Harry Potter Theory: Voldemort’s FULL Tri-Wizard Cup Plan!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 13 ก.ย. 2017
- Original Article :: miraniel.tumblr.com/post/96154...
Today Ben dives into the wizarding world of Harry Potter to try and answer a long standing question: Why did Barty Crouch Jr. set up the tri-wizard cup to return to the school?
Check out the Patreon for all those extra goodies: / supercarlinbrothers
The original article: / miraniel
Hey Super Carlin Friends! ►► bit.ly/196DDlu
Google Autofill Playlist ►► bit.ly/1DCdQNm
Theories ►► bit.ly/1z5uZcS
Super Carlin Gaming ►► bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
BECOME A SUPER CARLIN FRIEND➜ / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
FOLLOW US:
I N S T A G R A M➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
F A C E B O O K➜ / supercarlinbrothers
G A M I N G ➜ bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
P A T R E O N ➜ / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Want to send us something?
Super Carlin Brothers
PO Box 4339
Roanoke, Virginia 24015
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Business Inquiries Only: carlinbrosrtp@gmail.com
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Every time you give us a thumbs up a Narwhal gets its horn! (maybe..)
![How To Block Avada Kedavra [Harry Potter Theory]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/KfTpUGF7Uq0/mqdefault.jpg)
Ah, I'm so flattered. Someone cares for my work.
I care for your work, I aspire to be the next you.
@@carrie637 ........................ But that means you'll eventually die...............
@Fun With Kelsey who cares. 😅
That sub count tho
Voldemort: AVADA KADAVRA
Harry Potter: EXPELLIARMUS
1. Fake Madeye: portkeys a chair in his office
2. Fake Madeye: ask Harry to see him in his office after class.
3. Harry: Goes to the office, take a sit and BAM! he is in the graveyard.
There, book ends after 10 pages.
I assume Hogwarts has protections against portkeys in and out. If, as the video suggests, the cup was meant to be a portkey already... then it would have been allowed to bypass those protections by Dumbledore, the Ministry, or both. My theory is that it would be nearly impossible to make their own portkey out of the school, but it was possible to modify an existing one.
shockthetoast well, in the fifth book, in Christmas, Dumbledore creates a port key on the spot with just one incantation so they can go a visit mister Weasley in st mungos. So idk, seems pretty easy to me
@@billilililieee Dumbledore knows his ways around the security. Remember he said there are advantages to be him ;)
Ranganath Vaikuntham, that’s in movies, he never says that in the books.
@@carrie637 That's true. But I guess it is to be assumed in the book.
Imagine if, when Harry and Cedric were in the graveyard, Cedric touched the cup to inspect it and just disapparated back to the begining of the maze and just left Harry alone in the graveyard
Him: "don't hire Voldemort to plan your wedding"
welp that ruins my plans
What marriage?
Yeah or even Filch for that matter... He plans quite the red weddings.
Jait Das rip
hahaha now I need to see Daniel Radcliffe acting out as wormtail pretending to be harry
Now that you say that how did Fred and George not notice wormtail on the marauders map
+Koro Sensei Actually there is great theory about that in this channel, more or less saying: as the creators of the map, marauders cannot be seen on the map unless the viewer is one them. Harry seeing Wormtail was never stated in the books, it was just in the movie. And actually the theory makes total sense. Obviously, if it was me let's say, I would not want anyone to be able to see where I am, especially if I am up to no good (pun intended) other than my partners in crime. But you should definitely check that video!
Zeynep Ertüz I believe it’s on Seamus Gormans channel
+Emilemig 5 Oh yes you are right! To redeem myself I am just leaving Seamus' link here: th-cam.com/video/nMZlMD0Y7F4/w-d-xo.html
In my mind I remembered it as Ben was explaining it. I have no idea why :D
whut
I'd like to watch wormtail try to get passed crookshanks as harry. Now that would be funny
KitTheHufflepuff I
I was just thinking something. Isn't it strange that crookshanks didn't notice anything? Not only about crouch, but also about Rita.
alejandro ojeda Is there a scene where Crookshanks would encounter the morphed Rita?
alejandro ojeda
Watch the video on the theory about Crookshanks!
It'd be like how dogs can sniff out Terminators
I think the most plausible theory is that the cup was always supposed to be a portkey. It makes sense. Dumbledore and the others made the cup a portkey so when the champion grabbed it, they would be transported out of the maze so they wouldn't have to find their ways back out. It would explain why the cup takes Harry back to school and why, when he returns with Cedric's body, he appears in front of the crowd and not in the center of the maze.
Olivia Bennett Good to see sombody thinks the same way I do.
That
Except fakr moody offered to take the cup into the maze and turn it into a portkey nobody else touched it..i just read that book
your literally a genius ngl
Now that....is smart
I don't know whether it's stated explicitly in the books, but I always imagined Crouch Jr. to have spent only a short while (a year or so) in Azkaban, and then living with his Dad for the remainder. It think Snuffles says something about him (not realising it was actually his mom) not making it long.
That's actually one of the darker scenes, where Sirius says something like, "In the beginning, he cried for his mother, every night, but his screams soon quieted, then died. They all went silent after a while!"
What a horrible place is Azkaban anyway, considering that this is the ONLY Wizarding Prison (we know of) so, EVERYONE, no matter how petty their crime, goes there, to what is basically magical GITMO!
haha, u wrote all that and it got a single like
@@olegtrushin6220 I think that's empty ever since Grindelwald was defeated. I mean it's basically wizard Auschwitz and that place isn't used anymore. Kind of telling though, that the wizarding community didn't turn Nurmengard into a museum...
No one gets past Crookshanks. No one.
Angelica Schuyler Ikr #Crookshanks
crookshanks is hermiones cat, right? its been a while since I watched the movies, and I watched them in german.
TheMike0088 yep!! I wish I knew another language. It would be so cool to watch the movies in say, French or something.
TheMike0088 yes Crookeshanks is Hermione's cat.
TheMike0088 he's also in the books
0:23 - "Was it really necessary for Harry to win The Cup to kidnap him?"
Well maybe it was. If you wanted to teleport him out of Hogwarts. Normally you cannot teleport out of Hogwarts. But it seems that portkeys can. We had seen Dumbledore using portkey to teleport Harry from Hogwarts to Burrow and from Ministry to Hogwarts (Fifth book). If any portkey can do that, then this whole Anti-teleportation Spell would be *useless* . But what if only *Headmaster* could create such portkey (because he is "owner" of Hogwarts)? If Dumbledore was supposed to put such type of portkey-spell on Cup to teleport winner from center of the maze to entrance of the maze and Crouch knew that, then maybe Voldemort figured out that if you put another portkey-spell *on the same object* then it would *still* "ignore" this Anti-teleportation Spell.
