ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 ก.ย. 2018
- According to the National Judicial Data Grid, as on Monday, September 17 evening around 23 lakh cases, which are over a decade old, are pending in various subordinate courts of the country. These cases constitute 8.29 per cent of the total nearly 2.50 crore cases pending in the lower courts. Of these, nearly 6 lakh cases are civil in nature and nearly 17 lakh are criminal in nature. Civil cases usually involve private disputes between persons or organisations. Criminal cases involve an action that is considered to be harmful to society as a whole. The National Judicial Data Grid is a part of the on-going e-Courts Integrated Mission Mode Project. The NJDG works as a monitoring tool to identify manage and reduce pendency of cases. The e-Committee of the Supreme Court had launched the National Judicial Data Grid to provide data on cases pending in the district courts across the country. On this edition of ‘The Big Picture’ we analyse the burden of pending cases and what could be the possible solutions.
Anchor: Frank Rausan Pereira
Guest:
1- J Sai Deepak, Advocate, Supreme Court
2- Ashok Bagariya, Legal Editor, Hindustan Times
3-Justice P.S. Narayana , Former, Judge, High Court of Andhra Pradesh
4-M P Singh, Former Chairperson, Delhi Judicial Academy
After listening to the Respected judge...I fully understand why cases are pending!!!! Very UNFORTUNATE
Deepak Kumar that's True
Well said brother.
just about to type the same ... lol
Contempt of court.
LOL
I came to write the same,
See frank's face when justice narayana is speaking ...cant stop commenting on that😁😁😁
😂😂😂😂
He won't be inviting him anymore
Same here shubham..... hhaaaahhhhaaa
Aptly put forward by you...Frank ..terribly looking..!
thank god... x1.5 speed there......@P.S. Narayana
I go at 2x when the honorable judge speaks
SAme
Surbhi wt do u do...??
It's fun to have former judge Narayana and sai Deepak on the show 😂😂😂😂" the contrast ".
Way forward
1. Judicial strength: Vacancy, Strength, Ad-hoc, Salary.
2. Court hours at least 8 hours a day( Gujarat Model), More law researcher to supplement judges.
3. Frequent Adjournment practice should be checked.
4. Cost of litigation should be high( I believe it's morally and constitutionally wrong argument).
5. Government should lessen litigation, Economic Survey suggests, restrained litigation for tax officials as success rate just 29%.
6. Scientific court management, judges should delegate administrative jobs to court managers.
7. Seating in holidays too.
8. Improve quality of judges, as efficient judges lead to faster resolution of cases.
9. Law colleges should be more focused towards producing judges than lawyers (long term solution).
Such a nice advice
Thanks bro so summarising this whole debate. 👌
nishant raj.. Looks like your preparation is on the right track for upsc..
thanks for summarizing. But 3 year down the line nothing has changed
"I've got only one minute left on the programme, very quick comment justice Narayana, whats the way forward?"
"(Silent for two minutes) "
Even ×1.5 feels slow...
Now I understand why SC lifted the ban on saridon.
Lol😂😂
FIRST TIME IN THE HISTORY OF BIG PICTURE-
The reason of the Debate itself has invited to discuss the REASON😁😀😁😀😁😀😁😀😀😁😀😀😁😀😀😁
So true!!! 😁😁😁I think he was sleeping while speaking 😂😂😂
😀😀😂😀😁
Hahaha
kept myself awake while listening to the judge. an achievement.
Liked just by seeing J sai deepak's presence.
With due respect . The former judge takes more time than late atalji and Salman khan combined .😂😂😂😂
lol was thinking the same
Need to have a dj disc to control speed when judge and sai was speaking
one can imagine what Mr.frank must b thinking during deep thoughts of hon.justice! Anyway Good debate!
Justice first round gets over at 8:06
justice p.s narayan thinking about his pending case hahah while aswering the question .. thank god he is former judge if he is not retire definitely thousand case pending in his court
ashish beri hahahahah 🤪
hahahhahahha
Right... I was thinking that only...
Yeahh I was thinking the same ..hahahhaa this guy made me speed the video
with due respect,justice narayana was too slow articulating his thoughts.Perhaps that is the reason Frank chose to close the show by the remarks of J sai deepak.
Completely agree with Sai deepak that cost of litigation should not be increased.Infact people choose not to go court for the very reason of its cost and the cumbersome lengthy process.
nice topic.tnx rs tv
Speed of (or lack of) speech of the former Judge of AP and his long...pauses; provides a rare glimpse of the long delays and large number of adjournments in Judicial system.
Oh god what a great patience has been awarded to the panelists and frank......
Sai Deepak👍.Special courts can be established for pending cases.Trivial cases has to be transferred to subordinate courts.Leadership qualities have to be groomed in law graduates.
