. when they saw her body they would have thought hemraj is killer.. and then they killed him.. but they didn't het chance to dump him
Exactly that's the point if they were so innocent why aren't they keen for the justice of thier daughter?? 🤨
This case makes me feel sad. Unfortunately, this is never going to be solved.
brother ! There are many more such cases in the past (abroad)..most of them were solved after more than a decade...it takes time ... or the truth itself reveal after sometime
@@kadumpabin6188 I think now it's too late I think Aarushi's parents are culprits because there was only one door to enter the house and there was a lot of noise from that door, her parents could not even hear it. Shocking
Very well explained. Sad to know that murderers are still roaming free. We hope someday you will cover up Sushant Singh Rajput murder case too. 😔
Suicide not murder.
@@SigaP69 Murder not suicide
@@supriyacv murder only according to bots and their conspiracy theories.
@@mayankpandey5447 Anyone with good brain understand that it's a preplanned murder.
@@supriyacv actually anyone with a manipulated brain will think of it as murder cuz suicide and depression can be an alien concept for you scientist but not for normal human beings.
Had my school in the same locality ,so have seen media vans around the location....it was so scary to be so close to such a thing
I think the reason why this case is still unsolved is because, from the beginning, the police suspected the parents and tried to gather evidence to prove them guilty. In the mean time, the news got so much media coverage that the real culprit took advantage of the situation and escaped.
It is true one of the detective believed that parent were guilty
@@memchakonthoujam3413 yes exactly. There was this one answer on quora that kind of brings out a perspective which seems like the real incident that might have occurred.
Hell no . Third party came inside and did all that mess without parents being awared . Whatever happened / escalated / led to these two murders can be speculated from various perspective but culprit being other than parents is unlikely at all .
Confirmation bias
Nope ...parents r culprits
It's very much evident that parents know the truth for sure but no evidence..This case disturbs me like hell..Who ever has done the crime,I don't think they can live a peaceful life for sure..
The fact is the whole family know who's actually murder
If story telling was an art Aman is best in this channel
thank you abhishek❤️
Check out Mr. Ballen.
Everything is an art in the eye of the artist
True
Anmol will tell everything .just find him and confirm his identity to prove without any story fake identity fake police in some pictures .
I have been following this case ever since 2008, I was 18 then.
There are numerous theories about this case, n one of them being is that the Aarushi's parents were having an extra-marital affair n somehow both aarushi and hemraj were aware of it. Aarushi was quite disturbed with all these stuff and she may have threatened her parents to expose them in public,
Maybe this could have been reason that parents ordered a camera n gifted her a lot earlier from her birthday just to please her but she didn't forgave them n this led her parents to kill both of them and it's quite likely that they have taken help of Krishna and his friends as they had failed in their narco tests.
If that was the case then why will both parents support each other...
@@yogeshjoshi781 read articles..it was suspected that they were involved in couple swapping
I think case should be reopen as Cm of Up is yogi he can do this to serve justice let the truth come out culprit get caught and case get solved
@@knightrider8126 nothing cant be done now. literally nothing.
Pointed 📌
great articulation of story aman.
suggestion: that flashing red light is distracting. replace it.
Parents are the real killers .. remember the first incident the maid came home at 7:30 in morning and till she entered nobody actually called police... Why they was waiting for the maid to come and call the police?? They are the real culprits
Nhmm mng n
Probably they were shocked and stunned. You see your daughter lying in pool of blood, I am sure calling police is not the first thing that comes in mind.
Yes right ...
@@anushagupta4944 they saw her at 5 o clock at early morning .. maid came on 8 o clock didn't even thought to call police seeing daughter in that condition?? Atleast father would have thought .. but noo
@@anushagupta4944 wouldn't you atleast call the fucking police? Would you wait for hours to call police if you see your family member dead?
Amaaaannnnnnnn youuu are the bestttttt🥺💯
thank you❤️
Thanks for showing us an informative video.
When someone's ego is larger than life, they'll probably do anything, even murder their own child to protect it.