But Crouch would have to wait until Dumbledore creates such portkey in first place. And probably he just did that in the very day of the Third Task.
good thought
But what I don't get is why Harry croutch Jr. Pretending to be mad eye could just ask Harry to stay after class, and be like my leg is hurting you wouldn't mind picking up those books, and bam it was a portkey.
Ava _the_fangirl I think that's bc the only working portkey (inside hogwarts) would have to be one made by Dumbledore. And that would be the cup that took the winner from the center to the beginning of the maze, because Dumbledore doesn't go around making random portkeys. He confided the placement of the cup to Moody bc he trusted him, so he was the only one w the portkey alone and made it transport anyone who touched it to voldemort. I assumed it's complicated and time consuming (rising suspicions) to do that and also eliminate the part where it took the winner to the front, so that's why it worked 2 ways. But the theory seems interesting idk. Hope this makes sense, sorry about my english 💖
I was thinking along the same lines. I didn't think about the anti-apparition thing, though.
But it does make sense if Dumbledore cast the spell and then trusted "Moody" with the cup.
Perhaps Crouch Jr. found a way to add an additional, temporary, location.
Sort of, veiling or overshadowing the original destination.
Once Harry is in the graveyard, the "veil" is used up and only Dumbledore's original spell remains. Thus why he arrives back at the beginning of the maze.
@@soldc Guys. Portkeys do NOT work inside Hogwarts. When they do use that one time, I am preTTY sure (I had notes on this but cant say 100% just now), it is mentioned that they had lifted some spells for the special occasion - I may or may not be mixing this up with the time they used floo powder to get to/from christmas... But in general they do not work. Floo powder is done inside the castle but not in and out. Later when escaping Dumbledore uses Fawks and not a portkey which means if they had used a portkey before, it might take time to lift the spells. i had considered at one point that they had lifted the portkey spell for the guests that were coming to see the tournament but Dumbledore was aware of dangers and there is no reason they cant apparate outside the gates so. I dont think Dumbledore would have lifted the portkey protection. If the cup portkeying to the outaide of the maze was a thing, they would have lifted portkeys INSIDE the grounds, but not in and out - just like they did with the floo network and apparition classes. Apparating outside of the grounds would still have had to be BCJ's work which is some truly ridiculous feat for someone who had been imprisoned just after school and a huge dumb risk on Voldemort's part.
Easy peasy: lets say someone needs to set up the portkey. Most likely this would be a more powerful wizard. Maybe Voldemort just can‘t erase the original charm. He just sneaks in his charm to take place before the original one. When Harry and Cedric use the Portkey for the first Time Voldis magic on the object is gone, leaving the original „travel plan“ on it. Maybe voldi and his crowd didn‘t really plan much farther than „kill Harry“.
Excactly what ive always thought, since we’ve never seen anyone ”cancel” a portkey, and there is no proof that it is possible. Voldemort might have been able to, but here is a wizard far less capable than him (although crouch aint no slouch) having a fem minutes to set it up.
Lukas Kbäck. And even if it is possible to remove a port key spell under normal circumstances, it might not be possible when the spell is created by Dumbledore in the Hogwarts “no teleportation zone”
Didn’t Mrs Crouch die in the 80’s? Wouldn’t that mean Barty Jr has been under the imperius curse for almost a decade? (Though that doesn’t change your point because that’s probably worse for remembering spells you haven’t used in years 😂 Barty is still incredible for managing to be Moody for a year
Right?! I am pretty sure the swap/death happened about a year after Crouch Jr was sent to Azkaban (according to Sirius when he tells the trio Crouch Sr's background story). So that would be in 1982.
Yeah, I'm pretty sure there's even a line where Crouch Jr says something like 'the world cup was my the first time I left the house in years'
Just re-read book 4 and yea he got that totally backwards, it was a year in Azkaban (mother died in his place, good ol’ polyjuice bait and switch) and then decade under imperious curse.
People keep forgetting that Crouch Jr. spent less than a year in Azkaban before he "died" (aka smuggled out by his pops)... Sirius says so in the Hogsmeade cave in book four
Here's one for you: Say Tom Riddle manages to comeback in Chamger of Secrets. Young Diary Tom Riddle I mean. So... what does he do with the other Voldemort?? What Voldemort takes priority over the other? Would young Voldemort go find his older version and kill him to rule supreme? Would old Voldemort seek out his young version to manipulate and eventually kill to take his place? I've never seen that idea talked about anywhere.
I remember watching a video about that theory not sure who made but i doubt i would came with something like that, so i must ve seen it somewere else. In regards to that theory next paragraph is just my asumption, but i think:
Young riddle would use himself as a catalyst for his older self revival (which probably means throw himself into the cauldron).
I wonder about that, because I did think of that but Young Riddle seemed to have his own consciousness, and not being a memory anymore, he would pretty much also be alive and I just wonder if he'd be willing to end his existence for the sake of his older self... or if would cause some kind of Civil War among Death Eaters, or if Voldemort would end up forcing Young Riddle to give up his life for him.
young voldemort is just an horcrux, so it's like a magic picture plus a shard of voldemort's soul. once ready, ghosty voldemort would have reached him and reunited to become whole again
I don't think much would _happen_ , exactly. If Harry had died from the basilisk venom for example, Ginny would have died from being emotionally crushed by the horcrux, and the Horcrux diary would just remain in tact. So we'd have a dead Harry, dead Ginny, dead Basilisk and a part of Voldemort's soul inside the Chamber, possibly forever.
Also it's interesting that all that happened without the concious Voldemort's knowledge or approval. Lucius set all of that in motion to satisfy his own little vengeance against Arthur and Voldemort was furious about it. Imagine how upset he would have been if not only he had been messing with one of voldemort's horcruxes, but also vicariously killed his master's mortal enemy behind his back.
I think they’d become one, somehow?
I'd prefer Voldemort to plan my wedding over anyone in Game of Thrones; there deaths per wedding is just too high to ignore. Anyways, awesome video. This is was a plot hole that needed some theories about. Have a magical day Ben!
Wotso Videos I agree a GOT wedding would be awful!
"A Dothraki wedding without at least three deaths is considered a dull affair."
Wotso Videos true never get married in westros
I want the wedding planner who planned Joffrey's wedding
Anna Thoomkuzhy omg yes
The only mistake Voldemort ever did was to leave his planing to J K Rowling.
