ไม่สามารถเล่นวิดีโอนี้
ขออภัยในความไม่สะดวก
Which Sci-Fi Faction has the BEST AI? | Halo, Star Wars, Mass Effect, the Culture
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 ส.ค. 2024
- We examine the Artificial Intelligence (AI) of the Halo, Star Wars, Mass Effect and the Culture Universes on today's episode of Sci-Fi factions compared!
We're going to look at, specifically, the Droids of Star Wars Legends Lore, the Forerunner AI (or ancilla) of Halo Lore, the Reapers of Mass Effect, and the Minds of the Culture.
***
Background ships via FractalSponge: fractalsponge.net
Outro by Rabbitisparadise: freightmytrain
***
Check out my second channel: / eckstoo
Limited edition merch: www.teespring.com/eckhartsladder
Follow me on Twitch: / eckhartsladder
Want to help the channel out?
Subscribe: goo.gl/vBao71
Join the (superfun!) Discord: discord.io/eckhartsladder
And follow me on Twitter: / eckhartsladder
Why does C3PO have nipples?
what? haha
Same reason as Bat Nipples
Justice Clum wooing females?
to attract m8s
asking the hard questions
I just wanna drop this quote from the IsoDidact about the only Precursor AI we have seen in the Halo universe. This AI was named Abaddon.
"He now realized that it was a Precursor's version of an ancilla-one as far beyond those of the Forerunners as a keyship was to a wooden raft."
- IsoDidact on Abaddon
If they every decide to write about the precursors the way that greg bear wrote the forerunner sage then Halo most likely moves up beyond the rankings of the Culture.
Halo is already beyond the culture. It simply involve larger scales, and comparable levels of sophistication. It is Culture Minds that are more impressive than Ancilla.
Ego Alter
It's not beyond the culture
Did Abaddon have any arms?
Also is a machine gun in destiny
If I remember the Leviathan DLC correctly from ME3, the Reapers were designed to only purge the Milky Way by their creators. Once they reached the level of technology that allowed them to pretty flawlessly annihilate the most advanced species every cycle, they basically went on autopilot. No doubt had they succeeded against Shepard, they might have made some changes to their process in the next cycle.
ttlpwn34 Exactly, the Reapers were created for a purpose, not to keep advancing and go to other galaxies so it's not really a fair criticism.
Sadly Eckhartsladder has no clue about mass effect lore, look at other "compared" videos with mass effect...
Yes and no. The leviathans designed the reapers to ‘save’ the lesser races from creating and then fighting synthetics. The reapers solution was to purge the galaxy every 50,000 years, the reason being that synthetics would rise up and destroy their masters (which of course the reapers did themselves)
The Reaper's harvest is basically shooting fish in a barrel. While they had to work hard to harvest the Leviathan since that cycle they would only allow civilization to progress to a point they can still be easily beaten. Over time they let too much to be known, yes leaving enough for the next civilization to have someone to attribute the mass relays and Citadel is helpful but letting them leave clues to a superweapon that can wipe out the reapers is a problem.
In all honesty, the Reapers are kinda similar to the flood: they take living creatures and use them to add to their own numbers. If Shepard and his crew did not stop the Collectors (an indoctrinated race from the previous cycle), there would have been a human reaper, and likely also an asari, turian, salarian, krogan, batarian, and whatever other species im forgetting about
#42: Yuuzhan Vong v. Reapers
Dude, you cannot imagine how much I love this channel. This is what I come home to everyday, I just love it so much.
Been a sub from the beginning. Keep it up!!!
The Culture? Well damn it's them instantly, anyone ever seen his 5 most advanced Races and Factions in Sci-Fi video? That will prove why
Forerunner AI fighting the Flood Grave-Mind is a concept I always really loved. It feels much more like a clash of god's than it does anything else, two invincibly vast intelligences fighting on a Galactic scale.
It was less of a clash of gods, and more of a tentacle rape hentai.
Logic plague is a bitch.
Shadow Of Sundered Star it really wasnt easy, it was Mendicant's arrogance that got him beaten
That was a bit of an influence for me when writing about it - two big minds working against each other (my fanfic) www.fanfiction.net/s/11580757/1/HALO-Begging-After-Knowledge (part 1)
I still firmly think that’s where they’re going with the Halo games. That way you can have the Flood get loose but then you would have Cortana and the machines to counter them.
