I agree. I am a professional melodica player and have lots of them. The Hohner's keys get stuck and don't always go down if you don't push them straight. It's the worst of all melodicas. The Yamaha is definitely the best. The action is great and it requires less air to get the notes out and it's loudest of the three. It works well longest of the three. My favorite is the 25 note Yamaha. It's wonderful in all respects and fits into my guitar case. To tune them, open it up. File the end of the reed to raise the pitch, the other end to lower it.
@Mazamal Ehsan : I think that's just up to the user. Personally, I find the Melodions a bit mellower than the Pianicas, though the both of them are a blast to play. I have a Pianica P-32D and a P-37C; and a Melodion M-37. But, whether it's a Pianica or a Melodion, you won't go wrong.
I have 2 Hohners and a Suzuki M37. I love the Suzuki for the sound and quality but I do have to fix it often (adjusting reed gap space). I did want to get some feedback on the Yamaha 37d. I think I will get that one. I see the Suzuki now has a mid range priced 37 key.
Thanks, I tried to be as straight-up as possible and cover all the details I could think of. I hope I've helped people keep from feeling ripped-off or disappointed when they purchase from afar.
The Suzuki has many positives. My main issue is the quality for the price especially the tuning. The action is very fast and very even across the keyboard. The tone is very directed, very brilliant. It has many positive reviews and it is well built. It may come down to a taste issue about what sort of sound you are wanting. It would I think stand out in a mix. I'm glad you mention the Excalibur it's one I was curious about but had my suspicions.
Thank you for your great honest video...I bought an hour ago the Yamaha one online and was surfing afterwards and found your comments .Better I had done that before the buy.(big smile) I have allready an old Hohner melodica cassotto 27...bought it cheap secondhanded. It sounds great because it has a larger case so it sounds more full and like a saxophone. I have no question, by the way..I read all the comments on your video and if there is a golden medal for answering alllllll comments and questions...You are the one I vote for!!!! Most kind regards from the Netherlands, Ingrid
Thank You for your kind words Ingrid! : ) I hope you will enjoy the Yamaha. Yes the old vintage Hohners sound magical. I don't understand why they can't figure that out now. Happy playing!
Thanks for posting this awesome review of those 3 instruments. For whatever reason I seem to much prefer the tone of the Yamaha over the other two, even though it wasn't one of the louder ones.
You are welcome Matthew. Keep watching, something will come your way or there may be a great new model or manufacturer around the corner once they see how popular melodicas are becoming on-line.
I bought a Hohner Instructor 32 just to goof off with and I'm having a blast. I'm a piano/synth player and it seemed like something I could jump into playing. Maybe I'll get a nicer one some day.
Great video! But I have never played that instrument but thinking about buying a new one, so I would even more appreciate a video focused on which things I should check before buying a new melodica or any useful advice you could give to someone who has never played on that and is buying the first melodica in their life. Thanks:)
John, I would point anyone toward the Yamaha (as of right now) for it's consistency, adaptability and reasonable price. As Alan pointed out below, the 32 note is even better on price and easy to hold. I checked out a Gungor video, but I'm not sure what model they are playing?
I loved this comparo -- fascinating! My first impression, the Suzuki seemed to have the most bass end, the Yamaha with the strongest treble and the Hohner the most balance? But I would not bet the farm on that asssessment! LOL. But then I was blown away by the fullness and richness of the older Hohner. The mechanical aspects were very eye opening!
You're welcome, glad you enjoyed the video. I hope you will have fun with the Hohner. I don't think it is a bad instrument just not up to what they have made in the past. I believe I had done a little tuning on the Yamaha but the other two are out of the box.
Since I commented on this about a year ago, I have acquired the Suzuki M-32C and M-37C and played them quite a bit. In my opinion, the M-37C is better than the Pro-37V2, but the best of the three is the M-32C, which has a slightly less edgy and more natural sound (to my ear) than the other two. I'll also mentioned (perhaps someone has already) that the problem of failing or choking notes on the Yamahas seems to have been nailed down as a matter of reed gapping. The gap usually needs to be opened up a bit, though this is something to be done carefully, slowly, gradually, and of course at your own risk. This issue and reed gapping have been discussed at length at melodicaworld.com.
I like M-32C too. I also think it's better than Pro37-V2. The sound is heart-warming and its color-combination(white and blue)and design makes me feel wonderful. I want to keep it beside me forever.
I neglected to mention that the Suzuki Pro37v2 has a metal body (metal tray) - also true of Suzuki M37C and M32C, not to be confused with other plastic Suzukis, and both now available thru Amazon. But I haven't tried either M.
I like your assessment, thanks for watching. In my mind I think of it as the Suzuki being cornet-like, the Yamaha is harmonica-ish and the Hohner is the most accordion sounding which is exactly what you said!
Thanks for the great review. This was very helpful as I'm looking to buy my first melodica. Which of these three would you recommend? I was looking at the hohner.
+travisonacreek Good luck with your search. I wasn't too happy with the Hohner but a lot of people seem to like them. You may want to take a look at melodica world there are a lot of reviews of different models on there.
I like the 32 key Yamaha because it's compact and easy to hold in the hand rather than using the crummy hand straps characteristic of melodicas. I have several expensive melodicas, but the Yamaha P32D is the one I play the most. It's my hands down recommendation if you're buying a first melodica. If its $60+ price is too much for you, the Suzuki Study-32 is also better than Hohner and a real bargain at about $30.
I have the Suzuki Pro-37 and 32 key versions of the other two. In my opinion the Yamaha is far superior to the Hohner. The advantage of the screw off brass vent hole on the Suzuki is that it allows for much more effective blow-out of moisture, and it is easy and effective to blow moisture out from both ends.
I can tell you I was at the same place. A little frustrated with the Hohner and the Yamaha wanted something better but was daunted by the price on the Suzuki for something I couldn't return. If you have seen one in person you are a step ahead I ordered mine cold-turkey. This video was the reaction.
I started with a very cheap melodica, then bought the one from melodicas.co that turns out to be the Angel. I did like it a lot better. More recently I bought the Suzuki Pro 37, and I just love it. I find it so much nicer to play than the other two. Its more expressive, I can play trills and ornaments more fluently. I love its tone, especially the lower octave. Yes, I agree that it has a lot of cosmetic touches that make it seem like a 'real' instrument, but to my mind it is. Finally, they all seem to start a little out of tune and get worse. I found this post while looking for information about cleaning a melodica. Some people say its important but the manufacturers don't say anything about it.
thx for your reviews. I just bought the Hohner Performer 37. It will be good enough for me as I am not a musician and just want to "noodle around". You said that all three instruments came out of the box rather out of tune. Did you tune them for your video or is that how they all sound "out of the box". To my ears they all sounded fine.
+Otto Gross You're welcome, Of course I haven't been able to try all the melodicas that are out there Just lately I've been playing the Suzuki S‑32C. I may get around to doing a video review of it. Tuning and consistency seem more important than manufacturing choices. Even the really cheap melodicas sound good if they are in tune and play clearly...and are played well by the player.
There's the rub -- tuning. I haven't found one yet that arrives in tune, even if sold as "professional". In Amazon comments people some report that Hammond 44s are no better in this regard. Which company if any sells carefully-tuned instruments -- any idea?
These are the big three makers and they are all come from the factory atrociously tuned? It's very frustrating plus disheartening. There is a company in the U.S. that is selling melodicas they claim have been professionally tuned but from all appearances it looks to be re branded Chinese instruments that have the same poor factory tuning .
Thank you for making this video! Do you know if there is such a thing as left handed melodica?Ive learned to play guitar and violin changing the strings but now I want to learn to play this instrument I cant find one for lefties :(
Thank you for this video . I was wondering about the diferences betwen Susuky ( because the high price ) , and the others , and this video realy helps to figure out the diferences ( or may i say the lack of diferences :) Thank you , very helpfull video
You're welcome. I haven't tried Swan or seen one in person. I suspect from their appearance and price they may be from the same manufacturer as several other brands?
Nice comparison! You are right on with the Yamaha and other "generic" brands. I had both a no name and a Excalibur melodic and oen was 30 bucks less but otherwise they where the same! Melodicas are pretty much the all the same till you get to the Suzukis or an older Hohner like the one you have! Is there anything worth noting that's good about the Suzuki? I ask because my teacher has one and it felt so much better than the hohner 37 I play on! I was thinking about getting a Suzuki 37...