Daaaaang. That was a burn to both of them.
I'll keep that in mind when hiring a spell checker. It won't be you.
@@DavidRay39 lol you're wack
for all we know, Rowling is an excellent carpenter.
Anonymous Anonymous naaaa there was another mistake
I always thought the cup was twice made a portkey: 1.) to announce the winner
2.) to take Harry to graveyard
but when it was made second time portkey, the charm from the first portkey stayed so it still worked after Harry used it to come to graveyard but it worked backwards (if it makes sense for anyone else except me 😂)
'Weird infant slug thing'
Accurate description.
I thought Barty Crouch Jr was only in Azkaban for a year? Not 10! Also I think you need to be alive in order for your hair to work in the polyjuice potion. That's why Moody was kept alive in the trunk.
I think moody was kept alive so he wouldn't run out of hair
yeah i thought the person had to be alive. Although it is weird cause isn't hair just dead cells anyway? And if he was taking the juice every hour he would keep needing harry's hair till at least the end of the school year.
Pikachu Sparks No because even after the entire school year moody was only missing a few patches of hair so he wouldn't have used it all up.
bailal1 I think moody was kept alive to retrieve information from him if needed and to definitely have an infinite source of polyjuice potion ingredients.
Indeed, which was kind of a stupid reason that JKR made up so Moodey wouldn't be dead.
I mean, there are spells that make you grow glorious long beards (Fred & George got hit by it in that very same book/movie), Junior could have just used one on Moodey but for hair, cut them, kill him and voilà, huge quantity of hair, and as a bonus you don't have to drag an Auror around in a suitcase for a year.
Barty Crouch Junior must have been the most skilled wizard in the Death Eaters with Snape; we know he had exceptional grades when he was at Hogwart (we get that info when we, the audience, are still led to believe that he is likely innocent) and despite his young age and being rusty due to not being able to use magic when he was under his father's spell (imperius curse), and he still did all these crazy feats during year 4...
Dumbledore only noticed it wasn't Mad-Eye Moodey after his first (minor) mistake.
In a movie's deleted scene, there's one in which Moodey goes to talk to Barty Crouch Senior and does his "snake tongue flick" thing and you can see Sr. 's face going "oh shit" but it goes nowhere...
I would have loved to see more of Barty Jr. in his normal state, he was an interesting villain.
The only reason Voldemort kept his secret a return is because he failed at killing Harry... he wanted to return with a bang and kill "The Boy Who Lived".... when that went wrong, Voldemort's plan went a rye and he took advantage of the fact that nobody believed Harry
Yonathan Taye awry
Yeah, when is it stated that the plan was to be secret. Does anyone know. Because otherwise the secrecy might just have been until Voldemort has a new body.
@@JJSogaard Pretty sure Dumbledore told Harry that he thought Voldemort would've wanted to keep his return a secret at the end of OotP
I see a flaw in this theory (although I do like it). Polyjuice Potion requires the subject to be alive. That’s why BCJ had to keep Moody alive in the trunk.
Im fairly sure that moody was kept alive so that crouch wouldnt run out of hair. Though as Ive seen on other posts he definitely would have had enough hair anyways.
I believe in book they said that Moody was kept alive so that Crouch Jr. could talk to him and find out how to act like real Moody because Dumbledore know real Moody very well.
@@sbcd7808 I believe in book they said that Moody was kept alive so that Crouch Jr. could talk to him and find out how to act like real Moody because Dumbledore know real Moody very well.
@@IamAlmostRealWitch true but if he is eaten what shape word the other take him eaten not his full self we see that from Crouch
I think it worked both ways because the cup was originally a portkey to transport the winner back to the front of the maze. I think it was just a mistake with how long Crouch went without magic he maybe forgot???
Ketchup & Gummy Bears This was my understanding as well.
Yet he was still good enough at magic to cast a confoundus charm on a magical object that is not supposed to be able to be confounded.
Avatarbee *"confundus"
I'm so glad I'm not the only one who thought this!
Avatarbee no I have a mini theory that three schools can only enter but the goblet of fire picks someone from every school, not picking people from only three schools, so he just put Harry's name under a different school so he had a 100% chance of being picked
Since Cedric was not part of the plan, Voldemort was obviously not expecting him but it was a bit stupid to think "KILL HIM" as soon as he arrived, cos even if this theory is correct and wormtail arrived back as harry, there would be no Cedric. Voldemort should have Petrificus totalused him, then killed Harry wiped Cedric's mind/ imperiused him then sent him back as well. Boom, nothing amiss.
Wormtail as harry vs crookshanks yeaaa that's ganna end up well for wormtail (not)
Did he say "kill" or "get rid of him" by the way?
LeaselMary on page 638, line 5: "Kill the spare."
to be fair, the tri-wizard tournament is supposed to be dangerous and competitors dying shouldn't be a huge surprise. It's possible wormtail (as harry) could just come back with cedric's body, then pretend that he came across cedric's dead body in the maze and decided to bring it with him because that'd be the "noble thing to do"
But as voldemort said, desmemorization can be surpassed, so it really doesn't solve the problem.
Lol pettigrew running towards Dumbledores office as a rat, then crookshanks jump in him and eats him
And as Crookshanks puts him inside his mouth Peter transforms. RIP Crookshanks.
I love how there is a tri-wizard cup right behind him
Voldemort just likes to YOLO
Ambition seems legit
he doesn't live once its YOLONT (you only live 9 times since he had 8 (including harry as an accidental horcrux) horcruxes)
OMG AMBITION
Ambition lol
Tom Maryolo Riddle.
Actually, if they tried to kill Harry and then use his hair for the potion, it would only last until the effects wore off. That's why they never killed the real Moody - they needed him alive to make more potion.
Kanya Kishana but they wouldn't really need to keep up the ruse for very long. Just enough for his disappearance to not be linked to the Tournament. A large flask of potion should have been sufficient. Crouch had to keep the real Moody alive because he was planning on impersonating him for several months and needed to keep making more potion in order to do so.
Kanya Kishana exactly! They would need enough of Harry to keep making the potion! How long was this thing going to go on.
they could just used one deatheater as Harry and let him escalate and maybe kill Dumbledore or even make more terror as Harry
Okay, but-- You do realise you only need ONE piece of Harry, right?
Hair. Nail. Skin...
Harry may not be a big person, but.... How many hairs are on your head? How many nails do you have? How much skin do you have?
Because there's a LOT of material you can harvest from one dead body.
Voldy could have had all of Harry's hair shaved and given it to Wormtail to take with to Hogwarts.
