ไม่สามารถเล่นวิดีโอนี้
ขออภัยในความไม่สะดวก
Harry Potter Theory: Hufflepuff's Cup And Slytherin's Locket (ft. Seamus Gorman)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 ส.ค. 2024
- Seamus Gorman - / @seamusgorman4
Today J and Seamus dive into the Wizarding World of Harry Potter to discuss one of the few mysteries that unite Hufflepuffs and Slytherins: What are the hidden powers of Hufflepuff’s Cup and Slytherin’s Locket?
Hey Super Carlin Friends! ►► bit.ly/196DDlu
Google Autofill Playlist ►► bit.ly/1DCdQNm
Theories ►► bit.ly/1z5uZcS
Super Carlin Gaming ►► bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
BECOME A SUPER CARLIN FRIEND➜ / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
FOLLOW US:
I N S T A G R A M➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
F A C E B O O K➜ / supercarlinbrothers
G A M I N G ➜ bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
P A T R E O N ➜ / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Want to send us something?
Super Carlin Brothers
PO Box 4339
Roanoke, Virginia 24015
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Business Inquiries Only: carlinbrosrtp@gmail.com
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Every time you give us a thumbs up a Narwhal gets its horn! (maybe..)
Ravenclaw: Increased intelligence
Gryffindor: A magic sword to defend ones self
Slytherin: Information on a secret chamber
My house (Hufflepuff): WINE, BABY
Emily Wilkinson 😂😂😂
Best house! Hell yeah :D
#Hufflepride
Wait, so the only power of the Cup is to turn vinegar into wine? That doesn't sound like much at all....I mean, not that I'm complaining about wine lol but I expected more.
she had to deal with the other founders somehow.
If Neville was in Hufflepuff? Poor imaginary Neville. He’s gonna be smelling like vinegar 24/7
I agree! sorry neville
Oh wow.
So true.
honestly, I don't think so the way of getting into the Hufflepuffff commen room is a lot easier to remember.
@@rochelleahsolow2405 yes, but this is still neville.
Lol.
Omg.
Wow.
So true.
I like how all of the other houses have something like answering a question or the barrel thing and then for Gryffindor it's just like "remember the password"
And *some* people need a note for it.
Naw Slytherin has a password too.
Slytherin too
I’d say that’s up to the head of house. Mcgonnagal decides how gryffindors are to get into their common room, snape decides how Slytherins get into the slytherin common room, etc. just realized we don’t know who the heads of the other houses are. Or do we? I don’t.
Smo Cloud we do, professor sprout is the head of hufflepuff and professor flitwick is the head of ravenclaw. I think their common room entry methods are probably fixed already though, since the painting by the kitchen sounds like it’s been there for a pretty long time, at least before sprout
I headcanon that when Cedric "joined" the Death Eaters in Cursed Child, he was actually put under the Imperious Curse. It fits with Cedric's character better.
I’m so shook with how quite Seamus stayed while J was talking 😄 👏🏻
TheBakeey love you ❤️
TheBakeey yeah I was expecting him to talk
@TheBakeey It's your turn now to get to SCB !
TheBakeey I Love seamus
TheBakeey a man will do crazy things for love. I ship it.
When you didn’t fully read the title and got startled when Seamus came into the frame
kiwigirl48 it suddenly made so much sense with the Hufflepuff scarf in the background
kiwigirl48 me too lol. I was pretty stoked.
kiwigirl48
Same
Same 😂
8:33 Not to forget, Umbridge was a Slytherin too. Maybe the locket's knowledge isn't for heirs necessarily but for all Slytherins, like only Gryffindors can get the sword.
Every time the sword magically appears in the books it's to kill a snake. First time is when Harry use it to kill the Basilisk. Second time Harry and Ron use it to destroy the locket which has a picture of a snake on it (that was a bit of a stretch but it works in the pattern when you consider the third time it magically appears). The third time of course being whenever we use it to kill nagini
It doesn't "magically appear" in the frozen pond, Snape puts it there on Dumbledore's portrait's instructions.
i think it denotes the rivalry between gryffindor and slytherin (just my opinion)
Am I allowed to turn this into a theory and publish on WattPad? Please reply quick. @AlecSmith
@@iamsabz364 1 year later, no response.
It’s just a normal biblical reference to the symbolism of the snake...
When seamus turned, i swear to GOD, i was like "ooooohhhhh plot twist"
Right? Can`t remember the last time I got so surprised in a video.
