@@Karansharmaheyitsmeshe’s ironically saying “just between us” because she’s speaking directly to him, but the whole world is listening in. she saying you don’t have to hide it, you can be intimate and let me know if this thing between us destroyed you like it destroyed me.
I just looked up his gf and she's 25 years old, but they started dating in late 2018 which means she was at least 21-22 at that time. Taytay was right😭😭
i love how her instagram has all comments off but some posts she missed, and even those are limited. tagged photos are off as well. hmm edit: this is about the gf not taylor **
"You kept me like a secret but I kept you like an oath." HOW DO YOU WRITE A LINE THAT GOOD??? Seriously! Most amazing "new" lyric in what is already her greatest song ever!
When she said "you said if we had been closer in age maybe it would have been fine" then later on "I was never good at jokes but the punchline goes 'I'll get older but your lovers stay my age'..." just meant that his excuse when he broke up with her was their age difference and held it against her yet he kept dating younger girls.... the audacityyyyy
Jake's Girlfriend was Jeanne Cadieu. She has dated Jake Gyllenhaal; the couple began dating in late 2018. She is 25 right now and Jake is 40. Therefore when he dated her she was 22 and he was 36 (14 year difference) and when he dated Taylor she was 20 and Jake was 29. (9 year difference) " *I'll get older but your lovers stay my age* " " *You said if we had been closer in age maybe it would have been fine. And that made me want to die* " I love you Taylor Jake does not deserver you.
@@briannalee1998 How? Lol. Remember the photos of them with the lattes?? The scarf she was wearing in that photo was the same scarf Jake was wearing in a pap photo from February 2011, after they broke up lol.
Can we talk about the reference that she sings „They say all's well that ends well, but I'm in a new hell every time you double-cross my mind“ and in Lover she sings „All's well that ends well to end up with you“ 😭
She was NINETEEN when she wrote this. It's unbelievable. Imagine sitting on THOSE lyrics for 13 years!! She was nineteen & he was 29. Men like that specifically choose young, impressionable girls so they can mold them into the "perfect" girlfriend. Until it's time to trade them in for a new one, of course.
@@nosi8787 soldiers come back from war so beaten and battered. smaller and weaker and tired. that's how she came back to her life after the relationship.
I also believe this is the reason she let taylor launcher go.....Jake broke her....she didn't want or couldn't risk that kind of heartbreaking again despite TL being an absolute sweetheart.....so sad.
Half her weight = returning the whole song again like the other song was 5 min and she is returning 10m song the remaining half = half her weight she is reliving and releasing the whole truth = her weight
I am a new fan. Listened to the 10 minute version out of curiosity, like, "who needs a 10 minute version of any song" and wholly cow... blown away by the writing and the heartbreak that comes through. This album speaks to the 17 year old me...love.
the line that always makes me cry is "time won't fly, it's like I'm paralyzed by it. I'd like to be my old self again, but I'm still trying to find it". this is something I struggle with, especially in the aftermath of heartache. I wish I could be the person I used to be before someone played with my heart but I can never find her again _and it hurts so much._ I'm always stuck in time, repeating events that have hurt me beyond repair over and over and over again, unable to really move on with my life
“I’ll get older but your lovers will stay my age” “You told me about your past thinking your future was me” “Thinking he’s gonna say it’s love, you never called it what it was” “I forget about you long enough to forget why I needed to” “You kept me like a secret but I kept me like an oath” “So casually cruel in the name of being honest” These lines deserve a Grammy of their own
I come back and watch this video periodically! Lately I’ve been watching videos of people discovering Taylor and it’s fun to see them appreciate her, but they don’t KNOW the history or what it all means. I love that you guys appreciate the heartbreaking lines! I also forget what’s original lyrics and 10 minute now, so I love seeing you two sing along too!
Every time a new part of the song came on it was just the best to witness y'all holding your breath and just showing this intense concentration. Because when the line hit you it really hit you because you were listening for it
"Just between us did the love affair maim you too?" -Always the question in my head when we broke up. Does he have trouble sleeping at night too? Or is he somewhere having a blast because we're finally over? 😔 It's been 3years and it still haunts & hurts me.