At the sound of the Cannon - BOOM! - Heh, I laugh every time Filtch fires when Dumbledore mentions when things start.
I would hire Mrs Weasley for my wedding planning AND FOOOOOOOOOOOD cuz why not
But you can't use the polyjuice potion for transformations into dead people (or animals). So if Voldemort had planned to kill Harry and then send Peter Pettigrew back in Harrys place he would have to transform wormtail by using a different magic - maybe the kind Ron is transformed by when they break into Gringotts (I know it didn't look to different in the movie, but maybe it was better in the books?).
Or and here is my theory: Voldemort planned to kill Harry, alright, and then make it that nobody noticed Harrys death. How could he do that? Maybe by using a technique that was used by him in the last book? Bathilda Bagshot was dead and yet she kept moving and everything since the snake, Voldemort put inside of her, controlled her. Imagine this: Harry returnes from the maze, he doesn't speak a word nor does he use magic. "The maze changes people", is what people said before he even went in there. After a while he may start to smell bad and Dumbledore may even get suspicious, but to the world Harry Potter is still alive - a broken person. Maybe they take him to the hospital and keep him next to Nevilles parents and Lockhart? Or maybe the snake is not going to controll him forever, but just long enough to fake an accident that killed Harry Potter? Maybe he killed himself in his state of depression after whatever happened to him in the maze? It doesn't really matter - it's buying time for Voldemort to return in secret. I think this was Voldemorts plan.
Great thinking!
Don't you think Dumbledore a bit smarter to be fooled by this? Liked to read it anyway.
I honestly think that the cup was already set to take the winner to just outside the maze, and barty crouch jr. could not revert that effect, but instead just added an extra destination before that one...
Human Transfiguration is possible.
Like Grindelwald into Mr. Graves.
Surely voldemort could also do that to himself or to someone else.
"A Portkey can be any harmless object: such as a football, or a dolphin."
You have to cut Voldemort some slack for sending Barty Crouch Jr. against Mad-Eye, he literally only had Peter Pettigrew, Lucius Malfoy, and whoever Lucius could scrounge up as alternatives.
Lucius would have lost because he's not as strong as Mad-Eye, sure he's got money and strategy, but Mad-Eye is a much better wizard over all.
Peter is a piss poor wizard, in a straight up fight he'd lose very quickly, however he'd last a lot longer than whoever Lucius could scrounge up because at the time Lucius could at the very most grab a wizard of roughly equal power to himself, but comparatively less intelligent.
Barty Jr. had nothing to bring to the table, he was an expendable asset, he managed to beat Mad-Eye purely because he was actually willing to risk himself unlike Peter and Lucius, I mean he's far from the best wizard but against an aging paranoid Auror who by the time he attacked was sleep deprived, he had a good 1 in 5 chance of success (I'm being generous here his chances were probably closer to 1 in 8).
Anyway with what he had to work with Barty Jr. was the best choice: Expendable asset, roughly more powerful than Lucius, a major authority figures son (yay for sabotage of the enemy government) and easily smarter than Peter.
Oh, yeah. That's a good point.
Attacking a man with Trash Bins 101
1-Be Selfless
TH-cam Addict
There is a reason all garbage men are badasses, trash bins/cans are vicious.
Also they'd already taken out Barty Crouch, so it's quite possible Junior was already polymorphed to look like his dad (an act he'd pull off with ease), and went there in the capacity of dealing with one of the many complaints against Moody. A favor done out of respect for a prestigious former Auror (one that had similar views on prosecuting death eaters). Show up set off the bins and tell him "We have a complaint that you used X spell, and we need to clear it up, I want to keep this off the books out of respect, so if you'll let me cast Priori Incantatum, we won't have to have an official inquiry board." Moody knowing the way the Ministry works would likely hand his wand over for the couple of minutes the spell would take, rather than deal with the red tape. Then stun a wandless Moody, polymorph into him, and Imperius him while he's unconscious and can't resist. Faster and safer than actually fighting him before the. Muggle police show up. Not in the books that way, but my head canon for how he did it, and why him.
+Darkamora Moody would be way too suspicious for that to work.
can we just stop ridiculing pedigrew? I know he a bad guy, but can someone please just remember that the thing that sirius appearantly did which landed him in askaban for a long while was actually pedigrews doing, while overpowering sirius?
I swear these theories allow me to sleep at night. xD And again, something that has been bugging me for so long and then BAM explained. Thank you.
Another great theory. This is why I subscribed. Seamus Gordan made a similar, yet different theory a few days ago.
I don't know which one I believe more. They are two great and well thought out theories.
Sebastien-Loik Ntsangou-Kanda +Seamus Gorman
The HAMS Sandwich glad to know i wasnt the only one who noticed the similarities.
Sebastien-Loik Ntsangou-Kanda This wasn't the first video I've noticed that seems similar to one of Seamus' earlier ones...
I also saw Seamus's video which is why I thought I watched this one already. I don't agree with this theory. I don't think Voldemort would use Peter as a spy. It always seemed like Voldemort didn't really trust Peter, so why would he trust him to spy for him? In GoF (book Chapter 33, page 649) Voldemort says to Peter, "You returned to me, not out of loyalty, but out of fear of your old friends..." Also Peter would have to constantly take the Polyjuice Potion and would have to have a supply or make the potion when he ran out. That would be hard to hide from the Dursleys and Hermione (who is experienced with making the potion), Ron, Snape and Dumbledore. Snape knew when ingredients were being stolen from his store in GoF so he would notice again. Also it's hard to believe that Voldemort would just send a spy in for one hour, hence the constant making of Polyjuice. I personally, don't think he wanted anyone to return back that night, including any form of Harry.
Please a) do a collab with Seamus Gorman
b) do a Bolt theory
Or......... y'know.......... both in the same video?
Shaylee O'Loughlin yessssss a bolt theory yessss
Shaylee O'Loughlin Yes,Colab
why would you want a bolt theory? its pretty much the bottom of the barrel when it comes to modern era disney movies.
TheMike0088 They could do a theory on who Penny's father is. Besides, it is tremendously underrated and deserves more attention
Shaylee O'Loughlin
Agree
not to mention mad eye's motto is
*CONSTANT VIGILANCE!!!!*
I would pay GOOD MONEY to see an anime battle of Peter Pettigrew vs Crookshanks!
Y'know how BC taught them about the Unforgivable Curses, and taught Harry how to resist Imperio? Maybe he knew Voldemort would use the spell. Maybe he knew Harry would come back. Maybe he wanted to kill Harry to show his loyalty?