Yup . Honor killing
Teri 13 sal ki bachhi 40 sal ke bude ke sath soke dikegi to tera ego nahi alag ata hai ..
How about this-
• Arushi and Hemraj had a friendly relationship (like most children have with the house keepers) and arushi was in her room with Hemraj discussing about the camera.
• things get a little personal and they both end up getting intimate consensually.
• father hears something and goes in to check and catches them off guard.
• Hemraj starts panicking and eventually tries to run away, father in rage goes after him but arushi tries to stop him.
• in pure reflex he tries to push her away which leads to the head injury from bumping her head which leads to her death.
• meanwhile the mother comes in and takes care of arushi when the father is still running after Hemraj.
• Hemraj runs and eventually reaches the terrace, the father catches up to him and they argue and eventually the father kills him.
• then begins the mourning period for an hour where they try to call everyone they can. 6 straight commected calls prove this theory that they're panicking.
• eventually they clean up after arushi, then go for hemraj, the father first tries to mess up Hemraj's face so that when the forensics try to identify him, they get more time to get in the clear.
• now here comes the part that is missed by most of the theories, they said that the maid had to unlock a door which was locked from outside before entering the house. the father and mother (Both dentists, both earning, both rich) they bribed the made into putting this simple and small detail which eventually becomes a big part of the case.
[and from here on begins the case]
Ps- the reaction they gave when the maid arrived wasn't a reaction you would expect from the parents who'd just lost their child, they didn't even call the police, the ambulance, anyone, it's so clear that they're the culprits, like really.
Elite class girls are generally involved sexually with their servants and drivers. Never marry with them.
BUYING ad GIFTING CAMERA by TALWAR's were PART OF THE CONSPIRACY
It wasn't accidental
HEMRAJ had approached a senior social worker to inform her of something
Unfortunately it didn't happen
HEMRAJ had called his wife in Nepal and told about threat to his life
Hemraj ddn't receive any salary for months
This is not an accidental Murder
It was well planned
Only thing which screwed them was the PART of DISPOSING off HEMRAJ's Body which they failed due to Rabid Media attention
Imagine if HEMRAJ's body was disposed
THE STORY running today would be "NEPALI SERVANT MISSING AFTER KILLING DOCTOR'S DAUGHTER"
KHALLAS!
Nonsense. There were drag marks of body from stairs to terrace. Too much free time u have to say nonsense
I think case should be reopen as Cm of Up is yogi he can do this to serve justice let the truth come out culprit get caught and case get solved
It can't be head injury , if you listen carefully she had neck slit
It could have been a clear case. The only parties in case are Hemraj, Hemraj's friend, arushi and Talwar couple. But police showed such a low level of professionalism that all the evidence was destroyed. My relative was a part of probe. He told me for the first 2 days anyone could literally come inside the lobby of flat where bottle of wine was found opened. And the door of terrace was open for 5 days!. Imagine hundreds of people coming in the crime spot below while Hemraj is lying dead on terrace.
The stench of the body will be all over within 5 days
no way it will happen like that
@@SAFFRONINFERNO i didn't say Hemaraj was not left unattended for 5 days. He was found on Day 2 of investigation. The door was bolted when police went up on day 1. So they climbed the neighbour's terrace. Ridiculously, they didn't noticed Hemraj (must be because he was covered with Water cooler sheets near the corner, so police pov it was blindspot. My point is there gross violation of code of conduct that is needed in forensics and crime spot security. Otherwise it could have been somewhat easier to comprehend
@@Urgrannytranny I know all facts of the case
Thank You
Inspite of HEMRAJ's body being found only on the next day UP POLICE had cracked the case
Rest were all MEDIA NAUTANKI
Ultimately 2nd CBI also agreed withUP POLICE findings
When Aarushi's body was discovered in her bedroom on 16 May, Hemraj was missing at the time, and was considered the main suspect. The next day, Hemraj's partially decomposed body was discovered on the terrace. The police were heavily criticized for failing to secure the crime scene immediately. After ruling out former domestic servants of the family, the police treated Aarushi's parents-Dr. Rajesh Talwar and Dr. Nupur Talwar-as the prime suspects. The police suspected that Rajesh had murdered the victims after finding them in an "objectionable" position, or because Rajesh's alleged extra-marital affair had led to his blackmail by Hemraj and a confrontation with Aarushi. The Talwars' family and friends accused the police of framing the Talwars in order to cover up the botched-up investigation. The case was then transferred to the CBI, which exonerated the parents and suspected the Talwars' assistant Krishna Thadarai and two domestic servants-Rajkumar and Vijay Mandal. Based on the 'narco' interrogation conducted on the three men, the CBI assumed that they had killed Aarushi after an attempted sexual assault, and Hemraj for being a witness. The CBI was accused of using dubious methods to extract a confession, and all the three men were released for lack of evidence.
