ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ต.ค. 2024
- In a landmark verdict on the power tussle between the Delhi government and the Centre, a five-judge bench of the Supreme Court today unanimously held that Lieutenant Governor Anil Baijal does not have independent decision making powers, and is bound to act on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers. The judgement pronounced in the court by Chief Justice Dipak Misra, who was heading the Constitution bench, also held that the LG cannot act as an "obstructionist". In three separate but concurring judgements, the bench, also comprising Justices A K Sikri, A M Khanwilkar, D Y Chandrachud and Ashok Bhushan, said there is no independent authority vested with the LG to take independent decisions. It said all decisions of the Council of Ministers, who are elected representatives of the people of Delhi, must be communicated to the LG but that does not mean his concurrence is required. On this edition of ‘The Big Picture’ we analyse the Apex Court’s judgment on the power tussle in Delhi and its implications.
Guests - B.P. Singh, Former Governor & Home Secretary,
P.K. Malhotra, Former Secretary, Ministry of Law and Justice, GoI,
Justice Jaspal Singh, Former Judge, Delhi High Court,
Shekhar Iyer, Senior Journalist,
Anchor - Frank Rausan Pereira
It is a victory for everybody... Like a upsc aspirant answer..
There should be clearcut distribution of power. So that everyone can Focus on their respective public work and constitutioal responsibilities.
My personal views is that a democratically elected government is supreme in a democratic system of government.
sukhdev chopra Absolutely....as simple as that ...
You are right. But In case of delhi when it's capital of india Central Govt. doesn't want to leave it to someone else.. Even when Congress was in center and Delhi, they tried for it but they found that it might be risky to give delhi a full statehood and makes it out of the power of Central Govt. But Supreme Court made a Great Decision. But these issues will remain both Delhi Govt. and Governer should focus on their work.
Leave aside LG and CM of Delhi..I think there is some tussle going on between HC judge and SC.
Ankush Jindal i think there is no tussle between hc & sc brother it is the beauty of democracy & our judicial system everyone one has different thoughts on the same issue with the same constitution interpretation of judges of different courts are different...& Here again SC judges proved that why it is supreme...
Brother actually LG decides the Judges of High Court and i think it's common what was the judgement of Delhi High Court. High Court might be wrong but that's why they made Supreme Court.
Pratul Gupta every high court judge appointed by President after consultation with CJI & governor of concern state..but the recommendation made by collegium is imp in that case..
This Supreme Court judgement is a tight slap to BJP & LG.
Also, those High Court judges whose judgement was overturned by SC must be investigated whether they are competent to do their work.
There should be a mechanism wherein if a judge who continuously gives illogical & flawed judgement, is dismissed alongwith other punishments.
Thank u soo much -from upsc aspirant community
All problems actually started with the decision to transfer the services department from the CM to LG in 2015....because of which all IAS officers now has stopped listening to elected government. This is directly affected the governance...All the other discussion is bogus.. as the Delhi government has never interfered in the 3 depts being referred, that was never a problem area.
Thanks to rstv,all the guest done their job properly and clear many more things.As a first speaker Say's the SC given the very clear decisions on the petition filed by AAP govt...Others issues like complete statehood NUT of Delhi are remain on their position as it was previous.
I agree with Justice Singh. Vague terms will only perpetuate the issues.
as malhotra sir said new delhi area for the Central govt and rest for the State govt is the way forward..Ty RSTV
the question of statehood of Delhi remain un discussed or not fully discussed. A separate debate is needed on this,, as only the concept of separation of power won't work in Delhi. And the demands of complete statehood by Delhites is not completely in excess to the administration !!
RAJ 'KABIRA' that Washington model is something to look at as suggested by former secretary to law Ministry.
am agree with u
Frank -host of big picture is best for it as he listens very patiently to every view ..
U must increase time duration plz rajya sabh tv
Victory of Truth
first time all panels made so much sense:P great going BIG PICTURE hands down!