Thanks for the comparison. Very interesting perspective. To be honest I haven't thought about it before. As one can see Hohner is not what it used to be (the company was taken over years ago). Apart from that we don't have to guess in which country the instruments are made.....
I agree the HM 36 was probably the best sounding(and playing) melodica ever. A shame they are no longer produced i think it's the standard the rest are shooting for. They also say the clavietta is another excellent vintage instrument. although I've not seen one in person.
Your vintage hohner seems to have a much more full tone than the reissue hohner. Is that the result of better craftsmanship, or just more time for the reeds to develop and set in.?
Hard to say for sure. The entire body is plastic so it's not like a wooden instrument that sounds better as it ages. The reeds are brass which I've never heard of anyone saying aged brass sounds better? Never heard anyone brag on their 100 year old cornet? The brass may be of a different quality, perhaps heavier, perhaps a different recipe. More likely what you are hearing is the construction differences. The vintage Hohner is built in a way where the reeds are somewhat buried in the instrument. In person it definitely has a more muffled and diffused sound, which adds a warmth and fullness.
Crummy hand strap is right on Alan! You may be on to something with the felt strip although I've had the clogging happen after the melodica has been stored as you describe and not played for a week? Yes the Yamaha is superior despite the moisture issues.
Thanks for your comparison and great information. Have you tried a Hammond? I agree with the sound difference for the Suzuki and Yamaha. But the new Hohner sounds like a horn more than harmonica or accordion.
Yeah my piano teacher plays melodica, he has the suzuki 37 and the hammond 44! The hammond is amazing, very expressive and easy to bend on and as a wonderful range! The price tag is a bit much! I've played on them all and the suzuki and hammond are the best out of a lot of clones!
i liked the sound of the hohner, is the key depth your main critizism? I am a piano player so I did not mind if the action is deep; balance and expressivenss are more important. I saw an unboxing video of it and the guy played some thirds that sounded very even.
just forgot to follow up - I have a really cheap Thomann 37 keys which blocks up some reeds when you play it for longer, so I am hoping the Hohner is a little better at about double the price. Not quite ready to go as far paying for a Suzuki.
a a If you like the sound of the Hohner it's a good choice. I didn't mention the strong plastic smell it had. I actually put the case and box outside for several weeks under a porch till it aired out.
Thanks, I wish modern Hohner would take note. I see similar responses om all vintage Hohner vids. Wish they would take a page from the synth makers and do a vintage repro line. Especially the models that have the scimitar shape. They sound the best.
You're welcome. I've never seen a left-handed melodica? Beyond getting someone to custom build one the best idea I can think of is to take the breath hose and attach it to the back or bottom of a melodica with tape or something. Then the mouthpiece would be at the other end and you could play from the left side but your high notes would be closest to your mouth so you would have to use unorthodox fingering. Good luck. you should post a video of what you come up with. I'm a lefty too.
WOW. Very thorough review but VERY DEPRESSING RESULTS. Thank you for your candor. I share your sentiments about manufacturing quality and current emphasis on looks over internal functionality. QUESTION: Who will resuscitate the melodica? It took Grace Jones, Wierd Al Yankovic and They Might Be Giants to breathe life back into the Accordion but then they're still manufactured properly!
A bit depressing yes, but I hope to save others some disappointment. resuscitate the melodica? That's pretty funny since you breathe into one, :) We are trying to do that over at melodica world! Lot's of discussion on the ultimate melodica.
I'm not much of an ear player. I learned it from the sheet music. It was in a mandolin book. If you google the title and dig a little I think you can find the sheet music.
Yes at :25. But it sounds amazing on the melodica! I'm going to look for a music sheet so i could learn how to play it. It might be hard to find though you probably learned it by ear.
Whats the number one melodica you recommend? I've seen bands like Gungor use them in acoustic sets with guitars and strings and stuff. Thats how I'd want to use it. I ask don't want to spend too much ya know? Thanks!!!
hohner sound with yamaha keys will do fine i guess .. but this review is so honest i love it .. so which one do you think should i go with sir ? thanks
Love Hobelia I can't recommend the latest Hohners. The Yamahas are quite consistent but I've also read realy good things about Suzuki's other models that I haven't tried on melodicaworld.
On exception to the tone of so so plastic melodicas is the Hohner hm 36. They are the last generation of Hohner made in Germany, brass reeds, metal body, wide piano like keys, its built like a tank and due to its lack of sound holes, is very mellow and responsive. I got mien around $100 used on ebay and I need to take it in to get it cleaned and repaired. If you can't find a suzuki or a hammond this is the next best option! I even put a pickup on it, a damn find instrument I love mine!
Hi, thanks for the video. I broke a reed while cleaning mine, a honer student model. I was wondering if I could replace the entire reed plate from Honer since I can see the dismounting screws in pairs (many of them) but could not find that part. Would you know if those parts exist or if a repair of a single reed is possible? It broke in the middle. each reed seems to be soldered to the plate. Many thanks in advance for any help.
You're welcome. It's probably not practical to replace a single reed. If you can find an accordion repairman you would end up paying as much as buying a new melodica. Probably the same thing for buying the new reed plate? I've never ordered Hohner parts. Their info seems a little confusing but you could start here: www.hohner-cshop.de/index.php?stoken=B4AC3264&force_sid=&lang=1&cl=search&searchparam=melodica+reeds Seems they mostly sell harmonica reeds? I'd say buy another student if you really like that model and use your old one as spares for it. Good luck.
phlattgetit Thanks for the answer, I'll try that and probably end up buying a new one. Maybe another brand or model, although inexpensive is good as I use it only occasionally for finding chords or playing away from home. I saw the reed was bent differently than the others and tried to bend it into shape. A bad idea, especially given every note played fine.
It's a self-limiting cycle. the manufacturers don't take the instrument seriously so we get shoddy construction and no replacement parts. But, if they try and build better quality instruments the consumers don't take the instrument serious enough to pay those prices. If the note is sounding ok I would leave it alone. Sometimes the appearance of their position can be misleading. If the reed isn't sounding or rattling, buzzing etc. you obviously want to go ahead and make adjustments. Gentleness is the key.
Hi, Thanks for your comparison and review I have read most of the replies that you offer. You have mentioned that you recommend the suzuki M-37C and YAMAHA P-37D Do you know which one of the both requires less air to trigger the sound? I may choose that one first. Thanks a lot
My experience is I can get a more delicate sound from the Yamaha. Just barely breathing into gets a sound. The Sukuki takes a little more air to get the reeds to respond.
Fady,It didn't come very well tuned but you can tune a melodica with a great deal of patience.If you look on Melodicaworld you will find some guides and tutorials.
I just ordered a new 37 note Pro Milwaukee Excalibur melodica off of ebay. Have you heard anything about them? I thought they sound like they are well made and it says it has hand tuned reeds. It's made by Excalibur Accordions. They have a couple of videos on TH-cam.
Thanks for your help. I'm learning to tune my hohner, and my other two no name melodicas. But one day a note is sharp and the next it's flat! I'm looking for a teacher - I'm a classical musician - want to play jazz or blues, or anything else not classical. Anyone out there?
You're welcome Barbara, Tuning can be a frustrating process. You may want to notice how hard you are playing. Blowing hard can make a reed sound flat. Are you wanting on-line lessons? You may want to check out the forums on Melodicaworld there are a lot of dedicated players there and many tips and techniques discussed.
+Sam Labbato Somehow missed this comment? Yes Sam I usually remove the plastic mouthpiece at the far end of the tubes. Just my personal preference. i don't really think it improves or alters the sound.
All three have 37 keys. What if I want a smaller and lighter one so I can easily handle, a 32 key melodica? Have you tested them? Would a Yamaha 32 key be a good one to start with?
It looks like the Suzuki requires more air. 20 years ago I might have got a Hohner but after hearing current melodicas the Yamaha sounds best so I got one and have been pleased its tuning and sound, but maybe I should've got an Andoer instead since it seems about the same. Thanks for your review!