BTW, I just made a video sinning the CinemaSins video on "Harry Potter and the Sorcerer`s stone", check it out if interested. I do not usually self promote but Its related and I spent a lot of time on it so...
He looked like he was going to pass out he was so happy awww
Jay: "Glad you were able to uh... find your way here..."
Seamus: "Well yes, us Hufflepuffs are particularly good finders!"
Jay: "Yeah, its... well it's no fun if you don't know I'm making fun of you... guh, never mind..." :(
The quintessential Slitherin-Hufflepuff interaction! XD
Redcole111 😂😂😂😂
it really is ahahaha
Lol Did you see at 3:12 when J was mouthing Seamuses words😂😂
I thought some of his words sounded a little rehearsed
He probably remembering his lines or reading them
I mean this video irt was far too obvious they were just reading from cue cards or an auto-cue. Since they'd rarely actually be looking at eachother when talking, like you would if you were having this kind of conversation or discussion naturally. It's like the script was written in a way so that it's like they are talking to eachother, but then they talk to the camera far more often.
he pulled an Emma Watson
HELGA HUFFLEPUFF WAS A DAUGHTER OF DIONYSUS CHANGE MY MIND
....that MAKES TOO MUCH SENSE
But... Then does Percy Jackson also exist too?? Or is there another demigod community?
What is wrong with me...🤦♀️
OR MAYBE EVERYONE FROM THE WIZIDING WORLD ARE ATCHUALLY DESENDENTS OF HECATE!!!!!!!!!!
lol
oOooOOoooOOOOO
I think the locket made umbridge more powerful because she was so ambitious, which is a key characteristic of Slytherin. The locket recognised her ruthless ambition and empowered her magic to help her achieve her goal.
Hufflepuff's goblet MAY also be used to scry. Hufflepuffs are good at finding things and if you stare into swirling liquid and concentrate on some thing/one/place you can (supposedly) see that thing/person/place in the water. This can tell you nothing or everything if you are paying attention. Like what is nearby, what is going on, if it is damaged, if it is protected, etc... Mind you, just a theory.
Lunestia Crescent A Harry Potter theory, thanks for watching!
Lunestia Crescent Oops wrong channel.
Well yeah, except Hufflepuffs being good finders isn't canon.
Um, Hufflepuffs being good finders isn't canon. It's a continuous joke made in the Very Potter Musical series made by StarKid (go watch it is really good)
Lunestia Crescent when I hear the word scry I think about Charmed, lol
Where are my hufflepuffs at
Here
It's sad this only got 13 likes ;-;
Or maybe we got a ton closet Puffs that need the hugs and affection to show who they are
Halla
Hi 👋
I'm half hufflepuff half Ravenclaw my first test Hufflepuff then after that I got Ravenclaw but was so close to getting Hufflepuff so I would consider myself in Hufflepuff
A Hufflepuff with a theory here! (Too many comments to read through over here so if this exists as a theory sorry to waste your time)
While I find this theory interesting I have another one. In my head the four magical artifacts work only for the people who exhibit truly the values of the four houses.
The Gryffindor sword is bestowed only to those who would be brave before anything else, even if bravery would not be the best option in a situation. So for a Ravenclaw, the sword would not work because they would be thinking of the smartest way to avoid a bad situation which is in some cases not fighting but reaching truce through diplomacy, for a Hufflepuff the sword would not work because playing fair is more important for them than having an unfair advantage like a magical sword and for a Slytherin the sword wouldn't work because they would be of course thinking of the best way to get themselves and their loved ones undamaged by cunning manipulation and not with fighting. But for a Gryffindor the only proper way to enter battle or conflict would be armed only with a sword and their bravery.