What Justice Narayana put in:
1. Conflicts between different wings of Judiciary causing pendency, coordinated efforts required from all the three wings in a synchronized manner
2. Delayed appointments
3. Retirement age of judges should be increase or provision of retirement should be removed completely
4. Both sides are responsible, i.e., the Judges and the advocates.
It's miserable to listen him. Hats off to other panelists and anchor for their patience . Collegium system advantage's.
Yeah due to collegium
waah .. frank ..solute to ur courage for giving another chance ...and i can understand SAI DEEPAK feelings..
Seeing narayana we could easily understand why there is a huge pendency of cases in courts.. Lol
*Narayana's wife*: Can you bring a glass of water for me.
*Speed Narayana*: Yesssssss..............
(2 hours later)
Defenetely
........
I will
(3hours later)
Bring
Some
Water......
(5 hours later)
Just
wait
for
a
minute.
😂😂😂😂
4
Amazing ...god bless you creative ..!
Justice Narayan sir articulated good points
He could have done it with 5 minutes
I think he may be suffering difficulty in speech
Mr.sai Deepak should be brought more often , his approach is very pragmatic
The burden on the exchequer can be avoided by increasing the fees that the courts charges especially corporate cases and cases of various profound institutions. These clients pay hefty amount to the advocates then why not they be charged by the courts and let this money be used to meet the further requirements of judiciary.
Justice took half the show time
Frank sir! Patient are you in your moderating skills!! It was a pleasure to listen to J.Sai Deepak sir...thank you
just imagine that judge in a arnab goswami debate :D
Hahah hahaha. Arnab Goswami would have committed Suicide live on TV
Expression of Frank when Justice was talking 😂😂😂😅😅😅😅
Uncleeeeee...fast pls
With all due respect, Justice Narayana is the reason why TH-cam has provided the 1.5x speed.
I was smiling throughout the show...😁 When Mr Frank told Respected Judge to be brief I enjoyed his reaction @ 17:45 ...I wish I had grandfather like this or even a neighbour... amazing relatively...
Thanks Frank for the show once again.... Helpful in understanding the nitty-gritty of the judicial pendency... Good discussion...except former judge's slow response..😊
Former judge is saying to increase the retiring age of judges...it's ironic situation after listening to justice and dn jai said Deepak... definitely we want lawyers like him type to be the future judges...
J sai deepak gives very precise and to the point answers, I really liked this.
Thanks Deepak you were directly to the point
Thanks Rajya Sabha TV specially Frank Rasan Preira, for the Big Picture programme
J sai that is the question everybody wants to hear ....cheif justice of India... A place where you belong
Frank sir thank you
Thank you so much Frank Great
please rise it's
According to the National Judicial Data Grid, as on Monday, September 17 evening around 23 lakh cases, which are over a decade old, are pending in various subordinate courts of the country. These cases constitute 8.29 per cent of the total nearly 2.50 crore cases pending in the lower courts. Of these, nearly 6 lakh cases are civil in nature and nearly 17 lakh are criminal in nature. Civil cases usually involve private disputes between persons or organisations. Criminal cases involve an action that is considered to be harmful to society as a whole.
thanks.................
Thanq Mr Frank Periera for yr enamoured smile while welcoming the viewers of RSTV. Also thanq for highlighting the most important nagging issues of judiciary. Because the judges are reluctant to give up their pivileges n perquites...
Justice Narayana, damn fit for reappointment..
Respected Justice Narayana by the way his explanation everyone understands why many are pending in courts.
Frank was very happy closing the show.😂
man plz extend timing of big picture @rstv
Couldn't stop smiling at 17:50 when Honourable panelist has made me recall a scene from TWM Returns. (Without any offense to anyone).
This is a good question
you are a good question
your question hurts me.
I wonder what Frank is thinking when justice Narayana is speaking. Love to see reaction on Frank's face
8.20 j sai deepak's reaction was so epic...... It was as if he was sitting in a very boring teacher's lecture and suddenly Frank woke him up.
Accepting the problem and giving solutions, when are they implemented? How long people should face this problem? waiting 20 yrs for justice. Shame.
Watching at 1.5x speed and still waiting for judge naryana to speak his next word , and Sai Deepak as usual no nonsense and on point statements. 👌👌
At the end of the day, You are a gem;FRP!!!!🙂
Narayan 😂😂😂😂😂😂 make my day👍
J Sai Deepak at his best...........
Well, that was an interesting discussion! 😁
Expression on the face of Frank on listening to the H'ble Judge... hahahahaha
5:50 Time to take a nap.
Omg! That look on Frank's face! 😂😂
Thanks rstv, 20/09 /2018
All wings are responsible equally
Way forward is
Reducing the holidays in courts
Appointment on regular basis
Creation of all India judicial service
New courts to be created like lok adalat gram nayayala e courts & mobile court
Discussions could be increased to 1 hour to get more into topics
Seems like justice Narayan is also responsible for pendency of many cases.
