HEMA vs Buhurt, with Daniel George from Honour and Arms HMB club.
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 19 ต.ค. 2024
- Hello and welcome to another video podcast.
In this video I’m chatting with Daniel George from Honour and Arms HMB club in Rochdale Greater Manchester.
Daniel is the owner of Honour and Arms HMB club and is also the current Captain of The Northern Wolves medieval combat team.
During the interview Daniel speaks passionately and authoritatively about his love for the sport of medieval combat.
If you ever wondered what the difference is between HEMA and Buhurt then this highly enjoyable and informative interview is for you.
Thanks for watching and why not check out the other videos in the HEMA playlist.
Don’t forget to Like, Comment and Subscribe to the channel and let me know what other HEMA related videos you would like to see next.
Help support this video podcast by making a donation at, Buy Me A Coffee. www.buymeacoffee.com/jamesvideopodcast
If you would like to find out more information about Honour and Arms HMB club, visit the links below.
Website, honourandarms....
TH-cam, / @honourarmshmbclub
FaceBook, / honourandarms
I explained it to a guy as "Nerf/lasertag = Larp", Hema/SCA = airsoft, buhurt = rubber bullet military drills."
This is actually a fantastic way to convey that message of how hard or relaxed it is. But casual standard Airsoft like wear base gear to fight would be Hema, and SCA is more bulk up and make sure you don’t run any risk to get hurt.
I think it would be better to compare HEMA to something like Judo or BJJ - they are very focused on the technicality of the fight, with rulesets which facilitate a 1 on 1 combat situation to exhibit skills. There isn't a lot of focus on the group aspect within HEMA, which airsoft does tend to have. There isn't really a comparable ranged combat sport except perhaps hunting or target shooting in terms of technicality.
Jesus which military are you in that uses rubber bullets for training?
@@TheEpicDartfish Bajookieland National Guard.
No, HEMA is the real sport. Buhurt is just whacking each other aimlessly.
Buhurt is like paintball and HEMA doesn’t need an analogy. It is a legitimate sport and is best conceptualized as a variant of fencing.
Buhurt does not rely on combat theory. HEMA does and isn’t just *like* military combat drills, HEMA literally is a replication of medieval combat drills.
Great interview and a good look into this amazing sport, thank you !
Thanks I'm glad you liked it.
i apply fiore de liberi in buhurt, grappling, leverage and lock-ups it works well with 2 handed weapons. Try THEM BOTH!
It is a great resource, especially with a 2 handed weapon.
this is awesome
Out of all the films mentioned 300 is unironically the most historically accurate. I will die on this hill.
Great interview. Enjoyed this one
Thank you for your comment. I am glad you liked it
300 was totally inaccurate. Spartans looked nothing like what was portrayed (e.g. long hair), they defendedna pass while all the other Greeks who were not shown in the film retreated, and fought because they were ashamed of not fighting a previous war with the Persians that the Greeks won.
You’re fucking fried 😂😂😂😂😂
That was really informative, thanks for the video
I'm glad you enjoyed it. More videos are coming soon.
Really enjoy your content
Thank you very much, hopefully some more HEMA and Buhurt coming soon.
Awesome!
Thanks Damian.
Buhurt is a sport, HEMA is a martial art. Each is as valid as the other. Love training them both.
Oi! Love this content. Where’s the video of your troop trying buhurt? Cheers mate
HEMA is actual fencing, buhurt is beating each other to a pulp until you get concussions
Gloucester shout out!
There is new ruleset in Russian HMB which allows thrusts and count them as "clear victory" (ippon) if they were made in weak spot of armour, but weak spots must be guarded with chainmail.
Was this the experimental harness fighting category done at Rekon?
@@HonourArmsHMBClub Yep, HMBIA Full Plate Harness. hmbia.info/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/Rules-for-Full-Plate-Longsword-Poleaxe.pdf. Russian high-level athletes already getting ready for it.
@@ИванМалахов-д8д I do recall seeing this as an experimental category but didn't touch on it in this podcast as we talked mainly standard Buhurt and duelling.
@@HonourArmsHMBClub No offence, my post was about evolution of sport and desire of its practitioners to emulate medeval armored combat.
@@ИванМалахов-д8д None offense taken. I appreciate the sport is advancing to incorporate harnisfetchen events more but being outside of my expertise I did not talk about it.
Daniel's laughably ignorant of historical sword weight and balance. The rules attempt to retcon actual history in the name of safety, even though others commonly use historically weighted weapons without issue. The extant Conyer's falchion is on the larger end of the spectrum and weighs in at 1.3 kg. That's towards the maximum of how much they weighed historically. So, instead of the statement "you wouldn't find one that's less than 1.3kg" it's closer to "there weren't many that were heavier based on surviving examples". The Thorpe falchion is 0.9kg. So, way below what he thinks is historically likely. Most of the heavier later period swords which look like falchions are more likely to be hunting swords. I.e, swords for targets that don't strike back with metal weapons. Those swords still don't balance in the hand like a buhurt/HMB sword.
Hi, i am searching for a Buhurt Katana, but it is really hard to find =D. Maybe can someone help me =).
I am sure there are plenty of smiths who would be able to make you one.
Canadian buhurt shop, he's made multiple Asian swords.
Salt Lake City Crusaders has a guy who uses one in longsword duels.
Buhurttech has some right now!
Unfortunatly there is lots of midinformation in this video
I fucking hate buhurt
Why?
@@HoratioHuffnagel because this is not medieval combat. This isn't even HEMA. The point system is screwy those aren't places you would Target in real combat. I appreciate the amount of stamina it takes to be a fighter in buhurt but in all reality it's just LARPing to the next level. Go to the pool and slap people with noodles if the same thing
@@saultecumseh5237lol triggered much.
@@ripchapley6878 yes
@@saultecumseh5237 I've never understood the devision between Hema and Buhurt. The buhurt duels are scored like many Hema tournaments, and the melee is its own thing entirely with its own skillset.
The club I'm in does everything frum buhurt to military Sabre so we all get a decent variety of training, it's just sad there aren't many tournaments outside of buhurt duels and melee and Hema longsword where I'm from.