SLOG3 vs S-Cinetone - Which picture profile should you choose?!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 มิ.ย. 2024
- ❗ Color Presets For SLOG3 & S-Cinetone: whoismatt.com/luts
Move over SLOG3, there's a new picture profile in town! S-Cinetone is here to give you beautiful footage straight out of camera! But how does S-Cinetone compare vs SLOG3? And which picture profile should you choose? Here's a breakdown of the technical differences between these two picture profiles & some scenarios where I recommend filming in SLOG3 & S-Cinetone.
😍 Download my a7S III Settings Preset: whoismatt.com/a7siiisettings/
Sony Menu Setup Guide: • Menu Setup | Fast Film...
Sony Custom Buttons Setup Guide: • Custom Buttons Setup |...
SLOG3 Easy Filmmaking Settings: • How to EASILY film in ...
SLOG3 Color Grading Tutorial: • How To EASILY Color Gr...
Color Grading SLOG3 with LUTs Tutorial: • How To EASILY Color Gr...
S-Cinetone Easy Filmmaking Settings: • How to EASILY film in ...
Combine SLOG3 with S-Cinetone?!: • Can you combine S-LOG3...
How to live stream a wedding - • How To Live Stream A W...
Alister Chapman's S-Cinetone Blog - www.xdcam-user.com/2021/02/al...
►► Book more weddings! Download my FREE quick tips guide to book more wedding film clients: get.whoismatt.com/bookmorewed...
✌ Join my Learn Wedding Filmmaking Facebook Group: learnweddingfilmmaking.co/
⏱ EDIT FASTER! I use Archaius Creative to help edit my videos & they want to help you too!: www.archaiuscreative.com/whoi... (Get 10% off your first editing project when you use this link)
❗ Favorite Wedding Filmmaking Gear: kit.co/whoismatt
My Instagram: / whoismatt
Music licensing sites I recommend:
🎧 Sound Stripe - whoismatt.com/soundstripemusic (use the coupon code "WHOISMATT" for 10% off a yearly or monthly subscription!)
🎷 ART LIST - whoismatt.com/artlistmusic (free extra 2-months when you subscribe using this link!)
🎵 Musicbed - whoismatt.com/musicbedmusic
0:00 There's A New Picture Profile In Town!
1:05 Technical differences between SLOG3 & S-Cinetone
3:29 3 Scenarios Where I Would Choose S-Cinetone
6:34 3 Scenarios Where I Would Choose SLOG3
9:43 Help With SLOG3!
11:15 Bonus For Wedding Filmmakers
I’m required to state that I'm a part of affiliate programs for Amazon, B&H, SoundStripe, ArtList, Musicbed, and Adobe and that some of the links above are affiliate links. - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
😍 Color grade SLOG3 and S-Cinetone FAST with my presets: whoismatt.com/luts
nice luts but its too expensive for me.
Any way to buy a single lut. 03 is the only one that I'd use.
Matt not only the way you share your knowledge is priceless and by far one of the most well explained on TH-cam in my opinion but your LUTs look amazing and I'll definitely consider purchasing them. A huge thanks from one of your loyal fans
You do a fantastic job with your videos explaining everything clearly and concisely. Your touch of humor is also refreshing and funny without being a drag. Really good of you to share 😊
Just wanted to jump in and say thanks for putting out such excellent and informative content all these years. It's good to have a few reliable resources in this world of mostly nonsense. Keep up the good work Matt!!
Super helpful. So many people cannot explain the difference at this level for the life of them. Thanks!
Who else is here, watched the entire vid yet don’t own a camera that can shoot s-cinetone? 🤣
I was just like you up til recently
Only you
@@z352kdaf8324 it was actually me too up until only recently
There are ways to get scinetone on cameras without scinetone. So for a a7iii for example. Just search for it
😂 i have a6300 , S-Cinetone its like using Cine4
Really appreciate your work. Thank you for your videos. They are making the world of difference for me.