The Ravenclaw diadem works for me in the same way - if a Ravenclaw that values intelligence puts it on, it would enhance their natural ability to think logically and arrive at the best solution to a problem. If a Gryffindor puts on the diadem, it would not help them to think logically because their natural inclination is to do the brave thing rather than the smart thing. For a Hufflepuff the diadem might not work because they would prefer to be loyal rather than be smart (like how Hufflepuffs stayed in the Battle of Hogwarts because they were loyal to the school but the smart thing might have been to keep yourself safe and out of the battle) Lastly, if a Slytherin put on the diadem it wouldn't work because they would not be thinking of the smartest way, but of the easiest way - good results with little effort, as apposed to the smartest way that is the best result with perhaps more effort (for a Ravenclaw the effort wouldn't matter as much as the result)
Now I know that these are situations where some characteristics may overlap - the loyal thing to do would be to be brave, the smart thing would be to use your resourcefulness and find an easy way out, the brave thing would be the smartest thing, etc. but this only shows that we are a bit of every house. I am just illustrating my thought process. So if it is assumed that each of the artifacts reveals its power only to the people that embody their house values the most , it would stand to reason that they are some sort of test - they would only work when a Gryffindor is a real Gryffindor, a Ravenclaw is a real Ravenclaw, a Hufflepuff is a real Hufflepuff and a Slytherin is a real Slytherin. "Real" in this case used to describe someone who lives the values of their house as opposed to someone who thinks the values are cool but do not show them (Pettigrew being a coward, Lockhart being less than smart, Snape being loyal and brave)
For Slytherin's locket I think it is similar to the diadem - it would work in tandem with the persons natural resourcefulness and would enhance their ability to calculate how to get the result you want in the easiest way. Let's say the locket works like that and a Gryffindor puts it on - nothing happens because being brave would be more important to them than getting a good result. A Hufflepuff puts it on - nothing happens because they are thinking of what is the most balanced way and they are not looking for an advantage over their opponent. A Ravenclaw puts it on - nothing happens because they are thinking of the smartest way and not the easy way. Also, I think on top of helping Slytherin's with their cunning nature the locket would increase it's power for the Pure blood. Why did the locket affect Ron the most - it was "working" best for him because he was a Pure blood (but it made him angry because the powers of the locket were corrupted by the Horcrux). Now I can't exactly say if the locket had less of an effect on Hermione and Harry but I wouldn't put it past Salazar Slytherin to make the locket work only for those of the purest heritage as that is one of his values.
For Hufflepuff's cup I think it has a vanishing charm on it and it only holds liquid for those who are hard-working,fair and loyal, only for those who have proven themselves that they can work hard all day without reward because hard work does not scare them.The reward for your loyalty and playing by the rules would of course be a cup that you could actually drink from. If you do not display the Hufflepuff qualities the liquid simply vanishes and you need to drag your lazy butt to the kitchen so you can learn the value of hard work. So imagine that a Gryffindor holds the cup - it wouldn't fill because bravery and chivalry is bombastic and exists to be praised and (I think) a Gryffindor would not be happy to work hard all day just because they feel like it but because they would be praised for it. A Ravenclaw would perhaps think of the smartest way to do things while putting in less effort , thus being very efficient but avoiding work. And a Slytherin would never have a sip from the cup because you can be sure if they could cheat without getting caught they would most certainly do it. I get the idea about the vanishing charm from this article www.pottermore.com/writing-by-jk-rowling/cauldrons where JKR played with the idea that Helga Hufflepuff's artifact would be a cauldron somewhat loosely based on a cauldron that only cooks for the brave. So to me it stands to reason that Helga's cup would only hold liquid for people with the qualities that she values and would just vanish the liquid for anyone else.
I also like to imagine that while the four founders were alive they might have used their artifacts on their students to see how much they have progressed in adopting their values so I think that in addition to the item's power being most useful to their students, it would only work for the one who truly believes in the value of their houses.
And this is the longest comment I have ever written. If you reached the end you get a prize - your daily reminder - You are awesome! :)
C0unte55 I love this theory... it’s awesome!! 👏 👏
the sword of gryffindor shows that the items are not simple in their enchantments. the sword is nearly unbreakable, immune to magic, can adapt and change, and presents itself to those who need some muscle to back their courage (usually hilt-first out of gryffindor's hat, naturally). this means that the items don't just represent the primary quality of the house, the sword doesn't just show up to a brave person, it also shows the ability to adapt and grow, is unyielding and nearly unstoppable when used correctly and protects those who require aid.
that means that something like the diadem wouldn't just make the person who wore it smarter. it would grant them wit and wisdom, likely enhanced knowledge and increased ability to learn as well. putting the diadem on doesn't mean you're suddenly albert einstein in his prime, it would mean that your mind would become pliable, your memory would be enhanced, you would be able to visualize problems from new angles, and it would also provide the information you need. the diadem would be a tool to accelerate learning, like how the sword is a tool to defend the innocent.