Very informative and insightful debate.
P. C Malhotra supper sir,,, thanks for lot of information put in to our perspective
shreeyaja shree p.k.malhotra
U totally transformed yourself...omg 🤔
Pk malhotra rocks
Shekher Iyer sounds Politically motivated, blaming everything on AK.
I think the first thing is if I agree with the terms of judgment passed by SC, the only way I would do if SC clarifies the vague terms like mechanical manner, every and any etc.
Secondly a bicameral supremacy causes conflicts which are clear here. The concept of Washington DC is acceptable only in terms of compromise for the sake of development by the politicians.
shekhar Iyer is journalist but he is not seeing what Delhi gov is doing in field of Education,Healthcare.He is not talking on why LG refused permission to many good policy of Delhi gov. and also restricted other 4 CM from meeting Delhi CM? Journalist should be rational , should tell factual reality on ground.
Political bias is the reason
BJP/LG/AAP should function in letter and spirit of Spirit of Supreme Court judgement for the benefit of people of Delhi??
there should be clear cut demarcation of power between between all the constitutional post in the country and no other party can blame to each other in between the area of work
sir pls conduct a discussion on the reasons why India is lagging behind in football, a game which is being played by 191 countries across the world as their no 1 game , what are the reasons in the population of 130 cr we r not able to find out 15 players those who can mark at intl level, it is a matter which should discussed delicately and this is the ideal time to discuss it ,
I read yesterday that apart from those 3subjects even services are under central govt since 2015- that's creating even more problems for delhi govt,I mean how can a govt function when no one wants to work and the only agenda of lg is to create hurdles
Present structure is efficient enough to govern the delhi. Govt can increase the size of Nct
victory of right
Kindly cover up the illegal land encroachment in the border area of India by Myanmar Army about 3km toward India territory in Manipur State ... Govt is silence in such sensitive issue. Plz expose their inability to secure border area. In J& K where the army fire much bullet whereas in Manipur single words is not arise against the Myanmar govt. Plz look the issue seriously
Isaac Ali what do you really want to say .... Still your mind is not pure to be Manipur . If you are living in Manipur act as Manipur .... What's important you for saying border issue ... What's going in your mindset of Muslim people living in Manipur... Worthless fellow
Isaac Ali that's why you much know your history despite point out to other community ... You much to love your motherland first
Isaac Ali dear frn plz look up the first comment
Shit you listen to the judge at 1.5x and then at Normal speed it's like being high!!
JAI HIND SIR
it is all about prestige and nothing else as any governor or LG can refer any matter reserved for the president but in case of delhi what LG is doing is something else he is not doing anything and don't want others to do it.
My dear brother Frank,why not u try UPSC...
Because of age limit
Is rstv = upsc
anshu kumar ,but now he is working as a President role, I want to see as A Prime Minister role...bossu
Ask this journalist, why MHA has taken services from the state
EitHeR aboliSH the assemBlY of delhi and take it exclusively under jurisdictioN of centre or make it completely state
DEEPAK RAGHAV I think this is a great decision but all parties wouldn't agree with that and it will become an big issue.
Brother we cant give delhi a complete state because Delhi is the capital of country. If it become state land comes under state and if center want to open some international institutions they need to get permission from state. State may deny this. so one of the reason
I want presidential form of government in our country
Why there is a need of 2 governments?
Justice sahab ki baat bhi suno koi...
and everybodu should take charge to serve better Thier country best
Look all these jokers other than Mr. Singh going round and round bringing their biases
An extra burden switched to state govt. finally, NO DHARNA only WORK .... good luck AAP
Malhotra Sir 😊
sir, kya ya debate hindi mai ho sakti hai
watch desh deshantar or you can enable hindi captions in settings.
Anybody who feels PK malhotra sir will look like indira gandhi if set his hair like her ? not intended to hurt anybody feeling though.
ye AAP hai jo bjp congress ka jawab hai 2019 main...