Funny how this came out just as I was tinkering with these two profiles. Settled on s-Cinetone for the majority of work for two reasons: quicker turnaround for projects and a feeling that, because I spent $3500 on a camera, that camera should do most of the work. 😂 by the way, I find that if I protect the highlights when shooting and lift the shadows a little in post, they are plenty clean enough to get decent dynamic range.
I agree cinetone has quite a lot of dynamic range. Not as much as slog but you can film whole event easily with cinetone and adjust shadows or colors. Maybe its more challenging for outside a bit
TOTALLY!!
You are so full of knowledge. Thanks for sharing it with us. Subscribed.
Really enjoyed this boss. Gonna snag those LUTS for Cinetone for sure.
Love you bro
Your video helps alot
Learning a lot from you and enjoy watching your videos 📹
Thank you for keeping basic
Amazing video and explanation ! Thank you so much !
clear and comprehensive. Thanks a lot !
Great. Thanks for this. It’s good to have both options and it’s starting to make sense for me at last what are the advantages of each.
Absolutely love your videos!
Such an awesome video. Thanks for sharing.
Color grading on your content is smooth af to say the least
Very good point about ISO for SLOG3!
happy that i subscribed you! u helping me a lot to learn better my sony zv-e10
I love you Matt. Thanks for your videos.
I always love your tuts, so simple and to the point…REQUEST, could you make a video on how to open 4K 10-BIT video on Mac (Thumbnails and Video) Thanks.
Update to latest OS. Use VLC
There's another reason it may be better not to shoot in S-Log 3 (Alistair Chapman discussed this in a video about the FS5 a number of years ago): If you're shooting something that doesn't have high contrast (and thus not making use of the sensor's full dynamic range), and/or you're shooting something in which you want the maximum information about the colour variation in the mid exposure range (i.e. studio green screen), S-Cinetone should produce a better picture quality. To explain:
First, contrary to the way Matt describes it in this video, S-Cinetone doesn't "bake" the colour into your footage any more than S-Log does; they're both equally colour-gradable just in different ranges. The different profile settings distribute the colour information of your shot differently, but you still only have a fixed number of bits of possible colour values recorded. Shooting in S-Log distributes your bits of colour-depth (possible recorded colour values) more equally between the very bright, mid, and very dark ranges; that's why you're able to nicely recover highlights and shadows when grading without introducing banding and noise in those ranges. But, *putting more colour information into the highlights and shadows requires taking it away from the mids.* In high-contrast situations, that's a good trade off: When shooting 10-bit you have some levels of colour variation to spare, so putting them into highlights and shadows where you want to hold on to detail makes sense. But, when you don't have any extreme highlights and shadows (i.e. controlled even lighting), and it's important to be able to distinguish between subtle mid-range colour variations (i.e. green screen), then keeping as much colour information in the mids is critical.
When you grade footage, you introduce noise in the range that you're expanding. If, in post, you brighten S-Cinetone in order to recover detail in shadows, you're taking the small number of colour values which are recorded in the shadows and expanding them across a wider range of the available colour values. At the same time, you're squeezing a large number of colour values recorded in the mids and highlights into a narrower range of the available colours. That's why, when you do this, you'll get some noise/banding in the shadows but the mids and highlights will still look great. Similarly, when you grade S-Log footage in order to give the footage proper contrast, you take the number of recorded colour values in the mids and expand them to a wider range of the available colours (making the brighter mids even brighter, and the darker mids even darker). This means you'll get some noise/banding in the mids, but the highlights and shadows will be fine.
When editing green screen footage, any noise in the mid-range colour information reduces the quality of the key. Even if you're happy to grade log footage, when shooting any scene in which you won't end up needing the extra highlights/shadows information (such as in diffuse, evenly lit, indoor scenes, or when the final grading will be even higher contrast than what you would get S-Cinetone straight out of the camera), and especially when shooting studio green screen, *you'll achieve the best picture quality by avoiding log* and sticking with a standard profile like S-Cinetone.
