ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 พ.ค. 2024
- Subscribe to Vsauce: bit.ly/POIaN7
Follow Michael Stevens: / tweetsauce
/ vsaucegaming
All music by Jake Chudnow: / jakechudnow
Tommy Edison (Blind guy on TH-cam): bit.ly/rjyX7q
Color Blindness:
www.colourblindawareness.org/c...
and
colorvisiontesting.com/what%20...
Qualia: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qualia
We experiences are subjective: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subjecti...
Explanatory Gap: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Explanat...
Mary's Room and the Knowledge Argument: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Knowledg...
Who Asked the First Question? [PDF]: www.polyphony.ge/uploads/whoas...
Theory of Mind and Sally-Anne Task: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_o...
Koko the talking gorilla [VIDEO]: • Video
Questioning Behaviour: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Question
Synesthesia coupled with color blindness: www.scholarpedia.org/article/S...
Do blind people DREAM images? www2.ucsc.edu/dreams/Library/k... - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
Michael: "We are all alone in our heads"
Me and the 37 different voices in my head: no we're not
You again: Or are We??
*Vsauce music plays*
Me: *Is this a joke or a joke-mixed reference to Dissociative Identity Disorder?*
*Randy Orton's theme plays*
@@jwsnyderaal loll
@@konodioda4370 imao good old days
anyone else think of this concept as a young child, only to now discover they weren't the only person who thought of it?
Yes, yes
ancient school th-cam.com/video/DtmJCS1EsAI/w-d-xo.html
I am too late to answer, but yes I also thaught that too
me too
me too
Only took ELEVEN YEARS for this to show up on my feed.
same lol
My physics teacher taught me about this. Wanted to know more.
Right!?
Same
Reeeeeal
IVE THOUGHT ABOUT THIS FOR YEARS AND ONLY JUST FOUND THIS VIDEO
Same, I think everyone thought of that before
Bruh same
Lmao me too
Yes, I used to question color perception
I also had the same question for a long time, but whenever I tried explaining it to anybody they would think I was crazy😂. I don't know if I couldn't explain myself or maybe they didn't have mind theory😂
Vsauce talks about every single question that I’ve asked that no one could answer
good, same with me.
this is why i love him he answered it all
*This idea is best summarised in the film Good Will Hunting:*
th-cam.com/video/_3PT2LwW-Qg/w-d-xo.html
He answers questions that I didn't even know I was curious of.
What is the meaning of life
Conversations according to Michael:
"This is red"
"I agree"
This is how I talk to my friends.
SEND ME HATE ON MY VIDEOS>>
@@idkanameforthis ok yes but why
@@idkanameforthis I'd much rather send the hate here
@@idkanameforthis why not here
These videos are so truly timeless. I watched this video when it first came out,and even watching it 11 years later it still feels brand new. Michael is a cornerstone of TH-cam history and that will never change
Me too, and I’ve just discovered a comment of mine here from 9 years ago. I didn’t even knew I had been following this channel for so long.
Everyone’s entire perception of reality itself could theoretically be different, and we would never know… 🤯
u are everywhere
he a bot @@IceFrosti
@@mario_nustiuhe is a real person
@@_ZfxTH-cam_ hes not he just copies a top comment
@@_ZfxTH-cam_ having a video like" who is x" i didnt watch it but ik what he will say "i had a minecraft chanel and i delated the content bla bla bla " they just some guys that made bots to comment everywhere on yt and than buy 50k 60k subs or more sometimes than they put a video like" who i am" people click on it after he has the option to make money on the vid
Someone: “that’s red”
Vsauce: o r i s i t . . .
I am micheal
Or am i
the last of its kind No yes
@@gustavolemonke here in Australia we say yeeeaaaaahhhhhh naaahhhhh
@@CalebEade or do u?
The pen is rrrrrrRRROYAL BLUE
I just like the idea that someone out there might see the sky as my red and be like "Yes this is normal"
imagine your red is my blue
@@xcz1gd I was gonna say exactly that 😆 (only with better grammar but that's beside the point)
Imagine eating a purple apple normally
You might see the sky as my red and not think anything of it
But they define your blue as red but you see a whole alien world
11 years now and he is freaking making the exact same freaking nice content with the same "comedy" editing
It's not only crazy that vsauce still pops up on my TH-cam shorts in 8+ years of development in their camera equipment, but also the blind guy he talks about is still constantly riding the wave of the TH-cam algorithm after all this time.