For a polyjuice potion to work, the person you're trying to imitate has to be alive at the time of extracting their hair, correct? Surely this theory doesn't work for this reason...
UniqueImpact needs to be fresh and because he just died it would work
Or voldemort doesn't kill harry, but 8ncapacitates him and keeps him as a trapped, maybe even comatose source of polyjuice, which could really freak out lots of people, if he played it right for terror purposes.
I was wondering the same thing. They could have taken hair before they killed Harry, but Wormtail couldn't have imitated him for long maybe a day or so tops, depending on how long hair stays "fresh" after you pluck it. But even if Peter picked a whole handful of Harry hair, the ruse wouldn't have worked for long...
BUT
The Killing Curse doesn't leave any mark on its victims, right? So Voldy could have killed Harry, let Nagini have a few bites (which, I'll admit is not how snakes like to eat their food, but she would probably be willing to make an exception for her master, she seems to take orders from him that go against how a snake would normally act anyway) and then plop his dead body down on top of the portkey and poof, dead Harry shows up at the entrance of the maze looking like he just happened to fall on the cup after being brutally mauled by some horrible beast or another, which the maze had in no short supply. (Because it's a fun sporting event for children!) Deaths have happened before during the Tourniment, so it wouldn't have been looked into too closely.
And we're back to the Marauders' Map. I guess "Harry" just wouldn't use it. Peter's time would be limited anyway since corpses don't grow more hair.
i'd say that the throphy was programmed indeed to teleport the winner back to the spectators, but that when the graveyard was added it got priority and pushed the original teleport back, so that it would first go to the graveyard and then after on the second touch would do its original teleport to the spectators. would make much more sense. that you don't overwrite the teleport but just delay the old one for the newer added one
New theory: Why does Ben always where that hat?!?!?!
A better question than theory, but it would make a pretty funny video!
*wear
Jax Kitten DARN IT! I DID IT AGAIN!
He's hiding Voldemort on the back of his head
😲😲😲OMG!
The tricky part about this (or at least, the one that comes to mind) is that Harry shares his sleeping quarters with other people who might notice that he's either getting up to drink more potion every hour or that when he wakes up in the morning he stays hidden and has to transform back into Harry.
So, you’re telling me that Voldemort can’t just magically create an AK-47 or rob one from the muggle world and kill Harry. Bulletus Removus From Abdomenus?
Gunshotwound reparo!
I think Voldemort would view such a 'muggle weapon' as a gun to be beneath him and that's why he wants to use magic instead. Because in some twisted logic, it would mean that magicals are superior to muggles.
Or just hire a muggle world hitman to snipe him.
@@robertharris6092 Harry Potter and the hitman: a run against Death
I think the real answer is much simpler:
The Cup was supposed to teleport the winner infront of the audience. It was probably one of the teachers who enchanted it in the first place. Enchanting a port key probably doesn't require touching it, so Crouch just enchanted it to take the first one to Voldemort. Because he enchanted it after the first enchantment his took the priority, thus it took Harry and Cedric to Voldemort and then back to Hogwarts.
My thoughts exactly
In Order of The Phoenix Dumbledore creates a Portkey by saying Portus. *Ya I think this the only time we hear somebody say that.*
Why not just make a portkey out of Harry's breakfast waffles?
EDIT: I got this joke from CinemaSins go watch them 😝
Kasha 2 because it doesn't work like that.........
Greatest. Idea. Ever. 😱
Kasha 2 lol
TheBlueBaron yeah you're right I'll give credit to them
way too obvious. The reason Barty put it in the maze is because it would've been extremely well disguised. Harry is transported to somehwrre without anyone knowing, he is then killed and no one knows where or how. Voldemort is back, and no one knows, etc.
"A weird infant slug thing" hahaha
I always thought that voldy came back in secret because his plan didn't work. Once he killed Harry (and fed him to Nagini, yum yum) Voldy would have taken his Death Eaters and led an assault on Hogwarts. He would have had Dumbledore and Fudge dead, destroying the 3 people who were a danger to him most the first night he returned, and immediately sending the magical world into a panic and frenzy.
Yes. In a parallel universe, 'Harry Potter And The Order Of The Phoenix' is called 'Voldemort Conquers The World'.
Never underestimate the power of surprise! More battles/wars have been decided upon that random factor than anything else in history.
Haha. He suhucks at planning. ~ Ben 2017
Nah. Sounds too unrealistic to me. Voldemort would never allow Wormtail to leave him. He is too weak minded to fool anyone (except Harrys parents).
I would say it is way easier than that. Dumbeldore made the Portkey and making sure that it will work and not be blocked by Hogwarts security spells.
They simply could not break Dumbeldores Key and just put a new one in its place. The only thing they could do was to reprogram it a bit.
I
Well it seems to me that Voldemort would have just been using Wormtail as a pawn.I can't believe that Voldemort would care if he died or not. he doesn't really have to be that great of an actor, he just needs to fool Ron, Hermione, Dumbledore etc. Although, we do know that is *is* a good actor: he fooled Lily and James, like you said, and he pretended to be a dead man and a rat for 13 years.
I think maybe the sniveling movie portrayal of Wormtail is fooling you a little. The Wormtail in the books was pretty gifted. If he hadn't been, he certainly wouldn't have become an animagus or got to hang out with the rest of the Marauders. And yeah, he'd fooled people many times before.
"Dumbledore made the Portkey and making sure that it will work and not be blocked by Hogwarts security spells"
Perhaps... Maybe Dumbledore intended the cup to bring the winner back out in front of the audience for the final announcement of the winner. Even if that was his intention, why would someone have to "break Dumbledore's key"? Just replace it with a fake cup that ports the winner to the graveyard and back to the audience again. That way, a polyjuice version of Harry can be sent back for the announcement of the winner, and perhaps no one would suspect a thing.
Or in the time that it takes people to notice the fake Harry, through all the commotion of the Tri-Wizard celebration, all the Death Eaters, Voldemort, Dementors, etc., are raining down on Hogwarts for a huge battle.... but it didn't happen because the real Harry returned.
I have been wondering why Voldemort had to capture Harry through the cup for a while. It would have been much more convenient to do it sooner.
This makes much more sense. Thanks!
Great theory. I've mused before over why the portkey had to be the cup at all? Harry was alone with Barty Crouch Jr. enough times that year that he could have asked Harry to pick up any inconspicuous object that would transport him to Voldemort. When he had Harry in his office discussing a strategy for the first task for example, or just after any lesson. "Hey, Potter. Can you hand me that book please?"