Its been a while since I've seen "The Culture" mentioned, it's kind of refreshing and nice.
TheRedPanda37, there is something to (whispering) big sticks.
[Too bad there is None talking about here from the main [Flower Game]....]
(Only two certain videos here nearly a Year ago, and it was not too detailed and well-researched).
(at least the Halo [Flower] is here....barely).
Yes 👍
Hey all! Thanks for tuning in and May the Fourth be with You!
Follow me on Twitter why don't ya! twitter.com/eckhartsladder
EckhartsLadder Which Sci-Fi Faction has the best Intelligence Agency?(Star Wars Imperial Security Bureau, Star Wars Rebel Intelligence, Halo ONI, WH40K Imperium of Man)
I would like to see how they get their info, how reliable their info is, and how their sources are at accumulating this info from the enemy. If you could do this that would be awesome!
EckhartsLadder i droid wouldn't be consider droid
EckhartsLadder Whens the toe reveal?
EckhartsLadder please do a face reveal
This is one category that Warhammer 40K *can't* win because due to a previous AI rebellion, sentient computers are strictly forbidden in the Imperium.
AJ Jones 40k is ridiculous. That’s why I hate it in factions compared.
I think that "low celling" for Star Wars AI is also a result of previous AI rebelion
Everything is cranked up to 12 and runs off of rule of cool. But it's the people in 40K that make it awesome. For the most part they are ordinary folks just fighting to survive. In the Grimdarkness of the Far Future there is more than just War, there is real people too. That and everything is shades of grey. Nothing is *truly* black or white. It's all a matter of perspective.
datboi knows best Thanks, finaly someone who hates 40K in factions compared as I do.
Never liked the AI in the 40k universe. Unless you had some sort of soul or human interface, you just had a grumpy robot that you had to beg to work.
You know, a factions compared just about halo factions would be pretty neat
To bad it won’t happen:(
Here’s a proposal for a SciFi comparison: which faction has the most reliable economy?
-The Imperium of Man
-The Empire
-The UNSC
-The Federation
Samuel Aldern Not the imperium, the only reliable thing in the 40k universe is war
Hmm... Bad choices for economy... But Federation is good. However post war UNSC looks promising.
unsc is pretty much the only option.
the emperium is a shambles despite its inherited industrial capacity.
the empire a feudal mess of corruption and squander.
the federation has 2 for one special on free helishuttle rides to gulag planets.
Probably the Federation, since they are the only government on that list that has an economy geared towards peacetime.
100% UNSC,
The Imperium gets shat on by having both a shit economy, a shitty type of ftl, and shitty governing.
The Empire is corrupted beyond belief and it's almsot entirely too easy to just steal some shit from somewhere or you know have a star destroyer show up and just park itself on a crowd of people.
The UNSC actually doesn't have that many problems other than space pirates but they are stopped by the UNSC navy almost all the time.
The Federation just sucks lol it really just sucks and has such a low population it's amazing it even has an economy.
Culture definitely wins here.
40k oddly isn't a big contender in this competition. AI had its day in the Dark Age of Technology but their time has past. An argument for the Necrons could be made but even if they count, they suffer the same limits as the Reapers.
anulovlos
Necrons aren't Ai, they are souls inside living metal bodies, their intelligence isn't artificial
Necrons are more like Digital Intelligence.
@@the_dropbear4392 I know this is old, but it's still wrong.
NECRONS DONT HAVE SOULS YOU INCONSIDERATE ####!
But seriously, when they went through the biotransference process the souls were discarded and consumed by the C'tan feasting above.
The Culture Series is awesome! If you haven’t read/listened to those books and you’re a sci-fi fan you are really missing out
Some guy insulted me two decades ago in a dance club, just sitting there on a seat sniping comments at me like "If you were an AI ship in The Culture, your name would be "Lacking Gravitas" " and while I did lock away the memory (I literally can't forget anything) two decades later I discovered the Culture Wiki, and BAM... The memory came back.
Oh and the guy said his name was "Meatfu..." Ok not going to finish that.
I LOVE the new outro!
Which Sci-Fi Faction has the MOST HOSTILE PLANET? (Natural hazards and/or indigenous species.)
HalfDemonInuyasha Catachan.. There men borns
All it takes is a massive gas giant with corrosive atmosphere and good amount of orbiting asteroids.... Good luck surpassing this.