the qualities of hufflepuff are things like loyalty, generosity, bounty and patience. so, the cup would represent all of these qualities. in all likelihood, anyone can use the cup of hufflepuff, because generosity and bounty means you have enough to share and loyalty means you would want to. however, understanding the nature of the cup would be difficult, it's hard work, something the other houses would shy away from in their own ways, gryffindors would bluster and boast while the ravenclaws and slytherins would try and outsmart an inanimate object. the powers are likely related to summoning and other abilities related to providing and caring for those around you, such as the ability to produce food and drink with no known source through a difficult to master process. the cup can probably be used to defend yourself as well, but it wouldn't be very effective at it because that's not it's primary purpose.
meanwhile, the locket would be on the other end of the spectrum. it's unlikely anyone but a pure blood can even use the thing and even then, only those of slytherin's bloodline would be able to fully access it's powers. it would be related to the elites, secrets, and ambition fueled by cunning. so the locket would provide subtle abilities, boosting the power of a pure blood wearer through unknown means (ambition and cunning, it's not fighting dirty if you don't get caught). with the locket containing secret knowledge that only those of slytherin's bloodline can access, probably along with a plethora of other, subtle abilities, the locket may be the most powerful of the four items, but the cunning thing to do would be to never tell anyone that.
C0unte55 that’s a long ass comment
That was alot of writing ty for putting it in paragraphs
C0unte55 woah this is so cool how you write all of this
Seamus was fanboying on snapchat earlier, I'm so glad he finally got to meet SCB. Amazing theory btw, I'm not this creative or smart
yep seamus was definitely freaking out. he kept looking around in amazement too
As someone who constantly loses their glasses, I can confirm that not ALL Hufflepuffs are good finders. Although I am good at finding other things... I think my glasses have a disappearing charm on them or something. Doesn’t help that I need my glasses to see, you can’t use the things you lose
Classic muggle trap 😂😂
I didn't read the whole title and was so confused why J had a Hufflepuff scarf lying in the background. And then Seamus showed up.
I WAS DEFINITELY NOT EXPECTING SEAMUS TO SHOW UP
me too
Emma Rose its in the title
Me too I was so happy!!
so in the vid they’re saying:
the sword: I CAN KILL YOUR SOUL (I hear a creepy witch voice, idk about you)
diadem: YOU CAN TAKE OVER THE WORLD (~evil cackle~)
goblet: I make vinegar into wine
That sounds very Hufflepuff to me
What makes the cup even special considering that you can do the same thing with a simple spell.
Maybe the wine enhances the drinker's magical abilities or something? idk
Maybe it's whatever you like best to drink? Including blood (for vampires). Somehow it must be more than just horn-of-plenty that is easy spell to do. Or maybe it doesn't do anything. If the cup does things for you, it doesn't encourage hard work. Being able to bring out blood however, would grant more acceptance to vampires. And well, maybe the elves could make some blood sausages or blood pancakes. Just to mention a few.
I like to believe it is for restoration/healing. If you are worthy to drink from the cup it is wine that heals you for both magic and physical.
If not worthy you drink vinegar that does nothing or even worse.
It helps by playing into what hufflepuffs are identified as, loyal. Loyalty, sacrifice, support, can all be connected to healing or restoring. If your best friend is dying or is brain washed, and you get the cup to help them, a selfless and loyal act, then it might see you as worthy and thus allowing for wine instead of vinegar in the cup.
Barty Crouch Jr. Was also a ravenclaw
No
Technically there is no canon statement about what house he is in so he might not be a Ravenclaw.
Seamus, would like to point out that in the Middle Ages, a cup or goblet often represented Service, which is a characteristic/quality of Hufflepuff! Hospitality and welcome is also part of this. Worth noting that Hannah Abbott ends up running the Three Broomsticks. Also, there's a lot of Hufflepuff in in public service.
And one of my granddaughters is a Hufflepuff. She worries that she's not good enough (she was terrified that she would be Slytherin) which I think is kind of sweet, but she is worthy of that noble House. 😊
Her sister is a Gryffindor like me. 😂 Their little cousin Sam looks like he'll be Ravenclaw like his.parents.
Service and hospitality are fine virtues, and to carry the Cup, an honor.
7:03 you know you're a good theorist when you blow seamus' mind
i screamed when seamus showed up
same
I'm a Hufflepuff with an ash wood wand, it has a unicorn hair core. Omg I'm Cedric!