A possible answer is that portkeys are like apparitions, they don't normally work around Hogwarts. Unless of course you're Dumbledore who at the end of Order of the Phoenix created the only portkey that's ever seen taking someone to Hogwarts. Remember it had to be Dumbledore who lifted the anti-apparition enchantment in the Half Blood Prince so that they could practice it in the Great Hall. This might explain why Draco Malfoy went nuts in the Half Blood Prince attempting to repair the vanishing cabinet to get Death Eaters in, instead of just researching how to make portkeys.
Dumbledore might have enchanted the cup to be an exception to the rule so that the winner could be taken out of the maze and all Barty Crouch Jr. had to do was change its destination. It's a long shot but potentially explains why it could only have been the cup.
10th Doctor Crouch Jr should have just made Harry's broom into the portkey or some everyday object of Harry's that he would have touched... like seriously Voldemort
But yeah, it would make sense for Sir Noseless to send Ratman back as Harry after he was killed
I enjoy coming up with weird names....
I also thought about that, but would that have worked within the Hogwarts grounds though? Remember, there are all sorts of protective enchantments preventing apparition etc.
When Dumbledore and Harry are flying on broomsticks from Hogsmeade, Dumbledore actually has to undo some of the enchantments, or at least create an exception in them, while flying towards the castle so they could get in.
I took it that Dumbledore would have to have made a specific exception for the Triwzard Cup to allow it to function as a portkey and that Barty Crouch Jr, impersonating Mad Eye and being privy to such info, took advantage of that.
That would have aroused more suspicion if he just up and disappeared.
John Marston oh yeah, i forgot about the protective enchantments
There is a principle that says, the must simple xplanation tends to be the right one.
First the cup being a portkey was something planed as part of the tournament, simple fact no hidden intention no xtra toughs
Second, simple enought the portkey enchantment was overrided so instead of taking the first one to touch it to the entrance of the maze take the person to the cementery BUUUUT as soon as that spell was consumed, the original one will prevail letting the cup to be used again as portkey.
Third, the only way for harry to scape the cementery was using the portkey, but how does he know that it will work (sorry i dont remember if is told in the book or the ghost from his parents told him sorry sorry)
Fourth, and maybe must important, in the case that voldemort planned all this double use of the portkey to return and being seing , is because and only because HE WANTED TO SHOW THAT HE OVERCOME HARRY!!!!, so that will demoralize all the wizard world since they no longer have the boy who live to stand, showing voldemort as the stronger one etc etc, buuuuut again, since the plan didnt went trough he needed to stay hiden until he gets harry, didnt you realize that he start to act hiden because of this, and he only kinda reveal him self in the battle of howarts because he was only a that moment 100% sure that he will be able to defeat harry (having the elder wand) hope you read this and give me my opinion because to be honest i think that the first and secon reason things i say are the must logical ones, a spell over the spell of the portkey, and voldemort didint even want to comeback to howarts he only wanted to kil harry , thats all
m2mbestfan
"The simplest explanation must be correct..."
Occam's Razor.
m2mbestfan When I walk outside the land appears flat so the earth must be flat
This is seriously the best Harry Potter theory channel on TH-cam! ⚡️
1) Barty Jr was only on Azkaban 1 year. His mom took his place and died. So he had been a prisoner of his father for 13-14 years
2) Voldemort’s plan was to make his death look like an accident. It was stated. Then returned to Hogwarts.
3) the cup was always set up as a port key to help determine the winner.
4) the side track to the graveyard was the addition made by Barty jr
Make a video of "Complaints that you had of the Harry Potter movies"
No cause you the person you want to be have to be alive or else the polyjuice won't work
linhai huo Im not sure that is true, Barty jr. kept madeye alive so he could harvest hair for his potion, not because he needed him alive to use it.
This is fantastic! Thanks for clearing this weird point up!
Do a what if Lockhart obliviated Harry, Ron, Hermione
Has anyone talked to JK Rowling about the constantly-brought-up problems with spectating the Triwizard Tournament?
The organizer is a former beater known for having taken one too many bludgers to the head.
I'd actually prefer Volemort to plan my wedding.
you may now kiss the bride*giant snake jumps out kills and eats the groom*
That's such a great explanation of voldemort's plan 😍😍😍 great job!
Your videos are awesome !
SERIOUS QUESTION: please try find out who was the top scarer at monsters incorporated. i've always wanted to know.
Justice for the Blast-ended Skroots
Blast-Ended Skrewts
I'd say the wormtail replacement is the most logical. As an intj it makes the most sense.
Worm would of had ample time to become familiar with Harry's ego and idiosyncrasies. / as to reprise him.
I always thought that through some magical rule-breaking, the echo of Harry's parents were able to influence the cup. Partly because it's James who tells him to use the cup as a portkey to return to school.
But the person has to still be alive for the potion to work! That's why Moody was in the suitcase!
The person doesn't necessarily have to be alive. You just need their hair as an ingredient. Barty Crouch Jr. kept Moody alive so he could interrogate him in order to better impersonate him. Keeping the person alive would allow you to use the potion for a longer period of time since the person's hair would keep growing, you would continually have a supply of it. If you kill them and take all the hair they currently have to use one at a time the number of times you can use the potion is limited by the number of hairs you took from them.
Because you happened to mention that Barty Jr. Hadn't been able to use magic in some 15 years, it makes me wonder. How was he not an obscurial? How does Azkaban prevent its prisoners from becoming obscurials? They're obviously not using their powers in prison, so...
1. Obscurials only happen with kids
2. They're created when someone actively tries to suppress their powers. In Azkaban (and I'm assuming under the imperious curse as well) he couldn't have used them even if he tried
It actually says in the book that being with dementors long enough drains a wizard of his(her) powers. Plus whats said above
Ian McDonough Obscurials were invented in the Fantastic Beasts guide. The idea didn't even exist when she was writing the HP series.
+BB Bailey Didn't it? Dumbledore's sister Ariana is very clearly an obscurial, even if they didn't use that word. And I just finished rereading the 7th book today, so I think I know what I'm talking about.
Obscurials are created when kids themselves try to suppress their powers (ex: Ariana Dumbledore) while dementors can actually weaken wizards' powers and the criminals aren't the ones repressing their own powers.
I always just assumed that the Cup was always meant to be a Portkey, and the judges never bothered to tell the champions.
When Barty Crouch jr. enchanted the cup into taking Harry to the graveyard, he simply put another spell on top of the one already on the cup. So when Harry was transported to the graveyard, the spell Crouch jr. put on the cup was already used up, only leaving the original spell Dumbledore and the judges put on it, the spell that would take Harry back to the stadium.