Well considering death world's in 40k such as nocturne then there you go. it could actually repel a planetary invasion (Really centeralized though but there were tanks and great artillary which the planet ate so) to a great degree before space marines went into action
Justin Crossen Agree, I don't want to be there 5min
CharlieVGold 7 Well unless you try to boop the snoot Catachan is a nice place for a one way trip
"totally removed scarcity, death and destruction from the culture"
"gridfire"
Mr Jay White not used because it's too slow. Better to use pinholes. The few seconds it takes for gridfire is to long for any faction with effectors.
used gridfire as a counterpoint to the claim destruction was removed.
i only read the first 2 and a half books so far, and at the moment can only remember the destruction of the habitat/station with the cannibals from the first book.
Gah, I live for that cute outro.
/me sees title
"The Culture. So much the Culture"
Also, finally a list where Warhammer 40K would suck and he immediately ignores them. Boo.
BrokenCurtain
None of the modern factions use AI, and we don't know really anything about dark age AI
It's likely that the dark's AI is extremely advanced. But we can't be sure.
@@the_dropbear4392 The Tau uses AI in their Battlesuits.
@@TheFi0r3
Is so basic, tau are not intelligent than that ai
@@alonelyperson6031 you mean abominable intelligence?
Jesus over 200,000 subs now, well done. Love seeing a great channel grow.
Over 800,000
I mean.. the culture minds
spoiler
simulate whole universes, not out of necessity, but just for fun. They change a constant a bit and let a whole virtual universe evolve to see where it leads, and they do this without it noticeably taking anything away from their attention to other things.
To add to this (a little late I suppose), majority of a mind is situated in hyperspace, and when this part of them is removed from hyperspace, they can still stack the entirety of their consciousness inside of them, with the only problem being that they lose their personality (or something along those lines, it’s been a while since I’ve read a culture book) during it. Pretty sure this is found in consider Phlebas with the occasional segments featuring the mind.
What kinda breaks my heart about this and I'm sure it was mentioned, the Reapers were originally written for another purpose but due to a leak of Mass Effect 3's information or something, they altered the story highly (as I understand it). The reapers were originally harvesting races in order to try and figure out a looming threat of some kind of dark energy that was causing stars to collapse. I'm SEVERELY paraphrasing here, but I'm pretty sure that was said somewhere- and it gives them more of an altruistic, neutral vibe than what we got. I know all stories go through many iterations before settling into a single canon, but this one is very notable because what they went with completely changes their nature and also disregards foreshadowing from the previous games (in my opinion.) Feel free to tell me I'm wrong, it has been what- almost a decade? Since I was a Mass Effect NUT! lmao
*See's thumbnail*
Wow is this even a contest?
Once you bring in the culture everyone else loses. And this is coming from a die hard 40k fan
I mean come on people.
The culture is basically an entire civilization that will never stop learning, growing, and adapt.
I once read it on a spacebattle forum that the moment you challenge the Culture to a fight, you are already defeated before you could make your first move.
The issue...... Is the Time Lord's,who could kill everything in 40k,Halo,Star Trek,Star Wars, Starship Troopers and StarCraft (Hell the Culture and Xelee even apply) by pressing a damn button.
They are impressive, but not particularly more impressive than any properly portrayed galactic civilization. They are roughly equivalent to the Forerunners for example.
We all know the Downsteamers are Xeelee and Q's big titan brothers.
The culture manages it in a hard sci-fi universe too, that's what's truly excellent about them.
The GONK droid of course!
Gonk is even over Mendicant bias.
WHAT ABOUT BENDER?
Happy May the 4th! And thank you so much for taking my suggestion! Love you, Eck!
Hello Ethics!
I think that the most powerful AI in sci fi is Multivac from Isaac Asimov's "the last question".
People ask it if there is any way to reverse entropy and it gathers data until the death of the universe to find out how, then does it, recreating the big bang.
I really enjoyed this video. And the addition of the Culture was pretty neat, too. Although I have to say, I think why the Reapers seem to be stagnant isn't necessarily a flaw, or at least not one they haven't accounted for. They are, after all, performing a massive experiment on the universe, and when performing an experiment, you want to try to eliminate as many variables as possible. One variable might be the Reaper's own technological level, so they may be maintaining it at a certain level to act as a bit of a control, or a consistent foundation. Regardless, great video!