Where do you get the flex hoses? The cheap flex hoses that come with most of the ones I've tried are so flimsy they stretch when you blow and waste all your air pressure expanding the hose instead of playing the notes. Single notes are OK but chords don't have enough air pressure if you use the hose. Yours look like better hoses.
HI, thanks for your tests! I am about to buy a professional melodica and I wondered which of your types have the best bending facilities ? thanks for your time WIboud
I would say they bend anout the same. Maybe the Hohner isn't as flexible. depends also on if you are using the hose or the mouthpiece or blowing in directly. Lower notes are easier to bend.
Very good review. Sound wise they all are the same, more or less. The biggest thing is the reeds. Response and tuning is the key! If the company sends out of tune instrument, it's a toy. I expect real price to start at $200-300. 3 octaves of good accordion reeds will cost you $1000 easy.
No, no other remedies. It's all in the reeds. Shaving sounds a little extreme If you mean taking a blade to it, you could end up damaging the reed. I usually just use fine sandpaper or an emery board. Maybe a metal file for a stubborn reed or extreme change.
+ThePokeman92 I haven't tried the Angel. I haven't found anywhere to purchase it in the US? it gets fairly good reviews: www.melodicaworld.com/post_reviews/angel-melodyhorn-37/ It's suspected that's what is inside the Mylodica? the trouble with the 50 dollar range melodicas is that many of them seem to be the same model being re-branded by different companies. Generally the quality isn't quite there. So I can't really reccomend one over the other. they may be the same.
Hi there! I have tried the Angel Melodyhorn AM/37KW, the tuning is outrageous, specially after a few years of usage. I can only compare it to hohner (one of this student versions). The sounding of the angel is quite soft, although decaying over time as well. That would be the second best thing about it, the first one being the air per sound ratio. I noticed that the hohners usually lose air (even with the hard mouthpiece) whereas the Angel doesn't. The case is childish but who cares. I'm quite proud of it but it's quite old already and really out of tune. I'm doubting on which one to buy now
Not that particular model, no, I haven't tried it. There are a lot of models in that price range many of them are very similar. possibly made in the same factory but branded differently. I couldn't recommend one over the other without trying recent examples. By going just a little higher in price you would be within range of the Hohner or Yamaha and some Suzukis.
I really don't know. I ordered it years ago, I think from melodicas.com. They don't list it anymore. I don't remember it being listed with any name at the time, just a number code. It's not marked with any name or stamp on it nor is the case or the inside. I don't see any manufacturer marks or numbers. It looks similar to a Schoenhut but I haven't seen one of those in person so can't say for sure. So, truly generic.
I bought a melodica from ebay and when i get it i want to know how to get the spit out after i play i would like to use it to play it at home or at the center for the blind.
Depending on the model there should be some sort of release valve usually at the treble end. Either a button or flap or arm. Hold this open and blow vigorously. Be sure to not press any white or black keys while doing this.
With my hohner, I usually don't have to use the spit valve, I just pull my mouthpiece out and hold it upside down over a trash can so the spit flows out of the part where you put your mouthpiece
Which melodica do you recommend of those 3? At first, I was looking to buy a hohner 37 one but after reading reviews of its keys, tuning problems, and its sound quality being inferior to the others, although some people give it great reviews so I'm not sure anymore. They say it stays in tune longer than a Yamaha and them some others say something that disagrees with the previous one. I'm new to the melodica and I'm a beginner at keyboard but I really want to get into the melodica (I really love the sound they make), just don't know which brand is the best out there right now. Based on your review, they all have some downsides that turns me away from them. I was thinking of the Yamaha one just based on its sound, but then you mentioned that it gets unplayable after a while which sucks because I usually practice instruments at about 2 hrs average. I'm also looking up other reviews for (yamaha, hohner, and suzuki were the ones that every forum and reviewer seem to mention) and I'm planning on visiting a guitar center that apparently sells them near my house when i get back from school to actually test them out in person. Unfortunately, I kinda have a budget on which melodica to get (at about $100-$150).
You are in a bad place where I've been before. What you are looking for doesn't exist. Unfortunately the melodica as of now is an imperfect instrument. All the brands have shortcomings.There is no Stradivari or obvious choice that all the pros use. Some people are very happy with the new Hohners, I was not. Have you looked at my other video? The Suzuki M37C is much closer in price to the Yamaha P37D and in my opinion superior to the more expensive SuzukiPro-37V2. If you bumped your budget up just a little you could have them both? over time and experience playing you may discover you prefer one over the other. Or maybe keep both for different moods or playing situations.
Haven't checked out your other videos, but ill check them out soon once my finals are done. I actually watched this video while taking a study break. The Yamaha P37D is around $80-$90 and the Suzuki M37C around $100 right? I might be able to if I could afford to ask my parents to borrow some money and repay them later (don't really have enough on me to afford two right now) or I could just wait a few more weeks to save money. I was thinking of just getting one melodica because I'm just starting and don't really want to trouble anyone else with it. I've heard some people play the new Hohners and it sounds shrill and high pitch like a harmonica, which I didn't really like. I want it to sound either like a saxophone, which I've played a while ago. I have seen videos of some musicians who are able to get that sound but some people commented that it's just that they are skilled enough to make the instrument sound good despite its faults. The final decision maker for me will have to be actually testing them out in person at a music store if all three brands are available. If I find that I can play a melodica comfortably and still like the sound, even if it's a Hohner, I'll go for it. I'll still take other reviews, videos, and advice into consideration. And thank you so much for replying quickly.
I have heard the Suzuki M37C. It sounds different than the Yamaha P37D in a way that I can't really describe yet, but I still really like the sound of it. It kind of sounds deeper and mellower than the Yamaha but that could be just how the musician was playing it or the sound was affected by his recording equipment. Owning both would be awesome because I could experiment with their two different sounds.
I might describe it by saying you hear more of the sound of the reeds with the Yamaha while the Suzuki is built in a way that cloaks the reed sound and you hear more of the instruments body. You might also consider the 32 note version of each that would be more affordable. Or buy one in the 32 version and one in the 37. My favorite to play now is a 32 note version the Suzuki S-32C. I would caution you to not expect one to sound like a saxophone, harmonica or anything but a melodica or you may be dissapointed. Good luck with your search and your finals.
I don't really want it to sound like a saxophone, it was just the closest sound I could think of. I'm getting a Yamaha P37D and I was able to find a Suzuki Study-32C for $31 on eBay (as a secondary). I'm so excited to get them. Fingers crossed that they don't get damaged during delivery.
@@phlattgetit Perfect, THANKS!!!!! At the moment I have a walther (30 euros) with a Yamaha or Suzuki melodica (150 euros or a little more) what difference will they have (the more expensive suzuki, yamaha from the much cheaper walther?) In terms of sound (quality) I don't think so to have big differences with Suzuki. Which Yamaha model should I look for and at what price will I find it? (approx)
@@voiotv That's too many variables to give you an informed answer. I've never heard of the Walther. It may be just as good as the other two. Ultimately you have try one and see. There are days I really don't like the Yamaha at all. There's no ultimate melodica. Even the name brands aren't built to a high level of quality. I would concentrate on getting your Walther in tune. Maybe lubricate the springs and keys with something non-toxic. Check for any air leaks. Have look at this video: th-cam.com/video/r8Ju8i4cSy0/w-d-xo.html
Hi, I thought you did a good review. I have been on the fence regarding a new Yamaha P37D. I currently own a P32 and it seem as though the sound is very similar. My melodica is fairly in tune. I contacted a shop to have the tuning done and they said don't bother, buy a Hohner. I thought your older Hohner sounded great. They must have changed the material the reeds are made on the newer melodica. All in all I enjoyed your review.
Thank-you Will, I don't think a Hohner is any more in tune than Yamaha(probably worse) I suspect just the brand that particular store carries. I've handled a P32 close-up didn't play it but best I can tell it's identical to the P37D except for number of keys and color?
I like the sound from your older Hohner, it was a more sweeter sound than the newer Hohner. Besides the Suzuki, Hohner and Yamaha is there any other modestly priced good melodica? Thank you, Will.
