Yamaha Pianica P37D Melodica Review 2020
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ก.ค. 2024
- Yamaha P37D: geni.us/P37D
Learn to play like a pro with the NEW Melodica Lessons Book: geni.us/QF0A
0:00 Introduction
0:38 The carrying case
0:55 How to hold the melodica
2:27 The moisture release button
3.11 Opening the melodica
4:20 Melodica reeds
4:54 Tuning
5:11 The keyboard
6:04 Playing the Yamaha Pianica P37D
7:29 The verdict
8:34 Question of the day
MUST READ: Buying a Melodica in 2021: melodicaworld.com/buying-a-me...
Check out the Melodica World Facebook page: / 579136949211042
And the Melodica World Forums: melodicaworld.com
Equipment used to film this video:
Camera: geni.us/Dcmav
Camera lens: geni.us/Kdg4
Microphone: geni.us/ZRaHCdo
Light: geni.us/Piq2rxJ
Softbox: geni.us/AdIpFP
#melodica #pianica #YamahaP37D
The Pianica is Yamaha's term for the melodica - a Yamaha Pianica is a Yamaha melodica!
The Yamaha P37D is a popular choice amongst professional musicians, and compares well with the Suzuki m37c and the Hammond Pro 44 (and 44HP). Other models often considered are the vintage Hohner melodicas, such as the Hohner melodica alto and the Hohner melodica soprano. - เพลง
![USAB Showcase: Australia vs USA [OFFICIAL STREAM]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/keiEr_MOaSQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Thanks for the review. I bought one so I can play for my geese. They approve.
So glad to hear you're playing for your geese. They're very privileged geese :-)
Honking with the geese
At 7:25 he was about to play the lick.
I WAS SO UNCOMFORTABLE WHEN HE DIDN'T GO UP THE MAJOR SECOND
OMG I CHECKED THE COMMENTS AS SOON AS IT HAPPENED
I heard it too! 😂
I agree the Yamaha's are a fine, solid, reliable instrument. I like both the 37 and the 32, and most of the time the way I play the range of the 32 is enough. Also own a couple Hammond/Suzukis which cost more. Their tone might be more mellow, volume just a bit more, and they look more serious. But I'm not sure they're worth twice the money. A real benefit of the Yamaha is that it's easy to get inside to touch up the tuning! Yes the gasket looks REALLY fragile, but the rest of the disassembly is very easy and repeatable. The case is the toughest I've seen, protective but no nonsense. For entry-level players or somebody who also plays other keyboards and don't want a junky toy, the Yamaha is perfect.
I agree, the Hammond has a nice tone and classy keyboard, but its so much more expensive. One thing I love about the Pianicas are their 'honest' simplicity
Hi, the key size is the same Yamaha Hammond Suzuki?
@@sandrok.distilo9988 Yes, exactly the same size, on the outside it looks like the same keyboard.
Oops, I meant that both Suzuki's have the same keyboard. The Yamaha is a VERY slightly longer keyboard, like 1/8" in an octave.
I play a Yamaha 32 and it fits the bill with me. I started out years ago with a soprano metal one with buttons for keys. That little instrument got me addicted to Melodicas. I have a piano background so the melodica fit in perfectly with that.
I came here because I saw it on Amazon, wondered if I want to buy it. This is a definitive yes. My answer to the question of the day?? THIS THING IS FRICKIN' AWESOME
Did you buy one? What do you think of it?
I'd never heard of this. I was, randomly, looking up "Lap Organs" and this model popped up. Then I decided to look for a review video of it and you were first. So I checked it out. You, sir, played it beautifully. It sort of sounds like a harmonica, only better. Thanks for showing me ALL the ins and outs of this instrument.
dang, that was a beautiful demo!!!! Such wonderful musical subtleties! You have inspired me to work on my circular breathing!
WOW! you certainly blow my mind with your professional playing ... This Yamaha Panic P37D certainly delivered quality sound and more importantly playability. Let's all face it, just a professional pianica player with an outstanding musicianship like yourself, it is a great joy to call this real instrument. I played it when I was rather young back home in France whilst studying the piano and music theory at collage of Music and I absolutely loved it back then and more so now! Thank you for this review and I have just became another subscriber to you lovely and comprehensive channel. Love even the facts that you also have lessons on your channel as well which certainly encourage for me to take on this wonderful instrument again :) Music is a language of unity, fun and friendship 😍
A review answering all my questions and with great explanation and form, thank you!