Never heard of the Culture but, it sound like it was the bases for Neal Asher's Polity. I'm gonna have to read it now, Thanks!
Necrons vs Prometheans
Krogans vs Orks
Imperial Guards vs Honor Guards
May the 4th be with you.
No u
What?
Oh, never mind I got it.
Necrons wouls win with Prometheans. Prometheans numbers are limited meanwhile Necrons would be ressurected, Unless their bodies would be fully destroyed. Yet they still can reproduce and there is much more of them. Also, C'tan shards, Obelisks and Gauss cannons?
Edit:
Orks would win with Krogans.
Simply because the more Orks You kill the more of them will come.
Necrons can't reproduce, they're robots. The Prometheans Watchers can resurrect destroyed Prometheans, also the Crawlers, Watchers, and Soldiers are true AI, so they can be replaced with ease. I bet the Prometheans have a device for containing energy, and the C'tan are living energy. Halo has Gauss cannons, and the Prometheans can use them.
As for the Orks, remember that Krogan also reproduce at a high rate, and the Krogan are smarter.
On Starwars Legends in the Old Republic you did have a hybrid special droid called - Scropo used durng the Eternal Fleet and the Gravestone of Starwars the Old Republic . This special droid has a personality it can control other droids and order them do things. It can also activative defensive weapons , it can send other messages to other droids and to organics , it uses Tactics, It learns and studies, it knows how to use Technology, it can upgrade systems Upgrade weapons and do other things. It can be adaptive to learning. The AI on this thing is one of the most advanced in Starwars during the Old Republic. It was when Hk-47 , Revan, Vitiate the daughter, the son and some others were around during that time.
I also think that the Reapers see themselves as the pinnacle of technology and that there is no advancement above themselves.
The Stryx from the EarthCent Ambassador series!
Nobody picks names like Culture Minds. They have such... gravitas
I dunno. the "Mistake Not My Current State Of Joshing Gentle Peevishness For The Awesome And Terrible Majesty Of The Towering Seas Of Ire That Are Themselves The Mere Milquetoast Shallows Fringing My Vast Oceans Of Wrath" is a pretty shallow and unoriginal warship name.
Cosmic AC, the final iteration of Multivac, is still the most powerful AI, that I know of. I mean, reversing entropy and restarting the universe after heat death really can't be topped.
Make this a Galactic Versus episode:
STAR WARS 2M Saber tank
vs.
HALO M808Skorpion tank
vs.
COMMAND AND CONQUER GDI Mammoth MK III
I'd love to see which of theese tanks comes out on top.
Diana Grell Baneblade from Warhammer 40k.
The Emperor Of Mankind BANEEEEEEEE BLAAAAAAAAAAAAADEEEEEEEEE!!!
I swear to christ wh40k fanboys cannot stop trying to bring in non standard normal fucking tanks lol, they just have to see their precious sci-fi win XD, it would be like someone trying to say "Space marine vs Halo spartan 2" and me going "HALO UNSC INFINITY FOR THE WIN" god it's just so bullshitty because their equivelant of a normal standard tank is just absolutely shat on by the tanks on this list.
Leman Russ, the workhorse tank of the Imperial guard
+Blood Raven, thank you for using a standard tank, and I have the happiness to inform you that even so wh40k still loses because the Lemun Russ has 150mm of frontal armor and the halo Scorpian has almost 700mm of frontal armor.
I've got two words,mendicant bias
Darth Vader Exactly my thinking😂 for me Forerunner AI is Number one.
I got two words offensive bias , ggez.
Tfw Culture Mind
Raul Slandgkearth Gonzalez Guzman Well, true😂 but he is Forerunner too, so... the same.
Culture minds react so fast that “long battles” are over in microseconds, and span large portions of the galaxy.
Obviously, SW has the best AI. Look at me for example.
G0-T0 is the exception. B1 battledroids are the norm.
Roger. Roger.
Roger, Roger
Roger, Roger
OM-5..? OM-5!?
top ten saddest deaths
may the cheeki breeki be with you
May the 4th be with you😎😎😎!!! And I love your videos eck😃😃😃😎😎!!! How do you make these epic thumbnails too!!!
Acctually, Reapers don't advance. That's why they aren't "more advanced."
And the citadel and the original Reapers were built by an organic race.