Will, I will point you toward the reviews on Melodicaworld.com a lot of good people there have left reviews. I've not played that many brands myself to be able to give you a good answer. Hohner, Yamaha and Suzuki are all respected companies with a history of building a variety of instruments. So I took them to task for what they have produced There are a lot of other makers but some appear to be re-branded instruments from the same factory. If you like the vintage Hohners they seem to come up regularly on the auction sites.
Suzuki and Yamaha have been consistently making quality melodicas for years. Hohner is also well known. There are many other brands sometimes producing the same instrument. Beyond that it's difficult to tell you what to buy.
i did tune some harmonica's wich have the same reed-system ... and i followed "Honers workshop" on youtube (google it) and i used a tuner on my smartphone, you can find it for your smartphone. you just have to remove material from the upper OR lower part of the reed to adjust it to the right tuning :) i bought a second hand cheap harmonica to practise. but i found out it's pretty simple.... and with melodica's you only have blow reeds wich are easiest :)
If you look at the site melodica world . com there are many good reviews of different melodicas.Think about what sort of sound you want from the melodica, do you want it to be like your accordion or more like a harmonica. Then listen to a lot of videos on here where you can see which model someone is playing.You may want to try more than one model, some fit one style of music better than others.A new Yamaha or Suzuki or a vintage (not new) Hohner are good. If you aren't concerned with price you might consider the vibrandoneon.Good luck with your search.
hello how are you? I have to ask you. please tell me which of the melodica is more suited to the accordion? which is most similar to the sound of the accordion?
I think you could answer that better by listening rather than anything I could write about it. I've not heard a great deal of accordions or been around them so I wouldn't have a very informed opinion.
Thanks Allen, Very helpful....the EXACT information I needed to "think" about and I get to listen too!!! Perfect. I also think the Yamaha sounded best...more like the vintage Hohner, even before I heard the pro's and con's of each. Leaning in that direction for my first melodica,..so far. Appreciate the knowledge and effort!
In your opinion which have better tuning the Suzuki or Yamaha? (37keys) and does one have keys that are more similar to an acustic piano feel? Which model for you recommend?
Tuning on any manufacturer is never perfect one is as good as another when it comes to that. A piano feel has nothing to do with a melodica except the layout of the notes! There is no need for pressure or violence in pressing a melodica key. You should strive to press them gently as possible. Pressing a melodica key is pressing against a spring. Like pressing a doorbell pressing harder won't make it louder. If you are used to piano feel you won't like the melodica.
@@phlattgetit interesting, thank you for the input. I want to own a great melodica. I remember seeing somewhere someone comment that the Suzuki has better build quality..? might be a better choice just for that.
Well bro, I play many 'blow' instruments, mainly harmonica, but also everything else, and I have a big thing for buying toy instruments and play, to inspire my kids to become interested in music. Ive found that a good toy can have that fat, wet, clarinet sound that a mid-level real clarinet doesn't neccesarily produce, etc. My point is that the real difference often lies in the build quality, ie how long the instrument will last, and that the expensive stuff can be repaired (at great expense).
That depends on many factors. How much you are willing to pay, what sort of sound you want to have, what sort of musical setting you are wanting to play in, The range you want. I recommend having at least two different brands to have a variety. There are several comparison videos on TH-cam now, listen to them closely and decide what sounds good to your ears and your heart.
I have had a failed note on my Yamaha P32D. I took it apart and discovered that the felt strip under the front of the keyboard had a soggy sticky concentration of moisture and glue. I believe the problem mentioned in your video is the result of concentration of moisture, and the solution is to clear moisture well after playing and store your pianica on end or with the front of the keyboard (player side) up.
The 37-key Yamaha is the full 3-octave range(F-3-to-F6) of a vibraphone I used to play, which is why I got one, and I find it ideal for the hard-bop jazz I love. +@@Hanibalinux
@@HanibalinuxIt all depends on what you want to do with it. I bought the 37-key model because of its range---a full 3 octaves (F3-to F-6), just like a vibraphone I used to play, and I'm very pleased with it. It's easy to play, and no problem to clear the condensation out of it. I just set the thing on a table, sit down and get crackin'!
Richard that was purchased from an on-line merchant over 15 years ago. It was listed as a GL-37. It's no longer on their site. There are many models out there now that have a similar body shape. Currently the Woodnote brand appears to use that design.
I have one more question, in case you know. I am well aware that factories in Asia can make the same product and slap on a different brand name. So I am trying to decide and order tonight, between the Yamaha where I know I love the sound for $93, or the Woodnote, which only MAY be the same item, for $40, but I can not find recordings of that one so far. Do you have any insight that can help?
I have no experience with the Woodnote or heard a recording. My guess is it's a knock-off of the Yamaha shell with lesser quality reeds. On Melodica world there is some discussion and comparison of a similar (Yamaha-looking) melodica and the reeds are definitely sub-par.
So for me, they all sound really really similar and the price difference is too big to get a more expensive one. If I had the money I'd maybe get an expensive one for the better feel and look of higher quality materials. But I don't feel like I'm missing out on a lot when I get a cheaper instrument here.
+Kyle McCrea That's the Hohner Piano 32. No longer manufactured. Vastly superior in sound and quality to their current models, Except the keys can be loud. You can find them on the online auction sites. Sometimes a new old stock model is available.
Your best choice for now is the TEC line of controllers. www.tecontrol.se/products/usb-midi-breath-controller pair it with a small key controller like an Arturia Keystep if you want to carry it around the stage.
Man, this is a great video. Thank you for taking the time to make it.
Thank-you, I'm hoping to see great things from your new site. I hope people will watch your comparison video.
I agree. I am a professional melodica player and have lots of them. The Hohner's keys get stuck and don't always go down if you don't push them straight. It's the worst of all melodicas. The Yamaha is definitely the best. The action is great and it requires less air to get the notes out and it's loudest of the three. It works well longest of the three. My favorite is the 25 note Yamaha. It's wonderful in all respects and fits into my guitar case.
To tune them, open it up. File the end of the reed to raise the pitch, the other end to lower it.
@Mazamal Ehsan : I think that's just up to the user. Personally, I find the Melodions a bit mellower than the Pianicas, though the both of them are a blast to play. I have a Pianica P-32D and a P-37C; and a Melodion M-37. But, whether it's a Pianica or a Melodion, you won't go wrong.
I have 2 Hohners and a Suzuki M37. I love the Suzuki for the sound and quality but I do have to fix it often (adjusting reed gap space). I did want to get some feedback on the Yamaha 37d. I think I will get that one. I see the Suzuki now has a mid range priced 37 key.
you are a professional player with 25 keys instrument? i am going to check you channel, you must be a magician
What do you think of the Yamaha P37 brown, black etc and their sound vs the maroon?
Didn't bullshit any, appreciate that. Everything I was interested in knowing was in your video. Good job man.
Thanks, I tried to be as straight-up as possible and cover all the details I could think of. I hope I've helped people keep from feeling ripped-off or disappointed when they purchase from afar.
The Suzuki has many positives. My main issue is the quality for the price especially the tuning. The action is very fast and very even across the keyboard. The tone is very directed, very brilliant. It has many positive reviews and it is well built. It may come down to a taste issue about what sort of sound you are wanting. It would I think stand out in a mix.
I'm glad you mention the Excalibur it's one I was curious about but had my suspicions.
Thank you for your great honest video...I bought an hour ago the Yamaha one online and was surfing afterwards and found your comments .Better I had done that before the buy.(big smile)
I have allready an old Hohner melodica cassotto 27...bought it cheap secondhanded. It sounds great because it has a larger case so it sounds more full and like a saxophone.
I have no question, by the way..I read all the comments on your video and if there is a golden medal for answering alllllll comments and questions...You are the one I vote for!!!!
Most kind regards from the Netherlands, Ingrid
Thank You for your kind words Ingrid! : ) I hope you will enjoy the Yamaha. Yes the old vintage Hohners sound magical. I don't understand why they can't figure that out now. Happy playing!
Thanks mate! You too!
@@phlattgetit I just loaded yesterday my first video with the vintage Hohner I mentioned before
Thanks for posting this awesome review of those 3 instruments. For whatever reason I seem to much prefer the tone of the Yamaha over the other two, even though it wasn't one of the louder ones.
You're welcome, Yamaha isn't as loud no. It does seem to offer more finesse' over air-flow.