As a photographer of 23 years(Canon for 18 years) and a hybrid shooter for the last 7; I’ve recently switch to FX6 and 2x A7IV. S-log3 and Sony’s new color science looks really good. I can no longer complain about Sony colors. I think S-cinetone is fine but it just reminds me of jpeg shooters of 2005. Why shoot jpeg when you have so much control over log. If time is an issue(and not money)get a MacBook M1 Max. 😎
I really love S-Log 3! Glad that we have 10bit now to make it much easier to use!!
Agreed!
Matt - I've been loving your videos! Learning so much, and I have one random question - what are you filming your audio on? sometimes I'll listen audio only and I really appreciate how good they sound!
Thanks! Currently using a Deity S-Mic 2 and a zoom h4n
Thank you for this info! Subscribed.
Wow i got new knowledge about minimum ISO when shot S-LOG 3,very interesting tutorial ,thanks for this sharing
Perfect explanation THNX!
great vid and great info, thanks
I prefer S-Cinetone for any lowlight situation. I find that Slog3 introduces way too much noise in the final image. I think S- cinetone is better for this because you don’t have to expose 1.7-2 stops above like Slog3 which means higher ISO.
Thanks for this. I was just about to ask the question about exposing 1.7 stops higher which has been working well for me in SLog. Thanks for confirming it’s not needed with S-Cinetone. But it’s good to have a second option to compare, and it does seemed more attractive in some scenarios including bright light
Thanks for all these infos. Actually since I found Sony option of "Gamma monitoring assist" where I can put a Rec709 on the Slog3 I only shout in SLGOG3 + histogram (iso 800-6400) now without any trouble and I record A LOT of very low light clips (firecamp at night etc...) thanks for all these very great infos.
Exactly what I was looking for :-)
Matt, you saving our life bro 🤗, what pp you suggest for stills in a7siii with wdr ?
Thank you for the video Matt. My S-Cinetone footage looks very dark. It seems like I always have to bring up the exposure to 1.0 on Premiere and bring down the contrast all the way to like -75 or -100. This can't be right. What am I doing wrong, or are my settings somehow off on the Sony FX3. Please help. Thank you.
super tuto. Clear now !
impressive video dude ! Matt is my Man ! Hails from İstanbul/TURKEY
Great video. I'm curious on how do you shoot with ISO 25600 and have almost no grain on the footage
Thank you so much for this video. One question: which settings do you use for cinetone?
Great video. I use my main A7iv for weddings and 2 x A7iii's. I'd love to match the S-Cinetone on my A7iii's or at least get close.
Awesome stuff
my question iswhat profile to use with the a74 using green screen
great video matt! I think one thing to add is s-cinetone may be a great option for those that are color blind. Color grading is near impossible for me so im always looking for a camera that can give me a great look straight out of the camera. I would happily lose dynamic range over my color grading worries.
Just make sure you get "white" right.
Fujifilm will save your life. Their Film simulations are unbeatable .
hey mate nice vid as always one question for buddy what profile would you use for TH-cam vdoes on a A7S3
Hi Matt, awesome video as i am looking for "How to Video's using SONY A7R4" Hope this video helps me to understand few things.
So I just started shooting in SLOG 3 on the a7siii -- I also use your LUTS. It would be so helpful if you made a video about how to know WHEN to stray from the native and dual native ISO's...I'm so fearful of noise in post, and we just filmed wedding that had HORRENDOUS lighting during the ceremony. Both really yellow ceiling lighting and huge windows behind the bride/groom. For example - you show the clip above at ISO 40,000 f4... I would think this would be SO noisy?? and what about when the bars show above/below ISO's too high? Ok, I'm done rambling. :) Your content is fantastic !