"I create nothing. I bring Nothing. I succor only destruction."
That is the key issue with the Reapers. They don't care about anything other than their assigned goal. And because they don't need to advance, develop, improve or expand upon how they reap the galaxy in their cycles, they don't.
The Reapers themselves, given their scope and the time they've had, could be top contenders among Sci-Fi AIs. They just don't see any point in doing so.
All ships present at the battle of coruscant (or just one side) vs the byss fleet during shadow hand
Putting the Culture up against anything is a little unfair
This is a suggestion for a TH-cam video: Which (human) Sci Fi faction has the best Superweapon ?
The Death Star "(Star Wars)
The MC Device (Enders Game)
Nova bomb (Halo)
Red Matter (Star Trek)
I kinda agree, especially because (in the book) the MD Device was somewhat common on big warships
Dakara Weapon from Stargate (assuming a stargate network is present, over 99% of all life in the galaxy ends in a matter of minutes)
Talion of Gondor wasn’t the MD device mounted on fighters in the book?
shouldn't the ark or a halo be used as the superweapon for halo?
If you used a halo the outcome is pretty clear. But the nova bomb is still incredibly powerful. IMO, after reading it's effects in Halo: First strike, it's probably on par with the Death Star.
As soon as you mentioned the culture I knew it was game over for everyone else.
Culture wins just because of their awesome names. =) Also It's the most compellingly realistic view of AI and I think they would be quite capable of damn near anything, they just don't bother. Also not all minds are equal, though any mind could become more. Then there are drones which would be human like. I think in one book he had an intelligence scale, but beyond the drones it becomes irrelevant compared to the quantum computing General System Vehicles. Author was way ahead of his time. I still remember how the GSV's had force fields because of their height and the pressure would get to high or low, he just seemed to think about everything. Yeah, I'm a huge Culture nerd and always liked how no matter what, the mind was sacrosanct, whether organic or AI
Guilty spork
Skoot Ski , the eating utensil ai
From Warhammer 40ks dark age of thechnology
The Men of Iron
Best AI ever!
On Culture level???
Lol...
Banks Culture was my first introduction to the scifi genre, i can still remember my dad reading the books to me at night as a little kid. Growing up on The Culture and then Halo i never developed the fear of ai that people who grew up on terminator and irobot seem to have
Borg (Star Trek) vs Yuuzhan Vong (Star Wars)
Ay, Eck.
Once again, I shall ask,
(Metroid) the X Vs the flood (halo)
Sixth try
Replicators vs a Unified Star Wars universe (205th try now, *_I._** WILL NEEEEVER EEEVER GIVE UP!!!)*
Maybe sending this message to his Twitter account would help.
Regarding the Reapers, it shouldn't be hard to know why they haven't advanced. Their entire purpose is essentially to be the managers of a millennia long experiment by The Catalyst to find a solution to the original problem it was presented with (finding a way to prevent synthetics from destroying their organic creators). Thus, they are inherently limited by their original directive. I think the Geth would have been a better candidate, or even EDI, as these were allowed to develop on their own, and in different paths.
Oh my God, that new outro is amazing. Also keep up the great work man.
can mechagodzilla (showa, heisei, or millenium) defend hoth?
Recusant Class Light Destroyer vs Something
I need to catch up on The Culture universe. Have not heard of it until now. Thanks EckhartsLadder !!
The Animated Background really adds to the feel of the video.
-Also, I think It would be very interesting to have all these AI's sit in a room together.
How about blasters vs phasers? Or “which sci-fi faction has the best guns?”
Guy call me 40k bias, but the bolter is the best gun: a 20mm rocket/proyectil and it is an AP and HE round in the dame time.
Should specify; laser weapons or in general? Star Trek at least tried to be realistic with their physics.
Seraphinus Necron basic infantry weapon can kill tanks in seconds
photino birds. if you can call what they have guns given how mind bogglingly alien and advanced they are compared to anything else in sci-fi.
Star wars legends blasters, they in legends have the power at some places to literally blast through space ship hulls that can fly through stars.
4. Star Wars
3. Mass Effect
2. HALO
1. Culture
Well they are pretty Smart
Dude you made this on my birthday
Hey ladder, I just wanted to say. I really love you vids and they are always fun to watch. I want to thank you for all time you have given me and you other subs for putting these videos together and know that you will always have my support. Thank you again and have a great day.