{R.I.P AARUSHI}...
A point I find interesting is why would the mother/parents used to lock Aarushi’s room? 🔐 I find it suspicious. Was it to prevent Aarushi from running away? Had someone broke into the house before? Most likely it was to prevent the father or Hemraj from entering her room. Then why put the key on the nightstand in plain reach?
Her room door was like when it closes, the person inside could open it easily like every normal door but the person outside could open it only by its key.
TRUE BUT THAT NIGHT SOMETHING ELSE HAPPENED
arushi saw her mother having intercourse with hemraj ,arushi is a 14yrs old child and i dont think she would be okay with having sexual intercourse with a nepali 30+uncle . nupur talwar killed arushi,heat of the moment and when rajesh heard some sound in other room ,he came with golf stick and saw arushi dead on the floor .nupur talwar is a big kamapisachi,these married women need happy moments in bed if thier husbands won't do that ,these married women would lookout for some other source ,she manipulated the whole scene and said hemraj was forcing arushi and in that moment hemraj killed her ,listening to this scene rajesh talwar attacked hemraj with golf stick ,nupur also attacked with some sharp objject and then they killed him and took his body to terrace and left there . this is like a secret buried within a secret. even now nupur is hiding that affair of her with hemraj /
@@1ne7evN bro tm bta to aise rahe ho jaise is case ke record, evidence sab tumhari almirah mein rkhe hai jaise is incident ke agle din tumhi Gaye the waha investigation krne..
Did someone kidnapped your mind?
Think before you speak...how can you say so that Mrs. Talwar was physically engaged with her servant.....do you have any prove?
If not than mention that this is your assumption and nothing else
@@1ne7evNthis can be true as well,as far as I have studied this case.....I think nupur killed arushi
@@1ne7evNye toh kisine socha hee nhi 😮
You should have covered the part where CBI came with another angle in which hemraj's friends were involved in the murder.
You seem to have already chosen your side and announced that her parents were murderers.
The CBI angle was proven wrong by another CBI investigation only !. Watch “behind closed doors” an HBO documentary on this case.
Why will hemraj frnds turn the wifi off...seems like her father came into her room to turn the wifi off and saw something that compled him to murder her child
Hemraj ke frnd ko kaise pta ke wifi band krna hai taaki digital evidence na mile.... Aur usko kaise pta ke keys konsi hai terrace ki aur key nupur ke room me mili thi..... Mujhe to lgta hai ke arushi aur hemraj ke bich sexual relations honge aur arushi ke parents ne planning kr ke murder kiya hoga taaki proofs na mile.... Arushi ke parents arushi aur hemraj ko daily watch krte honge.... Isiliye planning kr ke murder kiya tha.... Giving her daughter camera gift is part of planning... Woh log acting kr rhe the......autopsy me sexual evidence nhi mile honge q ki dono safe sex krte hoge
There was a problem with their router
because that angle never had too much real ground. It is just popular due to movie. That angle had many flaws
Arushi's mom in her interview was emotionless for her daughter....on her dead daughters first birthday.
She was just defending her husband.
Coz for a lady husband is always more important than kids
@Nirbhay Pratap Singh No women can stop tears on her single daughter's brutal killing.
No matter what other thinks.
@@nirbhaypratapsingh3749 tum uske family member lagate ho 😂
@@nirbhaypratapsingh3749 if even courts think....talwars r killers.