Glad it was helpful!
This is the model I own. I love it very much. Starting to learn how to play.
That Hypnotic look, thumbs up, subscribed and buying my first Melodica Pianica P37D
This helped me make a choice for my first melodica. It seems to be the “best bang for your buck” option. Mine will be delivered soon. Can’t wait to try it out!
Well, I just got this very melodica the other day, so I am still evaluating it and figuring it out. It IS quite loud, and I really like the sound. I'm a harmonica player looking to expand into the melodica. I have some experience with regular sized keyboards, but getting my sausage fingers to work properly on this keyboard is going to take some work! You make it look so easy! Anyway, so far I am very pleased with my purchase of this Yamaha melodica. I should have lots of fun with it.
i am just getting into melodicas and this is my first review. i bought this instrument, but i have never played it. full
honesty, saw a meme of a guy playing one and wanted one really bad. my goals are to be semi-self taught. enough rambling, thank you for this review. your voice is very soothing
Great to hear you're getting into playing it John!
I love my P-37D it’s great, was happy to find something that did not feel like I was playing a toy. I have played the piano for a very long time so I wanted something that felt more professional.
Same here!
Got mine yesterday and,i love the pianica from yamaha.
Great to hear it!
Brilliant as always. I just wish you would do more videos!! Really! They are so good. We want to hear you play more. If not - some links to your melodica music?
Terrific review.
Yes.Cool melodica I have one like this. Always happy.
I agree completely with your view on this particular instrument.
Very good video, thanks ! keep going
Great video, presentation and musicality! Cheers
Thanks Zvika :-)
You really made that thing SING!
Thanks :-)
This is such a great video. Thank you!!
Thanks! Glad you liked it
I like how comprehensive your review is
Nice review
Thank you for that excellent introduction! Your playing sounds wonderful. I'm waiting for my P-37D to arrive, but I have my P-32D for now.
Thanks Pal, P32D's also a great instrument
@@MelodicaWorld And let's not forget the marvelous little P25F!
@@alanbrinton4659 Yes Alan, a lovely little instrument :-)
HOW MUCH?
Very good review, thank you.🎹👏👏✨
Glad you liked it!
A cool review, thanks!
Thanks for watching!
Definitely buying this to play at a park and confuse/amaze people. Excellent video bro!
+Khordmaster go for it! I take mine to the park :-)
I used to play melodica in a rock band I was in. People really got off on seeing me play it. Especially cute chicks. It is fun and a novelty and it makes you the center of attention. This has got me thinking about getting one again. Thanks.
Seems to be nice. Never played one, but it looks and sounds great.
great review
Excelente.. muchas gracias!
Well, I have a couple of Suzuki Melodion 37s, but I just invested in the Yamaha Pianica 37 thanks to this. I've graduated from the Chromatic Harmonica to the cheap melodicas to the Suzuki 37. The Yamaha Pianica 37 is my next step. Keep up the good work.
I. Also like the Suzuki melodeons :-)
Indeed. They sound like organs to me, and crowds love it when I play the Suzuki Melodions. My Yamaha Pianica arrives in the mail Friday, and I'm looking forward to this one.
You are awesome 🤩 Thank you
You get some lovely sounds out of it
Thanks!
Great video and very helpful. I want to add it to my instrument box in my studio. I use this to add colour to recordings. Great playing by the way!
Thanks, yes a great instrument to add a bit of live texture
You just gain subscriber sir, i have that melodica but dont have time and dont know how to play correctly.. thx sir
Wonderful playing there! Also saw the cyclical breathing in action. Never knew such a thing exists. Will have to explore.
Thank you! Yes, look into circular breathing, its really helpful :-)
I've got Yamaha P-32D, sounds good too.
I actually bought this exact melodica about a year ago, but I couldn't find many legit learning materials/method books for the melodica, so I kind of just....left it in my closet for a year. I just found your book on amazon and it seems to be exactly what I need. I'm looking forward to starting it.
Great to hear this! Thanks for buying the book, I hope it’s helpful. If you have any questions while learning, get in touch via the FB forum. Good luck!