Thank you for your help.
That old Hohner sounds magical.
I doubt I can find one.
Thank-you, I'm glad you get something from it. It was born out of my own frustration searching for a quality instrument.
You are welcome Matthew. Keep watching, something will come your way or there may be a great new model or manufacturer around the corner once they see how popular melodicas are becoming on-line.
I bought a Hohner Instructor 32 just to goof off with and I'm having a blast. I'm a piano/synth player and it seemed like something I could jump into playing. Maybe I'll get a nicer one some day.
Thanks so much for posting ! ( Brazil )
You're welcome! (USA)
Great video! But I have never played that instrument but thinking about buying a new one, so I would even more appreciate a video focused on which things I should check before buying a new melodica or any useful advice you could give to someone who has never played on that and is buying the first melodica in their life. Thanks:)
Wow..its a very helpful vdo..thanks.wish to see some more about melodica
Thank you for the review. What is your favorite Melodica?
John,
I would point anyone toward the Yamaha (as of right now) for it's consistency, adaptability and reasonable price. As Alan pointed out below, the 32 note is even better on price and easy to hold. I checked out a Gungor video, but I'm not sure what model they are playing?
I loved this comparo -- fascinating! My first impression, the Suzuki seemed to have the most bass end, the Yamaha with the strongest treble and the Hohner the most balance? But I would not bet the farm on that asssessment! LOL. But then I was blown away by the fullness and richness of the older Hohner. The mechanical aspects were very eye opening!
You're welcome, glad you enjoyed the video. I hope you will have fun with the Hohner. I don't think it is a bad instrument just not up to what they have made in the past. I believe I had done a little tuning on the Yamaha but the other two are out of the box.
Hohner chromatic harmonica's have also gone "Swanside"...while "Swan" has kinda improved a bit
Since I commented on this about a year ago, I have acquired the Suzuki M-32C and M-37C and played them quite a bit. In my opinion, the M-37C is better than the Pro-37V2, but the best of the three is the M-32C, which has a slightly less edgy and more natural sound (to my ear) than the other two. I'll also mentioned (perhaps someone has already) that the problem of failing or choking notes on the Yamahas seems to have been nailed down as a matter of reed gapping. The gap usually needs to be opened up a bit, though this is something to be done carefully, slowly, gradually, and of course at your own risk. This issue and reed gapping have been discussed at length at melodicaworld.com.
I like M-32C too. I also think it's better than Pro37-V2. The sound is heart-warming and its color-combination(white and blue)and design makes me feel wonderful. I want to keep it beside me forever.
I neglected to mention that the Suzuki Pro37v2 has a metal body (metal tray) - also true of Suzuki M37C and M32C, not to be confused with other plastic Suzukis, and both now available thru Amazon. But I haven't tried either M.
I like your assessment, thanks for watching. In my mind I think of it as the Suzuki being cornet-like, the Yamaha is harmonica-ish and the Hohner is the most accordion sounding which is exactly what you said!
Thanks for the great review. This was very helpful as I'm looking to buy my first melodica. Which of these three would you recommend? I was looking at the hohner.
+travisonacreek Good luck with your search. I wasn't too happy with the Hohner but a lot of people seem to like them. You may want to take a look at melodica world there are a lot of reviews of different models on there.
I love hohner performer 37! Thank you for the VIDEO. Its helpful a lot!
You are welcome. I'm glad it helped you.
I like the 32 key Yamaha because it's compact and easy to hold in the hand rather than using the crummy hand straps characteristic of melodicas. I have several expensive melodicas, but the Yamaha P32D is the one I play the most. It's my hands down recommendation if you're buying a first melodica. If its $60+ price is too much for you, the Suzuki Study-32 is also better than Hohner and a real bargain at about $30.
Yeah but not enough keys to play It’s Raining Again by Supertramp.
I have the Suzuki Pro-37 and 32 key versions of the other two. In my opinion the Yamaha is far superior to the Hohner. The advantage of the screw off brass vent hole on the Suzuki is that it allows for much more effective blow-out of moisture, and it is easy and effective to blow moisture out from both ends.
I can tell you I was at the same place. A little frustrated with the Hohner and the Yamaha wanted something better but was daunted by the price on the Suzuki for something I couldn't return. If you have seen one in person you are a step ahead I ordered mine cold-turkey. This video was the reaction.
I started with a very cheap melodica, then bought the one from melodicas.co that turns out to be the Angel. I did like it a lot better. More recently I bought the Suzuki Pro 37, and I just love it. I find it so much nicer to play than the other two. Its more expressive, I can play trills and ornaments more fluently. I love its tone, especially the lower octave.
Yes, I agree that it has a lot of cosmetic touches that make it seem like a 'real' instrument, but to my mind it is.
Finally, they all seem to start a little out of tune and get worse. I found this post while looking for information about cleaning a melodica. Some people say its important but the manufacturers don't say anything about it.
Great review. Thanks
You are welcome, Thanks for watching.
thx for your reviews. I just bought the Hohner Performer 37. It will be good enough for me as I am not a musician and just want to "noodle around". You said that all three instruments came out of the box rather out of tune. Did you tune them for your video or is that how they all sound "out of the box". To my ears they all sounded fine.
Thanks very much for this! What are your favoite Melodicas that are currently being manufactured? Which do you like MORE than these three?
+Otto Gross You're welcome,
Of course I haven't been able to try all the melodicas that are out there Just lately I've been playing the Suzuki S‑32C. I may get around to doing a video review of it. Tuning and consistency seem more important than manufacturing choices. Even the really cheap melodicas sound good if they are in tune and play clearly...and are played well by the player.
There's the rub -- tuning. I haven't found one yet that arrives in tune, even if sold as "professional". In Amazon comments people some report that Hammond 44s are no better in this regard. Which company if any sells carefully-tuned instruments -- any idea?
These are the big three makers and they are all come from the factory atrociously tuned?
It's very frustrating plus disheartening.
There is a company in the U.S. that is selling melodicas they claim have been professionally tuned but from all appearances it looks to be re branded Chinese instruments that have the same poor factory tuning .
Thank you for making this video! Do you know if there is such a thing as left handed melodica?Ive learned to play guitar and violin changing the strings but now I want to learn to play this instrument I cant find one for lefties :(
Thank you for this video . I was wondering about the diferences betwen Susuky ( because the high price ) , and the others , and this video realy helps to figure out the diferences ( or may i say the lack of diferences :)
Thank you , very helpfull video
Thank you for sharing your review. Have you ever tried the Swan brand melodica?
You're welcome.
I haven't tried Swan or seen one in person. I suspect from their appearance and price they may be from the same manufacturer as several other brands?
Nice comparison! You are right on with the Yamaha and other "generic" brands. I had both a no name and a Excalibur melodic and oen was 30 bucks less but otherwise they where the same! Melodicas are pretty much the all the same till you get to the Suzukis or an older Hohner like the one you have! Is there anything worth noting that's good about the Suzuki? I ask because my teacher has one and it felt so much better than the hohner 37 I play on! I was thinking about getting a Suzuki 37...
Thanks for the comparison. Very interesting perspective. To be honest I haven't thought about it before. As one can see Hohner is not what it used to be (the company was taken over years ago). Apart from that we don't have to guess in which country the instruments are made.....
I agree the HM 36 was probably the best sounding(and playing) melodica ever. A shame they are no longer produced i think it's the standard the rest are shooting for. They also say the clavietta is another excellent vintage instrument. although I've not seen one in person.
If you watch the auction sites you can find vintage Hohners. Occasionally even new old stock from a store closing.
Your vintage hohner seems to have a much more full tone than the reissue hohner. Is that the result of better craftsmanship, or just more time for the reeds to develop and set in.?
Hard to say for sure. The entire body is plastic so it's not like a wooden instrument that sounds better as it ages. The reeds are brass which I've never heard of anyone saying aged brass sounds better? Never heard anyone brag on their 100 year old cornet? The brass may be of a different quality, perhaps heavier, perhaps a different recipe. More likely what you are hearing is the construction differences. The vintage Hohner is built in a way where the reeds are somewhat buried in the instrument. In person it definitely has a more muffled and diffused sound, which adds a warmth and fullness.