Who r u ?
Telling she is innocent
There is no perfect crime but imperfect investigation
A month ago I was reading comments (I don't remember the channel's name) there a man described himself as an ex policeman and he stated that Arushi talwar was their adopted child. Arushi's Foster dad raped her and hemraj knew about it.3-4 days ago before the murder case, Hemraj went to seek help from a Social worker But she was probably going out of town due to some imp work so she gave him a cop's no. A month ago, he called up his wife and told her to take care of herself , he's in danger n all. He's wife was so scared that she was ready to come to Delhi from Nepal.( this statement was given by their neighbours on phone call) But somehow hemraj convinced her that everything was fine. Hemraj was just trying to save arushi.
Whenever I see the interviews, I see no pain in the talwar's eyes. I don't know the truth but this theory actually makes sense
Last line makes sense they have not even a single sign if grief
make sense
why arushi was happy if she had problem with her family and if so why she never showed any problem outside if her father was abusing her
@@vijayanvishnu3501 her best frnd knew ...(police changed the statement and even autopsy reports which they showed were fake)
Arushi adopted thi??
Every time I come across this case I feel very strong sadness for the poor 13 years old girl who had to die in a horrible way in the middle of the night. Please don't blacken the name of this girl without evidence. I feel it is equally possible that she was killed by the 3 rowdy associates of Hemraj who were present in the house that night. The local police did an outstanding job of messing up the entire investigation.
WRONG!!!! keep blaming the poor when most of the evidence point towards the parents.
@@captainlevi7188 Exactly 👌. Looks more like an honour killing.
The post mortem report revealed the heavy killing blows were on the back of Hemraj's head and on the forehead of Arushi.
Also the report said that both the throats were likely cut by surgical instruments and by people having keen knowledge of human anatomy.
Arushi's private parts had also been cleaned up....
Sad thing about this case is that it will never be going to solve completely due to destruction of the evidences from the crime scene ......
Weird..parents seem involved..but how can someone be so heartless..like how..for their own daughter..🙃
Teri bahan hoti to kya karata tu . Us jagaha . Pyar se gale lagata kya...
I believe the father sexually molested his own daughter, and the mother was well aware about her husband's nature. Probably hemraj saw something and wanted to help arushi which is why they killed him as well.
Yes mayb
@@shruwa No
No
No
Exactly I feel like that ..but little
O God .... this case is very twisted 😱😱😱😱
didn't expect @BigBrainco to leave out the CBI angle (Thadarai, Rajkumar and Mandal as suspects)...
The police botched up the investigation on the first day itself. All the little evidences gathered lead to one of the 3 workers being the killers but sadly we might never get to know what happened on that fateful night.
I did follow this case when I first heard of it. It was back in 2016-17 when Talvar movie was released and my interest was invoked.I did a deep research on this, read every report that was available . As per all the information that was available, I felt that the first CBI team tried looking at this case with an angle involving an outside help ( hemraj friends & the clinic helpers). They were also put under narcotics test in which they did admit doing something heinous, but since the test is not admissible in court, there were no hard evidence to support their theory. It was only after the second CBI team, which I believe was under pressure to close this asap, accused the parents and tried the case. One should watch the movie ‘Talvar’ if they want to know what and how exactly the things happened.
Also, @brainco , I watch your videos because I know that you present your matter without any bias and with full research, but this time, I really felt that your team lacked research n facts and this story was presented in very biased manner which made the parents prime suspects. The parents were not the suspects until the case was reopened and there was no action taken against police for letting people stampede the crime scene.
Very good... I completely agree with you.. Kuch research nahi kiyi... Bus bolne ke liye bol raha hai style main sabkuch
There's a reason why narcotics tests are not admissible in court. Because many times a positive can be a false positive in these tests. Simply moving your body and being nervous and afraid in general can falsely make your body act like it's lying which is why even if you are not lying you can appear to be lying. You can even fake these tests and lie and get away with it. That is why they are not credible to begin with. Yes hemraj's friends could be the culprit but the evidence is circumstantial. At the same time the parents can be the culprit too. There's evidences pointing towards both the parents and hemraj's friends so you can't just pick one side.