Stoppppp because I’m like two weeks fresh of a heartbreak and last week was supposed to be our anniversary and I was wondering when I was sitting in my kitchen , drinking wine and sobbing and pinning over someone who didn’t want me/ begging him to call if he at least wanted to…
Jake Gyllenhaal's current girlfriend is 25 years old. They started dating in 2018, when she was 21-22 years. SO... They really do be staying the same age.
“How do you write a line that good?” “AND CUT IT??!” “My ex wore plaid” Absolutely dying laughing in the middle of crying. Thank you so much for this reaction! And honestly nothing of Jake’s escaped this album alive. The bitch dragged his shoes and sofa in “Bet you think about me.” Can’t wait to hear the rest of your thoughts on the album!
This song shook me since SNL, when was the first time I heard it. I was never a Taylor listener, and this cut me to the core. I’m a professional singer and it takes a lot for me to get this moved, and this is brilliant! Kudos!!
I met Jake a week before her birthday. He was in Sydney promoting Love & Other Drugs & I told him I liked him and Taylor together and he smiled and said thanks then like the next day it was those photos of them together & then the next week he didn't show up to her birthday party.
This IS THE REACTION VIDEO. No pauses. They know the original. They’re also hot AF. I’ve watched along 5 or 6 times pretending I have friends who care about the TMV
i absolutely love the way you're mouthing the lyrics and then suddenly the lyrics from the vaults come in and you're like 4:26 then start listening carefully to the things she's singing about and when the lyrics you know come back you're back to vibing
She came for his throat, and took his spine while she was at it. Then she eviscerated him, and excoriated him. Like Jake is definitely rethink some life choices right there.
I would hope so. But if he's still the same guy, do we really think he would think about HIS choices? Except maybe ever dating her so he would avoid the scandal?
He has gaslighted her so bad, she has to write in a song and repeatedly telling herself, she was there, it was rare and remember all of it all too well.
but imagine listening to your boyfriend's ex-girlfriend describing the relationship and realizing he's acting the same way in your relationship! I really hope he has changed tho and they are happy but poor girl if he hasn't.
@@jankova0013 I don't think he's changed, I mean he's like 40 and they started dating when she was 22. I just hope she realizes that this is a pattern for him and leaves him soon because that is not okay. It's heartbreaking that this is still happening and I feel so bad for her.
@@corridawn3851 I mean the age itself isn't that big of an issue tho. The biggest problem was how he treated her and I hope that changed. But yes, it shows that it's probably just wishful thinking.
All too well 2012 broke me but this 2021 it destroyed me gosh the lyrics Ps. I'm picturing papa Swift look in his face looking at his only daughter on the door waiting all night with broken heart gosh I want to hug Taylor at that moment
I have lost count of how many times I have watched this video. I come back to it at least once a week (my husband loves it too). It's like taking a good mood pill. Hands down best ALTW 10 min version reaction out there.
I love, LOVE the 10 min story, because it’s not just a song, is a story. I’m an old woman who loves her music, started listening years ago and way back when I heard about him I said he didn’t deserved her love, and this new version proves I was right.
@Diva Snow again with the pacifist attempt without observing the patters. That's some "we don't know the exact story" no shit, Taylor just told everything to us in 10 minutes and she's still the one overreacting?? And in case you didn't know, someone was consistent with having girlfriends in their early 20s despite being a very old man 🥴
@Diva Snow You need to woke up. I mean we have now a short film that verifies the story. Stop defending him saying every story has two sides when you have proofs and when he is consistant in what she is saying. He has been with a girl whose 14 years younger than him just as Taylor said.
This is literally EXACTLY how I felt listening to this the first time. Like, beat for beat my reactions. And watching you guys lip synch along was just icing on the cake, and then seeing you get caught by surprise with the new lyrics was PRICELESS. I'm gonna watch this video a hundred more times. Also I actually said YES out loud when you mentioned how we need both versions. BOTH! VERSIONS! ARE! SO! NECESSARY! I keep seeing people saying like "the original is DEAD to me, it doesn't feel right anymore" and no!!!!! The 2012 album version is so important- it's tight, it's focused, it's just personal enough to feel, well, personal, but it's not so personal that it loses its universality. The long one is SO personal and it adds depth and even though the oath line could've absolutely stayed in the original (that double verse followed by a double chorus! love it!), it's no longer universal. Some parts of it absolutely are, but on the whole it becomes so pointed that it can absolutely only be about Mr. Gyllenhaal. I also feel like you lose the potency of the scarf with the longer version because it doesn't bookend the narrative anymore! But still, oh my god..... imagine being such a good lyricist that THOSE are the lines you cut. I literally cannot.