Crummy hand strap is right on Alan! You may be on to something with the felt strip although I've had the clogging happen after the melodica has been stored as you describe and not played for a week? Yes the Yamaha is superior despite the moisture issues.
Great review! Thanks :-)
Thanks for your comparison and great information. Have you tried a Hammond? I agree with the sound difference for the Suzuki and Yamaha. But the new Hohner sounds like a horn more than harmonica or accordion.
You're welcome. Haven't tried the Hammond.
Yeah my piano teacher plays melodica, he has the suzuki 37 and the hammond 44! The hammond is amazing, very expressive and easy to bend on and as a wonderful range! The price tag is a bit much! I've played on them all and the suzuki and hammond are the best out of a lot of clones!
Great job.
i liked the sound of the hohner, is the key depth your main critizism? I am a piano player so I did not mind if the action is deep; balance and expressivenss are more important. I saw an unboxing video of it and the guy played some thirds that sounded very even.
just forgot to follow up - I have a really cheap Thomann 37 keys which blocks up some reeds when you play it for longer, so I am hoping the Hohner is a little better at about double the price. Not quite ready to go as far paying for a Suzuki.
a a If you like the sound of the Hohner it's a good choice. I didn't mention the strong plastic smell it had. I actually put the case and box outside for several weeks under a porch till it aired out.
The old hohner that you pulled out sounds great
Thanks, I wish modern Hohner would take note. I see similar responses om all vintage Hohner vids. Wish they would take a page from the synth makers and do a vintage repro line. Especially the models that have the scimitar shape. They sound the best.
You're welcome. I've never seen a left-handed melodica? Beyond getting someone to custom build one the best idea I can think of is to take the breath hose and attach it to the back or bottom of a melodica with tape or something. Then the mouthpiece would be at the other end and you could play from the left side but your high notes would be closest to your mouth so you would have to use unorthodox fingering. Good luck. you should post a video of what you come up with. I'm a lefty too.
I'm glad it helped you.
WOW. Very thorough review but VERY DEPRESSING RESULTS. Thank you for your candor. I share your sentiments about manufacturing quality and current emphasis on looks over internal functionality. QUESTION: Who will resuscitate the melodica? It took Grace Jones, Wierd Al Yankovic and They Might Be Giants to breathe life back into the Accordion but then they're still manufactured properly!
A bit depressing yes, but I hope to save others some disappointment.
resuscitate the melodica? That's pretty funny since you breathe into one, :)
We are trying to do that over at melodica world! Lot's of discussion on the ultimate melodica.
Perhaps Jon Batiste? He's why I'm here.
I'm not much of an ear player. I learned it from the sheet music. It was in a mandolin book. If you google the title and dig a little I think you can find the sheet music.
You're welcome. I hope my video helps you find a melodica that suits you.
Yes at :25. But it sounds amazing on the melodica! I'm going to look for a music sheet so i could learn how to play it. It might be hard to find though you probably learned it by ear.
Whats the number one melodica you recommend? I've seen bands like Gungor use them in acoustic sets with guitars and strings and stuff. Thats how I'd want to use it. I ask don't want to spend too much ya know? Thanks!!!
hohner sound with yamaha keys will do fine i guess .. but this review is so honest i love it .. so which one do you think should i go with sir ? thanks
Love Hobelia I can't recommend the latest Hohners. The Yamahas are quite consistent but I've also read realy good things about Suzuki's other models that I haven't tried on melodicaworld.
On exception to the tone of so so plastic melodicas is the Hohner hm 36. They are the last generation of Hohner made in Germany, brass reeds, metal body, wide piano like keys, its built like a tank and due to its lack of sound holes, is very mellow and responsive. I got mien around $100 used on ebay and I need to take it in to get it cleaned and repaired. If you can't find a suzuki or a hammond this is the next best option! I even put a pickup on it, a damn find instrument I love mine!
They are hard to find but as soon as I get mine cleaned and repaired I'm going to use it as my main axe!
Hi, thanks for the video. I broke a reed while cleaning mine, a honer student model. I was wondering if I could replace the entire reed plate from Honer since I can see the dismounting screws in pairs (many of them) but could not find that part. Would you know if those parts exist or if a repair of a single reed is possible? It broke in the middle. each reed seems to be soldered to the plate. Many thanks in advance for any help.
You're welcome.
It's probably not practical to replace a single reed. If you can find an accordion repairman you would end up paying as much as buying a new melodica. Probably the same thing for buying the new reed plate?
I've never ordered Hohner parts. Their info seems a little confusing but you could start here:
www.hohner-cshop.de/index.php?stoken=B4AC3264&force_sid=&lang=1&cl=search&searchparam=melodica+reeds
Seems they mostly sell harmonica reeds?
I'd say buy another student if you really like that model and use your old one as spares for it.
Good luck.
phlattgetit Thanks for the answer, I'll try that and probably end up buying a new one. Maybe another brand or model, although inexpensive is good as I use it only occasionally for finding chords or playing away from home. I saw the reed was bent differently than the others and tried to bend it into shape. A bad idea, especially given every note played fine.
It's a self-limiting cycle.
the manufacturers don't take the instrument seriously so we get shoddy construction and no replacement parts. But, if they try and build better quality instruments the consumers don't take the instrument serious enough to pay those prices.
If the note is sounding ok I would leave it alone.
Sometimes the appearance of their position can be misleading.
If the reed isn't sounding or rattling, buzzing etc. you obviously want to go ahead and make adjustments. Gentleness is the key.
Hi, Thanks for your comparison and review
I have read most of the replies that you offer.
You have mentioned that you recommend the suzuki M-37C and YAMAHA P-37D
Do you know which one of the both requires less air to trigger the sound?
I may choose that one first. Thanks a lot
My experience is I can get a more delicate sound from the Yamaha. Just barely breathing into gets a sound. The Sukuki takes a little more air to get the reeds to respond.
@@phlattgetit thank you!!
Just curious - what was themake od the generic one that you said was equivalent to the Yamaha? Thanks
Nice, just wanna ask you about the tuning of the pro 37v2 is it tuned? Or there is a way to tune it? Thnx!
Fady,It didn't come very well tuned but you can tune a melodica with a great deal of patience.If you look on Melodicaworld you will find some guides and tutorials.
I just ordered a new 37 note Pro Milwaukee Excalibur melodica off of ebay. Have you heard anything about them? I thought they sound like they are well made and it says it has hand tuned reeds. It's made by Excalibur Accordions. They have a couple of videos on TH-cam.
thank you! ...i was thinking of buying a pro 37
the bottom line: either pay for nothing or get an old hohner...
but who has one wouldnt give it away
Thanks for your help. I'm learning to tune my hohner, and my other two no name melodicas. But one day a note is sharp and the next it's flat! I'm looking for a teacher - I'm a classical musician - want to play jazz or blues, or anything else not classical. Anyone out there?
You're welcome Barbara,
Tuning can be a frustrating process. You may want to notice how hard you are playing. Blowing hard can make a reed sound flat.
Are you wanting on-line lessons? You may want to check out the forums on Melodicaworld there are a lot of dedicated players there and many tips and techniques discussed.
I'd like to purchase a melodica.
What brand and model would you recommend?
Very good and honest review. Seems the generic yamaha alike is the best choice?
Thank-you, the generic doesn't seem to be available anymore unfortunately.
Did you take off the caps to all your blow pipes, because I have a hohner performer myself and it had a mouthpiece at the end of my blow pipe
+Sam Labbato Somehow missed this comment? Yes Sam I usually remove the plastic mouthpiece at the far end of the tubes. Just my personal preference. i don't really think it improves or alters the sound.
All three have 37 keys. What if I want a smaller and lighter one so I can easily handle, a 32 key melodica? Have you tested them? Would a Yamaha 32 key be a good one to start with?
Haven't tried them all but yes in general the Yamaha P32D is identical to the P37D except for less keys and the color scheme.
It looks like the Suzuki requires more air. 20 years ago I might have got a Hohner but after hearing current melodicas the Yamaha sounds best so I got one and have been pleased its tuning and sound, but maybe I should've got an Andoer instead since it seems about the same. Thanks for your review!
Yes, more air. I recommend the M-37C instead of the Pro-37V2.