Absolutely wrong
Evn i have watched TALWAR movie but that movie itself raise many question ....
When police asked for keys why talwars dint gave it in one go why they said first go and search hemraj ???
When a ur child die any other parent would have obeyed the police...
How murdered cleaned the room ??
For that one need to know where floor cleaner and cloth is kept
Which servant realy do party inside their owner home????
Which owner realy give their keys to servants when they are living in that house ......
There was a door from hemraj room leading outside why this was not told by them to police ....
Why his father called his brother at 3:09 am in the morning .....why they waited til their servant come to inform all
Any sensible parents would have asked help immediately
Sorry but you cannot blame Brainco for the bias!
The Research is pretty much up to standards but there are no evidenes (direct) to point towards anyone!
But still the CBI and the police accused the parents due to circumstances and if you read the judgement and if you know the law on this then Conviction can be based on Circumstancial evidences!
Don't do that red blinking light ever
FEEDBACK:
DONT PUT BLINKING LIGHTS IN BACKGROUND ITS VERY ANNOYING
PLEASE PUT SOME WARM BACKGROUND AT THE TIME OF NARRATION.
Biggest flaw in the theory based on sexual relations of aarushi and hemraj was that hemraj's dna wasn't found in aarushi's room. It's impossible for parents to clean the entire room so hemraj's presence in that room is impossible. Aarushi already had a bf then why would she engage with an old man. People just like to spice up things no one really cares about the victims😔
U can't deny the fact that arushi and hemraj had sexual relationship. There are many cases in india where family servants or drivers are involved sexually with owners minor daughter. I think u don't see the news.
@@prakashverma7053 actually its was arushis father who is a sexual predator....hemraj was just a victim tats parents want to put all the blames to hemraj...to hide his body they kept him in roof locked the door...so her mom first answered to servent is "dekho hemraj ne kya karke bhag gaya" but they miserably failed to hide his body
@@dexterboro1836 u r living in ur own imaginary world. Get well soon 🙏
@@prakashverma7053 u also get well soon
@@prakashverma7053 there wasn't a solid evidence so it would be bizarre to blindly trust this theory.
I have seen so many such kind of cases on TH-cam itself, cases like people who died at very young age and after seeing those innocent faces, the only thought revolve around my mind is like ki uss ladke yaa ladki ko kitna kuch dekhne ko tha zindagi mai, there could be so many things which he/she might be having desire of achieving something.
The way Aman jain tell storiess is just so mind blowinggg 🤌🏻✨
thank you sharmaji❤️
Neither police nor CBI but you resolved the case in just 11 minutes.
#Sarcastic
Bhai background ka wo red light bohot irritating hai next time please use na kre , requesting you 🙏😣 please, nehi to baki sab sahi laga 😀
In the first place Arushi was a teenager, why they kept a male maid? There are ample women out there and parents were working so the maid and Arushi used to be alone
Total degenerate elite family. The 13 year old daughter also had a boyfriend. Imagine that. Total trash westernized degenerate family.
@@SodiumSyndicate she was also physically active
@@ankanaghosh5163 lmao physically active?! 💀 You could've said sexually active
@@ankanaghosh5163 at the age of 13????
@@banasmitakalita7373 thought it would be odd to write that 😅 yes I meant that only
It will be an unsolved case in history unless criminals confession
Video starts at 5:33 actual story.....save your time guys
Just don't understand if her birthday comes on 24 may then wo apna birthday pehle(16 may) pr kyu celebrate krne wali thi?🤔
The parents thought that they will puy the blame on Hemraj and later whenever possible they will get rid of Hemraj body..people will think that he killed Arushi and ran away...but their bad luck police found Hemraj body..
Love you big brain co.❤️❤️
AMAN JAIN BHAIYAA IS BEST FOR THRILLED STORIES
thank you Arya❤️
@@Amanjain0907 😳💗
My only question
1.If parents were not involve then why didnt they shout out loud in the morning seeing the murder of their only child..rather they started weeping when the maid came inside the room
Because they found that their girl had relationship with a 45 yr old servant
It's too dangerous case..... I think father is guilty 😢
I think the parents killed Arushi,not intentionally,but accidentally,cos Arushis father got angry on Hemraj doing such a shameful act,which any parent will not accept,so to punish him he hit Hemraj,but accidentally hit his daughter.