I’m so stupid that when he put red on the screen I thought “oh yeah, that’s the same as my red”
Oof
@@codylord9220 4th
You’re not stupid, you just didn’t let him finish the sentence :)
you stupid idiot, may i ask what your iq is you little maggot
@HACKKER This may be my favorite broken English sentence of all time.
My red is better than yours.
F... off, my red is BLUE!
Fuck off you all. I am daltonic
F all y'all. My black is 24K gold colour 😏👑 🏵🎗🔑🛎⚱📯🔒🔆🔅⚜🔱🔔📢📣
My red fights my blue
Like if you get it
my red is angry
I watched these when they first came out. And I still come back every once in awhile. Vsauce you need to upload more vids!
This is something my friends and I in high school used to talk about in deep conversations,
Seeing you made a whole video about it so awesome
Micheal: is your red the same as my red?
Colorblind people: no.
Nicholas Aw-Yang what’s it like being a colorblind people?
I haven't seen any colour in years 😂😭
I'm not gonna like coz it has 69 likes
@Eddie Alonzo Colourblind people have certain coulers they see different for example red green colourblind they would see white but think red is a shade of green
True
So all this time we are just using a texture
wow
Im using the vanilla texture pack lol
Do you now where I download the outrun/synthwave pack? I'm using the default, very boring......
I’m just using shaders
Zenitzy 😂
This guy always comes up on my recomened with a video on a topic I had shower thoughts about the other day
A person studying atoms is just a bunch of atoms trying to understand themselves.
Robotic_Llama my head hurts
That's enough unprotected mindfucking for me today...
Its so true but I dont want to believe it.
Robotic_Llama we are not atoms
Ifraz Ali bruh.........
Remember when everything was black and white, man those were the days
Man, I remember those days, good old days when sometimes red was actually red and red was red instead of red, but you couldnt tell bc it was all black and white
Or were they?
Mr. Pootis yeah, I remember it like it was about 75 years ago..
Shirley Pugh it was insane back then you just had to take a shitty guess you could have been looking at dog shit and assumed it was purple
@@youknowyourewrongright93 or was it
i love getting vsauce videos once a year in recommendeds
It’s been 10 years and I still think about this every single day. And I have only seen this video one time until TH-cam decided to toss it into my algorithm today.
Anyway thanks Michael
“We are all alone in our minds”
Me: woah thats deep
“Let’s say I met an alien”
fcE300 unless schizophrenic
I just looked at this comment on the exact time he said the same thing
Right when I read this he literally said it
@@boxman6323 same lolol
OR IS IT!?!?!??!?!?!?!!!!@*×@>+*#*$;'
This video finally explained my 7 year old question.
Same...
🤣same
Woah, new people. Hi newer people, reply to me.
@@happynessblaster2365 no
I have many 7 year old questions that...🤨 never mind actually
I always wondered about that glad to see Vsauce talk about it
This had been one of my questions for the longest tome
Traffic Police : Sir u jumped the red light
Vsauce: Or did i? 🤔
Don't change it
It’s perfect
The cop will think he is on shrooms
moon men (vsauce song) song kicks in
Never heard jumped the red. Cool tho
They always ask: Is Your Red The Same as My Red?
But they never ask: How Is Your Red?
sad
Lmao!!
My red is 202020
I am 14 and this is deep
My red is anger and period :3
or do you want better, why is red?
Your content is simply amazing, I love your work and the way you think and communicate. I hope to see lots of other videos like this one.
10 YEARS AGO?? HELLO??
Sup
Hi
Vsauce: But is your red the same as my red?
Colorblind people: *wait, you guys are seeing red?*
BecauseICan the pfp goes so well with this
Wait, you guys are seeing colours?
@@alexmetaxotos1445 i got this red shirt
You got red shirt but i only got white
You got white but i only got back
You guys are getting shirts?