I think it might be the case that Slytherin's locket would empower any and all Slytherins - house members and blood heirs alike - in much the same that Gryffindor's sword will present itself to 'true Gryffindors' - this fits in with the fact that Slytherins tend to favour their own, see how Snape would favour the Slytherin students of the Gryffindors when he taught them both potions. Further, I think that it saps power from any non-Slytherins - when this was shown in the books, I think that this was an innate property of the locket, rather than an enchantment of Voldemort's - it fits in with a Slytherin's typical cunning - weaken your foe and exploit their weaknesses - and the fact that the habit of favouring one's own is sometimes done at the expense of another group - because Snape favoured the Slytherin students, he was far harsher with Gryffindors.
All this works well with what we see of the locket in the books, particularly how it helped some and hindered others. If the strength sapping were something that Voldemort had enchanted upon it, I highly doubt that he'd allow for exceptions - his other Horcruxes were defended in ways that were indiscriminate between his allies and his enemies, such as the ring which I imagine would have killed anyone other than Voldemort himself. And it just so happens that the golden trio, who were harmed by it, were all non-Slytherins, while Umbridge and Merope Gaunt were both Slytherins - either by house or by blood - and they both were empowered by it.
I actually do like that idea you mentioned of Rowling's at the end. honestly, it sounds like a cool method of sorting...
Who else went to check the title after seamus jumped out of nowhere in the video??!
For a second there I though there was a 3rd brother lol
mariel ivana there is...............
he's in a few videos
There is I think his name is Tyler but he’s not part of the channel
Well there is Tyler
yup, there is one but he's not a SUPER carlin brother, just a carlin brother
mariel ivana there is...
Qurill (I know I spelled that wrong) is an evil stain on ravenclaw.
Yes, I am a ravenclaw.
All the houses have their blacksheep, even ours.
And Lockhart too
it sucks being a ravenclaw, because i'm terrible at riddles.
THIS IS Y I HATE DAT DUDE!
ps, same. QUIRRIL U SUK!
lockhards not a dark wizard hes just a fraud
The theory would explain how Ron was able to "lear" parsel-tongue
I'm so excited to see a collaboration between you guys! I'm glad I could finally see a video happen with some of my favorite guys on TH-cam. Thanks for the great video!
Can you try to do a video with them?
Omg you got in in this toooooo!
Another one of my TH-camrs, oh no, am I dead?!!!! Cause there's no other explanation for why I'm in heaven!
Wotso Videos hey wotso videos
Wotso Videos I love your vids
At 3:12 does j start mouthing what seamus is saying? Lol, emma watson much?
I think so
I Don't Have A Name probably on a script,some people do that so they know what they're next line is
I Don't Have A Name well there is a lot to remember so he probably using it to remember his next line (not hating )
They both do it. Really distracting imo
I Don't Have A Name LLOLOLOLO
5:16 Seamus mood: slightly annoyed and shooked
OKAY BUT! Given how many of us Hufflepuffs are chaotic evil, I've had a long-standing theory that whenever they hear someone gets doused with vinegar, they'll rush out all panicked like "OH THANK GOD IT WASN'T THE ACID BARREL" to make sure they don't do it again because the sound is kinda annoying
lollipopsie _ what? hufflepuffs arent chaotic evil..?
@@juliannaelwell that's true
E was joking
@@juliannaelwell a lot of them are
the house itself isn’t
OMFG SEAMUS CONGRATS! We know this was one of your dreams!💛💛
Luna Lovegood is lame
i know I'm so happy for seamus
Hey Luna! The Quibbler going well?
I think we witnessed an internal freakout. Surprised Seamus sat so still, I'd be fidgeting like crazy.
If I were Harry Potter I would use the invisibility cloak to sneak into the kitchen to steal food
LIke James did?
I’d use it to never have to face myself in the mirror again
- hermionie avpm
he doesnt need to, i think the house elves seem to shower just about anyone with more food than they know what to do with quite happily, no point in sneeking around trying to find the pantry when you can have over 100 waiters at your service
And That Is Why You Are Not Harry Potter.XD
"the sword will present itself" "often to just defend yourself" against snakes mostly. the basilisk, Nagini,
4:03 *pretends he didn’t know this before* 😂😂
True (BTW love your name).
A tad cringy 😂 bless them
I CLICKED ON THIS VIDEO AND HAD NO IDEA WHO IT WAS FEATURING BECAUSE THE TITLE IS TOO LONG AND I SAW THE SCARF AND AHHHHHHHHHHHHHH I CANT
I've always wondered if the Cup of Hufflepuff was at one time the Holy Grail.