2 years?!!?? Damn. I remember 2 years ago I was absolutely HEARTBROKEN when this song came out and warching this video and laughing at yalls reactions.. I didnt realize time went by that fast
How does this not have more comments???!!!🤯😡 I ADORE this video of you both and have watched it SO many times because your reactions to this impeccable song are so pure and lovely.🥺 You make me cry every time! 😭I hope Taylor saw this! 🥰
I seriously love you guys. I've watched this reaction so many times because when I watch it it's like I'm listening for the first time with old friends. Thanks so much.
Omg I LOVED your reactions and how you literally froze every time a new verse started to play! All of this was so relatable. The general 'all too well' hype + shock.
I feel like the first released version is the story you share with people in general but Taylor's 10 minute version is the story you only tell your best friend. ❤️🩹
I loved this ten minute version. I reminded me so much of my ex, especially the line about not saying he loved me because my ex never said he had loved me until he broke up with me, and he only told me because I brought up how closed off emotionally he was especially when I expressed my love (we dated for 2.5 yrs too). But you live and learn and I eventually rebounded and got over him and now I am dating a man who puts the effort in and is communicative.
I love your reaction because I can see you know the lyrics to the original song and when there were new parts you had your jaw dropped eyes wide and heart breaking.
Ok but this is the only reaction video I come back to almost twice a week just to have the experience of listening it for first time..😌😌😌belive you me. You both have done a great job💜
This woman is a god damn legend. Her song writing ability is legendary but this is next level . Between her and Adele this year I need life support. God damn it.
And.... just like that I am 18 again, 21 again, 33 again, and every heartache in between! Damn, so good! Love your reactions, was a fun laugh at the end of a long day. New subscriber now :)
This is for sure the best reaction vid i’ve watched for ATW10 (and i’ve watched 10386272 vids lol). I just love how you guys just quietly sinked in the lyrics with eyes getting bigger and bigger with each new line.. coz that’s my exact reaction too. Lol
Let me tell you something my ex broke up with me the night before my birthday and he knew this. He also wore plaid…. 😑 I still haven’t gotten over it. I’m married and I’m like yeah that piece of wet lettuce broke up with me the night before my birthday because he wanted to get back with his ex.
jake gyllenhaal's current girlfriend is my age and i was 16 when this song came out LMAOOO. they started dating in 2018 when she was 22. taylor did not lie 😭😭😭
I HAVE to say Ive never watched these guys before but i have watched this reaction like 5 times. I LOVE theirs!!! Its def the BEST reaction of this. Love u guys. Ill sub!!!!
I'm still crying! I'm so hurt even though I'm in a happy relationship now. How could she do such a brilliant masterpiece that can hurt us so good in a damn best way? I love how she did this. Ps. Its monday here in Philippines and I am not well and Im still feeling like a crushed egg shell because of the the film. I can't stop listening to the song it is actually on repeat always.
@@jankova0013 omg you act like you know all the details of their relationship 😂. They only dated 3 months and he treated her crap. It’s obvious he didn’t like her and that’s okay.
@@GraceLove33 a lot of people (especially men) treat their significant other like crap. That doesn't mean they don't like them. They are just crappy people 🤷♀️
I love your expressions especially when the song start at the part "and I was never good at telling jokes but the punchline goes, I'll get older but your lovers stay my age". I love the way you get surprise bcs of that part ❤️
“You kept me like a secret but I kept you like an oath” might just be the greatest line she has written which is saying something considering she is without doubt the greatest lyricist of her generation. That line hits like a freight train every time…
![ละลาย (LALALYE) - DAOU PITTAYA ต้าห์อู๋ พิทยา [OFFICIAL MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wo6r9TgausI/mqdefault.jpg)
![[ ออกกอง ] วัยหนุ่ม 2544 โลกหลังลูกกรง..ทัวร์กองถ่ายหนังใน "คุกของจริง" | JUSTดูIT.](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vB--aOkZCpw/mqdefault.jpg)
My favourite line is “Just between us, did the love affair maim you too?”