No they would say,what is red
BecauseICan yellow and pink look the same to me lol
“We can all agree that red is warm and blue is cold.” But what if my warm *is* different from your warm?
Ever thought if someone sees in a way and another one sees UPSIDE DOWN? I bet no one thought of that
Yeah I was thinking of this as well. Like we all describe red as warm because we are used to it being the colour of hot things, such as fire. But if fire was blue and ice was red, people would say blue is a hot colour and red is a cold colour.
Blue is warmer than red
Leocatflip 929 it was a quote
Confusion
vsauce i always go back to your videos bc they make me feel nostalgic and because you've always been quite informative. ily sm
This topic has been on my mind for so long
What if we all have the same favorite color and all call it something different
Yes exactly my thoughts
+Bazaar Lizaard But not everyone even has a favorite color.
+Wimbledofy mind...blown
+Common Sense No... no stop right there go no further.
That is perfect
Roses are red
Violets are blue
Or are they..?
Pun intended
@@lukky6648 of course
*music plays
This is a joke *(0R IS IT??)*
Roses are red
Violets are violet for fucks sake
I saw this when it came out and i still think about it to this day,
I can say that about a lot of your videos, I hope you are proud of the great videos you have created throughout the years.
Thank you
It's amazing i'm just discovering this channel when it has had so many of my ridiculous questions of my incredibly creative mind and the most important existential crisis moments since i was 5-10 years old
I’ve always wondered this and I’m very happy to see it put into a Vsause vudeo
Wtf this was literally my shower thought when I was 10
I'm 10 now and I thought of this a week ago is it just a universeal age we think of this
@@fanimations1117 That makes it even crazier
@@pericoblanco5060... I thought of this when i was 10...oml-
My when i am trying to sleep thought
Ahaha me too
I FINALLY FOUND SOME OTHER PEOPLE WHO STAY UP AT NIGHT THINKING ABOUT THIS!
:')
me to it boggles my mind every time i think about it
I always find he makes videos on theories and paradoxes i constantly think of myself
IKR ME 2
same :)
This is something I’ve genuinely thought about for a long time, and I got excited when I saw this in my feed lol
Yes bro
@@yogeshpendharkar23 wut
@@cmilburn26 what you said?
Thank you Michael for kindly sharing me with Tommy Edison, I love him so much and he gives me so much encouragement!
Officer: Sir did you see that red light?
Me: colour is an illusion
Officer: step out of the vehicle with your hands up
Well then think of this as an illusion
Just say "Sorry I think I'm colorblind I'm on my way to the doctor"
I think this has to be the only decent joke in the comments
Not funny but I appreciate it
I’d say the like button is blue but color is an illusion
I hate that I can't know everyone else's experiences and it bothers me to no end.
Me too
It has 69 like's. NICE
my red is yellow
you could look into other peoples eyes
if it helps my purple is quite purple (similar to blue and pink) and my red is very red-like.
This was the exact same thought I've been having for a long time since my childhood only to discover that the question cannot be answered even by vsauce
Been asking this question since I was a kid! I love this in depth video!!!! I always wondered if the colors I saw were the exact as other people.
Video title: Is your red same as mine
Michael: aliens from far away from our solar system do not feel pain
Maitoparta that was an analogy
save_the_turtles_3000 r/whoosh
razeenrajaful damn
Tbf, Pain is an important evolutionary advantage.
Like, extremely important.
It gives feedback on injuries so you don't worsen then
So chances are that aliens will feel it
@@rpc0089 r/woooosh
You can't experience color
LSD: let me introduce myself
😂
@thegrandfinale2 say yes to LSD
@thegrandfinale2 ahhh ignorance at its best, good day sir ;)
@thegrandfinale2 you clearly dont know about LSD if you think it will flush your life down the drain. So yes its ignorance
@thegrandfinale2 enlighten yourself
Don't apologize again for going to the start it's actually brilliant. For me that's been listening this track for years it just feels amazing to start again and again and actually I felt like I want it again! Like you listening twice it would just be the real thing trust me
I thought about it a lotta times and now someone finally made a video about it let's goo
11 years ago
@@user-pc1rh3fe9b and 11 years ago someone finally made a video about it let's go...amen
How to break someone
Ask them to explain a color
+Swift Fonts Explain what green looks like then...