Not familiar with Andoer?
Your welcome, thank you for watching.
Where do you get the flex hoses? The cheap flex hoses that come with most of the ones I've tried are so flimsy they stretch when you blow and waste all your air pressure expanding the hose instead of playing the notes. Single notes are OK but chords don't have enough air pressure if you use the hose. Yours look like better hoses.
All the hoses you see me use are the ones that came with their respective melodicas.
HI, thanks for your tests!
I am about to buy a professional melodica and I wondered which of your types have the best bending facilities ?
thanks for your time
WIboud
I would say they bend anout the same. Maybe the Hohner isn't as flexible. depends also on if you are using the hose or the mouthpiece or blowing in directly. Lower notes are easier to bend.
Excuse me for the question, wich is the right technique for bending notes?
Very good review. Sound wise they all are the same, more or less. The biggest thing is the reeds. Response and tuning is the key! If the company sends out of tune instrument, it's a toy. I expect real price to start at $200-300. 3 octaves of good accordion reeds will cost you $1000 easy.
I have a 35 year old Suzuki and it’s flat compared to music I listen to and my new Yamaha s in tune. Any remedies other than shaving each reed?
No, no other remedies. It's all in the reeds. Shaving sounds a little extreme If you mean taking a blade to it, you could end up damaging the reed. I usually just use fine sandpaper or an emery board. Maybe a metal file for a stubborn reed or extreme change.
Have you ever had the opportunity to test the Angel Melodyhorn 37-K3? If not, is there anything you can recommend for about $50?
+ThePokeman92 I haven't tried the Angel. I haven't found anywhere to purchase it in the US? it gets fairly good reviews: www.melodicaworld.com/post_reviews/angel-melodyhorn-37/ It's suspected that's what is inside the Mylodica?
the trouble with the 50 dollar range melodicas is that many of them seem to be the same model being re-branded by different companies. Generally the quality isn't quite there. So I can't really reccomend one over the other. they may be the same.
Hi there! I have tried the Angel Melodyhorn AM/37KW, the tuning is outrageous, specially after a few years of usage. I can only compare it to hohner (one of this student versions).
The sounding of the angel is quite soft, although decaying over time as well. That would be the second best thing about it, the first one being the air per sound ratio. I noticed that the hohners usually lose air (even with the hard mouthpiece) whereas the Angel doesn't.
The case is childish but who cares.
I'm quite proud of it but it's quite old already and really out of tune. I'm doubting on which one to buy now
Not that particular model, no, I haven't tried it.
There are a lot of models in that price range many of them are very similar. possibly made in the same factory but branded differently. I couldn't recommend one over the other without trying recent examples. By going just a little higher in price you would be within range of the Hohner or Yamaha and some Suzukis.
the generic one you show around 6;00 what is the brand ?
I really don't know. I ordered it years ago, I think from melodicas.com. They don't list it anymore. I don't remember it being listed with any name at the time, just a number code. It's not marked with any name or stamp on it nor is the case or the inside. I don't see any manufacturer marks or numbers. It looks similar to a Schoenhut but I haven't seen one of those in person so can't say for sure. So, truly generic.
Was your older hohner the piano 36?
I bought a melodica from ebay and when i get it i want to know how to get the spit out after i play i would like to use it to play it at home or at the center for the blind.
Depending on the model there should be some sort of release valve usually at the treble end. Either a button or flap or arm. Hold this open and blow vigorously. Be sure to not press any white or black keys while doing this.
With my hohner, I usually don't have to use the spit valve, I just pull my mouthpiece out and hold it upside down over a trash can so the spit flows out of the part where you put your mouthpiece
Which melodica do you recommend of those 3? At first, I was looking to buy a hohner 37 one but after reading reviews of its keys, tuning problems, and its sound quality being inferior to the others, although some people give it great reviews so I'm not sure anymore. They say it stays in tune longer than a Yamaha and them some others say something that disagrees with the previous one. I'm new to the melodica and I'm a beginner at keyboard but I really want to get into the melodica (I really love the sound they make), just don't know which brand is the best out there right now. Based on your review, they all have some downsides that turns me away from them. I was thinking of the Yamaha one just based on its sound, but then you mentioned that it gets unplayable after a while which sucks because I usually practice instruments at about 2 hrs average.
I'm also looking up other reviews for (yamaha, hohner, and suzuki were the ones that every forum and reviewer seem to mention) and I'm planning on visiting a guitar center that apparently sells them near my house when i get back from school to actually test them out in person. Unfortunately, I kinda have a budget on which melodica to get (at about $100-$150).
You are in a bad place where I've been before.
What you are looking for doesn't exist. Unfortunately the melodica as of now is an imperfect instrument. All the brands have shortcomings.There is no Stradivari or obvious choice that all the pros use.
Some people are very happy with the new Hohners, I was not.
Have you looked at my other video? The Suzuki M37C is much closer in price to the Yamaha P37D and in my opinion superior to the more expensive SuzukiPro-37V2.
If you bumped your budget up just a little you could have them both?
over time and experience playing you may discover you prefer one over the other. Or maybe keep both for different moods or playing situations.
Haven't checked out your other videos, but ill check them out soon once my finals are done. I actually watched this video while taking a study break. The Yamaha P37D is around $80-$90 and the Suzuki M37C around $100 right? I might be able to if I could afford to ask my parents to borrow some money and repay them later (don't really have enough on me to afford two right now) or I could just wait a few more weeks to save money. I was thinking of just getting one melodica because I'm just starting and don't really want to trouble anyone else with it.
I've heard some people play the new Hohners and it sounds shrill and high pitch like a harmonica, which I didn't really like. I want it to sound either like a saxophone, which I've played a while ago. I have seen videos of some musicians who are able to get that sound but some people commented that it's just that they are skilled enough to make the instrument sound good despite its faults. The final decision maker for me will have to be actually testing them out in person at a music store if all three brands are available. If I find that I can play a melodica comfortably and still like the sound, even if it's a Hohner, I'll go for it. I'll still take other reviews, videos, and advice into consideration.
And thank you so much for replying quickly.
I have heard the Suzuki M37C. It sounds different than the Yamaha P37D in a way that I can't really describe yet, but I still really like the sound of it. It kind of sounds deeper and mellower than the Yamaha but that could be just how the musician was playing it or the sound was affected by his recording equipment. Owning both would be awesome because I could experiment with their two different sounds.
I might describe it by saying you hear more of the sound of the reeds with the Yamaha while the Suzuki is built in a way that cloaks the reed sound and you hear more of the instruments body.
You might also consider the 32 note version of each that would be more affordable. Or buy one in the 32 version and one in the 37.
My favorite to play now is a 32 note version the Suzuki S-32C.
I would caution you to not expect one to sound like a saxophone, harmonica or anything but a melodica or you may be dissapointed.
Good luck with your search and your finals.
I don't really want it to sound like a saxophone, it was just the closest sound I could think of.
I'm getting a Yamaha P37D and I was able to find a Suzuki Study-32C for $31 on eBay (as a secondary). I'm so excited to get them. Fingers crossed that they don't get damaged during delivery.
I would like your opinion, which melodika should I buy for quality sound, relatively good keyboard but not need a lot of air volume. Thanks!
The Yamaha line seems to take less air to produce a tone.
@@phlattgetit Perfect, THANKS!!!!!
At the moment I have a walther (30 euros) with a Yamaha or Suzuki melodica (150 euros or a little more) what difference will they have (the more expensive suzuki, yamaha from the much cheaper walther?) In terms of sound (quality) I don't think so to have big differences with Suzuki. Which Yamaha model should I look for and at what price will I find it? (approx)
@@voiotv That's too many variables to give you an informed answer. I've never heard of the Walther. It may be just as good as the other two. Ultimately you have try one and see. There are days I really don't like the Yamaha at all. There's no ultimate melodica. Even the name brands aren't built to a high level of quality. I would concentrate on getting your Walther in tune. Maybe lubricate the springs and keys with something non-toxic. Check for any air leaks. Have look at this video: th-cam.com/video/r8Ju8i4cSy0/w-d-xo.html
@@phlattgetit Thank you!👍
Hi, I thought you did a good review. I have been on the fence regarding a new Yamaha P37D. I currently own a P32 and it seem as though the sound is very similar. My melodica is fairly in tune. I contacted a shop to have the tuning done and they said don't bother, buy a Hohner. I thought your older Hohner sounded great. They must have changed the material the reeds are made on the newer melodica. All in all I enjoyed your review.