There's no need, figure out what music you want to learn and just do that using technique similar to you would with a synth keyboard. The notes are all lined up straightforward.
I have one, I don't play it as much as my Suzuki Melodian M-32C, as I don't like the tone as much, as the reedier, more jazzy sounding (IMHO) Suzuki. I did play it once though for a tango, Por Una Cabeza, as I needed the extra notes on top, and it was WAY better for that tune! Love the video!
Thank you for review with nice sound (often problem for melodicas video)
Yamaha is on the way to me ;)
Good choice, I'm sure you'll love it
Beautiful playing. I don't play it as well, but I've been playing one of those Yamahas on the road for years (I'm primarily a guitarist). You're right; they're well built, stay in tune well, and are solid instruments. I'm on probably my 5th by now))
Wow, your fifth? I used to get through them when I practised alot. The keys would actually develop holes!
Why have you owned 5? Do they break and wear out easily?
Thank you for the comprehensive and helpful review! I'm just trying to decide which one to get: the Yamaha and an older Hohner Cassotto 27...
I'd go for a Yamaha first - it's new and robust, and you can get replacement reeds. Then get a Cassotto, which will compliment the sound perfectly :-)
Thanks for the video. I just ordered the Suzuki M37C because of build quality and standard-sized keys. But this one sounds slightly better to me. :)
They're both great!
I love your play
Thank you :-)
I have owned several melodicas and currently play a Yamaha P37 ($100 USD) and also the Hammond 44 Hyper ($500 USD). The Yamaha has held up well over time and still plays great for acoustic jams. They tend to be tuned slightly sharp when new, to compensate for gradual loss of tone.
The Hammond is professional grade and superior in all regards. But it's main feature is a pick-up with volume control for amplification. If you intend to play with other amplified musicians, then you need the Hammond.
I agree, the Hammond is a refined instrument. I'd play one much more if it was a bit shorter!
@@MelodicaWorld I think it actually needs 2 and a half MORE steps at the low end. Middle C (C4) is in the C2 position on the Hammond 44 key layout. So you can only play 12 tones below middle C.
@@MelodicaWorld Interesting take... I always find myself wanting for more low end range on melodicas. I thought the Hammond was practically worth the price for the range alone, since it is the only option with more than 37 key that I know of
I agree with @user-uo9ip5ru3w that I would love to see a few models with even more range, especially on the low end.
I think they are tuned sharp because when you blow hard and loud the reeds go flat and are most in tune, so the melodica can be played loud without a microphone. But I tuned mine flatter so I could play a little softer as I have good breath control.
I bought the Suzuki M-37 and most of the notes are sharp a few cents. A few are flat (the A above middle C)! Very frustrating.
Now I have to figure out how to tune it!
This one sounds so much better than the hoffner variants of similar price, specially on those high notes.
Yamaha is the way to go, pls dont repeat my mistake.
I like using my melodica like a piano (: I can't for the life of me use the mouthpiece yet, but its only day 1 for me haha
It's great to start with using it like a piano, so you can see what's going on!
Don't worry! I have been playing for a couple years and I can play anything that way!
I do like the sound ...
Nice vid.Subbed!
thanks!
I play this melodica almost every day in the Pike Place Market of Seattle as the "Tango Cowboy." I learned quickly that I need to protect my ears. The melodica can be loud, and my ears ring after I perform for several hours. (More than just my usual tinnitus.) I started using a pair of earplugs called earWear 30 years ago for playing electric bass in a loud R&B band. When I use these earplugs I feel less fatigued after a day of busking. Protect your hearing my friends!
Thanks, good advice!
I have this melodica myself and use it in live performances with my Reggae band! I like to mic it with delay and play away.
Perfect!
Very good video !
I have a P37D.
It's really a pleasure to play it.
But I'm not a melodica specialist (I play violin and other instruments ...)
P37D is, for me, very good, fun and affordable !
nice!