+Swift Fonts If they do it, then do it!
+LetsPlayWouterGames That's what I meant.
+Pillow Friendly or jealousy
+Pillow Friendly Yes, but what does it look like?
Roses are red
Violets are blue
My perception of colors
Has a better hue
"violets are blue" okay buddy I'll try and believe that for now.
@@Dormasheen I mean MY blue
Bruh 👌😩🅱️☠️💯
MINE IS BETTER
Violet is violet
I have always thought of this, and still am. So happy someone else has thought of it
I have thought this for years and never knew how to communicate this concept. Thank you!!
When I was in 5th grade I asked my teacher this same question of is your red the same as mine? And if you throw a ball 100mph, and I drive a motorcycle 100mph right next to it, would I be able to reach out and grab it and not feel any force from the ball? She told me I need to stop wondering about such nonsense. It made me sad and I’ll never forget it.
Your teacher wasn't qualified enough to answer your questions
Your teacher is ignorant
Thanks for the questions! I'm gonna go find answers to them 🧐
So do I
Adam Norvell screw that teacher
who had this thought as a child that you were the only real human and everyone was just robots?
Me
Bruh what
Sysonic that thought alone is terrifying
_what were you on as a kid_
yes!
Bruh lmao I still sometimes think that
I think this might be my favorite vsauce video
Ive been asking myself this exact question my WHOLE life and I clicked so fast when I saw this video!!! Don't know why but this literally keeps me awake at night, as inconsequential as it is. Great video!!!
This man is a professional at making me question my existence.
IKR!!!! I've wondered about that since I understood color. Shoot I've had that question before I could understand color!!!
He’s the CEO of making everyone question their existence 😂
What a Shane Dawson
Vsauce + Psychedelics = Beautiful
And it always happens to me when I should be sleeping, then my mind is racing haha
Micheal: “Is your red the same as my red?”
Colorblind people: -_-
Doge The Salty .
@Noah Smith OH MY GOD IM DYING
Dyslexic people: Micheal
@Noah Smith haha
They already have special glasses that solves most color blindness. I know people who have them and can see colors now :D
I remember seeing this video from the homepage years ago and the nostalgia is real
This has got to be one of the greatest TH-cam videos I’ve ever seen
This man answers literally all of my shower thoughts
Fr bro I thought of the same concept in a shower
bathroom for me when I was like 12
I asked this question in the school to my friend instead of learning 🫠
@Crank Lucas What is Crank Lucas doing in the replies? lol. Respect.
@@kugelstich8632 same
Me trying to sleep:
My brain: iS yOuR rEd My ReD?
Michael: Called Qualia.
i wont like your comment because i dont want ruin 444 likes
😂
me in school:
I will wait a day for this comment to be 665 bc its 661 so I want to be 666th like
this question has always been on my mind, i dont know how i came across this video after 11 years but im happy i did
my god, ive been thinking abt this for forever and the legend made a vid abt it.
10 yrs ago lol
I ALWAYS EXPLAINED THIS THEORY TO MY FRIENDS EVEN BEFORE I WATCHED THIS VIDEO
i did too but they always make fun of me xD
Me too, I didnt thinked so many people do too.
I did, and then my friend was like "Isn't that color blindness?"
I didn't, because I didn't want to be the "weirdo" in our Group
I did and nobody understood
finnally I've been thinking about this for years I thought I was alone
I thought me and my friends were the only ones too:-P But every time I discuss sth like this,I feel like my brain is gonna explode;P
Me too!!! Glad to have someone similar?
+Ben Landeros
No you are not alone i thought about this too sometimes and when i see this video that shares the same idea as my i was so happy that i am not alone
+Ben Landeros SAME!!!!!!!!!!!
+Ben Landeros ikr!
i have thought of this for years, and you confermed it
I have always thought about this and since I started watching I'm happy I saw
Video title: “Is your red the same as my red?”
Vsauce: “apes don’t ask questions.”
We're Vsauce, you're talking about Michael.