Nah. Thing About The Holy Grail Is That The ONLY Thing Special About It Is That It's The Cup Jesus Drank Out Of At The Last Supper: Meaning The Cup,It'self Would Just Be A Normal (VERY Old And Basic Looking) Cup Made Of Wood Or Maybe Clay With No Special Powers.
@@JT5555 do you know how capitals work?
@aisleelovegreenwood6448 jesus didn't have any money,though so it's highly doubtful he had access to a golden cup and he wouldn't have had enough for everyone or be the only one to have it either so it's much more likely that the cup he and the rest of them drank from were simply made of clay.
Consider a simpler approach
Slytherin as you said regarded pure bloods as superior, what if he did enchant the locket to increase magical ability for the wearer, but only if they were pure blooded. Anything less would result in it weakening the wearer instead.
It shows my Voldemorts mother became so suddenly gifted but also why Voldemorts chose not to keep the herlum once he'd found it.
The locket wouldn't have recognised him as worthy due to his muggle father and therefore weakened him. In his rage he then turned it into a horcrux, confident that in doing so he'd gained a greater strength than any the locket could have offered.
Also, Ron is never said to have diminished power when wearing it, he's merely influenced by the horcrux. Harry and Hermione however, a half blood and muggle born, having difficulty with their spells.
Umbridge has apparently been outed as a half blood on pottermore which would confuse my argument, but this is what I had thought when I read the books
That's Kind Of In Line With What I Was Thinking: Slytherin Was't About His FAMILY Being The Only One's Who Should Be Allowed To Do Magick,Just PURE-BLOODS. It's Safe To Say That He Cared About His Pure-Blooded Students So He Locked Power Into The Locket (Because Slytherins Like Power) That ANY Pure-Blood Can Use,But Not Anything Below That.
Harry’s parents are both wizards so he is wizard born like Ron.
@Austin Su wasn’t halfblood a muggle parent and a wizard parent?
@Austin Su I just have a problem with understanding all of the nuances of discrimination. I just never understood it.
@Austin Su not saying you are discriminating at all ok. I am sorry if you ever thought I was accusing you at all. I just have a hard time wrapping my head around the concept of discrimination. I always found it weird.
4:30 me every time I have to present to the class
Evan Rules Me too lol😂😂
SEAMUS AND SCB!!!!!! MY GAWD MY PRAYERS HAVE BEEN ANSWERED❤️😭
Blondie Girl Life hey I saw your comment on a different video, I think a Mario Kart Roulette? I don't remember if I replied...
Right!
Blondie Girl Life you seem like an awesome person already
Blondie Girl Life mine too
Blondie Girl Life I was going to say that
They are both so respectful and quiet when the other is talking
Seamus made this so awkward for me. I can tell he wasn’t in his element or level of comfort ability. I can tell he was ready and he was so quiet when it wasn’t “his turn” to speak. I like him on his channel but here it wasn’t the same comfortable dynamic as the brothers.
Their newer collabs are less awkward. I think Seamus needed time to gain confidence since he’s younger
OH MY GOD. OKAY MY TWO FAVOURITE TH-camRS IN ONE VIDEO AND THEY START OFF WITH A FREAKING STARKID REFERENCE! WHAT IS GOING ON!
Seamus looks so tiny xD
Yiizy up know it hilarious
Seamus IS so tiny.
Why would you mention the cursed child, when we are all trying to forget 😭
here’s my take on this
i agree with the hufflepuff one that makes sense but i think that the slytherin locket could be something that increases power of your magic but it only works if you are a true. pure blood meaning you have no muggle in your blood just a theory of mine i haven’t read the books for a bit so this is prolly wrong
😱 it’s Seamus and Super Carlin brothers crossover! That’s why you were going to America!!! P.S. I’m an early subscriber and I love both of your channels!!!
Bailey NewTube I AM TOO!! I was confused as to why he was going to America buT
Erin Elise lol I was cringe (still am btw)
MY TWO FAVORITE THEORIZERS IN THE SAME VIDEO!! I HAVE BEEN SAYING THEY SHOULD DO THIS FOR YEARS!!
Dude, Seamus looks like he’s super-imposed, and he seems really loud! Great vid!
Sword power to absorb comes from goblin made metal
I missed half of the theory because I was just so excited about Seamus being in the video😂
just have to watch it again!