THAT SHIT WAS PERSONAL
what does it mean? please explain
Just between us.. Do you remember it.. All too weeellll😢
@@Karansharmaheyitsmeshe’s ironically saying “just between us” because she’s speaking directly to him, but the whole world is listening in. she saying you don’t have to hide it, you can be intimate and let me know if this thing between us destroyed you like it destroyed me.
oh now i get it@@taylorbarnhart9882
now we need the "Dear John (10 min version)"
This!
YESSSSSSSDS
Yesss yess YES!!!
😩😂
i don’t think it exists
The way we all FLIP when we find out he never told her he loved her!
Right! Not till after they broke up no wonder she was so heartbroken after the whole thing.
@@silverkyre My first serious bf did the same too. It makes you feel like complete shit!
@@suzysnewlife fuck em. Thats so messed up.
@@silverkyre It's all good. I'm married now! ♥
@@suzysnewlife ❤❤❤
I just looked up his gf and she's 25 years old, but they started dating in late 2018 which means she was at least 21-22 at that time. Taytay was right😭😭
Oh noooo
The way that this was the first thing i looked up too coz WOW
i love how her instagram has all comments off but some posts she missed, and even those are limited. tagged photos are off as well. hmm
edit: this is about the gf not taylor **
@@minoena the girlfriend? She didn't do anything wrong aside from dating a guy who can't get over the fact he is aging.
@@minoena the girlfriend didn’t do anything wrong
"You kept me like a secret but I kept you like an oath." HOW DO YOU WRITE A LINE THAT GOOD??? Seriously! Most amazing "new" lyric in what is already her greatest song ever!
When she said "you said if we had been closer in age maybe it would have been fine" then later on "I was never good at jokes but the punchline goes 'I'll get older but your lovers stay my age'..." just meant that his excuse when he broke up with her was their age difference and held it against her yet he kept dating younger girls.... the audacityyyyy
Jake's Girlfriend was Jeanne Cadieu.
She has dated Jake Gyllenhaal; the couple began dating in late 2018.
She is 25 right now and Jake is 40. Therefore when he dated her she was 22 and he was 36 (14 year difference) and when he dated Taylor she was 20 and Jake was 29. (9 year difference)
" *I'll get older but your lovers stay my age* "
" *You said if we had been closer in age maybe it would have been fine. And that made me want to die* "
I love you Taylor Jake does not deserver you.
I still think the song was about John Mayor.
@@briannalee1998 but the overwhelming evidence that points to Jake is too much for it to be about John.
luckily it's been almost a decade and they've both moved on and Taylor has Joe, which is basically her husband so...
@@briannalee1998 How? Lol. Remember the photos of them with the lattes?? The scarf she was wearing in that photo was the same scarf Jake was wearing in a pap photo from February 2011, after they broke up lol.
@Diva Snow no, they are saying ‘basically husband’ because they ‘ve been together for 5 years and they even live together
Can we talk about the reference that she sings „They say all's well that ends well, but I'm in a new hell every time you double-cross my mind“ and in Lover she sings „All's well that ends well to end up with you“ 😭
YES! THIS!
💯👏
I wouldn't be surprised if we never saw Jake Gyllenhaal again.
I hate how I know where this is coming from and with trix’s voice
the most unexpected fandom crossover
No body no crime
Tracy we know this is your fake account!
hi bald!
Popular opinion: We all got chills the first time we heard the line "You kept me like a secret and I kept you like an oath.l".
even to .this .day
english is not my first language and i never understood those lines🥲
@@higherself1113 me too, I've been trying very hard to understand it😮💨
@@higherself1113 it means she was committed to him, but he was ashamed of her. It’s a great line.
@@cawheeler27 that's sad. thank u for explaining😘
Imagine if she had said “f*ck the patriarchy” 10 years ago…….. It would’ve been a major news story 😂
Lmao
😂😂😂
We love the me too movement 🙌 it changed a lot in the media thank god!!
She was NINETEEN when she wrote this. It's unbelievable. Imagine sitting on THOSE lyrics for 13 years!! She was nineteen & he was 29. Men like that specifically choose young, impressionable girls so they can mold them into the "perfect" girlfriend. Until it's time to trade them in for a new one, of course.
@@IvyCowboy she started dating him when she was 20. And she said she wrote this at 21. But anyway it's disgusting.
"How dare you write a line that good and then cut it!? " hahahahaha definitely every swiftie😂
She really wrote this entire song by rehearsing with her band and just sang an unfiltered raw song it’s crazy we’re finally getting it 10 years later
why is no one talking about the “I’m a soldier who’s returning half her weight” line? my heart was shattered into 130000 pieces
What does it mean?