Thank you for this I was attracted to the Melodica Hohner Airboard keys piano 37 ( thought it looked funky) but heard a you tube playing 13 different melodicas and the Yamaha P37D sounded more mellow than any of the Hohner's. I have found one for sale in the States that is cheaper than buying it here in Australia so I was glad for this review from you as I think it helped me make up my mind on this one as you gave it such a good rap. Also you are right it does look grown up more so than the Hohner and as I want to start playing jazz standards with some friends think this will be the best bet. So cheers Darren,
Good choice Alison, you won't be disappointed :-)
It would be great if you could do a video tutorial for tuning this one! I have it, but a lot of the keys same 10+ cents sharp. I saw the forum thread on your website for this exact model, and it was really helpful, but watching it all the way through would be helpful too. I'm glad I found MelodicaWorld!
Hi Nick, I'm hoping to do this soon! Thanks for watching
Very good
I just got one of these, it's great! I have the Suzuki Pro 37 v2 but it's heavy and larger than other melodicas and it's hard to hold with or without the strap (I think the strap is badly located).
The Yamaha is light and easy to hold (I do use the strap) and it has a very nice sound (the Suzuki is shrill. From the aluminum housing?).
I have three Yamaha guitars and they're all very well made as is the P-37-D.
Great melodica!
I really like the internal spit valve, no more running to the bathroom sink when I'm done playing.
Glad to hear you’re getting on well with the Yamaha!
I use the strap. I have small hands so its much more comfortable.
I ordered it after seeing this video, I'm looking forward to it. I'm a melodica beginner, actually i use a cheap 24€ one that sounds more accordion / oboe while this Yamaha seems to sound more harmonica / Stevie Wonder that i like..
Cool, hope you like it :-)
@@MelodicaWorld Yes! I received 2 days ago. Wonderful sounding, pure and bright, smooth touch, fast playing.. 👍👍👍
Really appreciated this review! I have a secondhand melodica that was found in the toy section of a thrift store, and this helped me figure out that it was actually a P37D! Unfortunately it didn't come with a mouthpiece or a blow pipe, but it's still fun to try playing it regardless. I did ask my local music store if they could order replacement parts, and they checked with their suppliers at Yamaha but were told that they aren't available for the P37D. I know replacement parts for the P37E are more readily available, but I wonder if the same mouthpiece and blow pipe will fit the P37D?
Either way, thank you for the video and excellent melodica resources on the channel!
I imagine it would fit as they’re nearly identical. But many players choose to play with no mouthpiece at all!
Good
There is a slight issue with the Pianica keyboard (compared to, for instance, Hohner). However, this is easily fixed by just running a finger over ALL keys before playing. This has the immediate effect of loosening the key action, which is thereafter fine!
Yes!
Very good review. I am not a melodica player (but had one made in Germany as a kid). Reeds quality is not important just for melodicas, also for hasmonicas and other similar instruments.
Very true!
Hi, I' d like to see a video in wich you talk about the comparison bethween the different meodica sizes, thank you in advance!!!
Hi Enrico, the bigger the keyboard, the more flexibility you have when playing. So, musically speaking, the bigger the better. But its worth working out how many notes you'll actually need. Most tunes can be played comfortably on a 37 key, so it's a popular size. The 32 key has only 5 notes less, so this is also very popular. There's a 44 key (Hammond), which is great, but I think the instrument starts getting too big at this size. My favourite size is 34 key - these are all the notes I need, low G to high E. I really like the 25 key melodicas because they're so small and light, but not enough notes for me!
I've got this melodica, it is nice but it is not really in tune, low notes are a bit too sharp, I'm afraid to tune them, I broke a reed from my first melodica (more a toy than an instrument).
The P-37D is a real instrument.
I sometimes use a strap.
I think I am guilty of holding it wrong by the looks. making these videosI use the strap by wrapping my hand into it like a fist. I like it though. Thanks for making these videos, glad someone else takes this beautiful instrument seriously
There isn’t really a wrong way, whatever works for you :-)
I have a feeling the slight sharpness is its new-rigidity and will go away after breaking it in.
can you make a review to hammon melodica pro 44 H. I saw that you mention it on your blog :) Also it would be interesting to see a video about melodicas for classical music
Yes, I'll have to do a Pro44 H review at some point. I'd say it's more suited to classical music than some of the others because of the long range, and more refined tone
@@MelodicaWorld yey - i am looking Forward :)
I want to buy the hammon melodica. Have you made the experience that the hammon Melodica tends to Warp because of its wooden body?
