CAT vs. SOF-T Wide: Which Tourniquet is Better?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 พ.ค. 2020
- Which is better and which one should you buy? Here is a look at some of the pros and cons of the two most popular Tourniquets on the market: The CAT (Combat Application Tourniquet) Distributed by NAR (North American Rescue,) and the SOF-T Wide produced and distributed by Tactical Medical Solutions.
Please let me know which of these is your preferred tourniquet, and why, down in the comments below. You might help someone make a decision on which is best for them.
We sell emergency trauma medical kits!
Our Best seller:
The Yellowstone
www.mountainmanmedical.com/pr...
CAT Tourniquet
www.mountainmanmedical.com/pr...
SOF-T Wide Tourniquet
www.mountainmanmedical.com/pr...
![[Full Episode] MasterChef Junior Thailand มาสเตอร์เชฟ จูเนียร์ ประเทศไทย Season 3 Episode 4](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/e7Oqqo90x_w/mqdefault.jpg)
Any tourniquet that stops the bright red spurting blood is the right tourniquet.
"Doc" McLaughlin -- hoping this'll get to you as I've gathered from your comments you were a corpsman with the FMF and/or attached to a Marine company as their "doc".
Long after I left Uncle Sam's Canoe Club, I changed careers to being an RN. Cut my teetch at VA Reno. Many of my patients were former Marines. When I'd walk into a Marine's room, he'd see my gray hair and immediately address me as "Doc". Embarrassed I'd correct him saying that I was his nurse for the shift. I'd be even more embarrassed and would feel deeply honored when he'd correct me back with "No, you're MY doc!"
Welcome home and Bravo Zulu for taking care of our brother vets out in the bush.
I love CAT for arms but like the SofT for legs because of the clip where you can quickly open it, throw it around a leg then reattach the clip
Your channel is so underrated, you should have millions of viewers and followers! Thank you for what you do, and keep up the good work 👏
Thanks! I appreciate the feedback!
I have and use them both. CAT 7 is much faster to self apply. I like the SOF T Wide a lot. I carry both of them.
Great review, Brian! Honest, unbiased, informative. And some badass gear you've assembled there; love the "background". And, as always, thank you for your Service, then and now! HOOYAH!
Thanks Sergeant Raven! I appreciate the compliment.
Another trick for the SOFT-T WIDE for self application, if you can, lean against a wall and trap the tourniquet between your arm and the wall so that you can pull it tight.
Good demonstrations here.
Id say the CAT definitely has an advantage in one handed self application. Almost a deal breaker for me.
But sof got an advantage with applications on leg, i got 2 cats for arms, and 2 sofs for legs
@@user-pk8gm8xv7b That’s a good idea. If you practice you’d be able to use two different tourniquets under pressure.
I’m new to all of this. Thanks for the video.
Thank you for your post sir and explaining the differences between both tourniquets! Now I’m better informed!
You're welcome
Very informative videos! Thanks for putting these together and sharing.
Glad it was helpful!
Sweet. This was very helpful
Super informative. Thank you
I was taught (gen 6 CAT) single buckle for self aid and double buckle for buddy aid. Then a big study came out that single use all the time was the way the best way to use it.
What are the dimensions of the sof t flat folded?
Great tip re: the duct tape.
The Cat I’ve used countless times and honestly is my choice personally.
Great video!
Thanks GB!
I need to get a couple of sof-t
Check out our mods to level those bad boys up.
I like the duct tape idea, thanks
Check us out for some SOFT Wide mods. In our opinion, they make the SOFT Wide the superior tourniquet. Great video!
I also like that blade (your right-rear) - Where can I get one?
The blade by itself is an EJ Snyder SXB from Tops Knives. The two blades together right behind my head are Kukri I got from from Afghanistan.
Uh! You don't have to thread the strap if you prep it properly in your IFAC. It can boil down to training if they support the need for an effective tourniquet.
What is the better TQ for use on children?
Current philosophy on children and TQs is that the CAT and SOF-T have been shown to work on children. It was previously thought it would be ineffective due to the smaller limbs of kids.
But now it's been shown that both are effective due to the low blood pressure in children making it easier to occlude their little arteries.
This ease of occlusion means an adult can quickly shut off bleeding in a child with only good direct pressure.
Whenever you don't have a TQ available, direct pressure will add a lot of benefit.
@@MountainManMedicalthat’s good information to have, I want to start taking some classes and have at least a small med kit with me in vehicles for emergencies. There are stop the bleed classes not far from where I live I plan to start there
I got three black CAT tourniquets, my question is... How many times can I use the same tourniquet?
They are designed for one time use only. Continually using the same TQ will weaken the material and increase it's chances of failure.
That's why its a good idea to have a training TQ and one for actual bleeding.
After seeing you demonstrate the one handed application of each and taking into account the price of each, why would I possibly choose the Soft T over the CAT???? No brainer in my mind!!
Yep, definitely a good choice for self-application.
Check us out.
" prestine as possible " every guy i work with has a raggedy looking CAT TQ 😂😂😂 carrying it on duty wares them out FAST really I would advise if you carry in on a duty belt or vest replacing it yearly at moat if not 6 to 8 months
YOU SEE THAT WITH THE STRAP TOWARDS THE CHEST IT IS MUCH EASIER.🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄
CAT all day long
You applied the SOFT-Wide incorrectly. No disrespect. The strap should be able to be tightened via stretching flat across the chest. Just flip it around opposite way u had it. Active duty operator prefer the SOFT-Wide because it won’t get sand caught in the Velcro. Also be sure your SOFT has a lot number starting with 11 or 12 and ending in 19 or higher. They had a problem with the retention clips breaking (mine broke in training). Placing your tourniquet in a Molle pouch should be deployable and not hindered by rubber bands. See u on the battlefield. 😊👍
Thanks for the comment Bill. No disrespect, but I disagree. I'm not sure what you mean about the application of the SOF-T, but I've spent a decent amount of time in sandy environments and never had a problem with the hook and loop of a CAT becoming clogged with sand.
I won't pretend to be an operator, but I've worked closely with many from the community, from SEALS, USMC Recon, Rangers, Special Forces and Delta and never once has any of them mentioned to me that particular issue.
I also disagree with leaving the SOF-T loose in your pouch. Personally I'd rather take an additional 3 seconds to remove the bands then to pull out a tangled mess from my IFAK. You could get around the whole issue altogether by keeping the TQ in a pouch by itself I suppose.
All that said, I still prefer the SOF-T if I'm treating someone else, and the CAT, if I'm staging the TQ for self application.
😂😂😂😂SEAL AND DOES NOT KNOW HOW TO APPLY A TOURNIQUET ALONE. THEN THEY DID IT AGAIN TO CORRECT THE MISTAKE. THEY ARE THOSE WHO GIVE THEIR ARM TO TWIST.😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂SEAL AND DOES NOT KNOW HOW TO APPLY A TOURNIQUET ALONE. THEN THEY DID IT AGAIN TO CORRECT THE MISTAKE. THEY ARE THOSE WHO GIVE THEIR ARM TO TWIST.