@@nosi8787 soldiers come back from war so beaten and battered. smaller and weaker and tired. that's how she came back to her life after the relationship.
I also believe this is the reason she let taylor launcher go.....Jake broke her....she didn't want or couldn't risk that kind of heartbreaking again despite TL being an absolute sweetheart.....so sad.
Half her weight = returning the whole song again like the other song was 5 min and she is returning 10m song the remaining half = half her weight she is reliving and releasing the whole truth = her weight
@@nosi8787 I think there is also a literal meaning that she lost heaps of weight after the breakup as sad, heart broken and not eating.
The way they groan like they’re being punched in the gut with each line is the most relatable thing I’ve ever seen
"You kept me like a secret but I kept you like an oath" I have never felt so broken, I'm not even broken to begin with and only Taylor could do that.
The way I know for a fact Joe was hyping her up this entire re-recording like baby tell your STORYYYYYY
omg I thought the same, baby boy was telling her to over him, and I love him for that
I'm imagining him curled up on the sofa in the home studio with a glass of wine and the cats all around him shouting "Scalp him baby!!"
affirmative
Joe who? Im out of the loop 😊
@@Oglulubell Joe Alwyn, Taylor’s boyfriend
I am a new fan. Listened to the 10 minute version out of curiosity, like, "who needs a 10 minute version of any song" and wholly cow... blown away by the writing and the heartbreak that comes through. This album speaks to the 17 year old me...love.
❤️
10 mins not long ...
I like her already before but listening to the 10 mins version made me fall inlove with her. She's an icon.
The 10 minute All Too Well is a ✨spiritual awakening✨
the line that always makes me cry is "time won't fly, it's like I'm paralyzed by it. I'd like to be my old self again, but I'm still trying to find it". this is something I struggle with, especially in the aftermath of heartache. I wish I could be the person I used to be before someone played with my heart but I can never find her again _and it hurts so much._ I'm always stuck in time, repeating events that have hurt me beyond repair over and over and over again, unable to really move on with my life
You're right 👍
“I’ll get older but your lovers will stay my age”
“You told me about your past thinking your future was me”
“Thinking he’s gonna say it’s love, you never called it what it was”
“I forget about you long enough to forget why I needed to”
“You kept me like a secret but I kept me like an oath”
“So casually cruel in the name of being honest”
These lines deserve a Grammy of their own
Jennifer Aniston was the actress who came to check on her in the bathroom! They had a really sweet conversation and moment!
Aww I didn't know that! Jen is so sweet 🥰
Aww this makes me love that MORE!!
really? i heard it was anne hathaway
Awwwww
No I believe that is was Anne Hathaway
All Too Well 10 minute version. GREATEST SONG EVER WRITTEN. AMEN.
I come back and watch this video periodically! Lately I’ve been watching videos of people discovering Taylor and it’s fun to see them appreciate her, but they don’t KNOW the history or what it all means. I love that you guys appreciate the heartbreaking lines! I also forget what’s original lyrics and 10 minute now, so I love seeing you two sing along too!
Better Man and Babe are amazing. Message in a Bottle is a bop!! Nothing New is stunning with Phoebe finally getting her own verse!!!
Message in a Bottle gives me the feeling it should be the theme song of a romantic high school comedy😂
“The Very First Night” too! 😊
Forever Winter as well!
Every time a new part of the song came on it was just the best to witness y'all holding your breath and just showing this intense concentration. Because when the line hit you it really hit you because you were listening for it
"Just between us did the love affair maim you too?"
-Always the question in my head when we broke up. Does he have trouble sleeping at night too? Or is he somewhere having a blast because we're finally over? 😔 It's been 3years and it still haunts & hurts me.
Stoppppp because I’m like two weeks fresh of a heartbreak and last week was supposed to be our anniversary and I was wondering when I was sitting in my kitchen , drinking wine and sobbing and pinning over someone who didn’t want me/ begging him to call if he at least wanted to…
@@megankull8912 she is so amazing in pulling out those emotions right?
It did, don't worry
This song just solidified her status as the LEGEND to come out of this genaration. Absolutely phenomenal.
Jake Gyllenhaal's current girlfriend is 25 years old. They started dating in 2018, when she was 21-22 years. SO... They really do be staying the same age.
omg i get it now,thank you!!!!