I’m so happy you’re trending!!!
0:58 i absolutely ADORE that both J and Seamus knew/made the starkid reference. y’all cant do that to my heart😂😍
3:12 J mouthing Seamus's words😂
THE COLLAB IS AMAZING I HAVENT EVEN SEEN IT YET AND IM SO FREAKING EXCITED
My life is almost complete!
Now I just need Matpat, SCB, Seamus and Wotso all in one video 😂❤️
Fire And Ice Art Productions I was thinking the same thing
Fire And Ice Art Productions The dream
Fire And Ice Art Productions omg ! YES !😱
YESSSSSSS
Fire And Ice Art Productions MatPat, SCB, Seamus, Vegard, Brendon Urie, and Dan and Phil need to be in the same video.
It could make the drinker tell the truth, Hufflepuffs also value honesty.
Maybe she helped with Veritaserum?
But that would be just and fair
or turn water into liquid luck
Fill It With Enough Wine And They Will.>;3
I love how you’re talking about the items from your houses 😭💕 the HP fan in me is quaking
OMG I LOVE SEAMUS GORMAN, YOU TWO DOING A COLLAB TOGETHER IS THE BEST THING THAT HAS HAPPENED TO ME THIS WEEK, THANK YOU FOR DOING THIS COLLAB!!!!!!!!!!!!
Hey broooverr
Hey Brother!
+SuperCarlinBrothers haven't seen this anywhere so apologies if you've answered it a ton but, is your 'hey brother' bit taken from Red Dog in Almost Famous? That's what I think of when I watch your vids. Thanks for the interesting content! :)
I loved that little ‘rrrr’ when Seamus did it. He’s very adorable.
Seamus- 'Yes, us Hufflepuff's are particularly good finders.'
Me- 'Is that why you're wearing green?'
The Deathly Hallows
Loved the AVPM reference in the video
oh my god, its the best collaboration ever! I m literally obsessed with these two channels lately!
Seamus has been a fan for so long it makes my heart happy that you two are together
Orange McTwisty McTwist YeEmO dAd!1!1!1!!1!!!!!1!!
This is literally my dream. Nerds united.
3:12 watch J mouthing the line that Seamus is saying XDDDD
3:12 J is repeating what seamus says 😂
They probably on a script and j is making sure he stays
SEAMUS?! IN A SUPER CARLIN BROTHERS VIDEO?! COULD THIS DAY GET ANY BETTER?!
Shadow Realm Possibly
The brothers could take their shirts off. Then it'd be better.
Shadow Realm right!
Shadow Realm It can... There's a new Game Theory today 😊
Shadow Realm NO, THIS IS THE BEST THING IN THE WORLD
Congrats on being in a Supercarlin video Seamus! This is so awesome!
I'm not the only one who thought the acting was kinda cringey right lmao I love this channel😂
Slytherins and Hufflepuffs both are hard working.just something to think about
AHAHAH J MOUTHING SEAMUS' LINES I CAN'T I'M DONE I LOVE BOTH OF YOU GUYS DO A VIDEO ON HIS CHANNEL BYEEEE
Hahahah I was looking for someone to notice 😂😂😂😂😂
Oh my god thank you for pointing that out xD I love them so much hehe so cute!
J mouthing seamus' text is everything😂❤️
Oh no am i doing that!?!
SuperCarlinBrothers 😂😂
Omygosh I didn't even notice, haha :) But yeah, his lips are certainly twitching along in that Gamp's Elemental Tongue-twister bit!
When ur two favorite harry potter and pixar theorists film together💖
Heavily scripted😂🤣 but love it! Keep up the good work!
Yeah, at points this was painful to listen too, how stilted and obvious it was they were just reading from scripts, how they'd rarely actually look at eachother when talking or while the other was talking, the script was written to be like a conversation between thhe two but at no point did i ever feel like they were natural or actually talking to eachother in conversation, they talked to the camera far more often making the whole thing feel very off to me. Was more noticeable with Seamus
Noobie2k7 yeah exactly, it kept distracting me from what they were actually saying, it was too awkward & off-putting. And I find this Shamus kid’s voice extremely annoying, he was practically shouting for the whole video
Legendary Gaming it works with one person because you can’t script it as a conversation but with two people it just felt unnatural
I feel like y’all forget that Seamus is younger than J, he probably was really, really nervous. Their newer collabs are a lot more natural
WAIT WHAT
WHEN
HOW
OMG
SEAMUS IM SO PROUD OF YOU!!! YOU MADE IT ON SCB!!! :DDDDDD
seamus:“ us hufflepuffs are good finders”
me : *finger guns at screen* “ right inded my fellow hufflepuff we are”
nervousneed xoxo
Well, I found this comment soo…
Yep
I found this comment very accurate *finger guns*
Hufflepuffs ftw
I can’t find anything. I must not be a true Huffelpuff 😖
On Umbridge: I find it significant that the one spell we KNOW she became more proficient in was conjuring a patronus. You talked in your video regarding Harry's crazy golden flame spell about the horcrux's innate instinct for self-preservation.