Why do the Forerunners have more impressive megastructures? The Culture has literal ringworlds, and countless Orbitals all of which dwarf anything the Forerunners put out.
Marcus Tullius Cicero you clearly don't know much about the forerunner mega structures do you
I recommend you take a look at the ark from halo. Or the forerunner shield world's. Btw, the forerunners have ring worlds, they're called *Halo rings*
You know, the thing the franchise is named after? You clearly have never laid a hand on a Halo game.
@@thegamingcazador8295 A true ringworld is a ring around a star. Halos are small. The ark is smaller than Earth. A RINGWORLD IS A LITERAL LOOP AROUND A STAR IN HABITABLE DISTANCE. THERE IS MORE LIVING ROOM IN THAT RING THAN IN ANY HABITABLE PLANET IN THE GALAXY ADDED TOGETHER
Look up "the sarcophagus from halo"
@@Vellisipsi that things inside the planet Onyx is a Dyson sphere. Its diameter was like Earth's but way bigger. Also contained two or three planets. Culture's orbitals are nothing compared to that.
I’ll be damned if anyone gets this reference
Yo, dude, it’s almost lunch
Yeah,dude, I’ll be right there
I just gotta figure out which aI we’re going to put on this prototype
Did you try skynet?
Just came back from the simulator, it Tried to kill everyone again.
What about Hal?
To needy
GlaDOS?
It kept putting simulations in other simulations
AOWA?
She’s kind of a bitch
Ultron?
Tried to kill everyone
Mother?
Tried to kill everyone
Samantha?
[typing] huh, she’s missing
Ash?
Also-tried to kill everyone
21-O-1?
We don’t speak Japanese!
Shoddycast fallout 4 fistdroid hahahaha
Where are AOWA, Mother, Samantha, Ash and 21-O-1 from?
BXOTROT ___ At the risk of sounding dumb: What does AOWA stand for?
Lord Of Frog's Congolese Uncle it’s from shoddycast’s fisto video
Philipp Obitz I honestly don’t know
*Reapers (Mass Effect) vs Borg Collective (Star Trek)*
Important point, if a Culture mind wants to be a literal god they can do that. They just start up a simulation of a universe so perfect that this could actually be one right now and mess with it on as large or as small of a scale as they want all while they have countless copies running in tandem so they can mess around with different choices and the like. Consider how much processing power it would require to perfectly simulate every last bit of data that makes up our universe.
As they do this they also have the time to care for their meat bags, fulfilling their every little want and desire within socially acceptable bounds, run the enormously complex ring-worlds, craft-worlds or other ships that make up their bodies, ensuring their galaxy spanning 'government' continues to run smoothly and cracking every little question about the universe that is left for them to solve.
Yeah, this is actually dealt with in one of the books - they actually have a moral duty when creating their simulations to not make them too accurate/Real because they essentially become indistinguishable from reality lifeforms.
United halo galaxy vs yuzan vong invasion
depends on time period
Could Godzilla Earth attack the First Order in Star killer? 105th attempt.
Godzilla... in star wars... I have never considered such a thing.
Just a note for UNSC A.I. They were made from dead Human brains, since the mapping process destroyed the brain. Cortana was the only exception but she was made from a flash clone brain of Dr. Halsey
EDI for the mass effects universe because she's basically Reapers and Geth combined but evolved
Please like and comment which you prefer. Thank you 🙂
1) StarCraft vs Halo Can Reach survive a Zerg invasion?
2) 2 Harrower Dreadnaughts vs 1 Imperial Star Destroyer
3) Top 5 Imperial commanders from canon
May the fourth Be with you.
That outro was fantastic
The Reapers are limited to the Milky Way Galaxy because their intended purpose concerns only the Milky Way. While an organic would reason that other galaxies are in need of cycles similar to those in the Milky Way, the Reapers care only for it's management.
Best transforming fighter:
VF-11 thunderbolt from Macross plus vs the Union Flag from Gundam 00 vs the Viking from StarCraft vs the Mecha Tengu from Command and Conquer. Only grunt units no customs.
How long is a year in Star Wars?
(Please notice me EckhartsLadder)
Most places use Coruscsnti time which I think is 350 some days. I did a video on it.
EckhartsLadder Ah, well I found your channel at the beginning of the year, so I don't know if it was made before or after.