“How do you write a line that good?” “AND CUT IT??!”
“My ex wore plaid”
Absolutely dying laughing in the middle of crying. Thank you so much for this reaction!
And honestly nothing of Jake’s escaped this album alive. The bitch dragged his shoes and sofa in “Bet you think about me.” Can’t wait to hear the rest of your thoughts on the album!
Not the sofa 😂
My ex wore plaid hahahaha I can't stop laughing at this
This song shook me since SNL, when was the first time I heard it. I was never a Taylor listener, and this cut me to the core. I’m a professional singer and it takes a lot for me to get this moved, and this is brilliant! Kudos!!
Same! Wasn’t a Taylor but this hits me and deserves respect!
Her lyricism is out of this world. Taylor Swift is such a storyteller.
I love the mood changes everytime that we hear brand new lyrics
I met Jake a week before her birthday. He was in Sydney promoting Love & Other Drugs & I told him I liked him and Taylor together and he smiled and said thanks then like the next day it was those photos of them together & then the next week he didn't show up to her birthday party.
This IS THE REACTION VIDEO. No pauses. They know the original. They’re also hot AF. I’ve watched along 5 or 6 times pretending I have friends who care about the TMV
💯 ❤
The oath line made me loose it too. Shivers ALL OVER
"You kept me like a secret when I kept you like an oath"
I FELT THAT IN MY SOUL!!!
i absolutely love the way you're mouthing the lyrics and then suddenly the lyrics from the vaults come in and you're like 4:26
then start listening carefully to the things she's singing about and when the lyrics you know come back you're back to vibing
the fact that this 10 minute masterpiece brought the two of you into my feed is making my year. new subscriber, you are wonderful.
Saaame here, girl!! Loving it!
the way you both FREEZE when the new lyrics come. HILARIOUS.
swifties: ALL OF US
She came for his throat, and took his spine while she was at it. Then she eviscerated him, and excoriated him.
Like Jake is definitely rethink some life choices right there.
That's why "did the love affair maim you all too well" part. Maybe not during, but now, after ATW blew up like an atomic bomb.
I would hope so. But if he's still the same guy, do we really think he would think about HIS choices? Except maybe ever dating her so he would avoid the scandal?
He’s probably wishing he had shown up to the birthday party 😂 😂
He has gaslighted her so bad, she has to write in a song and repeatedly telling herself, she was there, it was rare and remember all of it all too well.
I wonder what Jake Gyllenhaal’s girlfriend is thinking now like is she low key relating ahaha she is having a bad day for sure
Hope she realizes something.
Hope she rethinks her relationship with Jakhole Gaylenhole.
but imagine listening to your boyfriend's ex-girlfriend describing the relationship and realizing he's acting the same way in your relationship! I really hope he has changed tho and they are happy but poor girl if he hasn't.
@@jankova0013 I don't think he's changed, I mean he's like 40 and they started dating when she was 22. I just hope she realizes that this is a pattern for him and leaves him soon because that is not okay. It's heartbreaking that this is still happening and I feel so bad for her.
@@corridawn3851 I mean the age itself isn't that big of an issue tho. The biggest problem was how he treated her and I hope that changed. But yes, it shows that it's probably just wishful thinking.
All too well 2012 broke me but this 2021 it destroyed me gosh the lyrics
Ps. I'm picturing papa Swift look in his face looking at his only daughter on the door waiting all night with broken heart gosh I want to hug Taylor at that moment
I didn't expect you guys to ACTUALLY play the song. It's like I'm reliving the song all over again. 😭😭😭
I have lost count of how many times I have watched this video. I come back to it at least once a week (my husband loves it too). It's like taking a good mood pill. Hands down best ALTW 10 min version reaction out there.
I love, LOVE the 10 min story, because it’s not just a song, is a story. I’m an old woman who loves her music, started listening years ago and way back when I heard about him I said he didn’t deserved her love, and this new version proves I was right.
SAME I screameeedd and got chills during "You kept me like a secret and I kept you like an oath"
Thank god for mama Swift getting the recording of the rehearsal when Taylor wrote this anthem. Whew.
actually jake gyllehenal's gf was 22 when he started dating her lmao
Jake.used her for her body then he started seeing things get serious with her he blamed it on her age typical player
@Diva Snow again with the pacifist attempt without observing the patters. That's some "we don't know the exact story" no shit, Taylor just told everything to us in 10 minutes and she's still the one overreacting??