@LolHow I was about to say-
I would argue that ANY animal that experiences curiousity is asking questions in its head
ikr
Its not the question about knowing smth. But question about permission.
”We are all alone in our minds” is the most depressing thing to hear when you’re alone in the middle of the night
Its literally 11pm and I'm watching vsauce and questioning my own reality right now
But what you refer to as "alone" is based on previous experiences, and based on the fact you think it is possible not to be "alone" (because if it is possible to be alone, it is also possible to not be alone). If you think it's possible not to be "alone" it means you've experienced not being "alone" before, even though, at that time, you were still "alone in your mind", so it's a contradiction. Most of the times you start feeling this way, or feeling that nothing makes sense, it is a flawed statement, because it contradicts true experiences you had in the past, and I keep seeing people fall in this trap over and over. For example, you may think "everything I have and will ever done is predestined to be this way, because that's how matter works. If I were to create a 100% perfect computer simulation of the Big Bang, everything would repeat itself and the necessary information for the whole universe would already be contained and determined in the Big Bang. Therefore I have no free will, because I am just matter reacting to other matter". The last sentence is a flawed statement. Just because you dwelved deeper into how things work, it doesn't mean you don't have "free will". In the past, you have made choices, by which you defined "free will" to yourself. Now you claim that your own definition of "free will" doesn't exist to you even though you've experienced it and defined it in the past.
I might have ranted for wayy too long but I always wanted to talk about this
@@defabc6676 Wow, go win a science competition or something.I don’t know but you are way smarter than me.
@@defabc6676 🤔
Then the voices in your head remind you that you aren’t alone
this video came on my recommended and now my head hurts.
I remember in 3rd grade I was trying to explain this to my friends and one girl got so offended, thinking I was just roasting her colorful outfit and then the teacher got involved too and thought I was crazy or hi on something... Long story short, I had to explain it to the principal
always had that question as a child, but never told anyone because I thought it was dumb or weird
Lol
Whenever I tried to ask someone they didn't understand what I meant
DUDE FUCKING SAME. I THOUGHT I WAS RETARDED BUT THE MORE I THIUGHT OF IT THE MORE IT MADE SENSE IN MY HEAD
Me 2
sammeeeeee
Vsauce: talks about my red and his red
Me: loses my focus
Vsauce: starts talking about aliens
Me: wait what just happens
Vsauce in a nutshell
Legit just happened to me while reading this comment and I have no idea what’s happening.
@@dtcdragon7164 i also lost my focus when i was reading the comments
@@livespeedyz3608 goddammit as did I while reading this
@@seemann2401 oh god it’s contagious that just happened to me I- 🤣
It's more than Highly Probable that Chocolate tastes either the same or damn-near the same to all humans who eat it. I think colour is the same. Everyone sees either the exact same red, or a damn-close shade of the same red we all see.
True, but we don’t know
I think that everyone sees color somewhat the same because If people did have different perceptions of colors then colors that contrast would be different to each person. So things like the videos that use black and white contrast to trick your vision wouldn’t work on some people because in the case that we don’t see all colors the same, someone would get two colors that don’t contrast and therefore the visual effect wouldn’t work.
It's a good point. But I think it is possible we see different colors anyway, keeping the same contrast between what I call red and green and what you call red and green. Take the negatives for example, red's negative is light blue, and green's negative is purple. The contrast between red and green could be the same as light blue and purple and it wouldn't make too much of a difference. Maybe it's not always the negative but the color spectrum could be a bit shifted, and contrast would allow to distinguish as different colors anyway
no you didn't get the brain's color interpretation point. let's say there is a strawberry which is red to you and a leaf which is green. in a b&w tv you will see them same contrast if their color value are same. you can not recognise the difference. and other person who sees red as your green also will see it like that. in a colored screen every pixel has a value of red, green and blue in the range of 0 to 255. for a strawberry it is 255 for red value and zero for others. for a leaf it is 255 for green and 0 for others. in a b&w screen the values will be same for strawberry and leaf so you can not distinguish them. to recognise the difference leaf or strawberry must have a different value. e.g. 200 for red and 255 for leaf and so in a b&w screen you will see a contrast difference.