Hi Matt, thanks for your great explanations. My question: What would be the workflow if I want to mix S-Cinetone and S-Log 3 footage in one film? What LUTs would help?
Hello Bernd use Filmconvert or Cinematch 🙂
Very informative. Where does HLG stand when compared to s-log 3? My workflow is rec2020 HDR.
hey man, im looking at getting into vlogging mainly fishing, travel and adventure so mainly outside daytime stuff would you recon slog 3 would be best for that or s-cinetone also i do intend to watch your videos on colour grading.
Great video. In Davinci, what should I configure when applying CST (or color management) for s-cinetone?
Hey Matt! Thanks for the informative video. I'm still learning here, but when you say S-Cinetone are you referring to the Gamma or Color Mode? I show that option on both. I'm using an a6700 shooting in 8bit.
What software do you use to grade your footage?
Hopefully you will get this message! What about doing a YT showing how to work with SLog3 and S-Cinetone in the same TL in DaVinci Resolve? Seems to me that both formats would be advantageous to use in certain scenarios. Color matching, at least close would be the tricky part.
Thank Sir. Great video. Looking forward to checking out and sharing your channel.
Hey Matt, could you fix the link for the "Color Grading SLOG3 with LUTs Tutorial"? It actually points to the video "SLOG3 Color Grading Tutorial"( You can also see that the same link is pasted twice from one line to another in the description). I also wanted to mentioned how great your tutorials are. I love them! Not only are you a wonderful videographer but you are a phenomenal teacher! I am a big fan of the pace at which you talk and the clarity of your explanations. Keep up the great job!
Das Model hatte richtig Bock :D
Hey Matt. For stuff like filming rivers and kayaking would the new Sony a7r5 compete with the Sony as73 since it doesn't have 120fps?
Just here to say that after testing several PPs with my A7SIII I can say that cine 4 + ITU709 matrix is by far the best at least for me. Try it out and maybe you’ll like it too
Sameeee
Hey matt great video but question…I have to shoot a DJ in a Club tonight would you recommend S Cinetone for that? I’m worried the base iso will be lower so I’m not sure
Hi!Great video!!I like to shoot in scinetone just to be faster!but which are the best,usable isos over 2000 iso to shoot in low light scenarios in a7siii??
Would be nice if the Atomos Ninja V allowed for 4k60 passthrough to be able to apply a LUT record already color corrected footage to avoid doing anything in post. 😃
Can you do one on slog3 at super low light I’m having a hard time exposing foe super low light situation like towards the end of a wedding
Super helpful, 🙏🏻
What are you thoughts on cine 4. Pro compared to scinetone
Hi! 2 questions: flexible ISO is Not available while using PP11? Why Not ? And 2) what Are your Settings in PP11? To use it without - or minimal colorgrading? Thanks soo much
what about a7iii and its 8bit colours? Is it still a good idea to film in sLog?
thank you!
This video helped a lot. I was just recently planning on filming some short documentaries/films with a collegue of mine and we weren't sure what profile to use, for the future I'll know what to use in any situation. Thanks a lot, Matt.
Probably a very silly question but which Picture Profile is S-Cinetone in the Sony A7s3 and/or how would you suggest setting it for this? Thanks!!
Hey Matt... I just start using my Sony A7siii... Should I start with their newest software update or the original that comes with the camera is fine? Checking out your settings videos now
I would update the firmware
Thanks!
Great Videos as usual Matt. I'm going to sound stupid but I've been shooting video for corporations but mostly weddings.
I've shot 3/4 inch tape to beta svhs mini dv to digital. I bought this new fx30 camera because everyone is getting away from camcorders and i though it would be time for me to move up to this new way of shooting. With the new fx30 can i do a run and gun video shoot and edit and produce a good 4k video without going thru the slog3 process and get a good 4k video?
Thanks in advance.
Matt, is there a S-Cinetone mode with HDR? Would love something better than the HLG footage straight out of an iPhone 14 Pro. Thanks.