And in case you didn't know, someone was consistent with having girlfriends in their early 20s despite being a very old man 🥴
@Diva Snow You need to woke up. I mean we have now a short film that verifies the story. Stop defending him saying every story has two sides when you have proofs and when he is consistant in what she is saying. He has been with a girl whose 14 years younger than him just as Taylor said.
The actress she's referring to is Jennifer Anniston
This is literally EXACTLY how I felt listening to this the first time. Like, beat for beat my reactions. And watching you guys lip synch along was just icing on the cake, and then seeing you get caught by surprise with the new lyrics was PRICELESS. I'm gonna watch this video a hundred more times.
Also I actually said YES out loud when you mentioned how we need both versions. BOTH! VERSIONS! ARE! SO! NECESSARY! I keep seeing people saying like "the original is DEAD to me, it doesn't feel right anymore" and no!!!!! The 2012 album version is so important- it's tight, it's focused, it's just personal enough to feel, well, personal, but it's not so personal that it loses its universality. The long one is SO personal and it adds depth and even though the oath line could've absolutely stayed in the original (that double verse followed by a double chorus! love it!), it's no longer universal. Some parts of it absolutely are, but on the whole it becomes so pointed that it can absolutely only be about Mr. Gyllenhaal. I also feel like you lose the potency of the scarf with the longer version because it doesn't bookend the narrative anymore! But still, oh my god..... imagine being such a good lyricist that THOSE are the lines you cut. I literally cannot.
The way y'all be singing along and miming the lyrics and reacting to the new additions is all of us
2 years?!!?? Damn. I remember 2 years ago I was absolutely HEARTBROKEN when this song came out and warching this video and laughing at yalls reactions.. I didnt realize time went by that fast
It was sad aggressive painful brutal beautiful than the short version and its killing me
I love how you describe it and i totally agree!
it’s sad, beautiful, and tragic 😔🤚
How does this not have more comments???!!!🤯😡 I ADORE this video of you both and have watched it SO many times because your reactions to this impeccable song are so pure and lovely.🥺 You make me cry every time! 😭I hope Taylor saw this! 🥰
I seriously love you guys. I've watched this reaction so many times because when I watch it it's like I'm listening for the first time with old friends. Thanks so much.
Omg I LOVED your reactions and how you literally froze every time a new verse started to play! All of this was so relatable. The general 'all too well' hype + shock.
All too well 10 min is literally my new favourite song ever since it came out
the entire re recorded album is a masterpiece
My favorite part of these All Too Well reaction videos is when you’re jamming to the new beat, and *freeze* when new lyrics start
Yep she was right checked up his girlfriend, Jeanne Cadieu, she is currently 25, his girlfriends did stay her age
Note: He is 40
I feel like the first released version is the story you share with people in general but Taylor's 10 minute version is the story you only tell your best friend. ❤️🩹
Yes, goddammit!! Yes!
Exactly.
I loved this ten minute version. I reminded me so much of my ex, especially the line about not saying he loved me because my ex never said he had loved me until he broke up with me, and he only told me because I brought up how closed off emotionally he was especially when I expressed my love (we dated for 2.5 yrs too). But you live and learn and I eventually rebounded and got over him and now I am dating a man who puts the effort in and is communicative.
Boys- where's the new part? Me- boy u r not ready 😭😭😭
I love your reaction because I can see you know the lyrics to the original song and when there were new parts you had your jaw dropped eyes wide and heart breaking.
"Bad day for Jake'' I can't 🤣🤣
Ok but this is the only reaction video I come back to almost twice a week just to have the experience of listening it for first time..😌😌😌belive you me. You both have done a great job💜
This woman is a god damn legend. Her song writing ability is legendary but this is next level . Between her and Adele this year I need life support. God damn it.
"my ex wore plaid"
this ought to be in a t-shirt!
"my ex wore plaid" KILLED ME HAHAHAHAH
It's been a year and I'm still re-watching your reaction on this. By far the best one!
Why has this become my comfort video 😂
Matt is all of us when he says, “Where’s the new parts???!” Lol 😂
Ps. This song is a a masterpiece 💕 I feel it too!