I wonder why this case is still unresolved, while it is a clear evidence that only people who were present in that home on that fateful night were Talwar Couple and the servent ....also it was the couple who washed / cleaned / altered the crime scene even before police arrived. Being a Dentist they knew that it was gross negligence and unlawful on their part to act in such a manner.
The house maid that visited very next morning as per her , Talwar Couple were quite Calm until they saw the maid and then strated crying. It clearly shows that they were mentally prepared and knew about the daughter 's death.
The most stupid part of the Case is Noida police failed to Secure the evidence in their very first visit, and discovered that Upstairs door is still locked and this is where they later found the body of their servent who lived with the family.
The very fact that Noise police failed to collect the Necessary in timely manner, lead to an Inconclusive resolution of this case ....
God damn right
Acc to me Rajesh Talwar saw Arushi & Hemraj at an objectionable position and all these things happened . And to save her husband Nupur lied .
Watch movie - Talvar
@Pranit Pawani nhi lekin kabhi mod dikhye hai usme bhi
Objectionable position??
💀💀💀💀
??
Wtf do you mean by objectionable position?
proud to be ex-jews vegetarian muslim - pm imran Khan ( ex-President of pakistan) hj
How can a 13 year old indulge in sexual activity??
Great job bro but what you do extraordinary for this case kindly share question from starting to end is same...
You didn't mentioned about the 1st investigation team of CBI wo declared Hemraj's friends as murderers and one of which was a assistant of Mr. Talvar. All this had been shown in the movie 'Talvar' of Irrfan Khan which is based on this case.
Bollywood wale sab manipulate karke bata te hain that's not true
@@jyotithapapatial3865 Nope. Wikipedia pe iss case ka pura article hai usme bhi likha hua hai ye sab.
@@azfarsweb if it's in wikipedia Or bollywood make the movie doesn't mean that it is true and believed.. There are many thing in wikipedia not true and bollywood manipulate things that also true.. Some things or incident, situation should be analyzed from our brain and heart because God has given us that not wikipedia and movie that is made up by humans
@@azfarsweb tereko pata he naWikipedia kp public hi edit to the "best of there knowledge "?
@@jyotithapapatial3865 It's just a fact shown by the movie and wikipedia. This fact may or may not be frictional. Neither I nor you was present there so if we can't accept that fact we can't deny it too. But the end thing remains same. The actual murderers are not proved in the court. Her parents are released because of not much proof. This is thing we know and that is shown by the movie and wikipedia.
You missed the points where friends of hemraj were in the house drinking
This, the Sushant singh rajput case and so many more mind boggling murder mysteries.. crime mysteries are so fascinating. now I realize why so many people are obsessed with crime mystery, thriller and suspense genres because the world is full of mysteries
I don't think parents can do such a heinous thing to their only child. And why would Aarushi have any relations with the servant, I mean she was a young attractive girl, she could easily have a boyfriend of her age. Hemraj was 45 and she was just a teen. Either it was the other servants or a third person, who initially came to kill Hemraj but Aarushi saw him, and then he killed her. Because there was an unknown fingerprint on the bottle of alcohol and various places in the house. And a different shoe sizes' footprint. Plus all the evidence was contaminated and the Police did not carry out the investigation properly.
@@efildliw7744 their relatives arrived earlier than the police, they called the police first. And the police only didn't take the evidence properly
@@yuvarajdeka9017 but she already had a bf, someone of her own age, why then get involve with a 45 year old servent
U r right
but the tool use to kill them was used by doctors, her genitals were cleaned but pajama was wet, a mere maid can't remove evidence, a 3rd person would never know exactly that night NUPUR will forget to unlock the door unless maid helped
in first place why will they keep a male maid in their house with a 13 year old? They were working full day and Hemraj and Arushi use to be alone.