Thanks
Matt, thanks for the video. I've been away from Sony for about four years, and have just purchased the A74, and I'm very impressed with the improvements in color and AF that Sony has achieved. The A74 is quite a camera. I'm looking forward to going through your most recent tutorials for these cameras. I recall I hated S-LOg and could never make it look right. I'm hoping S-Log 3 won't present those problems, at least to the degree I experienced years ago.
That notwithstanding I really love the skin tones and look of S-Cinetone. I'm glad they included it in the A74. I think it looks better than the Fujifilm film simulations---with much better 'everything else."
I hope I can get confident with S-log 3 and get some of your presets for the log File.
From one fellow Texan to another, thanks so much for taking the time to share your knowledge and expertise.
Thanks William!
It is best to use the Phatom lut with S Log 3.
Me parecen excelentes tus luts. Pero, los de registro para log...¿solo funcionan para slog 3? ¿no funcionan para slog 2? Slog 3 no tiene defectos en camaras sony que pueden grabar a 10 bits, pero, ¿y las que graban con solo 8 bits? Por ejemplo una a7c, graba solo en 8 bits, si filmo en slog 3 aparecen ciertas manchas raras en las pieles, ya que para procesar bien el slog 3 necesita grabar a 10 bits. Por eso la pregunta, tus luts, ¿se ajustan bien a videos grabados en slog 2?
ありがとうございます！
G'day Matt...I luv ur luts...I'm thinking to get a combo pack...u have sale or discount atm?
If you were making footage to go on a 30 foot movie theater screen
, or bigger would you choose s log or pro res?
?
Hello Matt!
Im a fan of your youtube channel! I from Sweden and i im a hobby fotographer. I have a quation that i havent seen any solution on youtube or the web. When i import my footage from my Mavic Air 1 and my Dji Pocket 1 the footage gets very jiddery on the edges of everything. And when i paus the clip it gets smooth and goes back to normal.
It only happens when i import Dji footage.
Is their a picture profile or lut that will give me a beard like yours ?
Amazing video Matt!
I film weddings and use Cine 4 and I run into a constant problem with my white balance... specially in that mix lighting between different locations. So every time I go and put a LUT over my videos, people look way too orange and my videos look way too moody. Do you think S-log3 will help with this or would I still have to have my white balance perfect every time? I know you kinda mentioned that in the video but I wanted to confirm hahaha
Thanks! You’ll want to manually dial in your Kelvin. If things look too orange when you apply your lut try dropping your Kelvin 500K lower
Hello, first I wanted to thank you for the very helpful videos on your TH-cam channels, I've seen and subscribed to many of your videos. I have a few questions and I would be grateful for your answers. A7iv can record at 10 bits. what does that mean? when i'm recording with 10 where i used. can I simply record with 8bit and still edit it in video, e.g. Davinci Color? I always without PP or PP11. what setting for video I can s.besten take.
Video format
XAVC S 4K (codec H.264) or
XAVS-I 4K
XAVC HS (H.265 codec)?
4:2:2 or 4:2:0 (100 or 60M)?
I shot 100 or so daily vlogs on SLOG. Same day turn on corporate event videos on SLog. IMO it comes down to the machine you have to edit on and your GRIT to get it done. Sounds like CineTone would not have worked in my case for indoor events :)
Just when you thought your videos couldn’t get any more pro.. boom.. you surprise us again..
Thank you
What about when using AUTO-ISO for exposure? Like in a vlogging scenario? Could slog3 still be used for that?
Set and watch your highlight zebras
I also heard that using s cinetone is better in an environment where there is only very bright artificial light. And slog is better used with natural light. Is that true?
Hi Matt, I have some interesting problem with slog-3 mode with my own lut. Fx-3 (firmware 3.0) record proxy with lut but origins still s-log3 what gets some problem on post ( need to make proxy in davinci for s-log3 proxy color ). What can you advice ? Thx so much.