'omg omg that girl is having a bad day tOO"
please i can't stop laughing HAHAHAH
And.... just like that I am 18 again, 21 again, 33 again, and every heartache in between! Damn, so good! Love your reactions, was a fun laugh at the end of a long day. New subscriber now :)
Girl at home kind of slaps now
I’m glad that people start to like this song with her re-recorded version. Always been a fan of Girl at Home here🥰🥰🥰🥰
ngl it was my least favourite red song before but I really like it now
I lost it at "my ex wore plaid" you guys are so funny 😂😂
This is for sure the best reaction vid i’ve watched for ATW10 (and i’ve watched 10386272 vids lol).
I just love how you guys just quietly sinked in the lyrics with eyes getting bigger and bigger with each new line.. coz that’s my exact reaction too. Lol
"WE'RE ALLOWED TO TALK IT'S OUR CHANNEL" lmao claim those rights, outstanding video as always
This was said as I read it 😂
Is it me?? Am I the only one who keep rewatching this video? It is so entertaining and you guy's reaction 👍👍👍
SPEAK NOW IS MY FAVE STILL. IT HAS MY HEART.
I re-watched this a least 10 times and not tired of watching it again
Let me tell you something my ex broke up with me the night before my birthday and he knew this. He also wore plaid…. 😑 I still haven’t gotten over it. I’m married and I’m like yeah that piece of wet lettuce broke up with me the night before my birthday because he wanted to get back with his ex.
Piece of 💦 🥬😂
@@ally_roro1482 he is though 🤣 no better way to describe him
What a beautiful insult… a wet piece of lettuce 🥬😂😂 forget that ex, leave the memory in the garbage disposal. Congratulations on your nuptials!
And here i am in the middle of the night, stoped listening to All too well, to watch the reactions for a straight hour.
jake gyllenhaal's current girlfriend is my age and i was 16 when this song came out LMAOOO. they started dating in 2018 when she was 22. taylor did not lie 😭😭😭
THE WHOLE ALBUM IS SO FLIPPING GOOD ITS KILLING MEEEEEEE
SO WE ARE ALL EXPERIENCING THIS ✨EXPERIENCE✨ COLLECTIVELY RIGHT???
I HAVE to say Ive never watched these guys before but i have watched this reaction like 5 times. I LOVE theirs!!! Its def the BEST reaction of this. Love u guys. Ill sub!!!!
This gives me chills. Watching two people just love this song as much as I did the first time, and watching it again gives me chills.
The way they got so still and just absorbed new lyrics was absolutely all of us 😂
I'm still crying! I'm so hurt even though I'm in a happy relationship now. How could she do such a brilliant masterpiece that can hurt us so good in a damn best way? I love how she did this.
Ps. Its monday here in Philippines and I am not well and Im still feeling like a crushed egg shell because of the the film. I can't stop listening to the song it is actually on repeat always.
Your reactions are so satisfying. Coz that's how I felt listening the 10 minute version for the first time. It's both beautiful and heartbreaking.
Its crazy how every time I watch reaction videos, I get INSANE goosebumps. This song is genuinely one of the greatest songs ever written period.
I was feeling really down today and watching this gave me such a happy boost! Thank you!!
the facial expressions are everything
Came back to rewatch because watching you guys react to this is everything!
Just like the all too well the short film, I’ll always come back to this video. Love your reactions 😭😂🧣☕️❤️🔥
“You said if we had been closer in age maybe it would have been fine
And that made me want to die”
This. This is it. This is the one. 🥲
He just didn’t like her
If the 33 year old guy you loved when you were 23 never said these exact words to you when you’ll never get it.
@@GraceLove33 that's why he was trying to get back with her and told her he loved her AFTER they broke up? No, that guy just had some serious issues.
@@jankova0013 omg you act like you know all the details of their relationship 😂. They only dated 3 months and he treated her crap. It’s obvious he didn’t like her and that’s okay.
@@GraceLove33 a lot of people (especially men) treat their significant other like crap. That doesn't mean they don't like them. They are just crappy people 🤷♀️
I love your expressions especially when the song start at the part "and I was never good at telling jokes but the punchline goes, I'll get older but your lovers stay my age". I love the way you get surprise bcs of that part ❤️
“You kept me like a secret but I kept you like an oath” might just be the greatest line she has written which is saying something considering she is without doubt the greatest lyricist of her generation. That line hits like a freight train every time…