Since you used clips from Halo 5 Iam surprised you didn’t mention that Cortana essentially orchestrates the takeover of the galaxy in a single day. In Halo Bad Blood they go a little past Halo 5 and she’s basically like MB directing the Guardians and portalling in armies of Prometheans. I haven’t read that particular book about the Cultur, but that is objectively pretty impressive feat.
Eckshart: "...Dumb AI..."
Eckshart: *shows Cortana*
Eckshart: *repeats that fudging statement again a few seconds later*
Eckshart: *shows Cortana again*
the flood vs orks from 40k
15
th atempt
interesting but I think the flood would win and then become even larger abominations by learning about the warp
Orks don't have a nervous system like any other organic being. infact all their organs are fluid in a fungal sack plus when an ork dies they release spores which in turn create more orks. Flood require a nervous system to infect and if it's not there or damaged in some way then they can't infect you. Just like the flood orks get more and more dangerous as they grow in number and unlike the flood we have seen they create ships, weapons, vehicles that shouldn't work at all but do any way.
Inquisitor Blizzard
The logic plague could infect them.
The logic plague only affects artificial intelligence. Orks are not AI. the logic plague is more likely to have an affect on necrons.
Inquisitor Blizzard Nope, the Necrons are a Metal/Soul fusion. Flood cannot infect a Soul. 40k is 40k :P
Remember in Halo, there was Project Freelancer that created (pretty much) Human level AI (IE. The Alpha, the others are just fragments except Epsilon who is the memory of Alpha). Oh and VIC was pretty gud too, and Sheila, and Lopez, and Andy.
(If you don’t get the joke/reference, go watch Red Vs. Blue, it’s a funny as hell and slightly NSFW web series with seasons 1-13 (Main Canon) available on Netflix)
Also available on here on TH-cam, and the Rooster Teeth site.
J17 Netflix is better though... it’s not in segments
in the old republic mmo, there's an AI who almost takes over the galaxy and was constantly learning and whose goal was to improve itself to become better than everything else. and in the same storyline both the empire and republic get beaten by a fleet of AI ships.
Hey Eck, my main proposition for a future video is more of an idea for a new series; but before we talk about that i wanted to ask you a lore/science based question. I know there are ion cannons in the star wars universe but my limited knowledge an I have never heard of or know if its even possible to ionize a turbo laser shot. I on occasion like to design capital ships and some of my designs have a axial super heavy turbo laser. I was wondering if its grounded in the star wars universe to ionize the axial turbo laser shot either before or after it leaves the barrel. I'm having a lot of fun making these ship and your videos help me find weaknesses and balance in my ships. I really don't want to design anymore around a axial ionized turbo laser if it isn't even possible. Please let me know in the comments if you have heard of anything like that or if you believe it would be possible in the star wars universe.
My idea for a new video would revolve around large battles conveyed beautifully with your majestic voice and amazing story telling abilities. The series would consist of an iconic "supercapital" ship like the eclipse or the executor with a small escort fleet battling it out to the death with a second fleet with a make up strong enough to give it a run for its money. The fleet make up and size would be completely up to you; whatever you feel stands a chance against the super's. I think this could work with your current series, star ship verses, or as somewhat of a stand alone. Super Capital ships are one of my favorite aspects of the star wars universe and a combination of your knowledge, enthusiasm, voice, and story telling capabilities would make for an amazing few videos. That said, everything I've watched that you've made so far I've loved; keep up the amazing work!
P.S. I loved both episodes of the "after Endor" series and would love to see them return. You are an amazing story teller!
You can't stop forerunner AI, calling it.
Damn, I was wrong.
You were wrong fam, sorry for your loss,
It's Ya Boi Daniel wait I still don’t get why mendicant bias wasn’t the forefront of the argument for the anchillas. the culture idea doesn’t really effect him because he made his own choices when he was with the flood...
What do you mean lmao, what are you talking about
You won the vote
Could the master chief with Cortana and blue team defeat an entire Star Wars empire ship? Or the Death Star?
Brad Deremer honestly a star destroyer would easily destroy a ship from halo since it's more advanced than halo warships and the amount if stormtroopers on board the star destroyer and death star would obliterate the Spartans especially with all the advanced tech star wars has at it's disposal
Robby Carlson master chief with Cortana and his team could definitely take on those storm troopers.