Relax yrr chodo ab ye sb court bhi pgla gya ha ye case solve krte krte cbi,police koi nhi kr ska toh hum yaha comment section me ise suljha lenge kya? Ye case aisa hi jitna isme ghuso utna ye ulajhta jata ha mene talvar movie 2019 me dekhi thi aur aaj ye video dekha phir se ye mystery ne mujhe dara diya bechari arushi bechara hemraj kisne mara inhe kon tha vo bhagwan jane ab toh
Why will parents kill their child? If they were aware the body is there they would have tried to hide it somewhere else. It was definitely not parents because they seem to be really unaware. It was the other servants or somebody else.
They are saying that she was mistakenly beaten by the golf stick on the head and again the neck was fully ripped.What should i believe ?
The case is still unsolved because as per one of the theory arushi's father had two more servants other than Hemraj, at that night due to some reason all the three entered in the house as hemraj had an extra key of the house, as they entered the other two saw arushi sleeping their and they tried to manipulate her but she woke up and as they were frightened one of them who was also an assistant of arushi's father in his clinic cut her throat and when hemraj saw them doing so they killed him too
They never entered the flat they have strong alibis
No one made a mistake Everyone does what they really want but they get what nature wants
True
It’s so obvious the parents wanted to frame the murder on Hemraj and never thought his body would be found
Hey there! Very well explained video. But, I would like to tell you there is an angle where, hemraj had couple of friends over for drinks.
Informative
I think Hemraj killed Aarushi,and then her mom dad killed Hemraj , because they saw Hemraj killed their daughter,
Nice theory
@@Thunder001-z6p just think little bit u will found the answer by yourself
@@shavan_senpai Right
Naah...the cuts on their daughters neck was clean like someone professional did it...and her parents are doctors so i think they only killed her
@@fjeidjej dentist* 😂yar
There was no one in the house except Talwars and Hemraj. Obviously, the parents have killed both of them and since they're doctors, they know how to clean the evidence very well. That's why they could never be caught.
Not everyone deserves to be a parent 🙂
Not everyone deserve to be a servant. Servant must live in their limits.
@@prakashverma7053true ....bt jb apna h shi n ho to dusro ko kya blame krna .... parents should also take care that his child is young n alone at home n it's not safe to leave her at home with a servant ...that's why everyone not deserves to be a parent
This shows how useless CBI is😡🤬
There were other people involved in this case there is no doubt in that. I remember this case because I start having a hallucinations about her due to constantly watching her news. People who say that hemraj was having a intimacy with Aarushi why the hell parents choose to kill there daughter like this and then torture the servant and plan everything so much clearly. There is no chance at all that something big happens and they made up this story no doubt in that. My dad always said that the family who gives so much facility to a servant why the hell he would take advantage of owners in this way. There is no sane person who is getting separate room with refrigerator, tv and ac and all the things do such a stupid thing and that too in there own house. They just did it to drive the public attention to this shit so that main culprit can get away easily. Parents eere involved no doubt in that but i think Aarushi witness something she shouldn't have which is why the meet such a end.
And then why was her private organ cleaned,I think her parents forced the actuall killer to rape arushi and kill herself,to seperate themselves form the crime
Heemraaj was killed by arusi parents for having intercourse...... inreturn heemraaj relative/friends killed arusi as a Revenge 👍.....only arusi parents is investigated the other is unknown
Arushi was killed by accident
@@syedmehvish3762 explain?
Due to sudden rage, the father tried to hit hemraj but he moved his head and the golf stick hit Arushis head at left eye. It lead to concussion and she died.After that Hemraj ran towards terrace, Rajesh talwar ran after him and he hit him on stairs.Hemraj was able to walk upto to terrace gate where he actually fainted . His head was bleeding so he put one his hands on his head and whole fainting he put one of his hands on the wall.After that talwar couple dragged him till centre.Then they cut his throat with accurate precession so that they can make a story.They did same with Arushi as she was also dead due to concussion
This all was done in fit of rage not planned .You can get this information from many platforms that Rajesh talwar is very loose tempered
Very well explained