As for the polyjuice potion part, yeah I do agree with you on that. That, or, Voldemort was just too swept up in the glory of his return to really think straight (though he usually seems to be one step ahead, so probably not).
Your Tri-Wizard cup looks cool man, I love it
voldomort cannot have used harrys hair if he was dead proof is why did barty crouch jr keep mad eye moody alive
@@invivoik It's stated in the book that it doesn't work if the person you change into is dead.
Do an updated Pixar Theory!!!!
I knew you had already done this video! 😂 Recycling is important 👌
I think Barty Crouch helped Harry more to keep him alive than to help him win the first two events.
I just figured they'd have Harry's body touch the Cup and get teleported before the whole crowd as a display of power. "The one person who could ever kill me is dead. Get rekt, Dumbledore."
While I like this theory I don't believe it. The fact that Voldemort is so shocked when Harry disappears make me think that he didn't know it was a two way port key. I believe Seamus Gorman and the Bakeey's theory that Barty Crouch Jr. wanted to kill Harry himself. If Voldemort had known that the cup was a two way port key he would not have been shocked, but would have been furious. He also likely would have moved the cup rather than leaving it where it was, where Harry had easy access to it. This theory in my opinion fits better. Watch Seamus's video for a full explanation - th-cam.com/video/JV8fyoMsT1o/w-d-xo.htmlm2s Still love you guys, even if i don't believe this particular theory!
I actually like this theory a bit better than Seamus's theory. Going off his reaction in the movies I have to agree with you though. I will have to reread that part in the book though to make my final determination as to which I think fits better. (Also I went scrolling through the comments to see if anyone mentioned Seamus's theory. Glad I found someone who has seen it too.)
RaeBriar I agree with you on the book. I haven't read them recently enough to remember his reaction. I did the same thing, and didn't see any about Seamus so I commented 😂
Well my books are sadly packed away at the moment so if you check it out let me know how he reacted :)
RaeBriar okay, I'll let you know as soon as I check
Fantastic theory. I definitely agree with your theory.👏
Filch dancing with his cat at the Yule ball is the embodiment of my life
harry would have to be kept alive to make the Polyjuice Potion. if Harry is killed and Pettigrew returns as Harry he would only be mr Potter for an hour. so he would definitely have to have him stored somewhere just as alastor Moody was. at this moment I'm trying to get inside of Voldemort's head and figure out why would he draw out such a complicated plan, at the end of the day it's still a conundrum to me.
Yes, this plan was very complicated but in my eyes actually the best way to get Harry out of the school and into Voldemorts hands without anybody noticing. If Harry would just vanish, people would notice but in the maze, nobody sees him anyway and it is so dangerous that even if something goes wrong, Voldemort could send Harrys body back after a little preperation and make it look as if he was killed in the maze. After all, everybody knows that the Triwizard tournament is dangerous.
I believe Dumbledore programmed the tri-wizard cup to return the first contestant who touched it to the entrance of the maze. Then Moody/Crouch offered to put the cup in the center of the maze and programmed it to send the first to touch the cup to the graveyard, but was unable to remove the previous enchantment, rendering it a two way portkey.
you, my friend, are simply GENIUS.
Ben and J, you are the BEST!!
Voldemort***
Plainish White Haha Volemort
Plainish White nobody cares nerd
Plainish White He fixed it...
I kind of came up with a Fantastic Beasts theory that I think is right up your guys' alley to address. It is as follows (originally sent as texts to my friends):
"Okay, am I the only one who thought Grindlewald's comment to Newt at the end - "Will we die, just a little?" - was out of the blue and didn't really make sense? (Theories of Horcruxes - nonsensical, of course for many reasons, most involving Dumbledore - notwithstanding.) As far as I'm aware, it's not a quote from anything nor does it have any meaning within the known Potter-verse (I say known for a reason, we'll get to it in a sec). So why put it in (aside from having to give Johnny Depp lines)? Why would Grindlewald say it all and specifically to Newt? I have a couple of theories/evidences that could help explain this. So, we know that Newt travels a lot saving magical creatures. We know that he was a favorite of Dumbledore's when he was in school. His older brother fought in World War I while he was off doing something with some dragons. The ministry of magic is not particularly fond of him, despite them being the ones who commissioned his book. He still has his wand despite being kicked out of Hogwarts. He has met, from the sound of it, multiple Obscurials aside from Credence and has been working to find a cure. Now, we know that Grindlewald has a strong connection to Dumbledore, and while we know the two of them fell out of touch, we don't know how out of touch. Since his teenage years with Dumbledore, Grindlewald has undoubtedly been traveling around the world too. His quest is first and foremost to find the Deathly Hallows (which he has one of already at this point since he stole it from Gregorovitch - this happens to be THE MOST POWERFUL WAND TO EVER HAVE EXISTED). But he's also on a quest for Wizard supremacy over muggles. This, in his mind, entails revealing the Wizarding community to muggles and then lead some kind of take-over. He almost certainly had some role in World War I trying to wreak havoc on the muggles (there's probably a Wonder Woman tie in there but that's a different discussion). His revealing of the magical community could probably be brought about by magical beasts - he may have been actively seeking them out at one point. His quest definitely led him to think of Obscurials as a way to reveal wizards (an idea that almost definitely came to him because of Ariana Dumbledore). He gradually grew until he was a huge threat to the ENTIRE WORLD of Wizards and constantly evaded capture (the newspapers at the beginning of the movie). And there's definitely a lot more to be revealed in the upcoming movies, which is where we come to the theory part and the reason I said the KNOWN Potter-verse earlier. What do all these little pieces of information that we've gathered mean? Well, Newt and Grindlewald were both traveling the world and were probably in a lot of the same places considering that they may have been looking for very similar things, albeit for very, very different reasons. Thusly, how hard is it to believe that they came face to face at some point in the past? There are a ridiculous amount of connections between the two and the odds of them NOT meeting at some point are considerably lower than the odds of them bumping into each other. Who's to say exactly what may have happened in this encounter - I don't think Newt is quite powerful enough to stop Grindlewald, especially if he's carrying the Elder Wand - but I think it could explain a few things. Newt seems very knowledgeable about Grindlewald's methods (interrogation scene) and Graves (Grindlewald) knows a lot about Newt (I mean, yeah, files and stuff, but how much info does MACUSA have on hand about a BRITISH wizard?) and he's very quick to sentence him to death - and yeah, that might be because Newt seemed to figure out his secret ID, but how would he figure it out so quick, and how would Grindlewald know that Newt knew and deem him a big enough liability that he needs to die? - as if he knows that Newt could cause problems. Basically, the entire interrogation scene makes a tad bit more sense with the perspective that they may have met. Which in turn lends some extra context for... well basically everything else in the movie, creating that much more depth to the story. And then there's what we started with: "Will we die, just a little?" It's not only the line that makes this theory seem likely, it's Newt's reaction. Or lack thereof. He doesn't seem confused or shocked or anything really. And while Newt isn't one to show a whole bunch of emotion, you'd think an out of context line like that would at least make him frown, right? Instead he just kind of nods like he's pondering the question. But it's not just that. It's like he's heard the words before and has more to think about in regard to them (like when you get a question at the beginning of class and then again at the end). I think that Grindlewald's words have a deeper meaning than we as the audience are led to believe, especially when spoken to Newt. To me, it seems like Newt had a run-in with Grindlewald sometime in the past that may have changed his life/behaviors/beliefs/world view (this may also tie in to Lita Lestrange and his relationship with her - or lack thereof in the movie). Sometime in that meeting, Grindlewald said something to Newt that included this question and context to go with it. And that will be explained in the future movies. That also would explain why this movie series about Newt is going to so heavily rely on Grindlewald's reign. Or why the timeline of Grindlewald's reign of power includes Newt so much. There's more of a connection between the two characters than we've been led to believe."