Thank-you Will,
I don't think a Hohner is any more in tune than Yamaha(probably worse) I suspect just the brand that particular store carries. I've handled a P32 close-up didn't play it but best I can tell it's identical to the P37D except for number of keys and color?
I like the sound from your older Hohner, it was a more sweeter sound than the newer Hohner. Besides the Suzuki, Hohner and Yamaha is there any other modestly priced good melodica? Thank you, Will.
Will, I will point you toward the reviews on Melodicaworld.com a lot of good people there have left reviews. I've not played that many brands myself to be able to give you a good answer. Hohner, Yamaha and Suzuki are all respected companies with a history of building a variety of instruments. So I took them to task for what they have produced There are a lot of other makers but some appear to be re-branded instruments from the same factory. If you like the vintage Hohners they seem to come up regularly on the auction sites.
Hello,
I want to buy a melodica and have two choices: Hohner 32-key and Gewa 37-key. which One de you advice? Regards.
Sorry, I'm unfamiliar with the Gewa. I hadn't even heard of it?
thank you for your help
You're welcome.
Pl guide me sir the best melodica durable and easy to play with melody
Suzuki and Yamaha have been consistently making quality melodicas for years. Hohner is also well known. There are many other brands sometimes producing the same instrument. Beyond that it's difficult to tell you what to buy.
This is my hohner 37 key Melodica Jamming Jazz/Reggae
If the notes in the melodica or melodica-like instruments are out of tuned when they come out of the factory, how does one correctly tune them?
You can find some videos on here or come over to melodicaworld to find a lot of discussion. Mainly you file the reeds.
Wow, seems like a major operation...
It's quite an undertaking, yes. I would reccomend setting aside an entire afternoon if you are going to tune several reeds.
i did tune some harmonica's wich have the same reed-system ... and i followed "Honers workshop" on youtube (google it) and i used a tuner on my smartphone, you can find it for your smartphone.
you just have to remove material from the upper OR lower part of the reed to adjust it to the right tuning :)
i bought a second hand cheap harmonica to practise. but i found out it's pretty simple.... and with melodica's you only have blow reeds wich are easiest :)
What is name of the third song? the classical sounding one.
I agree often we as consumers are poorly served by the manufacturers of musical equipment.
Hi. I am Garmon and Accordionist. And Iwant to play melodica. Which Bran of Melodica is good? Please give some advice.
If you look at the site melodica world . com there are many good reviews of different melodicas.Think about what sort of sound you want from the melodica, do you want it to be like your accordion or more like a harmonica. Then listen to a lot of videos on here where you can see which model someone is playing.You may want to try more than one model, some fit one style of music better than others.A new Yamaha or Suzuki or a vintage (not new) Hohner are good. If you aren't concerned with price you might consider the vibrandoneon.Good luck with your search.
which is like harmonica and which is like accordion?
hello how are you? I have to ask you. please tell me which of the melodica is more suited to the accordion? which is most similar to the sound of the accordion?
I think you could answer that better by listening rather than anything I could write about it.
I've not heard a great deal of accordions or been around them so I wouldn't have a very informed opinion.
To me the Yamaha definitely sound the most like accordion. That was what drew me to the sound.
Thanks Allen, Very helpful....the EXACT information I needed to "think" about and I get to listen too!!! Perfect.
I also think the Yamaha sounded best...more like the vintage Hohner, even before I heard the pro's and con's of each. Leaning in that direction for my first melodica,..so far.
Appreciate the knowledge and effort!
In your opinion which have better tuning the Suzuki or Yamaha? (37keys) and does one have keys that are more similar to an acustic piano feel? Which model for you recommend?
Tuning on any manufacturer is never perfect one is as good as another when it comes to that. A piano feel has nothing to do with a melodica except the layout of the notes! There is no need for pressure or violence in pressing a melodica key. You should strive to press them gently as possible. Pressing a melodica key is pressing against a spring. Like pressing a doorbell pressing harder won't make it louder. If you are used to piano feel you won't like the melodica.
@@phlattgetit interesting, thank you for the input. I want to own a great melodica. I remember seeing somewhere someone comment that the Suzuki has better build quality..? might be a better choice just for that.
@@Elazarko Possibly, they seem about the same to me.
Thank you!
You're welcome.
Well bro, I play many 'blow' instruments, mainly harmonica, but also everything else, and I have a big thing for buying toy instruments and play, to inspire my kids to become interested in music. Ive found that a good toy can have that fat, wet, clarinet sound that a mid-level real clarinet doesn't neccesarily produce, etc. My point is that the real difference often lies in the build quality, ie how long the instrument will last, and that the expensive stuff can be repaired (at great expense).
That depends on many factors. How much you are willing to pay, what sort of sound you want to have, what sort of musical setting you are wanting to play in, The range you want.
I recommend having at least two different brands to have a variety.
There are several comparison videos on TH-cam now, listen to them closely and decide what sounds good to your ears and your heart.
I have had a failed note on my Yamaha P32D. I took it apart and discovered that the felt strip under the front of the keyboard had a soggy sticky concentration of moisture and glue. I believe the problem mentioned in your video is the result of concentration of moisture, and the solution is to clear moisture well after playing and store your pianica on end or with the front of the keyboard (player side) up.
Which one is better the 32, 25, or 37 key yahama melodica?
37!!!! I like :)
The 37-key Yamaha is the full 3-octave range(F-3-to-F6) of a vibraphone I used to play, which is why I got one, and I find it ideal for the hard-bop jazz I love.
+@@Hanibalinux
@@HanibalinuxIt all depends on what you want to do with it. I bought the 37-key model because of its range---a full 3 octaves (F3-to F-6), just like a vibraphone I used to play, and I'm very pleased with it. It's easy to play, and no problem to clear the condensation out of it. I just set the thing on a table, sit down and get crackin'!
Hi, does anyone know the make and model of the generic melodica in the video, the one that had the same shell as the yamaha?
Richard that was purchased from an on-line merchant over 15 years ago. It was listed as a GL-37. It's no longer on their site.
There are many models out there now that have a similar body shape.
Currently the Woodnote brand appears to use that design.
phlattgetit Thanks! I may search a bit but will probably play it safe with the Yamaha.
I have one more question, in case you know. I am well aware that factories in Asia can make the same product and slap on a different brand name. So I am trying to decide and order tonight, between the Yamaha where I know I love the sound for $93, or the Woodnote, which only MAY be the same item, for $40, but I can not find recordings of that one so far. Do you have any insight that can help?
I have no experience with the Woodnote or heard a recording. My guess is it's a knock-off of the Yamaha shell with lesser quality reeds.
On Melodica world there is some discussion and comparison of a similar (Yamaha-looking) melodica and the reeds are definitely sub-par.
Thanks again. I read that and some reviews that put the Yammy at a higher quality. So I ordered a P37D last night. It's only money, right?
So for me, they all sound really really similar and the price difference is too big to get a more expensive one. If I had the money I'd maybe get an expensive one for the better feel and look of higher quality materials. But I don't feel like I'm missing out on a lot when I get a cheaper instrument here.
I'd have a look at the Suzuki M 37C then it's about a third the price of the Pro 37v2 closer in cost to the Yamaha. The key action is very smooth.
Thank You !
You're welcome.
Wich one would be the best for you?
As far as these three, I'm most;y playing the Yamaha for now..
Whats the model of the vintage hohner you pulled out? Thanks
+Kyle McCrea That's the Hohner Piano 32. No longer manufactured. Vastly superior in sound and quality to their current models, Except the keys can be loud. You can find them on the online auction sites. Sometimes a new old stock model is available.
+phlattgetit Thanks man! Yeah, it sounds much better than the others haha
Hello Insider!
I'm searching for a MIDI-Melodica since 1985...! Any suggestions?
Your best choice for now is the TEC line of controllers. www.tecontrol.se/products/usb-midi-breath-controller pair it with a small key controller like an Arturia Keystep if you want to carry it around the stage.