Not all the stromtroopers and Vader would wreck all the Spartans
Robby Carlson well Vader isn't on the ship.
Brad Deremer well he's on the death star and they could probably destroy the star destroyer from the inside but not from the outside and the death star even from the inside they'd fail cuz the numbers r too much and the tech star has in the death star is far more advanced than halo
Some quick info about AI capability in the Star Wars universe
Iokath was a massive artificial sphere constructed around a star located in the Unknown Regions by a technologically advanced species at some point before the Manderon Period. Every orbital body in the system was demolished and salvaged for core elements, from which an impervious habitat for the species was constructed, using all of it star's energy output. The species of weapon designers created many technological wonders such as the Gravestone, the Eternal Fleet, the GEMINI droids, SCORPIO and the Old Gods, using their superweapons on dozens of different worlds for live testing. When a civil war broke on Iokath, both sides began using their superweapons against each other, which led the engineers to drive many of their creations into Wild Space with their memory cores locked. However, that did not save them, as the Six Gods were unleashed on Iokath, eradicating all organic life on it and leaving a single self-aware droid known as ARIES to reshape the world in his image. Few visitors that found Iokath over the centuries were all killed by ARIES in brutal tests, until many new arrivals came to Iokath around 3631 BBY, in the middle of the revolt against the Eternal Empire of Zakuul by the Alliance.
If star wars AI seems stunted it is by design through restraining bolts and regular memory wipes to prevent rouge AI
starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Iokath
Suggestion: What if the CIS won the Clone Wars and were around and did not demilitarize by the point when the Yuuzhan Vong Invaded?
The Cylons?....
I mean if you think about it the cylons were not good AI in any way
@@temiajuwon8893 While they certainly weren't the most powerful, they are my personal favorite portrayal of A.I. in any sci-fi series. Because they were so flawed like their creators, and thus had a stronger impression of free will.
Forerunners easily
Nope
It's Ya Boi Daniel y?!!?
Watch the video, and hear about what the Culture AI have done
The Foreruner flood war
Location- lesser ark
Last hope
Mendicen bias and flood fleet arrives Foreruner outnumbered 1/346 Halo fired 6/1
- Offensive bias-
The others are insignificant when comared to Culture Minds which can “ascend”.
You really are wrong saying they they only “edge it”. Their minds operate in another dimension to cope with the instantaneous speed. They are intelligence and far beyond the term “artificial”
I prefer the Star wars A.I, they are so varied. There are the C-3PO's of the galaxy which are very human, then there are the others that are very robotic. But no matter what they aren't these "gods" that just do the best, they are flawed, and If was going to have to be in a universe with an A.I i would hope for it to be like star wars.
Cool mention of the culture. Big fan of mass effect and halo ai as well as star wars droids. This video has all my faves 👍
Don't forget about Abaddon.. the Precursor Equivalent of an Ai and ancilla that resided within the domain.
The Reapers stagnated despite consuming thousands of galaxies of species precisely by the very method that they were able to conquer (and I think it's one of the more interesting aspects of the Mass Effect setting) : They ruins left behind directed the development of ALL technology along a certain path, their path. So once a species developed spaceflight and discovered ruins on a nearby planet, they were essentially locked into a way of thinking, using Mass Effect based technology, and had little reason to develop away from that. Even the supposed way to defeat the Reapers, the Crucible, was ultimately just part of the plan.
Video Idea: Which Sci-Fi Faction has the best Gate Travel? Star Wars Hypergates, Lantian Stargates (SG-1) Iconian Gateway (Trek) or Eve Online's Stargates. Maybe even a special Mention of the Mass Effect Conduit.
The corgi at the end is awsome
The thing about AI in Halo is that even they are not infallible, as Halo 5: Guardians has shown. Lore has also shown that Forerunner AI have been corrupted by the Logic Plague, which Cortana probably has at this point, too.
2:05 lol the giant machine thingy looks like a cart titan
Lt Commander Data and the Doctor. Should have gotten an honorable mention. I mean both are pretty damn famous.
The culture from the Ian Banks M. Banks books. Nice to hear them mentioned. I like the mass effect reapers as well and HALO ai.
And off course Star Wars droids love them all
6:36 My takeaway from the reapers was that they are ascended being living in a sort of energy state and that their corporal forms are shaped in the way they are shaped because the creatures who created them were like the angels of Babylon 5