bit too long..
That was a lot to read but yh I guess its likely
Lissy From the Stars small note: Newt served in WWI as a dragon handler.
You should probably stop writing things this long. This is TH-cam. No one has the attention span longer than 4 seconds
Agree with the others, too long, and the only fresh (well, kinda) idea you really offered is that Newt and Grindewald MAY have met before. Oh, and that the line will likely be explained in future movies, which you really just plagiarized from Captain Obvious. Talk about over explaining.
The cup was already a portkey to the arena , crouch only added the one to the cemetary
Amazing theory guys!!
CONGRATS ON TRENDING :D
I like that you guys are using your noggin', and I enjoy most of your speculation videos, but this is a bad theory.
It's not exactly spelled out in the book, but we do have enough information to piece together what actually happened. See, Dumbledore was the one who enchanted the Triwizard Cup to be a portkey, the purpose being to transport the champion back to the rest of the school once they won.
The night before the final task took place, Barty Crouch offered to take the Cup into the maze. Crouch Jr. could not remove Dumbledore's existing portkey enchantment, but he COULD redirect it. He added a destination between the starting and leaving points, but Dumbledore's original destination was still on it. Thus when Harry touched the Cup a second time, it brought him back to Hogwarts.
Remember, they make it very clear that the ENTIRE POINT of waiting to kidnap Harry was so that Voldemort could return in secret. They wanted to make Harry's death look like an accident, like he got eaten by a skrewt or something. Sure they wouldn't find Harry's body, but nobody other than Dumbledore would suspect that Voldemort returned, and Dumbledore would've had a hell of a time trying to prove it.
qwertyo76 this is what I thought was going on. You can't beat Dumbledore's magic!
This makes a lot more sense.
My biggest problem with their theory is that voldie never actually trusted wormtail; Wormtail was just afraid of voldemort and the friends he betrayed, he wasn't loyal to voldemort. And he would've never been able to pull off being harry. Yes he knew everything about him, but he is nothing like harry. Wormtail was a coward and anybody who knew harry would've figured the whole thing out. And then dumbledore could've questioned him and gotten so much more information than if Harry just hadn't shown up.
Besides, if nagini did eat harry how would wormtail have been able to keep looking like harry all that time voldemort needed to secretly come back. Was the plan to be harry for as long as he had the polyjuicepotion and then disappear or something? Doesn't sound very likely to me.
qwertyo76 This totally makes sense, I like this theory
Voldemort was going to send back the body! I remember Dumbledore or someone talking to Harry about it after the 4th book and I've spent the last hour looking for it. 😂😝
But it's Wormtail and Barty that take out Moody. That part is described in the 'Veritaserm' chapter.
I remember it because I had the most awkward image in my head of Voldemort saying, "if it wasn't for those meddling kids..." Because it explained how Dumbledore thought Voldemort wanted it to look like an accident.
But that still doesn"t explain why did Voldemort want to do the whole triwizard tournament thing. why didn't he just tell Crouch to make a book portal and tell Harry to hold it for a little? It would work just the same. Except if...wait. Except if you usually can't use a portal in Hogwarts, and they only changed that in the maze so that the more thrilling win would work. Hm.
As someone said, it's probable only the headmaster of hogwarts is capable of doing that.
I honestly never thought about it before until watching this video but i must say this is a very well thought out theory and if true it would have made it alot more interesting to know of voldemorts original intent before harry escaped
The fourth book was best.
The fourth film was worst.
This is somethin I needed to get off my chest.
Nerdiology the third book is my favorite and probably my favorite film as well
Nerdiology if you read the books and expected it to be exactly like them
SealerHD The third film is when Dumbledore got switched to a shitty actor with no accent as well as the year directors changed, on top of that the kids were sporting Old Navy clothing for fucks sake when they were supposed to be in robes. The third film was when they stopped caring about matching the books.
Awwww you made a rhyme! I liked the third book the best. Also A Very Potter Musical/Sequel does a much better job at portraying the characters in the books than the movies do.
BB Baily I thought both Dumbledores sucked. They should have gotten the guy who played Gandolf, since he even had wizarding experience. Instead of yelling about the "GOBLET OF FIYAH!!!!!" he would say, "Is it secret? Is it sa,.... I mean, did you put your name in the goblet of fire?"
Barty Crouch Jr. could have simply made anything a portkey and made Harry touch it while he was feigning to be Moody.
Why go through all that trouble?
Hogwarts has protection against Portkeys. The Triwizard Cup is an exception, which is why it bypasses that restriction
The voices don't change in the movie, because then it's easier for the viewers to keep track of who is who
These videos got me through days in the hospital
Speaking of the goblet of fire:
"HARRYPOTTERDIDYOUPUTYOURNAMEINTHEGOBLETOFFFIRE???" Dumbledore said -calmly-
Just use that truth potion stuff to find out...
Is volemort some kinda disease for voles?
The person needs to be alive for anther person to make and use the polyjuice potion effectively that's why mad eye Moody was kept alive in the trunk
Aw poor Nagini must’ve been so disappointed. She was so hungry. At least she got a full tummy in the end.
At 4:40 I was thinking: I gotta get back to Hogwarts, I gotta get back to school!🎶
I gotta get back to Hogwarts, Where everyone knows im cool!