It is high time for all India judicial services
Justice p s narayanan should have been given full space to speak alone.
With all due respects, Expression on other panelists faces when Justice Narayana is speaking cant be missed :) Even the anchor looks pissed off !!!
In addition, is he here to discuss this very critical topic or advocate is own employment beyond retirement age?
Video is longer than usual thenks to PS Narayana...
Speed of speaking of justice itself explain why there is pendancy
20:43 just see the smile of J sai deepak, he almost fall asleep during this discussion 😂
Can jury system help in solving pendency? Not for sensitive national or religious cases but atleast in district level cases
there is a need to solve the pending cases quickly but it must be also taken care that justice is not ignored . I think jury system have a lot of problems because of that this system was removed.
@@abhilashjena4718 yeah there are problems in jury ,but that still exists in uk usa ,why don't we take clue from them?
Although Justice Narayana Sir is not able to match up your speed Frank Sir, please do invite him often for genuine perspectives !
"With my experience" "with my experience"...we all respect ur experience sir. But please share some of ur experiences with lame people like us.
Such a civilised debate....NDTV, CNN IBN,times now pls see this and learn
Which kind of guest do you invite which hasn't skill of communication,plz invite guest who have knowledge of subject and good communication skill and also change the guest
this reminds me of flash from zootopia
flash o flash
100 yard dash.
Might be this is the first time ever that frank allowing a opening statement more than 6 minutes from a perosn.....ie justice naryana.
Hon'ble Justice looks really confident. But Frank is impatient enough to wait him
With this Condition of pending of cases the effective democracy becomes very weak as it is being the guardian of constitution as well as can give justice to citizens.
Frank reaction in first 6 minute was price less
Why pending?
At least 5 crore cases are filed every year and judges dispose of only 2 crore
Current Judge to population ratio is 10 to 1 million but the Law commission report in 1987 recommends atleast 50 to 1 million
The government is the largest litigant in India, responsible for nearly half the pending cases
Low judicial quality in lower courts
ARCHAIC LAWS OR VAGUE DRAFTING OF LAWS
budgetary allocations for the whole judiciary are a pathetic .1% to .4% of the whole budget and moreover modernization and computerisation have not reached all courts
Colonial legacies like paid long vacations
SOLUTIONS
DOBLE THE NUMBER OF JUDGES AND CREATE ALL INDIA JUDICIAL SERVICE
MORE COURTS_ FTCs,lok Adalats, and Gram nyalayas
JUSTICE DELAYED IS JUSTICE DENIED AND JUSTICE HURRIED IS JUSTICE BURIED
Excellent points
@@deepanshugupta9144 thank u
At 10:43 j Sai Deepak says atleast get two ??? Plzzz anyone help me out abt what he is saying I can't understand perfectly
Justice Narayan...🤣🤣🤣🤘
@rstv
Please edit the name ... Its case in place of cass
Frank is bored as hell having to listen to the Honourable Justice
The Hon'ble justice (retd) took about 19 sec to be precise to decide on the nature of the question! And that gives an insight into how long it would take for a good judge like him to dispose a case altogether ! Anyway...lot of perspectives bundled together !
J Sai looks quite a bit like Darryl from The Office
Frank says "Justice Narayana... Quickly final comments..." I laughed out on how strange the judge's name and the word 'quickly' sound in one sentence. With his speed its understandable how he spent a whole day with one hearing. God bless him... Keep him "hail and hearty"! 🙏
Look lik the debate is more going towards the blame game rather them finding a solution.... look at one's glimpsing faces... when other one is countering.....
any way overall fine debate......
PS narayana sir was experience is good about pending cases..
Sir , even 1.5x not working in case of justice.
All respect for our judge but before him j Sai Deepak is like Eminem...
Just court me ye baitha hoga ,saala judgment bolne me hi ek saal laga diya hoga...
Justice Narayana😂😂
I am appalled at Ashok Bagaria's view to increase the cost of litigation ! He is advocating bringing down pendency of cases by denying millions of poor access to ustice by raising cost of litigation.
We must encourage time bound institutional as well as freelance mediation by specifically licensed and practicing advocates as an alternative to institutional litigation. If the matter is mediated within 6 months there should be no cost to the parties. Beyond 6 months each party must be penalised RS 5000 per sitting.
The licensed mediators should be felicitated by the Govt for good performance and punctuality of completion of matters and will recieve remuneration from the Govt.
For civil matters, we must be open to commercial mediation.
WATCH IN 2X
Very Fast Reply from Judge. That why These much cases are pending. No Surprise.
Guys speed up first 6 mins at 1.5x
narayanji aap thoda faster hona chahiye pls
RSTV must have some research done before inviting someone on its platform. though I am sure it must be going there, yet more attention is warranted. I m sorry but the honourable judge was disgusting.
Justice p s narayana speak fastly to understand everyone