That's just plain old good work Brother. Thanks for the review. It's an unfair couple of questions I have for you but here goes . . . .Your 5 favorite instruments? How many distinct models do you have? And what is the oldest melodica-like instrument do you own? Thanks from Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
My five favourite instruments: melodica, piano, concertina, glass harmonica, DIY pipe organ. I used to have most melodicas, but I wasn't playing them, so I gave many away about a year ago, and put the rest into storage. I can't remember what I have left now! I have a few old melodica-like instruments, including an Hohner Organette and original Accordina
@@MelodicaWorld It's immeasurable what you have done for music generally and the melodica type instruments specifically. I'll thank you for that. Bob from Philly
@@robertforrester578 Thanks Philly, really pleased :-)
Thanks for your videos. Is this melodica tuned 440? Is was thinking of buying the hammond 44 too. I need a responsive one for rythms. Thanks.
In my experience, it's normally a little sharper. But then, if you're playing it for a while, the moisture in the breath does bring it back down again...
You can teach to play the melody that you start playing at minute 6:06.?
Thank you very much
I am a happy owner of a P37D. 👍
Great to hear this
I love it! Instructions on how to play it? Price? Please. Thanks for the demonstration.
I have lessons and a video about melodica prices on my channel!
I use the hand strap!
Good to hear it !
I'm considering a melodica for playing in Celtic sessions where I don't want to use a full accordion. I'm a little concerned about the comments I've read about this model being sharp. Could this blend well with other instruments tuned to A440?
I'd say its definitely worth learning how to tune your melodica, whatever one you buy, as tuning on different notes will be inconsistent. Its important to have it tuned well for a session if you want to make a good impression :-)
Just my opinion, but I absolutely love the sound of this melodica. The tone to me is much superior to a lot of more expensive models. Hard to put into words exactly what it is, but there's a certain timbre this melodica has that I just really enjoy. It sounds sort of viola-ish, or a bit like a bandoneon (sans the octave). Very warm in the lower register, and direct but not shrill or grating in the higher register. Whereas I find others (the suzukis melodions for instance) tend to have this more whiney/honky tone.
But that's my personal opinion of course, I know most melodica players really like that suzuki more pokey soprano saxophone-like reedy tone.
I wonder, mr melodica world, do you have any idea what I'm talking about?? 😅
Well, I do play a Yamaha and not a Suzuki!
I find a good quality Melodica to sound more like a Valved Chromatic Harmonica. It's actually what got me interested in this instrument since you can easily play more complicated pieces on it.
You remind me of Olaf from "The Violin Studio" but for melodica!
I just checked Olaf out, thanks for the intro! Some really interesting stuff there :-)
Great review, thanks a lot! How narrower are the keys when compared to a traditional piano?
Thanks Diogo. They’re about 5mm narrower than a normal piano key. I prefer the smaller size, but some players would prefer something more similar to the piano size
Can you please do a video on how to replace reeds on a melodica
You unscrew the whole reed plate with a little screwdriver and lift it out. Swap it for a replacement and screw back in!
Lot's of free reeds are sharp slightly. Same goes for a lot of harmonicas even the expensive Suzuki Promasters.
Can you put the instructions and vectors from your diy 3d printed melodica on the web?
Hi and thanks so much for this review, it was so helpful to me! I have been looking to buy one of these, but stores near me only sell the next model, the Yamaha P37E. Do you think it's just as good? Thanks again!
Hey, glad it was helpful. Personally I prefer the P37D to the P37E, as its easier to play.
@@MelodicaWorld Thank you!
Hi bro! I've been watching to your videos to find a nice melodica that I could buy to use in recordings. Normally I have problems with the mid frequencies when I use my hohnner ocean.....listening to your video, I found that maybe this Pianica is more "closed" and soft with the mids. Should be nice to record. What you tell me about this?
It records well for me...
I have a P32 D and have been playing melodica for years. Here is my question. In your intro, you have pictures of the little melodicas I started out with. The metal ones with buttons for keys. Are they still available to buy? I would love to put one in my instrument collection. Thanks ahead of time for your response. I had a red one with, I guess, 20 keys. I loved that little thing.
I think you can still buy those, not sure if they’re still made from metal now…
I have Hohner Student 32, I like Hohner sound. I want to upgrade for better one with 37 keys. Which Hohner currently is the best?