And what is a horcrux? A part of a soul, obviously. The primary function of a patronus is to cast a shield between a witch or wizard and a dementor. And we know that the most horrifying power that a dementor possesses is to "suck the soul" out of a person, and that they feed on these souls. Certainly a horcrux would be an easy target, as it's fiercely wounded to begin with, and considering the types of monsters that we know are able to defeat a horcrux (ie. a basilisk) I would say that the dementor definitely falls into this category.
Therefore, I think that Umbridge's increased power doesn't come from the locket itself, but from the horcrux inside, doing what it needs to in order to protect itself.
And I thought Slytherin locket works like Venom, increasing the user's abilities, knowledge, and such.
But it's stupid lol.
I think Hufflepuff's cup is basically like the Cornucopia. Changing vinegar into wine would probably be one of its abilities but I think that's more of an effect of its real powers. I think the power enhancement or knowledge giving aspect of Slytherin's locket applies to those shares Slytherin's traits (ambition and cunning mostly), more so than being a direct bloodline of Slytherin. Merope was always wearing the locket but never was able to do even the simplest spells, and she never isn't anything like a Slytherin despite being a descendant of him, and it was only after her father and brother was taken away and she could fully embrace the chance to have Tom Riddle Senior (her ambition) was she able to do magic to trick him (cunning).
Heyyyyyy Seamus! I love you child! (I'm not a stalker...)
GoToHello he's not a child he just looks like one
GoToHello I am. I will find her and bring her to you.
David Graves yea. I call everyone child.
Yeas a grownup
I got a Slytherin locket for Christmas and I'm a Hufflepuff but I still like it
I Have Four,Baby Nifflers Guarding My Locket As We Speak.
I think slytherin and Hufflepuff have the most a-like traits. Hard work, determination and ambition all go hand in hand. Also fraternity and loyalty as well. All the main Hufflepuffs could’ve easily been slytherins (Zacharias Smith and Cedric had the traits just not as strong as their Hufflepuff ones). What differentiates both houses is kindness.
I honest to god thought you were getting to “only members of slytherin house can access the power, whereas anyone else will feel drained while in possession of the locket.”
Also: I HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS COLLAB SINCE I STARTED WATCHING TH-cam I AM SO HAPPY
I am so happy! These are literally the BEST TH-camrs alive! Also, Seamus always looked up to the Super Carlin Brothers, he considers them an inspiration.
When J is talking at the end Seamus is just like looking around awkwardly
He so cute 😂
This is so great xD You guys look like the prime example of a background Slytherpuff friendship xD
oh my god Seamus saying Hey Brother gave me butterflies ✨✨✨
Am I the only one happy AVPM reference to how they treat Hufflepuffs? Just me? Okay finna go watch the play again
Khari Lnnn I LOVE AVPM!!! Pigfarts!!!
i was so happy they made that reference
His accent is my favorite thing in the entire f'ing world omg😍😍😍😍😍
To Be Fair,He's British: That's Not A Accent,He's Just Properly Speaking English.XD
I loved this video. I'm a fan of theories about Harry Potter, but this one is just wow. Thank you for this. :)
THIS MAKES ME SO HAPPY.
I got so happy when I saw Seamus because I didn't read the title
I think the Umbridge was able to cast the patronus charm bcoz the horcrux made her do things that made her extremely happy she loved to trample on other people and coz the most amount of misery so when the horcrux was influencing her it didnt really try very hard bcoz she was inherently extremely evil ... she did not get any extra powers from the locket as she was not related to slytherin, she was just enjoying torturing the muggleborns and therefore that was a happy moment for her...
On the eve of the new game, I have found myself revisiting many of these videos, as a research tool.
I love these deep dives!💛