I've thought of this so many times, but never spoke about it out loud
S A M E
+Blaire Russ I have told people about this idea before.
Me too
same
Same
Man you don’t even know how many times I’ve layed in bed at night thinking about this
Same
Same
Same
Same
Same
Someone told me about this when I was younger and I’ve literally never stopped thinking about it.
My brain has been melting since the first time i saw this video 10+ years ago. Im still trying to figue out how to come up with a plan for this problem😂
What if every human has a completely differnt color scheme that we can’t even imagine
That's the whole point of the video
@@homedepotgaming774 what if yours unique and your friends also unique?
@@johnbyrne7247 you dont understand...
Did you watch the video. That’s what this is about.
@@leonhardolaye-felix8811 and your point?
This video is one of these "I swear I thought of this before" ones.
Yeah bruhh
SEND ME HATE ON MY VIDEOS>>
@@idkanameforthis Shut the fuck up. Go get a life.
My red is a nice red
except i know i thought of it before because i talked about it to my brother yesterday.
It’s like having adhd and having been told what a “normal” brain is supposed to be like, but never knowing what it’s like
10 years later and I think about this video at least twice a week
What if we all have the same favourite colour we just don't know it???
mabey, becaus in that case everybody loves yellow!! jk :)
MBG Gaming in my opinion yellow is the most plain colour ever
too much yellow makes my eyes hurt
GoldenMiru I'd say not, because of how some colors like blue can calm us down, and red makes us more agressive. Surely it's unique to the colour and not the perception...
False. I do not have a favourite colour, thus disproving your hypothesis.
You know, when I'm 10 years old, I asked my teacher this question once, she said "don't ask something unnecessary".
Hi Indonesian
it is more necessary than the most things they teach us at school
BRUH
All science was kinda "unnecessary" at one point. Your science teacher sucked
That teacher is being dumb because you shouldn’t deny children education!!!!
“No ape has ever asked a question” struck a weird part of my brain
I have been talking about this concept for over 20 years! It always confused people and no one could get on board! I love this ❤❤❤
what if everyone favorite color is the same color, like one person is blue, and someone els is green, but its the same in our heads, i dont know how to explain this lol.
EXACTLY what I've been thinking for years
EXACTLY what I've been thinking for years
EXACTLY what I've been thinking for years
Lol i get what you mean. That's a good question 0_0
I get what you mean bro
Plot twist: People with colorblind actually see a true colors.
But what does 'true colors' even mean?
Amazing point
John Ruben Saragi IM TELLING YOU ALL OF THIS IS THE FBI
Speech 100
@@johnrubensaragi4125 idk mate but theyre shining through
Honestly I thought I was the only one with this thought stuck in my brain, glad to see I’m not crazy
My favorite part of this theory is that we all could potentially have the same favorite color and not even know it
I have always imagined and thought about what if everyone's colors are different. There is no way to describe a color
IF we can identify the same colour as "Blue" Then why is it such a long stretch to assume we all perceive it the same way? its not like we're a different species.
@@Vishnu_Karthik yeah but why is it a stretch that we don't perceive them the same way?
@@_cj_evans You don't answer a question by asking a question.
விஷ்ணு கார்த்திக் Is that a question?
@@Vishnu_Karthik yeah but that's not how evolution works
Vsauce has always had such good camera quality even back 10+ years ago
yeah. 🫵🏽😂
That’s because it’s not a camera. He’s actually coming through your phone screen
@@grixxly2768 oh shit🤯
That's because he has the backing of the ONE WORLD GOVERNMENT to poison our minds!
Wake up, sheeple!
This was 10+ years ago!?!
I honestly didn't know this video existed I was thinking this for the past 3 years and I thought it made sense it would be the same because of the color spectrum blending so smoothly together, like red and orange and yellow and so on, like how it would make sense if they blended instead of someone's orange looking like someone else's green or someone else's blue, it wouldn't blend as well as the others
Vsauce: I cannot climb into your consciousness
Also Vsauce: *Or can I?*
*vsauce* *music* *starts*
*cums*
@@bugfairy uhhh...ok.?..
kikkinn wha?
lmao idk