I don’t really know the new hohners
I found out about this instrument while looking at keytars. Seems to be somewhere between a harmonica and an accordion. Would I rather use this over a keyboard with an accordion sound? Maybe if I played in an acoustic folk group. I might get one just to have for whenever the power goes out though.
Good point, you'll never have to plug it in!
If you were given the choice between this Yamaha P-37D, or the Suzuki M-37C, which do you think you would pick (it will be my first melodica)? Both the Yamaha and Suzuki are available for £60 each, which I'm hoping is a reasonable price for either model... From what I've seen so far, it seems like the Yamaha might have a slightly more accordion-sounding tone compared to the Suzuki, but the Suzuki seems to have better construction (metal body) and is possibly just a better melodica overall - but I'm really not sure!
Alternatively, there's the option of just getting a 32 key instead - the Suzuki M-32C - for £50, but I think the extra range of a 37 key would probably be better if I wanted to get closer to an accordion's kind of range?
Thanks for your help and for the very informative video :)
I think you’ll be happy with either the Yamaha or the Suzuki. The difference in sound is minimal!
i was wondering between this one and the suzuki 37c, what would you recommend personally?
I think the m37c looks slightly better because of the metal body, also it has an external moisture outlet, which is good. The tone is slightly different to the P37D. I'm used to the Yamaha now, but I have played the m37c at different times in my melodica life!
really useful review 👍 Santa has bought me the 32D which I'm looking forward to learning - just one question, all the keys are slightly stiff to press down initially although move freely - is this normal? Just wondering if new instruments need using to loosen them up
This happens to Yamahas - you have to press all the keys down once before playing
@@MelodicaWorld cheers 👍 Happy Holidays!
Yes..I have the same doubt too..none of the other melodicas Ive played have these stiff keys..its as if playing on a weighted key melodica. But it is not affecting my playing in anyway. So it is OK i guess.
On Amazon they are selling Yamaha P37 D02... Can you tell me if it's just the same model of your video? Are there any differences?
I don’t know, but it looks the same!
Hohner airboard carbon 37 vs yamaha p32d which melodica is best ?
Hi - Great review. I have now subscribed to Melodica World. I have a Yamaha maroon 37, about 15 years old. I want to replace the reed plates - one of the reeds is broken. Any advice where I can get the plates?
I’m in the UK, and get them from www.sontec.co.uk
@@MelodicaWorld Thanks, much appreciated.
New to your channel. Do you have any videos that show how to tune a melodica?
Not yet Dave. I have some instructions here though: melodicaworld.com/how-to-tune-a-melodica/
@@MelodicaWorld Thank you!
Just got mine in the mail. Noticed my C# is not playing until about tripple the amount of air enters than the notes directly next to it... i respect your advisement and would like to know what you think.
Did i get a faulty one or is this a common issue that can and should be fixed?
Hi, it can be fixed, but if you're not skilled in 'gapping reeds' I'd send it back for a replacement
Wow, a Yamaha P-37D. It was featured in the anime "Your Lie in April," as the instrument the female main character plays; and it was also used in the live-action "Nodame Cantabile," used to play Gershwin's "Rhapsody in Blue." (th-cam.com/video/8lapujQ18uk/w-d-xo.html) I have the P-32D, though, but I also have the P-37C. Both are a pleasure to play.
Have you played the P-37E yet? What’s it like compared to the P-37D? I just got one and I love it. However I think people would appreciate hearing your opinion on it as a professional player.
It's very similar to the P37D. The tone is slightly subdued, and it takes a little more breath power. Same reeds, keys etc
I actually use the strap as I play my melodica sideways with the mouthpiece. As I want to be able to play without having to look at the notes. Like knowing where keys are supposed to be. maybe its because I have small hands as well. I wish I had this melodica though. That or the suzuki m37c. I love both of them and its hard. Suzuki appears as a luxury, and yamaha does as well. especially with the newer p37e. Both are great instruments ad go for the same price.
lastly. How do I clean my melodica after use. Like I know I have to use the button and blow. But for how long? Or what are some good ways to take care of it. I just want to be careful with my p25f as its a very new melodica that I dont want oxidizing.
Read Alan's advice here: melodicaworld.com/forums/topic/give-your-melodica-a-bath/