Soooo the 10000 iso and the 25600 iso did you use some noise reduction soft ware cause those dont be looking that good for me lol
Matt, I know this sounds silly, but could you walk us through how you setup the s-cinetone picture profile? Is there any adjustments that you make in PP11 or do you just switch it to that and leave it standard?
Also, I'm a little bit puzzled about this here. I purchased an FX6 several months ago, and I love it. They give you an option to shoot high or low ISO base using s-cinetone, and that has worked out great. On the a7siii, it seems to be a lot more complicated.
Lastly, if you would be kind enough to run through the menu of the FX6, I'd be so very grateful!!!
My previous video to this one will do that :)
@@whoismatt I did watch that video, but perhaps I missed that part! I will watch it again 😅
@@whoismatt Hi Matt, love your videos. Canou give one on one Online training for Video shooting and Editing? I will like to know the cost and duration for training for beginner to Professional please..
Hey I’m still struggling with my video in post being clear
Hi. What do you think about hlg 2 and 3?
I will be filming business owner interviews in my studio with controlled lighting mainly for placement on their website. Obviously I will test SLOG3 against S-Cinetone but I’m sensing there may be a law of diminishing returns using log given the workload in post particularly if I apply your standard LUT to S-Cinetone footage. What do you think?
If you have controlled lighting I would go with S-cinetone :)
Cool 😎 that was my gut feeling and you have just given me a profit boosting workflow 👏
Are the luts ok for S LOG2?
I'm a starter so plz go ez on me but I have a question about using the S-log3. So I will be getting a sony A7RV with a sony 20-70mm f/4, but as I understand correctly I can just use 1/50 as shutter speed, f/4 as aperature and native 800 ISO and adjust the exposure with my polarpro 2-5 stop variable nd to keep the MM between 1.7 and 2.0? thx
I have an a7s3 and my main complaint about slog3 is how impractical the iso range is. If I want anything above 640, I need to jump to 12800, which causes a significant colour shift and makes skin tones look unnatural. It’s fine for event shooting, but not for commercial work. I’m curious if cinetone is better for those situations where you need iso 2000-6400? If not, canon cameras seem to be more practical for most shooting situations. No one seems to be talking about this.
So Canon cameras don't have an equivalent of Slog?
Exactly my question too! S-Cinetone is much more flexible for ISO right? Nobody is answering this of how to handle the massive gap between dual ISO’s in S-Log?
How do you get rid of the terrible noise SLOG 3 creates in low lighting environments especially at night?
Grading Log doesn't have to be a pain. If you use color space transform in Davinci Resolve you get a perfect conversion every time, without using a LUT. Sometimes LUTS can make your footage look strange; however, Color space transform uses mathematical data for your camera color and gamma to match whatever color space and gamma you want to convert it to. Non-destructively.
Do you find this works well w/ matching different cameras?
@@dominicgray2187 Yes, that is one of the reasions CST and ACES transform in resolve were developed. Davinci resolve has another feature in the studio version that will actually match two different clips as well.
So is a conversion to ProRes or Cineform no longer required when doing major work on footage like this?
@@rockrecordreport7136 If you’re using compressed footage, you want to convert it into something much more edit friendly. That’s what converting to pro res or cineform will do for you. Less compression and easier to edit.
@@tylerjslattery I know what these intermediate codecs do and what they are for. My question is again - does SLOG3 and S-CINETONE profiles output (COMPRESSED) footage that still requires ProRes? Because nobody wants to talk about that. They all talk about dropping over LUTS, talk about color corrections, but FAIL to discuss that intermediate step required. Notice that?
11:43 you said"Shooting in S-log keeping 160 ISO is no recommended " Whereas later on your footage you clearly mentiond that SLOG footage is recorded on 160 ISO From 4:23 Onwards Though the shot is good :)